Politico’s Crap About a ‘Career Path’ for Dissenting Journalists

Politico just published one of those articles that always drives me crazy where the media takes one or two examples of something and then tries to turn that into some sort of massive wave where in truth it is no such thing. This time Politico is saying that because three people left mainstream journalism to become media critics, that must mean there is a “career path” for disaffected journalists to fame and success.

The Politico story titled, “Media career path: Cry ‘media bias’,” is written by Dylan Byers and is loosely formed around the departure from CBS of excellent investigate journalist Sharyl Attkisson. Then the article segues to Bernard Goldberg and John Stossel both of who left big three network jobs to become Fox News analysts who often criticize the media.

The premise of the story is presented in the third paragraph:

It’s an increasingly well-traveled path: Over the course of the past two decades, a handful of journalists have left mainstream media jobs while decrying what they saw as an inherent bias in their own industry. Among them: Bernie Goldberg, John Stossel, and Doug McKelway–all of whom found a home at Fox News, a cable news channel that markets itself on the premise that the media is unfair and unbalanced.

I say the story is loosely formed around Attkisson because she has only taken the first step in that so-called new “career path,” so lauded by Politico. She quit CBS but has otherwise not done anything else at this time. So, to say she is following that “career path” is premature.

But the conceit in the piece using Attkisson at all isn’t even the point of criticism of this bad article. The point is Politico’s Byers takes the experiences of three guys who left mainstream media to become media critics and tries to turn that into some sort of ” increasingly well-traveled path.”

No, it isn’t any sort of “increasingly well-traveled path.” We’ve got three guys who have done this in the last 50 years. THREE GUYS!

Three guys do not an “increasingly well-traveled path” make.

It is flatly absurd to claim that this is some sort of trend. There are tens of thousands of people working in the news media. And Politico gives us less than half a dozen people who left mainstream journalism to make a new career as a media critic and present that as a trend? This is nonsense.

No, what we have here is a Politic’s Dylan Byers starting with a premise and then writing an article to “prove” his point by making wild assumptions and ignoring reality.

And that right there is typical of the news media.

New Mexico Police Chief Fired Likely Because He Attended Constitutional Rights Gathering
Breaking the Law: Pay Higher for Government Contractors Than Other Workers
  • jim_m

    Career path? obama’s new law will make it more like a perp walk.

  • pork chop

    While those three have made a well worn path there is a much faster route that most journalists prefer to travel on their career paths. It’s a six lane interstate highway leading directly to the current White House.

    http://www.thewire.com/politics/2013/09/rick-stengel-least-24-journalist-go-work-obama-administration/69362/

    • jim_m

      The biggest career path for journalists is either working in a dem admin or marrying a dem politician/operative. You can’t hardly watch a broadcast on ABC/NBC/CBS/CNN without having someone who fits in either of the above categories on the screen.

  • GarandFan

    “This time Politico is saying that because three people left mainstream
    journalism to become media critics, that must mean there is a “career
    path” for disaffected journalists to fame and success.”

    Given that logic, what with 3 Democratic State Senators in Kalifornia being either convicted or indicted on felony charges, one might propose that is also a ‘new career path’ for Democratic Senators.

    • jim_m

      I’m not sure that criminal activity and corruption are exactly new to the democrat party.

  • stan25

    Well when you are screwed by the purveyors of bias and butt kissing of the so-called Messiah by your colleagues, that is what happens. That is what happened to most of the people that are now working at Fox News. One that was not mentioned was Juan (Whiny) Williams, who got fired because he had the audacity to profile a Muslim as a terrorist.

  • LiberalNightmare

    The govt cant hire everybody.

    • jim_m

      If we go communist they can. I don’t doubt for a second that there are a lot of dems that would advocate that. (In fact my own congress critter would definitely advocate that and I think she may have publicly done so already)

Optimization WordPress Plugins & Solutions by W3 EDGE