« Attacking the President | Main | The Libby Sentence »

Another Report from Iraq You Need to Read

Kim's post below reminded me of a comment yesterday from BarneyG2000 who asked:

Lee, remember that Michael Yon exclusive?

http://wizbangblog.com/2007/05/29/more-should-see-this-story.php

I sure would like to see an update on that (since there is still no word of the events described ever tacking place on Yon's site).

Barney's comment reminded me that I had not seen the full Yon story, but had only read the riveting excerpt at Instapundit. Glenn Reynolds quoted from an email from Yon, but the story had not yet been posted at Yon's site. I decided to Google it last night and in about 2 seconds found the full Yon story. It is certainly worth your time to read. For those who missed the original post, Yon described the following:
I was present today when an Iraqi General was arrested on suspicion of murder and other crimes. The American commander, LTC Doug Crissman, narrowly averted a possible bloodbath today when he intervened, without orders from above, and arrested the General. The General was with 14 heavily armed men. I was a few feet away and snapped a photo of Crissman and the Iraqi General only seconds before Crissman silently grabbed the General's pistol out of his holster. Crissman's men had silently disarmed the other 14 men who were all around the building. The General was clueless. Incredible, and brilliantly executed by LTC Crissman. More in a couple of days. (I got it all on video/photo.)
Here is the link to the full Yon story that is packed with photos. It is a lengthy report, but definitely worth the time.


Comments (29)

Yon is incredible.. So much... (Below threshold)
Paul:

Yon is incredible.. So much better than the "new for retards" the regular media assaults us with.

Excellent article from Yon.... (Below threshold)
_Mike_:

Excellent article from Yon. And beyond words excellent work by LTC Doug Crissman and his soldiers.

Yon's writing is excellent.... (Below threshold)
al:

Yon's writing is excellent. Be sure to read the latest dispatch on his time with the Brits.

Yon should get some kind of... (Below threshold)
Matt:

Yon should get some kind of a reward. I'd suggest a Pulitzer, or even a Nobel, but those don't normally go to people writing the truth. Maybe someone should take up a collection for him to have a good vacation somewhere when he returns from theater. At least buy him a beer.

It was an interesting story... (Below threshold)
BarneyG2000:

It was an interesting story. It was also easy to see why nobody in the MSM is reporting on the events of the day. First of all the general is actually a colonel, and he was not charged with murder, and the army almost F-up the whole operation.

The Iraqi colonel was one of the few Iraqis that were actual fighting and defeating the al Qaeda insurgents. It appears that he was getting a little bit too powerful for the likes of the current government, so they ordered our boys to intervene in an internal power struggle.

Let's say that this guy is corrupt (who isn't over there?). Why does an effective al Qaeda fighter gets arrested, but Mookie gets away with killing US troops?

Don't just skim the story n... (Below threshold)
Heralder:

Don't just skim the story next time Barney. All of your incorrect assertions and outright distortions came out of your skull and not from the story...where none of what you mentioned is left to question.

Stop being such a contrarian.

Great story. Thanks for th... (Below threshold)

Great story. Thanks for the link.

It's another demonstration of the professionalism and skill of our troops on the ground in Iraq.

If Barney had a dimes worth... (Below threshold)
Ran:

If Barney had a dimes worth of brains, he'd feel pretty stupid about now, but that would be hoping for too much.

Damn your stupid barney. Fo... (Below threshold)
D-Hoggs:

Damn your stupid barney. For the record, I pointed the post out to you yesterday wen you tried claiming it was ll bullshit.

larkin, thanks for your com... (Below threshold)
D-Hoggs:

larkin, thanks for your comment.

That was an incredible piec... (Below threshold)

That was an incredible piece of reporting by Yon. Thanks for linking the whole story.

D-hogg, I read it yesterday... (Below threshold)
BarneyG2000:

D-hogg, I read it yesterday, but it was not easy to find or collaborate.

The original post was presented as a major story:
[US forces capture Iraqi General accused of murder!]

I searched Yon's site, the DOD site and ran a google search, and I found nothing. Yesterday I went back to Instapud and Yon's looking for the full story. I expected to see some type of headline on Yon's site pointing to the "scoop". I ran another google search and still could not find anyone that collaborated Yon's email.

As it turns out, the email over-hyped the events of the day, and that is why nobody picked-up the story.

By all accounts in the story this was an internal affair, and I do not understand why our boys were called on to arrest an Iraqi colonel that was effectively fighting al Qaeda.

You know the guys were there to fight.

Gee barney you must be pret... (Below threshold)
D-Hoggs:

Gee barney you must be pretty retarded, I found it in about 10 seconds. And ONCE AGAIN, it was an Iraqi General, not a Colonel like you claim, you expect anyone to listen to a word you say when you can't even properly read a column? Every thing you stated in your first comment, wrong, yet you conveniently ignore that. Just give it up barney, at least larkin has the decency to contribute a fitting comment.

Not easy to find Barney? W... (Below threshold)
Lorie Byrd:

Not easy to find Barney? What were you entering for your Google search? I typed in Crissman (the subject of the story) and Yon (the author) and the link appeared on the first page of the search results. It literally did not take more than about 2 seconds.

D-Hoggs,I need to ... (Below threshold)
Heralder:

D-Hoggs,

I need to correct you on that detail. He was in reality a Colonel but had essentially dubbed himself a General and it stuck. Yon talks about that at the end of the article.

Barney:

By all accounts in the story this was an internal affair, and I do not understand why our boys were called on to arrest an Iraqi colonel that was effectively fighting al Qaeda.

The reason was two-fold as Yon describes:

Around 1300, two members of the Hit City Council arrived at the JCC demanding that the Coalition do something. If not, they feared that the people of Hit would take care of it. The people were saying clearly that they did not want to attack the police general, but enough was enough. A mob intent on lynching Hamid would surely confront an armed contingent of his supporters, and American forces would be involved in the crossfire. Nobody needed a return to that, which would only undermine LTC Crissman's daily efforts to instill confidence in the people here that there would be a rule of law and that no one--not even the Chief of Police--was above it.

and

But Iraqi officials were clear. They wanted Hamid gone. And they wanted us to arrest him. Anbar is not one of the provinces that has been turned over to PIC control, so the task would properly fall to the Coalition.
You know the guys were there to fight.

I don't know to whom you're referring, but if you meant the U.S. soldiers present, all evidence points in the opposite direction. Wanting to fight would not have resulted in an armed and possibly hostile police station taken over without a gunshot.


As to why Hamid was arrested, well, it's also described in the link. I have no idea why I'm regurgitating it here for you...

"And ONCE AGAIN, it was an ... (Below threshold)
BarneyG2000:

"And ONCE AGAIN, it was an Iraqi General, not a Colonel like you claim,.." by d-hogg

God are you dumb. Can't you even read (from the story):

General Hamid was not actually a prisoner of war: his problems are with the Iraqi government, not with ours. Potentially, though, he could hang. (Note: As it turns out, "General" Hamid was not actually a "general" either. Although he'd claimed the rank for so long that everyone called him "General," Hamid is actually a Colonel. This information was not available until after Hamid's arrest.)

Perhaps because I'm confuse... (Below threshold)
Heralder:

Perhaps because I'm confused as to why this is difficult to understand. The details can certainly be difficult to grasp because the politics are confusing there, but I feel Yon is a very concise writer and explained it well.

Sorry that last bit was an ... (Below threshold)
Heralder:

Sorry that last bit was an extension to my previous post to Barney, I didn't realize they'd get separated.

brney, I thought you said h... (Below threshold)
D-Hoggs:

brney, I thought you said he was never arrested?

Lorie, in google I searched... (Below threshold)
BarneyG2000:

Lorie, in google I searched (variations of) "Iraq General Arrested Yon". All I found was a link to the original email from Yon posted on GR site.

I was also looking for verification of the story and if any other outlets (original intent of the post) were reporting the story.

I am not saying that the story isn't good, or not interesting. It is just not that big of a story that it should lead the evening news. That was the implied message of the original post that the MSM ignores good news out of Iraq.

If it was a general and he was actually charged with murder and we had to run an operation to capture him (rouge army), then that would be a good story, but the truth is:
-he is a colonel (considered a hero for his stand against al Qaeda)
-we have no idea if any charges were made against him (or if any are true)
-the LTC almost blew it
-he basically gave up voluntarily


Thats funny barney, I googl... (Below threshold)
D-Hoggs:

Thats funny barney, I googled "Iraq General Arrested Yon" and found this:

"The Arrest: A gripping account from Michael Yon"

Takes you right to it. I find it interesting that barney and the libs scream and bitch about the US working with the Iraqis etc... and when one of our fine men does just that, and at the request of local leaders acts, they bitch about that too. Apparently you missed this part barney?

"Some local officials who had once regarded Hamid as a hero were now beginning to fear him. Allegations claimed he was committing murders (extra-judicial killings), releasing some detainees for money, abusing other detainees, making deals with various insurgent groups (to include selling them weapons and ammunition), and condoning prostitution in Hit. (It is rumored that the prostitutes had provided critical intelligence on their AQI johns.) Our side believed many of the charges, because there was growing evidence that General Hamid was engaging in criminal activity that could unravel progress towards stability here that can only be described as astounding."

Oh well fuck stability, huh barney.

hogg, way to step up to the... (Below threshold)
BarneyG2000:

hogg, way to step up to the plate admit that you were wrong. You are a class act all the way.

I admit I was wrong barney.... (Below threshold)
D-Hoggs:

I admit I was wrong barney. Now, your turn.

What was I wrong about? Th... (Below threshold)
BarneyG2000:

What was I wrong about? That I went to Yon's site yesterday and I could not find the article?

You say that I can't read a column right after you prove you can't. Now that is embarrassing.

Jesus Barney, you're pathet... (Below threshold)
Ran:

Jesus Barney, you're pathetic.

"this is your brain..this i... (Below threshold)
Ran:

"this is your brain..this is your brain on "Barney"

Class act all the way indee... (Below threshold)
D-Hopggs:

Class act all the way indeed barney. Talk about pathetic.

barneyG' is another bryanD'... (Below threshold)
jhow66:

barneyG' is another bryanD'--from the Area 51 kooks.

BG2 is just a cog in the sp... (Below threshold)
kim:

BG2 is just a cog in the spin machine, producing gauzy transience, blown away by bias. Think cotton candy. bD, is intuitive and creative, and spins a much richer fabric. Think saddle blanket.
============================




Advertisements









rightads.gif

beltwaybloggers.gif

insiderslogo.jpg

mba_blue.gif

Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile

Contact

Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links

Credits

Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login



Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy