So where’s the Jeff Gannon/James Guckert story at these days? [Note: The pseudonym Gannon will be used for the rest of the article]
Even as the blogs investigating this story have continued to play the gay sex/escort/prostitution angle for all it’s worth, focusing on the the ancillary allegations shows how marginal the story actually is.
Allegation – Jeff Gannon received a special permanent White House press “hard pass.”
Fact – The bloggers who made that allegation have now retracted it. It appears that Gannon received day passes under his real name just as he has previously indicated.
Allegation – The White House should not have credentialed Gannon because he was a conservative shill not a real reporter.
Fact – Ari Fleischer, in an interview with Editor &Publisher, notes, “It is a slippery slope for any press secretary in any administration to pick and choose who gets a credential based on ideology, so long as they are a legitimate reporter.” A debate on the merits of Gannon’s journalistic credentials is beyond the scope of this post, but he certainly wrote and published stories at an online news organization, regardless of ones opinion of the relative quality of Talon News.
Allegation – The White House should have know about Gannon’s sexual history and barred him from the White House.
Fact – Ari Fleischer, in an interview with Editor &Publisher, notes, “The last thing our nation needs is for anyone in the White House to concern themselves with the private lives of reporters. What right does the White House have to decide who gets to be a reporter based on private lives?”
Allegation – Gannon had full access to the White House and was running around unchecked in the White House for years.
Fact – To make it scarier the blogs perpetrating this angle of the story need to mention the sexual angle, but on its face it’s a ridiculous claim. Regardless of how you try to spin it a day pass to the White House press briefings is not an all access pass. I don’t know it for sure, but they probably hustle you right out of there when the events of the day are over.
Allegation – Gannon got a press pass while others were rejected.
Fact – Gannon was denied the only passes that matter in this story – the Capital Hill pass issued by the Standing Committee of Correspondents and the White House hard pass, which allows ongoing access to the White House press briefings. The White House hard pass requires a pass first be issued by the Standing Committee of Correspondents. Gannon was left to apply for the only other type of pass available, the daily pass. The daily pass, like its name implies, is good for one day only and by all indications does not have the same restrictions as to who may receive a pass as the the others do. While goofy Maureen Dowd complains that her pass was rejected, she most certainly was writing about a hard pass or a Standing Committee pass, which Gannon too was denied. If Dowd really wanted to cover the White House she could have stood in line for day passes too…
Allegation – Gannon attended a press briefing before Talon News was founded.
Fact – This appears to be true. Gannon appears to have attended a press briefing under the auspices of GOPUSA. From Ari Fleisher’s interview it’s not hard to imagine that Talon News was created to insulate the press coverage that GOPUSA decided it wanted to do from it’s organization. This likely occurred in response to questions from Fleisher about whether GOPUSA was a party organization.
Allegation – Gannon received the Valeria Plame memo and was subpoenaed by the special prosecutor in the Plame case.
Fact – Highly unlikely. Tom McGuire and The Washington Post’s Dan Froomkin debunk that myth pretty convincingly.
Allegation – Gannon asked softball questions.
Fact – True. This is the essence of the Gannongate story. Gannon was “outed” (not sexually) by mainstream media types with the help of David Brock’s Media Matters For America. The reporters got their wish when Gannon quit. The bloggers continuing to pursue the story only “succeed” is they can claim a scalp besides Gannon’s, which is why they continue to search for new angles to implicated ANYONE else…

Sexist? Where on earth does that come from?
Anyway, I am an ex-journalist. I gave it up many years ago. I am now a mere seeker of truth and sanity. And it’s not an easy thing to be, especially on winger blogs.
If I got overly annoyed, my apologies. But when you say the first amendment doesn’t let us define who is or isn’t a journalist — I just get frustrated, because it seems like we are suddenly trying to rewrite the rules to accommodate Gannon. Last I heard, the White House took strong stands on family values and was not renowned for its tolerance of gay male prostitutes in its midst. Now it’s okay. Now it’s none of anyone’s business. Now, as of last week, we can’t say who is press amd who isn’t. Can’t you see, we’re shifting the goalposts to spare Scott and Bush the embarrassment that it really and truly deserves in this case. I am not for smearing the president. But when the shoe fits, he has to wear it. Something smells so mightily here, and the Republicans are holding one another’s nose, and it’s a strange and lurid sight. That’s all.
So it’s left to richard to slog it out in hostile territory. He better hope Kos sends in reinforcements – he’s running out of ammo.
Re: Joe – A little flare-up there, but I want to note that richard stooped first by calling him an “idiot”, thereby revealing HIS “level of political savvy and seriousness.” I think Joe overreacted.
It seems we’re down to a verifiable issue of what it takes to get into a WH briefing. Richard claims he knows based on 2 years as a reporter in DC (and I wouldn’t bet it was the WH beat). Darleen and Joe have promoted the ideal that it *should* be open to persons not in the established media – but no proof that this is the practice. Someone ought to know for sure, but they’re not particpating here (and I’m too lazy to research myself – for such a piddling issue anyway).
But then richard slips up and falls off the deep end again with fresh allegations:
“Oh my God. Papertiger, Gannon didn’t unearth that scoop — it was handed to him by Rove operatives. He didn’t do detective work. (You seem to think the MSM wasn’t interested in such information, which is flatly untrue — any reporter would have KILLED for that info; the “MSM” had Rather’s head on a platter and covered every second of Rathergate with glee.) Gannon was similarly handed info on Valerie Plame, or so it appears. Again, not by brilliant reporting, but because he’s a lackey for the GOP.”
You’re telling me that Gannon is THE direct conduit for WH leaks to tear down the MSM? Better retrieve the tin-foil from the TV dinner, rich. 🙂 I don’t suppose there’s any proof of any of this nonsense, is there?
As for the coverage that Rathergate got, we were there. Like so many scoops that hurt liberals and Dems, this story was put off for as long as possible, and once broken (by Drudge or blogs) then finally covered but with a slant that paints the offender as a victim of shadowy forces.
a) I’m not so sure that the WH was aware of Gannon’s salacious background. If they did know, I don’t think the WH would have chosen to work covertly with him – as you charge. Occam tells me they didn’t know, and this suggests that they didn’t have that much to do with him.
b) If they DID know (and weren’t working with him), I don’t think the WH felt they had any right to exclude him from press briefings based on this info. Think of the fuss from the left if they “excluded based on sexual orientation.”
It’s just impossible to take this stuff seriously.
Just tell us, equius, in regard to Joe’s passionate suggestion that anyone who wants a WH press pass, reporter or not should get one — do you think that’s intelligent or idiotic? That’s the only point that caused me to use the “idiot” word, and looking deep within my heart I can safely tell you that I was totally sincere; I truly felt it was an idiotic suggestion. Don’t you? Honestly now. For him to respond with his “fuck you’s” was a real shock and was quite uncalled for.
Excluding him for being gay would be unconscionable. Doing so because he was a working male prostitute would be quite another story. And you know it.
The WH may well not have known, which would indicate they couldn’t do the most fundamental ID checks. Fake name, male prostitute web sites that any google search could uncover, you know, little stuff like that they let go by…. No, I guess there’s no story here. Even though it tells us any terrorist on the planet can walk right into the West Wing if they ask for a day pass. Yikes.
I’m not sure the WH would have the right to exclude him even if they knew he is (was) a prostitute. On what grounds? A security risk?
I think the ideal that Joe and Darleen promote is laudable, but perhaps not realistic. (I do know they were NOT claiming that this was the current process. You may have misunderstood.) It’s not an idiotic idea, though – in fact it’s a good one. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if there were means for small, independent, and youth media representatives – if not any schmoe of the street – to get their chance as long as they weren’t carrying weapons or bombs.
The thing is, none of here know just what it takes to get in.
Richard
:::sigh::: gads, my 2 y/o grandsons have better comprehension powers than you do.
Neither me nor Joe has said any where “all citizens have a right to the WH press room.” At this point I have no idea whether your intransigence is real or pretense.
All “journalistic” standards, as you put it, are professionally adopted, not governed by legal fiat (libel & slander are not free speech). However, no matter how “clubby” self-proclaimed “Journalists” are, they do NOT get to silence anyone else that wishes to join the public square in speech in all its forms…tabloids, pamphlets, self-published weeklies, online versions of same, freelancers, etc. YOU have no more right to restrict the legal activities towards reporting, opinion or book writing than the government does. In your opinion Gannon is not a “real” reporter. You may be correct, but it still is your opinion, ONLY. If Bill Gates tomorrow bankrolls a building full of presses and starts “Microsoft, the Newspaper” the government has no more right to tell him he is not “legit” than it does Gannon or it does tell Scientology it’s not a “religion” (you and I may agree its a poor excuse for a religion, but we have no right to interfere in the free association or exercise of their religion as long as they act in a legal manner).
I came of age in a time when everyone with access to a mimeograph machine tried their hand at community alerts and newsletters. Were those people “illegitimate?”
Again… Gannon gave his legal and professional name (you call it “fake”… is that how you call about half of Hollywood, not to mention the writers that use noms de plume?) and was then cleared to stand in line for an OPPORTUNITY for a day pass. I guess you believe the other reporters in the WH press room that told E&P (at my link above) that lots of people with unknown backgrounds got in all the time were lying, right?
I’m glad you are an ex-reporter. You don’t really seem able to handle the job. Especially were it concerns libel.
Hmmm.
What a lot of nonsense.
1. So what if Gannon is gay?
Are you liberals suggesting that gays have no place in the White House press room?
2. So what if he had a colorful past?
How many currently accredited reporters broke the law in their younger years? Is the guy still a prostitute? Frankly an assertion that seems more smoke than fire.
3. The MSM press is liberal beyond belief.
Frankly anyone who argues otherwise is an ass. One of the THE unasked questions of the 2004 election was why John Kerry entered into the USNR in 1966 on a 6 year tour, but didn’t get his Honorable Discharge until 1978. As a former Marine I can tell you that it doesn’t take 12 years.
MSM isn’t liberal? What a crock. Clinton got softball questions all the time. It wasn’t until Monica became big news, ratings trump ideology, that anyone dared challenge Clinton on anything. Even then many of the claims made by women injured by Clinton were never addressed or even acknowledged.
…
Frankly unless, and until, you liberals actually come up with something other than penny-ante nonsense, I’ll ignore this ridiculous “scandal”. So far I’m terribly unimpressed and I plan to treat this subject with the disdain it deserves.
Although I am going to keep an eye out for when Gannon files his lawsuits. I’d bet his lawyers are making copies of websites even as we speak. And don’t think that just the website operators will get sued. There’s plenty of libel being tossed around by commenters. It would be a truly amusing thing to see a lot of people served with papers over this.
from E&P
After a 30-minute sit-down with McClellan, WHCA President Ron Hutcheson said he believed the current system was fine and hesitated to have the correspondents’ association play a bigger role in distributing press passes. “I’m not sure we need to do anything,” Hutcheson told E&P. “I’m not comfortable in passing judgment on who is a journalist and who isn’t. My overriding view is that if I am going to make a mistake, it is going to be on letting people in rather than keeping people out.”
—–
Currently, two types of press passes are issued. The “hard pass,” which allows reporters regular ongoing access to the White House, and “day passes,” which must be issued each morning and are good only for one day. Hard passes are more difficult to obtain, requiring the reporter to first obtain a Capitol Hill credential, issued by a committee of congressional reporters known as the Standing Committee of Correspondents.
Day passes appear to be available to any reporter who provides his or her name, address, and social security number and the name of his or her news organization, and can pass a basic security check.
There it is. Other unknowns from “questionable” news organizations, like Mukhiber, have always had access and gotten day passes. This Monty Python No One Expects the Spanish Inquisition! routine is downright insulting. The WH is much more open to let the “rabble” rub elbows with the Anointed “Journalists” and the Left suddenly is concerned with “standards.”
Yeah, right, sure, uh huh.
meshugga
“That’s the only point that caused me to use the “idiot” word, and looking deep within my heart I can safely tell you that I was totally sincere; I truly felt it was an idiotic suggestion.”
LOL. Don’t worry, as long as you meant it I can handle it. Besides, I think your suggestions are idiotic as well. Anyway, big deal. Let’s move on. You called me an “idiot”, I called you a “dumb fuck”. Same thing really.
“Seriously — I know how it works”
That’s nice. Anyway, the “way it works” is completely unacceptable. I want LESS corporate media in the press pool. The whole thing is a sham. It’s theatre. I want people like Kevin Aylward, Michael Totten, Kevin Drum, Jeff Jarvis, Charles Johnson, Josh Marshall etc. given the opportunity to ask some questions. Note, not just any old hobo hoping for a free snack at the Whitehouse, but citizen journalists who are untainted by corporate media’s corrupt culture and cronyism.
“Last I heard, the White House took strong stands on family values and was not renowned for its tolerance of gay male prostitutes in its midst. Now it’s okay.”
You’re buying into the myth that rightwingers are all “values voters”. God knows you leftwingers like to flog that overhyped horse. Sure, Dobson is probably pissed about Gannon being gay, but Dobson is a loser, and he doesn’t represent most of the “wingers” I know. He’s like our Barbara Boxer, only Boxer hates black conservatives. Dobson hates black gays.
Gannon was similarly handed info on Valerie Plame, or so it appears.
More, like he stooped down, picked it up, and read it in his WSJ. Add the fake press pass lie you keep ranting about, it’s not hard to figure out why you are no longer a reproter — assuming you ever were one.
Allegation: Daily Kos and Eschaton investigations delved into Gannon’s personal life.
Fact: The investigation was built almost entirely from public data.
Allegation: Daily Kos and Eschaton investigations were trying to prove that Gannon was gay.
Fact: Gannon’s extracurricular activities were a byproduct of the investigation of his real name, with the original purpose of finding a link between Gannon and the White House.
Allegation: “Media reports” falsely stated that Gannon had been issued a subpoena.
Fact: Gannon himself said he was subpoened at Free Republic–“Well, as many of you now know, I have been subpeonaed by the Federal grand jury for testimony in the CIA leak probe.”
Allegation: The left side of the blogosphere are celebrating the Gannon takedown, equating him to Rather and Jordan.
Fact: They agree he’s an obscure nobody.
Allegation: Gannon plagiarized RNC fact sheets.
Fact: That’s not all he plagiarized. Pick an article of his at random and look for the associated press statement. I’ve done it three times and come up with three near exact copies.
Allegation: Talon News purged their files when they saw the investigation coming.
Fact: Talon has eradicated every Jeff Gannon article ever written, both from their own website and GOP USA’s. When they discovered that people were using Wayback copies, they ensured those were purged, too.
Allegation: Gannon and others at Talon News quickly modified their Internet site domain records in an attempt to throw off the scent.
Fact: Last week, GOP USA and Talon News NIC records listed Bobby Eberle as owner, this week it’s Endeavor Media Group. Gannon changed his domain ownership, too.
Allegation: Gannon was a White House plant.
Fact: Unknown, but unlikely. But given that Gannon’s strong track record of plagiarism, it’s unlikely he wrote any of his investigative pieces and then the question rises: who did?
Oh, and to forestall the inevitable charge: I’m not from the left. Football Fans for Truth, “John Kerry throws like a girl, didn’t run the marathon or attend game 6” 527 organization that ol’ Hugh Hewitt himself thanked after the election. Haven’t changed sides lately, either.
Whether or not the Gannon story leads anywhere else, the right should take note. The left did an impressive job of building a case from data that most people don’t even know exists. They didn’t piss and moan and jump up and down demanding the media investigate–they did it themselves. The right might want to pay attention to the big stack of information they aren’t using yet, rather than dreaming up false equivalencies that no one brought up in the first place.
Why “Getting Jeff Gannon” might matter more than you think
So journalistic standards are your only raison d’etre to join up on the gay-bashing of Gannon? Am I reading that right?
No, you’re not. I never advocated gay-bashing. In fact, I stated that I was disappointed that his homosexuality has become such a lightning rod for the left. You must be reading another blog.
Darleen, what’s this obsession with the gay angle? It was barely mentioned in this thread until you came along. Get over it.
And while you’re at it, get over Al Gore. Sheesh.
Yes, there are some homophobes in the GOP… but this idea is not the root of the Admin’s gay policy.
Right. The root of the Admin’s gay policy is to amend the Constitution, the most important document that defines the United States, whose amendments grant rights to citizens, for the sole purpose of denying a right. But they’re not homophobes.
Jeff Gannon did an interview with CNN. Which means that Mr.Gannon has more integrity then the “real” ex cheif of CNN’s news department, Eason Jordan.
heh
Richard:
“No, I guess there’s no story here. Even though it tells us any terrorist on the planet can walk right into the West Wing if they ask for a day pass. Yikes.”
Now we’re reaching Richard. We’re getting awful desperate to make this into far more than it is and looking totaly absurd doing so.
Brian
If Gannon was a hack or opportunistic hack that lifted some of his writings from others..go ahead and bust him on that. He resigned.
However the salacious and vituperative attacks on Gannon have almost exclusively focused on his personal life… a scorched-earth virtual crushing that Kos himself said “hey, sex sells” a deja vu variation of his infamous “screw ’em” meme.
And then there was democrat.com with its “Did GW have sex with Gurkert” post with its “promise” to keep “at it” until the “truth” came out.
Yeah, RIGHT this is not about punishing the apostate gay.
And consider support of the FMA is not prima facia evidence of [drum roll] H O M O P H O B I A. There are reasonable arguments against same-sex marriage. However, face the fact that the FMA got rolling for two big reasons… MA judges and Mayor Newsom. When you tell The People “f**k off, we make the LAWS not you!” You’re gonna have people decide to go the legal route to try and amend the Constitution.
You know, that IS their right. Or do rights only exist at the behest of the Left?
The left did an impressive job of building a case from data that most people don’t even know exists. They didn’t piss and moan and jump up and down demanding the media investigate–they did it themselves.
Oh, give me a fucking break! They did a google search and made some phone calls while pissing and moaning and jumping up and down about why the msm wasn’t orgasming over the story.
Typing “allegation colon” does not make what follows relevant. And adding your little “fact”urd doesn’t make you credible.
The root of the Admin’s gay policy is to amend the Constitution, the most important document that defines the United States, whose amendments grant rights to citizens, for the sole purpose of denying a right. But they’re not homophobes.
No, they’re not. They’re just not willing to play some game of the emperor’s new clothes.
Jeff Gannon is clearly a real piece of work. All of Cal Lanier’s minutae illustrate a shady operator and questionable character. He shows very little discretion and therefore left plenty of stuff in the public record for the left to use against him.
But all this stuff (prostitution, plagiarism, etc.) is not important, doesn’t matter. So Kos & Co organized a take-down, and the right should take note. I don’t see why this matters.
The case for a link between him and the WH is weak; Day Passes are pretty easy to get. Gannon fancies himself a reporter, gets some initial attention as non-hostile to the President, gets a little GOP-USA money and starts getting regular day passes. Big deal.
So, the lefty blogs organize to see if he is one of those “paid journalists” we’ve all been hearing about. They find his PAC money (but nothing like Armstrong Williams) as well as his sordid background. That is, they don’t find what they’re looking for that would take down the White House, but they do find some goodies to take down the person.
What’s the point of that? Why is that important?
I think the blog-right has a good thing going. The blogger investigations against Rather and Jordan weren’t conducted quite as literally as the left has done with Gannon, but instead has demonstrated a sort of self-organizing that can emerge when disseminated agents are suitably motivated and connected. It’s a microcosm of the left’s statism vs. the right’s free market. I trust the free market to be more efficient in the long run.
Darleen,
If you’re gonna keep up the hypocritical gay-bashing angle, you might wanna get better evidence than pulling it out of a comment thread at democrats.com! Go to AMERICAblog or Raw Story, and pull your evidence from the blog posts!
But, I know you won’t!
It’s been 23 days since Media Matters posted it’s first report on Gannon. If this was just a salacious assault against Gannon, you wouldn’t be here!
The root of the Admin’s gay policy is to amend the Constitution
No, you’re thinking is muddled. (It’s getting late, I know.)
Amending the Constitution is the policy – not the root of the policy. Right? The root of the policy – its source and inspiration – is the age-old concept of the institution of marriage.
And I know you will scoff when I say in all honesty: this is not de facto the same thing as homophobia.
“The left did an impressive job of building a case from data that most people don’t even know exists. They didn’t piss and moan and jump up and down demanding the media investigate–they did it themselves.”
Cal, you’re too easily impressed. Searching WHOIS data is something your grandmother can do, even after it’s changed. For WHOIS change history, use Whois.sc. Here’s GOPUSA. Try it. You’ll be shocked. From jeffgannon.com to finding the names of the porn sites registered in his name is 5 minutes worth of work, especially if they are all registered to the same registrant, Admin or Technical contact. The rest are all just Google searches. The only thing I find even mildly impressive is getting hold of those pics with Jeff “RockHard” Gannon. As I understand it they caught a break when the guy who did those sites for Gannon heard of the whole kerfuffle. Nonetheless, that is pretty good. Nothing like the reasearch that went into the Dan Rather forgeries though.
By contrast, with Eason Jordan the proof was the video tape of the event and eyewitness accounts. Simple. No amount of Googling around the internet would have produced that video. Eyewitness accounts were collected though. Not much more you can do.
By the way, Eason Jordan allegedly had an affair with murdered WSJ reporter Daniel Pearl’s wife. That may be something where digging around archives will be useful. But thankfully nobody on the right is interested in that angle.
Anyway. I’m done with this thread.
Credible? It’s the comments section of a blog.
None of the meaningful revelations came from phone calls, and much of it came from domain databases and archive caches. They also did a number of google searches, on a number of subjects. It’s one thing to google Talon News, and quite another to google strings from Gannon’s articles and find the original plagiarized source.
>Typing “allegation colon” does not make what follows relevant.
You should probably mention that to ol’ Wizbang then, huh? See, I was using his format. Kind of a riff, you know?
“However the salacious and vituperative attacks on Gannon have almost exclusively focused on his personal life… “
Cite. Where are these “salacious and vituperative attacks” from the left bloggers that focus exclusively on his personal life? Bloggers, not forum posts, because Free Republic wouldn’t stand up to any sort of scrutiny, either.
I ask because, unlike you, I actually read the entire investigation at dailykos and eschaton (and there’s a bullet you can thank me for). Apart from the usual chortle at having uncovered a hypocrite (to the left, all gay Republicans are hypocrites), there were no personal attacks. They proved he was a gay male prostitute because he went on television and said he wasn’t. Bad move. Ask Gary Hart.
In fact, I stated that I was disappointed that his homosexuality has become such a lightning rod for the left.
Oh, yeah? Then why aren’t you on all the lefty blogs telling them you are so *disappointed* in their gay bashing? Otherwise, all you’re doing is having someone else do the dirty work for you.
oh…that’s right… Raw Story was the one accusing Scott McClellan of being a closet gay … you know, the nudge nudge wink wink about Scott and Gannon… ooooOOoooOOO ..
Yeah, not about gays. Just the “inauthentic” ones.
It’s really strange that you accuse ME of gay-bashing because I’m pointing out the beyond the pale attacks on Gannon.
Can we say projection?
the left, all gay Republicans are hypocrites
Of course. The Left is a cult and only THEY can confer authenticity on who is or isn’t a “true” gay.
God, that’s so friggin’ depraved. No wonder they are so apologetic about jihadists.
Joe said, ” I wish the Whitehouse would approve more reporters OUTSIDE of the mainstream media establishment. In fact, I believe that at least a third of ALL press passes should be reserved for citizen reporters ONLY.”
And Richard responded by saying “Brilliant… Yes, let’s allow all citizens into the White House press briefings. Gee, why didn’t I think of that? ” and calling him an idiot.
That wasn’t what Joe said, though, was it? He said *reporters* outside the MSM, _citizen reporters_, and he suggested reserving only a third of day passes for these citizen journalists. You might not like that idea, but you ought to at least recognize the difference between what he said and what you heard.
Next point- I actually am bothered by the fact that the WH missed his prostitution activities, and I think you make a couple of good points about that. My problen with it is that it is a very illegal activity, and I wish the security clearance process turned it up. Even though I suspect it’s not that easy to discover illegal activity that a person hasn’t ever actually been _charged_ with, I agree with you that this should be a cause for concern. You say you think most conservatives would have been upset about it had Clinton done it, and while I think not quite so many as you assume would be reacting differently, there are enough who would that I can say I think you got that right.
But you also get some stuff very wrong. His prostitution activities were not easily found via Google before the story broke, and in fact, were not ‘found’ at all- the creep he paid to do the website contacted the Americablog person and outed his client.
He did not get a daypass under an assumed name- he gave his real name and his social security number to the folks in charge of the passes. You lose mega credibility when you keep talking about him using an assumed name. They knew his real name.
The idea that as a gay prostitute Gannon was open to blackmail and thus a security threat is an idea that you might want to think through further. Gannon wasn’t privvy to WH secrets. I know you think he was leaked some documents, but there is just not any credible evidence that he did anymore than read the papers. He’s not in the military, he doesn’t work for the WH- what security threat might he have been blackmailed to *cause* exactly? I just can’t see that outing a reporter as a prostitute is a threat of much serious use to a blackmailer. He could be used for propaganda purposes, maybe (publish this or I publish that), but since his readership was so small, I can’t see that being of much value.
You also lost all manner of credibility by insisting that the MSM was out to get Rather during Rathergate and covered that w/o bias in his favor. Come on.
Here’s a question, a real question- you mentioned that he showed up with a press pass before the Talon agency even existed. But as I understand it only about a month or so before it was legall incorporated and all that. I have some experience (small, just two organizations) with incorporating and the paperwork involved, and although Talon may not have legally existed as an entity, based on my experiences, that does not mean Talon wasn’t functioning, in the planning stages, and that the people involved were not already more or less in place and operating at some level. In both cases where I have some knowledge of the process (in one of them I actually did all the bylaw writing and paperwork filing with the state secretary, and so I know our group was actually functioning as the entity we later legally became _months_ before we existed as an incorporated group) So I’m wondering how accurate it is really to say Gannon had a press pass before Talon even existed. Is it possible that what that really means is Gannon had a press pass before Talon had completed its paperwork? We can’t really be trying to say that Talon wasn’t even a gleam in its mama’s eye until the day the paperwork was magically filed and approved, right?
Well, I had some other questions/comments/brilliant observations, but it’s late.
He’s just not that big of a fish. I never heard of him before this story broke. I heard that a reporter asked that silly question about Democrats being divorced from reality, but I didn’t get a name connected with it, and I knew from the question he didn’t work for any MSM org. His sphere of influence was miniscule. He could have read Repub talking points all day long, and nobody knew about it except the reporters in the room and the tiny readership of his own agency, because his questions weren’t reported by the MSM until the Dems divorced from reality one.
Darleen,
I’ve read the Raw Story very carefully, and have it bookmarked. I know for a fact that it does not pointly, explicity or directly accuse McClellan of anything!
Such accusations are the product of hysterical and desperate apologists on the Right. Cite the passage, or shut up!
Joe–Mickey Kaus has commented quite a bit on Jordan’s affair with Daniel Pearl’s widow, and Howard Kurtz mentioned it in his original article (he then edited it).
And….wow, wait! Look here! Wizbang comments section on Jordan and Pearl’s widow. Or maybe don’t look, if you’re so decent. A google reveals that most conservative blogs have had a conversation on the Jordan/Pearl connection, so don’t be aping airs.
I never said searching NIC was difficult, but nice try at a strawman. I said that most people have no idea what NIC is, and even fewer thought of searching it. (and I do mean people, not just a narrow corner of the blogosphere)
I agree that there wasn’t as much opportunity for investigation in the Jordan incident, although lord knows no one tried. But come on. Research into the Rather memos? Experts got their views to bloggers, who broadcast it from there. I can’t recall a single relevant point that was achieved by investigation. The definitive KO was the MSM interviewing document experts, not anything dug up by the blogosphere. The major achievement was in getting the mainstream media to cover the story, do the research, and hold CBSs feet to the fire, when they showed every sign of ignoring it. A second accomplishment was broadcasting expert knowledge that was emailed or posted. Again, great stuff. But it’s not the same sort of investigative process that was done in the Gannon story.
Darleen,
I’ve read the Raw Story very carefully, and have it bookmarked. I know for a fact that it does not pointedly, explicity or directly accuse McClellan of anything!
Such accusations are the product of hysterical and desperate apologists on the Right. Cite the passage, or shut up!
Credible? It’s the comments section of a blog.
So, your defense for lack of credibility it’s a blog?
None of the meaningful revelations came from phone calls, and much of it came from domain databases and archive caches.
They called the damn webmaster and the guy sent them all the porn photos so they could post them. And that was the ONLY meaningful revelation in theis whole crappy affair.
They also did a number of google searches, on a number of subjects. It’s one thing to google Talon News, and quite another to google strings from Gannon’s articles and find the original plagiarized source.
It’s called select, copy, paste, google, dude. A crack smoking monkey could be taught to do that.
>Typing “allegation colon” does not make what follows relevant. You should probably mention that to ol’ Wizbang then, huh? See, I was using his format. Kind of a riff, you know?
Wizbang: Allegation, colon, relevant.
You: Allegation, color, irrelevant.
See the difference?
“However the salacious and vituperative attacks on Gannon have almost exclusively focused on his personal life… ” Cite. Where are these “salacious and vituperative attacks” from the left bloggers that focus exclusively on his personal life?
Cite where I wrote that first.
I ask because, unlike you, I actually read the entire investigation at dailykos and eschaton (and there’s a bullet you can thank me for). Apart from the usual chortle at having uncovered a hypocrite (to the left, all gay Republicans are hypocrites), there were no personal attacks.
Bullshit.
Cal, don’t be silly. Are Mickey Kaus and Howard Kurtz rightwingers now? And some comments at Wizbang talks about Pearls wife? Oh boy, this thing is going global soon! Tell you what, let’s just assume that it’s mentioned in a few other places as well, just to cut to the end. The point you’re missing is that Pearl’s wife has barely been mentioned by most (not all, most) rightwing blogs. It sure as hell didn’t feature as prominantly as the gay angle with the Gannon story.
And….wow, wait! Look here! Wizbang comments section on Jordan and Pearl’s widow. Or maybe don’t look, if you’re so decent.
Oh, give me another fucking break! One person in one thread as opposed to 500 comments in numerous threads fantasizing about every sex act known to man or beast. Get some perspective already!
This is the first I’ve heard of Jordan/Pearle.
I’m outta here…
“Get some perspective already!”
Unlikely. Cal’s a guy who is more impressed by Google searches than typographical analysis. If the Kinko’s where Burkett faxed his fake memos from had a porn site, maybe we could have nailed him through Google.
“although Talon may not have legally existed as an entity, based on my experiences, that does not mean Talon wasn’t functioning, in the planning stages, and that the people involved were not already more or less in place and operating at some level.”
Talon was a created, madeup entity, a pretend media group for GOP USA, a political action group. Gannon was issued a day pass under that company. If you check my article above, you’ll see that Gannon posted about a press conference he attended prior to April 2003. Click his moniker and you’ll see that he’s representing GOP USA.
Keep in mind that Gannon declared that he never went to a press conference before April 2003.
About his readership: according to Gannon, they had 700,000 readers. That seems overstated (and there’s no reason to believe Gannon on anything), but in any event, Talon News articles show up all over the conservative side of the blogosphere. Powerline, Michelle Malkin, and Rathergate to name just a few.
Shouldn’t you, oh, I dunno, actually read about it before you decide that the story is unfounded, unimportant, or irrelevant? Most of the posters here seem only to know what their favorite bloggers have said, and while that’s fine and dandy, it doesn’t suit you well for an argument on the facts.
Look, I want to be clear: While I’m not hooting and hollering at the victory, I’m not at all sorry that they did this investigation, and I think it’s quite possible (but not certain) that it will get more coverage than Jordan. The facts on Gannon, Talon News, and GOPUSA can’t be disputed: Gannon owned and managed the domains, Gannon plagiarized, Talon News is nothing more than a pretend media company for GOP USA to game the system, Talon/GOP USA purged their sites of any Gannon articles in an attempt to avoid scrutiny, Talon/GOP USA and Gannon altered their domain records in an attempt to foil same.
So they’ve already gone well beyond Gannon. If there’s any mechanism in place to validate media outlets, Talon News is probably in trouble. GOP USA may be in trouble if there are any laws about setting up a pretense of a media company to bypass various FCC restrictions. The actual authorship of Gannon’s articles may or may not lead to further embarrassing revelations, which could potentially lead further into the Republican party.
The investigation was entirely appropriate. That’s what journalism is, after all–digging up facts that require explanation or reveal untruths.
But the reason I wrote about it, and am trying to get people to pay attention, is that the conservative bloggers tend to think of the Internet as a really cool form of talk radio, and they need to realize that model is only a small part of the story. The left generated this story out of nothing more than information records available online, and they generated solid data.
They will in all likelihood do it again. The right needs to catch up.
Clive??
I’ve read the Raw Story very carefully, and have it bookmarked. I know for a fact that it does not pointedly, explicity or directly accuse McClellan of anything!
Guess you didn’t bookmark this now did ya?
excerpts:
Some question whether Gannon may have leveraged a personal intimate relationship with someone at the White House to gain access to President Bush …
Sources have intimated possible relationships with members of the White House staff. Guckert did not respond to requests for comment.
RAW STORY has been told that the White House Press Secretary Scott McClellan visited a gay bar in Austin, Texas, on March 19, 1995. The date was placed exactly as a local memorial service was held on the same day.
The source, who would only comment on condition of anonymity, reserved comment on whether McClellan was actually gay, but said he was frequently seen at gay clubs.
Hey man…just a nudge nudge wink wink thing!
I bet Fred Phelps is putting you all on speed dial now.
GannonWho–there’s a conversation of that sort at every conservative blog I checked. Free Republic is replete with speculation. I don’t see anything wrong with it; I’m just pointing out that Joe’s celebration of the right’s forbearance is overplayed.
As for it not getting the same play–well, duh. It’s not nearly as fun as a gay anti-gay Republican. But the idea that people aren’t aware of it and comment on it–including on cable news shows–is absurd.
Besides, as I keep pointing out, the left did not get into the investigation to out Gannon.
“Unlikely. Cal’s a guy who is more impressed by Google searches than typographical analysis.”
Not true (in more than one way). I’m very impressed with typographical analysis. But that wasn’t the role played by the conservative blogosphere.
Cal
Catch up?
I think you got it backwards. I think Gannon was the poor hapless mongrel dog ripped to shreds with shrieks of delight because the Left was smarting after Dan Rather and Eason Jordan (and remember, too, it was righty blogs that got the ball rolling on Trent Lott).
I think it’s to the right of center blogs credit that after Jordan resigned they did not do the personal tar-n-feather him and his kids too like the Left is doing to Gannon.
I’m very impressed with typographical analysis. But that wasn’t the role played by the conservative blogosphere.
That’s an absurd statement, because its untrue. IIRC (I’d have to go back and look), it was Bill at INDC Journal that actually got some experts involved. Charles Johnson did initial work and promoted Newcomer’s analysis.
ALL the anaylsis came through and was pushed BY non-left blogs. INCLUDING the debunking of the one “expert” CBS tried to peddle.
Hey Clive: Darleen wrote: Raw Story was the one accusing Scott McClellan of being a closet gay … you know, the nudge nudge wink wink about Scott and Gannon… ooooOOoooOOO ..
And indeed it does do just that.
Such accusations are the product of hysterical and desperate apologists on the Right. Cite the passage, or shut up!
You have the nerve to demand that she prove what she didnt’ say? You STFU! Talk about hysterical and desparate!
“Talon/GOP USA purged their sites of any Gannon articles in an attempt to avoid scrutiny”
You’re reaching. Maybe they simply erased it until the questions about plagiarism etc. can be cleared up. Is Jason Blair’s articles still on the NYT web site? If it is, I’m sure it has a warning sticker on it.
“Talon/GOP USA and Gannon altered their domain records in an attempt to foil same.”
You can’t alter WHOIS history. Sorry.
“I’m very impressed with typographical analysis. But that wasn’t the role played by the conservative blogosphere.”
Nonsense. Bloggers were very active in doing typographical analysis. Experts were only called in to validate and give credence to what bloggers already knew by then.
Yup Darlene,
The exact passage! Confirmed sightings of McClellan at gay bars in Austin!
Not accusations! ‘Wink, wink, nudge, nudge’, does not a Libel suit make. Got any quotes of Scott denying he visited those bars??
Remember, you’re claiming Gannon cannot be called a prostitute with no criminal record, therefore you cannot claim a closeted accusation with just ‘wink, wink…’
And indeed it does do just that.
So GW,
Where are the cries from the Right that McClellan has been libeled? Where is his quoted outrage at being libeled? Where are his quotes denying he’s never visited a gay bar in Austin?
You’re so adorable when you curse in intials…
Posted by west at February 18, 2005 09:05 PM :”They really are having a problem getting their message out. How’s this:
“Being gay and being allowed too keep your sex life private is your right – unless you are conservative, in which case beiong GAY is BAD, and you deserve whgatever you get – especially if your dick is longer than mine.” “
How about this from CNSnews:
“Homosexuality, at its core, is about narcissism and self-loathing.”
Gannon Flap Shows Liberals in Denial
By David Thibault
CNSNews.com Managing Editor
February 17, 2005
Posted by: Joe at February 18, 2005 10:32 PM: “I don’t care what Gannon calls himself professionaly. He probably did it to hide his gay past. Can’t blame him. “
Some of those sites were still up a few days ago.
Posted by: Papertiger at February 18, 2005 11:03 PM:
“I’m reading up on this Gannon story and it seems that he was the person with the scoop, that Mary Mapes was the contact point for the Fake Tang Memos.
Gannon got that scoop> none of the other press got that. “
So, how did this flunky get the scoop? Previously, all he had been known for was loaded questions and being a stenographer for the WH.
I don’t think any of us on the left would have too much to say about “Gannon” if he had been representing the WSJ, or the New York Post, or FoxNews, or the Washington Times — for none of us would be the least bit surprised to discover that someone working for one of those media outlets (and surely the Bushoisie doesn’t have any problems with those particular branches of the MSM you so love to hate, eh?) would turn out to be an actual whore.
But for the Bush White House to give preferential treatment to an obscure partisan “journalist” from an equally obscure partisan “news organization,” so as to make the briefing-room environment more friendly for the President, is a perversion of the very idea of a free and independent press, and is reminiscent of the way that Michael “Big Fat Porky Lard-Butt” (there, that’s out of the way now) Moore sells his own version of the truth under the guise of “documentary” film-making.