By now you’ve probably seen this Pulitzer winning picture from the AP and read some of the controversy surrounding it. It is a picture of 2 people getting shot in Baghdad.
If you are new to the story, you can get caught up to speed, here here here here here here here here and here. (it caused a stink)
But the 10 second version of all of those links goes like this… The photographer must have been working with the insurgents (and known there was a murder about to happen) to get this picture because the odds are incredibly long that someone would catch an execution on film AND, the photographer took the picture rather than running for his life. This is summed up by Powerline asking 2 questions:
The photographer was obviously within a few yards of the scene of the murder, which raises obvious questions, such as 1) what was the photographer doing there; did he have advance knowledge of the crime, or was he even accompanying the terrorists? and 2) why did the photographer apparently have no fear of the terrorists, or conversely, why were the terrorists evidently unconcerned about being photographed in the commission of a murder?
Allow me to be the iconoclast as I answer the 2 questions:
Q1 What was the photographer doing there?
A Let’s review, there was a news photographer in a war zone. Duh?!? Why do you think he was there? Do you think the pictures take themselves? There are several hundred (thousands?) photographers running thru a war zone for a year and you are surprised one of them caught an act of war on film? These guys spend 24 hours a day, camera in hand, looking for a picture like this… Are we surprise one of them got such a picture of marginal (technical) quality?
I hate to call out my fellow conservative bloggers, but this is just silly.
Just tune in your TV to all the various “caught on tape” shows that populate the airwaves and you will see that even amateurs mange to get pictures of the most bizarre things on film and tape. Really it is somewhat odd that this is a Pulitzer winning photo, it’s not that good. Frankly, I’m surprised this is the “best” anyone got the whole year.
Sure you might wonder if he had advanced knowledge but assuming he must have because “the odds were against him” is just silly. To me, a former news photographer, too silly to even mention publicly.
Q2 Why did the photographer apparently have no fear of the terrorists?
A If the photog was more worried about his safety than the picture, he would have been home on his couch. War photogs ain’t like most people, when they hear shooting they run toward it. It flies in the face of self preservation but it happens every day. Look at Geraldo Rivera, (love him or hate him) when we went to war, he gave up a multi-million dollar contract hosting a cable news show to go get shot at… and his brother went with him. It takes a different kind of person to do that.
Again, this is silly on its face to assume collusion because the photog did not run.
When tornado’s blew thru a small community I was in, I grabbed my camera and headed into the storm to get pictures, not giving much though to what might happen to me. That’s just the way news photographers (and firemen and policemen…) work every day. War photographers, by definition, aren’t afraid of war.
And as far as the terrorists not wanting their picture taken… If they sought anonymity, they would not have done this in broad daylight on a busy city street.
Finally, look at the picture technically… If this is the best he could do with advanced notice, he isn’t too good a photographer. Clearly it was both taken with a longish lens and cropped dramatically. (look at the grain) Admittedly my eyes see what most people don’t in a photo but if I had to take a wild guess, I would guess the photographer could be 100 yards [Ed – corrected years] away or more easily. (trust me I shot football for years)
This is an unspectacular picture that has been blown completely out of proportion (sadly) by people on my side of the agenda. Let’s not get crazy huh? That’s what the other side is best at.
Update below the fold. and Kevin Craver takes the time to answer some of the questions I glossed over.
]]>< 
Nice lab coat, Paul.
This is satire, right?
right?
April Fools, right?
right?
So why was the photographer in the middle of the street and why didn’t he stop the murders, or at least try.
So — you saying if you saw a person get injured in a torando you would just take their picture.
Further, this ain’t no tornado, these are terrorist who kill people at will. I doubt you would rush to the scene snapping pictures knowing they take journalists captive and behead them. Especially if they could be ID’ed — note the guy in the middle with no mask.
Don’t buy it — it was cooked from the get go. Nice try, but no sale.
Bill, not having a gun in your hand, what would you have done? Run screaming up to a group of madmen firing guns at innocent people, yelling at them to stop in the name of all that is good and right and just?
If all you’ve got is a camera, you do the best you can — in hopes, perhaps, of being able to help identify the murderers.
I’ll admit I hadn’t given much thought to the picture before this, but the “cooked” argument sounds a little too “Jeff Gannon was Lewinskying Dubya” to me. Someone please tell me: Who was standing on the grassy knoll?
I’m not wild about the fact that we gave a prize — not just an honorary prize, an actual cash prize — to a reporter who stood around and watched two people get murdered.
I also don’t buy into the conspiracy-theory side of this, but I think there’s plenty to be outraged about. When did being a reporter absolve somebody of all moral responsibility?
I don’t know, Paul, you ought to go look at Powerline’s latest on the subject. First of all, according to Salon, the AP has admitted that the photographer was tipped. Now, they didn’t that the photographer was tipped to a terrorist murder; they said that he was tipped to a demonstration. But we all know what the word “demonstration” means in this context. Second of all, you have to know what was happening where and when the photograph was taken. As I understand it, the murders happened at a polling site on the day of the Iraqi elections (someone correct me if I’m wrong), and the victims were poll workers. Now, given that the insurgents had made specific threats to disrupt the election by attacking polling places… well, I can put two and two together.
Further: Powerline has a later statement where the AP pretty much admits that it uses people known to the terrorists as photographers. The phrase “family and tribal relations give them access” pretty much sums it up. And the fact that the AP refuses to identify this Pulitzer Prize-winning photographer — why would they do that? Because, after the NBC/Kevin Sites fiasco, they are afraid that bloggers will research the photographer’s backgound and uncover his/her connections? Why else would they withhold the photog’s identity? (Don’t even get me started on why the AP should or should not have published the photograph. That’s a debate for another thread.)
I do agree with you on one thing: it’s not that great a shot. The composition is cluttered by all of the cars in the background, and it’s badly back-lit and underexposed. I think it’s very clear that the Pulitzer committee chose this photograph because it agreed with the committee’s political agenda, not because of any merits of the photograph itself.
Jeff if photogs are there to play moral judge and stop people from killing people in war, we have a problem… I share your concern that he got a cash prize for this but like it or not, it is news.
I do not think the photog had any responsibility to go running after armed men telling them to stop. See also McGehee above.
(especially- think about it people… The photog was shooting at random at this point hoping he got news. (news photography is a lot like fishing) He probably had no clue what happened until several seconds after it did.)
Cousin Dave
>>AP has admitted that the photographer was tipped
That’s not exactly what the AP said. It was a “source” not the AP. Further he said “likely” tipped to a “demonstration” not a murder, not defiantly tipped to a murder… Overreaction.
>>As I understand it, the murders happened at a polling site on the day of the Iraqi elections (someone correct me if I’m wrong), and the victims were poll workers. Now, given that the insurgents had made specific threats to disrupt the election by attacking polling places… well, I can put two and two together.
NOPE! The pic was taken a month before the election. 2 and 2 don’t go together in this paragraph….
>>Further: Powerline has a later statement where the AP pretty much admits that it uses people known to the terrorists as photographers. The phrase “family and tribal relations give them access” pretty much sums it up.
Not really… Kurds can work in the Kurdish areas when a Sunni can not… This is not admitting to aiding terrorism, it is an admission of demographic realities.
>>And the fact that the AP refuses to identify this Pulitzer Prize-winning photographer — why would they do that? Because, after the NBC/Kevin Sites fiasco, they are afraid that bloggers will research the photographer’s backgound and uncover his/her connections?
Sources and methods. Assuming the bad guys didn’t want their picture taken –which grows more likely as a system of justice is installed– he is at risk.
And on your last point political agenda might have come into play but the fact it was (astonishingly) apparently one of the “newsests” pics probably held sway.
Dave if you think this thru, many are overreacting.
McGehee — so why would you run up to a group of terrorists with guns in their hands when you were armed with a camera — and not feel threatened?
I would have at least tried to summon help.
Notice the terrorists don’t seem to be in the least bit concerned that the photographer approached them — despite at least one looking almost directly at the camera. Do you think that is normal terrorist action? The camera guy could have had a gun, couldn’t he? How did they know he didn’t?
The photo is obviously staged.
What’s wrong with you, Paul? Are you some kind of Photojournalistic Zealot? Are you taking this dumb position just to create another contrived controversy?
Keeeeeeeeeeeeeeeviiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiin!!! Paul is at it again.
I agree with Paul here. It appears to have been shot with a very long lens and then cropped for affect.
The picture is not very graphic either. It shows a guy, holding a gun and other men around him in various positions.
This is tame compared to other Pulitzer Prize Photos. If you want graphic, go back to 1968 and look at the photo shot by Eddie Adams that year. He won the prize and it is graphic, title Viet Cong Execution.
It shows a South Vietnamese General with a hand gun offing a Viet Cong prisoner. The photo was quite literally caught at the moment of impact.
Would you have expected Eddie Adams to go grab the generals arm and stop this from happening? Particularly when he was surrounded by his own troops? It happened in the middle of the street in Saigon.
War Zone photographers are there to get the shot, not get shot. Doing something that silly, trying to stop someone with a loaded weapon when you only have a camera, usually ends up in one person walking away and the other staying. Guess who would be staying?
Regarding Q1, the AP has admitted that it was tipped off to a “demonstration” that was to occur at that location, so your comment that we’re being silly to wonder about it is, well, silly.
Am I missing something? Other than the fact that it was obvious and I believe since admitted that the photographer was tipped off, why are all the winning pictures negative ones in Iraq?
Who knew that cameras only existed in Iraq?
NOT ONE TSUNAMI pic? An actually photo taken during the event and we can be rest assured they were not warned about the Tsunami.
>Regarding Q1, the AP has admitted that it was tipped off to a “demonstration
No it has not. Go read it again. overreaction.
Unfortunately, there is proof that photographer and cameramen are working with the insurgents and terrorists.
In addition to the Al Jazeera cameraman who filmed a hostage prior to him escaping before his execution in Fallujah, there is this video confession of a photographer filmed by the Iraqi police:
http://www.memritv.org/Transcript.asp?P1=625
Paul: Thanks for the response:
>>AP has admitted that the photographer was tipped
>That’s not exactly what the AP said. It was a “source” not the AP. Further he said “likely” tipped to a “demonstration” not a murder, not defiantly tipped to a murder… Overreaction.
On the source: Duly noted, although Salon
(who would be unlikely to make this up) said
it was an AP insider. However, I contend that
the word “demonstration” has a well-understood
meaning in the Mideast, and it does not mean
marching around with silly paper-mache figures. It’s a bit like the mobster at trial claiming that, when he told the mark to “come down to the docks at eight, there’s gonna be some action”, he meant a friendly game of cribbage.
>>As I understand it, the murders happened at a polling site on the day of the Iraqi elections
>NOPE! The pic was taken a month before the election. 2 and 2 don’t go together in this paragraph….
I stand corrected.
>>Further: Powerline has a later statement where the AP pretty much admits that it uses people known to the terrorists as photographers. The phrase “family and tribal relations give them access” pretty much sums it up.
>Not really… Kurds can work in the Kurdish areas when a Sunni can not… This is not admitting to aiding terrorism, it is an admission of demographic realities.
I follow the Kurd/Sunni reasoning, but the AP’s statement appears to go farther than that. To me, it’s equivalent of saying that a photog from Dallas can’t work in Houston. Who’d know the difference? Apparently, according to the AP’s statement, these people do.
>>And the fact that the AP refuses to identify this Pulitzer Prize-winning photographer — why would they do that? Because, after the NBC/Kevin Sites fiasco, they are afraid that bloggers will research the photographer’s backgound and uncover his/her connections?
>Sources and methods. Assuming the bad guys didn’t want their picture taken –which grows more likely as a system of justice is installed– he is at risk.
Hmm. I’m still leaning towards the contention that if the bad guys didn’t want their picture taken, they would have blown him away on the spot. The fact that he did it and lived to publish it is evidence (admittedly circumstantial) of a connection between the two.
>And on your last point political agenda might have come into play but the fact it was (astonishingly) apparently one of the “newsests” pics probably held sway.
Maybe, although if you look at the awards the Pulitzer committee has bestowed over the last few years, the record is not encouraging. And yes, some people are over-reacting. However, the point they are trying to make is: The identity or motivation of the photog aside, the AP didn’t have to publish this photo. Consider this: we’ve all heard about the incident last week in some Iraqi city where terrorists came storming into a market area, but the citizens took up arms and fought back and defeated them. Where are the news photos and videos of that? Do you mean to tell me that there wasn’t a single person with a camera present when that happened? Or was it that the news wires chose not to publish those photos because it would harm their pre-conceived notions? I’ve tried some Googling for photos of Iraqis fighting back against terrorists, and all I have come up with is Abu Grahib photos. I’ve seen this point made this week: why are Americans getting so hostile to the mainstream media? It’s because the MSM is willingly, happily, acting as propogandists for the enemy. It’s systematic and anyone who dares to question it is told that they are “overreacting”.
Dave don’t get me wrong— I’m not saying that the AP is a paragon of virtue or even unbiased.
What I am saying is that if we are going to accuse them of misdeeds, lets use air-tight examples..
This ain’t one of them.
Looked at objectively, this example is no more “suspicious” than hundreds of others. And frankly it makes us look like we are stretching using this example.
“We” have enough examples to be outraged about. Using this one makes us look silly.
*** holds nose ***
I agree with Paul.
*** runs from comment thread, gasping for breath. ***
lol
Looks like the Commissar’s objectivity is slowly evolving.
And he’s even funny.
I’m betting it’s an impostor.
McGehee — so why would you run up to a group of terrorists with guns in their hands when you were armed with a camera — and not feel threatened?
In reply, I’ll quote from Paul’s original post:
Clearly it was both taken with a longish lens and cropped dramatically. (look at the grain) Admittedly my eyes see what most people don’t in a photo but if I had to take a wild guess, I would guess the photographer could be 100 years away or more easily. (trust me I shot football for years)
I’m betting it’s an impostor.
Can’t believe you waited two hours to say something snarky. Musta hurt. :>)
There are several hundred (thousands?) photographers running thru a war zone for a year and you are surprised one of them caught an act of war on film? These guys spend 24 hours a day, camera in hand, looking for a picture like this… Are we surprise one of them got such a picture of marginal (technical) quality?
First: Murder of election workers in the streets is not an act of war.
Your answered your own second question – yes, a pro photographer would have done much better. More likely this was a picture taken by one of the group that performed the execution. The ‘tiped photographer’ story is all the more implausable for the low quality of the shots.
Truth is there weren’t hundreds or thousands of photogs running around all over Baghdad, for just this reason. Your description is far from reality on that point.
There’s something waddling and quacking here, but you’re right, it might not be a duck. And yes, nothing can be proven about these photos. In the same sense that the National Guard memos can’t be proven, that nothing can be proven about ABC/WaPo’s latest memos, can’t prove Sandy Berger intentionally stole documents, etc etc.
The question I want to ask (and would go a long way to settling this matter) is “Where is the rest of the photo’s?” Even as a wannabe photographer I know that with that type of action shot you pretty much hold the button down and burn your roll of flim in the hopes that you get one that comes out and wins you the Pulitzer.
Even Eddie Adams’s famos photo was just one of a series, he simply (or they simply) selected the one that had the most impact.
I also agree, it looks like it was shot with a long lens (400mm or so) with a pretty fast film (lots of grain) and then further “blown up”. Without the original, its hard to say if it was cropped after or not, and if it was, that would violate (to me) the spirit of the Pulitzer because the photo is being edited.
The emperor wears no clothes.
You can see it is not a very bright day.
The cars in the traffic jam are not compressed in perspective.
The depth of field is rather deep (you can see things in the far distance relatively well).
This all indicates it was NOT a long lens.
I say its most likely about 70mm (as opposed to normal 50 or 55mm)
I’m with Ken — doesn’t look like a long lense to me either. Which means the photographer probably feels pretty secure because of those “family and tribal relations” that give him “access.” In other words, these are probably guys from the photographer’s hood. And it’s also a reasonable conjecture that he isn’t worried because he knows the terrorists want to publicize their brutal deed in order to intimidate election workers and make the pending election a failure, thereby discrediting the Coalition’s mission.
But, Paul’s point is still valid — we can only speculate at this point and so shouldn’t be too eager to jump to conclusions.
Kinda like Paul thinks we don’t really know if the Oozers or Thumpers are right. I’m starting to see a pattern . . .
>I’m starting to see a pattern . . .
ssshhhh Michael
Ken a 70mm lens at 5.6 with a subject only 33 yards away gives you an infinite depth of field with a circle of confusion at .03mm
In other words, I don’t think so.
Looks like it’s you and me against the world, Paul.
Of course, the msm has never, never, NEVER, canoodled with terrorists before. So, I don’t know why anyone would be suspicious.
I don’t want to look at photos where the photojournalist is in bed or even just being used by terrorists. I don’t want my newspaper to print those photos. I want some guaranteed that someone is not playing footsie with them. Now, the AP says they can’t release the name of the photographer for safety reasons. Okay, so I can’t check him/or out. And, I sure as hell don’t trust the msm. So, don’t publish the photo. I don’t want to see it. It’s not that interesting anyway. And certainly not Pulitzer material in my opinion.
I can’t see what people are getting all worked up about with this. Conspiracy theories can be fun, but they can also turn silly in a hurry.
Sure, the Pulitzers have been highjacked by the leftist elite. Just like the Nobel. And Cannes, and the Academy Awards, and a whole bunch of other basically meaningless crap.
It’s a charade, and most honest and thinking people have realized this for some time. Big fricken deal.
I would guess the photographer could be 100 years away or more easily. (trust me I shot football for years)
I got a quibble with this. I can believe “yards”, but not “years”.
Yes, it looks like fast film. blown up and a long lens to me. But, I’ve only been a photographer for 40+ years.
Pretty crappy shot if you ask me.
No Jim— It was years– just “fast” film.
lol
Heck, I’ll leave the typo.
P
Very often, if photogs are “tipped” that something is going to happen at a certain place at a certain time, like a “demonstration”, they will frequently go out beforehand, scope out sights and angles, and front-focus their chosen sites with different rigs – often you will see photogs with two or three different rigs – especially stringers. They have to bang and bang and bang to get something salable to the press.
IMHO, that is what occurred here. This was a combination of a “tip” (be here to see a ‘demonstration’) with a right time/wrong place for the election workers, who were quite obviously previously scouted by the murderers.
This shot was not in focus or lit quite properly, so I think it was taken with a motorized rig from a distance and then cropped, but not much. IIRC, this is one of a series of shots of this incident; this one just happened to land the Pukelitzer.
Absent the true film stock, no one can know for sure. All the scuttlebutt about it is turning this set of shots into the modern-day Zapruder film, tho.
Why all the pontification? It is obvious that this picture shouldn’t have won any prize.
It tells no story without the addition of a thousand words. As a matter of fact, the scene isn’t much different than a traffic accident I witnessed in Cairo some years ago: Confusion, people running, praying, laying in the street and a policeman with a gun ordering the street cleared.
Prize winning photos should, without words, tell a story, raise a point, evoke an emotion… This one just begs a question: What’s going on?
What I am saying is that if we are going to accuse them of misdeeds, lets use air-tight examples..
This ain’t one of them.
Looked at objectively, this example is no more “suspicious” than hundreds of others. And frankly it makes us look like we are stretching using this example.
Amen Paul. We don’t need to be a bunch of wing-nuts like the DU, going on about any seemingly plausible theory without any proof.
There are better copies of the photo. The depth of field is too great for a long lense. The other photo shows the terrorists faces better and they were unconcerned about the photographer, who could have easily been armed.
What we need is for the photographer to step forward and explain, as well as the negative, and any other shots they took of the killing.
It surely isn’t original to take a photo of some terrorist executing a couple of helpless victims to try and make a political statement. The AP aided them in doing so and should be ashamed of it.
We deserve better from the AP, and the Pulitizer group, well they just …
Paul,
Your circle of confusion at .03mm is because you don’t have the correct setting on your feeblebletzer adjustment.
Actually, I took out my trusty Mamiya/Sekor 1000TL and mounted the 75-205 zoom and looked down the street at all the cars. I could get the proper width of field and perspective at about 85mm. Any more telephoto, and you can’t get a wide enough view.
Indeed, why the fuss? Photographs mean different things to different people, and one can always imagine a political motive when conditioned by years of liberal bias. But in this case, the fact that the victims are DEMOCRATIC ELECTION WORKERS tells me a story that nobody else is seeing. I see democracy confronted by the fascist boot of Islamic terrorism. I see the promise of individual liberty, as exercised by the pen at an election booth. And I see that pen resisted by the sword. We know who is mightier in the end. Yes it is a poor photo, but the subject matter is eminently worthy to my senses.
I completely agree that the upset about this photo is nearly preposterous (not the upset itself but why).
If we were to apply this same standard of upset to all photo journalism, there’d be a dismissal of most, if not all, wartime photos, even, let’s see…videos of cops and robberies as they occur, or just after…wrecks in process…I can think of dozens of very important photos that would be dismissed if we were to seriously include this line of upset that’s been attempted about this AP photo.
It’s a long-lense shot, obviously without time to compose a frame, and that alone seems to indicate that the photographer was caught unawares and responded…because…he…is…a…photographer. They do that, grab their cameras and fire away. That’s their impulsive response to sudden and partiuclarly sudden terrible incidents: take a photo of it.
The counter argument about this photo is preposterous.
I completely agree with Paul on this one. People that are saying that the photog must have been aligned with terrorists to get this photo…well…they obviously havent looked at alot of work by war photographers. They go to those places specifically to get images like this one.
I’m not at all suprised that this photographer caught this event. There are people quibbing about the exposure and composition, which arent perfect, but then thats a pretty good indication that the photo could have been shot in a rush.
Other people have brought up the idea that the photographer must have been complicit in the act since he was taking photos. The Eddie Adams photo is a good example…Adams raised his camera shot just as the gun went off, killing the Viet Cong officer. It wasnt what Adams expected; he just happened to get it.
War photographers are insane and brave at the same time. Check out the D-Day photos of Robert Capa…the guy was shooting pictures in the middle of that madness. Crazy.
Julie wrote:
I don’t want to look at photos where the photojournalist is in bed or even just being used by terrorists. I don’t want my newspaper to print those photos.
I totally understand her point. Like those videos of the beheadings that are staged and then broadcast all over the world. I dont want to see any of that stuff, but sometimes its hard to ignore. I dont like it either; but it is out there. It’s part of whats happening. People who stage crap like that incriminate themselves, and turn others against them, IMO.
I cant say that I like seeing this photo…its horrible, and I’m talking about the event that its showing (not the technical aspects of the photo). Those are election workers who are being murdered in public, and that is a deptiction of the kinds of things that have happened in Iraq. Not fun to look at, but photos like this give us an indication of what has gone on there. It’s hard for me to comprehend since Ive had democracy handed to me here in the US, but in some places things arent so easy. It’s important that we see whats going on, whether positive or negative.
Your circle of confusion at .03mm is because you don’t have the correct setting on your feeblebletzer adjustment.
Ken:
You can’t expect someone photographing a murder to get that adjustment exactly right. As you know, it can be tricky depending of lighting conditions, film speed, shutter speed, etc. I consider myself a seasoned photographer, and yet I am frequently a few degrees off.
Ken:
I could get the proper width of field and perspective at about 85mm. Any more telephoto, and you can’t get a wide enough view.
Paul was talking about depth of field, not “width of field”. Depth of field is how much appears to be in focus in a photo from foreground to background. Depth of field is affected by aperture, and by subject distance.
What you are talking about is the angle of view of certain focal lengths, which is entirely different.
Circle of confusion:
Disc of light in the image where a point on the subject is not perfectly brought into focus. The eye cannot distinguish between a very small circle of confusion and a true point.
-thats a fancy way of talking about what appears to be in or out of focus. The smaller the circle of confusion, the more appears to be in focus. Smaller apertures (i.e. f16, f22) give smaller circles of confusion, greater apparent depth of field…to a point.
Michael
He didn’t know what a circle of confusion was.. He made the term up. Suffice it to say it was not a 70mm lens. Nor was it a 400 as someone else guessed.
Just some back of the napkin math and a little common sense says it was between 200 and 300mm.
Considering this was a stringer from Iraq (a poor country) and not a professional, he probably had a cheapish zoom lens. From looking at the pic, he probably either had a 28-200 or something that went to 300.
Considering 28-200’s are dime a dozen, he probably was on the long end of one of them…. By best math guess tells me it was a 250 but I sorta doubt he had a 250 prime lens. If I had to pace a wager, I’d guess a 200 zoom. — but I might drop a chip or two on a 300 zoom just to be safe.
I read about publicity stunts and how, way back when, they got to be way out of control. Someone selling something would set up a stunt and call the press and get free advertising out of it. Eventually the press decided that they didn’t like being used and refused to cover the stunts. Without press coverage the stunts were useless.
A tip that something is going to happen, if it’s a grocery store opening or anti-war ralley or cancer walk-a-thon, is given when the organizers expect press coverage to help their cause.
Of *course* the photographer was not afraid of the shooters. They wanted their picture taken. They wanted a message sent to intimidate Iraqi citizens working for democracy.
So was the photographer an accomplice? Pretty much, yeah. So was the AP, after the fact. Did they have prior knowledge? Maybe not, but this wasn’t the only situation like this, was it? And then, of *course* the news article read, “Cowardly insugents murder election workers, proving themselves enemies of the Iraqi people.”
Sure it did.
He made the term up.
Are you telling me that all the time I have spent adjusting my feeblebletzer was wasted?
Of *course* the photographer was not afraid of the shooters.
really? how do you know that? it could be the case that the photographer was in on the whole thing, but also there is the possibility that he/she was there at this demonstration and captured this murder…because thats what photographers do. i dont know what the case is, so if you have more info please share it.
Michael,
Are you telling me that all the time I have spent adjusting my feeblebletzer was wasted?
Canon just came out with a digital feeblebletzer, which never has to be adjusted, of course. Geez man get with it.
Geez man get with it.
areaman:
I resent your implication that a seasoned photographer such as myself is not “with it.”
First of all, Canon models that have the digital feeblebletzer are extremely expensive toys. I expect prices to fall drasically in the next couple of years as more companies offer this technology. You’re a chump if you have already bought one.
Secondly, if you are really serious about photography, like me, you have to think twice before you buy this gadget. Certainly the digital feeblebletzer is convenient, but you lose a great deal of creative control over your composition. Even after the price falls, I think I am going to suffer a little inconvenience and stick with an analog feeblebletzer.