As a followup to my prior piece:
12 cans of Dinty Moore Beef Stew (540 calories/can): $23.88
10 gallons store-brand springwater: $5.50
5 cheap Dollar Store flashlights: $5.00
5 4-packs of batteries for flashlights: $5.00
Cheap AM/FM Radio from Dollar Store: $5.00
5 4-packs of batteries for radio from Dollar Store: $5.00
Manual can opener from Dollar Store: $1.00
All prices from Hannaford Markets and Family Dollar.
Total expenditure for survival kit: $50.38
Surviving disaster despite best advice of Kos, Atrios, and the rest: Priceless


Ashish,
I am a California resident as well. At a minimum you should have a flashlight and at least some water in your desk at work. Have emergency kits in your car, that way they are always with you, as well as at home. And figure out a family plan for where to meet in case of an emergency when people can’t get home, and a couple of points to contact (at least one of which is not in the same area) such as non-local relatives or friends. That way everyone can leave a message on their condition/location in case you can’t be reached at home/work due to communications problems.
You heartless bastard! How could you doom the entire city of New Orleans to death over $50?! How are these poor people supposed to find an extra $50, what with the prices of malt liquor and menthol cigarettes rising every year! Shame on you, you racist jerk!
Here’s a nice little one that comes in it’s own little bag for $55.
http://beprepared.com/product.asp?pn=K7%20A400
Quote from cirby: “The cheap food version of the list above:
10 pounds rice: $5
5 pounds beans: $5″
Actually these would make poor survival foods. They take way to much water and fuel to prepare adequately. Unless, you like raw rice and dried beans. Canned soups would be best since they have a long shelf life and are already cooked.
Ashish: I heard a good one for Earthquakes was to put a few items in a heavy plastic ziplock bag and duct tape it to the bottom of each bed in your house. You can also keep one under your car seat and at work.
– Cheap Flip Flops (it sucks to roll out of bed naked and find broken glass across every floor in the whole house)
– Small wrecking bar (aka crowbar, 8 inch is fine)
– Leather gloves
– Flashlight (the little “sqeezy” kind work fine)
– Whistle or other loud noise maker
– small clean cloth towel (old flanel shirt works if your up north)
– small bit of Duct tape (I like Gaffers tape better, it doesn’t have to be a whole roll)
– small pocket knive
and least importent:
– powerbar and a 20oz bottle of water (people go a long time without food or water. but if you are trapped 20oz of water is better then none)
This isn’t for long term but just to help out during the first few hours.
12 Cans of Dinty Moore Beef Stew? You might need to include a gas mask in that survival kit.
Hey, I LIKE Dinty Moore stew. With a little Lee & Perrins Worchestershire sauce in it.
Good post. Better comments.
Instead of $24 bucks for the Dinty, take advantage
of the numerous sales of store-brand can veggies.
Green beans, whole kernel corn, sweet peas, and
the like. Those “off brand” or store brand labels
will often sale out at 4/$1.00. Four dozen cans
come in at $12.00… and although they’re much
better when heated, the fact is that they
are fully cooked when they are canned, so they
can be safely consumed right from the container.
Forget about rices or pastas or dried
goods (needs water and cooking), or about breads
or crackers (relatively short shelf-lifes).
It may not be ‘balanced’ nutrition; but it will
get you through the week or so you need to
survive.
Even if one argues that “poor” people can’t spare
the $50, don’t tell me they can’t spare $5.00 for
water (find and save 2-liter soda bottles… free)
and food (16 cans @ 25 cents = $4) and a can
opener (99 cents). The flashlight and radio and
batteries are nice to have, but just the simple
$5 investment and a few minutes to set aside the
water bottles and can foods would have been a
major aid for those who found themselves waiting
for days down in NO.
FYI to everyone,
If you are in any survival situation and you don’t have plenty of water, you are better off not eating anything. The body uses a lot of water to process food, and dehydration is virtually always a bigger danger than starvation. Some foods take more water to be processed than others (i.e. anything with caffeine in it, such as chocolate) With limited water, there is also no benefit in “rationing” water after about the first 12 hours. You are better off drinking normally and delaying dehydration, than saving the water.
Finds from my surivial trip through the 99-cent store:
A 10-pack of single-edge razor blades.
A pack of six plastic utility knives.
Pork and beans, 2 cans for 99. The excess gas from Can One can be used to heat Can Two.
Plastic cutlery. 50 forks.
Rubbing alcohol, 2 pints for 99. Great for soapless cleanup.
Condensed milk.
Bobo-brand cola, 2 for 99. Caffeine boost!
Good advice on prepareness. Have been through some situations and ramen and canned stew are life savers. I lean toward chow that doesn’t require extra water since I live in the SW. Drought is tough to deal with and water heavy to carry. Consider food for pets you might have. Good dog/cat can be a lifesaver (kills vermin, guards) and is edible if things go really, really bad. Don’t forget a personal evacuation plan of where to go and how to get there if you home is unlivable and shelters are not an option. Everyone knowing where the rally point is is important espceilly if you have mobile teenagers.
Duct tape, sanitary napkins/tampons etc make great 1st aid, add some neosporin and you have it made!
With regards to heating food, if you do not manage to pack a small grill as noted in other posts, and your vehicle is not under water, you can heat food in containers on the carberator of the car. We used to do that with MREs during winter military exercises in Europe.
“10 pounds rice: $5
5 pounds beans: $5″
Actually these would make poor survival foods. They take way to much water and fuel to prepare adequately. Unless, you like raw rice and dried beans. Canned soups would be best since they have a long shelf life and are already cooked.
“
Actually, beans and rice are good survival foods, but you do have to have a stove, and you will need extra cooking water. Just budget for the extra water and fuel for your camp stove. Water is cheap, as in approaching free. And stove fuel isn’t expensive, either.
Canned soups are not bad. Not as many calories as the canned stew, but still not a bad choice. You’ll still want a stove to heat it with.
It is too bad I didn’t stock up on C Rations before they became rarer than hen’s teeth. Those were ideal, even without the heat tabs — the individual boxes when burned provided just enough heat to warm them up, we used to do that when I was in the Army back in the ’70s.
Actually, canned tuna or sardines and saltine crackers make for good emergency rations, too. They are cheap, and they don’t require heating. The salt from the crackers is good in the heat, too. Peanut butter is good alongside of the crackers, too. Unopened jars of peanut butter have a long shelf life, as does unopened saltines, and canned fish lasts indefinitely.
Just wanted to add one more thing: All the emergency supplies in the world wouldn’t have helped those people who were flooded out. So please add to your emergency kit the following:
1. Have a place to go. In our mobile society, even the poorest people have out-of-town friends or kin. Have somebody you can call to come get you if you have no car.
2. Have the mental attitude of thinking ahead. That costs nothing.
3. Have the mental attitude of not trusting the government to solve your problems. That also costs nothing, and as I said above, this is (I think) the most pernicious thing, and the thing that killed the most people in the hurricane’s path.
4. If you do decide that you’re going to trust the government, know exactly what it is that you’re trusting the government to do.
Phone books have emergency instructions in them with contact numbers, all kinds of assistance lines, and lists of where to go to get help. Most poor people in this country are not too poor to have phones — in fact, there are “LifeLine” programs that provide phone service to poor people, and free phone books are everywhere.
Please don’t get me wrong — I’m not “blaming the victims”. I hope that I’m teaching people that they don’t have to be powerless.
And there was no excuse not to use the New Orleans school buses and transit buses to get people out. None at all. None. Bravo to that kid who “stole” the bus and got 100 people out!
(quoting myself)
Have the mental attitude of not trusting the government to solve your problems. That [the attitude] also costs nothing, and as I said above, this [trusting the government in that way] is (I think) the most pernicious thing, and the thing that killed the most people in the hurricane’s path. …”
Sorry I was a little inarticulate there… posting in a hurry. Hope the italics clarify.
Great blog here, with lots of good advice. May we all learn well.
There are also now three types of flashlights to consider, they cost more but…
1. LED flashlights. Put out a lot of light, and the batteries last a long time.
2. Shake lights. Shake them, it charges a capacitor; doesn’t run too long on a charge, but you only have to shake again.
3. Crank lights. Instead of shaking, you turn a crank and it charges the capacitor.
Ashish said:
“…my current plan is to stock emergency supplies at my and my wife’s work place, at home and in our car. Is that an overkill? “
I think it’s a very wise idea. You never know where you’ll be, and if there’s extra stuff, you’re in a position to help others who weren’t prepared. In fact, I think I’ll take your suggestion and do the same thing.
A previous thread mentioned “some waterproof matches or a butane lighter”
If you’re preparing for cold weather survival, opt for matches. Butane liquifies at around -33F. Lighters don’t work without gas to burn.
Learned that the hard way on a winter survival campout as a scout. Trust me, you don’t want to have to put that cold lighter in your pants or under your armpit to warm it up.
Our ‘live thru CA falling into the sea’ kit at home has both.
Also Raman noodles, dried pasta, rice and beans can all be eaten dry. If you’re hungry enough sucking on some dry beans to soften them up enough to chew starts sounding pretty good. All in all though I recommend food with some moisture content, ie soup.
The main thing you need is potable water. With water to drink, food becomes a luxury you can live without for several days.
According to the Air Force Captain who taught me survival as a scout there are only two hard fast rules to survival that pertain to any emergency situation.
1. If you panic – you are dead.
2. If you give up hope, or give up trying – you are dead.
Everything else will vary depending on your current situation.
Pertaining to eating pets: Yes, if it got that bad you have a point. But before then, well, there’s no shortage of rabbits and squirrels around here — none at all. I’ve got a .22 (handgun, 6″ barrel) and an ample supply of ammo for it, and that would be just the ticket for a little subsistence hunting — also good for small varmits, some of which are tasty. And I’ve got heavier stuff for the bigger varmits, both of the 4 legged and 2 legged variety if needed. As Mary points out, you need the attitude of not trusting the government to solve your problems, and self defense is one of those problems.
I’ve always carried emergency supplies in my vehicle, thought everybody did. Water, flashlights, matches etc. Include a steel bowl for water, can use to boil/cook or water dogs. Yes, I travel with dogs constantly.
A good blanket and tarp are on hand too. Always have a shovel and good rope as well as hat and gloves. Living in the SW means being prepared for extreme heat and extreme cold at different times. Always have a basic tool kit.
If you might need to walk somewhere and have the space you might consider a walking stick and pack/bag to put supplies in.
For cooking consider the Esbit Falcon or other folding stove that uses solid fuel (not sterno, to fumy and bulky). Realatively cheap, compact, waterproof and can use bits of wood as well. Heats water fast.
“If you’re preparing for cold weather survival, opt for matches. Butane liquifies at around -33F. Lighters don’t work without gas to burn.”
I didn’t know that, but then again it never gets anywhere near that cold around here (Atlanta area). Unless I have to move up north (SHUDDER!) I’m not concerned about that.
“The main thing you need is potable water. With water to drink, food becomes a luxury you can live without for several days.”
In know that a lot of people don’t realize this, but it is the truth. With adequate potable water, you can last for over a week with nothing to eat, assuming you have “average” body fat to start with.
Hm…
How many of those people who “can’t rub two nickels together” still manage to find the cash to SMOKE a pack a day?
Good comments & suggestions all (OK, not Dylan or GoMommyGo). I keep a “bugout bag” with a change of clothes, toiletries, some bottled water, powerbars, a small first aid kit, a rain poncho, a small roll of duct tape, radio & batteries, and a leatherman tool. I’ve also got a two-week supply of canned foods, bottled water (and extra empty bottles), bleach, sterno, and a small battery-powered TV.
Remember, just because you’re dirt poor and can’t afford $50 doesn’t mean you can’t stock up. Try buying a couple of extra cans of Spagettios (or similar canned crap) whenever you go grocery shopping. It sucks, but I practically *lived* off Chef Boyardee canned food when I was in college. It’s cheap. So, so cheap. You can even get generic store-brand versions of most products.
Oh, and if anyone’s interested, I found a great web site showing how to make a dirt-cheap alcohol stove. Or you could just buy one, I suppose, if you’re not Morgan Spurlock.
“If you’re preparing for cold weather survival, opt for matches. Butane liquifies at around -33F. Lighters don’t work without gas to burn.”
Opps, My bad. That should be -1C or about 30F.
Sorry
You can get hand-crank cellphone chargers for $10, and hand-crank radio/flashlight/general appliance chargers for $40 or less. These are key because batteries that sit in your drawer for years will go dead right about a month before you need them. Worse, they might explode and leak battery acid all over your emergency supplies.
Another useful tip: a lot of people have solar lights in their yards. In an emergency these can be plucked from the ground and used as portable candles without being fire hazards.
Evil Otto, very cool alcohol-stove link!
That brings to mind something else that could usefully go into an emergency stash: Potable alcohol, such as vodka or EverClear. Useful as:
– Emergency disinfectant
– Emergency anesthetic (e.g. for setting a broken bone)
– Stove fuel (?)
– “Trade goods”
I wouldn’t flash it around, though, as it might attract bad guys if word gets out that you have an alcohol stash. :-/
Sounds like this very “simple” concept of a survival kit and what should be in it isn’t so obvious, even to the highly educated and well-fed with internet access. Or are you blogging from the public library?
Of course it’s wise to make preparations for a disaster. It’s wise for the individual, but it’s the REASON for FEMA’s existance, or so we thought.
If FEMA’s policy is every man, woman, child, infirmed, elderly person for himself, then please spend FEMA’s tax money on said survival kits and send them to every man, woman, child, etc.
They were paid to do a job. They failed. The individuals who failed to prepare — or DID prepare but were unlucky, or were too young or old to prepare, paid a very high price.
What price will be paid by those who took the money, but failed to do their jobs?
Is their a limit to the number of medals of freedom Bush is allowed to award?
One word: COSTCO. Most people leave there looking like they’re prepping for nuclear winter anyway…
Here are a few things in my kit that haven’t already been mentioned. I’m in earthquake country, and we rotate everything out every 6 months.
House & Evacuation Kit:
1. Good flashlights (don’t recommend skimping on these…you get what you pay for at $1 store)
2. Bulk boxes of individually wrapped peanut butter crackers, cookies, granola bars, nuts, etc. (from Costco).
3. Two cases of water, two cases of Vitamin Water (to offset the bad food we’re going to eat).
4. Stockpile batteries (large paks from Costco)
5. Fifth of Southern Comfort (for my nerves)
6. Fifth of Chivas (for his nerves)
7. Copies of all financial information in a Ziploc
8. CASH in small denominations in a Ziploc
9. Dog food
10. Extra contact lenses
11. Hand sanitizer
If there’s time to load up car:
1. TWO GIANT rubbermaid bins in garage are packed with our camp kitchen and camping gear. Ready-to-go.
In my car right now:
1. Backpack with two sets of clothes, hiking boots
2. Three days of food (dog too) & water, flashlight, blanket
3. Radio and two-way radio
Things I’m considering adding to my kit:
1. Guns
2. Ammo
FEMA doesn’t exist to “prepare for” disaster (in the sense of “take the place of what individuals should do for themselves to prepare for a disaster”) — it exists to clean up after a disaster.
I can’t think of a single disaster we’ve had in this country that FEMA could have prevented. And I can’t think of any way that FEMA could have done anything pro-active before the hurricane damage happened, certainly not without the state governor and the mayor calling them in.
As for “highly educated”, how much education does it take to look in the front of your phone book? As I said in my previous posting, the vast majority of people,even poor people, have access to a phone book.
I’m looking in the front of my phone book right now, and I see a “Free Info On Call” listing on all kinds of topics: news, health, women’s health, pediatric emergencies, phone numbers for the Red Cross, the county Victim Assistance Center, and a whole bunch of service organizaitons, both government and private.
I also see two pages entitled “Emergency Preparedness”, with a list of basic emergency supplies to keep on hand, what to do in case of an earthquake, how much bleach to use to disinfect water, and how to evacuate in case of a flash flood. (We don’t usually get hurricanes in southern California, but we do get flash floods.)
It’s all there, right in the phone book. No expensive Internet access needed. The information is free, and it’s in every public place and pretty much every home in America. All a person has to do is think ahead — and that is something anyone can do.
Jato said: “I’m going to pose a simple question. What government in this world could have erected a sea wall or some barrier that could have prevented the storm surge from hitting an area from the Florida Panhandle to Westside of New Orleans in 5 days? Answer: None!”
Er, no.
1/3 of the Netherlands is below sea level; much of that land is reclaimed from the sea. After a big flood in the 1950s that killed thousands, they put into effect a master plan to protect themselves from a once-in-10000-year fllod. Their levees are twice as high as New Orleans were, thye have multiple redundancy, the ability to divert water to unpopulated areas, and flood barriers that can be put across rivers when the water is high.
They’ve been doing this for centuries (their water councils predate the Dutch state) and are very good at it, because they have to be.
“Is their a limit to the number of medals of freedom Bush is allowed to award?”
He hasn’t awarded any yet that I know of, certainly not with regard to Katrina, and I don’t see why he would — nobody was exactly covered in glory. (Though personally, I would support giving the “bus kid” the Medal of Freedom in an instant!)
…nobody in authority was exactly covered in glory, I mean… Just wanted to clarify that.
Bravo to all the military and civilian rescue workers, and to all the organizers of relief efforts around the country and the world! (I’m even in charity with France at the moment — sending a team of Red Cross workers was a nice gesture on their part.)
My families survival kit includes (in addition to food):
Two burner portable propane stove
Small propane tanks
Sleeping bags for whole family
Several large 5 gal water jugs
Waterproof matches
LED flashlights
Krill Lamps (last a WEEK on two AA batteries)
Bunch of batteries
Portable battery powered AM/FM radio
Cell phone
Family band walkie-talkies
Tents
Swiss army knives and multi-tool
Hammer and hand axe
Firewood & starter bricks
Incremental Cost – $0 (Cause I bought the stuff for camping)
not to be absolutely cynical, but an AR-15 and 3 30 round magazines gets you everything mentioned above, with no advance planning. You don’t even need morals (in fact, they would be a hinderance).
Seriously, without the means to protect your emergency kit, it is almost worthless past the first day if any sort of social disorder erupts. There are plenty of arguments about the best way to protect you and yours, but undisputedly the best way in N.O. would have been to evacuate to safety prior to the (well publicised in advance) disaster.
You can now get tear-open tuna-fish pouches at the supermarket for $1.60-$2 per 4 oz. pack. I’ve seen them at the 99 Cents Only chain also (obviously for 99 cents). No need for a can opener, they are light, easily storable and you don’t have to drain them (won’t smell as much as trash).
The crank-driven flashlights are a good idea; so are crank-driven radios. (Small, cheap LED flashlights are a good idea too).
If toilets don’t work, and if a person couldn’t go outside, I’ve been wondering if it would be good to have plastic bags to execrete in, since they can be sealed?
Quick note on flashlights; C batteries or smaller allows you to hold the flashlight in your mouth leaving both hands free (an old campers’ tip). D’s are too big.
Sounds like this very “simple” concept of a survival kit and what should be in it isn’t so obvious, even to the highly educated and well-fed with internet access. Or are you blogging from the public library?
What the hell are you talking about? Is there some disagreement about the basics? FOOD AND FRIKKIN’ WATER! Do you need an internet connection to figure that out? People here might have suggestions or disagreements about what else should go in, or how much, but everyone agrees about what’s most important.
This is just another attempt by you to shift responsibility away from the individual to the government. Governmental help in a disaster is appreciated, but personally I don’t assume it’s going to be there for me, and I plan accordingly. Last year it paid off; I went through *three* hurricanes.
Of course it’s wise to make preparations for a disaster. It’s wise for the individual, but it’s the REASON for FEMA’s existance, or so we thought.
FEMA is a federal bureaucracy; with all that that implies. It’s up to the individual to make sure they’re prepared, because waiting for the government to step in and save your ass is foolish. One need only look at New Orleans to see that.
If FEMA’s policy is every man, woman, child, infirmed, elderly person for himself, then please spend FEMA’s tax money on said survival kits and send them to every man, woman, child, etc.
So it’s the government’s responsibility to make sure that you can survive an emergency? Before, you were making excuses, saying that some people were too poor to be able to afford the $50 needed. Several people showed that it doesn’t even take that much, and that the supplies can be accumulated over time. I’ve been dirt poor, and I can assure you that human beings are capable of surviving weeks on generic canned food. Go to Wal-Mart when they have a sale and you can pick up cans of store brand spaghettios 2/$1. Five bucks will give you enough to feed a small family for a day. Empty two-liters and a few drops of bleach will give you enough water for days.
They were paid to do a job. They failed. The individuals who failed to prepare — or DID prepare but were unlucky, or were too young or old to prepare, paid a very high price.
What a load of crap. FEMA doesn’t come in to play until after a disaster, and in the case of Katrina the disaster was overwhelming. Do you have a clue about the scale of this? It’s not just New Orleans. A good chunk of several states have been leveled. The USA has never seen anything like this.
FEMA will assist, but IT. TAKES. TIME. If you aren’t capable of putting a little bit of food and water aside to survive until then, I’m sorry, but I don’t have a hell of a lot of pity for you.
What price will be paid by those who took the money, but failed to do their jobs?
What price will be paid by people who didn’t make the slightest effort to plan ahead, who never assumed that anything could happen to them?
Is their a limit to the number of medals of freedom Bush is allowed to award?
Umm… OK. Whatever.
Water, food, tools, and flashlights are the basics, of course, but toilet paper would be highly appreciated by the women in my household. If the sewer system won’t accept donations a non-toilet place to relieve yourself would be appreciated, too. This reminds me of a product named the “Bumper Dumper.” It is a toilet seat which attaches to a vehicle’s trailer hitch, thus providing a place to sit, but no privacy. You need something to catch the mess. At home I would probably just remove a toilet seat and find a way to keep it on a five-gallon bucket–probably with duct tape. I have a few hundred Wal-Mart bags in the garage headed to the recyling bin. I may keep a few of them around now.
Evil Otto, you missed GoMommyGo’s point – she considers herself highly educated and yet she’s a complete moron on this subject. So obviously all those poor folk couldn’t possibly add one and one and get the same answer twice.
BTW, GoMommyGo? If the reason for FEMA’s existence is to make sure every individual is cared for in case of a disaster, what did we do before it’s creation in 1979? And I for one have no problem with FEMA being abolished, return the money to the states. Heck, my SEMA can get a huge funding boost and then it’s every state for themselves like the old days.
But I really like this part:
They were paid to do a job. They failed. The individuals who failed to prepare — or DID prepare but were unlucky, or were too young or old to prepare, paid a very high price.
Lady, you don’t even know what their friggin’ job is. I’ve actually worked in disaster relief with my atate EMA and jointly a few times with FEMA – get a clue, then talk to me about this. As it is your ignorance actually pains me.
Oh, and as far as I know – no limit to the number of medals Bush is allowed to award, but don’t count on getting one anytime soon.
TTFN
One Lb. coffee can will hold a roll of TP
and keep it dry. You can use the can as a cooking vessel or water boiler. If heat becomes vital,
a cheap pint of rubbing alcohol poured into
the can with TP inside will soak the TP and can be lit to provide an alcohol burner /heater.
A 5 gallon bucket with TWO lids and a roll of
small size trash bags can provide a good toilet facility- and hold TP, Pads a plastic tarp and duct tape inside while in storage. Buckets are often free at donut shops/cafes, etc.
Cut a hole in the second lid to make the seat, line bucket with a trash bag, snap seat lid down
to hold in place. Use tarp/ duct tape to provide a privacy curtain if possible. Remove and tie bags
and replace as needed. Use solid lid to cover for
odor and sanitary control.
Oatmeal is another bulk food that cooks with a little boiling water, can be eaten dry.
Large 55 gallon trash bags are another usefull item. Can be cut at bottom to provide a head hole, making a wind & water proof poncho. They are
also useable to seal food and clothes in a water proof carry bundle (using duct tape to seal and reinforce) if you need to carry stuff out.
Duct tape can also seal wounds to prevent infection if you have no better bandage and may have to enter polluted water.
Most all of these are “salvage ” items you can gather one or two at a time at almost no cost.
If I lived in NOLA, I’d have this set aside and stored in a cheap canoe or boat. What kind of city has to pump its sewage uphill but doesn’t have generators and fuel in place for when the power goes out? In fact, why wouldn anybody want to live in such a place, especially when it is hurricane country. Most flood pass naturally, when the water runs off. Earthquakes quit shaking after a few minutes. Fires run out of fuel. But when you live in a sump, nothing goes away by itself.
I think a lot of the people who have sent aid, and volunteered to help would be perfectly justified to tell New Orleans that when this happens again, don’t call for help. In fact, next time, I won’t send a check until after I see whether the locals are doing all they can for themselves.
That’s cold, but the reason I feel that way is because those who have actually been there with help have received nothing but complaints and accusations. This whole mess has a strong resemblence to the guy who killed his parents then asked for mercy because he was an orphan.
The rest of the nation has and will pour aid into this city, $60 billion and counting, and the response of the Democrats is ‘why wasn’t it there the day after the hurricane?’
Dylan
I’m skipping some of the comments, so maybe someone else has covered it..
but WTF is your problem?
I live in CA…you know, earthquake country? “Survival kits” are just a matter of course here and something that has been drilled into my brain all my life. It’s not like a huge deal, just a thoughtful “do ahead”… working flashlights, water, keeping the propane tank on the BBQ filled, keeping a well-stocked firstaid kit, knowing where to turn off the gas outside..having a food/water/firstaid kit in the trunk of the car.
Do you know at the beginning of each school year parents (in my school district) are required to make a kit for each of their children to be stored at school? (they get them back at the end of the school year)
We don’t get warnings of earthquakes so we know if the BIG ONE hits we could be stuck anywhere.
And we’ve always been told to be prepared to be on our own 3 to 5 days.
Jaysus on a Pony, too many people these days believe society should treat ’em as babies rather than expecting them to act like adults.
::Sounds like this very “simple” concept of a survival kit and what should be in it isn’t so obvious,::
In what way is food and water not simple? What varies are the details- some people will prefer (or find cheaper) spaghettios, some would prefer Dinty Moore, some like oats, instant potato flakes, and dehydrated carrots- that doesn’t make it complicated. That makes it flexible. The point is you buy what is available to you in your area inexpensively that your family will eat- it really isn’t helpful to have food you hate in the survival kit if you have kids. A kids appetite will already be deadened by the trauma of some disasters (variable by child and disaster, of course)- and they won’t eat much if they hate it. So of course what’s in my kit will vary from what’s in somebody else’s. Again, this is the beauty of it- it’s flexible, individual, and tailored *by* and for the family that puts it together, unlike a government bureaucratic one size must fit all ‘coz we’re too big to do it any differently approach.
::: even to the highly educated and well-fed with internet access. Or are you blogging from the public library?::
Quite often I have. Other times I’ve used a relatives computer. Currently our computer (which was a gift from a computer geeky friend) is part of our home business and homeschooling. By selling things via ebay and through email lists it pays for the internet connection and then some. We buy these things at yard sales for a quarter and we sell them for more online. I highly recommend this to others who need to bring in some extra cash. It opens up a nationwide market to us that was not available before. And I don’t have a college degree.
::Of course it’s wise to make preparations for a disaster. It’s wise for the individual, but it’s the REASON for FEMA’s existance, or so we thought.::
REally? Why did you think so? Can you point us to some official documents supporting the claim you appear to be making- that the REASON for FEMA’s existance is to make preparations for individuals for disaster?
::If FEMA’s policy is every man, woman, child, infirmed, elderly person for himself, then please spend FEMA’s tax money on said survival kits and send them to every man, woman, child, etc.::
Have you really not ever read FEMA’s own website and publications? FEMA’s policy has ALWAYS been that the first 72 hours, minimum, will be the responsibility of individuals, local and state officials in the disaster area. In case it slipped your attention- this is a HUGE country and FEMA is not God (neither is the government). It cannot be every where all the time. They have to have time to mobilize resources and shift them in the right direction- unlike the individual, local and state officials who will already be in the vicinity of their own local emergency.
::They were paid to do a job. They failed. The individuals who failed to prepare — or DID prepare but were unlucky, or were too young or old to prepare, paid a very high price.::
Quite often preparations go awry- they are washed away in a flood, or, as happened to us once, shattered on a Kansas highway and forgotten as family members are busy bleeding and in need of medical attention- and air lifting out to a better hospital. This is nobody’s fault, not even FEMA’s. Because some people cannot prepare is no reason most shouldn’t. Because sometimes your preparations will go up in smoke, or wash away in a flood, or get flattened in an accident is no reason to avoide preparing at all. But we both know that you cannot claim that every person who suffered dreadfully from this disaster had a disaster kit that just washed away.
Those too young, too old, too disabled did pay a price- but they suffered the cost of their local and state officials refusing to implement their own disaster plan- and they knew, they have always known, that FEMA has told them they won’t be there for 72 hours. You could know this too if you read their website.
::What price will be paid by those who took the money, but failed to do their jobs?::
I hope the mayor and the governor- and that is who you are describing, will never be elected to political office again. I hope they pay the price of being ashamed to hold a press conference or show their faces in public ever again. They _failed_ to do their job when they failed to follow their own plan AT ALL. FEMA has certainly bungled some things and been inept at others- but they did actually attempt to do their job. They did not leave several hundred buses under water, for instance, nor did they turn in their badges and walk away, nor did they loot businesses, nor did they send people to the convention center and not bother to tell anybody else about it and forget to provide them food and water. FEMA’s blunders are typical of Big Government (a good reason to despise BG). The mayor and governor are guilty of criminal negligence.
:::Is their a limit to the number of medals of freedom Bush is allowed to award?:::
I do hope you remember to include your ADD medication in your emergency kit.
All great ideas, GreyOne!
If anything Katrina has shown who will and will not survive.
Those who scoff at duct tape or having emergency kits. Those who never take reponsibility for themselves and their actions, the ones who always think of themselves as a “victim”. Those who think that “someone else” such as the local/state/fedarl government is responsible for their personal wellbeing are all ones who will end up being bloated, maggor riddem corpses.
Those who take responsibility for their own welfare. Those who know there may be a time in their lives where they have to survive without the “critter comforts”. Those who have a basic knowledge of first aid. Those who know how to do things for themselves are the ones who will survive.
It is simple natural selection, survival of the fittest.
I remember a passage in Stephen King’s book “The Stand” where (I forget the name of the character) one of the characters in the book is some college professor or professional student siad that before she would have looked down on Stu Redman as some dumb “redneck from Texas”. But after the disaster she would give all the intellectuals, college professors and other elitists in the world for 100 more Stu Redmans because they know HOW to do things besides talk.
GoMommyGo is one of those who obviously believes that someone else should be their nanny.
Don’t worry GoMommyGo, you won’t survive long enough in a disaster to care about which governmental entity “let you down.
The bright side of that is that is that there will be one less idiot in the gene pool. with your demise.
For at many years now our family has kept a very well stocked area in our garage. Basically I just started buying extra cans of stuff that we go through a lot of (and has a long shelf life) when it was on special. So not only do we have lots of food but it was all bought at a discount. Other advantage is that it cuts down on shopping time. Over the years the system has worked well:
When stock of an item gets a bit low keep an eye out for it to be on special. When it is, buy lots. Put them at the back of your stock and move items from the front into the house.
It may sound a lot of work but really isnt and the ‘system’ wasnt put in place all at once but gradually built up.
We probably have enough food to last 3 months at a pinch.
Look, at some level we need to take some personal responsbility – even if we’re living hand-to-mouth.
For example, on a budget so tight you can’t spend $23 on the stew … then buy one can a week using money from recycled cans.
You think I’m joking, but when you consider how ‘fat’ our poor are in this country, putting aside one can of stew or a bottle of water during the 40 or so weeks outside of the hurricane season isn’t all that difficult.
The problem is – no one, from top to bottom – did anything resembling contigency planning. For example, from time to time I make sure my 5 year old knows what to do in case of a fire a night vs. a fire in the kitchen when mommy is there.
I have my own evacuation plan coordinated with my wife and other family members that includes places to rendezvous point in case we have to evac. separately.
Point is, those who fail to plan should plan on failing when it gets tough. I mean sitting around waiting for the government to take care of my aged parents is about as imprudent as me waiting for Social Security to take care of my retirement.
“There is just something horribly, murderously, demeaning in the thought processes of those who would discount the importance of urgently encouraging everybody to do as much as they possibly can to try to have three days worth of emergency supplies.” I repeated this because it bears repeating.
DUCT TAPE – I read or heard an account of some men in the flooded area of New Orleans who used a large wad of plastic sheeting fastened together with duct tape as an emergency life raft to escape a flooded building. I wish I had saved the url.
If you build a 20 foot seawall on ground that is subsiding at about 1 inch per year it would no longer be a 20 foot seawall in 20 years. If the ground subsides at different rates along the seawall it will be a cracked seawall. Will a cracked seawall hold back a flood?