- [The] “idea that we’re going to win the war in Iraq is an idea which is just plain wrong.“
Howard “Hanoi Howie” Dean, in an interview on WOAI Radio in San Antonio earlier this week.
Howard “Hanoi Howie” Dean, in an interview on WOAI Radio in San Antonio earlier this week.
I am shocked, shocked that Dean would say what he really thinks.
Best DNC Chairman ever.
I, today with full assurity, conclude that the problem adversely affecting Dean and many other Democrats like him is that they were in college (or, at least, involved in academia) during the Vietnam War. Dean continues to say — as to other Democrats similar to him — that he’s “seen this thing before, you know, Vietnam…” and then to wax off over and over again about “Iraq is the just like Vietnam…” and then insisting on a failure mode, a “drop it”/”leave it” sort of command as if the U.S. was a dog they can summon. Because, that’s the concept ingrained in them from formative, academic years and the anger stems from the fact that the ‘dog’ isn’t acting as it should, that the U.S. isn’t dropping it, isn’t fetching a loss as expected (I paraphrase: “it happened in Vietnam, why isn’t it happening now?’ What’s the PROBlem?! Dog isn’t trained well enough, is acting out of order, isn’t doing what it’s TOLD!”).
Dean’s entire measure of reference as to U.S. military and “war” is Vietnam. And just look at Kerry, still “fighting” the same “man” he was with the very same words, manner, method and content he was in the ’60’s. And those they influence, many too young to have experienced the Sixties, believe their woefully inaccurate, Chairman Mao rhetoric, the voice that says the U.S. will fail because it’s doomed to fail, that it’s not able, not capable, bad/evil/wrong/dishonest/lying/fooled us…
Dean is far more mentally disturbed than ever even I thought he was, after hearing his words (this speech/talk/interview) of earlier this week. He actually IS a madman — it’s not just political-party competition, he’s quite mad. And I’ve always thought Kerry was, but Dean has cinched it with these comments. The man’s a raving lunatic.
assurance, not “assurity.” (^^)
Kerry and Dean are evolutionarily-backwards rejects with no understanding of self-preservation or self-defense.
That their genes survived into the modern era is a miracle.
Perhaps one day Dean and his cohorts will be visiting the Middle East, when Iran does a live fire test of its Shabab-6 missile…?
One can only hope.
I personally seriously dislike Dean. More for gut reasons than solid facts. I just get a feeling that he can’t be trusted and that he is a sell out (just another politican).
The quote doesn’t look so bad within the context of the interview as a whole. But meh.. since has anyone cared about context of a quote?
Barf. While I admit that I don’t think that going into Iraq the way that we did was the right thing to do and am no fan of the Bush Administration, now that we are there we had better damn win. Comments like this seriously annoy me. We have no choice but to win (by “win” I mean to put the US in an equivalent or better position that it was immediately prior to the war).
If Mr. Dean has nothing constructive to say about how we, the US, can put ourselves in a good position, then he should leave the adults alone to talk and excuse himself to the kiddie table.
When asked “Can we win?” the war on terror, Bush said, “I don’t think you can win it. But I think you can create conditions so that the — those who use terror as a tool are — less acceptable in parts of the world.”
I think that’s what Dean was saying. In the conventional sense he doesn’t feel that Iraq will be “won.”
When I read this interview I get the impression from Dean that I get from a lot of folks who don’t think we should be there. They feel the war is unwinnable but when pressed to explain why they tend to rely more on reasons for why we should not be there to begin with – the Bush lied sort of thing. Well, OK, if they think we should not have proceeded in the first place that is fine, I guess. But I am not sure why those feelings automatically extend to the impression that we cannot achieve the goals the President has set out – that is, win. For me, I don’t see any other choice but to win. But when this is over, I do hope that we can learn more about the intelligence that led to Bush’s decision because I think when that point arrives it would be a good thing to do.
DaveD,
Excellent observation!
My own two cents: If Dean is correct, and I don’t think he is, then should we just go ahead and hand the U.S. over to Zarqawi and bin Laden today? Think of all the needless bloodshed we could avoid.
The real war in Iraq today is against Zarqawi and his thugs. If we cannot win, as Dean thinks, then we shall lose the GWOT.
Of course, Dean doesn’t really think that. What he thinks (does he actually think?) is he hates Bush. Since Bush and the Republicans are the only ones fighting GWOT, that means Dean by default must fight against GWOT.
Consider what the Left has been arguing since 9-12-01:
You cannot “defeat” terrorism. Terrorism is a tactic, not an opponent. What we need to do isn’t FIGHT terrorism (remember, they also opposed going into Afghanistan), but to consider the root causes of “why they hate us.”
One has to wonder if edmcgon’s tongue-in-cheek idea of simply handing over Iraq to al-Zarqawi isn’t what the Left has been pretty much pushing (albeit in less blunt terms) since the Twin Towers came down?
Howard Dean should be dismissed—better yet, thrown out on his ass—as head of the DNC.
And Democrats wonder why they lost the election when this chucklehead is speaking for his party? No sane American can even remotely begin to relate to this man or oodles of moonbats who share the same beliefs he does.
Un-freakin’-real.
Lurking – who on the Left opposed going to Afghanistan. Names, please. Votes too.
Again, let me re-emphasize:
Bush on the War on Terror:
“I don’t think you can win it.”
Later from the same interview.
Bush on the War on Terror:
“I know if steadfast, strong and resolute — and I say those words very seriously — it’s less likely that your kids are going to live under the threat of al-Qaida for a long period of time. I can’t tell you. I don’t have any … definite end. But I tell you this, when we succeed in Iraq and Afghanistan, it’s the beginning of the end for these extremists. Because freedom is going to have a powerful influence to make sure your kids can grow up in a peaceful world. If we believe, for example, that you can’t win, and the alternative is to retreat … I think that would be a disaster for your children.”
Clear now?
jp2:
I politely disagree insofar as that I don’t believe Dean is agreeing with the President that the war on terror is not winnable; he’s saying the Iraq War is not winnable and that’s a different issue.
While those two wars are remarkably similar and connected, the parameters of success in Iraq should and must (and can) be measured differently than those in the WOT. In that respect, and without getting into too many details, one is definitely more winnable than the other: the Iraq War.
Will we have “a signing on the deck of the Missouri” moment? No. Victory parades? Not likely. Continued trouble from insurgents and Baathist hangers-on? Yes, very likely. But can we succeed in the establishing of a democratic, liberal governement that can work and operate on its own (it already is) in the heart of all the oppressive dictatorships, theocracies and monarchies (the cultures that help breed terrorism) in the Middle East? By God, we’re trying and making progress in that regard—8 million purple fingers is just the start of proving it.
How can he know the unknowable? Is he God? Or just a demi-god, maybe a Metro-god?
To say that we WILL NOT win is to pregnant with incoherence.
Perhaps he has better intelligence and military advice than Pres. Bush.
Oh, yeah. Flake.
Meant to say that his statement is pregnant with incoherence.
I am somewhat literate. But I can’t see the future, like Mr. Howie.
Peter F – you may have a point there – both of them could be talking in a larger sense, but Dean does seem to be speaking currently. As he’s been more right than anyone in the administration about the war, I don’t know who to believe. I think Dean’s measure for success, like many peoples views of Vietnam, revolves around preparing the country to handle security on their own. It doesn’t seem they are close, even Rumsfeld says it could be 12 years. I don’t know what Bush’s measure for success is, since he won’t tell us. Dean also has a plan, with real marks and timetables.
“Victory means exit strategy, and it’s important for the President to explain to
us what the exit strategy is.” -Governor George W. Bush
“Clear now?”
Not really. I actually agree with Bush on this one – I also don’t think we can win the WOT in Iraq, in the conventional sense. I think terrorism is a tactic now embraced by a large amount of Iraqis. I sure hope things will change for our sake. But like I said, I don’t think we will “win” in the sense that a.) most Americans feel we are safer and b.) the Iraqis are self sufficienct c.) most Americans feel it was worth it for 30 – 40 – 50,000 killed and wounded.
I just get the feeling that they don’t care. They are just screaming in opposition to anything the other side does. Later on when the troops do come home(after winning)the Democrats will try to take all the credit for it. Their people will gloss over all the crap that is being said now and make it seem like perfect sense. It is all so sad and pathetic.
Dean is simply a loser. He si most comfortable being a loser. His claim to fame was not so much how he did well in the Democratic primaries but how spectacularly he failed.
This, of course, makes him a demi-god to the loser worshipping left. They’ve never met a loser they didn’t love. It defines their whole purpose. By continually surrendering and losing they can claim victimhood, abdicate responsibility and look for someone else to take care of them.
Unfortunetly, their loser friends can’t do that either.
That’s why they need the government to di it for them.
As I recall when Bush said “I don’t think you can win it”, he made quotation marks around the word “it” as if “it” was something concrete. GWOT is a moving target. And damn straight we’re gonnna win. We have no other choice.
Dean is nothing but a knucklehead.
The funny thing is, that if Dems actually whole-heartedly supported victory in Iraq and took a tough anti-illegal immigration position, they would win the next Prez election by a huge landslide. Probably both houses of Congress, too. Just by doing those two things.
I think Hillary is trying like hell to triangulate that exact image.
One thing is certain, Dean, Kerry, and jp2 don’t want it won by a Republican. They’d prefer we lost than be proven wrong and made to look like the America-hating morons they are.
We’ll see if Dean is right – I hope not. He’s certainly been right about the war though, or at least much more grounded in reality than the Republican leadership. So many major mistakes…
“last throes” and “turning the corner”
Mission Accomplished
Greeted with open arms
The cost of the war
“We don’t torture”
WMDs
Troop Numbers
Armor and weapon supplies
jp2:
>>>We’ll see if Dean is right – I hope not.
I seriously doubt you hope Dean is incorrect. Sane people already know it.
>>>He’s certainly been right about the war though, or at least much more grounded in reality than the Republican leadership.
Your definition of “certainly” and “right” must differ from the general population’s.
>>>So many major mistakes…
Dean?… Agreed!
>>>”last throes” and “turning the corner”
Accurate – Now we have an offshore terrorist slaughtering ground to accomodate those desiring to meet Allah.
>>>Mission Accomplished
Accurate – The ship’s crew mission was accomplished.
>>>Greeted with open arms
Accurate – Or maybe the toppling of that ugly-assed statue was a way to show protest to the American “occupiers”?
>>>The cost of the war
Apparently, it’s the revelation of sheer stupidity of liberals.
>>>”We don’t torture”
Condolences to those suffering the humiliation and shame of “panty-hair”.
>>>WMDs
Sarin tipped missles. Long-range missiles. MMMM… yummy yellow-cake material… Choose your news sources wisely, jp.
>>>Troop Numbers Armor and weapon supplies
Yes, we should have consulted Howie and his Magical Mystery Think Tank on that.
Dean is a raving, insane moonbat defeatist of the highest order. His (and your) hatred for this administration is detrimental to the country.
Dissent? Sure.
Sedition for politics? Go F yourself.
SOTG
Actually, Dean’s comment is fairly astute. How do you define victory? I dare anyone to nail him down on that question. As we go forward, he will continually raise the bar on victory’s definition.
We have elections in Iraq? Ok, but the country still isn’t safe.
There hasn’t been any terrorism in 6 months? Ok, but our troops are still there.
Our troops are out of there now? Ok, but they still haven’t increased their oil production to pre-war levels.
They’ve increased their oil production to pre-war levels? Ok, but there’s still a streetlight out in Baghdad.
You see? He can go on and on, finding flaws in the diamond as he goes along. Nothing will ever be good enough. Unless, of course, he’s in charge. 😉
‘I think that’s what Dean was saying. In the conventional sense he doesn’t feel that Iraq will be “won.”‘
I’m sure that’s bullshit.
Bush was talking about the GWOT, Dean was speaking about Iraq. I’m sure few would be happier if the US did lose and few will do more to make it happen than Dean the rest of the Defeatocrats.
Juan Cole (who is considered an expert in this region) in an excellent thread dissects the problem with the manichean (polar opposite) prediction of Dean’s pessimistiic “US loss” vs Bush’s prognosis for US”victory “in Iraq. Although he has more in sympathy with Dean, Cole feels it is still possible for the US and Bush to win smart in Iraq. “The debate is just about disengagement strategy. Bush wants to keep a large US military force in Iraq for as long as it takes to build up a new Iraqi military and government under US tutelage, so as to avoid the disaster of a collapse of Iraq when the US comes out (when, not if). Bush’s plan probably envisions a significant US troop presence for a good five years (how long it will really take to train an Iraqi army, if it can be done at all).”
Well perhaps it wuold help us all if The Moron in Chief himself could define victory. In his speech last week, he defined victory as When the Iraqi’s can stand alone and then later as when the indurgents are defeated. He gave two seperate definitions of victory in the same speech. So while little eddie boy is free to speculate as to how Dean would define victory, we know that Georgie has no definition.
Steve: I’m definitely more willing to listen to Cole about any of this, rather than Dean or any other paid politician. He’s been on the money thus far.
Fredo: Love your criticism for his ‘hatred’ and at the same time lovely parting phrase of ‘Go F Yourself.’ Classy.
Juan Cole (who is considered an expert in this region)
Yeah — just ask him.
It is clear that the Democrats are ratcheting up their onslaught against Bush and the war. But let’s face it, that’s all they have to work with because their leadership has failed.
The Democratic leadership has put the party in a position such that they have no vested interest in any kind of positive outcome in Iraq. Every iota of progress toward a free and democratic Iraq it is a blow to the Democratic party in America.
Clearly, the Democratic party has a vested interest in America’s defeat in Iraq. There is no way, shape, or form that the Democrats (beyond the few who *truly* support the war) can benefit by America not being defeated in Iraq. Their leadership has guaranteed that much.
Kerry’s remarks that our troops terrorize Iraqi women and children, and Dean’s remarks in question here are not random. The virulently anti-war and at least semi anti-American sector of the Democratic party is writing the talking points these days. Time will tell what America thinks of that.
As an aside though, whoever said that Howard Dean was one of Karl Rove’s greatest achievements was dead on.
Seamus, at least the “Moron in Chief” takes the subject seriously which is more than we can say about you.
Why are the the two goals you cite problematic for you? They are not inconsistent, and I doubt the President said that one of the two was the exclusive litmus test for victory.
It’s a little too “nuanced” for the Kerry et al crowd. Last August Kerry wanted more troops, now he wants less. Who’s the Moron???
“They are not inconsistent, and I doubt the President said that one of the two was the exclusive litmus test for victory.”
I know you’re an idiot, but at least attempt to work with me here. That’s exactly the problem. What is the definition of victory? Is it whne the Iraqi’s can stand alone? Is it when the insurgents have been defeated? It is something else altogehter? Bush claims to have a “Strategy for victory” but he hasn’t been able to artidculate what victory is.
Mitchell,
The problem here is that Bush used two sentences to define victory. Seamus gets a little confused when you go past one sentence.
Seamus,
Allow me to explain the victory condition to you: Insurgents down, Iraqis standing, all at the same time.
Is that simple enough?
“Idiot” and “Moron.”
This is the level of discourse that passes for debate on the Left.
If your ideas suck, just throw a little bombast out there to hide the fact, huh?
Insurgents down Iraqis standing, well that’s a good way of defining victory, don’t you mean insurgents down Americans standing, either way you have just proved it America is losing the war because the Insurgents are not down their standing and they getting stronger and stronger, you idiots are so totally loyal to your party your fantasies about Iraq are unreal, it’s a nightmare and its messed up big time, I heard one fool on here describe the Iraqi government as liberal democracy, go and check the ideologies of the ruling parties you ignorant morons, SCRI is the largest party in the parliament go and find out what SCIRI stands for or which party the Iraqi prime minister is from.
These are extreme Islamic Shia parties and the only reason they not fighting is because they can gain power through the ballot box due to the large Shia population in Iraq.
Saf, sometimes things take time. I don’t recall anyone saying we would be done in Iraq on December 8, 2005. Nor did anyone say it would be done quickly.
These are your own expectations projected onto the Bush administration or the military. Regardless, wars are a messy business.
Look at WWII. It lasted 4 years for us (6 years for others). How long were we in Germany and Japan after that war? Half a century. Based on your criteria, I guess we really blew that war.
So what if the Iraqi’s are standing alone but the insurgents are still attracking? Or what if the insurgents stop attacking but the Iraqi’s aren’t standing alone? What if the insurgents stop attacking, but it’s simply a ploy to get us to pull out, and then they start attacking again? You jackasses blundered us into this fiasco, you’ve blundered your way through it. If at any point, you’d like to get together, put some thought into it, and maybe give us some specifics as to how you plan on getting us out of it, we’d appreciate it.
You’re right Mitchell. Maybe I should question your patriotism and whether or not you support thr troops. That passes as intelligent debate on the right.
Seamus, so what should we have done with Iraq?
It depends on what we wanted to accomplish. If we wanted to encourage democracy, we should have dropped the sanctions, sent food and medicine to the hungry and sick and waited for either A) the people of Iraq to “stand up” to Saddam or B) for Saddam to die.
If we wanted to maintain a fairly comfortable status quo, we should have left Saddam as the tin badge, third world, all sabre-rattling dictator he was and gone on wiht our lives as we had for the previous 11 years.
Or, if we wanted to promote a festering sore in the middle east that will plague us for the next thirty years, we should have done exactly what we did.
Instead of fighting back and slugging the bully like we did, dean, seamus and jp2 would have us crying and standing in a puddle of piss with a big snot bubble hanging out of our noses giving up our milk money on a daily basis. That is the faggotty America the liberal democrats want!
Seamus, the U.N.’s “oil-for-food” program was about sending food and medicine to Iraq. You see how well that went.
The people of Iraq tried to rebel after the first Gulf War. Saddam crushed that quickly. The Iraqi people had no plans to challenge him again anytime soon. You plan B would happen first.
What would have happened if Saddam died? One of his exemplary sons would have taken over. While this is speculation on my part, I don’t think much would have changed.
Let me get this straight: Your plan was we should have left Saddam alone to do whatever he pleases, as long as he keeps it within his own border?
I’m not talking about the U.N. I’m talking about the U.S. We take the food, we take the medicine into Iraq and distribute it.
Point two, you’re probably right.
Yes, I would have left things well enough alone.
Moseby, you drooling nitwit. Fight back against what? When, exactly, did saddam bully us?
Seamus: he bullied us by firing repeatedly on British and American aircraft policing the Gulf War I agreement he made–and then reneged on.
Failure to abide by a dozen or so UN resolutions.
He tried to assassinate Pres. Bush I.
Sadam would never willingly have let US into his country to distribute food and medicine, so you would really be arguing war on this point.
Post-9/11, a “comfortable status quo” is a fool’s speculation at best. He had a nuclear weapons program in hiding and appears to have been “running down the clock” on inspections for the day he could reconstitute his other wmd.
When you Libs got your fill of this as a “medicine and food” mission, you would have turned to some frivilous issue and forgotten him, until it was too late.
Saf: If all you’re reading is NYT and watching CBS, et al, then I can imagine you think the entire country is burning in one huge fire ball. If you don’t, then you are not paying attention to what is going on there. The Constitution is a very progressive document for the Middle East.
Idiot! Moron! Yo Momma wears combat boots, etc.
Oh, I forgot to add: I was chatting with God lately, and he really, really despises you. He told me to tell you that. And to, as he put it, “get your act together.”
And then he struck our shrubs with a thunderbolt and we had s’mores last night. You should have been there, we were handling snakes and everything.
I thumped a bible for your soul!
seamus, if you cannot see that saddam hussein was a bully then there is no hope for your sorry liberal pussy ass.
Seamus, would you agree that Mitchell is right about Saddam not allowing the U.S. into Iraq to distribute food and medicine?
As for leaving Saddam alone, even if we ignore what he was doing to his own people, would he have been content to remain within his own borders? Even if you ignore his buddy-buddy relationship with Al Qaeda, he has already attacked Iran and Kuwait.
What do you think he would have done once he found out Iran was building nukes?
he bullied us by firing repeatedly on British and American aircraft policing the Gulf War I agreement he made–and then reneged on.
Failure to abide by a dozen or so UN resolutions.
He tried to assassinate Pres. Bush I.
Exactly. Harmless sabre rattling from a tin badge, third world dictator.
Sadam would never willingly have let US into his country to distribute food and medicine, so you would really be arguing war on this point.
You’re right. But at least we could have gone to war with the moral high ground. If Saddam had wanted to go to war with us because we trying to bring food and medicine to his people, we would have been greeted as liberators and had roses thrown at our feet. We would have had an actual coalition, or at least been justified had we told any Old Europe country that dissagreed with us to screw off.
Post-9/11, a “comfortable status quo” is a fool’s speculation at best.
Using that theory, since Pearl Harbor, comfortable status quo is a fool’s speculation. In fact, using your theory, Saddam would have been justified attacking us, since it was only a matter of time before we attacked him. Hell, at this point, why not just nuke everybody, since at some point, somewhere, somebody’s going to attack someone else.
When you Libs got your fill of this as a “medicine and food” mission, you would have turned to some frivilous issue and forgotten him, until it was too late.
According to your own post, it would have resulted in war, so this is just nonsense.
America hater! Traitor! Troop killer! Your mother should be shot in the head for not having an abortion when she had the chance!