With the current furor over cartoon depictions of Mohammed, I’ve decided to take a step back and look at the big picture. Just how serious is blasphemy taken by some of the other major religions, and just how much respect is accorded other faiths by non-practicioners? (I figure as a repeatedly-self-declared agnostic, I am the closest thing to a disinterested party as there is around.)
Let’s look at some examples of blasphemous imagery, and see how they are handled:
First, there’s this cartoon I stumbled across a while ago. It is rankly offensive to two major faiths — Christianity and Judaism. But I have to admit I snorted at it. I even shared it with a select few (OK, just Laurence Simon), who said he was going to post it, but he never did.
How about stuff that’s pretty much guaranteed to offend Christians? How is that handled?
Luckily, we have two recent examples — Andres Serrano’s Piss Christ and Chris Ofili’s Madonna, made with elephant dung.
How did Christians react to these desecrations of their holiest symbols with bodily wastes? Yeah, there was a hue and cry. There may have been even a death threat or two. But the most extreme reaction I can recall by most people was a denouncement that these had been paid for with taxpayer money — THEIR money — and they were outraged over that. I don’t recall massive Christian riots over them, burning buildings and calling for death.
Judaism takes a bit more abuse. Partly because they’re a smaller group, partly because they’re much more in-your-face to the Muslim world, partly out of respect for historical tradition. But take a look at some of the anti-Semitic cartoons collected here, or this award-winning cartoon. Pretty extreme stuff, but again no major backlash.
Then there’s Islam.
The Ten Commandments, common to all three faiths mentioned above, says you shall not worship graven images. In Islam, this is taken to the extreme that one should not even create an image of Mohammed. And whether or not you believe in the tenets of Islam or not, they’re bound and determined that we shall all live by them.
Therefore, it is an unforgivable sin for ANYONE to draw pictures of Mohammed. Even non-Moslem cartoonists in a Western democracy, acting fully within their legal and moral rights — for the Danish government to tolerate that is, to much of the Islamic world, a declaration of war.
One of the basic tenets I learned in a class on ethics is that for any ethical system of beliefs to be acceptable, it must be universal. It must apply equally to all, or it is inherently unfair. So, by that standard, it seems that the governing principle underlying the Muslim outrage must be that one must respect a religion’s beliefs, even if you don’t ascribe to them.
And how does Islam rate on that standard?
Pretty shabby.
The Taliban, who I think we can all agree represented a very fundamentalist view of Islam, decided that its “no graven images” belief extended to two huge statues of Buddha in Afghanistan. And, with great ceremony and glee, they destroyed them — despite pleas from the world community, not just Buddhists.
In 2002, Palestinian terrorists fleeing Israeli military forces entered and occupied the Church of the Nativity. While the siege lasted, they repeatedly desecrated the Church and abused the Christian staff. And when they left, there were no apologies, no reparations — just celebrations that they had negotiated their way out, proclaiming it a great victory.
And let us NEVER forget the ongoing extermination of any signs of Jewish occupation of the Temple Mount, undertaken by the Palestinian Authority in contravention of international law and done under the color of “restoration” to the mosque built on top of the holiest site to Jews.
In Muslim nations, there is freedom to belong to another faith. As long as you don’t make a point of it. That means you can’t display any signs of your faith. You can’t build a house of worship. You have to pay a special non-Muslim tax. And if you get caught “attempting to convert” a Moslem (which could mean something as innnocuous as explaining your beliefs to a curious Moslem), you can be put to death.
That’s just for Christians. Jews have it even worse — when they’re even allowed entry into the country.
So let’s sum up: according to the Moslems, our Constitutionally-guaranteed rights of freedom of religion, freedom of speech, and all the rest are secondary to the tenets of a faith the vast majority of us simply don’t believe in.
I think not. The Golden Rule applies here: “do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” If the Moslem world wants respect, it must be willing to give it.
I am reminded of a great quote from Mahatma Gandhi. When asked about his opinion of Western civilization, he replied “I think it would be a good idea.”
Modern-day Islam, I am sad to say, is reminding me more and more of contemporary gangs. So eager to answer any insult or challenge, incredibly prickly about their “rights” and “turf,” and so quick to resort to violence. The Danish cartoons were a “dis” on them, and they seem poised to go to any lengths to avenge that slight.
So what do I think of Moslem civilization? I think it would be a good idea — but I’m basing that purely on speculation, as I’ve seen damned little evidence of it so far.


Is this a general feeling that because one is agnostic one has a keener insight into controversies arising from religious belief?
I think you should change the title of this post from “Fuck ’em if they can’t take a joke.”
to
“Fuck ’em.”
If they want civil war Europe should give it to them.
You can’t have your moral cake and eat it to. If you are going to lie, kidnap, torture, and kill, then you can’t argue your points from any moral high ground. It’s hard to believe anyone sho supports terrorism, and the killing of innocents, is offended by a cartoon. How do they think their victims families feel?
Raymond B
http://www.voteswagon.com
Dave D.
No. But it may make a difference to some that he isn’t speaking from a standpoint of religious bias.
Israel ought to kick the Arabs out of Jerusalem, decide it’s final borders and expell the Arabs from within it’s borders. Finish the wall around her borders. Do not let any Arabs work in Israel or come to Israel for medical treatment. Cut all electrical service to Gaza. Same for the West Bank of the Jordan. The Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza can either:
1-emigrate
2-die
3-drop the phony pretense of “Palestinian” nationalism and revert to what they really are; renegade Jordanians and Egyptians. Let Egypt and Jordan take responsibility for their renegade citizens.
As for Europe and the West it is time for us to remind the Islamic world that they exist at our sufferance, not the other way around. Expel the radical trash from our midst and make it crystal clear that we are quite capable and if need be willing to destroy them if they persist on threatening us. If they insist on forcing us to choose between us and them, then they loose.
57 countries that produce nothing and contribute nothing to the scientific, technical and cultural advancement of humanity. Is there one world class university in the Muslim world? one world class teaching and research hospital in the Muslim world? One world class R&D lab or high tech manufacturing and design facility in the Muslim world? And yet this trash has the insolence to demand that we bow down to them. What nerve. We ought to be ashamed of ourselves that we allow ourselves to be dominated by them. enough.
Jay Tea:
So what do I think of Moslem civilization? I think it would be a good idea — but I’m basing that purely on speculation, as I’ve seen damned little evidence of it so far.
My god you are being incredibly lazy and general here. This is like walking around talking abour “Chistian Civilization” as if that is a meaningful term.
There are, as has been noted time and again, quite a large number of Muslims in this world, and they cannot all be lumped into one category as you continually do. The people in Morocco are not the same as the people in Indonesia. The people in Iraq who are just trying to go about their lives, and who happen to practice Islam, SHOULD NOT be equated with terrorists who proclaim to be Muslims as well.
This is insane, Jay.
By your logic, I should hold you responsible, or characterize you, for what some random poster writes on here, under the pretence that he/she is a conservative. Guilt by association. However, I understand that since you are not posting things like the above post by a certain “cuban,” you are certainly not to be held accountable for those words. And I do not assume that you either agree, or support those words, simply because you might share a nominal relation to the person.
Do you get my point?
Fuck ’em, indeed.
Ryan, you may be right. I might be letting the 80% who are extremists color my perceptions of the other 20%.
Why don’t you cite a few examples to enlighten me? Say, a few examples of large groups of Muslims acting in a decent, responsible, respectful manner? Of contributing something of inestimable value to the world? Of doing the right, tolerant, peaceful thing?
I can think of exactly one instance in the last few years, Ryan — but I’m not going to do your homework for you. And I bet I can easily cite a dozen or more bigger counter-examples for every one you do find.
J.
Fuck Ryan, too.
Hell, fuck the Glob and all apologists.
http://volokh.com/posts/1139073913.shtml
So what do I think of Moslem civilization?
Tony Blair beat you to it; his response to the idea of a “clash of civilizations” —
“No; that would require two civilisations.”
Via M.M.
Jay:
You really believe that 80% of Muslims are extremists? Doesnt the very word “extremist” imply some sort of difference from the majority viewpoint? I really cannot believe that you think that 80% of the world’s Muslims think like these extremists do.
Really?
Why don’t you cite a few examples to enlighten me? Say, a few examples of large groups of Muslims acting in a decent, responsible, respectful manner?
Okay, so the current population of the United States is about 295 million, and about one percent of that, according to the CIA World Fact Book, is Muslim. Exhibit A, then, is the almost 3 million American Muslims who go about their lives as everyday Americans, “in a decent, responsible, respectful manner.” Of course, it cannot be assumed that everyone in this sample population lives up to that, just like we cannot assume that 100 percent of the American population lives in the ways you describe. So, lets say that 10 percent dont live that way…we still have about 2.6 million or so who do, which I would call a “large group”.
Now, there are some 3 billion Muslims throughout the world, and you think that 80 percent of them are extremists who support terrorism. I think you’re paranoid, personally, and would imagine that the vast majority of them are pretty much just trying to live their lives like the rest of us. Unfortunately for them, they have been living under the likes of Saddam Hussein, the Ayatolla, Mushareff, the Saudi Royal Family, etc. for decades.
But then, I’ll bet you believed the idea that the Soviet Union was filled with America hating commies who just wanted to kill us all. Amazingly, once the USSR fell, we realized that the country was full of a bunch of human beings who had lived under a horrible regime. A bunch of goddamn poor peasants who had been bled dry for 80 years. I think the situation in many Middle Eastern countries is pretty comparable. Let’s try to separate the people and the culture from the despots and criminals, if possible.
I count as evidence every single Muslim, out of the 1 billion or so that we have today, who does not engage in this type of activity as proof against your claims.
If 80 percent of 1 billion Muslims were extremists who support terrorism, that would be 800,000,000 people. You really think that 800 million people want to kill us? Seriously, please answer that. (stats from the CIA world fact book).
I do not think that we have a situation where 800 million Muslims are terrorists, or terrorist sympathizers.
^^the first time i wrote “3 billion Muslims” it should say 1 billion.
Denny:
Fuck Ryan, too.
Brilliant contribution Denny. I’m sure everyone’s very proud of you. Great job with the punctuation and capitalization…now we’ll just work on expanding your vocabulary.
Ryan, how do you not know they are not terrorist sympathizers? I think that using the word extremist is wrong. I do not seem Muslims protesting the suicide bombings in Israel. I do not see Muslims preaching against Hate and FOR tolerance. I do not see a Muslim version of Dr. King. I do not see a Muslim version of Ghandi. What I see is hatred, violence from Muslims outside the US. I see civil unrest with Muslims in France. I see CAIR in the US having connections with Terrorism and I hear the Leaders of CAIR stating that Islam and the Sharia should be the law code in the United States. I see Islam for what it is, a religion of hate and intolerance.
Thanks Ryan, I am very fucking proud of my post. I do look forward to ex-fucking-panding my vocabulary, but I just finished watching an old George Carlin show on HBO and I’m feeling pretty fucking inspired to use his brand of emphasis.
Surely you know my post was not personal. I’m growing increasingly intolerant of the muslim intolerance–and the Western tolerance of their intolerance. In England you can’t keep a copy of E.B. White’s books on your desk because one of them, Charlotte’s Web, depicts a pig on the cover. Christians and Jews are persecuted throughout the Middle East, yet we can’t even draw a harmless cartoon. While you claim mainstream Muslims are not part of this, each of their religious leaders apparently is–and the Muslim contingents of U.S. Universities seem fairly uniform in their support for the one-sided “tolerance” and “freedom.”
Therefore, Fuck ’em.
There’s no aspect of religion that’s “reasonable”; anyone else’s religion seems ridiculous because there’s no proof of any of it, and it plain doesn’t make sense, so why would we even EXPECT reason from them from a religious perspective?
It’s only overly PC Americans that try to make comparisons and calculate which behaviors are ok; to everyone else, anything they do that’s connected with their religion is automatically ok, and it doesn’t matter what anyone else is doing because only the faithful count, not heathens/infidels.
(is glad to have a nameless spirituality)
Robert:
Ryan, how do you not know they are not terrorist sympathizers?
What I can tell you is that I do not assume that they are. I know that terrorist sympathizers are out there, but I do not automatically assume that because a person is a Muslim, they must therefore be aligned with terrorism. It’s a HUGE assumption to make, and personally I think thats a good way to make enemies of people who might otherwise be allies.
I see Islam for what it is, a religion of hate and intolerance.
Well, thats your perception of it, and there isnt much I can do to change it. I look at Islam yet another religion, and one that takes different forms in different countries, like all religions. In the Middle East the political situation there has been anything but stable for decades, and democracy is hardly existent. Islam is a widespread belief there…but I would not blame Islam for terrorism in the middle east, the lack or democracy, or the general state of affairs there. Islam has been used by many terrorists to justify their actions, but still, in the end Islam is just a concept and individuals should be held accountable for what they do.
Terrorism comes from the fact that the Middle East has been run by a bunch of criminals for decades, along with the fact that it has been ravaged by wars. People want to blame Islam for the terrorism in Iraq, and I think that’s really simplistic and lazy. Maybe the long rule of the brutal Ba’ath Party had something to do with it? Maybe the horrible eight year war with Iran? Maybe the fact that Hussein let the people starve under the sanctions? Maybe the fact that since 1990 Iraq has been in 2 more wars, and the place is pretty screwed up? Maybe the terrorism comes from the lack of democracy, from the destroyed infastructure, and from the fact that the Sunnis, Shiites, and Kurds hardly get along?
But no…it’s all because of Islam. Right…
Denny:
For starters, Carlin rules. Just had to get that out of the way.
I dont take it personally…but it wouldnt be a stretch for a person to take suck a statement personally, considering the fact that you attached the phrase fuck you to my name. But what do i know?
I’m growing increasingly intolerant of the muslim intolerance–and the Western tolerance of their intolerance.
I think that clerics who go around speaking in 7th century rhetoric are about as bad as it gets. I dont find it acceptable, by any means. But I also do not assume that every Muslim believes that shit, and I think that putting them all in the same category might be a mistake.
I will refrain from condemning all Muslims, just in case there are some who, in fact, think in different ways. Otherwise, if we just call them all enemies, well, we’ve made a little self fulfilling prophesy havent we???
In England you can’t keep a copy of E.B. White’s books on your desk because one of them, Charlotte’s Web, depicts a pig on the cover.
Is that actually encoded in the laws? Pretty ridiculous if it is, but thats the way that democracies work, supposedly. So if it is law I imagine that an interest group got together and pushed that through.
Christians and Jews are persecuted throughout the Middle East, yet we can’t even draw a harmless cartoon.
Remember, Muslims get persecuted there too. Terrorists dont kill just non-Muslims you know. And the oppressive governments, like Hussein, have beat the hell out of Muslim civilians as well.
The cartoon: I think that Muslims should choose their battles and I think that this is not one of them. But then, I’m not going to go around propagating that kind of slander because I wouldnt want someone doing that to me. I think that this whole thing is blown out or proportion, and could be diffused by both sides pretty easily.
While you claim mainstream Muslims are not part of this, each of their religious leaders apparently is–and the Muslim contingents of U.S. Universities seem fairly uniform in their support for the one-sided “tolerance” and “freedom.”
Well look…they’re all offended and paranoid too. This whole post 9/11 thing hasnt been the smoothest of all times. They get all defensive, and upset, and I can see the point, considering how seriously they take the whole image thing in Islam. On the other side, maybe they could try to let it slide instead of making it into the huge battle that it is…why dredge it up. And us Americans, well I dont think that we need to make things worse by throwing more lighter fluid onto the whole thing by calling all Muslims evil and all that bullshit. Jesus.
Do we want to be a part of the solution or a part of the problem? Do you think it really helps ANYTHING to walk around saying fuck all muslims? Well, I dont see how that helps, at all. Feel free to disagree.
Right.
To Ryan:
Do you think it helps anything to kiss thier ass all the time?
they are so stupid if the christian jesus was drawn you wouldnt have a bunch of christians goin “arrrrrrr no blood you insult are lord now we are gonna kick some ass, TO THE CHRISTIAN VAN!!!” and for fuck sakes aint anyone realised there is no god eh? come on science out weights them. so all i have to say is fuck em and fuck em hard and for christ sake we would compleatly kick thier god dam asses!
bense
I’m sorry Ryan I believe but just not participating in terrorist attacks is not the bar Jay Tea set.
I believe he’s looking for an example where Muslims went out of they way to help and/or stop their brothers extremists without political pressure to do so.
grrr…. should read
I’m sorry Ryan but I believe just not…
Ryan is typical of the left. wants to see what he wishes too see and not what is actually there.
Rants about the differences between Indonesians and Moroccans all the while failing to note that they each have far more in common with each other than either with Danes and Americans. Yes Ryan there really is a Western Civilization just like there is an Islamic Civilization. And by the majority of metrics ours is the superior civilization. There really are objective measurements contrary to leftist belief in relativity in all civilization’s accomplishments.
Notice he doesn’t attempt to refute my observation
of the lack of accomplishment in the Muslim world.
Does he really believe it’s just a fluke that 57 countries through out the planet who just happen to Muslim are also incapable of producing advances in the sciences, technology and medicine?
He goes on about 80% of the Muslims not being terrorists etc. True and irrelevant. What is relevant is that the 80% do virtually nothing to stop the evil 20%. Indeed they provide the funds and the support needed by the 20%. The Soviet Union wasn’t entirely populated by communists, more like 20% who identified with that evil. The Muslim world on the other hand are populated by at least 80% who at the minimum notionally ascribe to that evil .
There is an old Spanish saying ” there is none so blind as one who refuses too see”.
Imagine if you will, the good that could come about, if those who are Muslim and their supporters were to stand up, make as much noise, get as much publicity, in as many places in the world as today but, their message was peace.
You may say Im a dreamer,
but Im not the only one,
I hope some day you’ll join us,
And the world will live as one.
Well, Im sure there were a few million German and Japanese civilians who didnt support what their governments were up to during the second world war. And I am sure that more than a few of those good folks got caught up in the carnage. Oh well. Thats the way history and the world works.
Do any of you who believe in things like freedom, liberty, democracy think that Europe will better off in 20-30 years when the growing Muslim population begins to exert its will?
I laugh at someone quoting John Lennon because in a world dominated by Islam Lennon would have been, at best imprisoned or beaten for a song such as Imagine at worst…well read the placards all those savage barbarians are carrying in response to these laughably mild political cartoons
Hey Johnny,
I’m on your side. I was just making a point.
I would seriously like to believe that the vast majority of Muslims are peace loving individuals who want no part of the violence the radicals tar their religion with. I really would.
All I need to help me believe is to read the stories about the arrests, by Muslim governments, of those responsible for burning embassies, murdering, torturing, bombing, raping, rioting, destroying property and otherwise terrorizing. I may have missed them. Could someone please provide the links? There must be links. About Muslim police forces quelling riots, arresting men who have committed “honor killings”. How about the news articles about the suicide bombers being arrested by (pick a Middle Eastern country, except Israel).
There are more than 1 billion Muslims out there. They have to be asserting control over that scant handful of bad seed that is doing those awful things in the name of Islam. Don’t they?
I’m still waiting.
That was the point of my message. I was talking to those Muslims who say they are peace loving and those that support them. I’m still waiting for an answer also.
Ryan,
Your response to my post was pretty damned reasonable, and it represents a view I’ve tried to hold since 9/11. I’m struggling, but losing my grip on it. I’m nearly ready to join the anti-Islam mobs as a result of the daily examples of absurdity emanating from the world’s mosques. I hate to admit it, but bigotry is moving into my soul–and it seems increasingly justified by recent events. Hell, I could be Archie Bunker soon!
As for the E.B. White thing, that was hyperbolic. As far as I can recall, the British government banned all images of pigs from government offices to show sensitivity to Muslims (as a result of their idiotic demand). Elements of Style is permitted, but Charlotte’s Web is out. Beanie Baby pigs are out. The government offices are pork free. I’m no pork fan, but that’s asinine!
I do want to congratulate you on your reasoned and respectful arguments, even though I’m tilting the other way at the moment.
Fuckin’ A!
There are a loit of folks waiting. And hoping. But mostly waiting. I am not convinced that we will be able to wait much longer.
Where is Charles Martel when you need him?
Ryan, in your response to me nearly every aspect involved Iran, Iraq and maybe the PA/Hamas. That does NOT address the issues of the Muslims in the Phillipiness killing foreigners, that does NOT address the bombings in Bali or other places in Indonesia or the Civil War in Sri Lanka or the Conflict between Mulims and Hindus in India/Pakaistan/Bangladesh. Nor does it account for the situation in Sudan, the former Soviet Union territoris or Lybia.
Like I said. Islam is PART of the cause. Recently Hamas came out and published an article stating that Seville (IN SPAIN) should be returned to Muslim Rule becuase it was once under Muslim Control.
Where is the G-d damned moderate Muslims protesting this crap? All I hear are crickets chirping away.
There is no peaceful resolution with any Muslim who believes in Jihad or believes that all territories that were once under the control of Muslims need to return to Muslim control. Funny, I don’t hear the descendent of the Romans stating that all lands under the Roman Empire need to become under the control of them Italians….or the Greeks stating that all territories under the control of the Byzantine Empire need to revert back. Nor do I hear Jews stating that all lands between the River of Egypt and the Euphraties needs to be reverted back under the control of the Jews.
In case you haven’t actually SEEN the cartoons under discussion, here they are
http://www.faithfreedom.org/Gallery/Mo_Cartoons.jpg
(slightly less controversial)
Ryan Wrote
” Maybe the terrorism comes from the lack of democracy”
I think, you are on to something here.
Well I stumbled across this thread in a Google search, and have read the lefty Ryan go up against some fire breathing red-blooded Americans.
The problem with Americans is that they are vastly ignorant of history. For them life began pretty much when Lincoln walked the streets of Richmond. Prior to that everything is a blurb, and yes there was the somewhat important crossing by Washington in a Morgan pose over the Potomac.
History is a well taught subject in Islamic countries, but focus for some reason is always Western history (a vestige of our colonial past). We however often hear from family members about the great Islamic history, but it is always diffused. It wasn’t until after my teen years that I began to explore this history and found that indeed there was much to the banter by elders.
Islamic history was a precursor to the Italian renaissance. Historians will often talk about how Western civilization is steeped in Greek civilization. Yet go dumb when explaining how it was that Greek and Roman history was retained when much of the Western world was nothing but a smattering of fuedal lordships raping and plundering each other (and no its wasn’t some obscure Monastary in Germany with SuperComputers data mining everything). They forget to mention that it was the Islamic empire that in the middle ages (dark according to Europeans) collected and enhanced the greek and romans thoughts. That Paper, Algebra, Astronomy, Banking, Hospitals, were all Islamic concepts, uniquely developed by these very countries some of these respondents are today stating amount to nothing. That it was the ability of the ignorant/illierate and backward europeans to study and learn during and after the crusades from the muslims that became the fundamental of european renaissance.
But I won’t digress there.
What people conveniently avoid and put aside is that Islam or Islamic empires were not raping or plundering the Christians. It was the Crusades that first brought to Islamic shores an evil ideology of hatred based upon religion. Ask any muslim to say anything negative about Christ or Moses, and you won’t get many respondents. The contrary is often exemplified as in the case of the cartoons.
Though I personally believe things have gotten out of hand (cartoons), people should try and understand that for muslims their religion is fundamental to their beliefs. Yes there is a disassociation of understanding between the West and the Islamic world. For muslims there is no concept of secularism. Islam is a code of law and society, not secularist constituionalism. If you are a muslim you must submit to this law. Islam has not acceeded to the secularism as perhaps contemporary Christianity has done. Christianity is more of a commercial entity than a religion today. This fundamental difference stems from the fact that there is no concept of a religious beauraucracy in Islam that gives into economic interest as the Church did in Europe. There is no Church in Islam. A muslim’s religion is through personal choice and requires no intermediary institution, priest, or prophet.
So personal belief is important to muslims and no secular thought or constitutionality will dilute that.
What you see today in the Islamic world in terms of countries are colonial vestiges. A deliberate ripping apart of the Islamic empires of East Asia, South Asia, Middle East, and North Africa. Most of which were before the Europeans colonized it under a single confederation of the Ottomon Empire. The unhealthy nature of the the last 60 years is an aftermath of this unnatural dissociation that has bred some much confusion in terms of identity. Not to mention the constant medling in the affairs of muslim countries by european and western interests.
Western interests have just not left the islamic world alone and have plundered her resources. So to the people who said what have they given us. First we gave you our freedom (colonial years), then our taxes (as colonial subjects), then our earned income for your goods (during colonial years local industry was destroyed and imported goods that helped driven European industrial revolution we forced upon a compliant rule native class), then our debt (after WWII, in the post colonial era, huge loans were forwarded and funnelled back to European banks and companies, leaving nations indetured), then our mineral resources, then our policies, and now finally you ask for our souls.
Finally to those who wonder about science. As the Church in Europe was burning people for epileptic seizures as Witches and Warlocks, Islamic scientists were pondering about the expansion attributes of the universe.
“The heaven we have built it with power. Verily. We are expanding it [Quran 51:47].”
Islamic scientists were wondering how the universe began and where life started:
“Do the unbelievers not realize that the Heavens and Earth used to be one solid mass that we exploded into existance? And from water we made everything” [Quran 21:30]
Over 1400 hundred years ago Quran came up with these words (on evolution):
“Is it not a fact that there was a time when the human being was nothing to be mentioned? We created the human from a liquid mixture, from two parents, in order to test him. [Q 76:1-2]
The Quran has incredible information on science, that baffles the mind. So much for a religion that has had no benefit to science.
“And God created every living creature from water. Some of them walk on their bellies, some walk on two legs, some on four. [Q 24:45]”
And one last thing, on slightly different note. There is more Greek blood (genetically) in a Pashtun in Tribal Belts of Pakistan than there is in a Brit, French, or Nord, Dane, or even a warm blooded American. Sorry just had to through that in… 🙂
Hopefully I added something to this discourse. And oh BTW my 4 close classmates from my school in this muslim country, one attended MIT (BSc), another (UPenn-BA/Yale-MBA), another (Princeton-BA/Harvard-MBA), another (UPenn-Bsc/Stanford-MBA), and I myself attended an Ivy League school. Just 5 average kids from a school in the Islamic world that are today some of the top performers in their fields in the US, all of whom came from the backward societies of the Islamic world. BTW over a 100 students from my class attended US colleges. Also this school has the highest academic scores of any school in the world and consistently beats the top public and private schools in US and Europe. So much for us raving lunatics producing anything.
Kashif,
I would be willing to put up Israeli scientists vs Muslim scientists any day of the week.
I am not ignorant of history. My collection of various books in my library number over 1000 books specializing in general and specific history related topics also quite a smathering of philosophy and some religious studies. Currently I am reading George Ostrosky’s History of the Byzantine State.
Please answer my questions in regards to my previous comments. Are you in favor of Jihad? Do you think that all lands that were once under Muslim rule should become Muslim territories? Do believe in the concept of the restoration of the Caliph?
Since the United States is rather welcoming to students and people genuinely interested in getting an education. Do you think that it is not “fair” that there are no synogagues or churches in Saudia Arabia?
Corrrect me if I am wrong but we do PAY for the oil we PLUNDER from the middle east do we not?
Yes we Americans are vastly ignorant of world as well as our own history but we are not the only ones. Oh by the way, what percentage of the Arab street would question whether the Holocaust actually happened? My guess would be a sizable majority.
Funny how the apologists for islam have to look back hundreds and thousands of years in the past to remind us all of how wonderful things were when Islam reigned supreme. They have no choice but to look to the past because in the present the Arab and Islamic world is a basket case.
Im not in the least impressed by the fact that you attended an Ivey league school. Im am less and less impressed with Ivey Leagues schools every year in general. But of course you had to come here in order to educate yourself.
The only thing about the Quran that baffles my mind is how anyone can recite that crap as evidence of enlightenment.
Robert,
I beleive it is ridiculous for anyone to say that lands once under Islamic rule should be reverted back to them. Muslims need to first manage what little they have before they even venture to make such asinine statements. Besides majority of muslims would never take such comments seriously.
So I really think this is a non-issue. Besides I think borders are of the past, the world is too inter-twined for us to worry about his/her lands. We essentially effect each other whether we like it or not.
Also it is dead wrong that there are no synagogues in Saudi Arabia. There should be no restriction on that. SA government is a weird concoction of tribal arabian customs. Some of their policies are way beyond the pale, and there is no love lost for some of what they preach in the majority of the Islamic world. To put it in context the entire population of Saudi Arabia is slightly more than the population of the greater Karachi (single city) area in Pakistan. However they wield far greater leverage due to the oil and money they have, something that buys them incredible leverage in capitals in muslim and perhaps even western countries.
Johnny O – Sure you pay a “buck” for the barrel, but is that what the free-market rates ought to be? Absolutely not. Ask any economist. Oil prices are incredibly subsidized by OILIGARCHY’s like the Saudi kingdom. They make enough money for the few hundreds princes to run around in their ferraris in Southern France, but they are certainly not making enough to empower their own people. It is an incredibly disfunctional relationship that the US has with the Saudis. We protect you, you sell us cheap oil. Saudis on the other hand have a second tier relationship with a Wahabbi sect; don’t create internal trouble for us and we’ll fund all your religious efforts.
In the process people go hungrey, stay ignorant, and subservient to a few local masters who in effect represent a status quo power, serving their own interests rather than their peoples, however extend their lease to life, by buying the strongest boy in the yard.
I’ll avoid your jousting on Quran. Your belief, cannot do anything about it, however I would like to agree with you that yes the Islamic world is a basket case, and I guess I did not manage to make my points clear enough.
One thing we learnt in the over-priced Ivy education was that there are no black and whites in life and history. Usually shades of grey prevail. Hence to atribute everything to others will not solve our own woes. However for intellectual discourse it is important to point out that there are causal impacts, predominately negative, when you have 300 years of colonialism, erasing of history, minizing the divisive effect of colonial concepts of divide and rule (clans, ethnic sects, races), lack of education, etc. My point was not to bring up the great Islamic empire. That is the past and though not indicative of the present is nevertheless important if we want to build a people with some sense of identity. It is this lack of identity and the forced indoctrination of secularism that is anathematic to Islam (which in itself is an alternative to secular governance). This oxymoronic diametrically opposed concoction is what causes societies and people to be dysfunctional. On the one hand they have a religion that is not a bunch of stories. It is an elaborate examination of how a society given its humanistic tendencies can function optimally under the Islamic legal doctrine. Then you bring in secular thought and everything goes out the door. Confusion is rife.
The last thing you want is a 1.5 billion people living in global ghettos, being policed by western armies. Some of you yahoos might think that is the way to go, but it is just not feasible. It won’t work.
And yes I would too put Israeli scientist above any contemporary Islamic scientist. My point was to counter only those arguments that Islam has provided nothing to the historical narrative.
Then finally, as Americans you live in a fishbowl. Travel the world. Your governments have indoctrinated so much fear of everything. First the native will kill you and rape your pristine wife. Then the Chinamen are coming. Then the black man will get you. Then the commies are coming. Now the raving lunatics with towels on their heads are going to slit your throat. All the while your governments are creating such chaos on other people’s shores. Watch Syrianna to get a small dose of what is happening.
********************************
The raving lunatics in Karachi (15000+) just last sunday danced to the likes of Bryan Adams, while Tiger Woods was just hiting eagles at some course in the “Towel Head” country of United Arab Emirates. I guess they really hate our way of life.
You can stay ignorant, it is truly easy. It is white here and black and dark there. Or you can read between the tea leaves, and live and let live others. That is the only way for the future. We are too small a world for us to have such caustic, angry, views about our next door neighbour. It is just not going to work if we give into it.
Look guys if any discussion is going to start with a basic self-righteous indignation of others, then we are not going to go anywhere. Step away from it just a bit and you might begin to see the truth. All sides.
BTW Johnny O, That cheap oil runs your Chevy Twin Cam. And BTW, another nice anecdote to take away. When 5% of the world’s population consumes 40% of the world’s resources, you are going to have problems. Resource distribution in this world is not equitable.
Are you willing to let that Chevy go?
Are you willing to pay more for those great Walmart goods?
Are you willing to switch on heat only once every other day in your wintery North East?
I would think not.
It is easy to blame others, and this is a human trait, we all do it. But when time comes to look at oneself in the mirror we stand next to a window looking outside.
Hopefully did not ruffle to many feathers.
Finally I as the majority of Muslims certainly think the Holocoust happened. And oh yes before I forget, it was a Christian the last time I remember who was evil one. And though Christian revisionists have come up with some incredibly amazing ideas of how Nazi germany wanted to end Christianity, those who want to consume some wafer of truth know, how deep Nazi Germany was in Christian symbology to justify their evil. That was only 60 years ago!!! Millions killed for a fanatical, germanic, racist interpretation of Christianity.
Continuing on the theme of the holocoust.
So millions killed by the fanatical germanic racist interpretation of Christianity. Strike One.
Millions enslaved during colonial years by predominately Christian countries, openly supported by the Church as a way to spread the “word of our Lord” to the backward dark reaches of the world. Stealing resources comes with the territory. Strike Two.
Hundreds of thosands of Pagan Native American killed, by who? Strike Three.
Incas (the most endearing) native South American civilizations massacred and wiped off the face of the earth. By who. Strike….
Hundreds of thousands of Jews and Muslims killed in the wars of the first, second and third crusades. Strike…
Hundreds if not thousands murdered as heretics, witches, muslims, jews in the inquisition period. By who. Strike…
So before we get on this frothing attack on the beastial nature of these dark people from this far away land, lets check ourselves and our truth potions…We are running majorly short.
Resource distribution is not equitable. If oil was distributed more equally around the world, the middle east was be a faint afterthought in rest of the world’s minds. It has nothing else of any merit to offer.
Hate to burst your bubble but hospitals date from the Roman era. The concept of zero and Algebra come from India. Paper originated in China.Banking and astronomy pre-date Islam by a thousand years. Oil was discovered by Westerners using western science and technology. Arab oil producers are basically rent seekers.
The Nazi’s were pagans and socialists. Bosnian Muslim’s eagerly joined the SS in killing Jews and the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem openly sided with the Nazi’s.
Other than pointing out that in the middle ages that the Arabs preserved Western knowledge most of your comment is factually incorrect.
With several trillion dollars in oil revenues in the last 60 years there isn’t one world class scientific university in all of Islam? Or medical research? The fact that you have to come here for an advance education speaks volumes about your homeland. Islam may have been an answer in the 7th through 9th centuries but today in the 21st century it appears to be the problem.
Kashif,
What I find interesting is that the pedantic attitude you have towards us fire-breathing americans, and then you comment about how many schoolmates attended Ivy League schools. I guess Americans suck at higher education, huh?
As a Christian who does live in America, I am offended by your statement that ‘Christianity is more of a commercial entity than a religion today.’… in American churches, we call that cultural Christianity… not a real abiding faith in Jesus Christ. So, I won’t label you as a Muslim who wants to subjugate and kill any infidel, if you don’t label all Christians in America as deriving an economic benefit from their faith. Because that, sir, is patently offensive, and if your only view of Christians is from watching Pat Robertson or Jerry Falwell, they are as whacked out as the fundy Mullahs in Iran….
Why aren’t Christians allows to freely speak their minds, to be open about their faith in Morroco, Saudi Arabia, etc, when they can be jailed for explaining their faith as you could do in America? What do Islamic nation states have to fear? I suppose as an American, I need to travel to these places so I can be thrown in jail for asking someone if they know about the redemptive power of having Christ in their lives…
Kashif,
Thanks for the input. It sounds like the U.S. puts out a good education. Who’s paying your tuition? BTW it’s great to hear you open up and let us read between the lines.We can see that deep down YOU REALLY DO HATE US. I don’t care what happened in history. The future looks pretty bleak thanks to Islam.
Oh, Kashif, btw…
Even though I may not agree with your view of my faith, and though I would be willing to die for it, I’m not willing to kill you, or destroy your property for your having stated view.
“What people conveniently avoid and put aside is that Islam or Islamic empires were not raping or plundering the Christians. It was the Crusades that first brought to Islamic shores an evil ideology of hatred based upon religion. Ask any muslim to say anything negative about Christ or Moses, and you won’t get many respondents. The contrary is often exemplified as in the case of the cartoons.”
So, does is this your answer? Well, we Muslims didn’t start it, so we’re not responsible for the violence that happened after the Crusades? As a Christian, I am appalled at what was done in the name of Christ back in the middle ages… don’t use the Crusades to jusify the Islamic position vis a vis violence in today’s world. Muslims may not state anything derogatory about Christ or Moses, but they don’t live by the teachings of these two when they state they want Israel (and the Jews living there) wiped off the face of the earth.
Would it be a better position to state as a Muslim that you renounce any violence that is done in the name of Islam? The funny thing is, in America, we do not see Muslims rising up and stating unequvocably that any terrorist activity perpetrated by fringe Islamists does not meet with our faith, our views and how we want to live as neighbors (here and abroad.) And by doing so, Muslims in America are tacitly supporting the violence. If it is indeed the religion of peace, then where is the outrage against these acts of violence?
Kasihf ought to study history. Islam originated in Arabia and spread by conquest throughout the Middle East and North Africa. And no slackers were they in the raping, pillaging and killing fields. Evil as the Crusaders were, the were attempting to re-conquer what were recently Christian lands.
Notice when current Islamic atrocities are pointed out the rebuttal is always massacres committed by westerner’s centuries ago.
Perhaps he can explain to us why the only middle eastern nation with front line science, medicine and technology is…………Israel.
The lunatic Muslims are playing a game of chicken with the West. one that they will loose. Brazil already has an effective ethanol fuel alternative which is now being mandated in all new cars sold in Brazil. Ten years from now I would not be surprised if every new car in the US is required to be able to run on either pure ethanol,methanol and any combination of both as well as gasoline or any combination of the three. the technology already exists. now all we need is the will to do so. Ten years after implementation the Arabs will be back to where they were in the 1920’s an 30’s.
It appears that God has a sense of humor, alcohol will save the West from the Muslims.
For me it’s all very simple…
The Muslims call the shots in their world…
In the West, Muslims should shut the fuck up!
I am European, and I am tired to see how castrated Europe has become… nothing can be done to hurt the feelings of those sensitive Muslim Bastards… while westerners are beheaded in the middle east.
Europe should present an ultimatum to the muslim world: get rid of the rotten apples yourselves, or go all rot in Guantanamo. I am tired of being a hostage in my own land. Enough is enough!
Go US military… send those fucking ragheads to hell!
Am I the only one who finds it almost stupefyingly ironic that Kasihf brags about the superiority of Islamic culture while using his WESTERN Ivy League education to uphold his bona fides?
TomB,
No you are not. I think Kashif is on his way to becoming a fine example of western culture’s greatest modern mistake.