With the anniversary of the war in Iraq (or, as I like to call it when I’m feeling formal, the Iraq Campaign of the War on Terror), I think it’s long overdue time to actually LOOK at some of the anti-war crowd’s charges and give them the slightest shred of credence, for at least long enough to rip them to pieces.
I don’t recall the original source of the statement “if you repeat a lie often enough, people will eventually believe it,” but it’s a fair observation of human nature. The anti-war crowd has taken that concept and proven it beyond their wildest dreams: they’ve chanted their mantras so often that they’re accepted as gospel by their compatriots (I heard Liane Hansen of NPR repeat the two following as factual on Sunday). But as they say in sports, let’s go to the tape:
1) President Bush claimed that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) prior to the invasion, and that was the primary reason for the attack.
Thanks to the ever-worthy Rob Port (my former colleague here at Wizbang!), we have this excerpt from a New York Times account from February 26, 2003 — almost a full month before the invasion:
President Bush sketched an expansive vision last night of what he expects to accomplish by a war in Iraq. Instead of focusing on eliminating weapons of mass destruction, or reducing the threat of terror to the United States, Mr. Bush talked about establishing a ”free and peaceful Iraq” that would…
Obviously, I don’t feel like forking over $3.95 for the full article. But that was enough to find the actual transcript of Bush’s speech, as delivered to the American Enterprise Institute. The sole mention of the threat Iraq posed is contained in one paragraph:
In Iraq, a dictator is building and hiding weapons that could enable him to dominate the Middle East and intimidate the civilized world — and we will not allow it. This same tyrant has close ties to terrorist organizations, and could supply them with the terrible means to strike this country — and America will not permit it. The danger posed by Saddam Hussein and his weapons cannot be ignored or wished away. The danger must be confronted. We hope that the Iraqi regime will meet the demands of the United Nations and disarm, fully and peacefully. If it does not, we are prepared to disarm Iraq by force. Either way, this danger will be removed.
The rest of the discussion on Iraq was on how the rebuilding of Iraq would take place, and his vision of freedom blooming in the Muslim world. And as far as WMDs being found — at least one artillery shell containing sarin has been used in an IED, as well as one containing mustard gas — the latter being one of over 1,000 mustard gas weapons, totalling over 80 tons of mustard gas — that was never accounted for in 12 years of Saddam’s “compliance.”
And never, NEVER forget that no one was obligated to prove Saddam was out of compliance with the 1991 surrender. Under its terms, the onus was solely on him to prove his compliance, and he deliberately and willfully failed to comply. Like a parolee required to undergo regular drug screening, he was presumed guilty until he proved his innocence — and failure to cooperate nullified his parole.
2) Bush told the American people that Iraq posed an imminent threat to the US.
Once again, let’s go to the tape. More specifically, President Bush’s 2003 State of the Union address, delivered almost three months before the invasion:
Some have said we must not act until the threat is imminent. Since when have terrorists and tyrants announced their intentions, politely putting us on notice before they strike? If this threat is permitted to fully and suddenly emerge, all actions, all words, and all recriminations would come too late. Trusting in the sanity and restraint of Saddam Hussein is not a strategy, and it is not an option.
And later, he specifically says the threat is NOT imminent:
America will not accept a serious and mounting threat to our country, and our friends and our allies.
What WAS imminent was the collapse of the sanctions on Iraq, fed by Saddam’s bribery through the Oil For Food program and other means. Our ears were being filled with the tales of the thousands of Iraqi children dying daily because of the sanctions, and the pressure to “ease up” and “allow Iraq to rejoin the community of nations” were growing more and more intense. The threat of Iraq being able to renew its quest for WMDs — which it had possessed and used in the past, both on its own people and its neighbors — was there.
3) Bush lied when he said Iraq possessed WMDs.
First, let’s break out the dictionary on this one. To lie means to knowingly and willingly state a falsehood as truth. There is a mountain of difference between lying and being mistaken. For centuries, folks said the earth was flat. Others said that the sun revolved around the earth. Nobody says they were liars, they were simply speaking what they believed was truth.
Likewise, Saddam DID possess WMDs — so far discovered in far smaller quantities than expected. But the assumption was an eminently fair one, considering several indisputable facts:
- In the 12 years between the first and second wars, Saddam was supposed to account for and destroy all his nuclear, biological, and chemical weapons, along with all research and development materials. Literally TONS of contraband was never accounted for properly, with a great deal of it being covered by Saddam’s “we burned it, but we lost the receipt” excuses.
- Saddam was trying to balance two competing interests against each other: convincing most of the world that he indeed had not WMDs, in accordance with the 1991 ceasefire, and convincing some of his neighbors (mainly Iran and Israel) and certain elements of his own people (mainly the Kurds and Shiites) that he did, and was willing and able to use them against those people if necessary. He thought he could count on his bought-and-paid-for allies in Fance, Germany, Russia, Great Britain, and the UN to provide enough cover to block the US from rigorously enforcing the 1991 terms — a miscalculation that proved in the post-9/11 world to be fatal.
- Saddam’s own generals and forces thought they would have access to WMDs for any possible US-led invasion. Captured battle plans referred to using chemical weapons against the invaders, and several key units had protective gear on hand.
Yes, there were flaws in the intelligence before the invasion. But intelligence is not a precise science. Based on the best information available, and the existing legal state (the repeated violations of the 1991 ceasefire, and the Congressional authorization of the use of force), the invasion of Iraq and deposal of Saddam was the least worst of the available options. And those who wish to rewrite history based on their own lies and prejudices need to be confronted and defeated with the most powerful weapon available:
The truth.

Fran,
Generals see things in military terms. During the Korean war General McCarthy wanted to use nuclear weapons against China. Maybe he was right, but if he was wrong the war could have escalated out of control. If all we wanted to do in Iraq was win militarily, we could nuke Iran and Syria to stop the flow of insurgents and arms into Iraq. We could annihilate any cite from the air if they allowed terrorists to operate in their area. The people of Iraq would soon learn to tow the line or die. Is that what you are calling for in 2006? If not, give us your plan for winning in Iraq that’s substantially different than what’s already being done.
Folks, all you need to know about people and posts like this is that they are continuously defending something THREE years later to themselves.
Yeah- Cuz after three years moonbats give themselves a clean slate…
LOL, ya criticize folks for gutter talk and character ass-assination, and they splash the same all over ya.
Res Ispa Loquitor.
1) President Bush claimed that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) prior to the invasion, and that was the primary reason for the attack.
Oct 28, 2002
“It’s a person who claims he has no weapons of mass destruction, in order to escape the dictums of the U.N. Security Council and the United Nations — but he’s got them. See, he’ll lie. He’ll deceive us. And he’ll use them.”
March 19, 2003
“Our nation enters this conflict reluctantly — yet, our purpose is sure. The people of the United States and our friends and allies will not live at the mercy of an outlaw regime that threatens the peace with weapons of mass murder.”
2) Bush told the American people that Iraq posed an imminent threat to the US.
Nov 3, 2002
“Saddam Hussein is a threat to America. He’s a threat to our friends. He’s a man who said he wouldn’t have weapons of mass destruction, yet he has them. He’s a man that not only has weapons of mass destruction, he’s used them.”
Mar 6, 2003
“Saddam Hussein and his weapons are a direct threat to this country, to our people, and to all free people…. I will not leave the American people at the mercy of the Iraqi dictator and his weapons.”
3) Bush lied when he said Iraq possessed WMDs.
Mar 17, 2003
“Intelligence gathered by this and other governments leaves no doubt that the Iraq regime continues to possess and conceal some of the most lethal weapons ever devised.”
It has come to light since then that there was plenty of doubt among the intelligence community.
I’m not going to get into “Bush Lied!” silliness, but he was clearly selling us a bill of goods. There are plenty more quotes, especially if you count others from the administration.
For instance this admission by Wolfowitz (May 28, 2003):
“For bureaucratic reasons, we settled on one issue — weapons of mass destruction — because it was the one reason everyone could agree on.”
Nick,
Thanks for proving Falze’s point… For anyone to believe Bush intentionally lied, you have to believe Saddam: a)compeltely destroyed his entire arsenal after the 1st gulf invasion and b) had no intention of ever reconstituting their production. Basically, you have to trust a mass murderer at his word (fire away with the bush/mass murderer/take him at his word rebuttals). If anyone can come up with some shred of evidence that Bush intentionally sent 2313 of this country’s best to thier death under false pretenses, I will don my shiniest pink jumpsuit and hop on the first VW van out of the land of christians and inbreeders to kiss Cindy Sheehan right on her pasty white cheek.
Mac Lorry , right on again.. that would be the easy way to physically end these threats. but to mean tyrant,s like Bush ,that would hurt His poll numbers to much and you know how He cares about those.. I bet that nutjob in Iran would,nt hesitate to use nukes on millions of innocent people though… as a matter of fact he brags about it . Scary
nick,
So did you consider it a lie when Kerry said he would be the next president or take a particular state, and it turns out different? When someone refers to a future event most people correctly access that as a statement of opinion, rather than fact. Question, do you know the medical term for people who can’t distinguish statements of fact from statements of opinion?
Being a fighter pilot in the reserves is serving admirably, particularly compared to Bill Clinton’s draft dodger status. Ending the White House sex scandals did restore dignity and integrity to the White House.
I’ve debunked this in one of my posts above. Basically there are documents warning UFOs are getting ready to invade. If it happened you would say Bush lied if he had said there’s no creatable evidence of an invasion from space.
Only an idiot like Michael Moore could come up with something so stupid. I expect you got the idea from him.
We have known for some time that the left has one definition for Democrats and a different one for Republicans. Bill Clinton can lie under oath, but it’s ok because it’s about sex. Bush says the war is a noble cause, but because his daughters don’t join the military, that’s a lie.
All we want is a single credible example of Bush telling a lie as a part of his duties as President. I had to qualify that, otherwise some liberal would cite an example where Bush told his mother she looked good.
Intelligence is a precise science, it just seems it’s not applied to many functions in the good ol’ USA anymore.
Do any of you deny that it was CIA backing that helped put Saddam Hussein in power in the first place, after he served time in prison for murdering his own uncle? That he received loan guarantees, illegally, during the Bush the First administration, for ‘dual-use’chemicals that could be used to make chemical weapons? That then Senator Bob Dole personally told Hussein that he’d help silence a pesky American reporter who kept reporting on Saddam’s atrocities? (Who shortly thereafter lost his job)
I would posit that whatever you believe about Saddam’s stockpile, the current gang of policy-makers, who actually are the same ones who served during the arming of Saddam would be the last ones you’d want to trust to get rid of him. Mr. Cheney, as Halliburton chief, made millions arming Saddam. Think there could be just a teensy-weeensy conflict of interest here?
Or, if you dispute these allegations, I wonder what you would advise IF they were true. Or if this country went to war for what you believed was a good cause, and then you found out the public had been lied to? Or do you believe it’s the government’s prerogative to lie to its’ citizens?
I’m just wondering what you believe is the proper way to oppose “our” government.
Mantis:
Great post. Unfortunately, the Epados, and Mac Lorry’s of this thread are like lemmings being led into the sea by Bush and the rest of the administration chickenhawks. They just can’t come to grips with the fact that they’ve backed an asshole.
The two words most associated with Bush in last week’s Pew poll were “idiot” and “incompetent”. But no, GMoney, Virgo, and all these other right-wing apologists sit on their fat, lazy asses and tell us we should support the president. I think they should go sign-up for the war. But I’m sure, like Little Dick Cheney, they have other “priorities”.
See this from CNN today:
“Has the Bush administration been effective in handling public relations on efforts in Iraq?”
Yes 9%
9430 votes
No 91%
96851 votes
Total: 106281 votes
But I guess that 91% (yup, 91%) of us are all wrong. That darned “liberal” media. Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Any CNN poll is suspect from the word go simply because they are the clinton news network..stinky pew polls do not matter either.. all that matters are election results ! and from what i see you fraudulent vote buying lazy libs are losing left and right including the major so called newspapers .. so keep on losing losers and we,ll keep pointing out your inadequesies to lead or tell the truth… Keep on raking in the buck,s cheney ..make mine Halliburton.
Alice de Tokeville,
See my post on “seasons” above. Basically there was good reason to arm Iraq, so that it could withstand Iran. When Saddam invaded Kuwait it was time to disarm Iraq. When Saddam found corrupt U.N. officials to get around the sanctions and when he violate the ceasefire agreement, it was time to remove Saddam. Each action was wise in it’s own season. Why is it difficult to understand that Policy has to change with changing circumstances?
Game. set. match., mantis. And all you had to do was quote Bush.
You can have whatever opinion you want, but you can’t have your own set of facts. All your examples have been rebutted. With no facts to base your opinion on it’s you who are being lead like a mindless liberal (I don’t want to defame lemmings). Just admit you hate Bush. No reason needed.
WRONG AGAIN jp2, man its getting to be a habit with you.. cant you see there is so much more at stake here than your hatred of Bush !
Refute the points Virgo – when you resort to insults, you lose.
What insult ?? stating your hatred for bush is not an insult..and you did not present any points
Refuting no point is easy. Why dont you quote ERR america …….ohhh thats right they could,nt hold a coherent thought long enough to keep anyone interested..and neither can you!
All this can be summed up in a few words:
BUSH HAS SOMETHING THAT ALL THSES LEFTIES DON”T:
BALLS
I still subscribe to the ‘change the topic’ postition of those who write in support of Bush in this post.
MacLorry is very concerned with someone pointing out a Bush lie…
…Bush himself is a lie.
Oh yea,…”Bring em on”. Unfortunately he’s using someone elses balls…the guys on the front lines.
Once again, consider the possibility that Bush, Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz disregarded the advice of many experienced military people, disregarded the Pentagons own plans concerning occupation and control and ‘blew it’.
A key question:
Do you all think that what we have in Iraq now, is the best that this country could do?
And this is not 20/20 hindsight. Back in the spring /summer of 2003 I was calling for more troops and control of the country through the implementation of a curfew.
Vote for Competence in 2006.
The media is bending over backwards for Bush. This the same media that tried to kneecap him two months before an election with forged documents?
I guess we’ll have to call that ‘tough love’.
no Fran i really dont , a neutron bomb would have been much easier for the ever evil Bush would,nt it
“And this is not 20/20 hindsight. Back in the spring /summer of 2003 I was calling for more troops and control of the country through the implementation of a curfew.
Vote for Competence in 2006.”
Vote for Fran. She had it all figured out three years ago you dummies!
Fran,
So what standard are you setting for Bush and all the Presidents that follow him; that they have to lead from the battlefield? It doesn’t take much thinking to realize that’s nothing but a recipe for disaster. Obviously you are motivated by something other than reason.
If you spent any time learning history you would know that Generals often don’t agree on military strategy. With some like Patton and Montgomery, it was a contest for glory. Others just have different opinions based on their own experience. That’s why we have a President, to make tough decisions when there’s no clear answer. The Pentagon has lots of different plans including carpet bombing all major cities in Iraq just as was done in WWII. Is that the plan you want to see implemented?
This is another question like the MSM is asking. Did you think three years ago that we would still be fighting in Iraq? Why not just cut to the chase and ask a person if they are clairvoyant. If the next Democratic nominee for President is from the left end of the political spectrum, that’s the litmus test s/he must pass to get elected, because that’s the standard Bush is being held to by the far left.
Of course if you have a solder for each Iraqi and have them follow them all day long and then lock up all the people in their homes at night you will have control. Now what are you going to do? Our thick presence makes the Iraqis feel we are conquers rather than liberators and locking them up every night is the proof of that. How are you going to build an Iraqi government when no Iraqi has room to breath?
History shows that the birth pangs of a country are often violent and disorderly, but from that bloody trial a common set of unifying principles emerges. It’s a messy process, but the only viable alternative for peace in the middle-east is the Trinitite option. Apparently that’s the one you are pushing for 2006.
Did you ever notice that when you start reading a post by a lefty that you can finish reading it with your eyes closed?
Yeah i kind of noticed that.. or you can just fill it in with the same old hate speech you would here on any self respecting liberal campus..
I was hoping someone would have responded to my post detailing the pre-war speeches of President Bush, which I believe quite succinctly rebut Jay’s entire post. No takers thus far. Guess it’s too tough to argue with us pinheads.
mantis,
Your points seem to have been rebutted before you posted them. Just more of the Bush is bad because he believed the vast majority of the intelligence, which showed Saddam had WMD. As I pointed out to others, there’s always going to be someone with a contrary analysis. All that shows is that the President has to make hard decisions and why a flip flopper is not cut out for the job. If the President waited until all the intelligence analysts agreed it would already be history and too late to act. What I find difficult to understand is why that’s difficult to understand.
Also, you said “Bush told the American people that Iraq posed an imminent threat to the US”, but the word “imminent” in not in any of the quotes you posted. Did you spice up the intelligence just to support your contention?
I don’t think anyone disputes that Bush believed and Bush told us Saddam had WMD.
Look back at my first comment, mantis. Bush said that but it was far from the only thing he said. WMD was *the* reason for the invasion of Iraq only for those who didn’t accept any of the other reasons. The one thing everyone could agree on? Sure, it was. But just because some people had a single reason doesn’t mean that was the only, or even primary, reason given by Bush.
I don’t suppose you remember a while ago (I really don’t think you pay that much attention to me,) when I said that Iraq was about remaking the region into something we could live with, as a first step and a catalyst for liberty and freedom… or something similar in so many words and another commenter was appalled, “Do our soldiers know that’s what they’re doing over there?”
Zogby, in his “interesting” poll found that 24% of them do believe that is what they are doing there and that 93% of them said that WMD was not a reason they were there.
It seems to me that a lot of people were listening to Bush’s speeches and just tuned out all the flowery, patriotic rhetoric about freedom and liberty and human striving, etc., as meaningless filler instead of what it was, which was a plan to destroy terrorism at the roots. You can take the WMD references and ignore the rest, even today. But why?
I don’t think you’re a pin head at all.
To all the supporters of the President and the war, I say thanks for putting up with the defeatists in our midst. Keep fighting the good fight against the domestic enemies of the Constitution, because, as surely as they, above all else, want nothing more than power, they will use the judges they appointed to interpret the Constitution to eliminate their enemies as a political force.
That means they will denigrate, demonize, and detain as many Republicans as they can until the average American is too intimidated to speak out against them. The terrorists in Iraq and Afghanistan (and many other Muslim countries) work via exactly the same principle. And history is replete with examples bearing striking resemblance to the tactics in use by the MSM and Dhimmicrats today. The Communists and Nazis and fascists were very effective using the exact tactics applied by today’s MSM and Dhimmicrats.
To all the Dhimmis in the comment threads (mantis, bethright, nick, Fran, jp2, and those who are certain that America installed, propped up, supplied Iraq and Saddam against our friends with the recognition that he would one day invade Kuwait, and that 9/11 was a Bushco conspiracy to get into a war to secure oil for his rich fat cat frat brothers — and you know who you are), I guess I can only say that it is better to keep one’s mouth shut and be thought a fool, than to open one’s mouth and remove all doubt.
Perhaps it is because none of you actually lived through the period of time in this world from 1980-1988 known as the Iran-Iraq War, and the reasons Iraq was minimally supported (reluctantly, I might add) by the United States, that you display such a cluelessness concerning history and foreign policy in the Middle East before you were born (or at least before you were conscious of anything except your own navel). The lesser of two evils is still lesser. And the lesser of two principles is still lesser. You figure out who really has America’s interests in their heart. Those who denigrate her daily. Or those who defend her daily.
Where do your words place you?
Subsunk
Ah, good, here we go then.
Mac,
Also, you said “Bush told the American people that Iraq posed an imminent threat to the US”, but the word “imminent” in not in any of the quotes you posted. Did you spice up the intelligence just to support your contention?
I was quoting Jay in the three supposed anti-war points he was refuting. You are correct that the word imminent was not spoken by the President in those quotes, but I think it’s pretty clear that he meant that. The whole “did anyone say the word imminent” argument is pretty stupid, it’s pretty apparent from the speeches during that time that the Bush administration was saying that Iraq was a threat that needed to be dealt with immediately, as supported by the fact that they invaded when they did. If that doesn’t mean the threat was supposed to be imminent, what does?
As I pointed out to others, there’s always going to be someone with a contrary analysis. All that shows is that the President has to make hard decisions and why a flip flopper is not cut out for the job. If the President waited until all the intelligence analysts agreed it would already be history and too late to act.
Well, considering what has come to light since the invasion, it seems fairly clear to me that there was a fair amount of dispute within the intelligence community about the threat that Iraq posed. I would call your attention to this National Journal article:
Two highly classified intelligence reports delivered directly to President Bush before the Iraq war cast doubt on key public assertions made by the president, Vice President Cheney, and other administration officials as justifications for invading Iraq and toppling Saddam Hussein, according to records and knowledgeable sources.
The president received highly classified intelligence reports containing information at odds with his justifications for going to war.
The first report, delivered to Bush in early October 2002, was a one-page summary of a National Intelligence Estimate that discussed whether Saddam’s procurement of high-strength aluminum tubes was for the purpose of developing a nuclear weapon.
Among other things, the report stated that the Energy Department and the State Department’s Bureau of Intelligence and Research believed that the tubes were “intended for conventional weapons,” a view disagreeing with that of other intelligence agencies, including the CIA, which believed that the tubes were intended for a nuclear bomb.
Let’s consider that in light of what VP Cheney said on Sept. 8, 2002:
“We do know, with absolute certainty, that he is using his procurement system to acquire the equipment he needs in order to enrich uranium to build a nuclear weapon.”
and Bush:
On October 7, 2002, less than a week after Bush was given the summary, he said in a speech in Cincinnati: “Evidence indicates that Iraq is reconstituting its nuclear weapons program. Saddam Hussein held numerous meetings with Iraqi nuclear scientists, a group he calls his ‘nuclear mujahedeen’ — his nuclear holy warriors…. Iraq has attempted to purchase high-strength aluminum tubes and other equipment needed for gas centrifuges, which are used to enrich uranium for nuclear weapons.”
More from National Journal:
The second classified report, delivered to Bush in early January 2003, was also a summary of a National Intelligence Estimate, this one focusing on whether Saddam would launch an unprovoked attack on the United States, either directly, or indirectly by working with terrorists.
The report stated that U.S. intelligence agencies unanimously agreed that it was unlikely that Saddam would try to attack the United States — except if “ongoing military operations risked the imminent demise of his regime” or if he intended to “extract revenge” for such an assault, according to records and sources.
The single dissent in the report again came from State’s Bureau of Intelligence and Research, known as INR, which believed that the Iraqi leader was “unlikely to conduct clandestine attacks against the U.S. homeland even if [his] regime’s demise is imminent” as the result of a U.S. invasion.
Now, how can one read this and believe that the Iraq threat was not exaggerated and trumped up? You can chalk it up to conflicting analyses if you want, but it seems pretty clear to me that the intelligence in no way matched the rhetoric of justification.
Saddam was a threat, yes. But not an threat that needed to be dealt with immediately thru invasion and occupation. And this administration knew that, but spoke as if it was.
Synova,
First, let me say that I do pay attention to what you post, I just come to this site in fits and starts and often don’t have time to respond to everything.
Look back at my first comment, mantis. Bush said that but it was far from the only thing he said. WMD was *the* reason for the invasion of Iraq only for those who didn’t accept any of the other reasons.
Well, I would respond with the quote from Bush at the time of invasion, posted above:
“Our nation enters this conflict reluctantly — yet, our purpose is sure. The people of the United States and our friends and allies will not live at the mercy of an outlaw regime that threatens the peace with weapons of mass murder.”
Seems to me he spells out the “purpose” of the invasion pretty clearly: Weapons. Anyway, the fact is that the administration knew that the only way to get public support for the war was to push the weapons threat. Freedom and democracy does not rally most people behind a military invasion and protracted occupation. Not a single speech or interview dealing with Iraq before the war did not focus on weapons. Many speeches and interviews did not mention any of the other “reasons”.
I don’t suppose you remember a while ago (I really don’t think you pay that much attention to me,) when I said that Iraq was about remaking the region into something we could live with, as a first step and a catalyst for liberty and freedom… or something similar in so many words and another commenter was appalled, “Do our soldiers know that’s what they’re doing over there?”
Zogby, in his “interesting” poll found that 24% of them do believe that is what they are doing there and that 93% of them said that WMD was not a reason they were there.
I have no doubt that that is what the soldiers believe they are doing over there, however the question here is how the war was sold to the citizens. Plus of course they don’t think they are there for WMD, they know there are none. In any case I really hope they are successful. However I doubt they can be, though not for a lack of trying.
It seems to me that a lot of people were listening to Bush’s speeches and just tuned out all the flowery, patriotic rhetoric about freedom and liberty and human striving, etc., as meaningless filler instead of what it was, which was a plan to destroy terrorism at the roots. You can take the WMD references and ignore the rest, even today. But why?
As I said before, WMD were the only constant, and by far the loudest, reason provided for war. Fear is what sells wars, not hope, and that was what they pushed first and foremost, to the citizens, the Congress, and to the UN.
See this from CNN today:
“Has the Bush administration been effective in handling public relations on efforts in Iraq?”
Yes 9%
9430 votes
No 91%
96851 votes
Total: 106281 votes
But I guess that 91% (yup, 91%) of us are all wrong. That darned “liberal” media. Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Posted by: nick at March 20, 2006 03:20 PM
Pure moonbat gold, right there. LMFAO!
mantis,
We do know that weapons inspectors documented the existence of tons of both biological and chemical weapons after the first gulf war, which still have not been accounted for to this day. We do know that British intelligence reported that Saddam was trying to purchase yellowcake, a report the British government stands by to this day. We can only speculate on the number intelligence reports that supported the President’s public position because much is still classified to protect sources and methods. To support your contention, you cite two intelligence reports as being contrary to the President’s public position. Prior to your post yesterday I had already disposed of that issue.
Basically every important military or national policy decision involves an entire spectrum of intelligence reports, some will support one position and others will support the contrary. Are you saying that’s not true? It certainly was for WWII, the Korean war and the Vietnam war.
Are you saying that a President shouldn’t make any major decision unless all the intelligence reports support one position only? If so, then no President is likely to be able to act in a crises. If that’s not what you mean, then I don’t see what your point is. Please explain why, contrary to precedence, Bush should have thrown out the majority of intelligence and gone with the two rather weak contrary reports you cite.
You seem to be saying that Bush’s sales job for the invasion of Iraq was over the top. In 2003, Bush was going to the UN in an attempt to get security council approval for invading Iraq. If you remember, he was having a hard time getting any support from Kofi Anan, France, Russia, and China. Pointing out all of Saddam’s violations of UN resolutions for 12 years as well as violations of the ceasefire agreement should have been enough. I’m sure Bush was mystified as to why the UN was so hard to convince, and in a last ditch effort he sent Colon Powell to make the best case, which was that Iraq had WMD, which the vast majority of intelligence supported. Little did we know at the time that key players in the UN, France, Russia, and China had been corrupted by Saddam’s oil money. It seems you want to hold Bush accountable for exaggerating the reasons to invade Iraq, while dismissing the actual corruption that compelled Bush to use increasingly persuasive arguments to invade Iraq. Without the corruption, there would have been no need to push the case so hard.
We also know now the Saddam’s corruption scheme was likely to have resulted in removal of UN sanctions against Iraq without Iraq ever coming clean. We also know that Saddam did preserve his capability to produce WMDs and his nuclear program. We also know that Saddam hated the U.S. Given all that, we know that Saddam would have been a serious threat to the U.S. had Bush not removed him from power.
There is a difference between an imminent threat and a threat. Bush never said Iraq was an imminent threat, but just a threat. It’s a ridicules argument to put words in Bush’s mouth and then says he lied, or to say that’s what Bush meant to say and then claim he lied even though that’s not what he said.
The entire left-wing case against Bush is founded on redefinition of words (a mistake is a lie), ignorance of history, ignorance of common sense principles like seasons, dismissing real wrong doing by the UN, and idiotic assertions about what Bush meant to say, but didn’t say.
Like I said before, give me one real example of Bush lying in his official capacity as President. So far I haven’t seen one.
All we want is a single credible example of Bush telling a lie as a part of his duties as President. I had to qualify that, otherwise some liberal would cite an example where Bush told his mother she looked good.
Posted by: Mac Lorry at March 20, 2006 03:15 PM
Mac Lorry:
Why do you make it so easy to show what morons you cons are? Here’s a credible example of bush telling a lie as “part of his duties as President”:
George Bush on 3/20/06
“First, just if I might correct a misperception, I don’t think we ever said — at least I know I didn’t say that there was a direct connection between September the 11th and Saddam Hussein.”
George Bush on 3/21/03
“The use of armed forces against Iraq is consistent with the United States and other countries continuing to take the necessary actions against international terrorists and terrorist organizations, including those nations, organizations or person who planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001.”
There is your lie. Thanks.
Nick:
Good one. It should be humorous to see all the definitions and explanations from the right-wing about why this isn’t a “lie”. Of course, they will dismiss it or bring up Bill Clinton to try and minimize what amounts to the very thing they’ve arrongantly insisted doesn’t exist – Bush lying. Don’t they ever learn that “bring it on” is always a mistake?
Gee, Mac Lorry disappeared fast after he was proved wrong, didn’t he?
nick,
So where in the 3/21/03 quote do you see where Bush says “that there was a direct connection between September the 11th and Saddam Hussein”?
Apparently you don’t you know how to read a series of items separated by commas. I’ll have to add failure to comprehend English to my list of requirements for the left-wing to make their case against Bush.
I’m still waiting for a single example.
Dang, Mac Lorry beat me to it.
A fundamental grasp of English proves nick’s point… well, pointless. Admittedly, Bush some times acts like he lacks that grasp, but this time he didn’t.
“Including” does not mean “limited to.” Anyone who thinks that Saddam’s Iraq was not a “terrorist nation” — defined as “a nation that harbors, sponsors, or commissions acts of terrorism by third parties” — is even more reality-impaired than nick.
And that’s a hell of an accomplishment.
J.
Nicky , Sorry but your last post does not inform anyone as to where a lie occurred ? what are you trying to say ?
Mac Lorry and Jay Tea:
You are both morons of the highest order. You sound like Bill Clinton’s “it depends on what the definition of “is” is.
Jay Tea, who said anything about “limited to”? Nice try at putting a lame twist on Bush’s lie – yes, his lie.
Mac Lorry, it’s obvious you’re challenged, but read it again…..
“The use of armed forces against Iraq is consistent with the United States and other countries continuing to take the necessary actions against international terrorists and terrorist organizations, including those nations, organizations or person who planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001.”
Talk about “reality impaired”.
Oh, and Jay Tea – pathetic attempt to retreat from your “coalition force” claim yesterday after my post outlining the numbers.
By the way – why aren’t the two of you over in Baghdad? After all, you obviously believe the war is a good cause. Put your money where your fat mouths are.
Nick:
The cons are nothing if not predictable. Just as I thought, they’re unable to comprehend that the terrorists arrived in Iraq AFTER we invaded. But Mac Lorry and Jay Tea never let facts get in the way of the way bizarre love affair with George Bush.
Ahhh , Saddam Insane paid 25,000 u.s. dollars to the families of palestinian homicide bombers and bragged about it !! so He is and Iraq was a terrorist enableing regime..
nick,
Like I said, your reading comprehension is not up to parsing a complex sentence. Bush will have to dummy down his speeches so you’ll be able to understand them.
Jay gave you the key, but you still don’t get it; talk about dense. See the word “including” Here’s the dictionary definition: “used to introduce examples of people or things forming part of a particular group or whole”.
I’ve highlighted the important part. Bush was talking about a larger group that included the subset of “organizations or person who planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001.” Bush didn’t say Iraq was a part of the subset, only of the group of “international terrorists and terrorist organizations”. Saddam openly supported international terrorists by offering rewards to the families of suicide bombers.
Lean to read moron.
bethright,
I addressed you directly yesterday about your nonsense, but so far I haven seen a reply.
Apparently you recognize the limitations of your intellect and decided it was best to just cheerlead nick.
Do you have the courage to stand on your own?
EXACTIMUNGO TOUCHEE Mac Lorry
Nick,
It’s been over an hour since you last posted. When I didn’t post for 29 minutes you posted the following:
I understand that people have other things to do, but you set the standard, so it must be that you ducked out after being proven wrong. Or is it one standard for me and a different one for you?
Yes and since Saddam was openly rewarding terrorists activities, how much dont we know about behind the scenes.. He declared war on the U.S., Tried to have George Bush #1 assassinated, and that bozo that fled the country after the first world trade center bombing just happened to coincidentally be in and out of Baghdad on a number of occasions. But Noooooo way could Saddam have any link to a terrorist training camp just north of Baghdad .. what was it salman pak or something like that.. no he,s just being “Misunderstood ” his intentions areas pure as the driven snow…
Yes apparently Nick has a double standard for a number of things that slam dunk his warped delusions of reality.. It was Bill Clintons illegal war that was not brought to the U.N. , IT DID NOT THREATEN THE U.S. but its ok because its macho Bubba doing it..truly a pathetic display of immaturity.
Basically every important military or national policy decision involves an entire spectrum of intelligence reports, some will support one position and others will support the contrary. Are you saying that’s not true? It certainly was for WWII, the Korean war and the Vietnam war.
I’m not saying that’s not true. I would also like to note that even though Roosevelt and others wanted to enter WWII to assist our European allies fighting off Germany, it took an attack on U.S. soil to get public support. The Korean and Vietnam wars were supported in large part due to fear of the threat of spreading communism. These were real threats and this administration knew that to get support for a war in Iraq they needed to convince the public that Saddam was a real and immediate threat.
Are you saying that a President shouldn’t make any major decision unless all the intelligence reports support one position only?
I’m not saying that.
If so, then no President is likely to be able to act in a crises. If that’s not what you mean, then I don’t see what your point is. Please explain why, contrary to precedence, Bush should have thrown out the majority of intelligence and gone with the two rather weak contrary reports you cite.
Weak reports? You do understand what the Dept. of Energy does, right? They would know better than any agency what those aluminum tubes were for, and they were ignored, as was the State Dept (not to mention the IAEA!). You also conveniently ignore the threat assessments which unanimously agree that Saddam was not an immediate threat to us. I’ll repeat that again since you seem so ready to dismiss it: All intelligence agencies agreed that it was very unlikely Saddam would try to attack the U.S.
I’m sure Bush was mystified as to why the UN was so hard to convince, and in a last ditch effort he sent Colon Powell to make the best case, which was that Iraq had WMD, which the vast majority of intelligence supported.
Last I heard even Powell knew much of that intelligence was, to quote him, “bullshit”.
It seems you want to hold Bush accountable for exaggerating the reasons to invade Iraq, while dismissing the actual corruption that compelled Bush to use increasingly persuasive arguments to invade Iraq. Without the corruption, there would have been no need to push the case so hard.
I don’t dismiss the corruption, it was deplorable. I just don’t think that invasion and occupation was the correct response.
We also know now the Saddam’s corruption scheme was likely to have resulted in removal of UN sanctions against Iraq without Iraq ever coming clean.
We could have done something about that besides invading.
We also know that Saddam did preserve his capability to produce WMDs and his nuclear program.
As compared to other, greater threats that actually had active programs. Threats, I might add, that still exist.
We also know that Saddam hated the U.S. Given all that, we know that Saddam would have been a serious threat to the U.S. had Bush not removed him from power.
We do? How do we know that? Based on all the evidence discovered in Iraq since the invasion? Maybe I missed something, but none of that has added up to a serious threat as far as I’ve seen. Or are you just referring to the threat of bad intentions? If that is the case we have a lot more countries to invade.
There is a difference between an imminent threat and a threat. Bush never said Iraq was an imminent threat, but just a threat. It’s a ridicules argument to put words in Bush’s mouth and then says he lied, or to say that’s what Bush meant to say and then claim he lied even though that’s not what he said.
I never claimed he said the word imminent. My contention is that his rhetoric, coupled with the fact that the administration was so gung ho to invade ASAP, could only suggest that the threat had to be dealt with immediately. Why, if not imminent?
The entire left-wing case against Bush is founded on redefinition of words (a mistake is a lie), ignorance of history, ignorance of common sense principles like seasons, dismissing real wrong doing by the UN, and idiotic assertions about what Bush meant to say, but didn’t say.
I already said I have no intention of joining the Bush Lied! chorus. What I believe is he was intent on taking out Saddam for whatever reasons, and any intelligence that did not support that intention was ignored and in some cases, covered up. What I also believe is that President Bush believed he was doing the right thing and was protecting this country. I believe he believed that Iran, Iraq, and North Korea all posed significant threats to the U.S. and our interests. What I also believe is that Iraq was chosen because it was the war we could win easily and quickly. It was such a war because Iraq was weak militarily (and had no WMDs, heh). I don’t think he started this war for oil or something stupid like that, I truly believe he was trying to protect this country. He just did it in a stupid, ignorant, and hubristic way and had he been more honest, we could today be talking about the great success of Afghanistan, whose infrastructure would be sound and whose economy would not be based on the heroin trade, whose government did not execute Christians. Maybe. It’s funny that you mention ignorance of history, since the Bush administration’s ignorance of Iraqi history has given us a three year war with an insurgency that at present doesn’t seem diminished at all. I think it’s good that Saddam is gone, but I fear what will take his place.
mantis,
I don’t disagree, but President Johnson had far worse intelligence when he used the Tonkin gulf incident to escalate the Vietnam conflict.
I disagree, but only with the immediate part. I think most thinking people realized that Saddam was under control, but that the UN wasn’t going to keep him under control indefinitely. That’s obvious in hindsight, but the signs were there in 2003.
It’s weak because the subject is so specific. There are other ways of enriching uranium, ways which don’t need special aluminum tubes. You have to remember that British intelligence reported Saddam’s attempt to obtain yellowcake, the raw material for producing an A-bomb.
I don’t ignore or dismiss this report, but once again I find it weak because of the subject. I never really thought Saddam would attack the U.S. while he was under UN sanctions. He had the potential of becoming a significant threat once he bribed his ways out of those sanctions.
That’s why Powell went to great lengths to filter out all the information he wasn’t comfortable with. As an experienced user of intelligences, Powell knew that nothing in such reports is absolutely reliable, yet the body of the evidence often points strongly to a given set of conclusions.
I’m sure Bush didn’t invade Iraq because Saddam was corrupting the UN. However, the corruption stacked the deck against Bush, so that he pressed the argument for war much harder than would have been needed without the corruption. It’s that hard pressed case that seem to be your beef with Bush.
Bush obviously thought differently, and being he was elected President, it’s his call.
Saddam was by far the easiest case to make having violate UN resolutions for 12 years as well as the ceasefire agreement. Divide and conquer is a better strategy than trying to take on all the treats at the same time.
Saddam still had his WMD programs intact including nuclear weapons. With no UN sanctions, Saddam would have had billions of oil dollars to spend on revenge. Don’t tell me you think Saddam was above revenge.
It was not about an imminent threat, but about a window of opportunity. It was time for the U.S. to act or withdraw. Bush decided to act.
Afghanistan has a longer history of resisting invaders than Iraq, but that was proven wrong if the invaders came as a liberator rather than as conquers. The rulers in Iran know that if Iraq becomes a prosperous and democratic nation, that their days in power are numbered. They see so clearly what the left-wing in the U.S. can’t.
I agree, and that’s why I support Bush. We must finish the job or this nation will suffer the consequences of failure for decades to come.
While you don’t agree with Bush (or me), at least you’re not calling him a liar. I respect that.