One of the reasons I so deeply appreciate the open comments here is that sometimes, my critics bring up a valid point. (It’s kind of a blind squirrel/broken clock thing.) Other times, they’ll challenge one of my beliefs in such a way that makes me re-examine it — and reaffirm it.
The other day, one of those critics took issue with my support for Israel in the current fighting with the Palestinians. They said that it seemed, to me, that “Israel can do no wrong.” Normally I just blow off such twits, but it got me thinking.
When there is a conflict one is not directly involved in, there are three positions one can take: support side A, support side B, or refuse to take sides. (Yes, there are gradations and variations, but they boil down to those three choices.)
Neutrality tends to come in three flavors itself: 1) “a pox on both your houses”/why can’t both lose, the sentiment I had during the Iran/Iraq war; 2) both sides have valid points, it’s a shame they can’t work it out peacefully; 3) I refuse to get involved on principle/it doesn’t affect me.
Now, I don’t believe neutrality is a valid option here. We have too many ties, too many interests, too much history invested in the region to simply sit by. Besides, in such cases, regardless of the eventual outcome, those who did nothing tend to lose any respect and credibility in the aftermath.
So that leaves us with just two choices: which side should we support?
Now, obviously Israel isn’t perfect. We have had pretty good relations with the modern-day incarnation of the Jewish state, but with a few bumps here and there. Overall, though, Israel has been a pretty consistent friend and ally. And their contributions to the world are not to be underestimated — that hunk of desert (apparently the only one NOT sitting on top of vast amounts of oil) is a high-tech center of the universe, their economy is thriving, and they’ve been willing to share the bloody lessons they’ve learned in decades of conflict with the rest of the world. We now know far more about treating horrific shrapnel wounds, for example, than we would have known otherwise — and that’s a lesson they paid for in blood.
They are also a stable, functioning democracy, with actual protections for minorities. Hell, in some cases, it’s better to be a non-Jewish Israeli than a Jew — only Jews are required to give military service. Non-Jews can do pretty much everything a Jew can in Israel, including serving in the armed services and the government.
On the other hand, we have the Palestinians.
Someone once described them as a people “who never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity.” At every crossroad, they look carefully down both paths to see which will cost them less heartache, grief, and blood — and inevitably turn away from it.
As another person put it, after the 1948 Partition that established Israel, “the Jews took the deal and made a nation. The Palestinians took the deal and made a war.” And promptly lost it. And have lost every single war since. It never occurs to them that perhaps war is not the way to get what they want.
People always bring up the 800,000 Palestinian refugees created with the founding of Israel. But they don’t mention a few other details surrounding that number:
1) Many of those refugees willingly sold their land to Jews and moved away.
2) Many of those refugees listened to the Arab world’s promise that if they just got out of the way, the Arabs would drive the Jews into the sea, and then they could return to their homes. It’s been about 60 years, and the Arabs haven’t kept that promise.
2a) Nor have those Arab nations done much to help the refugees who took them at their word. Instead,they’re denied citizenship, shoved into “refugee camps,” and kept as pathetic as possible for use as propaganda tools.
3) That number of 800,000 is woefully low. There were 1.6 million refugees created at the founding of Israel. While 800,000 Palestinians left Israel for Arab lands, another 800,000 Jews were flowing in the opposite direction, leaving behind nearly all their worldly possessions. But they didn’t sit around on their asses and whine about it. As I said before, they were handed lemons, but they didn’t make lemonade. They started a lemonade franchise that grew into a huge conglomerate, and never looked back. You’ll find very little sentiment among those refugees and their descendants to go back to their “ancestral homes” in Egypt, Syria, Iran, Jordan, Lebanon, or any of the other places. They GOT OVER IT.
3a) Those refugees were so successful partly because their new host government welcomed them, made them citizens, and helped them get on their feet — something not a single Arab nation did for their “Palestinian brethren. In fact, it’s worth noting that Muslim nations have killed far more Palestinians than Israel has — Jordan killed between 3,000 and 5,000 alone in September 1970, and in subsequent months the death toll from that struggle most likely broke 10,000.
4) The Palestinians have repeatedly constructed elaborate fantasies and charades, and demanded the world buy into them. They tout their “historic ties” to the region, but it’s utterly fabricated. Challenge a Palestinian supporter to cite some of the ancient Palestinian rulers. Or some noted events in Palestinian history. Or how it got along with some of its ancient neighbors. For god’s sake, ask them what ancient Palestine called its currency. They will have no answers, because there are none.
What is known as “Palestine” was a Roman corruption of “Philistine,” the name they gave to the region after they oppressed and tried to drive out the Jews. As part of their plan to erase the Jews’ ties to the land by naming it “Syrian Palestine.” It didn’t take, though. Even as late as the 1920’s, news accounts of “Palestinians” referred to Jewish residents of the region.
4a) The Palestinians, while saying they don’t embrace violence and terrorism, nevertheless seem to do so at every opportunity. Hamas stole an idea from the Irish and established “militant” and “political” wings, much like the IRA and Sinn Fein, but didn’t even bother to name them differently. And do a search on the name “Wafa Idris” — the last time I did so, the first 20 results were all about the first female suicide bomber. #21 mentions how the Palestinians, in cooperation with UNICEF, named a girls’ summer camp in her honor.
5) The Palestinians, virtually alone among the Arab world, cheered Saddam Hussein’s 1991 invasion of Kuwait. While the rest of the Arab world looked nervously at their own defenses and made a deal with The Great Satan (i.e., the USA) to save their own asses, the Palestinians lauded Saddam’s move and predicted massive defeats for those who challenged him.
Then, after the war, the Palestinians found themselves extremely unwelcome in newly-liberated Kuwait. Gee, nobody coulda seen THAT one coming…
6) After the 9/11 attacks, Palestinians were seen celebrating wildly and dancing in the streets. It was only when someone clued Yassir Arafat into the PR disaster brewing that he publicly extended his sympathies (and disease-ridden blood in a horrifically-staged photo op) and condemned the attack his very people were rejoicing over.
7) The Palestinians have had many, many “peace accords” with Israel, and made several agreements that were designed to lead to peace and an independent state. And by my reckoning, they have not kept a single element of a single one of those pacts. Instead, they make their demands, make a few promises, wait for Israel to make a few concessions, announce they can’t fulfill their end, arrange for a few horrific terrorist attacks, announce that Israel’s retaliation has “destroyed” the pact, and start a new round of negotiations — with Israel’s concessions from before as the new starting point.
8) When Israel pulled out of the Gaza Strip, some of the settlers planned to dismantle and take their greenhouses with them. Bill Gates (anonymously at the time) ponied up big bucks to buy them, then turned them over to the Palestinian people. Instead, the instant the settlers left, the Palestinians descended on their new property and looted, vandalized, pillaged, and destroyed it. They didn’t just kill the goose that laid the golden eggs, they ripped it apart and threw it on the trash heap.
9) In the latest outburst of violence, Hamas — the legally elected government of the Palestinian people — all but formally admitted its role in the recent invasion of Israel, the killing of two Israeli soldiers, and the kidnaping of a third. By any standard, this was an open act of war. Now they are complaining when Israel is actually returning war with war.
No, over the years, the Israelis haven’t taken every single opportunity for peace, understanding, and justice towards their Palestinian neighbors. But over those same years, I haven’t noticed the Palestinians taking even a single opportunity for the same. Instead, at every turn, they demand what they see as “theirs,” and they repeat that they will get all they demand, or they will fight and kill with every means at their disposal.
So be it.

That’s a fairly accurate description, Jay.
This was my cynical take on their future five months ago when Hamas formed the new, um, “government”.
http://dblyelloline.blogspot.com/2006/02/this-just-in_01.html
Sadly, a few of my predictions are coming to pass. I oughta go into the prophecy bidness…
First, today’s Palestinians are not responsible for the mistakes of their grandfathers, so what was willingly or unwillingly done 60 years ago isn’t a moral justification for ignoring today’s problems. Half of the people living in Gaza are children. The “sins of the fathers” argument is how people make the preposterous case for slave reparations in our own country.
Second, the fact that neighboring countries have been unhelpful to the problems there is not any rationale for us not to care. It is a non-sequitur argument. Clearly there is a moral deficit disorder prevalent in the Arab world, but that does not need to relevant to our own sympathies.
Third, Hamas was elected by a minority of the Palestinians living there. Continuing to refer to “The Palestinians” as some monolithic group is too simple-minded. Many of them do suck. Many of them do not suck. And yes, the suckers are their own worst enemies, but that still isn’t any moral justification for ignoring suffering of the innocents.
Summary — tarring the Palestinians with these broad brushes is the lazy man’s way of avoiding deeper reflection. Israel itself doesn’t do that, and if anyone had a reason to utterly dismiss Palestinians, it would be Israel. Instead, they take amazingly great pains to isolate the culpable Palestinians from the innocents.
Jay, that is an extremely accurate and lucid overview of the situation.
While certainly there have been failings on both sides, only someone totally ignorant of the facts would hold Israel as the “cause” of all the Palestinians problems. Indeed, the Palestinians (and their Arab brothren) are their own worst enemies.
“First, today’s Palestinians are not responsible for the mistakes of their grandfathers, so what was willingly or unwillingly done 60 years ago isn’t a moral justification for ignoring today’s problems.”
When the IDF goes in to blow up some Palestinian bomb factory, they aren’t doing it because someone’s granddad was part of Black September they do it because someone’s grandson is a current member of a terror cell.
Of course cirby, but blowing up bomb factories isn’t the point of this piece. The piece is an attempted justification for ignoring all suffering, including the baby who was strolling by the bomb factory.
Saddam Hussein’s 1991 invasion of Kuwait
Nitpicky, I know, but it was August 1990 not 1991.
And, oddly enough, when we see photos of dancing Palestinians, be it during the invasion of Kuwait or in the wake of 9-11, they’re usually not elderly folks, either.
In fact, I don’t believe too many of the Palestinian suicide bombers have been 70 year olds, demanding justice for their seized olive gardens. But I do believe that many Palestinian mothers, themselves no more than children at the time of the naqba are encouraging their children to become suicide bombers.
As for whether one can use the term “the Palestinians,” I’ve no doubt that not every German engaged in genocidal activities, nor every Japanese beheaded Chinese in WWII. Yet, that did not prevent us from waging war against “the Germans” and “the Japanese.” More to the point, were there some undercurrent of sympathetic Palestinians, one wonders where they are?
Where are the Palestinians who engage in peaceful, non-violent protest against Israeli policies? Where are the Palestinians who encourage peaceful coexistence in both English and Arabic? Where are the Palestinians who denounce and decry the suicide bombers, without the mealy-mouthed “but of course it’s the fault of the Jooooosssss”?
Sometimes, the morally upright are a minority, and the majority are undeserving of sympathy.
Jay, you left out:
8a) And why did those Jewish settlers have to leave Gaza? Because the Palestinians make sure, one way or another, that their lands are judenrein.
The “sins of the fathers” argument is how people make the preposterous case for slave reparations in our own country.
The fathers aren’t the ones blowing up the Tel Aviv bar mitzvah, Mr McCain … can I call you John?
the fact that neighboring countries have been unhelpful to the problems there is not any rationale for us not to care
So who doesn’t care? If you care to the point that you overlook the reality, then you’re an idiot willing to self-delude on the path to self-righteousness. Sometimes caring means letting stupid people — who had stupid fathers and grandfathers — learn the hard way that they’re being stupid.
Continuing to refer to “The Palestinians” as some monolithic group is too simple-minded.
Well, that’s always the case, but so what? A minority of Americans elected Bush — though he was the first to be elected by a majority of the voters in a helluva long time — but there are practical realities which sorta preclude viewing “America” as anything but a single entity. We have “American” foreign policy, not a foreign policy by those who voted for Bush, and another by those who voted for Kerry, and a third for those — like me — who voted for anybody but either. By continually offering up irrelevant discernments for impertinent reasons you do little besides wrap yourself around your own axle, and get nowhere and accomplish nothing.
“The piece is an attempted justification for ignoring all suffering, including the baby who was strolling by the bomb factory.”
…and where did you get that?
There’s “ignoring” the suffering of the Palestinians (who are overwhelmingly in support of their idiot violent groups), then there’s “well, we’d love to do something about the suffering, but they shoot at us when we try to stop it.”
I appreciate the suffering of the innocent Palestinian children, but why should anyone care more for them than their own parents, leaders, and Arab brothers do? Which, by all appearences, is very little indeed.
There will only be peace in the holy land once the Palestinians start loving their children more than they hate the Jews.
Golda Meir stated, “We will have peace when Arabs love their children more then they hate us.”
The Palestinians (and many of their Arab friends) appear to be dedicated to hate, violence and death. I’d like to convince these people in the value of civilized behavior and compromise, but that doesn’t appear to be possible. Perhaps the Palestinians are best left on the dung-heap of history as a bad example.
McCain,
Imagine for a minute that Hamas, Fatah, etc all renounced violence. That the adopted the tactics of Gahndi. That nothing the Israeli’s did would have them retaliate with violence. Got that picture in your mind.
Now how long do you think it would take to go from there to the Palestinians having their seperate state and being able to live in peace with Israel?
The palestinians use what happened 60 years ago to justify suicide bombers today.
But I guess all you wrote was just ” an attempted justification for ignoring all suffering, including the baby who was strolling by the” suicide bomber.
I’d blame the monster that built the bomb factory in a neighborhood full of children, not the folks that had to take it out before it killed their own children.
rwilyrnz, you are basically making Osama’s case for warring against the American people. Associating all people with their government, and associating all citizens monolithically, provides his moral justification for flying planes into buildings.
Jay hasn’t actually stated a preference for changing Israeli or US policy. Presumably he does not take associations as far as you would in justifying the indescriminate slaughter of civilians. I take the piece to mean we should simply not care when it happens.
cirby, what data do you have that supports your supposition that Palestinians are “overwhelmingly in support of their idiot violent groups”?
As always, Jay, excellent post.
Hi!
I guess I’m one of your progressive critics. In this case, however, we’re largely in agreement. Israel is (and has been for a LONG time) in a difficult spot with few (or maybe zero) good options. I find it hard to criticize the choices they’ve made. And the Palestinians have, in my opinion, made a disasterous choice with Hamas. I do feel Abbas was the best leadership they’ve ever had…but he was too weak to do anything constructive. If you read “The Missing Peace”, a book by a middle-east envoy employed by both Democratic and Republican administration, you get to see he was a (similarly unsuccessful) moderating influence on Arafat.
I find it all very discouraging…
BTW – I find you folks to be intelligent and gracious, although I frequently disagree with you. I try to treat you (and everyone) the same. Thanks for listening!
yetanotherjohn,
To answer your question, it would take about 2 seconds assuming that the borders are fairly drawn. There is quite a dispute already over what constitutes fair boundaries, so the answer to your question becomes more complicated.
Regardless, this thread isn’t about solving the conflict. Rather, it is a debate about whether anyone should care when women and children are killed. I really never thought I’d be arguing pro-life positions on a consevative website, but I suppose there is a first time for everything.
McCain:
The reality is that Osama didn’t exactly check to see that no Muslims, no women, no children, and no non-oppressors of the ummah were in the Towers that September 11th. Nor did his predecessors back in 1993.
So, those who strike at us do, indeed, view us, all of us, as Americans and, as such, liable to die for the “sins” of our nation.
More to the point, if (big if) Osama is truly pissed because of American support for Israel, or for our support for the House of Saud, or because we use 25% of the Earth’s resources, that’s pretty much going to mean that all of us are fair game. Because governments are seen as embodying the nation, writ large.
You might not like that, but somehow, I don’t think Osama and Zarqawi inquired as to personal politics or voting records before lopping off the head of Nick Berg and various others.
But what of it? Israel does not lop the heads off its prisoners, it does not indiscriminately bomb entire cities, nor lay waste to the countryside, nor perpetrate genocide. Is there really much doubt that, given the opportunity, both Hamas and Fatah would, at a minimum, make Jews a third-class citizen, and at worst perpetrate a new ethnic cleansing-cum-genocide, if they had the chance?
The lack of sympathy for the Palestinians is due to their proven track record of actions, up through the last few days and weeks, and as perpetrated by both Palestinians as individuals and by their government.
McCain —
“First, today’s Palestinians are not responsible for the mistakes of their grandfathers…” If that’s the case, why do they repeat them? It’s not old guys that are blowing themselves up and murdering Israelis. It’s adolescents and young men. It’s a generalization, but I’d have to say that the national sport of Palestine, by all appearances, is bitter hatred, and it’s pursued as avidly as European hooligans follow soccer. There are no rational, attainable objectives any adult would recognize. Just an endless series of bombings, kidnappings, and rocket attacks. Frankly, I think the Israelis have shown commendable restraint, far beyond what we ourselves would tolerate in similar circumstances.
“Second, the fact that neighboring countries have been unhelpful to the problems there is not any rationale for us not to care.” I do have sympathies for the Palestinean people, especially their children, who are coached in bitter, irrational hatred like a terrorist farm team. Just like I have sympathy for German Hitler Jungen and Japanese children during WWII. Not that it changes one damn thing. You sound as though the Israelis enjoy this sh*t.
“Third, Hamas was elected by a minority of the Palestinians living there.” If so, the “majority” should vote them out of office or otherwise replace them with rational, non-suicidal grown-ups. I’ll bet there were Germans that objected to Hitler’s rise. A few of them survived the war.
“Summary — tarring the Palestinians with these broad brushes is the lazy man’s way of avoiding deeper reflection.” In my opinion, Jay’s article is hardly superficial, but a well-read and well-reasoned argument.
You completely ignore the fact that the Israeli’s military and security operations almost invariably follow aggression by the Palestinians. I’m not aware of ANY exceptions where the Israelis acted without deliberate and bloody provocations by the Palestinians. At bottom, your arguments seem to be that we should have sympathy for the poor defendant who murdered his parents because he’s a poor little orphan boy.
Doesn’t fly.
I don’t understand this current situation at all…hasn’t Hamas said all along that their goal was to destroy Israel? Now they’re in charge of the government, war’s brewing, Israel’s got their army on their doorstep…
Well, Hamas? C’mon. Destroy Israel. This is your big chance…you can blame it on Israeli aggression and everything. You like to talk tough, now bullets are flying, this is your chance. Go, go get ’em, fulfill your charter!
Having never lived there or anything I guess I truly cannot grasp the Arab mind. They sit there, money flowing from the state they’ve vowed to destroy. Water, food, etc. flowing from the state they’ve vowed to destroy. Alive merely because the state they’ve vowed to destroy is too good to crush them like bugs because too many non-bug civilians would also be crushed.
And yet they sit there and demand that Israel leave them alone or they won’t give back their hostage. They fire a few unguided rockets vaguely in the direction of Israel in response to warplanes dropping precision ordinance on their offices and infrastructure. I read earlier in the week about ‘Israeli tanks massed at the border with thousands of troops in support’ while ‘dozens of Palestinian militants dug in and erected barriers to resist them’.
Like I said, I don’t get the Arab mind, the mind that leads Hamas’ leaders to threaten Israel as their collegues are rounded up and they themselves stare down the face of annihilation. It led Saddam to act like he had WMDs ready and waiting for his generals to use (and, boy, weren’t they surprised) in repelling us and our allies when we decided we wouldn’t stand for that sort of thing anymore. It let bagdad bob talk about the glorious defeat Iraq had handed the infidels as our tanks rolled down the street behind him. It leads Syria to talk about ‘driving away’ Israeli fighters as they buzz the building their President is sitting in, probably wetting himself quite severely.
And I think it’s breaking. Mubarek is allowing elections to be contested (slowly…oh so slowly). Women are voting in Kuwait (in separate booths, but you gotta start somewhere) and running for office (not very effectively, yet, but look at us…200+ years and still no women Presidents, barely any female senators…). For years osama and his cronies thought we were paper tigers as, time and again, we ran or failed to react to their aggression, destruction, killing (I won’t say who was President then). But now that people are standing up to the blusterers, we’re starting to see who the paper tigers really are (c’mon out and fight, osama, if we’re so weak and insignificant, why is he hiding after all, if we’re so loathed and weak and he’s so strong and blessed by Allah, rise up and smite us oh mighty smiter, we’re not hiding from you)…they’re the ones relying on ‘international outrage’ to save them…it worked against Israel years ago, it might work again…but it’s getting weaker and weaker each time they pull it.
(so much for saving this for my own blog)
McCain –
Did you just invoke the Chewbacca Defense?
I mean no disrespect, but your points just don’t seem to make any sense to me.
On your first item, if one is not to hold folk responsible for deeds 60 years ago, then why (extending the argument to what seems a natural enough conclusion) should the Palestinians in Gaza have any right to “return” to places within the borders of Israel? Why, similarly, should Israel feel any responsibility to let them in?
On your second item, if folk who share the Palestinians’ geography, ethnicity, and religion, who helped put them where they are 60 years ago, and who have 100s of billions of dollars a year in cheap oil monies refuse to help them, how can that not affect the views of those in the US? If one is an orphan due to slaying one’s own parents, does that one merit sympathy? If those in the Middle east who know these folk best have no sympathy for them, even despite their many commonalities and huge disposable incomes, might that not suggest that the folk may not MERIT much sympathy? If you say the kids are blameless, you may well be correct. However, if a person hurts an own child in an attempt to gain sympathy, might not extending copious help in response endanger the children of many? How is that so different from parents intentionally damaging their kids to make them higher earning beggars?
On your third point, if a government is lawfully elected in a free election, that same government represents the nation. If a majority declined to vote, well, a people deserve the government they elect, which brings me back to point #2 above. Should the US give aid to people because they elect a government freely and lawfully that does not serve them? Should it be a reward-able strategy to garner foreign aid by electing a sufficiently bad government? By that standard, the US may still owe the peoples of the former USSR for monies not given to them during the Stalin years, yes?
(edited to remove Chewbacca url)
“cirby, what data do you have that supports your supposition that Palestinians are “overwhelmingly in support of their idiot violent groups”?”
Ismail Haniya. Mahmoud Abbas.
Look those names up, find out what parties and organizations they belong to and what jobs they hold, and try to connect the dots.
The region under dispute, from Christ’s time to 1948, averaged, according to historic demographers, 73% Arabic 27 % Jewish. Yet Tea’s
recitation of Joan Peters type distortions is supposed to be accurate history?
Let’s tack on the mass conversion of non-Semitic Khazars to Judaism, which constitutes a significant sector of Ashekenazis today.
Let’s also acknowledge that as far as religious practise goes, “Bible Jews” are represented by the once-numerous,now small “Karaite” sect.members of which rejected the post-Christian era development of the Talmud.
The premise is then that non-Semitic practitioners of a religion bearing scant resemblance to that of biblical times –and the dominant secular component of that community–which composed a modest (27%) fraction of the endemic population until the 1940s –should have been able to flood the area and overpower the disenfranchised natives, without long term resistance.
Jay’s history is untenable and so are his political wishes. And if the US doesn’t adopt a totally neutral policy toward the combatants,or simply clear out, it is doomed to losing its already compromised position in the Moslem world.
http://www.palestine-encyclopedia.com/EPP/Start.htm
a more objective history
Jim,
On your first question, I don’t claim that Palestininans have any “right” to land any more than the Cherokee have a right to Georgia. I do claim that the world will be better off, we will be better off, and Israel will be better off when Palestinians eventually get some final borders. And I claim, rather curiously to some here, that Palestinian babies are important in God’s eyes.
On your second question, although I understand your point, the entire argument is a logical fallacy. Those same neighbors have a whole lot less sympathy for Israeli Jews than they do for Palestinians. If you take your own argument seriously, you are forced to sympathize more with Palestinians than the Israeli Jews because of how their neighbors feel. Sorry, no deal.
On your 3rd point, I agree. We should use carrots and sticks with the Palestinians in order to pressure change. But refusing to sympathize when babies die is neither a carrot nor a stick, but rather, it is unhelpful to the situation and also immoral.
My sympathy for the “Palestinians” has all but disappeared, because they do not seek peace. They seek endless war.
It is by no means all of them, but the majority.
And the majority has chosen war. There is no sympathy for a people that straps bombs to its sons and daughters and sends them to blow themselves up on crowded buses or in markets and pizzarias.
Only pity.
I admire Israel for is restraint, for it has the power to have long since wiped out these people. Instead, Israel has been careful to attempt to separate the good from the bad, and try to deal with sane men instead of terrorists like Arafat and Hamas.
As has been said, the “Palestinians” have repeatedly been offered peace but have chosen war every time. Well, then they deserve to get what they want.
It reminds me of the words of Gen. William T. Sherman in 1864. In his Memoirs, Sherman relates the actual exchange between himself and Rebel Gen. Hood and the city fathers of Atlanta. Sherman had ordered the evacuation of Atlanta after he captured that city. Hood and city leaders protested, claiming the order unprecedented and that Sherman was appealing to the “dark history” of war.
After several letters exchanged hands, Sherman finally had enough, and told them the absolute truth: “No one will define war in harsher terms than I will: War is cruelty, and you cannot refine it; and those who brought war into this country deserve all the curses and maledictions a people can pour out.”
If this latest incident develops further–or the next flare up does–then the Palestinains will deserve “all the curses and maledictions a people can pour out” because that’s the route they always chose.
Palestinian children deserve much *much* better because they *are* precious in God’s eyes.
You say set borders… and everyone is going to agree to those borders, eh?
People have made excellent points here and none of them equate to an antipathy toward innocent children. “Why should we care more than their parents or other Arab states” is pointing out that unless those parties start doing something significantly different there is nothing that can be done to really change the futures of those children. “Care” means “Do.”
And no, 70 year olds don’t volunteer to be suicide bombers… they convince teenagers to die instead. Because, you know, a young man has so much less potential than a 70 year old grandpa, so much less to contribute to the community. And Palestinians elect the “Mother of Martyrs” to office for her *wonderful* accomplishment of bringing children into the world and convincing them to blow themselves and Israeli civilians to kingdom come.
Pointing out that *our* lack of care for Palestinian children simply isn’t the problem is just pointing out that with friends (and parents and religious leaders) like these, who needs enemies?
Big Mo:
I agree with you, but the average American — or the average Westerner — would not. The related quote from Gen. Sherman is also on point: “War is method that our enemy has chosen, and I say, ‘Let us give them all they want.’ Generations will pass before they ever turn to it again.”
An earlier comment said it very well, if the Palestinians decided to use peaceful means, they would get their own state in quick order. They don’t want that. They are adopting what radical fundamentalist Islam is moving the Muslim world toward: a culture of hate, violence, and death.
It’s sick.
Hoop, I don’t think that website you touted is very objective. I looked through the subject index list:
http://www.palestine-encyclopedia.com/EPP/SubjectIndexM.htm
and have yet found ANY mention of the crimes commited by palestineans. It is a completely one-sided view of the entire problem (anti-israel). While this view may or may not be anti-semetic (which we have agreed that modern interpretations of such is anti-jewish), it definitely only looks at the problem from the point of view that Israel is the ONLY perpetrator. Last time I checked, Palestine isn’t the side that is trying to get peace, in fact each time a peace “accord” was signed, what broke it was an act of terrorism by a palestinean against Israelis.
From Ken Hoop’s cited URL, we get the following gem:
World War II was a Jewish war.
http://www.palestine-encyclopedia.com/EPP/SubjectIndexM.htm
By which, apparently, the author means that the Jews declared war on Hitler!
http://www.palestine-encyclopedia.com/EPP/SubjectIndex_10of10.htm#s10_wwIwa
Lest you think that this is merely rhetoric, from the pages of the Encyclopedia, we learn:
http://www.palestine-encyclopedia.com/EPP/Preface.htm#pre_jdwoh
But then, the author dedicates his volume to “His Eminence the late Haj Mohamad Amin El Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and Palestine and Chairman of the Arab Higher Committee for Palestine.”
Fine fellow, even if he colluded w/ Adolf himself to exterminate the Jews.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amin_al-Husayni
McCain –
The Palestinians did not show any sympathy when American babies died on 9/11.
The Palestinians have never shown any sympathy when their own countrymen/women/children have targeted and killed Israeli children.
The Palestinians can harm and injure their own children faster than anyone can stop them, and have. One need only review the jihad actions and mantra to obtain confirmation of that.
I can – and do – feel sympathy for the injuries suffered by innocents everywhere.
On your relative lack of sympathy argument, I consider that a second dose of Chewbacca. Those who you offered as feeling less sympathy for the “Israeli Jews” claim not to be of their ethnicity or religion, so there is no basis for such a comparison. And as for “deals”, the Palestinians have consistently rejected all the ones they have been offedred including the ones they have agreed to honor.
If I see that parents have injured one of their 8 children to improve that child’s beggar earnings, helping that child would seem to put the other 7 at greater risk. Thus, the better course would seem to force the parents to earn their living honestly. let the Palestinians act honorably by Western standards if they wish Western aid. If they have acted honorably by Middle Eastern standards, why have not the rich nations in the Middle east who share their ethnicity and religion helped them?
Jim, you seem to be falling off the proportional scale. Do you know how many Palestinians live there, and how many Palestinian children have actually been suicide bombers in, say, the last 50 years?
When you learn the answers to this question, your very human fault to hold an entire population of mostly women and children accountable for the actions of a few will begin to look like pure emotionalism.
I’m going to give up on your “neigbors” argument. I’m decoding it to mean that it is morally acceptable to care more for people who look like you than don’t, which is another very human emotion but one that is not shared by me.
Look, I completely understand that broad-brushed simplifications appeal to instincts within us. It is a way to make sense of situations that are complex, and a way to become entrenched and lazy-minded. However, when that instinct leads a person to justify immorality (at worst) or look the other way (at best), one pauses to lament that man is too imperfect.
Luckily for everyone, the Israelis are calling most the shots here rather than the commenters at Wizbang. They have historically followed a moral path, by and large, by showing enormous proportional restraint. And their path is moral because they DO care about the Palestinian people who are inhabitants and neighbors of their own land.
…while Hamas (who may not represent the majority of Palestineans as you say), who is the ELECTED government of Palestine apparently does not care about the innocent lives in Israel, whether Israeli or Palestinean that get extinguished each time a terrorist decides to go nuts.
Jay Tea, I’ve said this before but it bears repeating; when I find a post here that really absorbs me, it’s usually yours.
Sadly, the Palestinians continue to take advantage of one of the grimmest flaws in human nature; if someone spews abuse (verbal, physical, whatever), but then screams about how THEY have been mistreated by their victim(s), people inexplicably lose their ability to remember who started it, or to grasp that this is the crucial point, and take sides with the attacker… it’s a corollary of the Big Lie Theory.
McCain –
Well, to me, you seem to be teetering on some unrecognizable formation that you delude yourself to be the moral high ground.
For one, every single Palestinian who has been a suicide bomber or who has committed attacks on Israelis in the last, say, 40 years has been a child after the UN resolution formed Israel and the Arabs declared their intent to finish what Hitler started. Every Israeli Jew and Israeli non-Jew they have killed was a child and many died while they were STILL children, indeed, deliberately targeted as such on buses, at teen spots, and the like.
My goodness! What buzz words and labels you cast at me! Your little “decoding” thing I consider simply and totally offensive, but complex, lazy minded, broad-brush, immorality, entrenched, and your pretty little lament on the imperfection of man just smacks of precisely the things you accuse me of!
The US and the West have given the Palestinians who are the parents of their children staggering amounts of aid, much of which they then used to acquire the means to kill the children of others. Do you not, up there on your perch, lament all the many dead children that all that aid has purchased? Do you think the solution is to keep giving them more aid, knowing full well that they will continue to divert it to kill more children of others?
How about when that aid bought land mines that they used to inadvertently kill their own children, as in the recent beach mine incident, and then tried to blame it on Isrealis? Less aid, fewer land mines on Gaza beaches and fewer dead Palestinian children, yes?
How about when they use the aid to create fake films pretending their children died from Israelis and use them to incite their young men/women to go kill Israeli youths and children and perhaps die themselves? Less aid, fewer films, fewer dead that way too.
If the death of a child saddens you, no matter what the cause or ethnicity, it is to your credit. But to think it saddens anyone less who sees that the Palestinians have self-inflicted this on themselves, continue to do so, appear determined to keep on doing so, and who relentlessly use their own children as sacrificial props and tools even as they try to kill the children of others, then (IMHO) you delude yourself and actually further prolong this cycle.
Ditto, Omni.
Does anyone else see a slight parallel between certain Left-Wing extremists pattern of whining and the Palestinian pattern? As a foundation of change, I think we need some real psycho-historians to work on this mess.
Jim, although I appreciate your attempt to broaden the definition of “children” let’s not lose sight of a common error on this thread. Your own words were “The Palestinians can harm and injure their own children faster than anyone can stop them, and have.”
In truth, almost all suicide bombers have been young men in the their 20s and 30s. There have been approximately 120 suicide bombings in the last 50 years. There are currently 3-4 million Palestinians in the Gaza and West bank and another 1 million in Israel Proper.
Painting broad brushes despite these facts is in fact quite lazy. And again, it is immoral to justify harm on real kids, who number about 1.5 million Palestinians, because of the actions of these few men.
Epador, yes, I do see the parallel. Righties tend to separate their emotions from logic. Pass-the-Kleenex Lefties generally don’t.
I can’t help but notice that most of this weepy concern about babies extends only to Palestinian babies. Israeli kids don’t get brought up much.
Jay,
Excellent, concise post, regardless of the misguided comments here of a couple of detractors.
Harrumph!
How much is a Palestinian person worth?
Well, it takes 1000 of them to equal one Israeli soldier.
That’s the exchange rate they are demanding.
Wow.
cirby, what data do you have that supports your supposition that Palestinians are “overwhelmingly in support of their idiot violent groups”?
You mean BESIDES Hamas’ overwhelming electoral victory and the lack of a dearth of suicide bombers?
Regardless, this thread isn’t about solving the conflict. Rather, it is a debate about whether anyone should care when women and children are killed. I really never thought I’d be arguing pro-life positions on a consevative website, but I suppose there is a first time for everything.
Israel doesn’t target women and children.
Palestinians DO directly target them.
There is no moral equivalence here.
The region under dispute, from Christ’s time to 1948, averaged, according to historic demographers, 73% Arabic 27 % Jewish. Yet Tea’s
recitation of Joan Peters type distortions is supposed to be accurate history?
Care to reveal the religious make-up of every other country in that area pre-1948? There has been an impressive drop-off in the percentage of Jewish residents in — well, just about every other country in that region. Ditto Christians.
Arab states tossed out whatever Jews they couldn’t first kill and they went to Israel.
-=Mike
McCain
“And I claim, rather curiously to some here, that Palestinian babies are important in God’s eyes. “
‘To some here’? Who exactly are you talking about?
Name names. We’ll wait.
.
.
(crickets chirping)
.
Didn’t think so.
I appreciate a different point of view but please spare us the ‘Wizbang Hates Pali Babies’ hyperbole.
Hmmmm.
@ Jay Tea
Actually I believe that there was in fact one Palestinian king.
King Herod
Who was appointed by the Romans when no jew would volunteer to be the new King of Hebrews.
Who then slaughtered every male jew in Israel.
Hmmmm.
And what about the pregnant mother of two who was shot and killed, along with her two children ages 3 & 4, by a Palestinian infiltrator while she was telling her children a bedtime story?
I have no sympathy whatsoever for Palestinians.
They have murdered Israelis and, more importantly, **Americans** for 60 fucking years. As far as I’m concerned we should just napalm the whole bunch and let them fry.
Les, I think that Ed’s last comment provides an answer to your question. Do you have any more questions for me today?
McCain,
I appreciate your demeanor. Your posts are thoughtful yet I’m afraid I must take an opposing point of view. I am very concerned about the innocents of all ages amongst the Palestinian peoople. But those who lead them leave little choice as to how to respond to them. When that response results in the deaths of innocents, the blame still falls on the Palestinians. I would include those innocents as well. Their inaction is as much responsible for the deaths of their children as the heinous acts of their leaders. It seems to me, that their inaction is tacit support for those heinous acts, thus, they are, in effect, killing their own children. We, or the Israelis, cannot risk the lives of their own children in order to protect Palestinians’ children for them. The real problem is to end, once and for all, the aggression, which in my view, is the result of Palestinian hatred. At some point, a more comprehensive strategy, such as that suggested by ed, may be the only remaining option for the preservation of Israel’s people. That too, will be the fault of the Palestinians for leaving no other choice. Put yourself in that position. Do you really think there’s a moral dilemma in protecting your children from the aggressive tactics of your enemy if your defensive action kills the enemy’s child? It’s certainly regretable, but I don’t see it as immoral.
You mean BESIDES Hamas’ overwhelming electoral victory and the lack of a dearth of suicide bombers?
Hamas got 42% of the vote. The original comment was that the overwhelming majority of Palestinians support terrorists. That is false.
Israel doesn’t target women and children.
Palestinians DO directly target them.
Some palestinians do directly target civilians, about 120 of them in the past 50 years plus the ones who got caught. That doesn’t give you the moral clarity to ignore the innocent majority (all those dangerous women and kids that Ed wants dead) who do not target civilians. Incidentally, the few who do target Israeli civilians constitute a relatively recent phenomenon occurring within the last four years. Even most suicide bombers do not target civilians.
If Palestine was a proud nation with an ancient history, why was there no interest in becoming an official nation-state until the Jews wanted to re-create Israel? Until they were handed a massive defeat in the Six Day War?
Why do we have no recorded history of Palestine? It’s leaders prior to Arafat? It’s currency? It’s cultural traditions (other than splodeydopin and car swarms)? The concept of “Palestine” as a nation or a people did not exist before the 20th century.
The land-mass of Israel comprises less than one-tenth of one percent of the entire Middle East. Yet, to Arabs/Muslims, that’s too damn much if it is populated by Jews.
If the “Palestinians” were to lay down arms and stop killing, there would be no more terrorism or war. If Israel were to lay down arms, there would be no more Israel. And that is the goal of the “Palestinians” … to destroy Israel.
It seems as if the “Palestinians” have some sort of self-destructive bent. Surely they realize that they could never, ever prevail against the IDF in full combat. I can’t believe that they are ignorant of the “rules” and don’t think that they are no longer making terrorist attacks, but acts of war against Israel, and that Israel has the duty and right to respond in kind. As well, Israel has some powerful treaties in place with the US that promise our aid if they are ever attacked. It seems as if they are committing a mass suicide attack here …
A strong response by Israel is long overdue. Way overdue. I believe the US has done them a grave disservice by holding them back, demanding restraint. The probability that Israel has nuclear weapons is almost certain. I fear we are at the point where they will invoke the Sampson Option, as there are no other options now.
Les, I think that Ed’s last comment provides an answer to your question. Do you have any more questions for me today?
Said the man unconcerned with the death of a mother and her 2 children.
Hamas got 42% of the vote. The original comment was that the overwhelming majority of Palestinians support terrorists. That is false.
Hate to break it to you, but Fatah is hardly opposed to terrorism. To call Abbas “moderating” when compared to Arafat is like saying “Well, Goebbels wasn’t as bad as Hitler…”
If there wasn’t overwhelming support, there wouldn’t BE terrorism in that sandbox.
Some palestinians do directly target civilians, about 120 of them in the past 50 years plus the ones who got caught.
Ah, so the rocket attacks into Israel are immaterial, eh? Israel doesn’t TRY to keep their military apparatus and residential areas intertwined, as most of the Middle East does, so you can’t really argue “Well, they’re in the same area”.
That doesn’t give you the moral clarity to ignore the innocent majority (all those dangerous women and kids that Ed wants dead) who do not target civilians.
The kids have been brainwashed and good luck getting that fixed in that region of the world.
Incidentally, the few who do target Israeli civilians constitute a relatively recent phenomenon occurring within the last four years. Even most suicide bombers do not target civilians.
That is actually a rather blatant lie, but I doubt you care about that.
-=Mike