Robert Novak has finally revealed what he knew about Valerie Plame before he wrote his infamous column, when he knew it, and (mostly) who told it to him. And if Novak is to be given credibility, here’s how it unfolded.
- Novak was interviewing an unnamed high-level source (let’s call him “Skippy”) about various matters. During the course of the investigation, Skippy casually let slip that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson’s trip to Africa to investigate the possibility that Iraq was attempting to obtain material for weapons of mass destruction was pushed forward by Wilson’s wife, who worked at the CIA.
- Later, Novak realized the significance of Skippy’s slip when it started being passed around that Wilson’s public accounts of his investigation — that it turned up nothing — were at odds with reports of his classified report. The notion that Wilson and his wife might have had their own agenda for his trip started looking more and more likely.
- Novak called Karl Rove to confirm that it was Wilson’s wife who had pushed for Wilson to get the job, and not Vice President Cheney’s office, as Wilson was saying. Rove confirmed it.
- At this point, Novak consulted Joseph Wilson’s entry in Who’s Who to determine the wife’s name — up until now not stated by anyone — and published his infamous column.
- Novak then calls the CIA to confirm that Valerie Plame works for them, and the CIA’s spokesman confirms it.
- Special Prosecutor Fitzgerald has the names of the CIA spokesman, Karl Rove, and Skippy, but declined to pursue any charges against any of them.
- To date, the only person charged with anything in this matter is Vice President Cheney’s former chief of staff, “Scooter” Libby (who may or may not also be “Skippy” — nobody is saying who Skippy really is), for perjury. Libby, in essence, is accused about lying about telling the truth about a liar, namely Joseph Wilson.
- Joseph Wilson will not get to see Karl Rove, Skippy, or anyone else “frog-marched out of the White House.”
To sum up:
- The Wilsons arranged for Joseph Wilson to take the trip to Africa on behalf of the CIA for their own reasons. Whether this was to jump-start his career or make a political attack against the Bush administration is unknown.
- Wilson himself began politicizing his trip when he started lying about two things: who chose him to go, and what he found.
- The exposing of Plame’s employment at the CIA was a direct consequence of her and her husband’s actions, intended to prove the lies Wilson was telling about who sent him and what he found.
- Although he has not publicly stated so, the actions of Special Prosecutor Fitzgerald indicate that he does not believe that the publicity that Plame worked for the CIA violated any laws.
- Scooter Libby is once again proof of the old adage that “it isn’t the crime, but the coverup.” If Libby had simply told the truth about telling the truth about Joe Wilson’s lies, he most likely wouldn’t be under indictment.
Now, I’m no expert on all the minutiae of the Plame case. But I think this sums it up fairly well.

One interesting sidelight that falls out of Novaks “confession”, that is aside from the “not indictment thats due any day now against Rove”, or the howler that after countless words of pure wild speculation by the Left it turns out Joey “outed” his wife himself, concerns Harlow “confirming Plames employement” with the agency. CIA policy is strickly to deny, not confirm, in no way to comment on any sort of agency details. So either Plame was at that point simply a clerk, or Harlow intentionally broke policy, which in itself may or may not be legal. What it might be is some support for the “anti-Buah” cabal, opering within the agency idea. An attempt to deflect from their duplicity in getting caught falt footed on 9/11 and the entire al Qaeda mess, by floating the “Bush is the bad guy” rumor implying the “leaks” came from the White house. Nice ploy if true. Kill two birds with one stone. Of course the Liberal media laps it up. Problem is the 9/11 commision goes and pee’s in the cornflakes by exposing old Joey’s report, catching him in lies from his NYT article, and all hell breaks loose.
– Fitz has a problem now even worse than before. Now its clear he knew all this for quite awhile, and yet said nothing. Aside from that if there was no leak from the admin., then its doubtful Libby will end up cinvicted. It would be hard to get a conviction for “lying” about a lie. Well unless your name is Martha Stewart I suppose.
Even more difficult for Fitz to keep Libby from eventually getting some people on the stand, maybe even Wilson himself, in which case the wheels of this Liberal scam would come fkying off in all directions, and knowing Wilson I’d hate to have to depend on his br5and of character and motor mouth tendencies to keep the lies going if he thought he was facing prison time.
– Should be some interesting times ahead.
Did people change their names posting on here? Moonbats coming out of the woodwork. Covert agents do not drive to work every working day to Langley in Jag convertables. Niger is not all of Africa, what other trade could exist between Saddam and Niger except uranium? Does the left truely believe that if you repeat a lie often enough it becomes the accepted truth? Seems to be so. I would pay per view to watch the Liar Joe Wilson cross examined on the witness stand.
Live@9 doesn’t read the papers; or worse, reads the NYTimes. The Niger reference Bush made was correct–ask anyone at MI5 in Great Britain. They stand by the story. You don’t think Rove is controlling them, too, do you?
I love seeing the libs’ heads explode on this thread. You can almost see the smoke coming out of the ears, face turning red, fingers tapping on the keyboard furiously, and then, the only response: highly irrational, nonfactual rant. But rant is so much more satisfying than getting the facts right, isn’t it?
Shhh. Don’t tell Thom that the statute says that in order to be indicted and convicted for outing an agent, one has do know that the agent was indeed covert and has to do it with intent. None of that seems to be the case here and Fitzgerald agrees with me.
It’s been explained simply and at length here and some people still just don’t get it. Why aren’t these people in jail? Because none of them fit the criteria above. There is nothing to indicate that anyone knew Plame was enjoying covert status.
Golly! Joe and Valerie are travelling across country giving speeches and writing books. In the meantime we have a bunch of moontarts screeching about Valerie’s imminent danger and the treasonous people who “outed” her. All the while ignoring that Saddam’s cronies actually were in Niger with the intent to procure uranium. Joe lied – get used to it. They weren’t there to secure a lucrative deal on cow peas. And to top it all off, Niger isn’t the only place they went.
Damnit Oyster!
If you’re gonna go off and get all “factual” on these libtards, they’ll find a new “issue”, and we won’t be able to play with ’em on THIS issue anymore!
Now they’re liable to jump on the “hey man, it’s still a “fast”, even though it’s a rotating fast… that we can have coffee… and ice cream… and smoothies on” bandwagon.
What have you done? 😉
Mitchell,
I was only asking what factual errors did Joe Wilson make in his report from Niger.
As of yet no one on this board or any other I visit, has been able to explain what was in Joe Wilson’s report that was incorrect. All I’m asking for are the facts and then I’ll let the chips fall where they may. I do acknowledge that Mr. Wilson claimed that the Vice Pres. office sent him to Africa when in fact his wife was the main instigator, but that does not change the facts of his report. The MI5 has walked away from there original position on this years ago. Oh, and by the way, I’m about as far from being a lib as you can get. Just because I like to question the government and refuse to swallow its propaganda may make you question my conservative credentials, I can sleep well knowing I still hold on to a healthy dose of sceptitisium. As far as not reading the papers or reading the NYTs, neither one could be farther from the truth. I’ve worked in a “fair and balanced” TV newsroom for years.
I’ll stick to my original assertion – if Novak isn’t going to tell us everything he knows, and who Skippy really is, I wish he’d just STFU. Either tell us or go away. Stop jerking us all around already.
Live@9:
“the report from Africa, however still remains facutal.”
Well, yeah, it does.
You see, Wilson went to Niger, where he found out that there was a high-level Iraqi trade delegation looking into making a large trade deal with Niger. Considering that the two major exports from that country are livestock and uranium, that Iraq had plenty of livestock, and that one of the major people on the Iraqi delegation was a former bigwig in the Iraqi nuclear program, Wilson’s public denial of what he found is sorta odd.
Is just me or does anyone else see some “NEW” poster here? Hhmmmm.
cirby,
First off, thanks for the reply without the tossing of insults. That is a refreshing change from what I usually get when I question the official conservative view point.
I agree that Iraq would have loved to get its hands on the Niger yellow-cake uranium, that is not in dispute. What I’m getting at is, there are no factual errors in Joe Wilson’s report. The assertion used by this administration that Iraq was seeking to buy uranium from Niger was based on a known forged document the President used to build his case to go to war with Iraq. All Mr. Wilson did was to “spill the beans” on the forgery. Again, no factual errors were in the Niger report. For some to claim that the British stand by there earlier report is also false. This is from page 124 of the Butler report:
“Based on through analysis, the IAEA has concluded, with the concurrence of outside experts, that these documents, which formed the basis for the reports of recent uranium transactions between Iraq and Niger, are in fact not authentic. We have therefore concluded that these specific allegations are unfounded.”
This is my faorite part of Novak’s statement:
So Fitzgerald is sitting there with Novak’s testimony saying one thing, and Rove’s and Harlow’s saying something else entirely. And one takes from this that this is “over”?
And Cirby, who are you talking about? All these people who knew Plame’s identity? Name one.
And your arguments that “Nobody’s been indicted–so there’s no crime!” is too ridiculous. It’s equivalent to having a body full of gunshots and saying, “Well, nobody’s been indicted–so there’s no crime!”
And kirktoe, I did go back to the October, 2005 pressconference. Here’s what Fitzgerald said:
Valerie Wilson was a CIA officer. In July 2003, the fact that Valerie Wilson was a CIA officer was classified. Not only was it classified, but it was not widely known outside the intelligence community. Valerie Wilson’s friends, neighbors, college classmates had no idea she had another life. The fact that she was a CIA officer was not well-known, for her protection or for the benefit of all us. It’s important that a CIA officer’s identity be protected, that it be protected not just for the officer, but for the nation’s security. Valerie Wilson’s cover was blown in July 2003. The first sign of that cover being blown was when Mr. Novak published a column on July 14th, 2003.
“What I’m getting at is, there are no factual errors in Joe Wilson’s report. “
Yes, his report.
The one that admitted that Iraqi negotiators were looking into buying yellowcake.
“The assertion used by this administration that Iraq was seeking to buy uranium from Niger was based on a known forged document the President used to build his case to go to war with Iraq.”
The forged document was a very different case, and supposedly said that Iraq had already bought the yellowcake that Wilson found they were trying to buy. The CIA and other government analyses referred to this document as “suspect,” and it certainly wasn’t the basis for Wilson’s report.
“Specific allegations” are very different from what really happened, which was an Iraqi trade delegation going to Niger to look into buying uranium, Joe Wilson finding that out and reporting it in his official report, and then Joe Wilson lying about what he reported when he wrote those op-ed pieces for the papers as a partisan political operative.
To sum up: the letter you refer to was probably sold to the Italians for some quick cash, Joe Wilson didn’t find any actual uranium sales, and he did find that the Iraqis were proabably trying to buy uranium (but were stopped by local officials and the fear that they could get caught breaking sanctions).
As a footnote, most of the top guys in Iraq’s nuclear program were still employed by the Iraqis, in their old offices and facilities… waiting for what?
“And Cirby, who are you talking about? All these people who knew Plame’s identity? Name one.”
David Corn, who actually mentioned her “covert” status before Novak, with much more detail, and who probably got his info from Wilson.
Not to mention, of course, the KGB (from the Ames affair) and Cuban intelligence (from a CIA screwup that basically handed her ID to the Cubans).
The really funny thiing is that people pretend this leak was supposed to somehow “damage” Plame in some fashion by revealing her identity, but she was already public, due to her daily commute to her job at the CIA. They do not have covert agents walking in and out of the front door. Her job was “classified” (which means she couldn’t tell people what she did) but the fact that she worked for the agency wasn’t a secret at all.
Cirby,
It looks like you and I agree. There was no way that Iraq did, or was going to be able to, buy yellow-cake uranium from Niger. Yet, President Bush went ahead and used this false claim in his state of the union address anyway. So to get back at Joe for exposing the truth, someone from inside the administration tried to harm the Wilson’s by outing Valerie. Why? Let’s also not forget it was the CIA that asked the Justice Department to investigation the outing of one of its covert agents.
As usual, Cirby, no links, we’re just supposed to trust whatever you say.
Corn’s article came out two days after Novaks.
http://www.thenation.com/blogs/capitalgames?bid=3&pid=823
You other nonsense about the KGB and Cuban intelligence–do you work for them?
Your following comment relies on your ridiculous assumptions with no evidence, so merits no response.
Bush can just sell the whole damn country to the Red Chinese like he gave up that spy plane.
WHICH President was nailed for taking campaign contributions from the Chinese and had all of the witnesses suddenly run to China when they were subpoenaed?
Hint: Not Bush.
Every Republican president since Nixon has committed treason by entreating with foreign powers to subvert the will of the American people and the duly elected president, and you obsequious little Heathers eat it up.
But Democrats? Nope. They’ve never done that. I mean, yeah, Clinton tried to get US troops placed under direct UN control and all…
Kissinger sabotaged the Paris Peace Talks
This is where “proof” would go.
Bush under Reagan traded arms for hostages and oil price increases
Again, “proof” would be wise to include here.
Bush himself traded drugs for arms for the nun-raping Contras while his children and cronies robbed America’s Savings and Loans and crashed our economy
Wow, it’s funny that Clinton’s best friends robbed an S & L blind and his wife “represented” the gov’t in negotiations to basically giveaway all of the debt to the taxpayers, huh?
Bush II stopped terrorism by giving Al Qaeda EVERYTHING THEY ASKED FOR on a plate-removing US troops from Saudi Arabia and not investigating the Kobar bombings too closely, protecting Bin Laden interests in the US and abroad.
Khobar occurred in 1995.
Bush wasn’t in office in 1995.
SOMEBODY else was, though. And HIS FBI director said HE refused to push for investigations to avoid causing gas prices to go up.
You don’t appreciate what we have lost as a nation in terms of nuclear proliferation human intelligence and don’t understand the first thing about the spy business, No Official Cover agents, or the political agenda of the Bush Crime Family and its allies.
Again, Plame worked AT LANGLEY.
You can’t put somebody into ANY type of undercover work when THEY WORK AT LANGLEY.
Foreign intel officers can pretty easily figure out that the woman who drives into Langley every single day — well, she MIGHT just work for the CIA.
You identify with baby Bush because he is a sadistic, mean failure of a man, who failed at every job his father got him including President of the United States.
He’s “sadistic”? Are you sure you know what “sadistic” means?
Joe Wilson and his wife are American heroes who have sacrificed for this country and risked their lives.
Yes. A diplomat who names his wife in his “Who’s Who” listing — yeah, no problem with THAT. I’m sure NO foreign intel service can figure out who she is — since, you know, Bob Novak did it and all.
A trip to Niger is not a picnic and even Bush I has consistently praised Wilson and condemned the leakers as traitors.
Specifically referring to Agee and guys like that. Nice try, though.
Hey, Washington praised Benedict Arnold immensely for years. He was one of his best military officers.
I bet his opinion of him changed, though, after his actions and all…
I was only asking what factual errors did Joe Wilson make in his report from Niger.
Actually, none.
It’s just odd that his op-ed and his report from the CIA — didn’t remotely correspond.
The MI5 has walked away from there original position on this years ago.
Might want to check out the Butler Report.
And the 9/11 Commission Report.
The assertion used by this administration that Iraq was seeking to buy uranium from Niger was based on a known forged document the President used to build his case to go to war with Iraq. All Mr. Wilson did was to “spill the beans” on the forgery.
Except Wilson had never seen the documents as they were not in anybody’s possession at the time. That happened about a year later. The CIA most assuredly did NOT have them in their possession when Wilson went to Niger.
Wilson claimed he did NOT go on behalf of the CIA (http://next.epic-usa.org/epicdev2/_media/2003forumaudio/28-lecture-wilson-32.mp3) which is a pretty clear lie.
Wilson stated he briefed the administration the documents were forged. Since he never even saw them, that is a lie.
Wilson admitted as much in Senate Intel Committee testimony.
-=Mike
Live@9:
1) Wilson’s REPORT was accurate — Iraq DID try to buy yellowcake from Niger.
2) Wilso’s REPORT was also accurate — the effort failed.
The problems with Wilson are simple: His REPORT was classified, and in the meantime he published an op-ed piece in the New York Times that flatly contradicted his report, and added whole new lies (who sent him, etc.) to the mess. What the Bush administration was trying to do was to discredit him (justly) as a liar without violating the secrecy of his report.
In short:
Wilson writes in report X, Y, Z.
Government verifies much of X, Y, and Z through other sources.
Wilson writes op-ed for NYT saying X, Y, and Z never happened.
Bush administration, blindsided, tries to fight back against these damaging lies.
Wilson whines about frog-marching.
J.
Live@9: you aren’t reading Cirby carefully. You got it wrong on yellow cake. Read the 9/11 commission report re Wilson’s credibility problems. Do you think the commission works for Bush?
The forged Niger document issue is completely different from the issue over what Bush said in his speech. This tells me you are not well-informed, or haven’t really thought this through.
Thom, you continue to miss the point. Are you comfortable with a Republican CIA analyst sending her Husband, with no experience in WMD issues, to investigate whether there were uranium for purchase by Iraq? And then saying that there were purchases/attempted purchases of uranium?
Then, are you willing to protect her status when the Hubby writes an Op-ed in the Washington Times attacking a Kerry or, heaven forbid, Dean administration over their assertion that there was no uranium sought by Iraq?
And then, hiding behind her “status” at CIA?
You really like those facts? Now, does that not make it a little clearer for you, if you are able to understand such things?
“Live@9”:
No, we don’t agree. You took everything I wrote and pretended that it said the opposite of what I showed you.
You used the completely silly “Bush lied” idea, when what he said in the State of the Union agreed very well with what I said above (and what Joseph Wilson reported in his real report).
(I think I figured out where “Lee” is…)
Live@9,
What’s the false claim in the SOTU?? Didn’t Bush say that Iraq was seeking to buy yellowcake from Africa?? Isn’t that exactly what they were TRYING to do?? Where’s the false claim??
Given all the connect the dots related criticism of the CIA and the Administration after 9/11, didn’t it make sense to make some sort of assumption that Niger wasn’t the only place Iraq was seeking nuclear material, but just one of many??
You can argue what the proper next step should have been, but when a guy like Saddam is looking to get nuclear weapons, you need to do “something” to stop him. If you want to know why, Iran and North Korea are pretty good current examples.
cirby, Mitchell, Jay Tea
If it was known that Iraq tried and failed at purchasing uranium before the 2003 SOTU address, then why wasn’t it deleted from the speech?
Mitchell, you make a great point by turning the tables and having a Liberal administration doing what you just said a conservative administration did. Either way you look at it two wrongs don’t make a right. Outing someone’s CIA wife for revenge, no matter how much you disagree with their public statements is no reason to put our nation at risk. Again, it was the CIA that asked for this investigation not some Democratic institution trying to discredit an unpopular President. I wish you would use this critical thinking logic and apply it to other areas of Bush policy. As for the Wilsons all I can say is, if you play with fire your going to get burned. But I see no reason what so ever to purposely go to the press and have stories published concerning our government secrets, however poorly they were being kept. This holds true for the NYT’s Swift program disclosures, as well as administration insiders. I see no difference. I’ve enjoyed our give and take here today and feel I may have even learned something. Thanks
“If it was known that Iraq tried and failed at purchasing uranium before the 2003 SOTU address, then why wasn’t it deleted from the speech?”
His actual words from the SOTU:
“The British government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa.”
Why should he delete something that was true? That all of the intelligence services (ours and others) were telling him, and which was borne out by the actual report of Joseph Wilson (not the op-ed he wrote for the Times)? “Sought” is the past tense of “seek,” by the way, since you can’t seem to comprehend what it means.
“Outing someone’s CIA wife for revenge, no matter how much you disagree with their public statements is no reason to put our nation at risk.”
…and if that had happened, you could have some glimmer of a point. But since Novak said, very clearly, that the guy who first let the connection slip did it by accident, and didn’t mention her by name, you’re grasping at a straw that never existed.
Even if it were true, how in the hell could that be a real punishment for Wilson lying about Niger? A more direct move would have been to fire or demote her for suggesting that such a partisan political hack would do a competent job and keep his mouth shut, not to mention the nepotism angle.
If it was known that Iraq tried and failed at purchasing uranium before the 2003 SOTU address, then why wasn’t it deleted from the speech?
“Failing to purchase” and “attempting to acquire” are not actually mutually exclusive terms. If I want to buy a car but can’t afford a convertible, then my failure to buy a car that day does not mean I’m not trying to do so.
way you look at it two wrongs don’t make a right. Outing someone’s CIA wife for revenge, no matter how much you disagree with their public statements is no reason to put our nation at risk.
Except it wasn’t for “revenge”. Nobody can rationally say that at this point. It was done solely to explain WHY Wilson, who seems horribly unqualified to go, was sent to Niger.
Wilson claimed it was for the GOVERNMENT, not the CIA.
It was revealed that it WAS for the CIA and his wife, in particular, pimped him for it.
It wasn’t an attempt to “punish” a soul. It was not even an intentional slip. It was done to simply explain why that guy was sent when he probably wasn’t qualified to do it.
Again, it was the CIA that asked for this investigation not some Democratic institution trying to discredit an unpopular President.
The CIA has actually had an unspoken war with Bush for a long, long time.
-=Mike
The most glaring fact is that political hack Fitzgerald attacked, harrassed and intimidated absolutely innocent people for years, for no other reason than to see himself on TV, feed his obviously gigantic ego and do damage to the hated White House. This is the clown who should be investigated and brought up on charges of prosecutorial malfeasance. The leftist practice of prosecuting conservatives simply because they are conservative must be brought to an end and there is no better place to start.
On the points I find of interest.
————————————————-
To sum up:
1. The Wilsons arranged for Joseph Wilson to take the trip to Africa on behalf of the CIA for their own reasons. Whether this was to jump-start his career or make a political attack against the Bush administration is unknown.
2. Wilson himself began politicizing his trip when he started lying about two things: who chose him to go, and what he found.
3. The exposing of Plame’s employment at the CIA was a direct consequence of her and her husband’s actions, intended to prove the lies Wilson was telling about who sent him and what he found.
…
Now, I’m no expert on all the minutiae of the Plame case. But I think this sums it up fairly well.
————————————————–
To sum up your summing up. Items 4 and 5 are simply your interpretation. Since they are apparencly based on items 1, 2, and 3, and those items are based on error, then your conclusions are suspect.
Specifically. Item 1:
What reasons of their own the Wilsons might have for Joe going to Niger are hard to fathom from your writings. To jump start his career? If that was it why didn’t he go public until a year and a half later? He went in Feb 02, he didn’t speak about it publically until July 6, 03. How does he profit from that?
Did he intend to damage the Whitehouse’s position? How? The Administration was not vulnerable on that issue in any way, shape or form. The issue was not publically known, and the Whitehouse did not have a position on it. That was one of the few things Cheney did right. He asked a question about it, to get facts before taking a position. Bush did not make his statement about the British reports until 11 months after Wilson’s trip. Do you claim Wilson was so politically astute he predicted Bush would run with that 11 months after he said it was not good intel? If so,
Joe Wilson is so bright he should be secretary of state, instead of Condi Rice. If not, then there was no such motive even possible. BTW, Wilson’s trip and report provided protection for the Bush administration, not damage, had they chosen to use it.
As to point two. On July 6, 2003 the NYT published an op-ed by Joe Wilson, in which he said the *CIA* sent him to Niger. He correctly stated that Dick Cheney asked a question of the CIA that eventually led to his trip, but he did *NOT* say Cheney sent him. Further, in later interviews he made it absolutely clear he believed Cheney did not know he went.
I have looked for any journalist who said, before that op-ed was published, that Wilson claimed Cheney sent him. I have not yet found one. The earliest I have found a journalist saying that was on July 6, after the op-ed was out, when Dana Bash stood outside the Whitehouse, after an administration briefing, and made that claim. Every single reporter I have found who said Wilson made such a claim was after July 6, 2003. At that time Wilson had made his statement clearly, and in print. Any error after that time is on the reporter, not Wilson.
So, do you have any reporter saying Wilson claimed Cheney ordered, or even requested, Wilson to go to Niger? If not, then please so state.
As to point 3, if you can’t back up points 1 and 2, then point 3 falls by default.
I await your evidence to back up the accusations against Wilson.
bob klahn
Attn Mitchell
Live@9: you aren’t reading Cirby carefully. You got it wrong on yellow cake. Read the 9/11 commission report re Wilson’s credibility problems. Do you think the commission works for Bush?
AAMOF… YES!
The forged Niger document issue is completely different from the issue over what Bush said in his speech. This tells me you are not well-informed, or haven’t really thought this through.
Not it is not completely different. Both the State Dept and Bush’s then press secretary, Ari Fleischer, said it was the Niger report that was the source for Bush’s comments.
“Did he intend to damage the Whitehouse’s position? How? “
Well, for starters, there’s the whole “reported one thing in his official report, and turned around and lied about it in his New York Times op-ed” thing.
The facts say that Plame wasn’t covert, except maybe on some piece of paper nobody cared about, and that in the real world, too many people knew she was a formerly-covert CIA operative with a blown cover.
That piece of paper that nobody cares about is enough to make it illegal to reveal her identity.
And put some names on the people who knew she was a formerly covert CIA operative, and let them come forward and be questioned on it.
He neighbors didn’t know it. Joe’s family didn’t know it. It was covert.
The facts say that Plame wasn’t covert, except maybe on some piece of paper nobody cared about, and that in the real world, too many people knew she was a formerly-covert CIA operative with a blown cover.
That piece of paper that nobody cares about is enough to make it illegal to reveal her identity.
And put some names on the people who knew she was a formerly covert CIA operative, and let them come forward and be questioned on it.
He neighbors didn’t know it. Joe’s family didn’t know it. It was covert.
Uh… Cirby…
Three points.
I don’t recall anyone saying it was a large trade deal.
When was the Ambassador to the Vatican a bigwig in the Iraqi nuclear program?
Aside from the fact that Niger only has a few exports, has it ever occured to anyone on the right to ask, just what does Niger *IMPORT*?
(Hint… the same thing Iraq exports.)
Live@9:
“the report from Africa, however still remains facutal.”
Well, yeah, it does.
You see, Wilson went to Niger, where he found out that there was a high-level Iraqi trade delegation looking into making a large trade deal with Niger. Considering that the two major exports from that country are livestock and uranium, that Iraq had plenty of livestock, and that one of the major people on the Iraqi delegation was a former bigwig in the Iraqi nuclear program, Wilson’s public denial of what he found is sorta odd.
attn: Raymond Benson
It wasn’t Plame’s name that was classified, it was her position with the CIA.
BTW, the intelligence identities protection act does not say an agent’s name must be revealed to constitute a crime, it says the agent’s identity.
attn: Raymond Benson
It wasn’t Plame’s name that was classified, it was her position with the CIA.
BTW, the intelligence identities protection act does not say an agent’s name must be revealed to constitute a crime, it says the agent’s identity.
“When was the Ambassador to the Vatican a bigwig in the Iraqi nuclear program?”
There was more than one person on the trade delegation. Even though the Ambassador denies anything about the uranium purchase attempts, he also claims that he didn’t know that Niger didn’t sell uranium (even though Niger was Iraq’s major supplier back in the previous nuke program).
“You see, Wilson went to Niger, where he found out that there was a high-level Iraqi trade delegation looking into making a large trade deal with Niger.”
…and where he was told by his contacts that the Iraqis were looking at buying uranium since there wasn’t anything else in Niger that Iraq needed to buy. No manufacturing, no strategic materials, no food, nothing at all.
It’s like a paroled felon getting caught in a crack house, and telling the police that he was looking for a bottle of beer.
attn: Raymond Benson
It wasn’t Plame’s name that was classified, it was her position with the CIA.
BTW, the intelligence identities protection act does not say an agent’s name must be revealed to constitute a crime, it says the agent’s identity.
The woman who helped WRITE the law, on day one, said nothing here remotely comes close enough to even qualify as a crime under the law.
Again, a “covert” again working at Langley for years is not covert.
-=Mike
attn: Bob Klahn
Novak reported she was a CIA agent, starting this whole affair. Prior to that, her husband told the
world (or a least the readership of Who’s Who) that
she was a CIA agent. If she was covert, then he
first exposed her, since Novak found the entry in
an existing copy of Who’s Who.
Bob Novak has stated:
“I have revealed Rove’s name because his attorney has divulged the substance of our conversation, though in a form different from my recollection. I have revealed Harlow’s name because he has publicly disclosed his version of our conversation, which also differs from my recollection.”
Tell me if I’m wrong here, either Novak is lying or Rove and Harlow are lying. They all can’t be telling the truth, can they?
Clearly not, as Fitz hasn’t decided to press charges.
-=Mike
Live@9 (and Cirby):
Through your conversation with Cirby, you both are so close to breaking through all the political FUD and understanding what the conservatives have been saying about this all along. Finally, the government has caught up to the internet in progress of discussion about the whole affair. You can see that some of the things you think were true about Wilson’s side of the argument weren’t, and also a lot of the things you think were true about conservatives side aren’t true either. Your conversation is almost a model for the something that anyone could read and understand what’s going on in this affair.
And civil to boot! Honestly, this is a rarity in the blogosphere.
There is so much misinformation in some of these posts, and plain misunderstanding, that it would take way too long for me to go through it. It is obviously easier to type than it is to read with some of the libs.
You are left in the unenviable position of defending a liar per the bipartisan 9-11 Commission. And, you are concerned over something that was not illegal–the uncovering of the source of the Wilson slander/libel.
If this is what passes for critical thinking on the left, we have many good years ahead in the Rep. party.
Geez.
Yes
Of course the whole thing does fall down one one major point.
Wilson was telling the truth after all.
Denial is a splendid thing of course.
Oddly enough, this doesn’t make this presidency anything but the worst in history still.
Read the approval ratings and weap you idiots.
Even without any real opposition this admin is dissapearing up it’s own bum.
Tell us again how the mission in Iraq is accomplished.
Actually it needs to be said. How can you clowns be so gullible as you are? One thing which has never even occurred to the RW circle jerkers. Iraq has a vey significant amount of Uranium of its own. Why would they evere have worried about buying it from Niger?
This is why everyone who actually knows anything and can think independantly, knew all along that Hussein never even atempted to buy Niger Yellowcake.
Iraq is in a position to export, not import Uranium Ore. At least it was until it was illegally invaded and the country laid waste on the back of a bunch of proven lies.
Idiots!
“Of course the whole thing does fall down one one major point.
Wilson was telling the truth after all.”
Well, he was telling the truth to the official folks. You know, the part where he said that Iraq was trying to buy uranium from Ghana, but failed.
He lied to people like you, when he claimed the opposite (in a forum where he couldn’t be charged with falsifying testimony).
And you didn’t notice, even after we pointed it out. Several times.
“Iraq has a vey significant amount of Uranium of its own.”
Acually, that’s exactly the opposite of the truth.
If they had any significant deposits, they wouldn’t have had to buy that uranium from anyone else the first couple of times they tried to build nukes. The tiny bit they had was trace amounts out of things like gravel mining, and was nothing like what you need for any sort of nontrivial nuclear program. Ounces instead of tons.
Now, Iran has some uranium deposits, but nothing like what’s found in Niger.
attn Cirby
The significant amount of uranium of it’s own is hundreds of tons of yellow cake, not uranium ore. And it was left over from their previous nuclear work. Remember, Iraq does have a uranium mine, and did have a reactor program. After the reactor was blown up by Israel they had nothing to use the yellow cake for.
So, yes, Iraq had hundreds of tons of yellow cake, as per the CIA report on the Niger issue.
attn Raymond Benson:
I have never seen where Novak claimed to have found Valerie Wilson’s employment at the CIA in Who’s Who. I do recall reading that his entry listed his wife as employed at the front company.
Ah, I just rechecked on Novak’s recent column. He said he found her name in JW’s Who’s Who entry.
Bob Klahn
I posted in my first post the following:
Columnist Robert Novak revealed that he discovered Valerie Plame’s identity from her husband’s — Joe Wilson’s — entry in “Who’s Who in American,” in which he mentions her position with the CIA.
I do not know which year’s Who’s Who he used, so I
cannot verify if it does or does not say that.
Two points:
It seems a strange place to mention her CIA job.
It would be strange if Novak would lie about
something so easily disproved.
Raymond Benson,
Columnist Robert Novak revealed that he discovered Valerie Plame’s identity from her husband’s — Joe Wilson’s — entry in “Who’s Who in American,” in which he mentions her position with the CIA.
Where does Novak say Wilson mentioned Valerie’s position with the CIA in who’s who? Not in the July 10 06 column. Here is what he had to say on that.
————————————————-
Following my interview with the primary source, I sought out the secondadministration official and the CIA spokesman for confirmation. I learned Valerie Plame’s name from Joe Wilson’s entry in “Who’s Who in America.”
————————————————
There is no mention of her position with the CIA being in who’s who.
In Novak’s July 14 03 column, the one that blew Plame’s cover, there is no mention of Who’s who at all.
In his Oct 1 03 column he says only that her name appears in who’s who.
If you have any column by Novak where he say’s Plame’s position with the CIA is mentioned in who’s who, please give a link to it.
Her position appearing in who’s who is such an obvious breach I do not believe it could be there and not used by Libby’s lawyers in his defense. Therefor, I conclude the belief that Plame’s position with the CIA appearing in Wilson’s who’s who entry is erroneous.
Cirby:
You have heard of discovery, haven’t you? If your commentary below were true Libby’s lawyers could blow it all out of the water, simply by putting Wilson under oath, and questioning him about this.
The fact that they haven’t is very strong evidence the attacks on Wilson are not based on fact.
It would appear Wilson was telling the truth after all.
————————————————-
“Of course the whole thing does fall down one one major point.
Wilson was telling the truth after all.”
Well, he was telling the truth to the official folks. You know, the part where he said that Iraq was trying to buy uranium from Ghana, but failed.
He lied to people like you, when he claimed the opposite (in a forum where he couldn’t be charged with falsifying testimony).
And you didn’t notice, even after we pointed it out. Several times.
Posted by: cirby at July 12, 2006 09:10 PM
Bob Klahn
Here is my source for the statement that Wilson’s
Who’s Who bio mentions his wife’s CIA job:
http://www.theconservativevoice.com/article/16032.html