Valerie Plame has just filed a lawsuit in US District Court against VP Dick Cheney, Karl Rove, and Lewis Libbey claiming that they conspired to ruin her carreer.
The CIA officer whose identity was leaked to reporters sued Vice President Dick Cheney, his former top aide and presidential adviser Karl Rove on Thursday, accusing them and other White House officials of conspiring to destroy her career.
In a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court, Valerie Plame and her husband, Joseph Wilson, a former U.S. ambassador, accused Cheney, Rove and I. Lewis “Scooter” Libby of revealing Plame’s CIA identity in seeking revenge against Wilson for criticizing the Bush administration’s motives in Iraq.
Rumors of a lawsuit were flying several months ago.
I quoted Ed Lasky in my post about the rumor since he didn’t think it would happen because Wilson/Plame weren’t stupid enough to subject themselves to the rigors of discovery:
Wilson would have to be really dumb to expose himself and his wife to the rigors of discovery in a civil action. I have always wondered how two civil servants were able to afford an expensive home in one of Washington’s finest neighborhoods, for example. Wilson has gotten kid glove treatment from the press. He may just be stupid enough to expose himself to an adversary equipped with subpoena power.
I guess so.
Update: John Podhoretz can ‘t wait:
Oh, thank you, thank you, thank you, Valerie. Because, you see, if the suit is summarily dismissed, she and Joe will be laughingstocks. And if it goes any further, Dick and Karl and Scooter will have the right to do discovery — and then, I believe, Val ‘n’ Joe will reap the whirlwind.
Update II: Greg Tinti at Outside the Beltway comments:
According to Wilsons’ lawyer, “this lawsuit concerns the intentional and malicious exposure by senior officials of the federal government of [Plame].” And, despite the lower burden of proof in a civil case, there still hasn’t been one shred of evidence that indicates an “intentional and malicious” effort by anyone to specifically “out” Plame.
Lorie adds: I think we have a big promotional move here. Has the movie been cast yet? The thought of all the facts coming out in a court of law is something that I find quite delicious, but something I would be surprised to see. This is all about having a forum in which to repeat the Plame-Wilson accusations against the Bush administration. Since they stand in stark contrast to all the facts coming out this week, the mainstream media coverage should be especially interesting to watch. For those who have not been following the story this week, Wizbang has had the best coverage in the blogosphere. See here, here, here, here, here and here for a primer.

These people are looney and yet this is a very clever lawsuit. The VP has NO chance of winning anything in a DC court…
I guess she doesn’t want to take full credit for her own actions and wants to share, huh?
They’ve already shown themselves stupid enough (sending husband on trip/publishing in NYT/Vanity Fair, etc).
For one to be found guilty of a civil conspiracy, wouldn’t there need to be PROOF of an actual conspiracy???
Where is the proof, besides Mr. and Mrs. Plame whining about themselves???
I’m not sure what the grounds are for filing a lawsuit. She had already given up her career as a secret agent. She had a desk job at Langley. She wasn’t fired, she’s the one who quit. She ‘could’ allege constructive discharge (I was forced to quit), but since she was a hero to the anti-bush CIA, it’s unlikely anybody there gave her a hard enough time to make her quit. And, in any event, I can’t imagine that CIA staff enjoy a whole lot of civil service protections… they serve (or ought to serve) at the pleasure of the powers-that-be… and if the powers that be wanted her gone, so be it.
I call Joe Wilson to the stand … case dismissed.
Fizzzzmassss needs something to stay afloat.
Why isn’t Novak named in the suit? He was the one who leaked her name to the world.
An obvious attempt to keep a non-story going.
Lol, even before the debating of the case in court, you ring-winger already made final verdict. lol
Does US need a court system at all?
Lol, even before the debating of the case in court, you ring-winger already made final verdict. lol
Does US need a court system at all?
PS: At least Chris Mathews will have something to smile about tonight! Not that anyone will be watching.
Couldn’t this result in Wilson being charged with lying to congress and Plame being indicted for hiring a totally unqualified relative? Actually hyping an unqualified relative be put one the government payroll.
Somewhere in history I remember that both of these actions are considered criminal, not civil, actions. Lets see, criminal actions vs unfounded and unprovable civil actions. Who loses. Think the Federal prison system has kept Martha’s cell clean?
Joe & Valerie must have seen a downturn in the number of invites to Lefty soirees and weekends with Graydon Carter in The Hamptons. Hence the lawsuit and it’s charge that anyone other than Joe & Valerie’s loose lips caused her career (what it was following her decision to become a mother at 40+) to decline.
The whole affair has been the greatest thing to happen to their social lives, as hostesses in DC (google Sally Quinn’s comments on L’Affaire de Plame) had found Joe Wilson a boorish braggart until he became a tool for injuring Bush, Rove, Cheney et al. Seeing themselves as victims has probably brought them together closer than ever before.
The pathology of these two could provide great fodder for a PsyD dissertation, if anyone was brave enough to do it!
“Lol, even before the debating of the case in court, you ring-winger already made final verdict. lol
Does US need a court system at all?”
You mean the same way liberals handed down verdicts on Cheney and Rove in regards to Plame’s outing?
Why is it that EVERY TIME lefties lose, they file lawsuits?
;^)
langtry and tarheelcon get top honors. Double touche.
What are Ms. Plame’s damages, pray tell? Too much publicity? Being forced onto the cover of Vanity (yes, indeed) Fair?
What are the correct terms for Wilson–a “dandy,” “fop,” “narcissus,” “peacock,” “poseur,” “poser.”
Wow, I just realized this extends to most of the Democrats currently in ascendancy.
This should be big news leading into the ’08 elections — you can expect White House attempts to block subpeonas — we’ll no doubt see AG Gonzales arguing that Cheney can’t be required to testify — our nation will look on in horror as the story unfolds, nightly, in the news.
and Wilson was right – the adminstration did lie. Got them on “motive” as well.
Ouch, this is gonna leave a mark, Republicans.
I think Lee just had a wet dream.
Icky.
Keep dreaming, Lee. The only thing you are right about is that there’s going to be a mark left….either on Wilson, if the suit goes all the way, or on the nutroots, if it gets tossed.
After all that’s been revealed this week, do you honestly think that Rove or Cheney (let alone Republicans) are scared of this meaningless lawsuit? Come on.
This should be big news leading into the ’08 elections
I’m sure you mean ’06. And that is the only reason why they are doing this, the ’06 elections. This is nothing more than a political ploy to influence the elections, lawsuit probably won’t go much further after them.
Having practiced in Federal Court, I might remind some of the nutjobs (that’s you, Lee) that a Federal Judge isn’t going to screw around with a law suit. It won’t be the O.J. case; most Fed. Judges would probably be peeved that the docket is going to get clogged up with this garbage.
He’ll not waste any time dismissing a cause of action if there is no evidence to back it up. And there is none that we’ve seen to date.
Oh, and discovery works both ways; I can guarantee you that the defense attorneys are going to ask for anything and everything pertaining to CIA leaks/involvement as well as NYTimes involvement. And all those Wilsonian inconsistencies and untruths will be used against the Fop.
J.R. – Lawsuits don’t come to trial that quickly – this will drag on into 07 and 08. Expect a couple years of pain from this.
his will drag on into 07 and 08. Expect a couple years of pain from this.
And Lee gets an erection a cat couldn’t scratch, LOL
If Lee thinks this will be painful, I suspect he is just being plain hopeful. Cheney is not a poor man. He will hire a top notch team of lawyers, write the check and sleep soundly at night.
The Wilsons, on the other hand, will most likely be the ones to get smacked. Unlike the Grand Jury where only one side gets to ask the questions, The other side gets to ask questions too and me thinks the Wilsions might not like some of the answers they have to give.
VW
Lorie adds: “For those who have not been following the story this week, Wizbang has had the best coverage in the blogosphere. See here, here, here, here, here and here for a primer.”
Including Paul’s pathetic posts as examples of “coverage” is hilarious. His childish vocalization of his anger towards the MSM (apparently Paul tried to get a job as legitimate journalist and failed, hence the axe he grinds constantly against the evil MSM), and his repeated deletion of comments that prove him wrong, barely qualify his posts as “fish wrap”, much less “coverage”.
Yeeeeehawwww!
It’s early morning. The stench of a bed unmade for days hangs in the air. Valerie turns over slowly, so as not to wake Joe. Even so, raising the blanket rolls the empty bottle of vodka to the edge of the bed where it hesitates, as though daring Valerie to catch it before it falls.
This morning was no different from the mornings of the past year following the trial. Not yet able to stand erect, she could no more have caught that bottle than she could fly. The empty vessel disappeared from sight and landed with a gentle thud upon the lightly stained cheap pile carpet.
How fortunate, thought Valerie. Had this been the old townhouse, the bottle would surely have broken on the hardwood floor.
Valerie mused over the warning she once received- that it is costly to lose.
Oh damn, forgot the mandatory gun-fire. Yeeeehaawwwww !
*BANG BANG BANG*
Hey Lee, try me.
You’re clueless.
They filed suit after Novak’s statements? Yeah, he said Rove confirmed she worked at the CIA – but then, the CIA also confirmed it. This is a secret? And the name Plame he got from the Who’s Who entry – written by the Wilsons!
Plame filed suit after they were told — as Novak recently confirmed — that the investigation had been completed.
The fact that Novak lied puts Cheney in the uncomfortable position of having to confirm or deny, but probably wasn’t a factor in the timing of the lawsuit.
The republicans are really over a barrel now.
Lee has a very active fantasy life, as you can see.
Mitchell said: “Having practiced in Federal Court, I might remind some of the nutjobs (that’s you, Lee) that a Federal Judge isn’t going to screw around with a law suit. It won’t be the O.J. case; most Fed. Judges would probably be peeved that the docket is going to get clogged up with this garbage.”
Oh, I would be so impressed, were in not for the fact hat you are wrong…
Libby’s criminal trial is set to begin in January ’07. This civil trial will occur after the completion of the criminal trial.
You obviously need more practice, Mitchell, because you don’t know what you’re talking about (re: when the trial will occur) and you are instead just stating your opinion (that the judges will be peeved).
In what state do you practice? “Inebriated”? – lol
I hope Libby counter-sues them because the Wilsons’ lies ruined his government career. That’s really all that has happend after 2 1/2 years of investigations.
I think the timing of this is obvious, trying to overshadow the Novak Story of yesterday. If you read the mainstream articles none of them mention that Novak got Plames name from “WHo’s WHo”…
what are odds this gets thrown out
Well this trial will be a good laugh. I wonder who will be outfitting Mrs. Wilson (wife of the AmbASSador) for the trial.
I’m sure Lee will be down at the trial everyday when he’s not hanging out with his friend Ehren.
Seems to me this is yet another example of the left being unable to resist running against Bush.
While they’re all slapping each other on the back on how great it will be to win something, anything, as surely as they believed in Fitzmas, the real race will be proceeding apace and they’ll lose yet again in ’08.
Added Bonus: Joe/Val will, rather than extend their 15 minutes of fame into a half-hour, convert it into a chapter of permanent ridicule in the history books.
From Plame and Wilson’s Press Release:
Excerpts from the complaint:
Full text of the complaint here
Sorry – link to the full text of the complaint (pdf) is at the bottom of the page found at the link above.
People on the left tend to cry that their patriotism is being questioned. Here is Eric Alterman calling Novak and Rove TRAITORS. That’s a bit more severe than questioning their patriotism. What an effing hypocrite!
Eric, here’s what George Bush said on April 26, 1999 (emphasis added)
“As our analysts know, as our collectors of intelligence know, these are our enemies. To combat them we need more intelligence, not less. We need more human intelligence. That means we need more protection for the methods we use to gather intelligence and more protection for our sources, particularly our human sources, people that are risking their lives for their country.”
“Even though I’m a tranquil guy now at this stage of my life, I have nothing but contempt and anger for those who betray the trust by exposing the name of our sources. They are, in my view, the most insidious of traitors.”
Novak and Rove are traitors, according to President Bush’s definition.
People on the left tend to cry that their patriotism is being questioned. Here is Eric Alterman calling Novak and Rove TRAITORS. That’s a bit more severe than questioning their patriotism. What an effing hypocrite!
I get called a traitor here weekly, just for expressing my opinion. What’s the big deal?
Valeries life was so at risk she did a Vanity Fair spread.
ok.
natalie maines: speaking of “empty vessels” . . .Ms. Plame goes to bed with one every night (and it ain’t the vodka bottle).
Likewise, if she went to bed with Lee. But Lee’s peeny is so small, I don’t think he’d get more than one night in the sack, if only to compare how small it is to Mr. Plame’s.
Lee, what do you do for a living, if anything? I have never seen someone post on a blog as much as you. Why don’t you start your own blog.
Then, no one will have to scroll through it. I doubt you’d have any readers. Besides Ms. Frisch.
Lee is an idiot, by any definition.
Can you say, “summary judgement?”
I knew that you could.
Not one single offer of proof on any allegation. Make the Wilson-Plames pay the legal bills for all defendants.
Adjoran, and you think a summary judgement will be granted without knowing the outcome of Libby’s criminal trial?
You are a moron, by all definitions.
Umm, unless I’m mistaken, isn’t that “Who’s Who” thing one of those idiotic scams you have to pay money to to be listed in?
And Wilson DID IT?
Geez.
We’ll hear the Wilsons whining when discovery makes them look like total schmucks.
Kids, this is what happens when people believe that an echo chamber is, in fact, reality.
-=Mike
I wonder why the original leaker (Richard Armitage?) wasn’t named? Maybe the discovery process will help smoke him out.
Lee drooled at July 13, 2006 08:07 PM
Again Lee, Kettle meet Pot.
The two trials, if there ever are any, are not connected in any way, shape or form. One does not depend on the outcome of the other. Look again at what Libby is being charged with you tool. Does it have anything to do with outing anyone? NO!
The only reason that Plame’s trial may be after Libby’s trial, if there is one, is because of the litigation process in a civil suit. You know Lee those pesky motions and discovery and all, it kinda slows things down, and costs lots of money.
Oh, and where exactly have you been practicing law Lee, since you feel you know so much.
What a hopeless troll.
I cannot wait for discovery to find out all the juicy secrets about Mr. and Mrs. Joe Wilson! Oh this is going to be fun! Smoking Gun is going to be bookmarked now!
DavidB vomited, spewing forth: The two trials, if there ever are any, are not connected in any way, shape or form. One does not depend on the outcome of the other. Look again at what Libby is being charged with you tool. Does it have anything to do with outing anyone? NO!
Look again at the lawsuit filed by Plame/Wilson. The criminal case must be resolved first before the civil case can be argued. Whether Libby is guilty of lying, and what exactly is the truth, must be known before any judge is going to rule on the civil case. Hint: Cheney is named because he is Libby’s supervisor. Is Libby guilty of a criminal act or not..?
Are you a professional moron or is this just a hobby for you, DavidB? You come off as rank amateur, big on mouth, lacking in brains. Just my opinion…
Lee, my bad. In fact, you have no penis.
And no law license, obviously. Stick to your day job at motor vehicles or near the faculty lounge, or whatever you do the few moments of the day you aren’t posting here.
The criminal case is on a totally different track and the civil case will not be held up for the criminal, or vice versa.
If you have a law license, dirt ball, please let me have your license number so I can report you to the state bar for incompetence. And sheer stupidity.
Worthless troll.