I happened to catch this segment on GMA this morning and was pretty alarmed — not just by the alarmist rhetoric, but by some of the things that GMA reported as fact. Before anyone accuses me of being an environmental ostrich, all I am asking is to have a few words added to most global warming stories. Words like “believed by many” or “estimated” would do for starters. Instead, it is often declared that scientists say or warn us, about things that “will” happen, rather than “many” scientists say it is “possible.” You can read the GMA report at Newsbusters, but my “alarm” went off when I heard that temperatures are the warmest in a million years. Just exactly how accurate were the thermometers 999,999 years ago anyway? I sure would like to get hold of one of them because we have several in our home and vehicles and they rarely ever all say the same thing. I pass three time and temperature signs in a one mile stretch on the way to Wal-Mart and the temps generally vary a few degrees. I am sure those caveman thermometers were accurate within hundreths of a degree though.

Chris, it’s really not worth it. I’ve spent hours on this site trying to discuss the science of climate change, but it’s difficult to do that when the people you’re talking to honestly believe their “5th grade science” makes them more scientifically literate than most climate experts, and who view their elementary school’s “Weekly Reader” as the final say in cutting-edge science.
If anything, all this discussion proves is the sorry state of science education in American schools.
Did a little futher research.
1. The Arctic ice is not a factor, even if it did melt it would not change the levels of the ocean.
2. The Antarctic Ice, just isn’t going to melt, period. I may get smaller through sublimation, but it’s not melting anytime soon. The average temp in Antarctica is well blow the negative numbers.
3. Greenland, I had not factored that into the equations, after a bit research, into that particular ice self, that is a little disturbing. If it did indeed melt completely it would rise the level of the oceans of the world by a good 7 feet or so.
So yeah, Greenland melting is a bad thing. But that doesn’t change the fact that the level of flurocarbons in the air, and the level of carbon dioxide is no where near the high points form pre-historic evidence.
If the earth were indeed warm up enough to melt Antarctica, we’ll already all be dead. So it’s a moot point anyways.
Putting all of that aside however. My original premise is incorrect, I stand corrected on that matter.
However, I will not stand by and get into this Global Warming craze untill I see proof that we are causing it.
Greenland may be covered in ice, but that could merely left overs from the Ice Age. I still stand by that there is no definitive proof that man-made global warming is causing the ice to melt. It may be the natural order of things. Volcano’s and wildlife spew an awful lot of toxins and chemicals into the air. Has been doing it for a lot longer than mankind has been around, for that matter.
Greenland melting may be natural, or it may be man-made, but there is no evidence either way.
For Darby:
If nothing else, I’m impressed that you are actually prepared to spend a little time checking thing out. So grab a coffee, and take a little time to check this out: wired.com/wired/archive/8.11/ecohacking.html
CO2 levels need not necessarily be a problem. If you try to fix the problem mechanically, you are buggered – its just way to expensive. But if you use microbes to do the work for you, and remember those buggers double in mass every 20 minutes, you can actually scrub CO2 out of the atmosphere quickly, efficiently, and cheaply. Really cheaply. No need to modify your power plants, or build new nuclear plants.
In response to your actual post:
1. The Arctic ice is not a factor, even if it did melt it would not change the levels of the ocean.
2. The Antarctic Ice, just isn’t going to melt, period. I may get smaller through sublimation, but it’s not melting anytime soon. The average temp in Antarctica is well blow the negative numbers.
I’d be interested to see this research. Links or quotes, please.
“But that doesn’t change the fact that the level of flurocarbons in the air, and the level of carbon dioxide is no where near the high points form pre-historic evidence.
Yes, true. At 1000ppm CO2, the oceans were 60ft higher – and the last time that happened was 60 odd million years ago. Current CO2 levels are 360ppm, and increasing about 1.5ppm per year. Pre-industrial revolution levels were about 200ppm.
However, the increase in greenhouse gases is NOT linear – 25% of the worlds methane is currently stored in Russian permafrost, which is currently starting to melt. Methane is 40X more efficient at storing heat than CO2.
“If the earth were indeed warm up enough to melt Antarctica, we’ll already all be dead. So it’s a moot point anyways”
So what you are saying is that if the proof you required was actually presented to you in a form you believed, it would be a moot point?
“However, I will not stand by and get into this Global Warming craze untill I see proof that we are causing it.”
Ok, so the combined input from every major scientific instituation worldwide, including those in the US, including the latest panel set up by the Bush Administration in 2005/2006… all these are insufficient for you?
I don’t believe in global warming. That should get lots of people worked up, but I don’t. For every shred of evidence that says global warming is happening there’s at least one more saying it isn’t. I like how one report I read claimed that global warming was causing ice atop mountains to get THICKER. Sorry, global WARMING cannot cause more ICE.
Here’s one of many, many, many for you to ponder: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14944138
The writer tries to say that global warming some times ‘takes little dips’. No it doesn’t. . . it doesn’t exist.
I’m not open to debate, folks, so go ahead and post how angry you are, and how stupid I am. . . ’cause I don’t care, I’ve got a life to get back to.
We’re still talking about this?
My disagreements are the result of seeing the same goofy science that screamed “hurricanes seasons are getting worse because of global warming” and their horrific predictions of what the 2006 hurricane season would bring (nothing, thus far!).
So, here’s this:
“Part of the reason for the slow season is that tropical western Atlantic sea surface temperatures (SSTs) are running about normal, if not slightly below normal.
In contrast, at the same time last year SSTs in the same region were running well above normal.
The cooler SSTs in the Atlantic are not an isolated anomaly. In a research paper being published next month in Geophysical Research Letters, scientists will show that between 2003 and 2005, globally averaged temperatures in the upper ocean cooled rather dramatically, effectively erasing 20% of the warming that occurred over the previous 48 years.
Global Warming?
The slow hurricane season and the cooling sea surface temperatures might be somewhat surprising to the public. Media reports over the last year have suggested that, since global warming will only get worse, and last year’s hurricane activity was supposedly due to global warming, this season might well be as bad as last season. But it appears that Mother Nature might have other plans.”
But, that’s not “real science”, right?
“I spoke first hand to the FEMA people who were disgusted by how their agency went from one of high function under Clinton to one of complete disarray and ineptitude after being downgraded, underfunded and poorly managed by the Bush Administration.”
Look up Grand Forks, ND in 1997. Who was President?
Fema was not functioning “high” by any stretch of the imagination.
I still don’t understand how “I spoke first hand to the FEMA people who were disgusted…” = Bush drowned people.
Honestly, how am I supposed to trust your science, if you speak so ignorantly about Bush / Katrina, just as an opportunity to blame Bush.
Also, just as big oil is corrupted by money, money also corrupts scientists who depend on grants. Not all, of course – but it’s there. Just as journalism requires a “CRISIS!!!!” every five minutes to keep their ad revenues pouring in.
“The slow hurricane season and the cooling sea surface temperatures might be somewhat surprising to the public. Media reports over the last year have suggested that, since global warming will only get worse, and last year’s hurricane activity was supposedly due to global warming, this season might well be as bad as last season. But it appears that Mother Nature might have other plans.”
Yes, you are right J-Ho. Quoting the guy on the weather channel is not real science.
Did you even read that link?
And, once again, need I explain that bringing up the odd person here, the odd person there who support your opinion does NOT mean that there is any meaningful debate occuring? In your mind, does consensus mean that EVERYONE, every man, woman, child, on the planet would have to agree before anything would be done?
I’m still waiting for you to address the points I raised for you in the 1.33am reply.
Folks, you’re fighting a losing battle here. For folks like chris, lee, and muirego, global warming isn’t science — it’s a religion. And they are true believers, and every bit as fanatical in their beliefs as bin Laden is in his. They are hoping and praying for the day that Gaia will rise up and smite their enemies, which is everyone that doesn’t agree with them 100% on every issue and agree that chris and lee are smarter than they are and should run everyone’s lives.
Climate research in the U.S. has been horribly corrupted by the government grant mechanism. There is an entrenched, on-high politocracy at the NAS and other granting institutions that passionately believe in global warming, who want it all to come true, who hope and pray for unbounded environmental catastrophe to teach the nonbelievers a lesson — and they control the grants. The reason so many climate researchers are signing on is that they’ve seen the writing o the wall: anyone whose research fails to reach the politically correct conclusions will be shunned by the agencies, have their grants cut off, and their institutions will be threatened if they fail to drum that scientist out of academia. Ask John Christy if you don’t believe me. He has global infrared sattellite data that measures the temperature of the entire Earth’s lower atmosphere, not just a few pinpricks like the collections of uncalibrated and frequently-moved ground thermometers that others use. And his dota shows no trend — and the random variations that it does show match up almost perfectly with solar variations over the same period as recorded by Solar Max, SOLCON, and other Shuttle/Spacelab and satellite experiments. For this heresy, he has lost grants, been refused seats on panels, and many journals will not publish his papers. Most other climate researchers will not debate him or even speak to him cordially. He has been subject to personal attacks and death threats.
Global warming is the ultimate Stalinist realpolitik: “You breathe, therefore you pollute. Since you are a polluter and your very existence is bad for the planet, your every move and every thought must be rigidly controlled by the people who are inherently smarter and better than you, in order to miminize the horrible damage that you do by just living. Bad citizen! Bad, bad! Sit! Roll over! Play dead!” (And never mind that the people who are inherently smarter and better than you breathe and are polluters too — they have absolute moral authority, which overrides your puny factual arguments.)
When the global warming models are able to accurately predict the weather over two weeks (which they have never accomplished) I’ll start believing what they will happen in 100 years. Any other project that had such a collosal failure rate would have been cancelled.
Otherwise, it’s all just bunk to justify government grants.
The issue of global warming is one of the symptoms of what’s wrong with our political discourse. It’s pretty obvious where I stand politically to regular posters here. And I confess to not having enough knowledge about global warming to weigh in with my opinion.
What I absolutely don’t understand is the apparent lack of willingness on both our sides to work together to resolve this. What we are potentially talking about is catastrophic damage to the earth. I’m not saying that’s what is going to happen but how can the idea simply be blown off?
I’m not trying to assess blame here -god knows I do it enough on other issues. But it seems to me that the potential here is as serious, or maybe even more serious, than terrorism. It’s a shame “we” think so polarly opposite so often we give no quarter to one another.
Chris,
I am reasonably skeptic, whether you think it reasonable or not. Unlike you, I’m not trying to convince you of anything. No, I’m only trying to explain the basis for my skepticism. You certainly don’t win people over by beating them up with your viewpoint. Nor do you win people to your way of thinking when you consistently say “EVERY” institution, when that is simply not the case (as if there were no scientists at all who question global warming theories).
My resting body temperature is 97.1 degrees F. My doctors monitored my body temp for 4 months to get a consistent reading of my temp. To say that we can understand millions of years of global climate behavior by 20 or so years of science, is like my doctor taking my temp once and knowing what my regular resting body temperature is.
Yes, 20 or so years of science – because 30 years ago your scientists and your government were screaming GLOBAL COOLING!!!! What changed? And if they were so wrong about something of which they were soooo certain at the time, why should we believe them now?
Plus, it’s just fun to tweak the pseudo-intellectual tolerant crowd.
because 30 years ago your scientists and your government were screaming GLOBAL COOLING!!!!
That’s a myth.
Case in point. Monday evening the weatherman in Raleigh, NC said on Thursday it would 69 degrees but last night the weatherman said is would 81 degrees on Thursday. The point is if they cannot tell me what the weather is going to be on Thursday from one day to the next then how can they tell me they know for sure what it will be like in 5, 10, 50 years? I think there is some manner of warming going on but no one can say for sure how the earth itself will adjust which is the other irony of this. All of these guys are probably firm believers in evolution and the idea that the earth made itself capable of supporting life all on its own and since then has going through numerous changes in climate and what not but now they are saying it wil not do the same in response to human activity? I just do not see how it can run both ways.
Scarpion
Do you know you have more nerve endings in your gut than you have in your head?
Wow… Are we really talking about global warming?
This amazes me… I was super worried about the polar caps melting and putting everything underwater…
Untill I took 5th grade science.
You global warming nuts crack me up!
The polar caps will melt and raise the sea levels! OH NO, We’re all gonna drown.
AYDAYADAYAD……
Ok. Science lesson over. Anyone else want to worry about the world drowning if the polar caps melt?
Posted by: Darby
No! Science class is just beginning you STUPID IGNORAMUS!!!
Sit down at your damn science table get cup of water. Now melt some ice and then add it to the cup of water. Did the water level go up ?
Because the sea level rise doesn’t occur from the ice caps melting and NO ONE BUT RUSH F”ING LIMBAUGH EVR SID IT DID. The sea level rise comes from thermal expansion and melting of ice sheets and glaciers which are not floating in you cup you super ignorant TWIT!!!!!!
People like you are so undeserving the fruits of science. You get leukemia I say no medical treatment for you …you go pray your silly azz to death.
Almost 40 years ago when I was in first grade my “Weekly Reader” about had me about scared out of my pants with the Greenies preaching the coming “Ice Age”. Considering the maps the Greenies produced at the time, Arizona was going to be under the ice cap by the time I was in junior high … Whaddya know, I still haven’t
seen a polar bear in my neck of the woods.
Posted by: Ric
You lying piece of crud. I grew up 40 ears ago to and there were no such articles in our “Readers”. The was one article in the 1970’s about the next ice age and almost none in the scientific literature.
You’re just a stupid dern fool parroting the brainwashing crap you heard on right wing nut job talk radio….GOD you’re dummer then dirt.
I think what a lot of people are missing is that few global warming believers are saying it will kill mankind or make the earth unsuitable for life. Man is a very adaptable species and our will to live is probably our strongest guiding force. Before we become extinct, we will adopt some policy to mitigate the effects and ensure our survival.
But what is being said that something like 25% (maybe more) of mankind lives within 100 miles of the ocean. Any significant rise in sea level will cause an immense refugee problem dwarfing that of Katrina.
Of course, this will likely happen over the courses of generations, not a week to a month like Katrina, and the adverse effects (other than losing many historic monuments) may not be as bad as predicted.
But this is minimizing the certain effects of global warming (if it continues, which I believe it will unless measures are taken to reduce emissions and/or sequester airborne CO2). There are many other less certain effects like increased drought and wildfire, the melting of the permafrost and the release of carbon deposits, increased insect population and disease, lack of fresh water due to the melting of glaciers, etc, etc, some of which could create a positive feedback loop and cause the problem to grow exponentially. The impact of these factors is immeasurable until they actually happen (but if they did, they do have the possibility of being catastrophic).
Now I’m too young for this supposed Global cooling trend back in the 70’s, but as Chris has been trying to say – nearly all major scientific institutions “buy into” global warming. I think it would be pretty difficult to prove the same consensus existed for global cooling 30 years ago.
In this debate, we see classic, Bush-era conservatism in action. The United States puts out much of the greenhouse gases, but the conservatives would rather not do anything at all than make such sacrifices as giving up their SUVs and foregoing their attendance at NASCAR. Conservatives don’t like to have to make sacrifices for anybody, people of the future be damned. Dick Cheney said, conservation is a merely a “personal virtue,” not a basis for public policy, and, as we all know, conservatives have little interest in being virtuous (being selfish, well that’s another story).
So how do these conservatives proceed? They’ll claim over and over again that the overwhelming scientific consensus on the threat of global warming doesn’t prove anything. They’ll claim that the sun causes all of the problems, despite the fact that even there own beloved Bush Administration doesn’t buy this. It’s curious how the conservatives were so willing to wage war when they thought there was a chance Saddam had WMD, but they’re so reluctant to even lift a finger when there’s a good chance that smaller island countries will be overrun by water. But hey, this global warming thing would affect other people and not them, so naturally they don’t give a damn.
I’m not open to debate, folks, …..
Posted by: Logan
Wow that’s so unusual because my experience shows me that the average Bush supporter is en exuberant person with an open mind willing to listen and learn from others in a two way dialogue. Logan…what a rebel you are.
Two points:
Gravity is a theory, not a fact. The properties of gravity are well known but why these properties occur is still not completely understood.
The spike in CO2 levels 1 million years ago is an observation. Why these high levels occured is not known. The postulated reasons being put forth by the global-warming crowd are theories unsupported
by other evidence.
The most likely cause for this observed phenomenon is volcanic activity. CO2 levels spiked in the 1880’s after the eruption of Krakatoa, probably the largest eruption in modern history.
Man may be causing global warming, but this observation of CO2 levels 1 million years ago is a curiosity at best. It neither supports or refutes the current theory of global warming.
My money on the cause of current global warming is on that star I see rising in the East every morning. You know the one. Its emitting the highest levels of energy ever recorded in the 40 or so years we’ve been able to accurately measure them. In 20 years, as the Earth starts cooling, I guess it will be a 70’s redux: global cooling.
See, those that worship at the church of Global Warming, miss the obvious larger picture.
It doesn’t matter what we do. Why?
Because that Yellowstone Caldera is going to let loose very soon and destroy the atmosphere, send us into a cataclismic ice age, destroy all life (except roaches) and ruin my chances for a tan. Wanna see CO2 in the atmosphere, wait til that puppy erupts!
So, it doesn’t matter how much my sweet 1974 Bronco pollutes. The planet is going to spank our butts regardless! So, DRIVE ON!!!
Look up Grand Forks, ND in 1997. Who was President?
Fema was not functioning “high” by any stretch of the imagination.
Posted by: The Whistler
….”but most residents are pleased with this, seeing it as fulfillment of President Bill Clinton’s promise that the cities would “rebuild stronger and better than ever.”……
Yes, 4 years before that flood occurred President Clinton elevated FEMA to a more powerful and efficient cabinet level department.
http://www.answers.com/topic/red-river-flood-1997
Both have since been replaced by new and elegant buildings, though not before spending a few years housed in a former elementary school and an ice rink’s warming house, respectively.
New dikes have been constructed in both cities. The system of levees and new “invisible floodwalls” should be complete in
2007, having cost several hundred million USD. What were once entire neighborhoods are now covered by grass and trees, part of an extensive area of parkland called The Greenway. In East Grand Forks, this transformation is especially visible. One former neighborhood is now a large campground, the spiritual center of what is now known as the Red River State Recreation Area. The cities of today are significantly different from their pre-flood state, but most residents are pleased with this, seeing it as fulfillment of President Bill Clinton’s promise that the cities would “rebuild stronger and better than ever.”
What I absolutely don’t understand is the apparent lack of willingness on both our sides to work together to resolve this.
Posted by: Hugh
Well Hugh solving the problem would improve air quality, spur new technologies in renewable energy, hurt the oil industries profits, allow us to become energy independent, allow for home grown localized sources of energy not requiring huge energy companies, minimize the risk of future warming and spur the US economy.
I’m not sure but apparently some one apparently doesn’t like resolving the issue. I wonder if its the guys who are sitting on a trilllion dollars of future oil profits…..NOOOOOO it couldn’t be them because they don’t just worry about their bottom line they care about America and its people first…of course they do.
Hey — Look who popped out from under the rock! Hi muirgeo! Your BDS is showing!
sean nyc/aa —
I had the opportunity to work in the “science” world years ago. Follow the money. The “buy in” is there because politicians trying to appease constituents make monies available for “scientists” to study a “problem”. Tell the science community there is a grant available and watch’em line up at the trough.
Herman —
What are your credentials to evaluate so called global warming data and information? Physics? Meteorology? Business Administration?
ALso, what verifyable personal sacrifices have you made?
Just for fun, here’s a conspiracy theory that was new to me – I don’t think it’s true, but I must admit that my tinfoil hat was off for extended periods today:
There is a shadowy group of global warming supporters who know the world will soon ACTUALLY start to cool.
They want power and authority to ‘combat global warming’ because they know that whatever they do with it, the world will get cooler and they will then be able to claim credit for making it happen.
The more they can be seen to be doing, the more power they will be able to consolidate to carry out their real agenda (which is, of course, sinister).
Remember – Shiny side out, and the black helicopters can see through your roof!
My money on the cause of current global warming is on that star I see rising in the East every morning. You know the one. Its emitting the highest levels of energy ever recorded in the 40 or so years we’ve been able to accurately measure them. In 20 years, as the Earth starts cooling, I guess it will be a 70’s redux: global cooling.
Posted by: KobeClan
Well that’s because you are uninformed. Solar irradiance has not changed much in 40 years and temperature is continuing to climb.
http://eosweb.larc.nasa.gov/PRODOCS/erbe/browse/b_tsi_erbs_8410_9912.gif
M-go, “but most residents are pleased with this, seeing it as fulfillment of President Bill Clinton’s promise that the cities would “rebuild stronger and better than ever” – sure they are pleased now. But were they a day after, a week after, a year after??? Of course they weren’t. People here in New Orleans understand the insanely large task Fema was faced with, and although they wish things could have gone more smoothly, everyone here is thankful for what Fema has done.
Oh, and yes – I was taught in elementary that we were headed for an ice age. It was a big deal.
And why is it that you guys hate oil companies. If a strange new wonder fuel is found tomorrow, don’t you think that the free market will cause large companies to form, producing this new fuel? Who will you hate then? Or do you believe there will be some utopian free energy source provided by the government?
muirego,
So tell me honestly, you believe global warming is soley the result of oil companies?
If that is the case then there isn’t enough oil in the world to keep the trend going long enough to destroy the earth…and/or our civilization. That is, of course unless it all happens within 50 years, which I doubt.
Hugh,
You mentioned Global Warming being potentially more serious a problem than terrorism.
I think that can be best answered by asking the question:
Which would be more likely to kill me in the next ten years?
A) A Terrorist
B) Global Warming
I had the opportunity to work in the “science” world years ago. Follow the money.
Posted by: Ric
OK I’m following;;;
Oil: Exxon Chairman’s $400 Million Parachute
http://www.commondreams.org/headlines05/images/1027-06.jpg
http://koti.mbnet.fi/badbee/wavs/foodchain.wav
and here is where the money leads for you;
http://www.shiromi.com/images/diary/20040601-serf.gif
Heralder:
Good question. I am 60 and I have children and grandchildren. So I look at it in the long term.
H
muirego,
So tell me honestly, you believe global warming is soley the result of oil companies?
If that is the case then there isn’t enough oil in the world to keep the trend going long enough to destroy the earth…and/or our civilization. That is, of course unless it all happens within 50 years, which I doubt.
Posted by: Heralder
Global warming is mostly from burning fossil fuels of which oil is a major portion.
Let me ask you…if you were in charge of an industry that’s making more profits then any industry ever has and has hundreds of billions of more profits to make by just doing what you are doing and maintaining the status quo would you go looking for other sources of energy…..would you support legislation to look for alternatives….would you support electric cars….would you try to discredit scientist who talk about global warming….?????
Which would be more likely to kill me in the next ten years?
A) A Terrorist
B) Global Warming
Posted by: Heralde
Absolutely with out a doubt global warming..well except Bush is making the terrorist threat worse but not enough to set off the effects of his ignoring global warming.
Simpletons have seen dramatically how terrorist can kill people so for them they fear that threat more because they’ve never seen some one die of global warming. But its mostly epidemiological death. Just like you’ve never seen anyone die from cigarette smoke…but they do.
The heat wave in Europe several years ago claimed 14,000 -30,000 lives but it’s hard to attribute any specific one to global warming.
And if you combine the two, terrorism and global warming what we can say is that if you die from either in reality you will have died from our dependence on foreign oil because they are both linked to that dependence.
Fix global warming and you fix the terrorist problem.
“Fix global warming and you fix the terrorist problem”
I’m really sorry, but what planet are you on??? Do you actually think that if we take away the one thing the arab muslims have going for them (oil money) that all of a sudden they will be joyous and elated and develop a great love the west? You take away their only real source of income and they’ll stop being terrorists???
You do realize that there were terrorists and terrorism against the U.S. prior to Bush becoming president, don’t you?
Chris, I obviously don’t devote as much of my time to this debate as you do.
But there are very real concerns about the science on your side of the equation due to who is funding the research in question. It can throw a bias into results.
No one can tell us how much an effect, if at all, humans have on the potential phenomenon. I’m with the writers above: show us your definitive proof.
If you have no proof, you have a theory, at best.
Isn’t it interesting that while temperatures have risen in places like NY City, they have stayed the same for the last several decades away from the City, in NY?
How do you account for that.
You’re trying to reach to a conclusion for which there is no clear support, and for which there are a number of other factors that militate against it.
You could at least be honest and acknowledge that fact, as many scientists have done.
You still haven’t answered a point worth thinking about: if the scientists got it wrong on global cooling, why do you think they might not also get it wrong with global warming?
You never answer these essential points. So, my time here is at an end. Enjoy your Church of the Global Warming observances.
By the way, if you really felt strongly about this, you’d be irate that your fellow parishoners, the Clintons, Kerrys, Kennedys, and every other limousine liberal, are all flying around the globe on their lear jets.
Flying has the largest “carbon footprint” of any activity we do.
Morons.
Hugh,
I see, I’m 30…so perhaps I’m thinking too much in the short term. The long term may be a different story…but it really depends on how we handle both.
muirego:
In short:
yes
yes
no
no
But that’s just me. There’s money to be made everywhere in our society, including alternate forms of energy…especially if you’re on the forefront of the effort and pioneering and patenting new technology.
But that question is unfair in a way…because I don’t think like a CEO of a large business. I imagine I’d be willing to take risks and set precedents that they are not willing to.
I believe global warming completely aside, it’s important to find alternate forms of energy for other purposes.
For one, I would like to see us independent from places like Venezuela and Saudi Arabia for oil.
As far as the basis for global warming…I believe it to be real, I don’t necessarily believe it to be something that will destroy our society in twelve years, despite some estimates.
muirego, You really are an A-1 asshat.
I state the sun is at a 40 year high in energy output, and you refute my claims with a graph that starts in 1985 and ends in 2000.
Hey, asshat, my calender says 2006!
BTW, the total energy released by the Sun is not measured by solar irradiance. You also might want to find someone who possesses a cluebat to interpret that graph for you. Even the years you cherrypicked show the cyclical nature of solar output and showed a 10-year spike in 2000.
Your chart proves my point. Are you as stupid in real life as you seem to be on this thread?
muirego:
I have two major issues with this answer (which includes the rest of your post as well).
First, if you think that within ten years you’re going to drown or die in a heat wave then you’re not being honest. Despite the fact that that either can be prevented with very simple devices; an air conditoner and inflatable boat, respectively.
But I realize from how you set up your answer later, that you, by your own reasoning believe it to be semantically correct.
Secondly you say his (Bush) global warming. This is the noose that hangs your argument. Going on, you start making extremely remote and and improbable connections.
I think the main reason I disagree wth you’re reasoning is that I disagree we went to Iraq for oil. If we are to take out that whole link in your tangled chain your connections no longer connect.
muirego,
It would help if I read closer…when I said:
“Secondly you say his (Bush) global warming.”
I was wrong. I misread that you said “his ignoring global warming”.
The rest of my post stands without that remark.
But I’d like to add, Bush ignoring global warming won’t result in the end of the world. We should be looking more at China for that…which holds about a third of the earth’s population. Have you ever been there? The air is almost opaque.
I see we have all of the usual arguments against global warming, from outright denial of its existence to downplaying our impact to silly conspiracy theories about scientists. I’ll just take a few.
Global Cooling
Yes, there was a cooling trend between the 1940s and the 1970s, and yes, some of the media played it up in their typical doomsday fashion (as Lorie points out, they continue to do so with global warming). However, climate science was still in its nascency at the time, and much has been learned since. If you review the scientific literature (see Earl’s link above also) at the time, you’ll find it was much less conclusive about the cooling trend and what it meant, and that at the very least more research was needed and always recommended in the scientific literature. Furthermore, it was the scientific community that first presented the idea, and it was the scientific community that showed it to be wrong. Science is self-correcting by nature, even if it sometimes takes a while. If global warming theories are incorrect, they will be shown as such by rigorous scientific study and the scientific community will change its consensus. That is a big “if”.
Is global warming happening?
Please. I understand the argument that we have little to no effect on global warming. I don’t believe it, but at least its a healthy skepticism. I understand the argument that the warming trends are part of a natural cycle, for much the same reasons. But to deny that the Earth is warming despite the absolute certainty that it is is just plain stupid. If this is what you believe I wish you the best in finding the Ark, and a few more brain cells.
Scientists make conclusions about global warming based on desire for grant money.
First of all, any scientist who could conclusively show that global warming is not happening, or that we have no impact on it, would be rolling in grant money, for two reasons. First, revolutionary research is held in high esteem among scientists and funders, anything that opposes conventional wisdom will receive a lot of attention, if it is scientifically sound. Second, in case you haven’t noticed most of the “research” denying anthropogenic warming is well funded by energy companies. Those guys don’t have any trouble getting grants; too bad they decide to abandon their principles and perform shoddy, dishonest science to do so. Of course if any of them were conducting rigorous research and not shilling for the energy industry they would have no problem getting funding for their research from legitimate funders. Further, to believe this is the motivation of most climate scientists is to ignore how so many of them are funded. Do you suppose that the climate scientists at NASA and other government bodies under the auspices of the current administration are making claims about global warming for grant money, especially considering they have often been censored?
Thermometers
Climate scientists do not get their historical data from air temperatures, they get it from ice, or more specifically from air trapped in ice sheets that go back millions of years. If you want to dispute their findings, educate yourself on how they arrive at them.
Ok that’s it for now. In any case, I agree with Lorie’s main point that the media tend to give absolutist, doomsday type reports on this kind of thing, erroneously. Reading the scientific literature will make you understand what climate scientists are actually saying. One thing they do not do is make predictions with absolute certainty, but rather probability.
Your chart proves my point. Are you as stupid in real life as you seem to be on this thread?
Posted by: KobeClan
Yes, he is. I’ve asked the same question before.
mantis,
Of course global warming is happening. I doubt many people disagree. The question is why.
I’m sitting at my computer on a beautiful, sunny, Fall day watching the cats watching the birds at the feeders. I see your statement ’bout the cooling trend from the ’40s to the ’70s and I ask myself, what was the hottest year on record?
Wasn’t it in the ’30s? Yep!
Wasn’t the Sun at a peak of its cyclical output in the 30’s? Yep!
Are we now approaching the temp. record set in the ’30s? Yep!
What’s the Sun doing these days? Approaching the high end of its cyclical output.
I see a pattern here. Doesn’t anybody else?
Clancy:
LOLOL
Its fun playing with trolls, though I wouldn’t want one for a pet.
Fix global warming and you fix the terrorist problem.
Wow!! There it is, it’s just that simple. If it wasn’t for bush and those damn oil companies the pope and the mullahs would be holding hands and singing with each other!
Congratulations muirgeo, with that statement and the rest of your comments you have truly become Wizbang’s most inane and dim-witted commenter.
what was the hottest year on record? Wasn’t it in the ’30s? Yep!
Nope! (But it sure is easy to “prove” a point when you just make up stuff, huh?)
Of course global warming is happening. I doubt many people disagree.
Some on this very thread do not. You are obviously in the sane, if uninformed, category of doubters.
I see your statement ’bout the cooling trend from the ’40s to the ’70s and I ask myself, what was the hottest year on record?
Wasn’t it in the ’30s? Yep!
Nope. Since reliable data has been kept on temperature in 1861 (instrumental) or 1895 (official records), the hottest day on record is, lo and behold, 2005. 1936 was the hottest summer, not year, on record (though it seems you may be talking about the hottest day on record, anyway). It was, at least, until this year. And the top 5 hottest years since 1891? 2005, 1998, 2002, 2003, and 2004. Fancy that.
What’s the Sun doing these days? Approaching the high end of its cyclical output.
Wrong again. It reached its peak (of the 11-year cycle, by the way) most recently in 2002. A more accessible chart is available here.
I see a pattern here. Doesn’t anybody else?
Yes, I see patterns in solar variation. However, they do not explain the climate change that is occurring.
I see pattern too – the right-wing blogosphere does its darndest to lie about global warming — and the price of gasoline drops, favoring the Republican likelihood in the upcoming elections.
What a coincidence!
The Federal Environmental Protection Agency, directed by Bush appointee Steve Johnson, has this to say about global warming on the EPA website:
“According to the National Academy of Sciences, the Earth’s surface temperature has risen by about 1 degree Fahrenheit in the past century, with accelerated warming during the past two decades. There is new and stronger evidence that most of the warming over the last 50 years is attributable to human activities. Human activities have altered the chemical composition of the atmosphere through the buildup of greenhouse gases – primarily carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide. The heat-trapping property of these gases is undisputed although uncertainties exist about exactly how earth’s climate responds to them. Go to the Emissions section for much more on greenhouse gases.”
So this is essentially the Bush administration’s stated opinion on global warming. Surely you don’t want us to doubt Our President and His People, on such an important issue?
Earl:
Nice try.
Your link was to NASA. Use of satellite temp. readings began in 1979. Prior years they guessed at. Apples and oranges, you know.
Your homework assignment is to find a temperature record using the same technique for the last 125+ years.
Again, trolls: Your arguments would be stronger if you did your research better and not just stop at the first site that supports you. NASA’s temp. measurements are only accurate to 1979.
The year 2005 is #2 on the apples to apples list, not #1.