Just a few posts below, Lorie has a fantastic post in which she expands on CNN’s shameful decision to air the footage of terrorist snipers taking out unsuspecting US troops.
Today the Washington Post Times (Sorry folks. I knew it was the Times, but for some reason, my fingers had minds of their own today) weighs in with an editorial that excoriates CNN for showing the video and for John Kerry for defending it:
A new Hollywood movie about the battle of Iwo Jima opened last week right about the time CNN began airing footage it obtained from terrorists showing U.S. soldiers being killed with sniper fire. It is a fitting contrast. The movie tells the story of the three surviving GIs who were immortalized on film raising the flag over Mt. Suribachi. The CNN tape shows the exact opposite: Instead of heroism, we see unsuspecting American soldiers being dropped one by one. No flag raising, no glory; just another dead U.S. soldier.
Of course the Mt. Suribachi photograph is a distortion. The United States did win the battle, but long after the flag had been raised. In fact, three of the flag raisers would never leave the island alive. In 36 days of fighting, there were more than 25,000 U.S. casualties — one out of every three men — of which nearly 7,000 were killed. By comparison, in the Iraq war’s 1,680 days, the United States has lost 2,800 troops. Yet that single photograph further roused Americans to keep confidence in final victory.
Which brings us to Sen. John Kerry’s defense of CNN’s decision to air the terrorist footage: “As painful as the images of war are, it’s important to understand what soldiers go through.” If there had been a CNN equivalent in 1945, would it have been important to air footage of Japanese machine guns mowing down GIs as they waded ashore? Imagine watching hundreds of Americans being killed in one day of battle. Japan’s imperial government couldn’t have asked for a better propaganda weapon. The impact on a war-weary America would certainly have been emotionally crushing for those with sons and husbands still in battle, and might well have played in to antiwar sentiment. But it is much more damaging today when the nation is not as fully united as it was during World War II.
But let’s take Mr. Kerry and CNN at their word and assume that this type of footage has journalistic merit. It follows that CNN should also have shown its hours of footage from September 11. We’re talking about the people trapped in the World Trade Center who decided to jump and the other grisly images most Americans have never seen. Or what about the tape showing Iraqi terrorists beheading Nick Berg? CNN has kept this footage locked away out of some faux sensitivity for Americans’ fragile spines. The only way one can see the full horror of September 11 and other terrorist carnage is by downloading amateur videos off the Internet.
In a mind-numbing article on Sunday, Boston Globe columnist Joan Vennochi also defended CNN’s decision, because, as she understands it, Americans are too dim to appreciate the reality of war. “Without a draft, it is easy for the rest of the country to tune out casualties,” she wrote. “Much of what is seen on television makes war feel as bloodless as a video game.”
This sort of forced logic does a poor job of masking CNN’s and its defenders’ real motives. Their goal here is to undermine the war effort, even if that means being a mouthpiece for terrorist propaganda.
I’m still sick about CNN treating our troops in battle as enemy propaganda. I can’t imagine how parents with sons and daughters in Iraq must have felt watching the video of that brave soldier being shot. Yes, CNN blocked out the part where the bullet hit the soldier’s head, but they then showed him slumped and possibly dying. How disgusting. And they actually have the nerve to act like showing this terrorist snuff film was some kind of noble deed.

The Republican hypocrites weigh in again. They label the MSM as liars and biased players — but if there is something in the MSM they like they link to it and quote it.
Republicans will lie and say anything to get your vote.
It’s time for a change.
Keep letting cnn know how you feel everyday. Waiting for “pucker puss” (lee lee) to chime in 5—4—3—2–
The single most powerful weapon the terrorist have is the left-wing press. Without press coverage there would be no purpose for terrorist acts.
See!!!!! He even beat the count. But what can you expect from someone that lives in the land of the “happy” ones.
Have the soldier’s parents/relatives sued for damages, yet?
This was indeed shameful; utterly unnecessary and poorly thought-out. This lands in the “snuff” film category, and is not news but sensationalism of the worst sort.
I wish it HAD been The Washington Post.
However, it was The Washington Times, according to the link.
oh GIVE IT UP lee… I hope you say the things you do just to start debate, because if you think the Democrats are a lick better, you REALLY need your head examined.
“….being a mouthpiece for terrorist propaganda.”
As defined by the first comment in this thread.
Lee, do you believe that the images from 9/11 should be shown on television? Do you believe that Nick Berg’s beheading should be shown and other incidents like it?
shouldn’t these comments relate to the message/story? i don’t have a problem with any media showing these types of images, so long as the purpose is to inform. that would include showing images of the horros of 911 too! it is in every american’s and civilized person’s interest to recognize the enemies determination and methods (yet absent any logical agenda). the fact is: certain media outlets have their agenda -do we not concede that point? who is the real enemy?
It’s obvious that Lee has no offspring in the military. or conscience. or soul.
show the lunatic scumbag enemies doing all the dirty deeds they desire to disseminate! stoning people to death; slaughtering; torturing – even to their own fellow muslims (believers). this is the stone age barbaric scum that want your head and mine too. burying our heads in the sand, as to the nature of the enemy, is a constructive form of aiding the enemy in achieving their goal.
Lee I note you didn’t say the media weren’t liars or biased players-glad to see you’ve finally figured that out.Everything else you wrote is wrong as usual though.
i agree with lee’s logic: if he says something that runs contrary to the issue at hand – which he is obviously lurking around waiting to do, as he was the first comment, then he can detract from the real issue.
do we not agree that we should know our enemy? (cnn has a different agenda than that) and to know the enemies nature, we should see our brothers and sisters in the battle for civilization.
Lee-Offspring-Military-Conscience. ?????
Being a member and mouthpiece of a party that is already directly responsible for the murder of 3 to 5 million civilians in Southeast Asia can’t be easy. Has CNN shown the piles of skulls recovered in Southeast Asia, most not even buried by the communist wing of the democ’rat’ic party. Just the result of another ‘defeat and retreat’ led by Hanoi John and Hanoi Jane.
Evidently the older members of the ‘party’ want to spread the guilt around in the younger generation of dimwits by getting millions murdered in Iraq and it will happen within 30 days of a ‘defeat and retreat’ by the dimwits.
I couldn’t agree more that CNN should not have shown this footage.
I’m sure you are all equally outraged by the Republican National Committee’s ad that utilizes terrorist propaganda film footage. The ad has messages from bin Laden and Zawahiri and also shows an IED blowing up a US military vehicle. You can see this treasonous film on youtube:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=KgHBfGw3bNc
I find it appalling that the Republicans would repeat the message of the man who murdered 3,000 of our fellow citizens. I lost a cousin in the Trade Center and it really makes my blood boil to see CNN and the RNC promoting terrorist propaganda.
td: i’m terribly sorry about your cousin. but this is not simply propaganda. this is a real war that many folks cannot seem to comprehend; many good american’s mistakenly look to the rnc or bush as the “enemy.” cnn is a source of the creation and existence of that mindset.
I haven’t seen CNN airing any footage of the Mosques in any of the Muslim countries, with hundreds of people chanting ‘Death to America’. Isn’t that news worthy?
Lee,
You end almost each post with ‘It’s time for change’. Explain what we need, what the plan is, instead of just saying, “The Dems will do it better”. I want examples.
If Clinton were running the show, what would you say about this video airing? What about Kerry? Oh, wait, that’s right. If either of them were the Commander and Chief, there would be no war, we would all work things out and hug each other. It’s not like the Dems ever said we sould be in Iraq. Just don’t click that link. It would break your heart, Lee.
I think what people need to realize is that CNN is a business whose “product” is news and entertainment. When a business like CNN acts in an arrogant and reckless manner as in this case, we the consumers can make our voices heard by simply refusing to purchase the “product”. Unfortunately, given CNN’s status on most cable and satellite services, it’s hard to not purchase their product. That is, part of your cable or satellite bill is going towards propping up their failing enterprise. So what do you do? You do what I’ve done and remove your cable sevice and use the $50/mo to buy DSL or the equivalent. And you lobby for a la carte programming so that, someday, you’ll be able to pick and choose which channels you wish to subscribe to. Until then, I’ll refuse the cable service.
I like to compare CNN’s presence on cable like going into a grocery store, buying your usual items, then the store clerk saying that you cannot buy anything unless you purchase a box of Kellog’s corn flakes. “But I don’t wan’t corn flakes…” you protest. “Sorry…if you want to shop in our store, you have to get the corn flakes!” So what do you do, if you’re lucky you can go to another store, or perhaps start your own!
Regrettably, I agree that CNN has every right to show these images. However, it is very sad that they chose to do so. With bureaus in every corner of the world and a lot of local staff who are not US citizens I am sure it is not hard to find a way to create a library of images such as these. Someone in a position of authority, however, has the final say on whether the film be shown. This film is a propaganda coup against the United States’ war on terror no matter how poorly you feel it is being handled. If folks like Lee do not feel that footage such as this inappropriate, then they cannot complain about propaganda devised by the US government to support our side in this conflict. Propaganda has always been a part of war and to the best of my knowledge is not a punishable offense. The footage as shown by CNN hurts our side and helps the enemy irrespective of whether CNN felt that way to begin with. I don’t think freedom of the press means that the US government HAS to allow CNN to attend briefings, HAS to give CNN updates, HAS to talk to their reporters. They can do like others and get their info from AP feeds or however. I would tell them, “Hey, get ALL the news you want your way, but you’re on your own. Or, maybe, embed yourself with a band of Sunni jihadists. You seem comfortable in their company anyway. Just don’t count on us keeping track of where you are anymore.”
And they actually have the nerve to act like showing this terrorist snuff film was some kind of noble deed.
It’s time for the current administration to charge the most onerous traitors in the country and let ’em fry. As Texas govenor, the President allowed simple killers to earn their harsh sentences. Why not traitors under the guise of newsmen too?! The timing would be peeerfect.
Logan, asking Lee to actually give some answers will only result in a link to the DNC website, or something equally irrelevant.
“If Clinton were running the show, what would you say about this video airing? What about Kerry? Oh, wait, that’s right. If either of them were the Commander and Chief, there would be no war, we would all work things out and hug each other. It’s not like the Dems ever said we sould be in Iraq. Just don’t click that link. It would break your heart, Lee.
We were all for the war, Logan – until the reasons for getting into Iraq turned out to be made-up lies.
Democrats six months ago were pushing for a timetable on Iraq – but that was not part of the POLITICAL plan of the Republicans – now they’ve flip-flopped and are setting a timetable.
How do you people sleep at night, knowing that American soldiers and innocent Iraqis died so that Republican politicans could gain political advantage for your losing cause…?
Just more lies from the integrity-challenged Republicans. It’s time for a change.
(PS – I didn’t click the link – thanks for the warning)
The bottom line is this was a PROPAGANDA VIDEO from THE ENEMY, which CNN chose to air. The enemy doesn’t produce their propaganda for “journalistic purposes,” they produce it to HELP THEIR CAUSE.
CNN is in bed with enemies of America. Apparently most on the left are okay with that.
I wonder why?
I apologize to all here for going off message, but I can’t see how you sleep at night Lee having unwavering support for the party that considers the partial birth abortion a cherished right – thank you for letting me get that off my chest.
Lee, if the President doesn’t listen to you he is clueless and insensitive and doggedly pursues a failed agenda. When he changes tack, he is a flip-flopper. You are obsessed but not pathologically so like muirgeo. As for not setting a timetable earlier let me put it to you this way, if the folks that administer this site said that after December 1st all posters would no longer be able to dump on Lee, I bet you would shut yourself up here until Deceember 1st and then have a field day. Get the idea???
@ DavidD
Propaganda has always been a part of war and to the best of my knowledge is not a punishable offense.
Even Nazi propagandist extraordinaire Leni Riefenstahl lived free to the ripe age of 101 in post-war der Vaterland promoting her images of well-hung Africans to the remnants of a perfect Aryan race. But propaganda is one thing while exposing a secret surveillance program or promoting a snuff film of our boys like a Holywood hit is another thing entirely to me. It’s so obviously wrong yet it hides under the guise of a free press.
What would all the right-wing bloggers do if they didn’t have CNN and the liberal media to bash incessantly? You’d all have to actually talk about real issues like the war itself!
Obsessing over this kind of issue is clearly just a way to fire up your base. If this was about principle you would all be just as enraged by the RNC ad.
Again, not defending CNN. They shouldn’t have shown that video.
“Lee, if the President doesn’t listen to you he is clueless and insensitive and doggedly pursues a failed agenda. When he changes tack, he is a flip-flopper”?
Republicans lie, and people die as a result, DaveD. This isn’t a game. I hold our politicians accountable for their actions, and when they f*ck up, I demand a change.
I hope Republican voters do as well.
Lee, how do you sleep at night knowing that the majority of intelligence going into the Iraq war was lined up by the Clinton administration, by a Clinton appointee. Oh, you didn’t know that? Well Hillary sure did take credit for it as she was PROMOTING the war herself, saying that they were expecting a thank you letter from the Bush Admin. for the intelligence her husband lined up, of course that was before she said she was against the war.
Still waiting for your answer lee.
“Lee, do you believe that the images from 9/11 should be shown on television? Do you believe that Nick Berg’s beheading should be shown and other incidents like it?”
lee, “I hold our politicians accountable for their actions, and when they f*ck up, I demand a change.”
Talk about lies lee, Jesus Christ, that”s a whopper. You hold nobody but republicans accountable, inluding for things that are democrat’s fault. The intellectual dishonesty you display on a daily basis is astounding.
@ Lee
This isn’t a game. I hold our politicians accountable for their actions, and when they f*ck up, I demand a change.
The only thing you demand, Lee, is another nickel off the street to feed your crack pipe.
@ TD Larkin
What would all the right-wing bloggers do if they didn’t have CNN and the liberal media to bash incessantly?
We’d continue working hard at our jobs and being happy.
The planes hitting the Twin Towers should be shown every Friday night at 8PM on all channels. The US public needs to remember who started this war.
See Dave, thats the problem, lee would shit himself if we showed that on TV, shooting a US Soldier in the head though, now that is prime television.
Lee, I cannot dispute your statement, it is not a game. I think you probably find many of us clueless because we do not consider Bush a premeditated liar. No matter the past, we are in Iraq. No matter what your feelings on whether we should have ever gone there in the first place, that fact remains we ARE there. We are put off by the number of civilian casualties under our noses. So, let’s save our young soldiers that the left is consistently so fond of and leave. So, what if what remains might be even larger scale killings of Sunnis by the majority population of Shiites. Is it of no consequence to the liberals who dies once we are out of there because the killings that continue can still be blamed on Bush? If you say we got ourselves involved in a culture we do not understand then OK, I’ll give you that. But commit yourself further, do you feel this is a culture that is completely incompatible with democracy? If not, why not help; we had assistance in our beginning when a sucessful outcome was far from certain. If you believe these people cannot sustain a democracy, explain why they are incapable. It’s difficult, it’s sometimes sloppy, it’s war. It’s NOT A GAME as you say, therefore, there are no rules describing the beginning and end on the bottom of the box.
old lee is downright infectious to you guys! he’s got everyones goat. you’re arguing with a lamp post when you debate with someone like him/her/it. lee is a self loathing little socialist that has never had the courage to truly challenge (it)self in any meaningful way. these types see the blogs as an opportunity to feel like they actually have any significance.
nice work DaveD
Yeah Lee you hold politicians accountable all right. What about all the elected Democratic criminals that you still support? Lee, when you talk about holding politicians accountable how about them? You’re nothing but an ignorant leftist shill.
P&G is one of the larger advertisers on CNN. The corp formerly know as Proctor and Gamble controls dozens of well known brands. Ive emailed severl people at the compant, and didnt even get so much as a courtesy reply.
I am putting together a letter I’ll send to everyone I know concerning CNN’s callous disregard for the family and friiends of that soldier who was shot by the sniper. CNN seems to be proud that is the US based propaganda arm of Al Jazeera/Al Qaeda, and I see the ony way yo gets its attention is through its advertisers.
Anyone have any better ideaas?
“Yeah Lee you hold politicians accountable all right. What about all the elected Democratic criminals that you still support? Lee, when you talk about holding politicians accountable how about them? You’re nothing but an ignorant leftist shill.”
Now you liars are pissing me off. Name the Democratic criminals I support, Xennady?
Or are you just another ignorant lying Republican shill?
I didn’t see the video…but criticism (apart from any disrepect for the individual deaths of the soldiers) seems to be based on the general idea that revealing the grim reality of the war is negative to the war effort…Frankly I would rather see all sides (apart from the gruesome bits)..We are all grown-ups, and presumably we can all make up our own minds, bearing in my mind, the dictim that ‘the first casualty of war is truth.’ Information and a video like this may give encouragement to the enemy, as well as moral support to our soldiers in their difficult, almost impossible job in Iraq. But wasn’t it Dr. Johnson who said “truth if any there be, is solid and durable: that which may be derived from errour, must be, like its original, fallacious and fugitive”?
You’re pissed off now lee? Guess the truth hurts huh. As I said before. you hold them all accountable, as long as they are Republicans, and if they aren’t, well, just shift the blame to them anyway.
Still waiting on your answer,
“Lee, do you believe that the images from 9/11 should be shown on television? Do you believe that Nick Berg’s beheading should be shown and other incidents like it?”
LEE
“We were all for the war, logan- Until the reasons for going into Iraq turned out to be lie’s“
Well then Your admitting all the dems were lying then, because regime change and the reasons given were all stated by democrats before Bush was in office You lying POT.
Exactly 914. And in Hillary’s own words during that time, her husband’s administration lined up the majority of the intelligence used in going to war. lee has his head so far up his ass it’s ridiculous. He can’t be honest about ANYTHING!
We were all for the war, Logan – until the reasons for getting into Iraq turned out to be made-up lies.
Made-up lies? We went to war for a regime change. We had intelligence that Iraq had WMDs, we knew they wanted them, Saddam said he had them, but that was NOT the main, let alone only, reason we went to war. The left likes to say it is, but we went in for a regime change.
How do you people sleep at night, knowing that American soldiers and innocent Iraqis died so that Republican politicans (sic) could gain political advantage for your losing cause…?
I can sleep at night because you are wrong. Republicans may lose the majority. . . wow, THAT plan sure worked, huh? Freedom isn’t free. I pray for our troops. I have family over there. I’m proud of them. They are heroes, fighting so I can be here defending them against the likes of you.
It’s time for a change.
(again) Tell me a PLAN.
(PS – I didn’t click the link – thanks for the warning)
Then my point has been made.
Republicans lie
Does the phrase “I did not have sexual relations with that woman” ring a bell?
D-Hoggs,
asking Lee to actually give some answers will only result in a link to the DNC website, or something equally irrelevant My point exactly.
Dave said “The planes hitting the Twin Towers should be shown every Friday night at 8PM on all channels. The US public needs to remember who started this war.”
Exactly! That would remind us that this war was started by a bunch of Saudis, Egyptians and Pakistanis and that there were NO IRAQIS on board the planes on 9/11. And there were NO IRAQIS in the leadership of Al Qaeda and that there was only a minor presence (in the Kurdish north) of any Al Qaeda in Iraq.
Remember CNN the Communist News Network is owned by TED TURNER the wealthy big time leftist who is always donating to eco-freaks and the UN so why should we be surprised by this after all TED TED TURNER is the producer of that leftists cartoon aimed at kids CAPTIAN PLANET and he is also the one who produced other watermellon programs like NETWORK EARTH,ONE CHILD ONE VOICE, and others no wonder CNN has lost its number 1 spot to FOX NEWS
This is how Lee holds ALL politicians accountable:
On Mark Foley: “Anyone who stalks children is sick. Anyone who apologizes for a political party that protects such criminals is even sicker.”–lee
On Gerry Studds: “Studds’ constituency re-elected the man to office for 12 more years of service after the scandal broke. That demonstrates that he obviously was a good representative for the people he served.”–lee
That pretty much says it all.
td, since when did we go into Iraq because of 9/11? You are a dumb ass.