« Always consult your physician | Main | Survivor Predictions »

Body-State Metaphor

If you're looking for an example of what not to post, read on.

Thank you - The Management (Kevin)

We are working on a timeline of the body-state metaphor.
We began with the following and may add Quesdnay and Montesquieu.

620 - 560 BC Aesop
586 BC Nebuchadnezzer
503 BC Meneius Agrippa
427 - 347 BC Plato
59 BC - 17 AD Titus Livy
45 - 125 AD Plutarch
1115 - 1180 John of Salisbury
1363 - 1429 Jean Gerson
1364 - 1429 Christine de Pizan
1554 - 1586 Philip Sydney
1564 - 1616 William Shakespeare

First sets of student rough drafts are in!

"Writers continued however to be interested in elaborating the basic idea..."

Started with the Excerpts Below - Can we fit in Frank L. Baum's allegory (Wizard (king) of Oz separated powers btwn Lion, Tinman & Scarecrow)?

Full article at http://www.findarticles.com/cf_dls/m2242/1603_275/55683940/p1/article.jhtml


Aesop's fable of the Belly and the Members, in which the belly was denounced for its parasitical idleness and finally boycotted by the hands, mouth and teeth, with the result that they pined away, obviously incorporates the same general idea of using the body as a metaphor.

Though Aesop's fables were known as a collective entity to Herodotus and Aristophanes in the Fifth Century B.C., they were not necessarily all the same fables that were attributed to Aesop subsequently: the earliest surviving texts are at least six hundred years later. It is not clear therefore whether Aesop was the source of a story recounted by Titus Livy at about the time of the birth of Christ, or whether the version that has come down to us of Aesop's fables borrows from Livy. The latter recounts how, when the common people defected from Rome in the early days of the Republic, Menenius Agrippa was sent to persuade them to return. He described to them how 'In the days when all parts of man were not as now in agreement, but each member had its own ideas and speech, the other parts felt it improper that by their care and hard work and service the stomach acquired everything, while lying passively in their midst enjoying itself; so they agreed that the hands would not carry food to the mouth, nor the mouth take in anything offered, nor the teeth chew.' The same story was also told of Menenius Agrippa by Plutarch a few decades later, Livy being presumably his source, and from Plutarch it was taken over by Shakespeare, in Coriolanus (Act 1, Scene 1).

What is arguably another version of the same basic concept appears in the second chapter of the Book of Daniel, in the Old Testament, where Nebuchadnezzer dreams of an enormous statue of which the head was of gold, the chest and arms silver, the belly and thighs brass, the lower legs iron and the feet commingled iron and clay: the connection between the two versions is suggested by Plato's Republic which in Book Three refers to rulers as gold, soldiers as silver and husbandmen and artisans as bronze and iron, and in Book Four argues that man, like the city-state, is divided into an intellectual part, a spiritual part (i.e. anger, sense of honour etc.) and a physical part (carnal appetites).

The simile received further elaboration during the early Middle Ages. In the version in John of Salisbury's Policraticus (mid-Twelfth Century) the prince is the head, the senate is the heart, giving both good and bad deeds their impulse, the judges are the eyes, ears and tongue, the soldiers are the hands, the revenue collectors are the belly, which if over-stuffed and holding on too obstinately to its contents causes illness, and the peasants are the feet. The terms John of Salisbury uses, senatus, judices et praesides provinciarum, quaestors et commentarienses, suggest the later Roman Empire rather than any regime he was likely to have known personally, indicating an earlier western European source, now lost. Christine de Pizan, in Le Livre de Corps de Policie of 1406, has the prince as head, knights and nobles as hands and arms, and labourers as legs and feet. A few years later Jean Gerson's Oratio ad regem Franciae revived the story of Nebuchadnezzer's dream, glossing the statue's golden head as the king and royal family, the silver chest and arms as the 'chevallerie', the brass belly and thighs as the clergy and the iron of the legs and the iron and clay of the feet as the bourgeoisie and peasants, 'on account of their hard work and humility in serving and obeying'.

By the Sixteenth Century the writings of John of Salisbury and Christine de Pizan were almost totally forgotten, and even Gerson's Oratio ad regem Franciae was sinking into oblivion: but Aesop and Plutarch were establishing themselves as popular classics. The 'Belly and Members' fable is repeated by Philip Sidney in The Apologie for Poetrie and is referred to in Book Four of Spenser's Faerie Queene; it might even be thought to have been rather hackneyed by the time Shakespeare used in it Coriolanus. Writers continued however to be interested in elaborating the basic idea.

Full article at http://www.findarticles.com/cf_dls/m2242/1603_275/55683940/p1/article.jhtml

Print your own copy of our 20 page (pdf) coloring book at http://www.tomoyama.com/preparehope/ Then help us use it to update the oldest known body-state metaphor: Aesop's Fable "Belly and the Members."

Comments (7)

WTF?... (Below threshold)


I nominate this post to be ... (Below threshold)

I nominate this post to be the all time most boring post eve-er made in blogland.
It has it's own place say in a PBS special never in a blog entry.

Many thanks for this nomina... (Below threshold)
clopha deshotel:

Many thanks for this nomination for "most boring" post. The bulk of this comes from a much longer article that actually did put me to sleep. But come on, the cleverness of this fable from Aesop can be instructive, perhaps it just needs to be spiced up with some slang and profanity!

Consider the accidental mon... (Below threshold)
clopha deshotel:

Consider the accidental monarch in the Wizard of Oz, he was very willing (via the author Baum) to separate his powers between the Lion-Tinman-Strawman ... The general idea of using the body as a metaphor arose from Aesop's fable of the Belly and the Members, in which the belly was censured by the hands, mouth and teeth for its parasitical idleness. This fable, which was introduced in the 2nd Millenium BC, inspired the emergence of the body-state analogy that became the oldest political metaphor. Different versions of the body-state comparison were developed by great philosophers over the centuries which is why it is not surprising that this political metaphor influenced the most important tactical innovation of 20th century warfare.


OK, so I am talking to myse... (Below threshold)
clopha deshotel:

OK, so I am talking to myself...and those of you who have contacted me outside of this forum...but try this out - Giulio Douhet is an Italian (d. 1930) who may be included in the military applications of the body-state metaphor, but while this may be good for discussion among video-game developers, we may want to include some other viewpoints, eh? Anyone have the courage (oops, maybe there is a better word?) to insert their wisdom here?

Here is another finding usi... (Below threshold)
clopha deshotel:

Here is another finding using the "body-state-metaphor" as a search term with metacrawler... http://www.findarticles.com/cf_0/m0GER/1999_Fall/56457597/print.jhtml

Some more good finds here.<... (Below threshold)






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy