« Blog for Relief Day | Main | Spending Hurricane Aid Wisely »

A historic injustice

Today marks the 60 anniversary of the formal surrender of the Japanese, when the representatives of Emperor Hirohito signed the unconditional surrender on the deck of the battleship USS Missouri.

And in one sense, that act was a triumph of politics over honor.

America's entry into World War II was marked by Pearl Harbor. In that attack, Japanese aircraft carriers attacked and devastated our fleet, damaging eight of our battleships -- two of which were lost. And the rest of the war repeatedly showed that the battleship, as glorious and powerful and romantic as they were, were creatures of the past -- and the new, unchallenged queen of the seas was the aircraft carrier.

The battleship fulfilled its designed purpose exactly twice -- off Guadalcanal in 1942, when the Washington and the South Dakota sank the Japanese battleship Kirishima, and in the Surigao Strait in 1944, when six old US battleships (five of them resurrected veterans of Pearl Harbor) fought the Japanese and sank the battleship Fuso.

The rest of the time, battleships served three far less glamorous roles. They protected aircraft carriers from air attack, they bombarded islands prior to invasions, and they served as fuel carriers for destroyers and other smaller ships.

Meanwhile, it was the aircraft carriers that fought and won the battles. Time and again the power of aircraft, flown from these floating, moving air bases, determined the outcome of battle after battle -- and, eventually, the war.

When the Japanese finally surrendered, and the Navy was deciding which vessel would have the honor of hosting the actual signing, by all rights it should have been an aircraft carrier. Ideally, there was one ship that deserved the honor above all else -- the U.S.S. Enterprise.

The Enterprise was a leader practically from the start of the war in the Pacific. She sailed into Pearl Harbor on the evening of December 7, 1941, and it was on her bridge that the legendary Admiral William F. "Bull" Halsey declared "by the time this war is over, the Japanese language will be spoken only in Hell!"

The Enterprise guarded the Hornet when she carried the famed Doolittle mission, when Army bombers made the first attack on the Japanese mainland. She fought at the Battle of Midway, where her planes gave the Japanese their first real defeat, and forever broke the back of the Japanese navy when they sank four aircraft carriers (all of whom had attacked Pearl Harbor seven months prior), losing only one in return. She fought at Guadalcanal, and was severely damaged.

By the end of the war, the Enterprise was the most-decorated ship in the Navy. She won 20 Battle Stars, the Navy Unit Citation, the Presidential Unit Commendation, and the Royal Navy's Admiralty Pennant -- the only ship outside the Royal Navy to ever be awarded that honor.

The Enterprise's war came to an end on May 16, 1945, when a kamikaze plane struck her. Her forward elevator -- a plate of steel weighing 16 tons -- was hurled over 400 feet in the air in the blast. She limped home to Pearl Harbor, and then was sent on to Bremerton, Washington for repairs -- 578 days since she'd last been back to the United States. She was repaired and went back to sea, but not before the war ended.

By all rights, the Enterprise should have been given the honor of hosting the surrender. In her absence, another carrier should have held the duty -- the Yorktown, named after the Enterprise's sister, who fell at Midway, was present.

But there were other considerations. The new president of the United States was Harry Truman, who assumed the Oval Office upon the death of Franklin Roosevelt some months before.

And Harry Truman was from Missouri.

That meant that the mighty Missouri, certainly a proud and noble ship, but only bearing three Battle Stars, was granted the honor. And that is why she is now moored in Pearl Harbor, next to the watery grave of the USS Arizona. It does form an appropriate bookending -- the battleship that died at the outbreak of the war, and the battleship that saw the death of that war.

And while the Enterprise certainly merited preservation as a museum and monument to her valor, efforts to save her failed. She was ignominiously scrapped in the 50's, with only her mast saved as a memorial -- and that, too, was ultimately thrown away.

But that dark cloud had a silver lining. With the destruction of the World War II Enterprise, that freed up the name for the Navy to christen the very first nuclear-powered aircraft carrier in her honor in 1960 -- and that proud ship serves to this very day. When Gene Roddenberry needed a name for the starship that would be home to his "Wagon Train To The Stars," he chose to honor "The Big E." And it was that example, along with legions of rabid "Star Trek" fans, that persuaded NASA to name the very first space shuttle "Enterprise."

Today, the name "Enterprise" is most known as a couple of spaceships that never really existed, while the proud vessel that made that name so legendary is often forgotten. And I speak as a proud Trekker with a stack of Star Trek books a good two feet tall -- and that's just the reference material.

The adventures of the fantastic Enterprises are thrilling -- but they pale in comparison to the ship that served as their inspiration.


Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A historic injustice:

» Eclipse Ramblings linked with V-J Day

Comments (12)

I'm thinking the backdrop o... (Below threshold)

I'm thinking the backdrop of the big guns was probably the reason for decision to use a battleship.

Especially combined with the idea that many American & Japanese civilians probably didn't realize the military power an aircraft carrier represented. But it's hard to miss those guns though.

I think of the car rental c... (Below threshold)
We'll Pick You UP:

I think of the car rental company.

Good post.... (Below threshold)

Good post.

Thank you for remembering U... (Below threshold)

Thank you for remembering USS Enterprise CV-6, the "Big E".

OT weird fact- I crossed th... (Below threshold)

OT weird fact- I crossed throught the Suez Canal witht the current U.S.S. Enterprise in the late 90's. Due to the age of her reactors (she has 8) she has earned a bizarre though much loved moniker:

"Mobile Chernobyl"

We had a patch the crew had made with that name displayed on our sub the rest of that deployment....especially when dropping a few dozen tomahawks on Baghdad.

I'm with John on this one, ... (Below threshold)

I'm with John on this one, with a few twists.

Ceremonies, especially in the East, require symbols to have real power. The Japanese had begun the war with a sneak attack on US BBs. It ended with them surrendering on the deck of one.

Additionally, there was always some small risk of foul play or implacable fanatic deed. Using a modern BB essentially zeroed those risks to US folk, while a CV would not.

The man that lived across t... (Below threshold)

The man that lived across the street from me when I was a kid, his name was Jack Reicher (sp?), was a junior officer aboard the Missouri. On the day of the surrender, he was suddenly tasked with finding a table for the surrender ceremony. He was at a loss at first. After some searching, he said settled on a table from the enlist men's mess and had it brought top-side. The table looked rather plain, so he decided to retrieve a felt cloth used for officer poker games and throw it over the top. And so, Japan later that day surrendered on a mess table with a poker cloth on top.


that's awesome Gizmo.... (Below threshold)

that's awesome Gizmo.

I would have preferred the ... (Below threshold)

I would have preferred the signing to take place on USS Nevada or USS Oklahoma which, IIRC, were still in service when hostilities ended, but those vessels did not have nearly the visual oomph that the Iowa class BB vessels carried.

Perhaps just standing before the 16-inch gun turret on USS Missouri in the middle of Tokyo Bay, the Japanese representatives must have thought that if they mess this up, the Gaijin will stuff us into those gun tubes and return us to shore.

I did a posting at my blog ... (Below threshold)

I did a posting at my blog about my father's role in getting the Generals and Admirals and Japanese in top hats from shore to the Missouri. Check it out if you have the time. I agree the Big E was the proper choice; dumb luck it was stateside.

Great post Jay Tea, this is... (Below threshold)

Great post Jay Tea, this is probably my favorite thing you have written.

I stood on the same quarter... (Below threshold)

I stood on the same quarterdeck where the instrutment of surrender was signed, when I was 16 years old (1973) while it was in mothballs in the Navy Yard in Bremerton Wa. All I can say is AWESOME!!!!! Like others, was throughly stunned by the size of those massive guns that were mounted on the weather deck. Did not get a chance to go below decks to see what the inside of the ship looked like. At that time, these areas were closed off to the public.






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy