« Is Your Elementary School A Shooting Gallery? | Main | Hezbollah Captures 2 Israeli Soldiers; Israel Strikes Back »

Howard Kurtz Misses Point in Novak Column

I know Howard Kurtz usually writes about the people in his business but in writing about the Novak revelations he failed his primary job as a journalist. So wrapped up was he in telling the story of Novak and how Novak did his job that Kurtz ends up misleading the reader as to how Novak's column fits into the big picture of the Plame Game.

Novak Says He Named 3 Sources in Leak Case
By Howard Kurtz Washington Post Staff Writer

Syndicated columnist Robert D. Novak acknowledged for the first time yesterday that he identified three confidential administration sources during testimony in the CIA leak investigation, saying he did so because they had granted him legal waivers to testify and because Special Counsel Patrick J. Fitzgerald already knew of their role.

I gotta tell ya. If I'm a liberal at this point I'm dancing. So far it looks like there will be some frog-marching going on.

In a column to be published today, Novak said he told Fitzgerald in early 2004 that White House senior adviser Karl Rove and then-CIA spokesman Bill Harlow had confirmed for him, at his request, information about CIA operative Valerie Plame. Novak said he also told Fitzgerald about another senior administration official who originally provided him with the information about Plame, and whose identity he says he cannot reveal even now.

While (almost) everything he types is true, it paints an inaccurate picture. He puts it in reverse chronological order (and leaves out big hunks) distorting the whole thing.

Further, while it is good to hear this from Novak's mouth, we've known for over a year that Rove obliquely confirmed Plame's identity. This is only news if you forgot.

Novak triggered one of the capital's most tangled investigations with a July 2003 column reporting that Plame had suggested sending her husband, former ambassador Joseph C. Wilson IV, to Niger to investigate whether Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein was trying to obtain nuclear material from that country -- an unsupported claim that was included in President Bush's State of the Union speech.

Does Howard Kutrz read his own paper? Ever?

That claim has been supported 15 different ways including by Joe Wilson himself. If I could give Kurtz the benefit of the doubt on the rest of the piece, he blows that here.

Critics say that Novak helped the administration retaliate against Wilson, who had become a prominent critic of Bush's conduct in the run-up to the Iraq war, by revealing that Wilson's wife worked for the CIA. Novak said yesterday he does not feel that he was used.

Kurtz ignores that Novak's column COMPLETELY debunks this myth. As did his own paper earlier. The original "source" gave out the information inadvertantly and in response to a Novak question and everyone involved -including apparently Fitzgerald- says the administration official did not leak Plame's name. The myth that the administration called 3 reporters trying to get them to out Plame was killed (again) today. Kurtz didn't get that apparently.

I didn't clip the whole article (you can go read it) but did you notice something missing?

For 3 years now we've been wondering where Novak got Plame's name and Howie didn't even bother put that in his article. The absolute biggest hunk of news in the story and he didn't even mention it.

How could Kurtz miss this?

Novak's newest column debunks so many of the loony left's bizarre theories that they should be on suicide watch. Instead, if they only read Howard Kurtz they'll probably think they got good news.

With all due respect to Kurtz, he really dropped the ball on this one.


Heh- The AP's Pete Yost went moonbat with the story. Again missing the fact that the administration clearly was not out to harm Wilson and that Novak got Plame's name not from an administration official but from Joe Wilson's own entry in Who's Who. Instead it's "All Rove All the Time."


Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Howard Kurtz Misses Point in Novak Column:

» Rocket's Brain Trust linked with Novak Says He Named 3 Sources in Leak Case

» In Search Of Utopia linked with Wizbang goes full tilt on the Plam suit...

Comments (9)

What was the line, "64,000 ... (Below threshold)

What was the line, "64,000 repitition equals one truth"?

I'm sure the left figures they can get there eventually.

What was the line, "64,000 ... (Below threshold)

What was the line, "64,000 repitition equals one truth"?

I'm sure the left figures they can get there eventually.

jpm100 - you've got 63,998 ... (Below threshold)

jpm100 - you've got 63,998 to go - but it's a good start! ;-)

Okay, enough. Who really c... (Below threshold)
Rich Barrett:

Okay, enough. Who really cares anymore about Plame, Wilson, and what Rove did or didn't know? Not a whole bunch of Americans, that's for sure. This little affair has been blown up by the elite in our media and carried to idiocy by bloggers. The majority of Americans couldn't care less any more -- if they ever did care in the first place. I keep reading this as if it's the most sensational news ever. Enough, it is not -- it is just something for the dung dobbers to revel in.

Rich, I know a lot... (Below threshold)


I know a lot of otherwise intelligent people who swallow the Wilson story hook line and sinker. People with upper-level management jobs... They are so hateful of Bush that they turn red when he's mentioned and hell if they're not going to go crazy over this story.

The French Connection</b... (Below threshold)

The French Connection


If you're a regular reader of The American Thinker there is a conspiracy theory over there that this was a high level French intel directed disinformation campaign. This was to discredit President Bush and throw the dogs off the involvement of high level French officials in many of their dealings with the Saddam Regime.

This involvement includes the UN Oil for Food Scandal (The French were the largest recipients, followed by the Russians and the Chinese), Niger/Oil (French mining and oil interests), and dangling EU membership in front of Turkey to deny our use of their airspace and the IV ID to invade from the North (perhaps would have stopped the insurgency in its tracks by cleaning out the Sunnia Triangle before it could start?)

Here's the key link at The American Thinker I dug up again:

Joseph Wilson IV: The French Connection

and some more at:



Exactamundo! I wrote about ... (Below threshold)

Exactamundo! I wrote about this last night at PostWatch. It's link-a-licious! The Post has a long history of getting this wrong, despite the Susan Schmidt article you link. Kurtz also got it wrong when he wrote about it last year, eventually adding a semi-corrective rowback line. Maybe the same thing will happen again.

Hmmm.Howard Kurtz ... (Below threshold)


Howard Kurtz is a liberal shill and completely irrelevant.

It's amazing how most of th... (Below threshold)

It's amazing how most of the mainstream "journalists" can't follow a complicated fact pattern. Half-way through their article, they forget what the wrote, and then change tack into a contradictory "finish."

Maybe, they're just not very bright. Certainly, not very thorough.






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy