« Mommy Dearest | Main | Carnival of the Trackbacks LXXVIII »

The deafening silence of the humanitarians

I'm not certain which I find more appalling -- that in Israel, nearly every building has a bomb shelter, including a day-care center for the elderly, or that last week it was needed.

Of course, I can interpolate, Clintonesque, why they aren't protest Hezbollah's near-slaughter of the elderly. The protesters say that they are against the targeting of innocents. Hezbollah's rockets are utterly unguided; any casualties they inflict are pretty much random.

Another interpretation is that dead Jews simply don't count as much. This theory has some support from Kofi Annan, the Secretary General of the United Nations. Last week, he issued a statement condemning the fighting in Lebanon. On the surface, it seems a reasonable, compassionate, balanced, fair statement.

Then, prompted by Meryl Yourish's own dissection of the statement, I looked more carefully at it. The statement goes into detail on the numbers of casualties so far.

But Kofi has the numbers of the Lebanese at hand (300 dead, 600 wounded), but the writer has to insert the number of Israeli casualties (28 dead, 200 wounded) on his own.

Further, he mentions how the Israeli withdrawal was not supposed to lead to this sort of thing -- without mentioning that it was the UN that was supposed to make sure the continued bombardment of Israel by Hezbollah didn't happen.

And does anyone notice that the UN tends to make "tsk, tsk" noises whenever Israel is getting pasted, but immediately feels the urgent need to intervene when it's their enemies are on the ropes?

Let's see those "humanitarians" deploy themselves as human shields across northern Israel, around such buildings as schools, hospitals, senior centers, day cares, and the like. I'm sure that Hezbollah will acknowledge their shining innocence and nobility and refrain from any more attacks that might endanger them.


Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The deafening silence of the humanitarians:

» A Cool Change linked with UN-Equal

» Cranial Cavity linked with Hey Look an Honest Headline!

Comments (31)

I'm not holding my breath, ... (Below threshold)

I'm not holding my breath, but I wish they would (and just die already).

...of course, we keep heari... (Below threshold)

...of course, we keep hearing about those 300 dead Lebanese, but for some reason, they don't mention the age, sex, or political affiliation of those people.

You know: like how many of them fall into the "18 to 26, male, Hezbollah" cohort...

Sure, they're "civilians," but terrorists are civilians, too. Officially, anyway.

Don't get overly wrung out ... (Below threshold)

Don't get overly wrung out over what Kofi says and does, or doesn't say or do -- I see him as more of a titular head than anything else. Attacking Kofi is an easy target for right-wingers who want to find someone to vilify, but it's just adding noise to the channel - what the U.N. does provide is an international court of opinion.

Here's more, from the open U.N. Security Council meeting Friday. Arab states were extremely critical of Israel--no surprise there, but..

European states were also critical, however, with Switzerland's Peter Mauer saying, according to a UN summary, that respect for law was not a matter for negotiation. International humanitarian law prohibited attacks on civilians who were not directly participating in hostilities. Parties to a conflict were obliged to distinguish between civilian and military infrastructure, to respect the principle of proportionality in all military operations and to refrain from any form of collective punishment against the population. ... There was no doubt that Israel had the right to protect its territory and its population against such acts. Nevertheless, the reaction of the Israeli armed forces in Lebanon was clearly disproportionate. An entire country could not be held ransom for acts of military reprisal. The repeated air strikes against civilian targets were a serious violation of international humanitarian law, as was the indiscriminate firing of rockets by Hizbollah against population centres in Israel.

Israeli Ambassador Dan Gillerman insisted that his country was responding to terrorism and the kidnappings of its soldiers, and that Hezbollah had to be disarmed. Taking up his theme, US UN Ambassador John Bolton agreed that... (also quoting from UN summary)

There was no moral equivalence between acts of terrorism and Israel's exercise of its legitimate right to self-defence... Of course, the civilian deaths were a matter of great concern to his country. That was a tragedy, and he would not attempt to describe that any other way. The United States had urged the Government of Israel to exercise the greatest possible care in its use of force. But, it was a mistake to ascribe a moral equivalence to civilians who died as the direct result of malicious terrorist acts, the very purpose of which was to kill civilians, and the tragic and unfortunate consequence of civilian deaths as a result of military action taken in self-defence."
Israel is the "world's Jew"... (Below threshold)

Israel is the "world's Jew" and as such is held to a different standard.

Hezzbollah has been allowed to remain the defacto ruler of southern Lebanon and sequesters its arms and rockets within residential areas, even homes.

The proportionality argument is specious. It is yet another instance of whatever terrorist act, act of war or crime is committed against a Jew, the Jew has no right to react.

PSHezbollah is del... (Below threshold)


Hezbollah is deliberately using citizens to shield their arms as evidenced by their actions blocking, by force, residents from leaving their homes/towns.

Hezbollah wants Lebanese civilian deaths.

Islamism is a death cult.

The problem, Jay, is that H... (Below threshold)

The problem, Jay, is that Hezbollah isn't “on the ropes”. Based on available information the best guess is that their capability has been minimally degraded (Hezbollah's acknowledged casualties are around a dozen; Israel claims they've killed around 100 Hezbollah). That's a tiny fraction of their total numbers.

Worse, Hezbollah seems to be benefitting politically. Its popularity in Lebanon has grown, if anything—it's practically unanimous at this point. And although Arab governments are divided popular opinion in those countries is pretty solidly behind Hezbollah.

Lee, one number for you: 15... (Below threshold)
Jay Tea:

Lee, one number for you: 1559.

It's the UN stating that Hezbollah was to be disarmed as part of Israel's withdrawal from Lebanon.

That worked out pretty damned well, didn't it?


After a lot of thinking (sc... (Below threshold)

After a lot of thinking (scary huh), I have figured out why the Euro-weenies and the rest of the appeasers are screaming so loud. It is because, they don't want their Arab populations rising up and taking them out. As we all know, most of the European countries have a sizable Arab population and a lot of them support Hezbollah and Hamas, one way or other. We all saw the ruckus that was raised over a few piss ant editorial cartoons in Denmark. Well that would be a Sunday school picnic compared to what would happen, if the Euro-weenies and the Unholy Nations decided to support Israel and the United States in its war on terror. Although I don't see that happening anytime in the near future.

Dave, Here is a di... (Below threshold)
LoveAmerica Immigrant:

Here is a different assessment
The only difference from the usual scripted Middle East war is that this time, privately at least, most of the West, and perhaps some in the Arab world as well, want Israel to wipe out Hezbollah, and perhaps hit Syria or Iran . The terrorists and their sponsors know this, and rage accordingly when their military impotence is revealed to a global audience -- especially after no reprieve is forthcoming to save their "pride" and "honor."

After all, for every one Israeli Hezbollah kills, they lose ten. You are not winning when "victory" is assessed in terms of a single hit on an Israeli warship. Their ace-in-the-hole strategy -- emblematic of the entire pathetic Islamist way of war -- is that they can disrupt the good Western life of their enemies that they are both attracted to and thus also hate. But, as Israel has shown, a Western public can be quite willing to endure shelling if it knows that such strikes will lead to a devastating counter-response.

(Hezbollah's acknowledge... (Below threshold)

(Hezbollah's acknowledged casualties are around a dozen; Israel claims they've killed around 100 Hezbollah). That's a tiny fraction of their total numbers.

Well, the total boosters in their fan club, anyway.

As we keep finding out, when a terrorist-aligned organization claims a membership number, it's most often a small fraction of that, with an even smaller fraction actually being involved in daily operations, and a miniscule minority with any training or skill.

Out of the couple of hundred thousand "loud" Hezbollah in Lebanon, there are probably only 5,000 to 10,000 with any real official involvement in the group, with only 1000 or so having any real training or weapons, and only a couple of hundred with what a modern army would consider enough skill to deploy on the battlefield.

This is the conclusion from... (Below threshold)
LoveAmerica Immigrant:

This is the conclusion from the link above. Exactly what I think, but he can express it much better. So enjoy (maybe Lee is not happy about the Bush reference)

In this regard, it is time to stop the silly slurs that American policy in the Middle East is either in shambles or culpable for the present war. In fact, if we keep our cool, the Bush doctrine is working. Both Afghans and Iraqis each day fight and kill Islamist terrorists; neither was doing so before 9/11. Syria and Iran have never been more isolated; neither was isolated when Bill Clinton praised the "democracy" in Tehran or when an American secretary of State sat on the tarmac in Damascus for hours to pay homage to Syria 's gangsters. Israel is at last being given an opportunity to unload on jihadists; that was impossible during the Arafat fraud that grew out of the Oslo debacle. Europe is waking up to the dangers of radical Islamism; in the past, it bragged of its aid and arms sales to terrorist governments from the West Bank to Baghdad .

Some final observations on Hezbollah and Hamas. There is no longer a Soviet deterrent to bail out a failed Arab offensive. There is no longer empathy for poor Islamist "freedom fighters." The truth is that it is an open question as to which regime -- Iran or Syria -- is the greater international pariah. After a recent trip to the Middle East, I noticed that the unfortunate prejudicial stares given to a passenger with an Iranian passport were surpassed only by those accorded another on his way to Damascus .

So after 9/11, the London bombings, the Madrid murders, the French riots, the Beslan atrocities, the killings in India, the Danish cartoon debacle, Theo Van Gogh, and the daily arrests of Islamic terrorists trying to blow up, behead, or shoot innocent people around the globe, the world is sick of the jihadist ilk. And for all the efforts of the BBC, Reuters, Western academics, and the horde of appeasers and apologists that usually bail these terrorist killers out when their rhetoric finally outruns their muscle, this time they can't.

Uh huh.... sure they'll "de... (Below threshold)

Uh huh.... sure they'll "deploy themselves as human shields" to protect Isreali's. I'm not holding my breath waiting till I see the appeasement crew crossing over from Lebannon to the Isreali side to take up their positions.


Jay, Thanks for the... (Below threshold)
LoveAmerica Immigrant:

Thanks for the analysis of Anan 's statement. We knew that that Anan and the UN are simply useless and corrupt. They have allowed the UN to be used as a cover for the terrorists. Folks like Mantis made a big deal of that speech to score cheap personal insults against posters like Retired Military in the other thread. I gave mantis the benefit of the doubt for his argument in that thread. But I also made the point about his tactic of resorting to personal insults to cover up his lack of args.

Lee, one numb... (Below threshold)

Lee, one number for you: 1559.

It's the UN stating that Hezbollah was to be disarmed as part of Israel's withdrawal from Lebanon.

That worked out pretty damned well, didn't it?

Following the passage of Security Council 1559 Syria withdrew its military. Lebanon, however, failed to expel Hizbullah, despite repeated calls from the UN to do so.

Lots of resolutions fail to achieve their stated goals. Vilifying Kofi Annan clouds the real issues. Yes, the "righteous right" has to feed its constant hunger for someone to hate, but it is misdirected here, in my opinion.

well..I have to ask...how m... (Below threshold)
Drew E.:

well..I have to ask...how many images of children killed by bombs from whatever "side" will it take before we give up our petty opinions and quit spouting BS opinions that we have not experienced?

...at what point in time will we quit being afraid and realize that how misarable our life might be...
if we were eight years old...in Iraq...Gaza..Beriut...Israel...the house down the block...
I read all this passion...what are you Jay...and others here doing to channel this passion into easing the trauma with children in your neighberhood? What are you doing to ease the trauma for children in the world? It takes less than you think...oh yeah please post borrowed pharses like "moonbat"...discount what I say if you have no children..if you have kids..to what cause are you willing to have them die for?..

We have to back away..it is not about our hate..it is about how far are we willing to go to teach children "our hate"...

Lee:You can't poss... (Below threshold)
USMC Pilot:


You can't possibly be defending Kofi Annan?

Drew E.:Please sha... (Below threshold)
USMC Pilot:

Drew E.:

Please share some of your wisdom as to what the US and Isreal should do when attacked by terrorist. You are not a "moonbat", but you sure have your head buried in the sand, and if you bury your head in the sand long enough something will bite you in the ass.

Kinda like Iraq?...see Isra... (Below threshold)
Drew E:

Kinda like Iraq?...see Israel thinks(like we do) their techno advantage means victory...just like we thought in Iraq...we invaded iraq because of 9/11..Israel crushes Gaza and bombs Leb..because of a few hostages..a simple question...
Are you willing to surrender your owned guns?..should those anywhere be required to do so?

forget all the weirdness...
What is "victory"
In my lifetime the things that have bitten me in the ass are bugs...you have a method of ridding this world of "ass biting bugs?"

anybody who is proud that Bush represents our nation...is..well..entitled to that belief

Drew E:Yes! It's c... (Below threshold)
USMC Pilot:

Drew E:

Yes! It's called insectiside, and when they come back I kill some more of them. I don't just let them wander off and come back for some more blood whenever they feel like it. It's the same thing you do to terrorists. You kill as many as you can find, and when they crop back up you kill some more, or you bury your head in the sand and let them drop a rocket on your (8) year old child.

Drew E"Kinda like... (Below threshold)
Drew E "Kinda like Iraq?...see Israel thinks(like we do) their techno advantage means victory...just like we thought in Iraq...we invaded iraq because of 9/11..
Is it really necessary to engage someone that still holds to that falacious idea?

Or for that matter use the tired tactic of avoiding an honest question ("Please share some of your wisdom as to what the US and Isreal should do when attacked by terrorist.") with some idiocy about giving up our weapons.

Ignore him and he will go away.

LeeWhy should Isra... (Below threshold)


Why should Israel (or for that matter, America) trust the UN? It's not like Kofi and company haven't collaborated with Hezbollah before.

DrewEIf you think ... (Below threshold)


If you think Israel's going after Hezbollah is only over "a few hostages" then you haven't been paying attention.

Or is your blindness about the ongoing predations against the Jewish State deliberate?

Moreover, Anan is a corrupt... (Below threshold)
LoveAmerica Immigrant:

Moreover, Anan is a corrupt and incompetent leader at the very least. His son was involved in the oil-for-food bribery with Saddam, as his deputy. The Congo sexual abuse of refugees happened under his watch too. How successful the UN has been in Haiti, Bosnia, Kosovo ... so far?

Darleen, This post ... (Below threshold)
LoveAmerica Immigrant:

This post summarizes well the sad state of the left 's intellectual and moral bankruptcy

All Things Beautiful has an excellent find today. She links to this editorial from The Editor-In-Chief of the Arab Times, Ahmed Al-Jarallah

He concludes the article with this:

Unfortunately we must admit that in such a war the only way to get rid of "these irregular phenomena" is what Israel is doing. The operations of Israel in Gaza and Lebanon are in the interest of people of Arab countries and the international community.

If even many in the Arab world realize this, (Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan condemned Hezbollah's attacks) and the left doesn't that tells you volumes about the nature of the left.

"It's not like Kofi and ... (Below threshold)

"It's not like Kofi and company haven't collaborated with Hezbollah before."

And you offered that link as proof? A blog post?

Hmmm. Right-wing bloggers today are waving their arms in the air -- claiming that the NYT has committed treason with the release of a story about a Friday arms shipment to Israel. That's a lie too.

Linking to right-wing blog posts as proof makes your claim less believable, instead of more.

In order to comply with DNF... (Below threshold)

In order to comply with DNFTT, I will simply thank Lee-who-will-not-be-named for all the links and logical arguments to support their "debunking" of the myth that the UN peacekeepers are corrupt, collaborating, abusive and inept, sometimes all at the same time. Quality bloggin' at its best.

Epador, Lee didn't ... (Below threshold)
LoveAmerica Immigrant:

Lee didn't bother to follow all the links to Israel news, UN report etc... in the article. Why is Lee compelled to defend such a corrupt figure like Anan?

LEE is Kofi Anan..... (Below threshold)

LEE is Kofi Anan..

Epador, Lee didn't bothe... (Below threshold)

Epador, Lee didn't bother to follow all the links to Israel news, UN report etc... in the article"

LoveAmerica Idiot -- I most certainly did, you liar. My most recent comment was directed to Darlene, and the link she provided. That's why my comment is preceded by a quote from hers.

You trolls are amazing - either that or you are just plain stupid.

LeeAll the support... (Below threshold)


All the supportive links are in the one link I provided.

But hey, it might shake your faith, so why should you look?

The UN "peace keeping" forces rape and take bribes at will with little or no consequence. And coverups go right to Klepto-Kofi

BTW LeeIf you want... (Below threshold)


If you want to sneer at me directly, drop an email...but when you post on this thread, you cannot expect others not to comment.

Amazing that you seem to think they are trolls!

Classic projection .... dayum!






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy