« Human Stem Cells Found in Amniotic Fluid | Main | The Word of 2006: Plutoed »

The Evolution Of Insurance Claims - How UHC Changed The Way It Listens

OK, right from the start I admit that this one is going to attract very few people for its excitement value, but it's a very big deal if you can grasp the significance of these changes. For full disclosure, I state here that my health insurance carrier is United Healthcare, and that they will be providing coverage for my cancer treatment. This situation should be considered in weighing possible bias on my part regarding United Healthcare.

As you all know by now, I have cancer. PMP for short, Pseudomyxoma Peritonei if you're into the long version. Cutting to the chase, dealing with this cancer has already meant a string of doctor visits and tests, and will involve at least one major surgery and a bunch of chemotherapy. There are all sorts of factors to consider in this sort of thing, but one of the big worries is what it costs, financially, to survive cancer. And a big part of that worry is the cost of medical care. One of my fellow patients with PMP revealed that her hospital stay produced a bill in the amount of roughly $280,000. You know, that's a big number in anyone's book, and enough to send the average household right into bankruptcy.

Now, as it happens I have health insurance, through United Healthcare. The policy in general says they will cover 80% of accepted charges after the annual deductible is paid. That's fine when we are talking about paying for a short stay of a well-known condition, but PMP is not well-known, and everyone I have talked to says that the hospital stay will be for several weeks, followed by several months of recovery. And even if UHC agreed to cover the hospital stay, the projected bill could easily result in me being responsible for $57,000. I do not have that kind of money, and I could not realistically pay that kind of cost out even if someone gave me years to do it.

OK, roll back to the mid-1980s. One big and common complaint about major insurance companies, was how hard people had to fight to get claims covered. From 1994 to 2000, I worked for a third-party claims administrator and I can tell you that there was a lot of difficulty. Sometimes it was fraud, but as often by the provider or the patient as it was from an insurer, but a lot more often there was something missing or misunderstood in the information and communication. This happened the most often when a claim was very large, or the diagnosis was controversial or complex. Things only got worse during the Clinton Administration, because in its zeal to protect the patient, the administration often made insurance companies out to be the villain. Imagine you run a business, but you are not allowed to control your costs. This was how many insurers saw the trend in government management of Healthcare. At that same time, the strong rise in medical malpractice suits and the subsequent jump in premiums made providers feel that they were being pinched; they were being forced to accept standardized reimbursement for medical services, but which did not rise in proportion to their operating costs or sense of risk. And patients continued to complain that valid needs were unmet, and legitimate claims denied purely for financial reasons. As recently as 1998, the matter seemed impossible to resolve.

I cannot speak for every insurer, but United Healthcare examined the issue, considered its options, and made changes. So far, that sounds like something any company would do, but in the case of UHC, the first changes were not towards patients or providers, but in the quality of information UHC had to use to make decisions. Speaking at the 11th Conference of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN), Dr. Lee Newcomer, the Business Leader of Oncology Services for UHC explained that "it can be difficult to separate human error from system error", meaning that the data sources had to be evaluated, and for that, UHC needed to hear - directly - from providers and patients. Participation in medical conferences like the NCCN Roundtable was one way to find out information, but UHC also opened queries to doctors and clients about their satisfaction with UHC. UHC also conducts clinical research in cooperation with laboratories and doctors, especially on those conditions with little established data. UHC also began to release Clinical Profiles, a program to coordinate doctors' practices with other programs and to establish national benchmarks for medical care. In 1999, UHC followed this with the start of a Care Coordination program, which connected the different services, medicines, and treatments that patients needed for extended and serious conditions. And somewhere along the way UHC examined the numbers and determined an Out-of-Pocket Ceiling that any client would be expected to pay in any year, and UHC eliminated lifetime limits to medical care for most clients. In my case, this means that while my surgery and the associated costs will be expensive, they will be within predictable limits and in general the level of worry I will have from my insurance claims has been greatly reduced.

It remains to be seen how the promise will meet up with the reality, but I have read accounts from other PMP patients with UHC insurance, and the response has been very favorable. True, a lot of this depends on doctors and their staffs following through with the insurance company and all the paperwork, but it should be noted that at least some of the insurance companies have remembered that the patients are real persons, and they respect us in accordance with that truth.

Comments (10)

I am truly sorry for your d... (Below threshold)

I am truly sorry for your diagnosis and hope you continue to fight against the cancer.

You should just send the physicians and hospitals a note stating that you can not afford to pay the "copay".

I am sure you will find the physicians are more than willing to write off your 20%. However, the hospitals may not be so accommodating and certainly the insurance company will not be happy.

I want to be perfectly clear in stating that the people least able to afford the absorption of your costs will be most likely to try (doctors).

Also, note that the majority of "costs" is not Physician related, but is Hospital and ancillary services driven.

Good luck.

You're in my prayers. May ... (Below threshold)

You're in my prayers. May everything go even better than expected.

One more thing, don't EVER,... (Below threshold)

One more thing, don't EVER, NEVER miss an insurance premium payment again. It will 'insure' your premium triples!

Write that check every month yourself. Your life may depend on it.

You have my heartfelt wishe... (Below threshold)

You have my heartfelt wishes that you beat this thing and get better.

DJ, I pray that you win you... (Below threshold)

DJ, I pray that you win your battle with cancer.

Having said that, I hope that eventually UHC treats you better than it treated me. The insurance I had with my old job was through UHC and quite frankly, it blew chunks. For routine stuff it was OK, but if you ever had a problem or something out of the ordinary happened and you called them up to get it worked out, the UHC support staff is uniformly one of the most incompetent I have ever had to deal with. For one simple problem, I had to call about a dozen times, speak with twelve different low-functioning mentally deficient customer servicereps, over a period of several weeks, get into a shouting match with a supervisor, before my problem was resolved.

Again, my prayers are with you. And I hope you don't have to go through anything like what I had to go through with UHC.

Best wishes in your fight, ... (Below threshold)

Best wishes in your fight, DJ. Keep positive. We look forward to seeing a post from you reporting that the cancer is in full remission.

Best wishes DJ,I t... (Below threshold)

Best wishes DJ,

I too have UHC, trained monkeys could do a better job. The invoice was from "Emergency Medical Services" UHC's question, "Was this emergency visit necessery?"
My answer: "Well, I could have waited for my broken leg to heal itself, but I figured what the f***, maybe I should go see someone about it."

Best of luck and get well s... (Below threshold)

Best of luck and get well soon.

I am an "Independent Agent"... (Below threshold)

I am an "Independent Agent" representing over 40 life & health insurance companies (including UHC) that are in the small business (under 50 employees) group insurance market and I have a question.

Are you sure that you do not have an OOP (Out Of Pocket) maximum in your plan? I have never actually looked for the type of plan you are describing specifically because of what could happen in a situation such as the yours. The way it normally works is that there is a deductible, $1-5K then coinsurance 20-40% of the next $5-20K, then 100% of the balance until the policy maximum of $2-5M (or unlimited with HMOs). Taking the absolute highest of what is available in our market ($5 Deductible then 40% of $20K) that would result in your maximum obligation being $13K. Still nothing to sneeze at, but somewhat better.

If I can be of any assistance, feel free to contact me. I will happily donate a few hours of time.

Development Emergency Medic... (Below threshold)

Development Emergency Medical Service in America has received the second wave, improvement of quality of service and speed of reaction WBR LeoP






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy