« Louisiana elects Republican Jindal as Governor | Main | Wow, Imagine How Bad Things Would Have Been If They Hadn't Gotten Rid Of Paul Wolfowitz... »

Well, that helps explain it...

About a month ago, I wrote about a New Hampshire family in a bit of legal trouble. The father had discovered that his 15-year-old daughter had had sex with her 17-year-old boyfriend, and confronted the boy at the school -- "confronted" meaning "beat the crap out of," leaving him bruised and needing stitches. The father was charged with assault, and later the boy was charged with statutory rape.

It turns out now that the girl -- naturally scared at being caught -- had told her parents that the boy had forced her to have sex. Only after her father was tossed in the clink and the boy was stitched up did she finally admit she had been a willing participant.

I tend to be a law-and-order sort of guy, but in this case I think that the best interests of justice would be served if all the charges were dropped. The boy did have sex with a minor, but he got the snot beaten out of him by her father. The father did assault the boy, but he was provoked -- and acting as most any father would, in similar circumstances. And the girl has to live with the knowledge that she got her boyfriend beat up and her father arrested -- and I bet neither is in an overly forgiving mood. Plus, with both the boy's name and her father's name public now, she's gotta be severely humiliated.

We have enough real problems going on in New Hampshire right now. Our courts have far more important issues to address than this silliness.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (18)

What dumbass parents let a ... (Below threshold)

What dumbass parents let a 15 year old girl have a a boy friend in the first place, let alone one that is 2 years older. They didn't see this coming? Gimme a break.

Idiot parents absent from the job.

10 bucks says she gets knocked up before she turns 17.

Well, no, they didn't let h... (Below threshold)

Well, no, they didn't let her have a boyfriend. She was turning adult and making her own decisions. Choice is wonderful.

"We have enough real proble... (Below threshold)

"We have enough real problems going on in New Hampshire right now. Our courts have far more important issues to address than this silliness." -- Jay Tea

Uh, Jay, don't you yourself have far more important issues to address instead of this silliness?

Think about it.

I do find this story intere... (Below threshold)

I do find this story interesting. You have a 17 year boy old by acting like a 17 year old boy. You have a father acting like a protective father. And you have a teenage girl acting like a Democrat. No personal responsibility, lying to avoid consequences and wanting someone else to pay for her mistakes.

Just wait until New England... (Below threshold)
civildisobedience Author Profile Page:

Just wait until New England is under sharia law. The daughter would be killed for being a whore and the men would get off scot-free. There are some great advantages for men under Islamic law, one is having sex with whoever you want that is not already married and not having to be responsible for anything, including rape. LOL, stupid liberals...

I would say that this case ... (Below threshold)

I would say that this case might be dismissed after everyone has gone through counseling. The father emotions may have gotten the better of him in this case but since his daughter is 15 he still has 3 more years to deal with other issues he might as well get help starting now.

Maybe it was just "Love (or lust)" maybe not.
Teenage girls sometimes they do not know the difference between rape and regret because of how sex is presented to them. Other times rape is rape but because they LOVE the boy they will retract it to protect him. Other time is jealously finding out that the love of their life is hooking up with other girls and sometimes their best friends. Other times boys can be predators going after younger girls knowing dating an older boy acts as status symbol.

The boy should know that having sex with 15 year old is against the law and he might prosecuted. Having sex as teenager can have consequences aside from pregnancy, STD and psychological impact. There also legal consequences these can be brought not only by the parents but by the state(usually only done when their is pregnancy and they want child support payments made). The old saying ignorance of the law is no excuse. So he should know about this and the affects having a relationship with girls under 16 and or 3 years younger than him. I just wonder if when they are teaching kid how to put condoms on Bannas if they go over these legal aspects of this?
They did when I went to grammar school. Back in the 80's when I went to school they explained this as part of Sexual Education along with the finical cost of raising a child. We learnt that the act has many consequences but maybe that is because it was a Catholic school.

herman:Uh, Jay... (Below threshold)


Uh, Jay, don't you yourself have far more important issues to address instead of this silliness?

Congratulations on becoming new editor-in-chief at Wizbang! (If by editor-in-chief you mean asshatted buffoon)

I disagree with you, Jay Te... (Below threshold)

I disagree with you, Jay Tea. Crimes are crimes, and resolution of these offenses needs to be according to the relevant laws. I have no idea how the state of New Hampshire treats statutory rape, but at least a few states take into consideration the age difference between the participants when both are close to the legal age of consent.

On the first point, perhaps the charges should be dropped, but I don't know.

On the point of father's assault -- the charges should remain. Yes, he acted on the same IMPULSE that many fathers would act on ... but the very definition of civilized, adult behavior is setting aside those impulses. Failing to do so, in turn, can be a crime.


C.O.,You are right... (Below threshold)


You are right, under some interpetations of Sharia law the girl would of been killed for besmirching the families name. In the tribalism that often goes along with Sharia, there could of also been a nice little blood-feud between the two families for the 17 year olds attack upon their honor.

I believe the father did the right thing under the circumstances. More parental direct-action like that would do wonders for teenagers deportment towards each other.

Good one, Jay. Just <a href... (Below threshold)

Good one, Jay. Just a few days ago you were so adamant that being wrong in a judgment call is no excuse for avoiding the consequences of that call. That doing something you BELIEVE is the legal and right thing to do doesn't get you off the hook when it turns out you were wrong and it WASN'T.

But now you're saying that this adult who beat up a teen should be let off the hook for what he (wrongly) BELIEVED was justified.

Actually, this goes far beyond your previous point, as there's no way that this dad BELIEVED that was he was doing was legal. He just decided to do it anyway.

It's interesting to see that you're a supporter of vigilante justice.

Illustrating the point, pw,... (Below threshold)

Illustrating the point, pw, that laws are generally good, and it is right to have them, but they can be specifically bad and spark a consideration for change. That was neither ordinary rape nor assault.

There are better ways to re... (Below threshold)

There are better ways to resolve this situation. In an era before laws, well written ones anyway, this event might well have been the origin of a strong nuclear family. Personally, I'm not sure anyone did anything wrong in this situation.

Why didn't the young animal beat the old one's ass?

Can she bake a cherry pie,<... (Below threshold)

Can she bake a cherry pie,
Charming Lil, Charming Lil?
Can I beat her Daddy's ass,
Charming Lillie?

What dumbass parents let... (Below threshold)
Steve L.:

What dumbass parents let a 15 year old girl have a a boy friend in the first place, let alone one that is 2 years older. They didn't see this coming? Gimme a break.

Actually, had you read the article, you would have found that the reason that the girl lied was because her arents did not like the boy and the girl was not allowed to be dating anyone. She wass sneaking around behind her parents back, engaging in the bad behavior. Short of chaining her to her bed, there is little different the parents could have done to prevent her seeing the boy.

Well, Steve, the Dad could ... (Below threshold)

Well, Steve, the Dad could have beat up the boyfriend to test his intentions. There are ancient solutions to these problems.

Law. Too much ego in its cosmos.

Short of chaining her to... (Below threshold)

Short of chaining her to her bed, there is little different the parents could have done to prevent her seeing the boy.

It's the lefties' fault. Always encouraging dating, claiming "everyone does it". Instead, they should be preaching "absence".

This is not silliness. Thi... (Below threshold)

This is not silliness. This is our future generation, America!! Parents, do you know where your teenagers is, whom he or she is with and what they're doing? Well, do ya?

Brian went to school to lea... (Below threshold)

Brian went to school to learn to make acute and telling points as above. This kind of problem predated political ideology, and to apply it to the problem makes you seem as educated as Brian.






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy