« The Knuckleheads of the Day award | Main | Tour the Clinton Library »

College Daze

Of late, more and more states have started finding their own remedies to the illegal alien problem. Leading the charge is Arizona, which is finding that if you simply make it uneconomical to be an illegal alien, they'll go elsewhere.

But of course, not every state is quite so perceptive. And leading THAT charge is -- who else? -- Massachusetts.

A couple of years ago, there was a push to grant in-state tuition to illegal aliens who resided in Massachusetts. This was, amazingly enough, defeated in the legislature (but only after huge howls of protest from the electorate.)

Well, some ideas are so foul that you can't even flush them away. Massachusetts' governor, Deval Patrick (a guy with no prior electoral experience, but he had served as a Director of Ameriquest, one of the main "bad guys" cited in the sub-prime mortgage mess), has decided that it really is a good idea -- and doesn't need the legislature's approval.

Under the defeated bill that Patrick is attempting to pass by executive fiat, the student must have graduated from a Massachusetts school or "equivalent," lived in Massachusetts for three years, and make at least a token gesture towards becoming legal.

The Boston Globe weighed in, too, and both papers were quick to find Republicans to criticize the plan.

This is amazing.

No, not that Republicans would criticize the plan. That either paper would be able to find Republicans in the first place. Massachusetts is the bluest of blue states -- the Democrats hold both Senate seats, all ten House seats, all state-wide offices, and 85% of each house of the legislature. This means that the Republicans quoted are essentially irrelevant on this issue, as they are on almost everything in Massachusetts -- everything that happens, politically, in Massachusetts can be laid at the feet of the Democrats, for good or ill.

I can kind of understand why Patrick would try this tactic. As we saw in the gay marriage debacle, you can pretty much count on the Massachusetts legislature to do everything it can to do no thing on any issue that might smack of controversy. They were warned by the Supreme Judicial Court that they had to address the legal status of gay marriage, or the Court would do their job for them -- and they did. And then, when the people tried to undo the Court's action, the Legislature threw all of their resources into keeping the matter from going anywhere -- because it would eventually have to go through them.

And in the case of the Big Dig, the legislature thwarted every single effort Governor Mitt Romney made to wrest control of the project, to bring some accountability and common sense into the huge disaster. They saw the Big Dig as a fountain of money, a place to feed at the trough and put relatives and cronies on the public payroll. Right up until the sheer ineptitude of the project finally killed a woman -- and then they couldn't give Romney all the authority he wanted and more, as long as it meant they could now blame him for the failings of the project.

So here's a controversial issue where the legislature tried to take a stand, and got spanked by the public. Patrick (wrongly) believes that it's a good idea, and he knows that he has at least some sympathy from the legislature -- after all, it was a fairly close thing when the plan was defeated. So why not follow the precedent set by the Big Dig and gay marriage, and just bypass the legislature entirely?

I'm wondering if there's another factor here. This move would add to the draw of the Bay State for illegal aliens across the nation. There is also a move afoot to have illegal aliens counted as part of the census, at least as far as Congressional redistricting and reapportionment of Representatives goes. As of right now, Massachusetts expects to lose at least one and possibly two House seats in 2010. Could this be part of a plan to staunch that loss of power?

The cited rationale simply doesn't hold water. One person argues that the students would end up being a net plus to the state's economy. But there's no requirement that the student actually achieve legal status, just "pursue" it. When they graduate with that degree, there's no guarantee that they will be able to legally work in Massachusetts.

As the old saying goes, "in a democracy, the people tend to get the government they deserve." The people of Massachusetts freely elected Deval Patrick and the 85% Democratic legislature. They have absolutely no grounds for complaint about how they act. If they really cared, they'd stop re-electing the same incompetent, corrupt busybodies.

In the meantime, though... thanks again, Massachusetts, for serving as such a great bad example.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (10)

This is amazing. No, not... (Below threshold)

This is amazing. No, not that Republicans would criticize the plan. That either paper would be able to find Republicans in the first place.

It's not real, of course. They simply make the statements so we all think that there is a single viable Republican in Massachusetts.

This keeps people from thinking that Massachusetts is a Stalinist Socialist utopia- which it is.

60 minutes, a few years ago... (Below threshold)

60 minutes, a few years ago, did a segment on the big dig and pointed out that the whole thing was done under republican administrations...and the nitwits in MA buy this load of you know what.

Yes, Judith, the state had ... (Below threshold)

Yes, Judith, the state had Republican governors for most of the Big Dig. But the legislature kept nearly every scrap of authority over it (mainly the money) for all that time -- right up until a hunk of ceiling tile collapsed and killed a woman. Before that, every single attempt by a governor to exert any sort of authority was smacked down by the legislature -- which was always overwhelmingly Democratic.


"There is also a move afoot... (Below threshold)

"There is also a move afoot to have illegal aliens counted as part of the census, at least as far as Congressional redistricting and reapportionment of Representatives goes. As of right now, Massachusetts expects to lose at least one and possibly two House seats in 2010."

Me thinks the Federal Courts will nix this nonsense.

FWIW, the Big Dig project w... (Below threshold)

FWIW, the Big Dig project wa the brainchild of Fred Salvucci, Secretary of Transportation for Mike Dukakis. The funding was secured (initially) by Tip O'Neil, and the project was well into the final design stage before Bill Weld became the first Republican governor in two decades.

That said, the management of the construction of the project took place almost entirely on a Republican Governor's watch, with the Secretary of Transportation in charge.

I hope Patrick goes ahead with this plan. And continues on his current track of a blunder a month. That way, we may have a fighting chance of getting the office back -- if we can only talk Charlie Baker into running. I don't see any other viable candidate.

Me thinks the Federal Co... (Below threshold)
John Irving:

Me thinks the Federal Courts will nix this nonsense.

The Mass Dems will probably try to compromise, treat the illegals as 3/5's of a citizen or some such.

As someone who lives far aw... (Below threshold)

As someone who lives far away from Mass., I think it's great if they do things to attract all the illegals. I think it's only fair that they foot the bill for a change. Of course, when liberals from the NE finally have to start paying like those of us in the west have had to pay for illegals, there will finally be some pressure on the fed to pick up the tab.

But nonetheless, let Mass. have all the illegals. Only when they are actually dealing with the problem can their legislators speak with some credibility on the subject. Right now they know as much about the problem as they know how to manage the western forests.

In contrast to the failed p... (Below threshold)

In contrast to the failed plan by Huckabee in Arkansas to extend scholarships to the children of "resident" illegals, the in-state tuition thing may just be something that gets people riled up without reason.

Do most schools require proof of citizenship to qualify for "in-state" rates, or do they only require proof of residence?

Maybe things have changed - many have - but back in the day, you only had to prove residence of a custodial parent or guardian. The schools never asked about citizenship itself, that I recall. If they still don't, and certainly the prevailing preference in academia would be not to ask, then arguing over who gets the "in-state" tuition rate is, well, academic . . .

The Illinois legislature at... (Below threshold)

The Illinois legislature attempted this same thing, and they were swamped with calls by taxpayers who were po'ed that an illegal alien could get in-state tuition, but a law-abiding family had to take the hit from Springfield if they wanted to send their kid here.

The proposal is still out there, but there are far fewer supporters, and the pols are hoping that nobody will remember this in November.

I prefer the actual, full M... (Below threshold)
Boyd Author Profile Page:

I prefer the actual, full Mencken quote, JT:

"Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want, and deserve to get it good and hard."






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy