« No | Main | No One and Done »

The Knucklehead of the Day award

Today's winner is CIS or Citizenship and Immigration Services. They get the award for the following.

During his nearly four years as a translator for U.S. forces in Iraq, Saman Kareem Ahmad was known for his bravery and hard work. "Sam put his life on the line with, and for, Coalition Forces on a daily basis," wrote Marine Capt. Trent A. Gibson.

Gibson's letter was part of a thick file of support -- including commendations from the secretary of the Navy and from then-Maj. Gen. David H. Petraeus -- that helped Ahmad migrate to the United States in 2006, among an initial group of 50 Iraqi and Afghan translators admitted under a special visa program.

Last month, however, the U.S. government turned down Ahmad's application for permanent residence, known as a green card.

Before we get to why Ahmad was turned down, read a little bit of his background.

Retired Marine Capt. Jason P. Schauble, who returned from Iraq in 2004 after being wounded, is Ahmad's official sponsor. In a letter he appended last week to Ahmad's immigration file, Schauble condemned whatever "faceless bureaucracy" rejected the application. "I don't know what a foreigner has to do that is greater than what Saman Ahmad has done in service to his American allies," Schauble wrote.


At the time, KDP forces were fighting both Hussein and a rival Kurdish party. Ahmad joined the KDP militia. "I don't have any resources, I don't own a penny. I want to eat," he recalled. In his area of Kurdistan at the time, "even you cannot clean up street if you do not become part of that group."

By early 2003, U.S. Special Forces in the region were working to unify the Kurds as allies in the invasion of Iraq. Ahmad, the only English-speaker in his KDP unit, became a translator and liaison. After Petraeus's arrival in Mosul, Ahmad's offer to work full time for the Americans was turned down on grounds it would anger his KDP commander, he said.

He deserted the KDP military and decided to try his luck at U.S. headquarters in Baghdad, taking with him the commendation for his "outstanding service and dedication to the 101st" signed by Petraeus on Sept. 11, 2003.

In Baghdad, Ahmad became a Marine translator and was sent to Anbar. In an affidavit, Gibson -- now a major -- said Ahmad was the first translator in Iraq to wear a Marine uniform, body armor and helmet, and "the first one to be entrusted with a weapon." Ahmad accompanied Gibson's Kilo Company on more than 200 patrols over seven months in violent areas of western Iraq. "I simply could not have accomplished my mission without Sam's tireless and unconditional efforts," Gibson wrote.

But threats against Ahmad's life by anti-coalition forces led the Marines to decide to get him out of Iraq. Schauble shepherded his visa application and met him at John F. Kennedy International Airport on arrival.

A USCIS "Fact Sheet" on special translator visas notes that applicants must be "otherwise admissible to the United States for permanent residence," so Ahmad and Schauble foresaw little problem in his obtaining a green card. To buttress his case, Ahmad successfully applied for political asylum once he reached the United States.

In 2006, he began applying for permanent residence -- submitting the same documents that had won him a visa and asylum -- and finished the process last August.

In the meantime, he continued working for the Marines at the Quantico-based Center for Advanced Operational Culture Learning, established in 2005 when the corps realized that its lack of knowledge and understanding of Iraq was undermining its mission.

Ahmad spends much of his time being flown by Marines to training bases around the country to provide rudimentary Arabic and cultural pointers. The maximum language training is 40 hours, which he said is too little. "But at least you can teach him to say a tactical word, how to survive," how not to shoot "a guy who didn't stop" at a checkpoint. Those on their second or third tours have more complicated queries, he said. "They say: okay, we're going to go there and it's Ramadan time, what is 'no'? What is 'do this -- don't do this'? What do I tell my Marines?"

According to Human Rights First, a nonprofit that handles similar immigration cases, groups such as the KDP do not appear on U.S. government lists of designated terrorists. Instead, determinations of "undesignated terrorist organizations" are made, case by case, by the USCIS, part of the Department of Homeland Security.

Using definitions in the Immigration and Nationality Act, the USA Patriot Act and other legislation adopted after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, it is up to USCIS officials to research an applicant's background and make a decision. According to Ahmad's denial letter, the information in his case was obtained from the Web site of the Memorial Institute for the Prevention of Terrorism, a DHS-funded nonprofit group.

The legislation contains waiver provisions -- by the secretary of state for foreign petitioners, and the secretary of homeland security for those who, like Ahmad, are already in this country. But there is no path for a denied individual to apply for a waiver.

In a velvet box in his desk drawer at Quantico, Ahmad keeps two medals he received for his service in Iraq -- the Navy-Marine Corps Achievement Medal and the War on Terrorism Expeditionary Medal. Above his computer, he has a snapshot of President Bush. He was a guest at the White House last year when Bush presented a posthumous Medal of Honor to a Marine for actions in an Anbar mission in which Ahmad participated.

Ahmad remains in this country under his special visa and asylum status, but neither one has the permanence of a green card. Under U.S. law, those granted asylum can be sent back to their country if the secretary of state determines that it is at peace and that the danger to the person has subsided.

Ahmad said he would like to return to Iraq, but only "as a Marine." He has no family there, he said, but "I have the greatest, biggest family in America. I have the USMC."

Ahmad served this country in the war zone, and is still dedicated to helping Marines before they go serve in Iraq. He would appear to be a model person to get a green card. Now I suggest you don't have anything in your mouth when you read why Ahmad was turned down.

His offense: Ahmad had once been part of the Kurdish Democratic Party, which U.S. immigration officials deemed an "undesignated terrorist organization" for having sought to overthrow former Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein.

Ahmad, a Kurd, once served in the KDP's military force, which is part of the new Iraqi army. A U.S. ally, the KDP is now part of the elected government of the Kurdish region and holds seats in the Iraqi parliament. After consulting public Web sites, however, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services determined that KDP forces "conducted full-scale armed attacks and helped incite rebellions against Hussein's regime, most notably during the Iran-Iraq war, Operation Desert Storm and Operation Iraqi Freedom."

Ahmad's association with a group that had attempted to overthrow a government -- even as an ally in U.S.-led wars against Hussein -- rendered him "inadmissible," the agency concluded in a three-page letter dated Feb. 26.

This is incredible. Ahmad gets punished for supporting our country. He would have been better off serving in the Iraqi army trying to kill Americans.

Just one more example of the insanity of the US immigration system. I name CIS aka Citizenship and Immigration Services today's Knucklehead of the Day.

Hat tip- Immigration Law Blog


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (10)

It's because he's not Latin... (Below threshold)

It's because he's not Latino, folks. Nothing against good, hard-working, patriotic Latin Americans, but the whole Immigration process is completely skewed to accept Latin Americans and virtually no one else.

The USICS person is an utte... (Below threshold)

The USICS person is an utter and complete idiot.
The US Government after Desert Storm encouraged the Kurds to over throw Saddiam.
Then we left them high and dry. Our polices under first Bush and through Clinton was regime change

Here is someone willing to use his experience knowledge and put his life on the line doing a job to Help other American succeed. The immigration bill they tried to ram down our throats gave asylum to MS-13 gang members. However, someone who supported our troops in combat can not be given due consideration. I think we need a letter writing campaign.

As sick as it clearly is, i... (Below threshold)

As sick as it clearly is, it'll probably take a private bill from a Congressman.

Does this surprise anyone? ... (Below threshold)

Does this surprise anyone? Yeah, I want govt.-run health care.......

Ahmad said, "I feel asha... (Below threshold)

Ahmad said, "I feel ashamed." No, Ahmed, WE feel ashamed that we have people in our government who would treat you this way.

There are two issues at pla... (Below threshold)

There are two issues at play. 1) the reason he was turned down, meets the letter of the law according to a faceless, unaccountable low level beurocrat, and that should be good enough for the rest of us. 2) The fact that he fought to over throw Hussein isn't the problem, it is that he was willing to fight to overthrow ANY govt is the problem. Only the U.S. Govt gets to decide who will be overthrown, and then only sanctioned GROUPS are allowed to do this, never individuals (regardless of individuals making up the group).


matt, i'm assuming you're t... (Below threshold)

matt, i'm assuming you're trying to parody what you think conservatives think. if that's true, you really don't understand conservatives. and if you truely believe what your wrote, you need some help.

And yet liberals still want... (Below threshold)
Spurwing PLover:

And yet liberals still want to give hundreds of illegal aleins perimate citizenship in america

Sounds like its easier to b... (Below threshold)

Sounds like its easier to bring home a dog than a Kurd. What BS.

Sorry langtry -- while it m... (Below threshold)

Sorry langtry -- while it may seem skewed to you, out of 1,266,264 admitted immigrants in 2006, at most 484,328 were Latino. The only country in the western hemisphere to have more immigrants to the US than, say, Russia, was Mexico.

This is not defending DHS -- the enormous power given to DHS in a knee-jerk reaction to the imperative of combating terrorism hardly matches DHS's capabilities. I've know DHS to give asylum to folks that were members of the ruling party in their homelands -- and asylum wasn't deserved -- and reject many cases where the folks had well deserved fears of persecution.






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy