« Thieving Scum | Main | Bad analogy of the day »

Feces Wrapped Up As Wisdom

My step-daughter was gushing about a book when I last spoke with her. We were discussing her upcoming graduation from the University of Houston with a degree in Marketing. Because she was unsure about what she wanted to do next, I suggested some books that ideally she ought to have read before choosing her major, but she came back with two books she was very impressed with, books she said had opened her eyes on how to arrange venture capital for her business ideas. The one she gushed on the most about, was "Rich Dad, Poor Dad" by Richard Kiyosaki and Sharon Lechter. The book boasts of it's time as a "#1 Best Seller", which apparently is the closest it ever came to establishing any sort of credentials. The cover reminded me of one of those vapid romance novels, and I was right - once I started reading the thing, it became very obvious that Mr. Kiyosaki is very enamoured of himself. The book is a poor primer on finance, but it does produce a strong chronicle of mercenary narcissism. I have since come to understand that Mr. Kiyosaki, hmm, embellished his biographical accounts with "fictionalized" citations in order to "educate" his readers. Kind of like Hillary's mythical account of her trip to Bosnia, a lie and a stupid one. In Kiyosaki's case, however, it seems there were many lies, repeated and underscored, and the man seems to care nothing for the truth - not a good quality at all in a financial advisor. It seems that writing a series of books (18 so far) for gullible readers who don't think things through to any degree, is the path Mr. Kiyosaki chose for his financial success. Caveat Emptor and so on.

The reason I wrote about Mr. Kiyosaki's Lies-For-Luxury, is because there is a lot of that out there. I mentioned Hillary's pack-o-fibs from her failed attempt at establishing foreign policy credentials, there's Obama's 'nothing unusual' association for more than two decades with an anti-American racist, and of course there's McCain's war record, both for his steadfast love of his country and comrades in Vietnam, and his stubborn determination to cut off Free Speech in McCain-Feingold, and his expeditious attack against letting Judicial nominees be guaranteed an up-or-down vote on the Senate floor*. But what's worse, is these largely self-infatuated politicians running for President are largely representative of the government we have today. You see, pretty much all of the problems Americans are worried about come into three classes:

1. Things the Government can address effectively
2. Things the Government cannot address, but individuals can
3. Things beyond human control

I won't go into an exhaustive review here, but it should be obvious that the first class is the smallest group. And what's strange, of those things that the government can address, very very few of them are the duty or within the scope of the President of the United States. Yet all the speeches from the candidates promise things that either would be addressed by Congress, or by the state or local governments, or else cannot be fixed by government at all. And speaking of non-federal government, don't be too sure that your local government is going to be a big help. Here in Houston, for example, the District Attorney had to resign, in short because he was exposed as a conniving racist who saw nothing wrong with abusing his department's budget and authority limits. The new candidates to replace him are all talking the shiny new ideal of accountability, none of them noting that such precautions were supposedly already in place. On a different level and in another place, it is both ironic and troubling that not even a week after the Governor of New York resigns because of in appropriate conduct, his replacement also admits that he had an extramarital affair, as well. Perhaps the most significant message from such stories, is that no one is really surprised anymore by them.

- continued -

I have seen this all before, and I guess the bad news is that corruption and unaccountable government is common, indeed endemic throughout the world, even here in the United States. There is some good news, in the fact that for all its flaws the United States has a better system of government (even at the federal level) than most countries, and that government in the United States is more responsive now than it used to be, especially in the age of blogs and YouTube. But mostly, the good news is that for all its power and noise, the government is no substitute for the invidual's ability to take care of his own affairs. Most Americans seem unaware that the Great Depression of the 1930s was not the first one in our history - the others were weathered largely through the strength and perseverence of ordinary people. That is not to say that government should not consider acting when and how it is able, but it is to say that a lot of the credit government takes for fixing a situation is actually due the individuals who put things back together on their own. In that light, recovery from Hurricane Katrina should be credited to the hard-working people along the Gulf Coast who rebuilt their lives on their own efforts, for example., rather than the self-praising mandarins of either FEMA or the local and state governments. And in that light, recovery from the sub-prime mortgage will basically happen because regular people work to fix the problem, from the market correcting rates and prices, to banks and financial firms taking steps to protect against unexpected volatility and debt. I am not naïve about human nature and the desire for people to hide risky ventures inside double-talk and new hybrid financial instruments - it really should have been obvious early on, that 'Collateralized Debt Obligation' was a sneak phrase for 'Junk Bond with Makeup'. But the inevitable lawsuits over this problem will likely once again teach banks and finance companies that judges and juries are not impressed with anything that won't pass the smell test. So on this point I disagree with President Bush; a radical overhaul of the Federal Reserve and the Securities and Exchange Commission will not improve consumer confidence or make the system run any better; when the problem is due to monkeys in the works, the answer is not to add more monkeys.

In conclusion, to all those people looking for a simple eay to get rich I will admit that there is one solid way to make money. There are many formulas and practices which can help build wealth, and there are any number of tactics applicable to help set financial goals, but the core principle is really very simple:

Spend less than you earn. Repeat until you are satisfied with the amount of money you have saved.

Sadly, that is a lesson no government ever seems willing to learn.

(* corrected, thanks to Professor Addison)


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (12)

If I remember that p.o.s. b... (Below threshold)

If I remember that p.o.s. book correctly, the basic premise is "work really, really hard until you have enough money to buy real estate in a marketplace that is not currently going to shit."

If someone had followed his advice to the letter five years ago and sank a ton of cash into new housing, they might very well want to punch Mr. Kiyosaki in the face.

DJ--you might consider encouraging your daughter to teach English in Japan or Korea or Taiwan. Nothing makes a 20-something-year-old Westerner fully appreciate how good life is here, than spending a year elsewhere. Also, she'll be able to save $15-20k while living like an upper-middle class citizen and traveling around Asia/Oceania on the cheap.

Kiyosaki makes it clear tha... (Below threshold)

Kiyosaki makes it clear that he is talking about fictional characters.
What is your opinion on the lessons he was trying to teach ?

"Mr. Kiyosaki's Lies-For-Luxury" is as deep as you apparently got ...

How many books on personal finance have you managed to convince people to buy ? 1 - 2 - 3 ?

Matthew ...You are... (Below threshold)

Matthew ...

You aren't remembering correctly ...

So since the books by Kiyos... (Below threshold)

So since the books by Kiyosaki are poor primers on finance what would your better choices be ?

I'm not sure why you had to bring the Kiyosaki books into a bashing of the candidates economic policies ? One has nothing to do with another ... the whole micro vs. macro thing ...

In almost any area, there a... (Below threshold)

In almost any area, there are serious books and books aimed at the "pop culture."

One tiny quibble: McCain's "Gang of 14" blocked Frist's "nuclear option" - which was NOT about "letting Judicial nominees be guaranteed an up-or-down vote in a Senate committee," but rather mandating a vote on the Senate FLOOR for nominees.

[ noted and corrected - thanks Mr. Addison - DJD ]

Well Jeff, the way to start... (Below threshold)
DJ Drummond:

Well Jeff, the way to start is with people who know something about Economics. My starting five to learn Finance properly would be:

A Random Walk Down Wall Street, by Burton Malkiel (Economist from Princeton)[ overview of the stock market in general ]

On Economics, by Milton Friedman (Nobel-winning Economist) [ Macro Economics discussion ]

Finding the Next Starbucks, by Michael Moe ( CFA, Merrill Lynch ) [ discussion of growth stocks and risk attitude ]

Magic Numbers: The 33 Key Ratios That Every Investor Should Know, by Peter Temple ( British Financial Writer and Investment analyst ) [overview of financial metrics ]

Financial Statement Analysis and Security Valuation, by Stephen Penman ( Professor, Columbia Business School ) [ examines how to analyze a company from its financial reports ]

Kiyosaki does not mention t... (Below threshold)

Kiyosaki does not mention the real wealth building method he has proven out, which is to sell seminars on how to get rich to the gullible.

Actually the best finance b... (Below threshold)

Actually the best finance book ever written is Rhe Richest Man in Babylon by George S. Clason. A much more accurate and useful book and any of these new fangled ones.

Argh - just washed my finge... (Below threshold)

Argh - just washed my fingers and can't do a thing with them.

The title of the book is "The Richest Man in Babylon".

DJI would ad... (Below threshold)

I would add to your list the following:

The Road to Serfdom and The Fatal Conceit, both by Hayek.

SOCIALISM and Man, Economy, and State with Power and Market by Mises.

Young people need to understand theory and principle first. This is how Buckley brought about the conservative revolution, Friedman prevailed on taxes and, ultimately, the success of Reagan.

If she is truly interested in business, she can download for free the Berkshire Hathaway annual letters to shareholders written by Warren Buffet. They are priceless. I reread them every year.

For a little education and ... (Below threshold)

For a little education and a lot more entertainment, might I suggest P. J. O'Rourke's "Eat The Rich?"

I'd also recommend his interpretation of "On The Wealth Of Nations," but I haven't bought that one.



For a little educatio... (Below threshold)

For a little education and a lot more entertainment

In that case I would also suggest Bonfire of the Vanities.






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy