« US Open Playoff today- Tiger Woods vs. Rocco Mediate | Main | Obama's Delusion Continues »

Genesis Of A Smear

Political smears are insidious things. They work most frequently in the shadows, out of public scrutiny. So it is a very, very rare thing to find one at its nascent stage.

Smears, at that point, are very much like subatomic particles. They cannot be observed and studied without changing them. In this particular case, I fear that discussing the situation will have the effect of stifling, perhaps even killing it outright.

That's a risk I'm more than willing to take.

Of course, I'm talking about the most-likely-mythical video of Michelle Obama denouncing "Whitey."

And yes, I am stopping short of an absolute denial that such a tape exists. I firmly believe that it was a myth, that no such thing ever happened, let alone somewhere where it might be videotaped, but stranger things have happened. I'm willing to say that I am 99.9% certain that it never happened -- but I won't go out on a limb and commit the logical fallacy of trying to prove a negative.

Now, I don't follow national politics with the level of attention to do this properly, but I think I can lay out a bit of my own observations and ideas on what's going on here.

The first person, apparently, to give the whole "whitey" issue any legs was Bob Beckel. Beckel, a lifetime Democratic activist, attributed the rumor to Larry Johnson, a former CIA analyst and Hillary Clinton supporter. Johnson said (or almost said) that he had the tape, and was ready to release it. However, when you parsed what he said very, very carefully, he never said he had the tape, never said he saw it, only that he had spoken with people who had seen it and trusted them implicitly.

Note that very, very carefully: the person at the heart of the rumor is (or, at least was) a Hillary Clinton supporter who was very critical of Barack Obama, and it was pushed on to the main stage by a guy who had worked for both Bobby Kennedy and Walter Mondale.

So, who's getting the blame for the "smearing" of Michelle Obama? Why, us big, scary, mean, evil right-wing bloggers.

Personally, I never wrote about the tape here. I did comment elsewhere that I doubted it even existed, and had my own theory about the hype -- Johnson wanted it to be true, convinced himself it did exist, and announced that it would be released in hopes of pressuring the holder of the tape to release it themselves and keep from getting "scooped" by Johnson. But when that never happened, Johnson was left looking like the delusional idiot (I'm being kind; I think it's more likely "self-aggrandizing, manipulative, unscrupulous asshole" would fit better) he is.

As hoaxes go, it wasn't too bad a one. It had, at its core, a certain plausibility -- Michelle Obama is on record of saying some rather unpleasant things (I'm thinking of the "for the first time in my adult life, I'm proud of my country" remark), as well as a long association with a church that has become infamous for its leaders saying similar things. So it was not completely out of left field (so to speak).

But on the other hand, she is nowhere near a stupid woman. She is an Ivy League-educated lawyer, and that kind of remark -- even if uttered to "fit in" with the general atmosphere of the Trinity United church crowd -- is way, way out of line. It would be the equivalent of Pat Buchanan railing against "those fucking Kikes" -- he's way too intelligent to say something so crass, so unequivocally racist and bigoted, so blatantly hateful. Even though, in Buchanan's case, I strongly suspect it has crossed his mind on numerous occasions.

But I digress. The issue here isn't whether or not Michelle Obama ever said such a thing on tape, it's who is getting blamed for pushing the rumor that she had. As noted above, the two key figures in the story -- those who put such effort into getting the rumor out -- are long-time Democratic activists, one of them a Hillary Clinton supporter.

But that's getting swept under the rug in the rush (no pun intended) to turn the whole story on its ear and blame the right wingers.

Michelle Malkin has a magnificent posting up on it, showing Bob Beckel on Fox News on two separate occasions. First, he's teasing the hell out of the existence of the tape. Then, weeks later, he's slamming the right-wingers who -- in some alternate reality -- did what he did himself. He even manages to call them "crackers."

Charles Johnson of Little Green Footballs has two pieces up on this whole sordid mess. The first covers much the same ground as Michelle Malkin's, while the second goes a bit further into the background of Beckel and Johnson -- including Johnson's sojourn as a diarist at The Daily Kos, that known hotbed of right-wing bloggers.

And if that isn't enough, let me introduce another line of argument -- the legal question, "cui bono?" "Who benefits?"

The rumors started flying just as the final nails were being driven into the casket for Hillary Clinton's campaign. The story -- if it had proven true -- would have been a devastating blow to Barack Obama's candidacy. He can jettison his preacher, his church, countless campaign staffers when they prove embarrassing, but this is his wife, his life partner. He's even more stuck with her than the Clintons are with each other.

At that point, the biggest beneficiary of his downfall would be Hillary Clinton. Clinton, the chosen candidate of chief rumor-monger Larry Johnson. Clinton, the #2 choice of the party of Bob Beckel.

If the right wing had been behind the rumors, then letting them loose at that point was incredibly stupid. There was still a chance for Obama to step aside and Hillary to take the nomination, well in advance of the convention. This is the kind of thing you sit on, you keep silent over, you hide away until it's much closer to the election. Then you hit Obama with it, and you not only take down his candidacy, but leave the Democrats very little time for damage control -- not only will you take out whoever they choose to replace him, but you cause incalculable damage all the way down the ticket. "Whitey" could have, in theory, helped the Republicans not only keep the White House, but given them a fighting chance at Congress. This whole mess broke at the worst possible time for them, politically speaking.

Keep an eye on this matter. The myth that the whole "whitey" tape was cooked up and pushed by the Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy will continue to be pushed forward more and more, and the true origins will be forcefully forgotten by the Keepers Of The Records. Unless enough people call them on it each and every single time they try to push it.

Because, to them, "truth" is only relevant when it serves A Greater Purpose. And if Bob Beckel and Larry Johnson have to get swept under the carpet (it's a little difficult to recast them as rabid right-wingers, so they're best forgotten) to serve The Greater Purpose, then so be it.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (12)

Keep an eye on thi... (Below threshold)
Keep an eye on this matter. The myth that the whole "whitey" tape was cooked up and pushed by the Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy will continue to be pushed forward more and more, and the true origins will be forcefully forgotten by the Keepers Of The Records. Unless enough people call them on it each and every single time they try to push it.

The nutshell rebuttal: Why would the VRWC try to save Hillary and not save this so-called bombshell just days before the general election?

The return leftie rebuttal to that is more likely to be "Republicans wanted to run against Hillary because McCain had better odds of beating her than Obama".

So I axe you: Why would they take out Hillary when they had a bombshell against Obama that was sure to hand the election to Republicans?

There's nothing more to say because the leftie argument doesn't hold up to scrutiny. But they hope enough of "No news watching average Americans, who catch sound bites at election time" will think the worse to towards Republicans.

And the lefties will push this was a right wing smear for Obama sympathy votes fer shore. Poor, poor Obama, how can he win against such racism from the right wing in this country? Ya'll get the gist.

Best thing to do is every conservative blog and talk show host should demand Obama apologize for blaming a Hillary smear on Republicans. Keep it on the front page a few days. Enough average Americans may then understand the "actual" leftie smear.

Another outstanding post Ja... (Below threshold)

Another outstanding post Jay. Thanks for bringing it all together.

It is my opinion that Larry... (Below threshold)

It is my opinion that Larry Johnson is the root of this story and that the tape is bogus. I went through his various postings and over the course of the several weeks that he teased and prodded this story, key details changed.

The number of sources who confirmed the story for Larry Johnson changed with each telling. On June 7 the story was confirmed by 2 sources. However, five days earlier on June 2 he had 5 sources confirming the tape.

The party membership of the sources changed too. On May 19 he had 4 sources all Republicans confirming the tape. Yet two days later on May 21, his 4 sources were 3 Republicans and a prominent Democrat.

At one point he goes to great length to emphasize that the Obama campaign has a copy of the tape. According to Larry he got confirmation of this from a prominent Democrat and Obama supporter.

If this is a Republican disinformation campaign, why is a Democrat confirming the tape? Did Larry lie about that? If he lied about that then what else is he lying about?

There is no "Whitey" tape. ... (Below threshold)

There is no "Whitey" tape. Better luck with your next smear.


from what i understand, alo... (Below threshold)
Dave W:

from what i understand, alot of media sources are trying to blame Rush Limbaugh for this "rumor" even though he didn't say a word of it on his show for about 2 weeks. Why should anyone be suprised about this? This is how the liberals work. They put something in the mainstream, wait for a right-winger to comment on it, and then spin it way out of control like the right-winger brought it up, suggested it, agreed with it wholeheartedly and wants to kill puppies in addition to everything else.

Lets not forget who these idiots are and start electing people who are going to fight back. Where are these people? Hell if i know, but someone needs to find them.

There is no "White... (Below threshold)
There is no "Whitey" tape. Better luck with your next smear

No s**t Sherlock that there is no tape.

The Hillary blogs that were pushing it were sure hopeful while the conservative blogs doubted its existence.

So who are you addressing when you say "Better luck with "your" next smear" since we know the source was Hillary supporters at a very interesting time: "just before the primaries ended and the super delegates need to "shite or get off the pot"?

But then I did say the lefties would push the "The Republicans Did It!!!" mantra. Exhibit "A" posted by [email protected]

What this whole thing prove... (Below threshold)

What this whole thing proves, again, is the MSM's inability to contradict anything the left says. ww

Let's see... I go out of my... (Below threshold)

Let's see... I go out of my way to say that I don't think there ever was such a tape, and prove beyond a reasonable doubt that it was Clintonistas who were pushing it, and STILL [email protected] wants to give "us" the credit for it.

Poor fellow. His name is woefully incomplete. "[email protected], [email protected]" is a bit more descriptive.


...and had my own ... (Below threshold)
...and had my own theory about the hype -- Johnson wanted it to be true, convinced himself it did exist, and announced that it would be released in hopes of pressuring the holder of the tape to release it themselves...

I disagree Jay. I think this whole tape issue was a lie and an intentional disinformation gag cooked up by Larry Johnson. The CIA specializes in spreading disinformation and using misdirection to mask the source. Larry is former CIA.

Any piece of disinformation has to have a grain of believability to it. With the Jeremiah Wright problem in the news, with Michelle Obama making questionable statements, her saying "Whitey" wasn't unbelievable.

So the disinformation gag does several things; first it sows fear, undercertainty and doubt into the Obama supporters and most importantly into the superdelegates. Here's what he said on May 16.

"Does Barack have an obligation to tell the Democrats, super delegates in particular, about this tape? Did Barack and his campaign do their basic homework and identify this tape as a potential problem? And, more importantly, do they have a copy? Probably better to deal with this issue before the convention rather than wait for October."

Notice how he brings up the superdelegates and warns how this might come back to haunt them in October when it's too late to change to Hillary.

The second part of the operation which has been successful, was to pin it on the Republicans. It has now become the narrative that this is a Republican smear.

Throughout his many postings he talks about all of the Republicans who have the tape and how they are going to use it. He brings up Karl Rove and some mysterious billionaire (Scaife?), who are fighting over how to release the tape. All misdirection to blame the Republicans.

The whole tape story was all a great big lie to get people so nervous about Obama that they went over to Hillary with the icing on the cake, it all gets blamed on the Republicans.

"[email protected]" Fi... (Below threshold)

"[email protected]"

First real laugh of the day. Thanks.

Why do you automatically as... (Below threshold)

Why do you automatically assume that "your" referred to the right? I deliberately left the accusation ambiguous. I think you protest too much.

[email protected], you failed English ... (Below threshold)
John Irving:

[email protected], you failed English class, didn't you?






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy