« Cooking Polls - State Poll Edition | Main | About That Campaign Worker Attack... »

Breaking: Obama Supporter Attacks and Mutilates McCain Volunteer

Drudge has the headline in red. These Obama cultists are dangerous and out of control. What the hell will these people do if the messiah loses on November 4th?


Is this the new strategy to get Obama elected? Vote Obama or we'll riot, mutilate people and destroy property? Keep in mind, community activists used intimidation to get banks to give home loans to minority and high risk customers. They stormed bank lobbies and scared away customers. They harassed bank presidents at their homes. It seems they're willing to go even further and actually mutilate a McCain supporter. Will voters with McCain signs in their front yards be targeted, too?

To me, this is an argument to defeat Obama soundly on November 4th. We will not be intimidated into voting for Obama.

Update: Here's the story. A woman was robbed at an ATM in Pittsburgh. The guy was apparently going to leave until he saw her McCain/Palin sticker on her car. That's when he attacked her and mutilated her, carving a "B" on her face. An Obama supporter robbing someone, at random it seems, at an ATM and then leaving the mark of the messiah on her face when he sees she supports McCain. Thug.

Update II: Ed Morrissey has more, including a photo of the victim. She's identified herself as Ashley Todd, who's a College Republican field rep.

Update III: I got an email from a reader:

Just spoke with my friend who is a McCain staffer here in Pittsburgh. She said the woman was attacked after she left a McCain campaign meeting last night on the University of Pittsburgh campus. The assailant is described as african american male and she has identified, in detail, the attackers shoes. He beat her up "really bad" she said. Pittsburgh Police are in possession of a horrific photograph of the victim.

Update IV: Here's another report:

Pittsburgh police spokeswoman Diane Richards says the woman was withdrawing money at 9 p.m. Wednesday when a man approached her from behind, put a knife to her neck and demanded money. She says she gave him $60.

The woman told police the robber then noticed the bumper sticker, punched her in the back of the head, knocked her down and carved a "B" on her face.

Some commenters are accusing the victim of faking her attack. Well, according to the report above, she was standing right in front of the ATM at the time he robbed her, so the security camera will tell us what happened. Added: This is happening now.

Lorie adds: If the media is fair about it, this story will get a lot more attention than some idiot who may or may not have yelled "Kill Him" at a McCain rally. Any media report that does not include Obama's instructions for his supporters to "get in their faces" will be incomplete and do a disservice to news consumers by not giving them the full story. My husband says this won't get as much attention as the McCain angry mob story did. Come on ABCBSNBCNN, prove me and my husband wrong. It will be easy enough to check and I am sure someone will by comparing the Google and Nexis hits of the two stories. I know those in the media can't be shamed or embarrassed into giving McCain and Obama equal treatment, but this is just such a clear cut case -- I can't believe they would want to give their critics this kind of ammunition. UPDATE: After seeing the picture, I am suspicious about this story. The cut looks really clean and straight to have been done in a violent attack, but that is something the police will surely sort out, like the Secret Service did those "kill him" McCain angry mob chants. If this were to turn out to be of similar dubiousness, I wonder if the media will cover them similarly. If this turns out to be the real deal expect a big yawn, but if it is a hoax, it will get plenty of attention. Probably more than this story did anyway. UPDATE II: Michelle Malkin has more info and I will be surprised if this is not a hoax. This woman sounds like she might need some help. I noticed tonight that Palin is speaking in Pittsburgh in the morning. That makes me wonder if Todd thought this was a way to meet her.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (148)

PITTSBURGH -- A 20-year-old... (Below threshold)

PITTSBURGH -- A 20-year-old woman who was robbed at an ATM in Bloomfield was also maimed by her attacker, police said.

Pittsburgh police spokeswoman Diane Richard tells Channel 4 Action News that the victim was robbed at knifepoint on Wednesday night outside of a Citizens Bank near Liberty Avenue and Pearl Street just before 9 p.m.

Richard said the robber took $60 from the woman, then became angry when he saw a McCain bumper sticker on the victim's car. The attacker then punched and kicked the victim, before using the knife to scratch the letter "B" into her face, Richard said.

Richard said the woman refused medical treatment after the assault, which happened outside the view of the bank's surveillance cameras.

The robber is described as a dark-skinned black man, 6 feet 4 inches tall, 200 pounds with a medium build, short black hair and brown eyes. The man was wearing dark colored jeans, a black undershirt and black shoes.


Looks more like a mugger th... (Below threshold)

Looks more like a mugger than an "Obama supporter."

Agreed. Not that the politi... (Below threshold)
mcg Author Profile Page:

Agreed. Not that the political angle doesn't matter, but this is a story of a thug who'd have been a thug in a non-election year, too.

Uhhh, yeah Carlos, he carve... (Below threshold)

Uhhh, yeah Carlos, he carved "B" into her for "mugger". Riiiiiiiight!

Carlos,Most the ti... (Below threshold)


Most the time they are the same thing. Voting to steal other people's money is only slightly less moral than this method.

Here's where McCain volunte... (Below threshold)

Here's where McCain volunteer came from:

McCain staffer says she was mugged, had 'B' cut into face
Thursday, October 23, 2008
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Pittsburgh Police are investigating a report by a campaign staffer for John McCain that she was mugged and the letter B was cut into her face.

Police say the 20-year-old woman, who is from Texas, reported that the attack occurred yesterday in one of the city's eastern neighborhoods.

But they said the woman told them she did not seek medical treatment.
More details in tomorrow's Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.


These are the kind of thing... (Below threshold)

These are the kind of things that are so over the top that they often tend to be bogus BS. It would not be the first time somebody has faked something like this to get attention and made everyone look foolish for getting bent out of shape. I recommend restraint in the outrage department until this is better confirmed.

of course i meant "slightly... (Below threshold)

of course i meant "slightly less immoral" - oh well.

I'm confused--are Obama sup... (Below threshold)

I'm confused--are Obama supporters all a bunch of Prius-driving latté-sipping arugula-chomping book-reading school-attending elitists, or are they deranged muggers?

hyper - "I'm confused--... (Below threshold)

hyper - "I'm confused--are Obama supporters all a bunch of Prius-driving latté-sipping arugula-chomping book-reading school-attending elitists, or are they deranged muggers?"

You forgot the third option, potential Canadian citizens.


hyper - "I'm confused--a... (Below threshold)
The Listkeeper:

hyper - "I'm confused--are Obama supporters all a bunch of Prius-driving latté-sipping arugula-chomping book-reading school-attending elitists, or are they deranged muggers?"

You forgot the third option, potential Canadian citizens.

Canada won't take em.

Website of the angry milita... (Below threshold)
Adrian Browne:

Website of the angry militant Obama supporters:


Yes We CARVE !!!! It's rather shocking.

Hey now marc, be fair! I re... (Below threshold)

Hey now marc, be fair! I read that comment on my iPhone while driving my Prius and spilled a latté all over these great wool slacks that I stole from one of Stephen Harper's campaign workers at knifepoint. I resent your generalization.

Always nice to hear a happy... (Below threshold)

Always nice to hear a happy story on this scummy website.

Don't let this most likely ... (Below threshold)

Don't let this most likely bogus incident distract us from the real issues, such as Sarah Palin's wardrobe.

Hey billg, if this is such ... (Below threshold)

Hey billg, if this is such a scummy website, then why are you here?

That's a lot of taxes she's... (Below threshold)

That's a lot of taxes she's going to have to pay on those duds, OregonMuse, regardless of whether she gifts them afterwards and goes back to the gubernatorial Carharts. For the time being, though, the lady has nice threads--to lose in. Hey-o!

It's a scummy website be... (Below threshold)

It's a scummy website because billg is here.

Hotair has a photo of the w... (Below threshold)

Hotair has a photo of the woman "allegedly" attacked. I can't believe(well I can actually)that the liberals on this site are actually condoning this action. It appears this way according to some of the posts here. If this is the case you liberals officially make me sick.

...and hyperbolist, peabrai... (Below threshold)

...and hyperbolist, peabrain3000, and the rest of their ilk.

As a McCain supporter mysel... (Below threshold)

As a McCain supporter myself, I kinda wish you would stay away from stories like this. It sounds so bogus. Similar to this taped phone call from Michelle Obama that API claims to have.

Uhhh, yeah Carlos, he c... (Below threshold)

Uhhh, yeah Carlos, he carved "B" into her for "mugger". Riiiiiiiight!

Uhh, Yeah D-Hoggs. I'm sure this man is actually a pillar in his community, when he doesn't have Barack Obama around to stir him up. Riiiiiiiight!.

Adrian, those were some sca... (Below threshold)

Adrian, those were some scary pumpkins. Except the stem made his logo look like "Alfalfa".

I wonder why she would refuse medical treatment?

The B is backwards -... (Below threshold)
Adrian Browne:

The B is backwards -- she did it herself by looking in the mirror.

anyone know the significanc... (Below threshold)

anyone know the significance of the 'B'?

worded that badly. carving... (Below threshold)

worded that badly. carving the first letter of Barack? I'm not questioning the woman's account, but didn't know that Obama supporters went around tagging with a 'B'.

jmc, and this "pillar in hi... (Below threshold)

jmc, and this "pillar in his community" didn't just rob his victim. The story says he was going to leave, but got angry when he saw her McCain/Palin sticker, beats her up and carves a "B" on her face. Evidently, Obama will make him even more of a "pillar" (of salt) in his community. Geesh!

Welcome to the brave new wo... (Below threshold)
steve m:

Welcome to the brave new world of "Change". The Fascists are becoming more emboldened, where will it end? When will law-abiding citizens speak-up? Have we become a Nation of Cowards?

If this seems familiar . . ... (Below threshold)
Adrian Browne:
"Uhh, Yeah D-Hoggs. I'm sur... (Below threshold)

"Uhh, Yeah D-Hoggs. I'm sure this man is actually a pillar in his community, when he doesn't have Barack Obama around to stir him up. Riiiiiiiight!."

Umm, he's obviously not jmc, ya genius. Apparently you didn't understand my sarcasm pointed at Carlos who tried to claim the guy wasn't a Barack supporter but just some random mugger that likes to carve the letter B into people's faces. Nothing to see here!!

Be skeptical as you will, b... (Below threshold)

Be skeptical as you will, but imagine how this would be spinning right now in the MSM if a black Obambi supporter had had a "J" scratched into her face.

Arma-fscking-geddon, kids.

The rest of the story. <br ... (Below threshold)

The rest of the story.
He went off, beat and cut her after seeing the McCain sticker on her car. That is a hate crime. Come on liberal slime, defend the criminal slime. Is the FBI involved yet or are hate crimes like racism, only whites can commit them?

IF this is a hoax I'll be o... (Below threshold)

IF this is a hoax I'll be one of the first to say she needs to go to jail, but you liberals can't even denounce this action IF it's real. You people are a real piece of work.

We're gonna spread happines... (Below threshold)

We're gonna spread happiness
We're gonna spread freedom
Obama's gonna change it
Obama's gonna lead 'em

We're gonna change it
And rearrange it
We're gonna change the world!

Adrian--did it ever cross y... (Below threshold)

Adrian--did it ever cross your mind that after the guy beat the crap out of her she was laying on the ground with her head near him and her feet away from him when he carved her face?! No, it didn't, because I'm sure you think she gave herself those lovely black eyes too.

Liberals simply following t... (Below threshold)

Liberals simply following the instructions of the 'one' to get in people's face.

And liberal larry will experience more of the changes the democrats promised in 2006 when the stock market was 15,000, unemployment 4.5%, and gas $2.20 per gallon. Todays world is the effect of the democrats promise to change the direction of the most productive economy in the history of the country. The opposite of good is evil and booming economy is destroyed economy. All for political purposes,then for a fact the democrats care more for their personal power than for the people.

Oh for the love of...... (Below threshold)

Oh for the love of...

It goes without saying that this is a very shitty thing done by a very shitty person who appears to be an Obama supporter. The ridiculous comments made by "the left" in this thread are a response to the ridiculous implication that this is somehow in character with your average Obama supporter.

Ed Morrissey's post is very well written and he is careful to point out that it would be stupid to generalize about any ticket's supporters based on the actions of a nutjob. It was stupid when people claimed that Bill Gwatney's murder was in character for a Republican, and it's stupid to imply that Democrats are the sort of people who carve up a 20 year old girl's face because they dislike her bumper stickers.

Chip, by your reasoning, any time someone doesn't denounce something they must tacitly support it. That's pretty glib.

While it could be fake, sin... (Below threshold)

While it could be fake, since the left was willing to believe that Randy Rhoades, Keri Dunn and others were attacked for their beliefs, I am certain they will extend the benefit of the doubt to this young woman while the police investigate.

But then again...

Scrapiron, LiberalLarry was... (Below threshold)

Scrapiron, LiberalLarry was parodying liberals, pretty sure. Your "point" stands regardless.

Hey lefty assclowns, how ab... (Below threshold)

Hey lefty assclowns, how about just "this was real crummy and they ought to catch the puke that did this. Our thoughts are for the girl to recover soon".

Nope, gotta claim she's faked it, the guy really wasn't an Obama supporter, blah blah blah. From throwing pies at conservative speakers to vandelizing Norm Coleman's garage to screaming BUSHITLER to hoping for the AQ to beat us in Iraq to wishing Tony Snow and Cheney to die to blocking recruiting stations to making unbelievable attacks on Palin.......I could literally go on and on. These few examples show us continuously who the left is. Some scumbag cutting up a girl after he discovers she's a conservative just furthur reenforces our belief that such hateful people don't deserve to be in power.

No hyperbolist, an... (Below threshold)

No hyperbolist,

anytime something so heinous happens and they minimalize it such as has been done in this thread is when the perception could be made that the action is supported. You guys do the same to us, but this act IF true is truly heinous and should not be minimalized until proven a hoax, then you can belittle the woman all you want.

If obama wins God only know... (Below threshold)

If obama wins God only knows the damage he and his tribe will do? If he looses, are his followers going to riot? I think obama is going to divide the people more then ever win or loose. And I blame the media for building him up as a god (mainly because he is black and liberal)..and a lot people believed every word of it. And I think black people are going to vote for him because of skin color and for no other reason.
I like people who think like I do, not who look like I do.

Sounds fishy to me. We'll ... (Below threshold)

Sounds fishy to me. We'll see.

First: See if it's true.... (Below threshold)
a. moral:

First: See if it's true.
Second: See if it's true
Third: If so, feel sad, but it's certainly not an indictment of Obama or his supporters.
Fourth: Feel free to speculate, however, how this would be treated if the "shoe were on the other foot" - I would expect marches, candlelight vigils, calls for "healing" (code for vote Obama).
Fifth: Re-think the notion of allowing convicted felons to vote.

I'm going to reserve judgem... (Below threshold)

I'm going to reserve judgement about this. I still recommend restraint until there is more confirmation from the police. There have been too many examples of sick hoaxes from BOTH sides of the political spectrum to ignore the possibility.

Whether she is the victim or the perpetrator of a hoax, either way this is the work of a sick mind and it needs to be prosecuted.

You folks are just fricking... (Below threshold)

You folks are just fricking unbelievable.

This is somebody's daughter.

What the f*ck is happening to this country?

If this is fake the woman m... (Below threshold)

If this is fake the woman must go to jail.

If it is TRUE, then a WARNING shall go out to ANY and ALL Bambi supporters!!!!!

YOU will be dealt with.

I have a McCain sticker on my car, along with an NRA sticker.
Guess what kind of response to
aggressive Obama bullshit you will get from me???

If Bambi loses the election and the sheep want to riot?
We can respond to THAT game too....

This country will NOT be trampled over by punk thugs. THEY WILL be dealt with.

I saw the pic on Drudge. T... (Below threshold)

I saw the pic on Drudge. The fact that the B is carved backwards and the black eyes look fake-NO puffiness at all, makes me think it's faked.

Not out of the question for that area I guess, but just judging by the photo, I'm guessing it's a hoax.

Apparently you didn't u... (Below threshold)

Apparently you didn't understand my sarcasm pointed at Carlos who tried to claim the guy wasn't a Barack supporter but just some random mugger that likes to carve the letter B into people's faces. Nothing to see here!!

Apparently you didn't understand my sarcasm directed at you for your poor reading comprehension.

Here is what Carlos wrote:

"Looks more like a mugger than an "Obama supporter."

Meaning Carlos thinks of the man as more of a criminal then a political activist. Definitely nothing to see here!

Yeah, the B is backwards, a... (Below threshold)

Yeah, the B is backwards, and it looks like she scratched it into her cheek with a fingernail. She's a nut, folks. She probably even forgot that the ATM camera taped the whole hoax.

i dont want to doubt the st... (Below threshold)

i dont want to doubt the story purely on political grounds but it sounds weird eh?

i saw the picture... and its said she refused medical treatment? picture holding down or otherwise restraining someone who is fearing for their life, and carefully scratching an even, legible letter onto the soft, slippery skin of their face without causing any significant bleeding. i honestly dont see how its possible, even if the alleged attacker had somehow been able to get her to be completely cooperative

BTW im a liberal anti-bu$h republican in favor of gun ownership rights that would discourage alleged crimes like these. i own a couple of beauts and im a damned good shot. any red points for that?? =]

Lib'-larry if "it" does win... (Below threshold)

Lib'-larry if "it" does win, if I were you, I would keep my mouth shut. Open it around the wrong person and it could be your last. Lowlife.

Ooooh, crazy ol' jhow, thre... (Below threshold)

Ooooh, crazy ol' jhow, threatening to kill someone for saying something he doesn't like! You're a piece of sh*t, you know that?

It works like this:<... (Below threshold)

It works like this:

By following a charismatic leader, some humans get the idea that this makes them more important than they can otherwise justify in their daily life.

Those same people, lacking is self generated self esteem, can be from an assortment of life styles and life choices.

Yes, up to and including a mugger.

The type of leadership that Barack Obama has selected as his "Style," can often yield exactly the result displayed by this story.

And this is one of about three reasons why I will not be voting for him this November.

Frankly, self styled messiahs scare the hell out of me, not so much for what they might do, but rather, what their followers will most certainly do in the name of the "Cause" that is so much bigger than themselves.

First the charisma, then the fear, then more charisma, then the brown shirts. And yes, I meant exactly what I said. Our system of government precludes what happened in the Weimer Republic and I personally do not link or think that Obama is a modern Hitler.

What I am pointing out is the that cult of personality politics leads to excess, especially when the style is intentional. And no question in the case of Barack Obama, it is intentional.

Again, it isn't what Dear Leader does, it is what his self deluded followers do in the name of Dear Leader.

Page 11.

Anyone who will rob at a AT... (Below threshold)

Anyone who will rob at a ATM could well steal a car as well.

But the backwards B in some photos certainly suggests she used a mirror to make the mark on her own face and the story is a hoax on the other hand.

When I used to be a lead singer for a punk rock band in 1979, I used to use a mirror to write VOID on my forehead because it looked disturbing. If you didn't use two mirrors it came out backwards. But it looked creepy and outrageous for stage and use, and washed right off along with the other stage makeup and silver hair dye I used.

Ooooh, crazy ol' jhow, t... (Below threshold)
The Listkeeper:

Ooooh, crazy ol' jhow, threatening to kill someone for saying something he doesn't like! You're a piece of sh*t, you know that?

And he's still a better example of humanity than you'll ever be.

It's good to be skeptical, ... (Below threshold)

It's good to be skeptical, kinda like you guys and the media were with that story of the perosn that yelled "Kill him" at the Palin rally. Oh yeah the Secret Service investigated that and couldn't find ONE person to corroborate the story.
Where is all the media on this story?

I'm saying it could be a hoax but don't minimalize it to the point of being crass.

Sounds fishy.If true... (Below threshold)
Les Nessman:

Sounds fishy.
If true, the guy who did it should be drawn and quartered. Literally.
If a hoax, the woman deserves serious jail time.

And he's still a better... (Below threshold)

And he's still a better example of humanity than you'll ever be.

said the nut defending the man who insinuates violence against others for disagreeing.

I think this is fishy, but ... (Below threshold)

I think this is fishy, but I am loving the liberals harping about "generalizations" when they link everyone from McVeigh to Hitler as being rebublican. Hyper and Pea, your hypocrisy is truly amazing. Paul H. you are one weird dude. ww

Remember college republican... (Below threshold)
Joe Isuzu:

Remember college republican Francisco Nava's assault at Princeton?

Coming from another college republican, I think I'll take this with a grain of salt, thank you.

Willie, have you actually e... (Below threshold)

Willie, have you actually ever heard or read anyone claiming that Hitler was a Republican? Have I? I don't know McVeigh's party allegiance but he was right wing. And more to the point, who the f*ck cares about Timothy McVeigh? What has he got to do with this subject? I don't think you know how to use the word 'hypocrisy' properly. That's alright, you'll learn what it means when you get to the sixth grade.

Listkeeper, I'm not sure you know what the word 'humanity' means, or at least how it might be applied to a neanderthal like jhow who is too stupid to realize that "LiberalLarry" is parodying liberals. Ah whatever, shine on you crazy diamond!

This woman is so stupid, sh... (Below threshold)

This woman is so stupid, she carved the "B" into her own face using a mirror. The "B" is backwards.


How long did it take the mu... (Below threshold)

How long did it take the mugger to make a perfect backwards B with a knife that doesn't break the skin?

And what's up with all the "mutilated" and "maimed" headlines? Could Republicans try to be a little more obvious about their sensationalism?

Sorry Dale but conservative... (Below threshold)

Sorry Dale but conservatives can't hold a candle to liberals in the press and their distorted headlines.

You get an "E" for effort though.

Don't you people see this w... (Below threshold)

Don't you people see this whole thing is a hoax orchestrated by Karl Rove to divide us? President Obama will UNITE us. He'll bring all Americans together, black, brown, jews, muslims. And we'll need to be unite if we're to stand up against the greatest evil this country has ever faced: Rich people! Did you know that every one of the hijackers on 9/11 made over $250,000 a year? But Bush chose instead to go after Muslims. Obama won't take his eye off the ball and will make sure that rich people leave and take their big greedy corporations out of our country once and for all.

Pretty fishy. It's Kim thou... (Below threshold)

Pretty fishy. It's Kim though, and it's Wizbang, so don't expect a correction or apology if it turns out to be false.

Either way, I feel bad for this poor woman.

My gosh you people... (Below threshold)
dr lava:

My gosh you people are just incredibly gullible. I realize that this is a very trying time for you "conservatives" [whatever that means anymore]. But you could try to exhibit some self respect and not totally meltdown in public.

Could you guys appear to any further out of touch?

cops say the wound was self... (Below threshold)

cops say the wound was self inflcted ergo she's a liar!!!

Watch this space for mine j... (Below threshold)

Watch this space for mine jp2, because if it turns out to be a hoax I will apologize specifically to you, but won't hold my breath for yours if it turns out to be true.
Yeah the B looks like she did it herself, but could have also been done with him standing or kneeling over her with her feet away from him.

ww:even though im ... (Below threshold)


even though im accustomed to neocons blathering incoherently and frantically, im still curious as to how i would qualify as a hypocrite

Dude just followin' odas, g... (Below threshold)

Dude just followin' odas, gittin' 'n da' bitch's face 'n all. Ya' can't be sure he be meanin' "B" fo' Barack o' "B" fo' Beatch, but ain' dat free speech? He be doin' da' gummint's job, yo, redistirbutin' da' welf, 'n doin' sum reparatin' while he at fun' raisin' fo' Obama 'n ACORN. Jes start'n, whitey.

/sarc off

It's racist to say it lately, but there are dark days ahead in America.

twolaneflash,I'll ... (Below threshold)


I'll say it, that wasn't even funny, and I'm a little offended.

Word, Chip. Nowhere is it i... (Below threshold)

Word, Chip. Nowhere is it indicated that this crime (if it happened) was racially motivated, except in your comment, twolane. Pretty sh*tty thing to say. How would you feel if you were a black person and you read that comment?

Peabody, don't bother asking Willie to explain his choice of words, you'll get a headache.

Ace of Spades makes a good ... (Below threshold)

Ace of Spades makes a good point. If the mugger was holding her face in the crook of his left arm (which would put her face upside down to him), and was right-handed, the B looks exactly as you'd expect it to. It looks like it was rubbed on with the eraser of a No.2 pencil.

However, it doesn't explain a black eye (or two) without a hint of puffiness or injury other than "bruising".

It may have happened but I thought that it had happened in the last 24 hours. I would expect her to look a lot worse for having been "beaten badly".

Link, Rachel? Or was this s... (Below threshold)

Link, Rachel? Or was this something you overheard a cop in a bar say to his drinking buddies?

hyperbolist - i think he... (Below threshold)

hyperbolist - i think he'll get a headache. thats why i asked LOL

peabody, you almost ... (Below threshold)

peabody, you almost make hyper sound informed...

Paul Hooson:<p... (Below threshold)

Paul Hooson:

I am calling you out son. Rather than look for the truth, you jumped, leaped, pissed in your pants to make it look like something it was not.

According to the police report, the officer confirmed that he "observed the wound on the right side of [her] face.

Emphasis added. Sheesh. . .

Look at the picture again. Look at it long and hard Paul Hooson. IT IS A MIRROR IMAGE YOU CRETIN. Paul, you should be ashamed of yourself.

At one point in time, I had some respect for you. At this point, I don't.

And as for the rest of your turkeys who were trying to make it out the girl's fault, go read my diatribe on idiots involved in a personality cult. Your picture is there.

OUCH lamedusa, good one! zi... (Below threshold)

OUCH lamedusa, good one! zing zinggg!!!!


"It's Kim though, and it's ... (Below threshold)

"It's Kim though, and it's Wizbang, so don't expect a correction or apology if it turns out to be false."

And, of course, there's jp2 who's too stupid to figure out the story is from Drudge. You and your apology crap. What gall.

"OUCH lamedusa, good one! z... (Below threshold)

"OUCH lamedusa, good one! zing zinggg!!!!"

No, pea, it's just your lefty-huddle concussion talking, and of course nothing of substance to add to the post.

If the media is fair abo... (Below threshold)

If the media is fair about it, this story will get a lot more attention than some idiot who may or may not have yelled "Kill Him" at a McCain rally.

Yeah- tell me how that works out.

lamedusa:<a href="... (Below threshold)
Larry, do you believe it be... (Below threshold)

Larry, do you believe it because she's working for McCain? People pull these kinds of hoaxes fairly frequently.

...whereas you contribute s... (Below threshold)

...whereas you contribute substance every time you smear your inane drivel on a thread, right LaMedusa? Ooooh, tell us again how much you hate Obama! It's interesting stuff.

Barry: a threat of violence against a Presidential candidate is newsworthy. So is a woman getting beaten and mugged. What the mugging has to do with Obama as such, though, is beyond me. Obama didn't get mugged, and he didn't mug anybody. It has nothing to do with him.

No shammy, I believe... (Below threshold)

No shammy, I believe it because I saw her picture. I know what people look like who get beat up. Now picture someone knocking her to the ground and standing over her. The B would look exactly like that carved on the right side of her face as seen by the perp.

Yeah, what I said.... (Below threshold)

Yeah, what I said.

I've still never seen a black eye with no swelling.

I think it's fair to ask th... (Below threshold)

I think it's fair to ask the question "What if the skin color of the 2 involved had been reversed?"

Does anyone, with an honest bone in their body, think that the MSM and cronies would not have interupted their broadcasts and that it would lead the headlines tomorrow in the Times and other "National" papers?

Race pimps like Rev. Al, JJ and King Louis would be lining up for "peace marches" and even more ppl would be pressured to assuage their white guilt and vote for the ONE.

Of course pointing this out is code for racist. I've come to the understanding that the word "racist" is really code for anyone who can think for themselves and is meant to end arguments that liberals can't win on intellectual or moral grounds.

...whereas you con... (Below threshold)
...whereas you contribute substance every time you smear your inane drivel on a thread, right LaMedusa? Ooooh, tell us again how much you hate Obama! It's interesting stuff.

Yes, it is. Which one of the real reasons you keep coming back here, to read the other comments. Unfortunately, your other reason is still just to "pick a fight".

Lorie sez:"but this ... (Below threshold)
Adrian Browne:

Lorie sez:
"but this is just such a clear cut case"

Good pun!

That people are investing millions and millions and millions of dollars in the candidacy of Barack Obama without first checking that he's really eligible to be the President and has faked his own birth certificate is more believable than this story.


Look at the picture agai... (Below threshold)

Look at the picture again. Look at it long and hard Paul Hooson. IT IS A MIRROR IMAGE YOU CRETIN. Paul, you should be ashamed of yourself.
At one point in time, I had some respect for you. At this point, I don't.

Ooh, Larry... this one is going to hurt when you figure it out.

I am loving the liberals... (Below threshold)

I am loving the liberals harping about "generalizations" when they link everyone from McVeigh to Hitler as being rebublican


<a href="http://www.merriam... (Below threshold)


But regarding the post itself, if it is a hoax with missing info, it is Drudge who'll have to fess up.

After seeing the picture, I... (Below threshold)

After seeing the picture, I have some doubts. I'm skeptical until I see a full police report.

A coule of thoughts pop up,... (Below threshold)
Thomas Jackson:

A coule of thoughts pop up, first where are the security camera film. Then why did she not go to a hospital?

While the Obamaists have done some despicable things this sounds like the work of a mugger/loon rather than an attack on a McCain supporter.

The film will tell the tale.

Hoax.Check it out:... (Below threshold)


Check it out:

Racial Mugging Victim Helpfully Twittered Her Terrible Tale -


Shortly before a John McCain campaign volunteer was reportedly robbed at knifepoint and had a "B" carved in her face after her assailant noticed that her car carried a McCain bumper sticker, the woman blogged last night that she was "Stubbornly searching for a bank of america to avoid ATM fees" and had somehow ended up "on the wrong side of pittsburgh."


Pittsburgh law enforcement sources tell TMZ they have serious questions about the authenticity of the alleged victim who says she had her face cut by a politically-motivated attacker.

We're told there are several things about the alleged attack that don't add up. A Pittsburgh PD official says they are conducting a "thorough investigation" and have not determined if the alleged attack is real or a hoax. But we're told there is definitely a level of skepticism.


Okay, I have cooled ... (Below threshold)

Okay, I have cooled off.

First of all, the picture is a mirror image. So I was extremely unhappy that someone, multiple of the usual suspects, was trying to make it like she used a mirror to do it to herself.

That was just dumb. And it was reaching.

Now could it be that it is a put up job? Of course it can be exactly that. But contrary to one socalled pundit, it doesn't happen all the time in a political context.

It does happen in domestic cases.

You gotta be drinking a lot of Kook Aid to automatically assume that the girl did it to herself. If she did, shame on her. Meantime, shame on those of you AUTOMATICALLY ASSUME she did it to herself BECAUSE of whom she is going to vote for.

How many screaming Drudge h... (Below threshold)
Adrian Browne:

How many screaming Drudge headlines have turned out not to be true? He put the headline up there based on a comment on a blog -- nothing more -- because he knew it would outrage people. It would get people to come to his site and hit the refresh button. $$ That's what he does best -- he's good at irritating people. He's good at getting people riled up. Part of his schtick is to write stories that are so outrageous that people question it and others are forced to defend it. Refresh. Refresh. Sure lots of his screaming headline stories turn out to be true. He doesn't care whether they are or not.

Coincidently, this article appeared today listing 9 or so stories that have been repeated and repeated and repeated that all turned out not to be true:


I'm not surprised this crim... (Below threshold)
Joe Conservative:

I'm not surprised this crime happened. Most of these Obama supporters are "no good, give me a hand out thugs!"

It is so interesting how th... (Below threshold)
Joe Conservative:

It is so interesting how the Obama crowd espouses to be so peaceful and desiring WORLD PEACE...."No more War" they say!!!! Yet they are the most VILE and HATEFUL and VIOLENT. I have never seen people behave like this..."spewing venom" at another candidate like the Obama folks have done against McCain and Palin. It is one thing to attack anothers policies or record but the personal hatred and attacks are UNBELIEVABLE!!!
I would also like to comment on this $150 million that Obama raised in September....Ummmm aren't we having an economic crises in this country???? Maybe it's not that big of a crises!!!If he's so willing to take my hard earned money and spread it around to those who don't want to work(Higher taxes) why doesn't he take that 150 mil and spread it around as well....hmmm don't think we'll ever see that! These elitest think they are the ONLY ones who deserve to do well finacially and it is amazing how little they turn around and give to charity(ex:Joe Biden)

This is really simple. Peop... (Below threshold)

This is really simple. People's reaction to this shows all you need to know.

If the girl had been a democrat attacked by a republican, there would have been a general outcry (especially from this site) that this type of behavior is unacceptable.

I would be ashmed if anyone I know spoke like you guys (and you know who I am talking about). Please continue, it's always nice to have fodder for a future conversation to prove to any casual bystanders just what caliber of people we're dealing with here.

Kim wrote:Drudg... (Below threshold)

Kim wrote:

Drudge has the headline in red. These Obama cultists are dangerous and out of control. What the hell will these people do if the messiah loses on November 4th?

Jesus Kim, you should at least pretend to be reasonable. This is out of control.

Maybe this is true, and maybe it isn't. If it's true, the person who did this is an atrocious criminal who should be punished. There is no explanation or excuse for this kind of thing.

One way or another, there is NO REASON for people to react to this and start blaming ALL OBAMA supporters for the actions of some psychopath.

Just like there is no reason to start assuming that certain fringe people represent ALL conservatives, there is no reason to fly off the handle and make assumptions about all liberals based upon news like this.

There is no denying that this kind of crime is horrible and inexcusable. I have no idea whether it's true or what.

You know, I fully understand that the different political sides disagree and all, but this is taking things way too far. And there are plenty of liberals who take things too far as well. It's bullshit, and at some point people have to find a way past this kind of partisan madness.

The way people react and treat one another is depressing sometimes. Is this what we all really want?

Come on ABCBSNBCNN, prov... (Below threshold)

Come on ABCBSNBCNN, prove me and my husband wrong.

That's a completely useless thing to say, and if all you do is say things like that, nothing will ever happen. If you want to do something about media bias, see my name's link.

For extra credit, wait until a biased reporter is doing a public appearance and then go out and call them on one of their lies to their face on video. Then, upload it to Youtube. (Note: I mean a real question, not a rant or a stupid question, etc.)

I'd like to see some of the... (Below threshold)
The Listkeeper:

I'd like to see some of these people saying she did it to herself try to do so to themselves and see how far they get.

First of all, the pictur... (Below threshold)

First of all, the picture is a mirror image. So I was extremely unhappy that someone, multiple of the usual suspects, was trying to make it like she used a mirror to do it to herself.

Larry, as you noted, the "B" is on her right side. Touch your right cheek. Then go to a mirror. On which side of the image you're viewing is your hand? Compare that to the location of the "B" in Todd's picture. They don't look the same, do they?

However, despite t... (Below threshold)
However, despite the comments popping up in other threads, I don't think this says anything terribly significant about the election or either candidate. Criminals aren't known for their kindness, temperament, or intellect, and this particular criminal sounds like he's a couple of bricks short of a load even for that crowd. The initial crime had nothing to do with politics at all, so it's not an example of partisan thuggery as one would expect some to paint it.

That's from Ed Morrisey over at Hot Air. Now, if only some of the folks here at Wizbang could keep their heads on straight as well.

Brian, he most likely had h... (Below threshold)
The Listkeeper:

Brian, he most likely had her in a headlock when he was doing the cutting. In that case, the B would be upside down in relation to the face.

Pretty pathetic Larry, espe... (Below threshold)

Pretty pathetic Larry, especially considering the insults you hurled.

Can't wait for this to develop...heat up the crow.

I have a question for all o... (Below threshold)
Joe Conservative:

I have a question for all of you socialist "redistribute the wealth" libs. I am certain you have this philosophy because you want to help the less fortunate or could it be that you just want to make them dependent on liberal demacrats so that they will continue re-electing you to continue to get the handouts? Here is my question - If you care about the downtrodden (really care) why don't you help them on your own nickel outside of the government (read taxpayor's pocket) treasury? Why is it that Joe Biden gives less than $5,000 on several million dollars of income? Does he really care about those in need? If so why didn't he put his money where his mouth is? You want to know the reason? It is because he does not give a flip about these people. All he and all of the others in the socialist democrat party care about is giving out crumbs to the needy to keep them dependent on the government system and the politicians that vote for these socialistic policies. I should warn you that this scam is about to come to an abrupt halt If Obama gets elected. Those getting the handouts are expecting big pieces of the pie instead of crumbs and that will not happen. Those expecting bigger handouts are going to feel ripped off and will revolt. Those footing the bill are going to revolt as you have never seen before and this socialist welfare crap will disappear for generations until another stupid generation comes along and falls for the lie again.

Joe Conservative:L... (Below threshold)

Joe Conservative:

Look, I understand the need to vent and all, but try to stick to the subject of the thread.

I have a question ... (Below threshold)
I have a question for all of you socialist "redistribute the wealth" libs.

Ask this guy.


jp2~What might be ... (Below threshold)


What might be a good idea, rather than posting a video that was recorded eight years ago, try to find something more recent that coincides with a breakdown of each candidate's plan side by side:

Keeping also in mind these numbers are basic, which don't include write-offs and various other deductions for each individual household. If you really believe Obama's "tax increase" on the rich is going to benefit you, personally, then you are not just not looking closely enough.

I'm going to concur with an... (Below threshold)

I'm going to concur with another commenter over at Oliver Willis, in that I'm not going to doubt the woman's story until the facts are out - that's pretty heinous, no matter how fishy the story may sound. Either way it doesn't reflect on the Obama campaign or the election in the slightest. Sickos are sickos and will find justifications for sick behavior.

Liberalism is not social... (Below threshold)
Cato the Elder:

Liberalism is not socialism, and never will be... Liberalism has its own history and its own tradition. Socialism has its own formulas and aims. Socialism seeks to pull down wealth; Liberalism would preserve private interests in the only way in which they can be safely and justly preserved, namely, by reconciling them with public right. Socialism would kill enterprise; Liberalism would rescue enterprise from the trammels of privilege and preference. Socialism assails the pre-eminence of the individual; Liberalism seeks, and shall seek more in the future, to build up a minimum standard for the mass. Socialism exalts the rule; Liberalism exalts the man. Socialism attacks capital; Liberalism attacks monopoly.
Winston Churchill, 1908

I have a question for all of you socialist "redistribute the wealth" libs.

Progressive taxation is not socialism. If it was, most of the founders were socialists by your mislabeling. George Washington identified himself as a liberal. Look it up. Try a library, the internet is full of garbage. And don't even get me started on their ideas about property in land. They were decidedly proto-Georgists and even Wiliam F. Buckley, Jr. was "sympathetic with" Henry George's "analysis" as are many libertarians. The Ardens, Delaware is a Georgist community in the U.S. and has bee for some time, as was Fairhope, Alabama.

Henry George said that the rent of all land ought to be public. ...I am sympathetic with that particular analysis.

[From: Firing Line, PBS, 6 January, 1980]


Like Thomas Jefferson and most of the rest of the Founders? The estate tax was his "revolutionary idea" because he did away with the laws of primogeniture and entails.

Jefferson and the Aristocracy
How Cicero's Writing Influenced Jefferson's View of Hereditary Power
© James Hogan

Feb 10, 2008

Influenced by the writing of the Roman Senator Cicero, Thomas Jefferson introduced bills to repeal the laws of primogeniture and entails in the Virginia legislature.

Historians attribute the majority of the ideological roots of America's founders to European Enlightenment thought as well as English opposition party writings. However, in at least one place, it is difficult to connect the founders' ideals and modern European thought - Thomas Jefferson's strong statements regarding the dangers of a hereditary American aristocracy. The idea of noble birth rite and hereditary power were firmly entrenched in 17th and 18th century European thought and to advocate against them would have been controversial if not outright dangerous. Jefferson however, experiences no reticence in condemning the institution and introduced laws aimed at destroying it. Stating in an 1813 letter to John Adams, "These laws, drawn by myself, laid the axe to the root of Pseudoaristocracy."

Jefferson: What I saw at the Forum

Jefferson, as with the other founders, had studied the history of Rome almost from the time he started his earliest education. The fact that the American government today looks much like the mixed constitution state (executive, senate and a representative lower house) of republican Rome should not be surprising given the founders ardent study of it.

But still, the Roman republic fell and was replaced by a dictatorship. The cause of this democratic failure would certainly need to be addressed so as to prevent it from happening in the United States. When Jefferson looked for answers, he found Cicero. Marcus Tullius Cicero was one of Rome's most influential politicians in the late republic and its most prolific writer.

Jefferson's interrogation of Cicero was revealing. Although Cicero does put some of the blame for the fall of the republic on Julius Caesar, he delivers the brunt to the aristocratical Senate. Men of birth and wealth, possessing a sense of entitlement, corrupted by greed, allowed themselves to be bribed into complicity with a dictator. Cicero repeated this theme in his letters, speeches and in his late philosophical works.

Not in this Republic

Well, if a corrupted aristocracy helped bring down the Roman Republic, it was not something Jefferson wanted in his new republic. After signing the Declaration of Independence, Jefferson returned to Virginia where he had been elected to the state legislature. In one of his first acts there he introduced a bill to end the laws of primogeniture and entails. Primogeniture - Latin for first born - required that all of a man's wealth be passed to his eldest son upon his death. Entails stipulated that this requirement applied to the land in perpetuity. Over time this practice ensured the slow accumulation of great wealth by a few the families who had lived in the state the longest. These families formed what was a called a 'Patrician Order" by Jefferson. And where the King picked his advisors to administer the colony. This system established the conditions favorable for the formation of a permanent aristocracy in Virginia.

Jefferson was successful in getting his bill passed. And, while today it is a little noted event, to Jefferson it was an important act in his political life. In his autobiography he wrote:

"To annul this privilege, and instead of an aristocracy of wealth, of more harm and danger, than benefit, to society, to make an opening for the aristocracy of virtue and talent, which nature has wisely provided for the direction of the interests of society, & scattered with equal hand through all it's conditions, was deemed essential to a well ordered republic."

Cicero would have been proud.


The Adams-Jefferson Letters: The Complete Correspondence between Thomas Jefferson and Abigail and John Adams. Edited by Lester J. Cappon. 2 vols. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press for the Institute of Early American History and Culture, Williamsburg, Virginia, 1959.

Syme, Ronald. The Roman Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press, 2002.

MacKendrick, Paul. Karen Lee Singh coll. The Philosophical Books of Cicero. London: Gerald Duckworth and Co. Ltd., 1989.

The Works of Thomas Jefferson. Edited by Paul Leicester Ford. G.P. Putnam's Sons, New York, 1904.


Jefferson was probably most proud of two accomplishments in his life. These laws and public education, specifically the founding of the "public" University of Virginia because that is what is on his tombstone, not the DoI or the Constitution. Look it up.

Jefferson on welfare:

Notes on the State of Virginia, Query 14 Laws (on welfare policy)

Thomas Jefferson

[American welfare policy in the founding era. -- TGW]

...The poor, unable to support themselves, are maintained by an assessment on the titheable persons in their parish. This assessment is levied and administered by twelve persons in each parish, called vestrymen, originally chosen by the housekeepers of the parish, but afterwards filling vacancies in their own body by their own choice. These are usually the most discreet farmers, so distributed through their parish, that every part of it may be under the immediate eye of some one of them. They are well acquainted with the details and œconomy of private life, and they find sufficient inducements to execute their charge well, in their philanthropy, in the approbation of their neighbours, and the distinction which that gives them. The poor who have neither property, friends, nor strength to labour, are boarded in the houses of good farmers, to whom a stipulated sum is annually paid...


That's a very conservative historian's book, (Claremont Institute) Vindicating the Founders, as is this fellow:

Forrest McDonald.

I suggest you read his books, to get an idea of what the Founders thought because you don't know any more than most politicians, or if they do, they aren't telling you, for obvious reasons, or at least this speech he gave recently to the right wing online Library of Liberty because I doubt many of you have any idea what small "r" republicanism is all about. You may be surprised.

"The Founding Fathers and the Economic Order"


Of all the Founders, it was only Hamilton who was what we would call a "capitalist".

Brian, he most likely ha... (Below threshold)

Brian, he most likely had her in a headlock when he was doing the cutting.

That's already been posited. Pretty straight precision cutting for an enraged guy holding a probably hysterical woman in a headlock.

What might be a good ide... (Below threshold)

What might be a good idea, rather than posting a video that was recorded eight years ago, try to find something more recent

Says the guy who doesn't hesitate to harp on Obama and Ayers serving on a board 11 years ago.

I don't mind going off the ... (Below threshold)

I don't mind going off the beaten path here in regards to the topic because, well, we've already got 117 comments at this point. No one's likely to read this anyway.

Cato, first, you got a negative for length. Everything you cut and pasted could have been summed up in a couple paragraphs.

Second, your statement, "Progressive taxation is not socialism." No it's not. You're arguing a straw man. It's how the taxes are used. When they're taken and then given to someone who did not earn them, it's socialism. It's very simple. Why are the uses of the money called "social programs" and not "liberal programs"? Liberals who espouse this use of the money are socialist in nature. When these "liberals" determine who is needy of the money based on ever evolving circumstances (ie when the lifestyles of those with more money improves, the standards of what constitutes "poor" increases) then those with big screen TVs, new cars, etc are considered "poor" if they struggle to maintain that style of living.

Take note of Jefferson's words, "The poor who have neither property, friends, nor strength to labour,..."

One must define "the poor" properly. It's not an arbitrary/evolving definition based on "keeping up with the Joneses".

Like most conservatives, I have no problem the socialistic aspect of helping those who are poor in spite of great effort. I DO have a problem with indiscriminate charity imposed by a government.

We've been barreling headlong down that path for a long time, and that it's becoming "mainstream" to accept that our government mandates it and administrates it so poorly is troubling.

That's without even briefly touching on public education.

Oyster, for the record, I r... (Below threshold)

Oyster, for the record, I read your comment. I agree. ww

Brian and other twit... (Below threshold)

Brian and other twits. I haven't a clue whether it is self infliced or not. What I do know is that the police office said it was on the right side of her face.

A mirror is NOT a camera. So get out your digital camera. Take a picture of a B written on your right cheek - by a friend. Take the picture, then look at it on screen.

What do you see?

Let me make it easy for you. You see the RIGHT side of someone's face on the LEFT side of the picture you are viewing.

This is what drives me crazy about you LIBS, you see a fact staring you in the face, and you still try to dodge it; make it something that it isn't.

Larry, what exactly are you... (Below threshold)

Larry, what exactly are you arguing? Every picture I've seen of the girl, the "B" is on her right cheek, or, the left side of the picture as you say. So what is your issue?

I also agree read and agree... (Below threshold)

I also agree read and agree with you Oyster, we must also look at the similarities between the Roman Republic and our experiment in that type of democracy.

Not only did Rome come to see an entreched politcal class that gave rise to dictatorship, but also they changed the question from "What can you do for Rome?" to "What can Rome do for you?" They learned that controlling the "mob" with free bread and circus was key to their power.

It's scary sometimes the similarities I see between the fall of the Roman Republic and the things that are happening in America today. Remember up until the 1950's the turnover rate in congress was near 50%, today it's near 1% and the senate is even less.

Entrenched political class, giving bread to the masses, keeping us "entertained"...kinda scary.

You see the RIGHT side o... (Below threshold)

You see the RIGHT side of someone's face on the LEFT side of the picture you are viewing.


I certain all you wingnuts ... (Below threshold)

I certain all you wingnuts were desperately hoping that this story was true but its fallen apart:

The alleged "victim" is not on the ATM security tape and she has changed her story about a dozen times and is now saying she never saw the assailant and she woke up and the B was on her face.

Its pretty bad when your story doesn't stand up to scrutiny for even 12 hours.

It's even worse.Sh... (Below threshold)

It's even worse.

She admitted she made the story up and will apparently be charged with filing a false report.


What a bunch of losers!

Kim:Would you care... (Below threshold)


Would you care to make some sort of statement about dangerous and out of control self-mutilating McCain-Palin 'cultists' now, then? I don't think any Obama supporter has gone quite so far to spread racial hatred yet.

She made it all up! Typica... (Below threshold)

She made it all up! Typical craven McCain supporter, a total racist and liar. Ha ha ha, in your faces , wingnuts. You all were drooling at the prospect of this story being true, because it feeds right into your racist mindsets.
You idiots ran with this so fast and so hard and you didn't even think for just a second that this whole story stunk from the get-go.

Oh the poor little virginal white girl, so brutally attacked by some vicious black man who hates McCain!!!

Ha ha haaaaaaa!!!!

When do you plan to retract... (Below threshold)

When do you plan to retract this erroneous story. The police department and the alleged victim have stated that this was a hoax. The alleged victim did not pass a polygraph and the ATM video did not show an attack. All news outlets have reported that she has recanted and admitted that she made this up.

It is time for you to take the high road and admit to race bating and inflamatory blogging.

Retract your story or provide the necessary updates to truly inform your readers.

She faked it, and anybody w... (Below threshold)

She faked it, and anybody with an IQ over 74 could have figured it out by the backwards "B" alone.


Is this the new strategy to... (Below threshold)

Is this the new strategy to get McCain elected? Make up lies, scare people unnecessarily, spread rumors and innuendo without checking facts?

Oh, now I remember. That's been the strategy all along.

Ms. Todd is a disturbed woman who needs mental and emotional help, but the bandwagon of McCain supporters who jumped on this story should really be ashamed of themselves. The backward B on her face seems like evidence that Todd did this to herself with the aid of a mirror.

Ok I said I would apologize... (Below threshold)

Ok I said I would apologize for jumping to conclusions on this story, I'm a man of my word. I'm sorry I jumped to conclusions. Now if only some others would take my example and learn from it, jp2, hyperbolist, brian, et. al.

"Lorie adds: If the media i... (Below threshold)

"Lorie adds: If the media is fair about it, this story will get a lot more attention than some idiot who may or may not have yelled "Kill Him" at a McCain rally...... UPDATE: After seeing the picture, I am suspicious about this story."

Wouldn't it have been a good idea to look at the picture BEFORE you told other people how they should be reporting it?

POLICE: McCAIN VOLUNTEER MA... (Below threshold)
The Truth:


By JOE MANDAK, Associated Press Writer Joe Mandak, Associated Press Writer

PITTSBURGH - A McCain campaign volunteer made up a story of being robbed, pinned to the ground and having the letter "B" scratched on her face in a politically inspired attack, police said Friday.

Ashley Todd, 20-year-old college student from College Station, Texas, admitted Friday that the story was false and was being charged with making a false report to police, said Maurita Bryant, the assistant chief of the police department's investigations division. Police doubted her story from the start, Bryant said.

Todd, who is white, told police she was attacked by a 6-foot-4 black man Wednesday night. She now can't explain why she invented the story, Bryant said.

Todd also told police she believes she cut the backward "B" onto her own cheek, but she didn't explain how or why, Bryant said.

Todd initially told investigators she was attempting to use a bank branch ATM when the man approached her from behind, put a knife with a 4- to 5-inch blade to her throat and demanded money. She told police she handed the assailant $60 and walked away.

Todd told investigators that she suspected the man then noticed a John McCain sticker on her car, became angry and punched her in the back of the head, knocking her to the ground and telling her "you are going to be a Barack supporter," police said.

She said he continued to punch and kick her while threatening "to teach her a lesson for being a McCain supporter," police said. She said he then sat on her chest, pinned her hands down with his knees and scratched a backward letter "B" into her face with a dull knife.

Todd told police she didn't seek medical attention, but instead went to a friend's apartment nearby and called police about 45 minutes later.

The Associated Press could not immediately locate Todd's family.

Bryant said somebody charged with making a false report would typically be cited and sent a summons. But because police have concerns about Todd's mental health, they are consulting with the Allegheny County District Attorney.

Todd remained in custody, and police were preparing to charge her with making a false report to police.

"We had some serious cases going on, and this wasted so much time," Bryant said. "Our detectives have been working through the night just to verify the information we suspected was false from the beginning."

Todd worked in New York for the College Republican National Committee before moving two weeks ago to Pennsylvania, where her duties included recruiting college students, the committee's executive director, Ethan Eilon, has said.

Eilon declined to comment on the investigation Friday or to help The Associated Press contact Todd.

Earlier Friday, police said they had found inconsistencies in Todd's story. They gave her a lie-detector test, but wouldn't release the polygraph results. Investigators also said bank surveillance photos did not back up the woman's initial story of being attacked at an ATM.

Police interviewed Todd after she contacted police Wednesday night and again on Thursday, Bryant said. They asked her to come back Friday, ostensibly to help police put together a sketch of the man. Instead, detectives began interviewing her.

"They just started talking to her and she just opened up and said she wanted to tell the truth," Bryant said.

Bryant said it doesn't appear that anyone else put the woman up to the false report.

Police suspected all along that Todd might not be telling the truth, starting with the fact that the "B" was backward, Bryant said.

"We have robbers here in Pittsburgh, but they don't generally mutilate someone's face like that," Bryant said. "They just take the money and run."

The real story here, of cou... (Below threshold)
The Truth:

The real story here, of course, is that Wizbang in general and Kim Priestap in particular have lost every ounce of whatever questionable credibility they ever had. They soiled their britches in grand style "reporting" this "story," which has now been exposed as an utter, total lie.

But let's concentrate on the Kimster, shall we? She's been completely and thoroughly exposed as a shrill, hysterical spokes-hole, a mindless, Palin-esque empty shell tool who reflexively parrots, without investigation, without conscience, without the slightest glimmer of intelligence, the following idiocy:

"Drudge has the headline in red. These Obama cultists are dangerous and out of control. What the hell will these people do if the messiah loses on November 4th? Is this the new strategy to get Obama elected? Vote Obama or we'll riot, mutilate people and destroy property? Keep in mind, community activists used intimidation to get banks to give home loans to minority and high risk customers. They stormed bank lobbies and scared away customers. They harassed bank presidents at their homes. It seems they're willing to go even further and actually mutilate a McCain supporter. Will voters with McCain signs in their front yards be targeted, too? To me, this is an argument to defeat Obama soundly on November 4th. We will not be intimidated into voting for Obama."

Really Kim. Have you no pride? Have you no shame? Have you no decency?

You certainly have no credentials as a journalist, reporter or writer. You've embarrassed yourself about as totally as one can in public.

You're a complete moron. I wish you a wonderful eight years in the country of President Obama. Get used to it.

Haven't you heard. She made... (Below threshold)
Are you Kidding:

Haven't you heard. She made this up and has since been arrested by the police for filing a false report. I knew it the minute it was reported. I'm sure someone who is stealing money is going to stop and carve on the victim's face!

And the irony is, such atta... (Below threshold)

And the irony is, such attacks have happened to real on Obama supporters.


Totally forgotten and ignored in the news, of course. It's nice, in a horrible sort of way: it confirms over and over again, who are really the good guys in this thing. Who are the ones trying to heal things, and who are the ones trying to divide and break.

And you call us the crazy ones, and say the media is biased in our favour.

I started reading the comme... (Below threshold)

I started reading the comments here, and was actually laughing out loud. Funny only one person came back and admitted they were wrong for jumping to conclusions. Too funny!!

Bwahahahaha,.......<p... (Below threshold)


This fake attack really burn the emotion of die-hard republican and demonizing half other american who different from them, and suddenly the truth reveals....

Bwahahaahah....i really want to read your comment after you know the truth guys....


This was a fake attack, a l... (Below threshold)

This was a fake attack, a lie for attention or political gain. First off black eyes as they are do not form right after an attack they actually can take up to a week to turn black before that it would be swollen red with congealed blood. But what do I know I am just an Atheist with no criminal record not even a traffic ticket but I drink lattes oh and I have never done any drugs not even Marijuana also I read a lot of books so I am eroding the morals of society.

Where is the apology from t... (Below threshold)

Where is the apology from the reich-wing GOPigs for their utter and complete meltdown and blaming of the Left?

*crickets chirping*

Wow I would be really embar... (Below threshold)

Wow I would be really embarrassed if I had reported a story like this.
I'm still waiting for McCain or at least some of his supporters to condemn this attack.

Only one person has come ba... (Below threshold)
yo mama:

Only one person has come back and apologized for jumping to conclusions.
Only one of you have enough decency to admit when you're wrong.
And the McCain campaign has been very slow to condemn this too.

I, for one, don't care if t... (Below threshold)

I, for one, don't care if this attack was faked.

For every hoax attack on God-fearing American Patriot Republicans, there are at least ten real attacks that go unreported. Why, just last week, I stepped outside to pick up my morning Washington Times and found that some liberal creep let the air out of my inflatable McCain-Palin lawn display/moon bounce.

When McCain is elected next week, we'll throw all these Osama-backing thugs into Guantanamo bay, where they belong.

Don't you MORONS feel STOOO... (Below threshold)

Don't you MORONS feel STOOOOOOOOOPID NOW??!! Way to jump on the bandwagon without waiting for the facts. That poor BLACK MAN has been accused of eveything under the sun. RAPE, "HE STOLE MY PURSE", "HE DROWNED MY BABIES","HE SHOT MY WIFE AND THEN SHOT ME", the list goes on. Boy does he get around...and he's been around for so long. Hope you find him soon. GET A GRIP!! THAT BLACK MAN DOES NOT EXIST

mnove sahki qxvmd bqylz... (Below threshold)

mnove sahki qxvmd bqylz

brtqpk fyjd ixkh... (Below threshold)

brtqpk fyjd ixkh

xdrv xpfzilk... (Below threshold)

xdrv xpfzilk

gpzmika mnhfi... (Below threshold)

gpzmika mnhfi






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy