« Attorney General Michael Mukasey Collapses | Main | Wizbang Weekend Caption Contest™ »

The Knucklehead of the Day award

Today's winner is Father Jay Scott Newman of St. Mary's Catholic Church in Greenville South Carolina. He gets the award for the following-

South Carolina's Charleston-based Roman Catholic Diocese said Friday that it doesn't believe parishioners who voted for Barack Obama should have to seek penance before partaking Holy Communion, a condition a Greenville priest suggested this week because of Obama's stance on abortion.

The priest, Father Jay Scott Newman of St. Mary's Catholic Church in Greenville, couldn't be reached for comment late Friday.

"As administrator of the Diocese of Charleston, let me state with clarity that Father Newman's statements do not adequately reflect the Catholic Church's teachings," Monsignor Martin T. Laughlin said Friday in a posting on the diocese's Web site. "Any comments or statements to the contrary are repudiated."

On Friday, Newman said in a message posted on St. Mary's church Web site that his original statement had been misunderstood. Newman said that he didn't intend for his comments to be seen beyond his parish and that he has received more than 3,500 emails from across the globe both in support of and condemning his comments.

In Friday's posting, Newman said that voting for Obama isn't "in itself or by itself a mortal sin" but that "a vote for a pro-abortion candidate can be a mortal sin if the intent is to support abortion, that abortion is not merely one issue among other important issues, and that no Catholic should endorse a pro-abortion politician if a plausible pro-life alternative is available."

I'm Catholic, my wife works for the local diocese, and I have problems with what Father Newman said. Mostly because the Roman Catholic church is hypocritical when it comes to life. Take for instance a mother 6 years ago who was on hospital pregnancy bedrest. She was a diocese employee, the church she worked at paid her health insurance premiums. The Diocese of Palm Beach sent a HR employee to tell the mother in the hospital that her health insurance was being stopped unless she paid for them. She can't work because of being in the hospital, so where the #%^%! is the money supposed to come from? The skin flint diocese and church pastor thought it more important to save the $80 a week in premiums than the two human lives were at stake. If life was so sacred, you know what the choice would have come down to between the money and the mother and child. Sick, sick, sick and BTW the mother lost the child but then Bishop Sean O'Malley got a consolation prize. He's a cardinal.

Memo to the catholic church- Stop the human life hypocrisy. I know what matters to you the most- the almighty dollar. In the meantime I name Father Jay Scott Newman of St. Mary's Catholic Church in Greenville South Carolina today's Knucklehead of the Day.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (12)

You seem to be among the ma... (Below threshold)

You seem to be among the majority of "catholics"....the ones that voted for a man that advocates infanticide. You are right, we have asked the moderate muslims to deny the islamofascists (at peril of their life) and the catholic church should just stop this nonsense about pro-life, join your people and get on with the killing of babies....it is a very profitable business. This priest should never have taken this stand, a stand vaguely similar to two popes and many cardinals, that life is precious and the "catholics" that elected obama should have given that more consideration when they voted.

The quotes around 'catholic... (Below threshold)
Kit Winterer:

The quotes around 'catholic' are telling. If you don't want to follow the tenets of the Church, why bother saying you're a member of the Church. I find it impossible to fathom how any real Catholic could vote for Obama, knowing his anti-child record and believe anyone knowing that record and voting to empower him with the ability to make the killing of innocent children a national policy should be excommunicated.

The woman in the hospital s... (Below threshold)

The woman in the hospital story sounds bogus to me, the casual observer.

RF Young writes- "The woman... (Below threshold)

RF Young writes- "The woman in the hospital story sounds bogus to me, the casual observer."

I'm intimately acquainted with the woman who was hospitalized. In addition I've got the documents from the diocese that were addressed to her when she was in the hospital. Want to take your head out of your ass for one second reread my post and wonder why I wouldn't say this without reason.

Talk shit about the shitty ... (Below threshold)

Talk shit about the shitty Catholic Church and all the non-Catholic defenders of blastocyst-Americans' right to life come crawling out from under their rocks to stick up for the Papist hypocrites like this Fr. Newman *sshole.

Abortion is one thing that Catholics are supposed to be opposed to. Others include poverty and war--any war. If one candidate says he's pro-choice but anti-war, and another says he's pro-life but pro-war, one must use their own moral reasoning to decide which candidate best represents their views. In other words, they must go beyond the teachings of the Church to find a satisfactory answer to this dilemma.

And the dioceses continue to hemorrhage young educated parishoners, and churches are sold and converted into loft condominiums. Progress. Smells good.

hyperbolist, Y... (Below threshold)


You may want to get your facts straight before you attempt to speak for the Catholic Church. You attempted to play the moral equivalence game and failed. Abortion is not just one of many issues. Beyond that there is nothing in Catholic teaching that makes a 100% blanket requirement to oppose any and all wars. Then you got cute and said: "If one candidate says he's pro-choice but anti-war, and another says he's pro-life but pro-war . . ." Those in favor of infanticide like to claim no one is pro-abortion and jump up and down saying others must call you pro-choice. Yet there you go saying the other candidate is "pro-war." Acknowledging that we need a strong military for our nations defense is not being "pro-war." It would be nice if we could all just hold hands and sing kumbuyah (sic) and get along but a realist understands that that it isn't likely.


It is certainly a sad story you tell about a woman whose boss won't pay her medical insurance. However, it is also completely irrelevant to the situation in SC where the priest is advising his parishioners that they should examine their consciences and seek penance if they did something to advance the most prevelant evil in our day.

"...the most prevelant evil... (Below threshold)

"...the most prevelant evil in our day."

Really? Awesome! Glad all those far more serious problems--famine, war, poverty, subjugation of women--have been solved, so that we can now turn our attention to the welfare of blastocysts.

Abortion is one of many issues. (How could it possibly be otherwise?) The Church is opposed to war--including the war in Iraq. In fact, the Catholic Church--of which I have first-hand familiarity--is far more anti-war than I think is reasonable. They are pacifists to the extent that they refused to take sides in WW II (which of course meant they were tacitly siding with the Fascists and the Nazis).

It's ridiculous to paint th... (Below threshold)

It's ridiculous to paint the Catholic Church with such a broad brush because of one incident that you are aware of. The Catholic Church helps the poor all over the world.

Actually the Catholic Churc... (Below threshold)

Actually the Catholic Church is not opposed to war....if you remember the debate when we were talking to the un about Iraq, the church spelled out when it approved of war. Over a million babies a year are killed in our country by abortion. Now we have a president elect that also advocates killing them after they are born. I believe most Catholics that voted for obama were not aware of his stance on killing babies (at least I hope that is the case). Conservatives believe in teaching people to fish so they can be independent, liberals believe in giving people food so they become slaves for life. The Church is run by people who have faults. The Church also does great good. The priest was correct to inform his parishioners of the beliefs of two popes, many cardinals and the teaching of our Catholic Church, life is precious and they had an alternative to obama....they should have voted accordingly.

How? By telling people in o... (Below threshold)

How? By telling people in overpopulated, undernourished regions that they should not use birth control? By laundering Jewish treasure plundered in WW II? By covering up a massive pedophilic sex abuse scandal?

Some Catholics surely make the world a better place--including clergy, missionaries, and your everyday believers--but some Catholics work towards making the world worse. Being Catholic does not make one's actions good or helpful, and it does not make one's motives pure.

As for comment #8, it's actually really easy to paint the Catholic Church with a broad brush because official Church doctrine is meant to be universal for all believers and it is publicly available.

A worthwhile post if only i... (Below threshold)

A worthwhile post if only in that it demonstrates how little is required, these days of the ascendant fascist and his too-dumb-to-know-they're-lied-to and crypto-fascist supporters, to bring the anti-Christian, anti-Catholic butt-headed bigots from their burrows.

And, RFYoung, for what it's worth, I'm with you. And with Rightwingsaparkle, who also biffed the brainless bigot where it counts.

Blessings - Brian Richard Allen

Yes by all means vote for t... (Below threshold)
Thomas Jackson:

Yes by all means vote for the candidate who advocated partial birth abortion under all circumstances and call yourself a good Catholic. I think breaking all the commandments and being proud of it doesn't disqualify you as a Catholic, after all just look at Pelosi, Kennedy, and Kerry.

Its fun being a buffet Catholic. It must be wonderful to be able to cast the first stone.






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy