« Economic Perception vs. Reality | Main | Obama In Cairo »

Twenty Years Ago - Tiananmen Square

Today marks the twentieth anniversary of the massacre of civilian protesters in Beijing's Tiananmen Square by the People's Liberation Army of the People's Republic of China.

For nearly two months, students, faculty members, and ordinary citizens from Beijing had gathered in Tiananmen Square to protest the restriction of freedom by the ruling Chinese Communist Party and to demand economic reforms, democracy and the right of self-rule for the Chinese people. The crowds had originally gathered on April 15, 1989 to mourn the death of moderate reformer Hu Yaobang, but continued to gather as the passion of the protesters increased with each passing week. Protest leaders kept the crowds pouring into Tiananmen Square, motivating them with speeches, hunger strikes, and the dream of freedom from the oppressive Communist government. Despite martial law being declared in Beijing, crowds of tens of thousands continued to gather daily.


On June 3, 1989, the People's Liberation Army was dispatched in order to disperse the crowd of 100,000, and to permanently put an end to the embarrassing protests, which by that time had garnered tremendous world-wide attention. The attack began at 10:30 PM that evening, and soon escalated into a full-scale military assault. The timidity of the original PLA troops was evidenced by the fact that dozens of them were pulled out of their armored personnel carriers by protesters, who then set the vehicles ablaze in an effort to form a blockade around themselves. But PLA reinforcements were quickly brought in, and by dawn on June 4, Tiananmen Square had been cleared of protesters. Foot soldiers, armored personnel carriers, and tanks continued to fire upon and trample civilians as they fled in front of them.

The next day, June 5, saw the most famous event associated with Tiananmen Square unfold. From Wikipedia:

The suppression of the protest was immortalized in Western media by the famous video footage and photographs of a lone man in a white shirt standing in front of a column of tanks which were attempting to drive out of Tiananmen Square. Taken on 5 June as the column approached an intersection on the Avenue of Eternal Peace, the footage depicted the unarmed man standing in the center of the street, halting the tanks' progress. As the tank driver attempted to go around him, the "Tank Man" moved into the tank's path. He continued to stand defiantly in front of the tanks for some time, then climbed up onto the turret of the lead tank to speak to the soldiers inside. He reportedly said, "Why are you here? You have caused nothing but misery." But this is debatable, as no one was close enough to hear him besides the soldier. After returning to his position blocking the tanks, the man was pulled aside by police. Eyewitness reporter Charlie Cole believes that "Tank Man" was probably executed after being taken from the tank by secret police, since the Chinese government could never produce him to hush the outcry from many countries. Time Magazine dubbed him The Unknown Rebel and later named him one of the 100 most influential people of the 20th century.

Officially, the Chinese government has never acknowledged the June Fourth Massacre. In the following weeks, the Communist leaders of China grudgingly reported the deaths of 241 civilians and soldiers, with an additional 7,000 wounded. According to their official report, no one died at Tiananmen Square, and those who died were mostly students who deliberately engaged in violent clashes with PLA troops who were assigned to peacefully disperse the crowds. Immediately following the attack, The Red Cross reported 2,600 deaths. Other estimates have placed the number as high as 10,000, but the true number of deaths will probably forever remain a mystery.

Westerners were stunned by the brutality of the assault. It had been two decades since Soviet tanks rolled into Prague in order to crush the series of reforms instigated by Alexander Dubcek, and bring Czechoslovakia back under hard-line Communist rule. Perhaps the Chinese were spooked by the first relatively free elections held in a Communist nation, Poland, since the end of World War II, which also took place on June 4. That election resulted in the capture of 99 out of 100 Polish Senate seats by Solidarity candidates, and paved the way for the peaceful, free election of Lech Walesa as Poland's first non-Communist leader in December 1989.

The decision by the Chinese to violently end a peaceful pro-democracy protest proved to be one of the most disastrous decisions made by a Communist government since the 1960's. The resolve of the protesters, combined with the oppression and cruelty of the People's Liberation Army, energized and transformed the freedom movement in Eastern Europe and ultimately led to the implosion of the Eastern Bloc and the collapse of the Iron Curtain. By the end of 1989, the Communist governments of Poland, Hungary, East Germany, Czechoslovakia, Bulgaria, and Romania had all been overthrown.


A nice slideshow from The Telegraph, including the famous photo of the "Tank Man." Their video report is here, as well.

Tiananmen Remembered by the BBC.

Exiled student leaders of the original Tiananmen Square uprising continue to call for democracy in China.

"Tiananmen 20 Years later: One Person's Appeasement, Dilemma and Hope" - Seattle Times

"Returning To Tiananmen Square" - Jeff Widener, Huffington Post


ADDED: Commenter Paul Hoosen noted that the official Chinese news agencies are silent today about Tianenmen. Yet Chinese government censors have remained extremely vigilant during the past twenty years, eliminating any reference to Tiananmen in print publications, and heavily censoring the state-controlled access to the Internet in order to block any news agencies or web sites that contain information about Tiananmen. An entire generation of young Chinese has grown up learning about Tiananmen only by word-of-mouth, and only those who have left China have actually seen the uncensored news footage and read the numerous eyewitness accounts of that terrible day.


Claudia Rosett, WSJ.com: "What I Saw At Tiananmen"

150,000 attend a candlelight vigil in Hong Kong.

Captain Ed Morrisey at HotAir.com has some thoughts too.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (12)

As to be expected, the offi... (Below threshold)
Paul Hooson:

As to be expected, the official Chinese agency didn't have a single thing to say about this sad anniversary. Yet slowly, economics has opened China up to the world and made the government much more responsible than it once was. Change will eventually come to China, but economics will likely drive that change, not some political struggle similar to what created the downfall of Eastern European Communism.

So economic reality triumph... (Below threshold)

So economic reality triumphs over ideology. Who'd have thought it?

I expect a futher change in China over the next couple of decades. It'll be interesting to see what happens.

It would be rather bizzare if, in thirty or forty years, we shed our freedoms and embrance a nanny-state governmental model and China adopts them, urging the people to get away from a nanny-state mentality...

Sad, that so many risked th... (Below threshold)

Sad, that so many risked their lifes for what we have and what we surely take for granted.
Yet...people here are willing to give it up for the security of having the gov't wipe their...ummm...(was thinking of another word) noses for them.
The only people who would embrace this are the dumb and lazy and then the ones who think they are going to be part of the elite..so they won't suffer what this will bring.

I been reading some good books on socialism and communism gov'ts....I would rather be dead before I lived under them.

Tiananmen Square was a brid... (Below threshold)
Mac Lorry:

Tiananmen Square was a bridge too far in the movement to democratize China. Nevertheless, it's amazing how far China has come in twenty years, if not so far politically, certainly economically. Think what could be if North Korea had come that far in the last 20 years.

Paul, by having China loan ... (Below threshold)

Paul, by having China loan us more money, they are less in a position to care about the world community. We are in hock to them. Now, they owe us nothing. ww

JLawson: "It would be rathe... (Below threshold)

JLawson: "It would be rather bizzare if, in thirty or forty years, we shed our freedoms and embrance a nanny-state governmental model and China adopts them, urging the people to get away from a nanny-state mentality..."

I don't think it's bizarre at all. The people who live in the former Eastern Bloc are about as staunchly opposed to statism/socialism as you can find, simply because the lived under the boot of the communist State for forty years. Likewise, if the North Korean state collapses and the nation is unified once again as a democracy, the former North Koreans will want absolutely nothing to do with statism.

The only bizarre thing to me is that American intellectuals are so eager to embrace a nationalist state with a centrally-planned economy, given how spectacularly that idea has failed (or in the best-case scenarios, stagnated) during the last 90 years.

Excuse me? "The resolve of... (Below threshold)

Excuse me? "The resolve of the protesters, combined with the oppression and cruelty of the People's Liberation Army, energized and transformed the freedom movement in Eastern Europe and ultimately led to the implosion of the Eastern Bloc and the collapse of the Iron Curtain."

This is a huge conclusion with which I and many historians do not agree. The brilliant Three -- Reagan, Thatcher, and John Paul II -- are widely considered to be the ones who brought down communism. Reagan's big push for defense, which bankrupted the USSR, the beautiful speeches and support for the free people of Poland by John Paul II, and Thatcher's dismantling of the nationalization of British industry all combined to collapse the communist stranglehold.

It's just sad that these pe... (Below threshold)

It's just sad that these people will never be recognized by name and they may never see the fruits of their labor. Will China ever progress in democracy? I think the Chinese government has too much of a stronghold for anyone to be able to interfere...I mean they blocked all networking sites on the Internet today to eliminate even the mention of the massacre.
Scary video showing the world views on the anniversary: http://tinyurl.com/qogjrs

Tank Man lives. Updates of ... (Below threshold)

Tank Man lives. Updates of this iconic image are all over the Web today. Here, for example:


In those days hundereds of ... (Below threshold)

In those days hundereds of inocent freedom lovers were murdered in cold blood by the wretched communists the liberal hollywood suck faces like HANOI JANE are so in love with

You people are truly cluele... (Below threshold)

You people are truly clueless about what we were fighing for.

We were fighting for something that we believed wouldve made China better. Get a clue why Russia people gave up democrazy so quickly, they also elected a former KGB as their president.

Stop using the money that belongs to your children, grandchildren or even great grand children ..... in the name of freedom and human right. then Chinese will learn from your political system.

What is the Chineese ideogr... (Below threshold)

What is the Chineese ideogram for "Moby"?






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy