« Sympathy For The Devil | Main | 2010 Ramblings »

"Islamophobia is a fake concept"

We've all heard the meme... so succinctly expressed by Pamela Taylor at The Washington Post:

As we all struggle to make sense of the terrible events at Fort Hood, it is all too easy to blame a particular religion or a particular ethnic background. No doubt, certain pundits will have a field day, using this tragedy to proclaim yet again that Islam is a terrorist religion and Muslims or Arabs are violent and not to be trusted. Those who have more a favorable view of Islam and Muslims will realize that the shootings do not reflect Islamic teachings and that the vast majority of American Muslims are appalled at such violence.

Until we know more about Maj. Nidal's motives we should not jump to conclusions, and certainly we should not declare that he had religious/political motivations simply because he was Muslim.

The shootings at Fort Hood raise many questions. Major Nidal complained of being treated poorly by fellow soldiers because he was Muslim. It got bad enough, according to a New York Times article, that he hired a lawyer to seek to end his military career early. This request was denied, and he remained in the military. How severely did Islamophobic treatment by the very people he was trying to serve impact Maj. Hasan? How did the army's refusal to let him end his service early, even though he agreed to pay off the cost of his education, affect his feelings about the army? What kind of stresses are Muslim soldiers placed under when they are deployed to areas where they are killing fellow Muslims, and perhaps people of similar ethnic background? Is the army taking extra precautions to deal with the additional stresses these soldiers are under?

Unsurprisingly, her mindset is shared by Barack Hussein Obama.... and many, many other Leftists, to our detriment and the detriment of all of Western society.

Phyllis Chesler at PajamasMedia has cogent and relevant and brilliant things to say about it all:

We had all better learn this, beginning with the U.S. Army. The army must become free of political correctness; otherwise, there will be more Ft. Hoods, more single-cell operatives. There is a difference between "jumping to conclusions" and making a rational, reasoned judgment based on fact and experience. The Army should mandate the reporting of jihadic or Islamist statements by its soldiers. No one should be penalized for making such reports.

Islamophobia is a fake concept; there is no anti-Muslim backlash

Fake phrases and fake concepts like "Islamophobia" gave Major Hasan all the cover he needed. Even soldiers and other psychiatrists in the American Army were afraid of reporting Hasan's Islamist (not Islamic) rants lest they be seen as "racists" or as "Islamophobic," lest they be written up, demoted, even dishonorably discharged.

The politically correct concept of "Islamophobia" was as much behind the trigger as Major Hasan was.

Americans have been propagandized: The Islamophobia narrative as propaganda

Islamists are very clever and have launched a successful campaign to treat a totalitarian and apartheid system as a persecuted race, as a victim. The terrorist jihadist is always the victim. There is no anti-Muslim backlash. Hell no! The fact that Major Hasan was not ejected from the army because his colleagues feared death by lawsuit/loss of their careers is perfect proof of that.

Deliberate confusion
The term "Islamophobia" is a deliberate attempt to combine criticism of a belief system with hatred of a people because of the color of their skin. Thus "Islamophobia" is wrongfully allied with the real horrors of racism.

"Islamophobia" is a nonsense term. A "phobia" is an "irrational fear." "Claustrophobia" is irrational because enclosed spaces do not tend to kill you. But given the permanent intifada against Israel; a high level of Muslim-on-Muslim crime, including terrorism and honor killings; a fearfully mounting death toll; and the realities of Islamic (not Islamist) gender and religious apartheid, we actually have many reasons to be fearful of some - certainly not all - aspects of Islam. Women, gay men and Jews have particular reason to be fearful. As do civilian commuters in major European cities, tourists in Asia and Africa, and American soldiers on military bases.

It's not "phobic" to be worried about Islam/Islamism. It is eminently rational, given that since 9/11, there have been more than 14,000 jihadic attacks against civilians around the world. This does not include battlefront statistics.

Do not demonize the truth teller, deal with the issues

But to think that the answer to any criticism of Islam or Muslims is to demonize its critics and to indulge in exaggerated self-pity is to make the world more dangerous for us all.

The truth
America is fighting back in a war that radical, jihadic Islamists have declared against Israel and the West, especially against America. The Islamists have managed to persuade western leftists, academics, politicians, and the media that America and Israel are waging a war on Islam. It's what Osama bin Laden thinks.

Brainwashed People believe that the attacker is really the victim

The jihadist is always the victim. Men have been forced into becoming terrorists, forced to hijack planes and fly them into the World Trade Center, forced to shoot down soldiers at Ft. Hood or blow up civilians, both Muslims and infidels, in Israel and all across the Middle East because the jihadist's land was being "occupied" by infidels or because they were being forced to fight an American war against other Muslims. (By the way, Muslim-on-Muslim crime, including terrorist crime, is the real, hidden story here). Finally, the jihadist is always the victim because, poor guy, he is "mentally ill" and needs our help and understanding.

Ms. Chesler makes the point, time and again, on separating Islam from Islamists, the Muslim faith from the faith practiced by Jihadists... and it's a point I believe to be flawed, a topic for another day perhaps... but her points excerpted here are pointed and true and should be read and passed on.

It truly is a life and death issue.



TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Islamophobia is a fake concept":

» Brutally Honest linked with "Islamophobia is a fake concept"

Comments (8)

I dont know what everyone i... (Below threshold)

I dont know what everyone is so upset about ... to paraphrase Whoopi Goldberg, Its not like it was 'terrorism' terrorism.

Islamaphobia, Homophobia, b... (Below threshold)

Islamaphobia, Homophobia, both are BS terms, but are slung at people who disagree with both, yet do not have any fear of muslims or homosexuals.

It's like being called racist simply because you don't agree with The One's marxist ideology.

The people who accuse other... (Below threshold)

The people who accuse others of Islamophobia are guilty of religious bigotry. They would never accuse people who hate and fear Christianity of a phobia.

Anyone who dismisses Islam as irrelevant to the problem of terrorism today is exhibiting their own prejudice. Why can't we at least talk about the problem openly and honestly?

Texbob - well, that IS raci... (Below threshold)

Texbob - well, that IS racist, isn't it? /sarc

You know, maybe they do things differently in the Army, but if someone in the Air Force had gotten onto a Major because of their religion, THAT person would be looking at real trouble of their own.

So I'm not convinced that things are that different in the Army. Could it be he was being criticized because of his anti-military, pro-splodydope statements? For his ranting about Islam at a medical conference? For his support of the jihadist movement? Could it be he felt he was being picked on because he was advocating an easy-out for Muslims? Might someone in his chain of command have pulled him to one side and said "Cut out pushing your religion on your patients", and that was unfair enough in his mind to cause a psychotic break?

Seems to me like this guy was wound WAY too tight. And the system failed him - through not being willing to make it completely clear to him that HIS version of 'diversity' had to make accomodation for everyone else's. And no, "I'm OK, You're OK" hasn't been replaced in the pop psychology listings by "I'm a Muslim and You Must Die."

BTW - apparently he never filed any charges, or actually attempted to get out of the military according to the AP: (From the first link above...)

Meanwhile, the Pentagon has found no evidence that Hasan formally sought release from the Army as a conscientious objector or for any other reason, two senior military officials told The Associated Press. Family members have said he wanted to get out of the Army and had sought legal advice, suggesting that Hasan's anxiety as a Muslim over his pending deployment overseas might have been a factor in the deadly rampage.

Hasan had complained privately to colleagues that he was harassed for his religion and that he wanted to get out of the Army. But there is no record of Hasan filing a complaint with his chain of command regarding any harassment he may have suffered for being Muslim or any record of him formally seeking release from the military, the officials told the AP.
I really don't think the 'He was a victim, and we should all feel sorry for him!' meme is going to fly at all. He did the crime - now we'll see what happens next. Perhaps he'll not survive - but it'd sure be nice to get some rational explanations from a failed jihadist.

(Then again - anyone want to bet on him developing amnesia?)

Nothing was done about that... (Below threshold)

Nothing was done about that ticking time bomb, Hasan, because people are afraid of the Thought Police's enforcement of the PC Thought Crime Laws.

I've been telling people fo... (Below threshold)

I've been telling people for years that being afraid that a muslim terrorist is going to suicide bomb the train you're on is not Islamophobia, while being afraid that a muslim is going to break into your house and start redecorating the place a la Debbie Travis is. One is rational, the other is not.

Perhaps if Ms Taylor pulled... (Below threshold)

Perhaps if Ms Taylor pulled her head from her anal orifice, she'd discover that a majority of problems in the world are being caused by people OF THE MUSLIM FAITH. I haven't read of anyone else from other religions CUTTING OTHERS THROATS or DOING SUICIDE BOMBINGS of late. Perhaps Ms Taylor would care to enlighten us on her thoughts in that area.

For the record Garandfan, w... (Below threshold)
JustRuss IT1(SW) USN [reitred]:

For the record Garandfan, we haven't heard much about it but aren't the Irish still at it?

Just saying, other religions have crazies as well, but Islam has the highest percentage per capita.






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy