« What Will Egypt Look Like In One Year? | Main | Obama offers departing Gibbs an emblematic Democratic 'gift' »

What I Know (and hope) about Egypt

I would like to expound on the subject of Kevin's earlier post.

Egypt has been in the midst of a serious crisis, precipitated by a stagnant economy, rising food prices, and continued unrest at the hands of Muslim extremist groups.  Protests have been met with heavy handed tactics by the government.  Things finally boiled over, and voila, a "revolution."

But revolution will not restart the economy, nor will in bring down the price of food.  Both of those problems will surely get worse, since nothing spooks investors or the market like chaos and uncertainty.

The protesters in Cairo represent only a small fraction of the Egyptian population.  While the Cairo crowd is young, energetic, and presumably college educated, most of the rest of Egypt is not.  While support for a "moderate" government or a moderate leader like Mohammed El Baradei, remains strong among the protesters, it is unclear whether the same level of support exists in provincial areas. 

On the whole, Egyptians seem to be very conservative on religious and cultural matters.  A recent Pew poll reported a substantial majority of Egyptians favoring more religious presence in government and the imposition of violent penalties for adultery, theft, and apostasy, and around half of Egyptians expressed a desire to see workplace segregation of men and women, and also expressed either support or sympathy for suicide bombings and the terrorist group Hamas. 

The Muslim Brotherhood, which has been a powerful player in Egypt since the 1920's, should be taken very seriously.  In spite of the idiotic pronouncements by our own government officials, the Brotherhood still maintains its close ties with Hamas and can correctly be described as an inspirational force behind contemporary radical/terrorist strains of Islam.  The Brotherhood was also responsible for issuing a fatwa and carrying out the execution of Anwar Sadat, whom the Brotherhood considered a traitor for negotiating peace with Israel.   In fact, the continuing threats posed by the Brotherhood and its extremist allies are at least partly to blame for Mubarak's continued use of emergency powers and police state tactics.  It's reasonable to assume that the Brotherhood will attempt (as it has been doing for 80 years) to strong-arm its way into power, perhaps by concentrating on more provincial, conservative regions of the country. 

Like all dictators, Hosni Mubarak has accumulated a personal fortune well into the billions of dollars.  He has enjoyed autocratic rule under a suspended constitution, with little or no accountability, for thirty years.  Although he could simply disappear and spend the rest of his life in some kind of secluded island retreat, such a scenario seems unlikely to me.  He and his family have had too many fingers in too many pies for far too long, to simply walk away from it all.  How this will affect the restructuring of the Egyptian government remains to be seen.

Finally, it is unclear whether our own Smart DiplomacyTM has undertaken the necessary steps to ensure that the government that is in place a year from now remains an ally of the United States and supports our efforts to combat violent Islamist terrorism.  

However, on the positive side I will note that it is no longer 1979.  The brutality and underwhelming achievements of the Islamic Revolution in Iran, particularly the costly war with Iraq, will surely impede the plans of some to have another such revolution in Egypt.  Those currently protesting the Mubarak regime are certainly aware, at least to some extent, of the use of force by the Ayatollahs in Iran two years ago, to crush similar protests of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's fraudulent election victory.  There is also the fact that older Egyptians undoubtedly recall the pain and humiliation of two consecutive defeats (1967 and 1973) by the Israelis.

To me, much of the Middle East still seems caught up in the idealism and the promise of heavenly blessings preached by Islamic fundamentalists; but at the same time, although they continue to celebrate what they perceive to be small victories in the name of Allah over the US and Israel, there seems to be a strong overall sense of fatigue, no doubt caused by 50 years of intifada and jihad and nationalist wars, all without a single major or decisive victory.  They continue to support radicals, because each radical promises that his cause will be the final uprising that achieves victory and restores honor.  But with the failure of each radical movement to secure peace and victory, the fatigue grows.

Therefore I am hopeful that the Egyptian people will reject a government that pushes the country toward Islamic radicalism and militant nationalism -- a path that surely would lead to more violence and bloodshed in the Middle East.
Enhanced by Zemanta


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Comments (6)

Well, you can hope all that... (Below threshold)
Brett :

Well, you can hope all that. I think Mubarak had it right, however, from Reuters (phone call from Mubarak to Benjamin Ben-Eliezer):

"He gave me a lesson in democracy and said: 'We see the democracy the United States spearheaded in Iran and with Hamas, in Gaza, and that's the fate of the Middle East,'" Ben-Eliezer said.

"'They may be talking about democracy but they don't know what they're talking about and the result will be extremism and radical Islam,'" he quoted Mubarak as saying.

U.S. support for pro-democracy elements in Iran has not led to regime change in the Islamic Republic, and Hamas, a group Washington considers to be a terrorist organization, won a 2006 Palestinian election promoted by the United States.

Hamas seized control of the Gaza Strip in 2007 after a coalition government it formed with Western-backed Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas collapsed in a power struggle.

Another domino falls.

We already know how to successfully establish democracy in the Middle East. This ain't it.

The Iranian people have bee... (Below threshold)
Jim Addison:

The Iranian people have been tired of the mad mullahs for 20 years or more. "Fatigue" doesn't bring down regimes who have the guns and are willing to kill the opposition.

The Iranian mullahs were willing to kill the demonstrators in 2009, and they crushed the opposition. The Egyptian military regime was not willing to do the same, and fell.

If "fatigue" could bring down dictators, North Korea would have reformed decades ago.

Not good signs. When you s... (Below threshold)

Not good signs. When you start with bringing the existing government leadershp to trial, you are going to spend years with one side killing the other. Now it starts..

Former Interior Minister Habib El Adly, former Prime Minister Ahmed Nazif and former Information Minister Annas El Feqy banned from travelling and assets frozen

Former Information Minister Anna El Feqy prevented from travelling and under house arrest

Swiss bank freezes assets of ousted President Mubark

MB leader Essam El Erian calls for the head of the Supreme Constitutional Court as Chairman of the transitional period

Qaradawy congratulates Egypt and the Arab world on Mubarak's departure

Israel closes embassy in Cairo following news of Mubarak's stepping down

The less than 2% of the Egy... (Below threshold)

The less than 2% of the Egyptian population that indulged in the recent street agitations will now hear from the Islamanazi Muslim Brotherhood and its Islamanazi Persian and Hamas and Hezbollah sponsors -- and from the 98% of those Egyptians who did not.

Expect US Department of State "controlled" post liberation Iraq redux and a par-for-the-course Islamanazi reign of terror.

And I hope the next "War An... (Below threshold)

And I hope the next "War And Peace" will be written by trained Monkeys ,also, but I doubt it will happen.

please check out <a href="... (Below threshold)






Follow Wizbang

Follow Wizbang on FacebookFollow Wizbang on TwitterSubscribe to Wizbang feedWizbang Mobile


Send e-mail tips to us:

[email protected]

Fresh Links


Section Editor: Maggie Whitton

Editors: Jay Tea, Lorie Byrd, Kim Priestap, DJ Drummond, Michael Laprarie, Baron Von Ottomatic, Shawn Mallow, Rick, Dan Karipides, Michael Avitablile, Charlie Quidnunc, Steve Schippert

Emeritus: Paul, Mary Katherine Ham, Jim Addison, Alexander K. McClure, Cassy Fiano, Bill Jempty, John Stansbury, Rob Port

In Memorium: HughS

All original content copyright © 2003-2010 by Wizbang®, LLC. All rights reserved. Wizbang® is a registered service mark.

Powered by Movable Type Pro 4.361

Hosting by ServInt

Ratings on this site are powered by the Ajax Ratings Pro plugin for Movable Type.

Search on this site is powered by the FastSearch plugin for Movable Type.

Blogrolls on this site are powered by the MT-Blogroll.

Temporary site design is based on Cutline and Cutline for MT. Graphics by Apothegm Designs.

Author Login

Terms Of Service

DCMA Compliance Notice

Privacy Policy