Colorado – The Next Florida?

Looking for the next Florida?

Colorado voters to re-consider ‘winner take all’

The Denver Post has this to say:

We urge voters to reject Amendment 36.

If the measure is approved, Colorado could lose political relevance as presidential candidates come to realize that there is so little at stake in Colorado. It wouldn’t be worth a candidate’s time to campaign here and to speak to Colorado concerns if the best result would be a one electoral vote advantage.

Never mind the constitutional crisis that would be provoked this year if the measure passes and Colorado’s unusual vote loomed as decisive between President Bush and Sen. John Kerry. The Amendment was written to apply to this year’s presidential election. In a close race, such as 2000, the inevitable litigation over that clause could throw the election into dispute.Proportional electors is an interesting idea if applied nationally. Applied to a single state it has the effect of marginalizing the importance of any particular state enacting similar legislation.

There are two real constitutional problems with the measure. 1) If passed the results of the 2004 presidential election would be allocated according to the scheme (most likely 5-4). 2) The measure usurps the constitutional requirement that the Colorado state legislature define the rules related to its electors to the Electoral College. My guess is that the Supreme Court would quickly strike down the law. The constitution is pretty clear on the Electoral College process.

The obvious Florida reference comes if the initiative passes and the overall electoral vote difference is less than 5 votes. There’s a variety of scenarios where either Bush or Kerry win the election by losing Colorado and the initiative passing. Next thing you know it’s a repeat of Florida 2000.

Anyone want to bet that the cable news networks are NOT praying for that kind of controversial result?

Jacques Derrida Decomposing
Who's "Fair and Balanced?"

15 Comments

  1. Tom October 11, 2004
  2. MrGrumpyDrawers October 11, 2004
  3. Jim October 11, 2004
  4. tony October 11, 2004
  5. Remy Logan October 12, 2004
  6. Hank Fenster October 12, 2004
  7. -S- October 12, 2004
  8. Rance October 12, 2004
  9. Ralph October 12, 2004
  10. bains October 12, 2004
  11. conelrad October 12, 2004
  12. Randy Charles Morin October 12, 2004
  13. Pavel October 12, 2004
  14. McGehee October 12, 2004
  15. Tony Iovino October 12, 2004