All over the news and the blogosphere are accounts of the battle of Fallujah. And one recurring theme is the cost in the lives of innocents this battle will incur. We’re already being shown pictures of wounded and crippled children, struck down in the battle.
I’m going to risk outraging a great number of the readers here, but I’m going to go out on a limb here and say I don’t give a damn how many civilians get killed in Fallujah, as long as we get the bastards.
There’s an old saying: “once you pay the Danegeld, you never get rid of the Dane.” Once we have established that we will refrain from pursuing our enemies when they hide among civilians, we threaten all civilians in the future. Any time one side in a battle publicly imposes limits on itself, the other side will immediately exploit it.
Earlier on in Iraq, we showed respect for mosques. Shortly thereafter, mosques suddenly became the centers of the resistance, being converted into fortresses and arsenals. Had we blown up the first few they occupied, I’d be willing to bet that there would be hundreds more that would now have been left alone.
We have long shown that we respect hospitals. When we took the main hospital in Fallujah, it had been converted into a headquarters for the insurgents. And as soon as the Iraqi commandos had taken the hospital and raised the Iraqi flag, they started shelling the hospital even as we were turning it back into its original purpose.
Now we come down to the insurgents hiding behind civilians in the heart of Fallujah. If we show restraint and allow them to escape, we will have shown that taking hostages is a successful tactic and endanger God knows how many more innocents down the line. We have to stand firm and show them that there is no escape, no shelter, no sanctuary.
I don’t want there to be a single innocent death in Fallujah. And having faith in our military’s equipment, training, and scruples, I know they will be minimized as much as possible. But there will be many heart-breaking stories and images from this battle. We mustn’t let them cloud the real issue — if we let it stop us now, there will be many more Fallujahs in the future, and eventually we’ll have to disregard hostages or simply give up. And we can’t afford to surrender in this war.
J.
(Author’s note: before you excoriate me over this posting, please know I hated writing it even more than you hated reading it. But I have a moral obligation to speak the truth as I see it, no matter how much I’d like to ignore it. It’s an ugly world these days, and saying otherwise merely postpones the inevitable.)

“If we lose this war we will all be tried as war criminals.”
Gen. Curtis LeMay
Superhawk: You’re probably right about the title. I tend to let myself get a little sensationalistic in my titles. It’s a bad habit.
Sarah: It’s a cliche’ that “liberals feel, while conservatives think.” The gist of your argument seems to be that I make you feel bad, so I must be wrong. Go ahead, prove me wrong. I’d dearly love to be proven wrong on this one. But my argument is based on what I perceive as simple logic and reason. If you can point out the flaw, I’d be very grateful.
And Sarah, my First Amendment rights aren’t yours (or anyone’s) to trade away. This pesky thing called The Constitution of the United States says so. Give it a read some time.
J.
James, exactly how long has it been since the government of your country was THE major player on the international scene? Go sit down and quit sniping at those who actually fight for the future of Western Civilization. We don’t have to travel. We don’t have to care what you think. I’d be much more prone to care if you foreigners weren’t so friggin’ condescending all the time. “Operation Clark County” by the Guardian was a prime example. Look down your pointy nose at us dumb Americans all you want. While you’re doing that, we’ll be saving your ass by making sure the terrorists stay close to their home bases in the Middle East rather than exporting it to Western nations.
Get a clue: we don’t care what you say.
If you respond to me, it’ll just reinforce my point that you really do think we care what you say. If you think the U.S. is wrong to invade Iraq, go join the forces trying to expel us. Good luck with that.
“Those who study history are surrounded by those doomed to repeat it.”
Actually, James, to be fair, please tell us what country you are from and explain to us dumb Americans what your nation has done to secure the rights of freedom-loving people around the world in the past 300 years, along with what your nation is doing to secure the spread of consensual government and end oppression?
(Note: sipping espresso in an internet cafe in a European capital and complaining about the American cowboys doesn’t count)
I’m watching a press conference being held by Lt. Gen. Tom Metz in Iraq. And all the reporters are asking is about casualities and how many civilians are being killed and other dumbass questions. General Metz has more patience than I. Personally, I’d tell the reporters to “eat sh*t.” Is there a group of people more contemptable than the denizens of the news media. Ooops, here’s a female reporter asking General Metz a really dumb question. These press conferences are a waste of time. These reporters are going to make up stories anyway.
“In my life, I have prayed but one prayer: ‘Oh Lord, make my enemies ridiculous.’ And God granted it.”
— Voltaire
I apologize for using quotes, but it comforts me to know that great minds before me have suffered the same pain.
Yeah, thanks for saving our asses in the Middle East. When I watched the news this morning, I kept thinking, GREAT JOB! Yeah, my ass feels saved.
My 18-year-old cousin visited this weekend and just couldn’t accept the notion of civilian casualties. If we accidentally bomb someone’s house, he said, won’t he hate US instead of the terrorists we were trying to get? Aren’t we just creating more hatred and animosity?
So I asked him to consider the alternative. We DON’T attack an area because of a concern for the innocent. That gives our enemies a stronghold from which they can coordinate attacks. From there they build IEDs. They set up kidnapping operations. They behead civilians on camera. They plan assassinations. Heck, maybe they even take over the innocent man’s house at the end of the block for their own operations. What now is the cost of sparing that man’s house?
He quoted the old aphorism, “Better to let ten guilty go free than condemn one innocent.” But when those ten guilty go forth and murder 20 innocents, you have not SAVED an innocent life; you’ve merely traded one for twenty.
It’s a hard world that often requires hard choices. He knows it; he just doesn’t want to believe it. He’s young. It’s tough. If he asks again, though, I’ll direct him to your post, Jay Tea.
uuhh wonder where our “wiseman” james went? (could be the time of day when he does his ass kissing)
“Some asses may require several wars to be saved”
MahaRichie
Yikes!
While I disagree completely with the sentiments expressed in this article, I am even more disgusted with people like James who seem allergic to any form of civilized discourse. Coming here with talk about ‘Nazi-pigs’ is just utterly indefensible.
That said, I respectfully submit my opinion that you are dead wrong and you do give truth to the ‘conservatives think, liberals feel’cliche. “As long as we go in and kill all those terrorists, it doesnt matter who else dies…why didnt they get out anyway…many are even aiding the terrorists…etc… Seen from a strictly pragmatic view, your analysis would be correct. However morals do dictate that gung-ho warfare is not the most important thing. That frightened six year old girl trapped in her house by the fighting should not be sacrificed because you feel you have no choice….and this is coming from someone who was fairly sympathetic to the war mind you.
So yes, even though they will-and should- storm Fallujah, please don’t suddenly start throwing around the ‘collateral damage in the name of the greater good argument.
A few thoughts. This is 100% RIGHT, the civilians in Fallujah knew we were coming and therefore those that are there are either there WITH THE TERRORISTS by choice, or are hostage.
Second, to the Marines, Soldiers, Airmen, and Sailors who have CHOSEN to serve this country, THANK YOU AND GOD BLESS!
“When I watched the news this morning, I kept thinking, GREAT JOB! Yeah, my ass feels saved.”
Such a shame. Perhaps if it weren’t we would be spared the misery of your talking out of it.
We should make it clear to the leaders of the muslim world, that they need to tear down the madrasas, cut off the terrorists funding and sanctuary. We need to impress upon the leaders of the muslim world that if we are hit in America with weapons of mass distruction, we will strike Meca as a response. This would go a long way in cutting the support of the Islamic facists. We can no longer pretend that this terror is not supported by the Saudi and Iranian governments.
Right on Chuck! We have to stop pussy footing around,and threatening their beloved Mecca should wake them up to reality.
I think that a Britney Spears tour in the middle east would tear down a lot of walls. “To Mecca or Busts” should be our rallying cry.
Inside any besieged city there are NO civilians. Everyone is a combatant….think Stalingrad, Moscow, Jerico.
God Bless the Marines/Army
I disagree. The insurgents will no doubt be defeated but in the end, the innocent will still pay a heavy price. That’s the way things work and it sucks.
“It’s an ugly world these days…”
Precisely when wasn’t the world ugly, Jay?
As Jay Tea’s favorite liberal for the moment, I thought I’d respond to his poorly titled and clumsily worded argument.
link
James and Sarah,
“America, Fuck, Yeah! Lick my butt and suck on my balls.” – Trey Parker & Matt Stone
Just since you liked quotes so much.
Or better yet “Only a dick can fuck an asshole. And sometimes, pussies get so full of shit they turn into assholes.” – Trey Parker & Matt Stone
No one should be celebrating the deaths of innocents, and Jay isn’t. You are incredibly naive and intellectually shallow if you fail to recognize the essential weakness of your positions (if you are indeed 2 different people) given the ruthlessness and global pretentions of militant islam.
Being blinded by your hatred of the President and this country is no way to go through life.
(sorry for the profanity, Kevin and Jay, but that ‘s the way Team America was)
This thread is getting tiresome…the nauseating smugness and snobbish superiority of Sarah and James…well, what can one say of someone with the brains of a marmoset and the moral compass of an alley cat.
Sarah’s quoting of Voltaire is especially revealing since he was one of Rousseau’s biggest detractors (he of the “natural rights of man” theory). Besides being a descpicable human being, Voltaire was a mediocre author raised to literary god status by people who lived 150 years after he died.
And James…”it’s time we sit down and negotiate with these people…”? WHAT KIND OF A LOON WOULD SIT DOWN WITH THE BEHEADER ZARQAWI?
Perhaps we could arrange a dinner for just the two of you…just make sure you watch the silverware.
This thread is getting tiresome…the nauseating smugness and snobbish superiority of Sarah and James…well, what can one say of someone with the brains of a marmoset and the moral compass of an alley cat.
Sarah’s quoting of Voltaire is especially revealing since he was one of Rousseau’s biggest detractors (he of the “natural rights of man” theory). Besides being a descpicable human being, Voltaire was a mediocre author raised to literary god status by people who lived 150 years after he died.
And James…”it’s time we sit down and negotiate with these people…”? WHAT KIND OF A LOON WOULD SIT DOWN WITH THE BEHEADER ZARQAWI?
Perhaps we could arrange a dinner for just the two of you…just make sure you watch the silverware.
Its just the same sort of ethical problem as the entire invasion of Iraq, on a smaller scale. We knew civvies would die in this war. However, we felt the end outcome would be better for us all, in the long run.
People die in wars. We try to avoid it. Our enemies revel in death, and kill people even without our being around to fight with. Much of the left seems to lose sight of that.
“I’m a liberal, but I’d be willing to give up my First Amendment rights if it meant that people like you would not be allowed to speak.”
Sarah, not only are you a liberal, you’re also a card-carrying idiot.
So–your solution to deal with speech you disagree with is for everybody to be silenced. Riiiight.
“crayola thinking” seems to be something of a liberal talent.
On the subject of the post–Fallujah will simply cost what it costs in civilian casualties. And too damn bad. The West didn’t pick this fight and as far as I’m concerned, the more civilian casualties the better. We still have a long way to go to catch up with 3000 dead on 9/11.
Jay, I can understand your point of view, but I feel that we should all keep in mind that people with far more infomation than you and I are running this thing.
The end game is a stable Iraq and by extension a stable Middle East. If we stomp around Fallujah killing up everything that moves we will probably just delay that outcome.
I think the Bush administration knows what they’re doing.
I hope.
Keith:You may or may not be a liberal.Who the ‘F’cares.One thing that is obvious from your post is…You are a ‘scumbag and a reprobate’.Your statement:[“The west didnt pick this fight,and as far as I’m concerned the more civilian casualities the better.We still have a long way to go to catch up with 3000 dead on 9/11”.]Is the sickest thing I have read in a while.It almost sounds like something a very immature person would make .If you are a kid, you are a dope and,I forgive you .If you are an adult I would like to sew your ass to your face.
We want to be sucessful in Iraq,but our brave Soldiers and Marines will do anything to avoid civilian casualities.
Deliberately killing bystanders early in a battle could assure that the enemy will not continue to use them as shields, and in the long run such a policy could save the lives of more bystanders than it destroys.
However, such a policy would be evil. And as we have learned from liberals for decades, no act is so evil that it cannot be rationalized.
The best policy is that which our good military people are carrying out: Take care to avoid civilian casualties, while recognizing that some are inevitable. This way you can face yourself after the war, and meanwhile you will avoid turning more innocent civilians into enemies.
MahaRichie, actually, I was being moderate.
My personal preference would be to drop a 5 megaton bucket of Instant Sunshine on Mecca.
Unfortunately, in this respect war is just like taxes. If you create incentives for terrorists to hide among civilians, they will. Unfortunately they are going to do so, because they know that it will force us to kill some innocent civilians. And then liberals will work to undermine the war. Sad.
To all my detractors.
I would like to extend my apologies for any offence caused. I find it ironic though, that people with such hard line views can take offence so easily from a few innocuous words. Much more offensive is the blinkered views of those who support the war, yet have no idea of what it is the war is about.
When you fall (or are pushed) off your moral high horse I’m sure the world will embrace you again as the great country you once were. Until then I pity you.
” Much more offensive is the blinkered views of those who support the war, yet have no idea of what it is the war is about.
When you fall (or are pushed) off your moral high horse I’m sure the world will embrace you again as the great country you once were. Until then I pity you.”
James, I’m Australian. not American and I support this war 100%. Perhaps in part because I have a bloody good idea what war is about, having served in another army and fought against “guerillas”. Until and unless you’ve seen true evil up close and personal, I’d suggest you refrain from assuming that all of us have “blinkered views”.
As for referring to the U.S. as the “great country you once were” I guess you’re just confusing America with the tired, unprincipled ang gutless has-beens of Europe.
keith….I am Australian aswell. I hope it was the Australian Army that you fought for.
You can bet one thing-“james” never served in any army. Why? I know of no army that accepts cowards. Glad to find out you do not live in the USA!
even still, Australians need to mind their own business (concerning our choices for president).
James, nope..it was the Rhodesian Army. I dunno why it’s a matter of “hope” that I fought with the Australian Army, though.’I fought in Mozambique, Rhodesia, Northern Ireland and one or two other places and it taught me that negotiation with terrorists is impossible.
It also taught me that they use civilians as cover when it suits them, knowing full well that a stupid and/or compliant media will blame the troops for civilian casualties.
Although my point of view comes across as “extreme” to some people (it obviously does to you) I strongly believe that until and unless the majority of Muslims publicly condemn acts such as bombing and shooting schoolchildren, beheading innocent civilians and using places of worship as firebases, then we have no choice but to treat Islam as a whole as the enemy. Read the Koran–Islam regards the West (infidels) as the enemy.
Sure, I might wish it were otherwise, but to stick to the norms of civilised behaviour in this conflict is to set ourselves up to lose Western civilisation.
The argument that it would “make us no better than them” doesn’t wash–we flattened German and Japanese cities during WW2 and yet managed to keep our values, to revert to civilised behaviour after the war was won.
It takes what it takes.
The reason for this war is because the alternative, doing nothing, was not exceptable. In taking down sadam we have sent a message to the rest of the muslim world. We have had enough. Kadaffi heard this message, Syria and Iran need to open their ears also. If we can establish a democracy in Afganistan and Iraq, we have a chance to change the course of the middle east. The enemys of the U.S. should know from history that we free people (France) defeat nations (Germany, Japan) then build them back up, set them on their feet. Then we leave, asking only for enough land to bury our dead. Thanks all you people from down under for your support. Also, thank God for the Brits.
You mean thank god that Tony Blair is the current prime minister of Great Britain. The British people as a whole are a very socialistic society. I know two people who have “defected” to the United States (that is, they became United States naturalized citizens) from Great Britain because of the socialistic society in GB. One of them is a marine engineer (emeritus – aka retired) who currently teaches at my school (The California Maritime Academy), and the other is a woman who is my mother’s friend (she’s real classy).
Thank God that Tony Blair is the current prime minister to see that the war was just, and to stand by allies in time of stress and need.
I would also agree with you, but remember the only ass in this whole war is Bush! If we had gone after Bin Laden and Al Kaida to begin with the war would be over by now. Remember, 911 belongs to Bin Laden.
hey “joel’ you been drinking to much Kool-Aid.
Civilian Casualties are a difficult topic. Whether our focus is retribution for 9/11, removing WMD from the hands of a tyrant, or just removing the tyrant from his mass murders throne, the mother and child which are these casualties did little or nothing to warrant death. But the analysis cannot be did the civilian do anything to deserve death. Such a standard would obviate all war, justified or not. So, what is the analysis? The pacificist might say,
I sincerely hope that Osama bombs all your houses and kills all your families. You are no better than bloodthirsty terrorists, although their English is much better than most of yours. If America is primarily made of this mentality, it’s my sincere hope the US is nuked off the face of the earth.