Terri Schiavo is going to die because Michael Schiavo has better lawyers.
Exhibit #1) This article in the St. Petersburg Times (Memories diverge on what Terri wanted), explains it all.
On the Monday in January 2000 when the Schiavo case went to trial, the Schindlers’ lawyer remembers being surprised to see a St. Petersburg Times reporter in court.
What are you doing here, Patricia Campbell asked. She had no anticipation that the case would make the front page.
Back then, Campbell was working alone, without an assistant to help. On the other side was Michael Schiavo’s lawyer, George Felos, who had handled the seminal right-to-die case of Estelle Browning, which went to the Florida Supreme Court in 1990.
Campbell said in an interview Wednesday that she took the case out of sympathy for the Schindlers. She said about 20 attorneys had turned down the couple, who had little money.
Campbell, who now has a prestigious AV rating from the Martindale-Hubbell lawyer peer review system, had never handled a right-to-die case. She did not have money to find witnesses, she said. Indeed, Campbell did not take depositions from Joan and Scott Schiavo before the trial. Normally, that would be a basic step for a lawyer preparing for trial.
Campbell presented just two witnesses to address the claim that Terri would not want her feeding tube removed.
[More]Exhibit #2) This morning Florida’s Department of Children and Families missed an opportunity to legally take custody of Terri Schiavo. WFTS reports:
Wednesday afternoon, Pinellas Circuit Judge George Greer issued a temporary restraining order, preventing DCF from removing Terri from the Pinellas Park hospice where her life-sustaining feeding tube has been disconnected.
This morning at 8, DCF filed an appeal to Greer’s order. When they did so, an automatic stay of the order went into effect, meaning that they could intervene.
The attorney for Terri’s husband Michael (George Felos), who opposes any attempts to prolong Terri’s life, said he suspected DCF wasn’t aware of that stay until he had filed a motion for a new restraining order.Legally Terri’s family was never able to recover from that one day in court 5 years ago. Felos was just rubbing salt in the wound this morning as he continued his legal dominance…

!00% exactly correct, Kevin. I have personally observed cases follow this precise pattern as the result of failed legal expertise in the early stages of litigation (but not on the same Schiavo issue). There were so many angles that could have been used here that could have tied-up this case for YEARS it’s shocking. I often compare getting legal help to getting medical help: would I want my child operated on by a local, Florida general practitioner or would I search out and get the very best practitioner no matter where he or she practiced? The answer should be obvious. The comparison is quite close. Naturally, money can be a deciding factor. Ironically, however, I think the facts are so compelling in this case that finding a top-flight attorney to undertake their representation pro bono would not have been a problem. Finally, this is not to suggest that these attorneys didn’t do the very best they were capable of doing. Perhaps they were simply out-classed in the ring.
Can someone tell me if Terri is considered an invalid or physically disabled????
According to Michaels lawyers, Terri is a Vegetable.
When I was a pup just out of college, I was a witness in a libel action that was in litigation for FOUR YEARS, and ended up being settled out-of-court. I was not named as a party, thank God. But giving a deposition for TWO DAYS in front of a half-dozen lawyers whose clients had been dragged into the mess has formed my highly negative views of attorneys and the American legal system. It is not only a huge drag on our economy, it leads to tragic, unjust stupitdities that leave poor defenseless people like Terri Schiavo twisting in the wind, without any meaningful protection of her interests.
I propose “National Spit-On-A-Lawyer Day,” to be celebrated annually on the anniversary of Terri Schiavo’s impending death by starvation.
Is it only me who is bothered by the fact that a legally-blind judge — Judge Greer — was assigned to this case? I mean, how the hell can he make a ruling if he could not see Terri for himself? He depends on the advice of others. Is that “due process?” I know it’s not PC to bring up this point, but screw PC — we’re talking about a woman’s life here. And why the secrecy? Why are family members prohibited from videotaping or filming Terri on her deathbed? Why isn’t the MSM demanding access in the name of the First Amendment? Why? What are the Liberals (yes, they are pulling the strings — I saw the director of the Florida ACLU saying as much) so afraid the American people might see?
I think you are right on the money.
Also, when you consider that Felos makes his name and living off right to die issues, the Schindler’s were overmatched from the begining.
Having a bad attorney verses a good attorney makes all the difference in any type of case, had OJ Simpson been a poor man depending on a public defender, anyone doubt he would be sitting on death row right now?
Why Is Terri Shiavo Going To Die?
Terri Schiavo is going to die because Michael Schiavo has better lawyers.
OH PUUUUUUUUUULLLLEEEAAAZZZZZZE!!!!!!!!!
Cindy
Why isn’t the MSM demanding access in the name of the First Amendment?
The First Amendment grants the media the right to barge in on someone’s private hospital room and videotape them?
I think most of America has no clue, no idea, of what it’s like to be in this position. I also don’t think anyone has ever walked into a room of a person who is brain dead – ie vegetative state. At the age of 27, the last thing Terri would be thinking of, is a living will, so she’d she something on tv or out on a walk and chatting with her husband, she’d tell him how she felt about living in such a situation. At the time, living wills and donor cards were just starting. So the only person who would know what she felt and what she wanted would have been her best friend, lover and that man would be her husband.
There are thousands of cases like this throughout the country and we don’t hear about them because they didn’t have parents who splashed it all over the front pages and now all over the friggin internet. They won’t even show you pictures of what she looks like today so all I can tell you is to think of Karen Ann Quinlin.
Yes, her brain stem still functions. The only thing the brain stem does is breathing, body temperature and blood pressure. Just because that grape sized thing at the base of the neck still functions, does not mean she does. She is brain dead and probably noticibly seen over the the last of the 15 years she has been in a vegetative state.
You can thank Medical Science for this conundrum. I was 24 years old when I had to make the decision for my husband to be unplugged. At one point, even Terri was in that condition. Again, over the past year, I had to push that decision through on my father because I knew this was not what he wanted. He did have a Living Will but you also need a DNR – a do not resuscitate order. And if you’ve been resuscitated, you have immediate shut down. Even with a living will, they will monitor your brain activity for three days before they will again, shut you down.
They are also not telling you the complete story. She is not being starved to death and without fluids- even though that is the case. She is heavily sedated just in case – one of the benefits of being in a hospice. Back when I did my thesis on eutanasia for college (in my mid thirties), I learned even more than I had after I was 24. (That situation caused me to go out and get a living will and a DNR).
You would be amazed at the lengths some people have gone through to die – and most of them without dignity. Many were not brain dead but their brain stems were dead or almost dead. Perfect example: ALS
There was a woman who actually had herself removed from her hopital bed, brought to a motel, so she could starve herself away. Starvation is incredibly painful. Although they have not said it and would probably deny it, Terri is heavily sedated. No one is that cruel and I’m sure her hospice is seeing to her care. Trust me, they didn’t close the door and walk away; she is indeed being cared for. I doubt she feels anything but they’ll do it anyway for the sake of the families and that of Terri.
Now if she were not in the news CONSTANTLY and was not in the news over the past years because of her parents, her husband could bring her home and arranged for her to have a shot – not unlike those they get on death row and her ending would have been quick and over in ten minutes. But too much notice about this situation has been given, so they did not have the option. All that’s left is the option to starve and remove fluids but let me tell you from studying, from example, from knowledge, she is not suffering even if she could feel suffering. So instead they make this really big deal about her starving to death – not even having water without telling you the entire truth. For some one who has been in this state for 15 years and over the last 7, completely brain mush, is indignanty for her and for her family.
Her family has to move on now; they need to let go of their daughter and let go and start living for themselves right now. They have put off their lives for over 15 years and if anything was going to happen, it would have happened by now. So what they need to do is get along with her husband, plan her final body goodbyes and then focus on living their lives without Terri.
If they hadn’t made such a big deal over it, they could have quietly let her die by the lethal shot which really lasts at most 5 minutes and no one would even know the difference. She doesn’t know the difference now and she never will.
It’s time for this country to move on – this stuff if happening every day. She’s not in a coma, but in a constant vegetative state from being brain dead. It’s way past time to say goodbye. And her family and spokespeople are going to make it worse than it really is. There is just so much you do not know.
This can be reproduced anywhere.
Cindy
Terri Schiavo is going to die because Michael Schiavo has better lawyers.
Terry Schiavo died because she had a heart attack brought on by bulemia and malnutrition. Frankly I don’t care if they disconnect her or not, she’s gone, and either way she can’t be hurt.
It’s sad to watch the personal tragedy of a family turned into a Neo-Christian circus, at least in this one rare instance, the American Taliban is belly-flopping for all to see. Ten to one, Americans disagree with Congress getting involved, see through the politicla subterfuge, and even the evangelical community, albeit by a narrow margin, isn’t buying this turkey.
Well put angel.
Cindy, that had to be one of the most disjointed pieces of drivel I’ve ever read on the issue. I will, however, poke a few holes in that spiel.
First, there has been no “three days” of brain monitoring applied to Terri. Period. Without that type of study, we don’t know what her mental condition truly is, and Michael hasn’t allowed it. Also, a person is considered “brain dead” when there is no significant brain activity at all. Brain dead people don’t grunt, roll their eyes, open and close their eyes, etc. Don’t confuse the two. Vegetative and Brain Dead are two different situations.
Michael truly could have taken his wife home and given her a lethal shot, but he would be tried for murder under Florida law. He may have evaded conviction from a sympathetic jury, but Florida law expressly prevents such action.
“this stuff if [sic] happening every day.” Oh really? how many estranged spouses are granted life-and-death control over their partners? I’d be curious about those statistics.
“And her family and spokespeople are going to make it worse than it really is.” I find that hard to believe. Starving a living human being is hardly exacerbated by fighting for her survival.
” There is just so much you do not know.” And you do, I guess. Hmm. Didn’t know you were personal friends of these folks. Maybe you could explain why paramedics who responded to Terri’s collapse immediately called for police backup and assumed this was a domestic violence case.
“This can be reproduced anywhere.”
Huh?
My only real question is whether you’re naturally this dense, whether you have to really try for it, or whether you’ve missed your medication for the past few weeks.
DS:
1. What exactly is a “Neo-Christian?”
2. To which poll are you referring that states that 10:1 ratio of disapproval and the stance of the evangelical community?
3. Do you really expect to be taken seriously tossing out the “American Taliban” line?
Just wondering.
I disagree entirely. Michael Shiavo has a better legal argument. You simply cannot bring the moral position that life beats death into this. A court must look at it neutrally, life and death are equally appealing for someone like Terri, which would she prefer? The court found that she would choose death. No they never recovered, from that decision, they had lost at that point. However, their lawyers were good enough to drag this out an additional ten years. To blame the judges and lawyers for this is to miss the whole point, none of this has anything to do with the legal system. There was a family dispute about Terri’s wishes, the court heard the facts and ruled for Michael. Why on earth would the the Schindlers get a Mulligan? Why would a new court do a new reveiw of the facts? That is not how the system works or should work.
DS and Cindy can go pound sand. Who the fuck are you to say when someone should die??? Who the hell appointed you master over life and death??? You wanna play God, then don’t be stupid, be smarty, go and join the neo-nazi party. They like to exterminate undesirables too. In fact, I suggest that someone that doesn’t respect life is an undesirable, like DS and Cindy. Time for each of you to be euthanized. (This is an object lesson for the deranged. It is not an endorsement of actions.)
~DS~: I’m an atheist and a registered democrat who crosses party lines when voting. So, there goes your bs theory.
allium: Good. I’m glad you like it because she posts it at least 3 times a day no matter what the topic.
Brian –
No one said for the MSM to “barge in.” A news pool cameraman could be escorted into Terri’s room.
Let me make this clear — once our courts and government take actions against a person which would result in death, then it is the people’s right to know everything. Or do you favor people being held by the government without access to anyone?
One other thing: the law and the US Constitution belongs to us — the citizens of the United States. Not to a bunch of shyster lawyers wearing black robes. Not political leaders. And definitely not the ACLU.
BDiddy
You are so very wrong. Spend about 6 months in law libraries and try to find cases that aren’t in law books, like the library, etc and therein you will find the truth.
My writing is disjointed when I write late at night but I still make sense if you get past the typos. WE’RE TALKIG 15 YEARS AGO.
These situations are happening every day, big mouth. And I take my medication every day. 🙂
To someone who wants to take my words and copy them elsewhere, to give them permission, you let them know it can be reproduced anywhere.
15 years ago, again assole, THERE WERE NO LIVING WILLS, DNR orders, so when the police got to the house they would automatically think it was house hold abuse when it was a woman who abused herself and more than 10 minutes passed without oxygen. Things have changed in 15 years and Michael Shiavo deserves empathy and respect.
But people like you always think you’re right. You have never been in a room with a brain dead individual and have had to make that awful decision. Terri was resuscitated by the paramedics (I used to be one myself) which is unfortunate and for 3 days, realizing what happened, her brain wave activity would have been accessed and the news given to her husband. And he had a hard decision to make. We would not be aware – and I’m totally sick of it – of Terri Shiavo if it weren’t for her parents and their blustering on television, going to court , etc etc etc because they can’t say goodbye. It’s time for them to move on, too.
Ptuey!
Cindy
SteveL-
You’re missing the point — you can always blame SOMEONE. In this case it’s clearly not Clinton, or liberals, or activist judges, so it must be the lawyers’ fault.
jayro
Is this the same legal system that is competent enough to make the decision that someone should be put to death as punishment for their crime? Are we to understand that in capital cases the defendant always has access to the kind of top notch legal help that would prevent any mistakes that might lead to a wrongful conviction and an innocent person being put to death?
Or do mistakes like this only happen in civil trials?
Posted by: SteveL at March 24, 2005 04:38 PM
You don’t understand the issues involved in this case. In fact, neither did the 11th Circuit or the SCOTUS. I’ll say it one more time for the hard-of-thinking: Terri’s parents want her alive. Terri has no document describing her wishes. Terri’s husband is a dick. Conclusion: Terri should live. For an explanation of why Terri’s husband is a dick, re-examine his actions and ask yourself if these are the actions of a loving husband. To want to murder someone’s daughter inhumanely against the parents wishes, makes him the biggest dick a woman could possibly marry. Of course, we’ll be hearing anytime now from the feminist groups…{crickets}…Well I guess not.
Cindy:
You are always telling us you are right and no one else knows anything. Which is hilarious in that there is at most a 50-50 chance your posts are even responsive to the topic.
You have never been in a room with a brain dead individual and have had to make that awful decision.
Oh, yeah? And your proof of that is?????? YOU are not the only person in the world that has had to make a difficult decision regarding a love one.
Posted by: firstbrokenangel at March 24, 2005 04:46 PM
You are one arrogant ignoramus, with the morals of an alley cat.
Rick Dement:
In no way was Schiavo afforded the procedural safeguards a capital defendant receives. If she did, they wouldn’t be killing her.
Terri Schiavo is going to die because Michael Schiavo has better lawyers.
Actually, Mike also has the LAW on his side…Ibut that’s not in the script Randall Terry prepared for you.
Funny Cindy
How it’s been MICHAEL that’s become Larry King’s co host as of late.
No “Living Wills” 15 years ago? The Quinlan case was over 30 years ago you twit and that one that dealt with withdrawl of LIFE SUPPORT (not things like FOOD and WATER) got people drawing up documents to clearly and unequivocally stating their wishes.
WE DO NOT KNOW what Terri’s wishes are. Certainly Michael’s conflict-of-interest indicate reasonable doubt about his testimony. In this regard the Law should have erred on the side of Life and let Terri’s family take care of her.
Brain-dead means no brain waves. NO ONE has argued that even from the “let’s kill terri” ghouls of Felos and Cranford.
Terri’s only crime was becoming braindamaged without a LIVING WILL and she’s being put to death for it.
DS and Cindy can go pound sand. Who the fuck are you to say when someone should die??? Who the hell appointed you master over life and death??? You wanna play God, then don’t be stupid, be smarty, go and join the neo-nazi party. They like to exterminate undesirables too. In fact, I suggest that someone that doesn’t respect life is an undesirable, like DS and Cindy. Time for each of you to be euthanized. (This is an object lesson for the deranged. It is not an endorsement of actions.)
Posted by: TruthTeller at March 24, 2005 04:43 PM
Pound sand, huh? You go by what the doctors say; it’s not playing God, either. The person is already dead – resuscitated by paramedics or the hospital, then assessed. If Terri had an organ donor card, this discussion would not be taking place. You know once they resuscitate a patient and then assess the situation, that’s when they learn the damage that has been done. If you’re dead, you’re dead and no reason to be on respirators, iv’s, eventual feeding tubes, catheterization. Back then, they weren’t taking chances. Florida is the worst state in our country regarding eutanasia. Three days after my father completely stroked out and was on total life support, I called the nurse on an early Monday morning around 2. She told me what I needed to know and she told me what they recommended. I called my father’s wife and asked her why my father was on life support when I knew that was not what he wanted. They got together with her that day and shut him off at 6 pm that night 4 days AFTER he was actually dead. She even said “He has a living will” – well, you need more than that – you need a DNR and I happen to have both. Cost me $50 through a lawyer.
So truth teller, you’re not a truth teller and you can go pound sand, assole.
Cindy
Is Michael Schiavo a scientologist?
Even though Felos was the more experienced of the two, I don’t think it’s fair to Campbell to say she lost an otherwise winnable case.
As to why Campbell only called two witnesses, was that because of Campbell’s inexperience, the Schindler’s limited funds, or because Campbell could only find two witnesses who would/could testify in support of the Schindlers? (I’m hypothecating: what’s the likelihood the Schindler’s – knowing they had a fight coming up – hadn’t called as many of Terri’s friends to see if those friends had anything to offer… only to come up dry?)
Maybe Campbell did blow it. Maybe she just had a bad case to argue…
Cindy:
How typically off topic. Schiavo was/is not on a respirator. Feed her like I’m sure you feed yourself and she will live.
p.s.: I can’t believe you were dumb enough to pay $50!
You’re all STUPID. Terri Shiavo is DEAD. All their doing now is putting her body to rest. It’s not that hard to understand and Michael Shiavo has been on TV many times before so his being on Larry King is not a big deal; it’s only a big deal because it’s the only NEWS ITEM on tv and on the web right now and THAT is pissing me off.
Cindy
Of course Michael Schiavo has better lawyers: he has access to almost unlimited funds. According to Courts to choose victor in battle over woman’s life (Oct 2003):
But the Florida case has been built on testimony from Michael Schiavo, his brother and sister-in-law that Terri Schiavo made casual statements to them that she would not want artificial life support in the event of a medical calamity.
Yet during a 1992 medical malpractice trial, Michael Schiavo did not bring up his wife’s end-of-life wishes and pledged to use the money he was seeking for Terri Schiavo’s care and rehabilitation.
Michael Schiavo won the suit. After costs, Terri Schiavo’s guardianship netted $700,000 and Michael Schiavo $300,000. Most of the $700,000 has been used for legal fees as Schiavo has pressed the case to fulfill what he says are his wife’s wishes. According to Felos, Michael Schiavo has not used any of his own $300,000 for legal costs.
As with many tragedies, the only winners are the lawyers. One set of figures I’ve seen show that the trust fund that was set up for Terri’s treatment and longterm care has paid more than $470,000 to lawyers — so far.
And I, too, find it interesting that the “husband” sues to get the maximum amount of money out of the doctors for her longterm care. And then, later, suddenly remembers that she didn’t want to be kept alive this way. I just can’t get the word “fraud” out of my head.
There are also unconfirmed reports that she has a repeatedly demonstrated a swallowing reflex, but she has not been given any swallowing therapy so that she could be fed without a feeding tube. She has apparently received no therapy at all.
For the record:
1. I have chosen not to be kept alive this way, and I have stated so in writing.
2. Too much misinformation is out their for me to render a valid opinion.
3. Neither the “husband” not the parents should make the call. The “husband” appears to have an agenda, and the parents are too emotionally involved.
Hey, cindy!
I’m still waiting to hear how you reconcile your wanting to kill Schiavo with Pope John Paul’s comments on the case? What? Cat got you tongue? Or, are you salivating about pulling the plug on him, too?
Julie
I NEVER SAID SHE WAS ON A RESPIRATOR – SHE WAS ONCE – SEE THE TRACH IN HER NECK???
dammit girl, get it straight.
C
Jaysus on a Pony, Don, is this what animates the “pull the tube” crowd? You’ve set your own litmus test that “let Terri live” = “extemist anti-abortion”
I’m PRO CHOICE (not pro-abortion) and I’m opposed to Terri being ACTIVELY KILLED when she was not terminal, not dying, not in pain and left no written expressed wishes.
What is it about Terri’s parents wanting to care for their daughter that is so F**king harmful to YOU?
The Pope is also a sad situation and totally different – he’s not brain dead.
Smarten up girl and don’t address me again.
C
You’re all STUPID.
Yes, cindy, we know. Because as you are repeatedly telling everyone, only you are smart enough to comment on the subject. Hail, cindy!
it’s only a big deal because it’s the only NEWS ITEM on tv and on the web right now and THAT is pissing me off.
So, is the problem that:
1. it’s messing with your television viewing pleasure?
2. or, is it that you aren’t getting enough attention?
Cindy
Thank god you’re no longer a paramedic. You don’t seem to know what the medical criteria for DEATH is.
Good lord, Cindy has reading comprehension problems too
But it sure was a Freudian slip..looks like she’s waiting around for someone to start hiding the Pope’s 3 squares and water, too.
I NEVER SAID SHE WAS ON A RESPIRATOR – SHE WAS ONCE – SEE THE TRACH IN HER NECK???
dammit girl, get it straight.
C
You’re the one that analogized it to you father being on a respirator, not me. So, you get it straight, oh demented one.
The Pope is also a sad situation and totally different – he’s not brain dead.
How do you reconcile your opinion with the Pope’s? Are you avoiding answering the question because you know you can’t? Yeah, I think so.
Smarten up girl and don’t address me again.
You telling anyone else to smarten up! lol! And don’t hold your breath, I’ll address you any time and every time I have a free moment. Now answer the question please. Doesn’t this make you a bad catholic?
Posted by: firstbrokenangel at March 24, 2005 05:06 PM
Your ignorance is boundless.
Good lord, Cindy has reading comprehension problems too
You are only now noticing? lol!
But it sure was a Freudian slip..looks like she’s waiting around for someone to start hiding the Pope’s 3 squares and water, too.
lol! Yeah, cindy, you willing to starve the Pope, too?
I think Cindy has been hitting the bottle or something, because her reading comprehension and knowledge of the differences between brain death and brain damaged is way off.
“Maybe Campbell did blow it.”
I think she probably did in at least one respect, she failed to depose Michael’s brother and sister in law before the actual trial.
I’ve always said that the left-wingers were a bunch of brain-dead jerks with metal plates in their heads. Does that mean we can start starving them to death?
RE: TruthTeller’s post (March 24, 2005 04:50 PM)
You [SteveL] don’t understand the issues involved in this case. In fact, neither did the 11th Circuit or the SCOTUS…
Do you really believe this?
Cindy
Why are you bothering? You are trying to force the myopic to see past their noses. Give up and enjoy your peace.
TruthTeller
You are one hell of a moral example, aren’t you? Someone disagrees with you and you resort to name calling and foul language. Thankfully we don’t have moral police, and you are not one of them. You morals look to be lacking at this point.
Catchy moniker by the way, to bad you aren’t a truth viewer.
Have a great day. I am, watching the meltdown. . . .
Why are you saying that what happen to Terrie could never happened to an innocent person accused of a capital crime? Are you unaware that DNA testing has proven that a number of people put to death could not have committed the crimes of which they were accused? If you were shown this evidence would you be for or against capital punishment?
You know, Jim, I was wondering how much of a “slip of the tongue” it was the other day when Howie Dean the Scream called Republicans “brain dead.”