Terri Schiavo is going to die because Michael Schiavo has better lawyers.
Exhibit #1) This article in the St. Petersburg Times (Memories diverge on what Terri wanted), explains it all.
On the Monday in January 2000 when the Schiavo case went to trial, the Schindlers’ lawyer remembers being surprised to see a St. Petersburg Times reporter in court.
What are you doing here, Patricia Campbell asked. She had no anticipation that the case would make the front page.
Back then, Campbell was working alone, without an assistant to help. On the other side was Michael Schiavo’s lawyer, George Felos, who had handled the seminal right-to-die case of Estelle Browning, which went to the Florida Supreme Court in 1990.
Campbell said in an interview Wednesday that she took the case out of sympathy for the Schindlers. She said about 20 attorneys had turned down the couple, who had little money.
Campbell, who now has a prestigious AV rating from the Martindale-Hubbell lawyer peer review system, had never handled a right-to-die case. She did not have money to find witnesses, she said. Indeed, Campbell did not take depositions from Joan and Scott Schiavo before the trial. Normally, that would be a basic step for a lawyer preparing for trial.
Campbell presented just two witnesses to address the claim that Terri would not want her feeding tube removed.
[More]Exhibit #2) This morning Florida’s Department of Children and Families missed an opportunity to legally take custody of Terri Schiavo. WFTS reports:
Wednesday afternoon, Pinellas Circuit Judge George Greer issued a temporary restraining order, preventing DCF from removing Terri from the Pinellas Park hospice where her life-sustaining feeding tube has been disconnected.
This morning at 8, DCF filed an appeal to Greer’s order. When they did so, an automatic stay of the order went into effect, meaning that they could intervene.
The attorney for Terri’s husband Michael (George Felos), who opposes any attempts to prolong Terri’s life, said he suspected DCF wasn’t aware of that stay until he had filed a motion for a new restraining order.Legally Terri’s family was never able to recover from that one day in court 5 years ago. Felos was just rubbing salt in the wound this morning as he continued his legal dominance…



I propose “National Spit-On-A-Lawyer Day,” to be celebrated annually on the anniversary of Terri Schiavo’s impending death by starvation.
I like the name, but I think “spit” is a typo.
Cats have morals?
I’d echo the sentiment that Terri died from a heart attack brought on by bulimia, not because of litigation. The “Terri” everyone knew prior to 1990 hasn’t existed for 15 years, nor will she ever.
Rick
I know of people who have been cleared of crimes using DNA, and some who’s original convictions have been affirmed by such testing.
Now, wouldn’t you argue that a person convicted 15 years ago should have the chance to test evidence with technology available only 5 years ago?
So why has Terri never had a MRI or PET? Or her last swallow tests were in 1993? Why is she not being afforded the same retesting that a capital crime defendant gets?
BTW as an aside, can you cite me a source for showing an executed defendant being cleared AFTERWARDS by DNA?
DavidB
Well, maybe you can answer me this simple question.
Why is the prospect of Terri living with her parents such a threat to some people?
Gabriel
Your premise is true for lots of Alzheimer patients, too.
Do we get to starve them to death, too, just because of “diminished” personhood?
Jim wrote:
No one said for the MSM to “barge in.” A news pool cameraman could be escorted into Terri’s room.
You said “demand”, not “request an escort”. No one has the right to “demand” access to anything, and this surely has nothing at all to do with the First Amendment.
once our courts and government take actions against a person which would result in death, then it is the people’s right to know everything.
The courts are taking actions for Terri, not against her.
Or do you favor people being held by the government without access to anyone?
Not at all. Fortunately, that’s not happening here. (I’d be interested in your views of the detainees at Gitmo, but that’s another thread.)
One other thing: the law and the US Constitution belongs to us — the citizens of the United States. Not to a bunch of shyster lawyers wearing black robes. Not political leaders.
I agree completely. Fortunately, the there are judges to prevent political leaders from hijacking or circumventing the laws and the Constitution.
BoDiddly wrote:
2. To which poll are you referring that states that 10:1 ratio of disapproval and the stance of the evangelical community?
I don’t know if this is the one DS was referring to, but the Fox News poll shows that 2% of people think the government should make the decision. Of course, that’s 49:1, not 10:1. In a new CBS poll, 82% say Congress and Bush should “stay out of” the Schiavo situation.
And this poll discusses the stance of the evangelical community:
And evangelical Protestants divide about evenly – 46 percent are in favor of removing the tube, 44 percent opposed. Among non-evangelical Protestants, 77 percent are in favor – a huge division between evangelical and mainline Protestants…. Regardless of their preference on the Schiavo case, about two-thirds of conservatives and evangelicals alike call congressional intervention inappropriate.
Finally, for those who have challenged the polls’ use of the term “life support”, the latest ones ask about removal of her “feeding tube”.
Well, maybe you can answer me this simple question. Why is the prospect of Terri living with her parents such a threat to some people?
It’s not a threat to anyone. It’s just not what Terri wanted, and the courts are protecting her right to not have her parents impose their will on her.
Darleen
Simple question and an even more simple answer. It is none of our business. The more complex answer you would not want to hear. I leave it at that.
This Just In!
DR. BILL HAMMESFAHR
Throughly discredited on local radio talk show. The good doctor, enjoying his new found celebrity, granted a phone interview to a local radio talk show, the John & Ken show on 640AM in LA.
The good doctor was asked about his Nobel nomination and who nominated him back in 98 or 99. He had a little trouble recalling and when the show hosts reminded him that it was a Florida state representative, he confirmed it.
Then when the show hosts pointed out that the only people who can nominate someone for a Nobel Prize are past winners and a select few others, which do not include Florida state representatives, he quickly ended the interview before more damning questions could be asked.
Questions like, what about that $3K billing error for services you never rendered and ending up costing you a fine of over $50K.
Chuckle. . .this guy has no credibiilty issues . . . right?
http://www.johnandkenshow.com/
You may notice that these guys are hardly liberal. . .
No John and Ken are not liberal nore conservative, they are a-political for the most part.
That said, Dr. Hammesfahr has been totaly discredited long before his recent spat of TV appearences. Sadly, this hasn’t stopped the conservative entertainment community from pushing him as some major expert in this case when he is just a money grubbing publicity whore.
About the Doctor…
The Dr for Michael Shiavo the “PVS” expert is also pretty suspect. I can’t remember his name. He has lost as many cases as he has won. He tried to say a guy who could get around by himself in a wheelchair was in PVS.
He is a one trick pony who can find PVS in anyone. This does not mean Terri isn’t in one. But I just thought you should know before you gloat too much.
Do we get to starve them to death, too, just because of “diminished” personhood?
You bet they do it if they are allowed to or not. FIRST HAND EXPERIENCE NOT THEROY GANG
Why are you saying that what happen to Terrie could never happened to an innocent person accused of a capital crime?
Read what I said again: In no way was Schiavo afforded the procedural safeguards a capital defendant receives.
You don’t have a clue what is involved in representing a capital case. Why you would even try to compare the two only goes to show that you don’t know what the hell you are talking about. Jeesh! What next are you going to lecture on? Neurosurgery?
I agree with that conclusion of yours, Kevin, that Terri Schiavo’s life is being concluded because Michael Schiavo had better legal helps, and after hearing today’s statements on the news, seems that the ACLU and others made sure of that.
It’s great that Michael Schiavo has been so well represented. And that the ACLU has been able to financially enable him to do so, among others. It’s a tragedy that Terri Schiavo’s life was not considered and that what Michael Schiavo desired was more important than the life of Terri Schiavo.
After listening to many legal and even some medical sources today make various statements, many of the physicians have made statements that contradict one another, even as to what they consider qualified evaluations and how and what they do not, and that various illustrious instructors in law schools can denounce “emotionally charged words such as ‘murder'” while denying to describe what inducing Terri Schiavo to die actually is (what’s the word, I’m interested to know what they’d call it since she isn’t killing herself and isn’t being put to death by society as punishment, although that last part I am today wondering about)…it’s quite possible that many academics just cannot face the facts here and that they find more comfort in distance from the hardcore reality that a person is losing her life and has suffered greatly simply because someone of dubious character thinks that she should.
Amazing how “should” has now become a legal term, a medical diagnosis.
Terri Schiavo can anticipate a wonderful eternity in Heaven. God’s plan for all this…I anticipate good coming from this evil.
Another thing, a bit off topic to Kevin’s issue here but not completely, is that the neurologist who has posed other ideas about Terri Schiavo’s medical condition/diagnosis has also been denigrated and even suggested to be disqualified by others involved here (Felos and the ACLU and a another doctor, I believe I heard expressing this earlier today) because he’s “a Christian” and “associated with the right-to-life movement” — not because of his medical qualifications.
I was wondering if we as a country are now supposed to disqualify, say, Jewish physicians becuase some of them are Orthodox, for starters.
The very idea that this respected and respectably qualified neurologist can be suggested to not be allowed to be involved as to his professional opinion about Terri Schiavo’s diagnosis (he’s suggesting that further tests can establish just what her diagnosis actually is and that that hasn’t yet happened and that there’s, in his opinion, cause to suggest that Terri’s diagnosis is inaccurate to-date), the very idea that he’s supposedly to be disqualified “because he’s a Christian” is mindblowing in statement.
I read here that ~DS~ is still committed to irrationality, as in describing Terri Schiavo as having already “died.”
Unfortunately, rhetoric such as that — nonsense in the fullest dimension of that concept — has been motivational.
Dr. Hammesfahr has been totaly discredited long before his recent spat of TV appearences.
How has he been discredited?
many of the physicians have made statements that contradict one another, even as to what they consider qualified evaluations and how and what they do not, and not . . .
Every fact used to increase a sentence, including one that imposes death, must be found by a jury beyond a reasonable doubt. ( 6th Amend, 14th Amend. Blakely, Apprendi, Ring, Booker.) There’s a procedural safegurard Schiavo was never afforded.
Every defendant, not just one facing death, is entitled to an attorney. (6th Amend.)
Joser! Dude! Smokin’ that sh*t will rot your brain and now you know what THAT will get you… no more 3 squares and water.
Brian: since Terri Schiavo left no recording of what she did want, you have no idea what she wanted or wants now.
Michael Schiavo is the only person who seems to think he knows what Terri wanted (I write, ‘wanted’ because according to Michael Schiavo, Terri Schiavo is “dead” already, suspect statement in and of itself, not to mention much other that he’s said).
Without a recording for everyone to refer to about what Terri Schiavo wants, we have to err on the side of life. Listening to the ACLU and many strangely odd persons fascinated with someone dying although they’re already ‘dead’ (it’s a mystery to me how the illogic has flowed in that area), the process of concluding her life seems paramount to determing what Terri wants.
There hasn’t been much exploration about that other than what Michael Schiavo and his siblings have to say about that, but to many of us, it’s an unreliable social and psychological environment in and of itself. I’ve heard many, many people express this very thing lately.
It’s not about what Michael Schiavo wants but what Terri Schiavo wants. Her parents and family want to care for her, so let them. The only downside to that is that those gloating over her death won’t have her death to gloat over, in my view, because there’s no explanation otherwise.
Emotionally reasoning here…
Susan
It’s “Dr.” Ronald Cranford.
-S- No, Michael is NOT the only one. Both his brother and sister in law gave similar testimony. Michael’s sister Joan was a “close friend” of Terri’s and she said they talked about the topic as many as 12 times.
At least get your facts right.
Terri Schiavo is going to die not because Michael Schiavo has better lawyers, but because he has better legal position.
PERIOD
funny how no one in Terri’s family ever heard her say “If I’m brain damaged, kill me.” Ever. Just Michael’s family.
No written instruction, then default to life.
I apologize Bo, I just saw your comment. You asked:
1. What exactly is a “Neo-Christian?”
A Neo-Christian is a member of the extremist religous right. They’re identified by the tendancy to claim worship of Jesus while rejecting his liberal teachings to attend the sick and poor, smearing and ridiculing those who do observe those tenets, and supoprt instead a political ideology which rewards the rich and powerful. Neo-Christians tend to politically support Neo-cons.
2. To which poll are you referring that states that 10:1 ratio of disapproval and the stance of the evangelical community?
I said ten to one, and albiet narrowly by evangelicals. “More than two-thirds of people who describe themselves as evangelicals and conservatives disapprove of the intervention by Congress and President Bush in the case of the Terri Schiavo, the brain-damaged woman at the center of a national debate.” ABC News source: http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory?id=609577 . CBS News SHOULD CONGRESS AND THE PRESIDENT BE INVOLVED IN SCHIAVO MATTER? Yes 13% No 82% source: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/03/23/opinion/polls/main682674.shtml
3. Do you really expect to be taken seriously tossing out the “American Taliban” line?
LOL! Yes, apologizing for torture (This is especially puzzling considering that Christ was tortured to death, you’d think even the Neo-Christians would be sensistive on this) defending the President’s ‘right’ to whisk anyone off with no trial, due process, or even informing the family, to Syrian or Egyption or Saudi torture chambers, and basically swallowing any line the Neo-cons put out, apologizing for lies and misinformation, ethical lapses that would make Clinton blush (BTW, I’ve been a republican all my life, but this gang is despicable and shameful) and hiding behind a facade of religious justification, using as one’s initial premise that factual data which contradicts a narrow intepretation as ascertained by violent fundamentalists fanatics, many of whom are happily predicting the end of the world any day now, is about as close to the Taliban as this nation has been in a century. Christ you see, was a raging liberal, and mandated that his followers act likewise to honor him and achieve grace. The perverted, violent, fanatical version of Christianity practiced now by the religious right and often brilliantly manipulated by the Neocons, is thus called Neo– Christianity, so as not to be confused with the original and traditional peace loving followers of Jesus Christ.
Terri Schiavo is going to die because that’s what she wanted.
The rights of individuals to assert authority over their own life and death decisions is a victory for all Americans.
If Michael Schiavo is the proximate cause of Terri’s condition, why has the State of Florida not commenced a criminal action against him? Even at this late date, if he were charged with a crime against Terri she’d be a material witness and the feeding tube would be reinserted to preserve her value as a material witness. The fact that no such charge has been filed by a Governor who has publicly spoken of his willingness to kick down the door to her room and take her forcibly into State custody tells me that no such cause of action exists.
IOW, those who believe Michael Schiavo to be the cause of Terri’s condition are suffering from a severe case of recto-cranial inversion.
Fuck all you gouls just gloating over the imminent death of a helpless human being. All of you would be the first to shove a Jew in the oven. I do hope you have to go through this same decision in your life. It would be a good object lesson.
From Peggy Noonan:
…..Everyone who has written in defense of Mrs. Schiavo’s right to live has received e-mail blasts full of attacks that appear to have been dictated by the unstable and typed by the unhinged. On Democratic Underground they crowed about having “kicked the sh– out of the fascists.” On Tuesday James Carville’s face was swept with a sneer so convulsive you could see his gums as he damned the Republicans trying to help Mrs. Schiavo. It would have seemed demonic if he weren’t a buffoon. …..
…..Terri Schiavo may well die. No good will come of it. Those who are half in love with death will only become more red-fanged and ravenous.
And those who are still learning–our children–oh, what terrible lessons they’re learning. What terrible stories are shaping them. They’re witnessing the Schiavo drama on television and hearing it on radio. They are seeing a society–their society, their people–on the verge of famously accepting, even embracing, the idea that a damaged life is a throwaway life.
Our children have been reared in the age of abortion, and are coming of age in a time when seemingly respectable people are enthusiastic for euthanasia. It cannot be good for our children, and the world they will make, that they are given this new lesson that human life is not precious, not touched by the divine, not of infinite value.
Once you “know” that–that human life is not so special after all–then everything is possible, and none of it is good. When a society comes to believe that human life is not inherently worth living, it is a slippery slope to the gas chamber. You wind up on a low road that twists past Columbine and leads toward Auschwitz. Today that road runs through Pinellas Park, Fla.
Sadly Turthteller the Neocons don’t seem to hold life in the high regard you yourself do. The same folks who are grandstanding over Terry Schiavo’s tragedy are the same cats who cut medicaid, and who limited medical practice awards, both of which Schiavo, and anyone else in her shoes, are critically dependant on. They’re the same folks who apologise for torture, collateral damage in warfare, and the death penalty, and who enacted the Texas Futile Care Law. Apparently, some lives are more equal than others …
Sadly ~DS~ I am a neocon. So that busts your theory. Furthermore, this is not a neocon issue, thank you, but a moral one. Too bad you don’t get that.
It also forces you to choose between your faith, assuming you have faith, I don’t know you personally, and your ideology. You can either be a Neocon, or a follower of Jesus Christ. Too bad you don’t get that, and it’s sad you feel the need to resort to insults. Let’s consider faith based morality in general among social conservatives …
The question isn’t whether or not you believe your personal mythology TT. I have no doubt the commentators here and many others do sincerely believe their mythology is ‘the one true mythology’, and all others are false; just as of course all those ones you consider false have adherents who claim the same about your own cosmogony. I have no desire to disabuse you or they of that belief whatsoever. I’d stand shoulder to shoulder with you defending your Constitutional Right to worship whatever flavor of magic invisible sky wizard you happen to admire. I’d be highly uncomfortable in a culture in which such a belief was illegal or in anyway restricted; but all this is predicted on the condition that you and your fellow cultists don’t hurt anyone or force others to pay lip service to your shamans and holy men with the threat of imprisonment or violence. As long as you leave the rest of us alone, more power to you if you find peace in this manner. Yes, I understand it provides folks great comfort in horrid circumstances in which the emotional or physical pain is often unbearable. Furthermore, the core values of Christianity as taught by Jesus Christ are indeed highly admirable practices imo; to wit, care for the sick, the poor, the handicapped, the disadvantage and disenfranchised. The world would be a much better place if folks observed those tenets.
The question is, why should I believe your claims about the actual deities themselves? If you make an extraordinary claim, I expect extraordinary evidence. As would you yourself if the tables were reversed. If I told you I have an invisible fire breathing dragon in my garage who predicts the future and who saves the souls of dead people to live in his Mighty Spines in Paradise, you probably wouldn’t just take my word on it and convert to Dragonism, eh?
If you claim there is some sort of mystical realm where dead people dwell in happiness or in pain, you’re going to need to produce these folks for never-ending, lengthy, detailed interviews. If you claim that your deity can predict the future, then I’ll expect detailed predictions concerning the future from you available on request for as long as I’m willing to ask. For example, ask your deity the next major airline disaster in which there will be over 100 dead, flight number, time and date, airline, and exact mechanical or other malfunction which precipitates the accident, and I’ll be willing to give you further tests to see if that wasn’t a fluke. After many such successful tests, I’d be willing to consider you may be onto to something. But Bo, no excuses as to why you can’t perform that will even be considered. Either back up your extraordinary claims with extraordinary evidence, or don’t be shocked if I don’t take your word for it.
The question, is why should I believe your extraordinary claims over those of my Hindu pizza delivery boy, or my Islamic mechanic, or anyone one else? The only standard of evidence I’ll accept is evidence, not excuses for why your magic sky king exactly imitates one which does not exist in the first place. In this case, why should I believe you that fertilized human blastocytes, or victims of brain injury lacking a cerebral cortex, are under the protection of an invisible fairy who will become angry if we interfere? Why should I believe there is a supernatural structure you call a soul which is imbued into an embryo at conception and which embodies some kind of eternal life, if you can neither define, or produce, this mythical entity? Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Capiche?
The problem with organizations such as the Taliban, or the Neo-Christian Right, or Shi’a Clerics in Iran, or David Koresh or Jim Jones; is they don’t leave others alone. They hope to enforce their beliefs with the threat of prison, fine, or violence. They’re also wide open to political manipulation by outside unscrupulous individuals in positions of power, whose religious claims oddly always seem to coincide with their personal wealth and power interests, what a coininkidink huh Bo? If for example the same followers of Christian mythology found themselves outvoted in a small town by Hindu’s, who believe that animals hold the reincarnated souls of human beings, and who made eating meat a capital offense equavelent to murder, they’d be singing a different tune and go flippin ballastic, and rightly so imo.
Forcing others to observe your personal religious Fatwas is not just morally abhorrent and utterly unacceptable, it’s 180 degrees against the core values of America as delineated in several key Amendments in our most cherished legal document. That’s why we oppose it globally Bo; It stinks, it’s sick, it’s primitive, it’s indefensible. It’s frankly un-American and anyone who advocates it is frankly selling out those patriotic Americans who value that hard won freedom, who defended it, who uphold it in other parts of the world at great personal risk, and for which millions in this nation have sacrificed their limbs and given their very lives.
And, if you are going to shit all over the rest of us and ignore the Consititution of the United States by enforcing those practices from the barrel of a gun, at least be true to them. Jesus spoke over 1000 verse in the New Testament mandating care for the sick and weak and poor and even the criminal. Yet the Neo-Christian Right ignores that in favor of bashing gays-which I don’t believe Jesus once mentioned BTW-and happily hops on the bandwagon of cutting taxes and programs to help those very people Jesus was telling them to help. It is a perversion of that faith, one most foul, and I’d have to guess Jesus wouldn’t be thrilled with it, although being the Messiah I’m sure he would forgive them: I however being a mere mortal, will not.
Incidentally TruthTeller, I’m a staunch Republican, or at least I was before the party was hijacked by religious fanatics. One thing to be concerned about is how badly this thing is bellyflopping across the nation. Even the evangelical Majority disagrees with Congress stepping in. And the damage done to the unity of the GOP is reaches farther than anything the democrats could have possibly hoped for. The party is splitting over this, and the Neocons, a platfoem which I doubt you can even define much less discuss with precision, are terribly worried that the pandering might be backfiring.
RE: TruthTeller’s post (March 24, 2005 09:30 PM)
This:
PN – …it is a slippery slope to the gas chamber. You wind up on a low road that twists past Columbine and leads toward Auschwitz. Today that road runs through Pinellas Park, Fla.
begat this:
TT – Fuck all you gouls just gloating over the imminent death of a helpless human being. All of you would be the first to shove a Jew in the oven. I do hope you have to go through this same decision in your life. It would be a good object lesson.
WOW! I think I’ve witnessed my first imposition of Godwin by proxy… and courtesy none other than our esteemed P. Noonan. Can this be right? Impressive.
Sherard…I KNOW that Michael Schiavo’s siblings believe that they know what they know. I’ve acknowledged that fact so many times on Wizbang as it is to be beyond tiresome to continue to read that very wan retort as if it justifies killing Terri Schiavo because Michael and his domain demand that she die.
There is evidence to suggest that Michael Schiavo was abusive (and certainly still is in mammoth proportions) Terri Schiavo. He certainly is a controlling personality and whatever was said or was not said, bringing his siblings into the mix here as “evidence” of what Terri Schiavo “said” suggests, also, that these are not acceptable sources. Meaning, they are persons quite obviously with special interests in the situation and not reliable as nonpartisan sources, if not persons who could be, also, anticipated to be manipulated by Michael Schiavo.
All things considered, Michael Schiavo and his peers do not a sound source of fact make. To a whole lot of people including myself, based upon the behavior by Michael Schiavo and not based upon random offensiveness (although he is certainly an offensive person from what I’ve seen and heard him express).
Michael Schiavo also has even been recorded as initially maintaining that he did not know what Terri wanted, as to her wishes if ever disabled, and it was years afterward, and only then when he was awarded substantial funds for Terri Schiavo’s rehabilitation, that Michael Schiavo suddenly popped up with his current insistence, that of “knowing” that Terri Schiavo “was dead already” and “would not want to live like this” (both statements defy reason, much less combined in one message which has been Michael Schiavo’s craziness, among other things, ever since).
On the other hand, there are people who are Terri Schiavo’s closest friends who DID know that Terri expressed to them that (1.) she was not happy in the last year or so prior to her disability in her relationship and marriage to Michael Schiavo and that (2.) she did not find Michael Schiavo trustworthy and shared concerns and doubts and even expressed a possible divorce to one friend and (3.) several friends of Terri Schiavo supported that and that is that Terri spoke about the idea of ending someone’s life based upon profound disability to be unacceptable and concerning to her within a religious and ethical perspective and that (4.) medical professionals who had contact with Terri Schiavo prior to her disability spoke out about Terri having made similar statements abot finding euthanasia and deprivation of food/water for severely disabled persons to be unacceptable…
All things considered, you have Michael Schiavo saying what he says, his (what is it, two?) siblings agreeing with him, and then you have a larger number of uninterested persons (non related but persons who had close relationships with Terri and one who still maintains that she is Terri’s best friend and has been), some with professional qualifications (so they’re far more reliable as source than Michael Schiavo’s siblings), who all agreed that they knew that Terri Schiavo would not find it “right” to end her life under current circumstances (or anyone else’s) but whose testimony has been disallowed from previous legal procedings, without much explanation (many people have shared that they felt ‘silenced’ or thereabouts and can’t understand why their experiences with Terri would not be taken into consideration).
So, if you’re focused on numbers, the numbers are in the corner on Terri’s behalf that she would not want her life to be ended by current process, etc.
And, you have Michael Schiavo who first made it pretty clear to many that he didn’t know what Terri would want, then he received the rehabilitatiion funds (which he did not spend on rehabilitation for Terri but for his own legal fees to deny her rehabilitation, among other things), then he decided that he did know what she wanted but that she was “dead already” and “would not want to live” and that she should “die” (she’s already dead, then she wouldn’t want to live, then she had to die…the babbling of a crazy person)…
It’s nonsensical that no one with anything counter to Michael Schiavo’s demands has been considered. He’s been represented but Terri has not been. Mr. illustrious law school instructor from Harvard Law School earlier today said that he regarded the word, “murder” in relatinship to Terri Schiavo as being “emotionally charged and baseless” but what else is it that’s taking place? That has been taking place? What else IS it?
Terri Schiavo is alive. If she was “dead already” she’d have putrified by now. She hasn’t. She’s severely disabled, yes, but she isn’t dead. But Michael Schiavo insisting that she has to die (although she’s “already dead”) is murder. If not murder, then what is it? It’s not euthanasia. It’s not suicide. It’s not an accident. So, what is it?
`DS~:
Incidentally TruthTeller, I’m a staunch Republican, or at least I was before the party was hijacked by religious fanatics.
In other words, you’re a dumocrat. Go ahead, you can say it.
You can bitch about the religious fanatics hijacking the party but take a look at yourself. You seem perfectly comfortable shitting all over everyone else’s religious beliefs. You’re hatred is fanaticism. You are unable to stop yourself from spewing all over the place. And you dare call others fanatics? What a creep you are.
And talk about shoving beliefs down other peoples throats – do you think anyone in their right mind is going to read the shit diatribe you posted? You go on and on with this stupid anti-religious crap of yours. What a whacko! You are everything you pretend to rail against.
Truthteller sums up exactly what is bothering me so mightily about this case. The religious right and the extremism are making me sick. I’m a republican who’s opinion sides more with Michael Schiavo, and I’m being told I’m gloating over the imminent death of a woman, that I endorse a culture of death, that I’m happily skipping down the road to eugenics blah blah blah. Well, fuck you! Because that’s the farthest thing from my mind and heart. Some of us can side with the husband and think removing the tube is the right thing and STILL be saddened by her impending death. Too many people seem to think that the only acceptable end of this is to have Terri’s “life” sustained. Well some of us think that the main thing is to get the legalities straightened out in such a way that a family matter doesn’t become a matter for govt meddling. You don’t give a damn about laws or the family or anything else in the advancement of your agenda. You don’t give a damn about Terri Schiavo. She’s just some pawn, some symbol to make a political or religious or social statement.
All you’re doing is proving the point the moonbats make about “Jesusland” and the religious wing of the GOP. And pissing off GOP voters who don’t want any truck with the religious right. And you better damn well remember that you need us to win elections.
carla: since Terri Schiavo left no record of what her wishes would be under such circumstances, there’s no way to determine what her wishes are and all the rest is heresay. If it’s heresay that her friends’ and medical professionals’ testimony said that Terri wouldn’t find the current circumstances acceptable (read previous), then it’s heresay that Michael Schiavo and his siblings could revise their story a few years after Terri’s disability and say that she wouldn’t want to live, that she was “already dead” and the like.
No one KNOWS what Terri’s wishes are so society has to act on her behalf and extend basic considerations that go beyond what we do for convicted felons and animals. The least any of us could do is provide competent screening for accurate diagnosis for the woman and to maintain her as comfortable as possible among persons who love and enjoy her presence, however limited (her family). Let her pass away but by natural means and not by inducement, deprivation, by the hand of someone else.
Since she left no written directive, there is no way to determine what her wishes are, and thus, Terri Schiavo merits care from society. The day the option is to kill first based upon disability, that’s the day that we no longer are a society but madmen.
Hey Shark!
1. If the shoe fits. . .
2. And I’m not religious.
3. Oh, and fuck you back double.
dying with dignity Please read before reaming me a new one
RE: shark’s post (March 24, 2005 10:27 PM)
…I’m being told I’m gloating over the imminent death of a woman, that I endorse a culture of death, that I’m happily skipping down the road to eugenics blah blah blah…
Water off a duck’s back, shark. Person’s advancing such hostile rhetoric, whether from a respectable columnist who uses flowery prose to disguise the disdain or the impolitely dogmatic using colorful retort, are unworthy of considered response. Rest your hands and engage with those of sincere concern.
Exactly Shark. I remember warning some buddies about the relrioug right and them saying “Oh we’re just sucking up to them to get their votes, no one takes that crazy shit seriously”.
If someone busted into Terri’s room and removed the feeding tube without a court order, that would be attempted murder. However, because a court judge ordered the removal its perfectly legal. The only question about this case is what is Terri’s wish. We don’t know. Her husband is a dick. Her parents love her. All that matters is the morality of murdering a human being that is not on life support. We don’t do that in this country. All of you that still whine about “right-wing religious fanatics” should know something about me: I’m not a Christian and I don’t know if a God exists, BUT that doesn’t make one less moral. Shark and ~DS~ are ignorant when it comes to morality. Morality is a universal code (possibly from God). If you are a secularist, you have situational ethics. Morality, by definition, does not change at the whims of man. However a secularist will change and that leads to moral relativism. Morality says to value the sick, the infirmed, the disabled as much as the healthy. That is why human life has an INHERENT value. That is why murdering Terri is wrong.
Well about a dozen courts have heard evidence you’ve not heard TT and they disagree with you about her husband.
This is truly a lose-lose scenario. No one will win here. There is plenty of room for reasonable poeple to come to different conclusions on her status, and I did state from the get go that I don’t care if she remains on life support or not. I intereviewed one of the radiologists in Florida who read the original CAT Scans, an evangelical Christian BTW, and who did some extensive followup case work on Schiavo, and I accept the preponderance of evidence presented by that individual and which several courts now concur, under a variety of judges from democratic to highly conservative; that she is not going to improve, that she is unaware and unable to cognate (Incidentally, her husband took seven years to give up and accept the consensus diagnosis according to several independant sources, and although I have been unable to confirm the following, there are reports that the women he now lives with was introduced to him by the Schindlers, who at that time were counseling him to get on with his life)
But if she is dead, leaving her hooked up, or taking her off, doesn’t matter to her. She’s gone. You could string her up with puppeteer wires and dance her across the nation, something Delay has metaphorically already done, and she wouldn’t be hurt in the slightest. So, if the parents want to take care of her body, I’d be inclined to allow them, if it were my decision. And even though I think she’s not feeling anything whatsoever, something in me finds the idea of starving her or dehydrating her to death quite reppellant. I’d suggest a big syringe full of morphine for her myself, were it my call on how to stop her heart. I surely don’t hold the actions of her parents against them, I can’t imagine how horrifying this drawn out tragedy must be to endure. I once watched my fiancee die of leukemia, it took six months. I can’t imagine 15 years. They’re probably half crazy by now.
A Defense of Genocide
Obviously, wherever Singer’s ideas are accepted as the basis for policy, it becomes a vitally important thing to be seen as a person. Infants, for example, are seen as non-persons. According to Singer they may therefore be killed with far less justification than would be required if they were understood to be persons. Certain adults to whom labels such as “persistent vegetative state” (PVS), “profound mental retardation” and “dementia” are attached may also be killed with less justification, according to Singer.
~DS~
Stands for dumb shit, right?
No, a dozen courts have not heard the evidence. There was one, let me repeat, ONE, trier of fact. And that was Greer. All other courts deferred to Greer’s factual findings. This was not the purpose of the Congressional bill. She was never adequately represented, you ghoul.
Someone on another page got very ticked off that I mentioned eugenics. Too bad, Eugenics led to euthanasia.
The Eugenics Movement in the U.S.
Many people are unaware that Hitler’s extermination policies began with the large-scale elimination of people with disabilities. Proponents of physician- assisted suicide are offended when allusions are made to this piece of disability history in the course of debate over the so-called “right to die”. The fact is that Hitler stole most of his ideas on eugenics from publications originating in the USA.
In 1906, W.J. McGee, Director of the St. Louis Public museum, published one of the most detailed and graphic descriptions of the ravages of extreme dehydration ever recorded. McGee’s account was based on the experiences of Pablo Valencia, a forty-year-old sailor-turned-prospector, who survived almost seven days in the Arizona desert without water….
Saliva becomes thick and foul-tasting; the tongue clings irritatingly to the teeth and the roof of the mouth …. A lump seems to form in the throat … severe pain is felt in the head and neck. The face feels full due to the shrinking of the skin. Hearing is affected, and many people begin to hallucinate… [then come] the agonies of a mouth that has ceased to generate saliva. The tongue hardens into what McGee describes as “a senseless weight, swinging on the still-soft root and striking foreignly against the teeth.” Speech becomes impossible, although sufferers have been known to moan and bellow.
Next is the “blood sweats” phase, involving “a progressive mummification of the initially living body.” The tongue swells to such proportions that it squeezes past the jaws. The eyelids crack and the eyeballs begin to weep tears of blood. The throat is so swollen that breathing becomes difficult, creating an incongruous yet terrifying
sense of drowning.
Finally … there is living death, the state into which Pablo Valencia had entered when McGee discovered him on a desert trail, crawling on his hands and knees: “His lips had disappeared as if amputated, leaving low edges of blackened tissue; his teeth and gums projected like those of a skinned animal, but the flesh was black and dry as a hank of jerky; his nose was withered and shrunken to half its length, and the nostril-lining showing black; his eyes were set in a winkless stare, with surrounding skin so contracted as to expose the conjunctiva, itself as black as the gums…; his skin [had] generally turned a ghastly purplish yet ashen gray, with great livid blotches and streaks; his lower legs and feet … were torn and scratched by contact with thorns and sharp rocks, yet even the freshest cuts were so many scratches in dry leather, without trace of blood” (Philbrick, 126-128).
Posted by: ~DS~ at March 24, 2005 10:56 PM
You have got to be the must fucking dense nimrod on this site. Dig: TERRI IS NOT ON LIFE-SUPPORT JACKASS.
I they reviewed the case Julie, that means they reviewed the evidence…follow along now sweetie …
Was that too fast? You with me so far? Now compare that to my statement “About a dozen courts have heard evidence you’ve not heard ..”
Nothing in there about a case, just a statement that about a dozen courts have heard the evidence. And why the hostility? I realize Paul doens’t agree with many views expressed here, but if he wanted an echo chamber my guess is he wouldn’t have an open to all comers comment section.
LOL. Very impressive TT. And you’re very sweet. Isn’t TT doing well folks, considering?