(I’m breaking my blogging break because this is just too important to miss.)
For all of you who keep blaming Bush and trying to protect Blanco, I’m afraid I have some bad news for you. Blanco got caught on tape by CNN admitting she did not ask for Federal Troops. When she didn’t think the cameras were live, she made the startling admission to her press secretary.
AND that’s not even the worst of it….
Why didn’t she ask for federal troops? As Blanco explained to her press secretary as she wiped away tears, if troops came in, they would “put good people in jail.”
She was more worried about the “poor looters” than she was the victims. This is outrageous.
SHE WEEPS AT THE THOUGHT TO THROWING LOOTERS IN JAIL!
Then she tells her press secretary, “I really need to call for the military, I mean, I really should have started that in the first call.” BUSTED!
When Miles O’Brien asks her what day it was she asked for Federal troops, she tried desperately to stammer her way thru the answer like a 9th grade foreign language student trying to mumble their way the the oral part of a final exam. When pressed for an answer, Governor Blanco breaks down and has an Admiral Stockdale moment, replying:

“I don’t even know what day it is.”
Thank goodness The Political Teen got the damning video.
While she was sheading tears over the poor looters going to jail, they were destroying not only the city itself but its reputation worldwide. Incompetent does not even begin to describe this woman. I truly hope this woman runs for reelection… I’ll personally buy the air time to play this video. If you ever doubt the importance of your vote, watch this video.
Related Update: If you missed Mary Landrieu getting absolutely taken apart by questions she can’t answer on FOXNews Sunday, The Political Teen has that one too. It’s a don’t miss.


Tubino, that’s already been debunked, by no less than the partisan LATimes. She had plenty of LANG that she never called up. Get your facts straight, idiot.
I don’t even know why I bother with this. You’re so fucking stupid that you actually believe that FEMA has control over the National Guard. God, what an idiot!! Do some fucking research. Even the head of DHS, literally and legally, has NO AUTHORITY, over the lowliest private either in the National Guard or Title 10 Troop (Active Duty).
If you want to be taken serious, educate yourself so you can have a point to argue. Spouting incorrect assumptions as facts lables you as nothing more than a Left tit mouthpiece – one without a brain.
I live in NC where Ophelia is about to hit. This is only a CAT1 and here what our Gov. says:
“If you have not heeded the warning before, let me be clear right now: Ophelia is a dangerous storm that is likely to cause flooding from storm surge in rivers and sounds, power outages and property damage over the next 24 to 36 hours,” Easley said.
“The slow-moving nature of this storm may increase its impact along our coast. I ask everyone to remain vigilant and to follow evacuation orders and other directions issued by state and local officials.”
People have left. I know if a CAT4-5 were coming we’d all leave. People in NOLA should’ve listened and made plans. . .
Actually, one of the biggest differences in the response to Katrina between Blanco and Barbour came from their use of the National Guard. Both states have Guard deployed so don’t start any of that nonsense.
Barbour positioned his Guard toward the coast to enable them to better react to the storm. He knew it would put them somewhat in harm’s way, but he also wanted a quicker response. Blanco held her Guard back in realtive safety until after the storm passed then moved them in. It took longer for them to react and, thus, longer for them to restore order.
It is amazing to me how quickly people forget the actual events that occurred and remember only the spin from later. For example, everyone *knows* that the people at the Superdome were abandoned until Friday. If you actually look back at the reports at the time, you will see that the levees broke on Tuesday and flooded NO. Wednesday, buses showed up to evacuate the Superdome but were turned away by gunfire. Rescue operations were halted because of gunfire. Thursday, buses once again rolled in and started evacuating people.
The reason politicians lie and flip-flop is that they know that the American people have an attention span of a gnat, and for the most part, they’re right. People can’t remember events that they witnessed on television from two weeks ago, so they count on someone to tell them what they saw. Too often they rely on the exact wrong people for that history. The argument over this video proves that. Here you have a person making a statement on camera about an event. It’s not a second-hand report, it’s her saying it. Yet, she has her spin machine out there spinning and spinning and spinning and people eating her story up with a spoon.
People can reasonably disagree abou policy or execution of a policy, but how in the world can you deny that Blanco said what she did?
It’s like the old saying, “Who are you going to believe: me or your lying eyes?”
Now the liberals are accusing us of placing blame…funny how the tides change. Weren’t they JUST pointing fingers at Mike Brown/FEMA, Bush et al? We have an ADMISSION on video and they now want to accuse US of pointing fingers? You can always tell where the truth lies…it’s right under the squirming liberal. Blanco dropped the ball because her bleeding heart pumped peanut butter for the LOOTERS, the mayor REFUSED to use the resources at his disposal to evacuate because he didn’t want to dip into HIS emergency fund…to me these are two key pieces in the puzzle. It’s one thing to be unpreparred, but these two had complete control over when and where and they STILL fumbled…horribly and with devastating results. Just further proof that a liberal mind is a terrible thing…
So Blanco is being held accountable! GOOD! This is what we the people should do. Even if right wing wacko want to play it down by calling childish names like ring around the posey or the BLAME GAME.
Politicians are accountable! That includes the bumbling cold hearted fool you worship, Bush.
Bush may have LEGALLY performed according to the letter of the law. But that doesnt mean he is a good leader.
If Bush was playing guitar with his country star buddies 3 days after 9/11 or doing “fly-overs” and fake photo ops for the press do you think he would of been re-elected?
Nope.
And Katrina is just as devestating. The state and local government of Lousiana failed and failed miserably. But that’s no excuse for the sleeping King.
“And Katrina is just as devestating. The state and local government of Lousiana failed and failed miserably. But that’s no excuse for the sleeping King.”
I must be one of the few swimming against the current meme that this disaster response was unconscienable. Could it have been better? Maybe. Do people make mistakes? Always. It just seems to me that this has been the best response to a natural disaster that I can remember. Let the party without sin cast the first stone. I invite comparisons to previous disasters of this magnitude.
Tob
Well comparisons to previous disasters will fall short. Why? Because after 9/11 we are supposed to be ready for disasters and terrorist attacks. We are supposed to be on a war footing and war readiness. This disaster highlighted how UNREADY we are. I am sure terrorists have noted our total lack of ability to respond. (After claiming God is punishing us.)
I for one have been upset with King George for awhile now. Ironicly I see the federal hurricane response as more of the same, and basically exactly what you would expect to see given the management style of this administration. The funny thing is that almost every one of my friends who has supported Bush all along doesn’t seem to see it that way. They think that the government has really let people down, and that it is this guys fault. These guys played a little too much politics on this one and ran a little fast and loose on the governing part, and the average Joe on the street has taken notice.
“These guys played a little too much politics on this one and ran a little fast and loose on the governing part, and the average Joe on the street has taken notice.”
Perceptions change as facts emerge and passions cool. I agree that the current response shows that an intentional disaster, dirty bomb or bio attack, would find us just as unready. Will we be ready? Could we be? I don’t think that ready is the word we should use. It’s my hope that our response to disaster will continue to improve and that our country will continue to be as prosperous as it is, allowing the kind of restoration effort that we now enjoy. (imagine this disaster occurring during the Great Depression).
Tob
From what I have seen from Mayor Nagin is that he was the first person to take responsibility on what was or wasn’t done. He came out in a interview, the same one where he is critical of Gov. Blanco and her “I need 24 hours to make a decision” comment.
Look, if you can not see that Gov. Blanco is a fucking train wreck under pressure than there is something wrong with you. Part of Mayor Nagin freaking out on the phone is that he didn’t know what the hell was going on. It seems like Blanco asks for the Federal Gov’t and than washes her hands with the whole thing. What kind of leader is that.
Mayor Nagin may have made mistakes, but you saw he still fighting to save people and the city NO. That’s a leader.
For the people who say the people in NOLA area couldn’t just walk out:
http://www.clarionledger.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050913/NEWS0110/509130369
They’ve relied on gov’t all their lives. Thats why they didn’t leave. Mandatory evacuation people. Able bodied people should’ve gotten the hell out. Period.
So what I’m getting here (and I’m WAITING for the first moon-bat to say this) is that because President Bush isn’t FRIGGIN PSYCHIC, it’s his fault? If he would have sent federal troops in WITHOUT a SPECIFIC request for them, that would have been ILLEGAL, as far as I understand it, so once “Governor” Blank-O SPECIFICALLY REQUESTED them, he sent them.
People are going on about FEMA, and how they were supposed to respond. Huh? My experience with FEMA is that they hand out the checks — that’s about it.
Having grown up on the SE coast of America, my family has gone through several hurricanes, one of which landed a tree on our roof, one of which turned power off for over a week, and one of which destroyed the trailer park my aunt and cousins lived in. FEMA never had anything to do with search & rescue, etc. I remember when St. Louis and other midwestern towns got flooded in the 90s. Again, I don’t remember FEMA having anything to do with evacuating people or such stuff. FEMA is the =last=-responder by design, not the first-responder.
FEMA was a manager to coordinate long-term recovery efforts, disburse federal funds to disaster victims — that sort of thing. When did their mandate change?
Gov. Blanco should have known that she needed to give the President specific permission to send in federal troops. If the President had made that decision unilaterally, it would not only be in clear violation of the law, but also an act of political suicide. Can you imagine the hue & cry if Bush had superceded the Governor’s authority and taken command? The democrats would then have *at least legally* a legitimate argument for assailing the President’s disregard for Constitutional Law. It would be grounds for impeachment – it wouldn’t matter a whit to Pelosi, Biden, et al. that he was doing it for humanitarian reasons: he’d be drawn & quartered.
Whether or not people think this is right in a time of disaster is irrelevant. The Constitution clearly precludes the President from taking such a step unless specifically requested to do so by the Governor. Case closed.
Please, Paul, not looters. They’re constituents.
[i]”For all of you who keep blaming Bush and trying to protect Blanco, I’m afraid I have some bad news for you. Blanco got caught on tape by CNN admitting she did not ask for Federal Troops.”[/i]
This is like saying that you are holding a fire hose but waiting for a person inside a burning building to yell for help before turning on the water.
2nd of all. I don’t know ANYONE who is trying to protect Blanco. Just because someone hold’s the leader of our country to some sort of accountability standard, or a certain level of responsibilty for his administration doesn’t mean we are die hard Democrats.
3rd. This is not a blame game, dodge ball or a tennis match.
hey “Bigdick”, do you talk to your imaginary friends very often. well i talked to my imaginary friends a while ago, and they said W did all he possibly could.
The Constitution clearly precludes the President from taking such a step unless specifically requested to do so by the Governor. Case closed.
Exactly.
The last thing this country needed is another politician. It needed a LEADER.
Immediately after 9/11 we had Mayor Rudolf comforting and commanding the people on the ground, I gained alot of respect for that man on that day. And shortly after we had Bush standing on a pile of rubble rallying the troops and re-assuring the people.
This time we had Bush waiting for the DVD to come out.
Sad. Case closed.
“Sad. Case closed.”
Well, that settles it. 😉
Tob
Hey “jab”,
Your svengali like knowledge of my anatomy aside, I have no doubt you have imaginary friends, I have no doubt that “W” did all he could. That was kind of my point, that he has broken the machine so badly that even though we were suppossed to be all prepared after 9/11, that in fact things where FUBARed. My friends, both real and imaginary feel the same way. There are plenty of people who screwed the dog on this one, and your boy is at the top of the list. I have not once praised Blanco or Nagin. This is Neo-con small government in action, if you are okay with it then fine, but my albeit emperical evidence seems to show that most moderate people are not. Don’t worry hon, none of this will get in the way of the Bushies drinking mai tais at the Hamptons this year.
It’s so funny to see that those who usually refer to President Bush as a fascist dictator are incensed that he didn’t act like one and overtake the state without permission.
“This is Neo-con small government in action, if you are okay with it then fine, but my albeit emperical evidence seems to show that most moderate people are not.”
As I stated, I’m not satisfied with it (not being satisfied with anything short of perfection) but its not horrid and after getting over being overwhelmed by the distruction, I think its better than I would have expected. As I said, I think its better than any previous response to a disaster of this magnitude and thats something.
Tob
I think you meant anecdotal not empirical, unless you’ve take surveys. 😉
We, in Texas, will make a full court press to register all of the displaced Katrina victims we are sheltering here and look forward to watching Texas turn blue in the next election. That is exactly what old Babs Bush is afraid of. Be afraid, be VERY afraid.
Shaun:
Ya know, that’s a pretty damn good observation!
What Nelson Muntz would say to Gov. Blanco: “A-ha!”
There’s a real easy way we can solve this entire question:
Support an independent counsel investigation, with a bipartisan review panel that has subpoena powers, to look at every single aspect of the Katrina response. From the Mayor all the way up to the President. Including a full timeline.
I’m a Democrat and a Liberal, and I support this. I want to know exactly how much of this blame falls on Nagin, on Blanco, on Brown and FEMA, on Chertoff and Homeland Security, and on Bush. Should it turn out, after such a thorough investigation, that Nagin and Blanco own more of the blame, so be it.
If you are all interested in getting to the truth of this matter, assessing accountability, and fixing problems, I think you will support this or a similar idea.
“We, in Texas, will make a full court press to register all of the displaced Katrina victims we are sheltering here and look forward to watching Texas turn blue in the next election.”
WTF? Your from Texas and you don’t know the relative populations? You could take in all of LA and still be a red state. One with more electoral votes.
Maybe that is a good idea. 😉
Tob
“I think you meant anecdotal not empirical, unless you’ve take surveys. ;-)”
The sad part is that I looked it up and everything. “Anecdotal”, “Anecdotal”, “Anecdotal”. Spell it 3 times and you will remember it! 🙂
The Constitution clearly precludes the President from taking such a step unless specifically requested to do so by the Governor. Case closed.
I will say, I find it difficult to square this sort of excuse, with the supposed conservative ideology of accountability.
If the President had spent those days on the phone, doing everything possible to talk reason into Blanco, signing the paperwork necessary to send in the New Mexico Nat’l Guard offered by Richardson, etc. etc.; and Blanco blocked Bush from helping every step of the way, THEN you might have an argument.
But Bush played guitar and ate cake while people were dying – precisely as if he felt it really wasn’t his problem.
And besides the callousness this sort of behavior indicates, which is bad enough – it really did **legally** become his responsibility to do the best that he could to help, the moment Blanco requested Bush to declare a disaster area – which was done on 8/27.
“Support an independent counsel investigation, with a bipartisan review panel that has subpoena powers, to look at every single aspect of the Katrina response. From the Mayor all the way up to the President. Including a full timeline.”
Jim, we get it already. You don’t like Bush. 😉
But seriously, an independent counsel? Has some crime been committed? I thought that one of the best points raised in this post was Oh Dear’s link to the documents. That seem to establish that all the i’s were dotted and t’s crossed. An after-action or lessons learned report may make more sense or perhaps that’s what you meant.
Tob
Let me try again,
The “Hurricane Pam” scenario predicted:
61,290 dead. Latest projection is well under 1000
384,257 injured. Far less in actuality.
250,000 children missing school. Far less in actuality.
New Orleans uninhabitable for well over a year. Actually they are planning on having Mardis Gras next year (that is about 6 months)
All of the predicted devastation to the oil supply lines has been much, much shorter term than predicted.
So far the only real complaint is that some folks went a couple days without food and water, and had to wait a couple days on a bus. This is intolerable? Are you all fucking nuts?
I’ll say it again:
Predicted dead- 61,290 Actual- less than a 1,000
Hmmm.
@ tubino
“Did Blanco have sufficient LA Natl Guard, that should contact and get there quickly? No.”
She had 8,000 LA National Guard available out of 12,000 LA National Guard total. Yet Blanco only mobilized 1,800 LA National Guard by Monday and another 1,200 LA National Guard by late Tuesday.
Even now only 4,000 of the 12,000, it’s back to 12,000 because the 256th Brigade has returned from Iraq, available LA National Guard have been mobilized.
“tubino” your point would be a lot more impressive if it included, you know, facts.
“Predicted dead- 61,290 Actual- less than a 1,000”
From you lips to G_d’s ear.
Less that 1000 recovered so far. The destruction in Mississippi has to be seen to be believed. It could still go a lost higher although I grow more optimistic with each passing day.
Tob
Jim, we get it already. You don’t like Bush. 😉
Heh. OK, you found me out. 🙂
Nevertheless, I’m up for a full look here, and let the chips fall where they may. However much responsibility Nagin and Blanco are eventually found to bear, so be it…
But seriously, an independent counsel? Has some crime been committed? I thought that one of the best points raised in this post was Oh Dear’s link to the documents. That seem to establish that all the i’s were dotted and t’s crossed. An after-action or lessons learned report may make more sense or perhaps that’s what you meant.
I’m thinking a commission very similar to the 9/11 commission, with the additional helpfulness of an independent lead investigator. I’m very willing to just settle for a 9/11-style commission. It could even have all the exact same people on it. I thought they did quite a good job.
I think such a commission is needed, because when politicians of ANY stripe or rank are at risk, getting at the truth can easily require subpoena power. And I that an after-action report, without that level of power, will just be pushed away from any potentially damaging info that the politicians can avoid.
After all, look at all the tooth-pulling it took, just for the 9/11 commission to get it’s info…
Hmmm.
Frankly what I’d like to discuss is how Mayor Ray “Naggin” Nagin is going to pay for his police officers going on vacation to Las Vegas when the City of New Orleans is broke.
And how is it that the City of New Orleans is broke? Since it doesn’t seem they spent any money on police overtime, or mandatory evacuations or frankly anything else. Where did the money go?
Hmmmm
Washington Times
“Mayor says New Orleans now bankrupt
Sep. 13, 2005 at 9:02AM
New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin says the hurricane-devastated city is bankrupt and is scrambling for loans to pay its employees through the end of the year.
“Technically today we’re out of cash,” Nagin told reporters in Baton Rouge. “The city is bankrupt … We have no money.”
He said the city spent its last available cash last week on city employee payroll and was seeking bank loans, federal assistance and other means of financing to continue paying its bills and staff, the New Orleans Times Picayune reported Tuesday.
However, Nagin was emphatic state and federal officials would not railroad through city reconstruction until it had passed city muster.
“I don’t want anybody outside of New Orleans planning nothing as it relates to how we’re going to rebuild this city without us signing off on it,” Nagin said. “
If the City was broke from making payroll last week, then the City of New Orleans has been skirting bankruptcy for months. The City certainly didn’t spend any money when it came to doing what it needed to do in support of Katrina.
So was this the reason why “Naggin” Nagin didn’t want to do the mandatory evacuation? Which seems really odd since the entire purpose of making the area a federal disaster area is to provide additional funding for evacuations.
There’s a lot that doesn’t seem right going on here.
“I’m thinking a commission very similar to the 9/11 commission, with the additional helpfulness of an independent lead investigator. I’m very willing to just settle for a 9/11-style commission. It could even have all the exact same people on it. I thought they did quite a good job.”
I hope we don’t get a replay of the 9/11 commission although I’m not opposed to an investigation per se. The devil’s in the details as they say and more grandstanding by big-government types is more than I can bear. 🙂
Truthfully, I so expect any and all governments to screw up anything that they put their hands to that I’m grateful when any response to disaster works at all. I don’t know why so many people expect government officals to be perfect when they are just the same people that one sees on the street and, in my case atleast, in the mirror. They aren’t granted godlike powers upon their election or elevation.
Tob
RightWingLiberal:
Granted, Bush didn’t equal Giuliani in his command of the situation on 9/11. Bush didn’t equal himself on 9/11. But there is a critical difference “on the ground” when you compare Bush’s ability to act in the case of 9/11 with that of New Orleans. In NYC, confident and capable people were in charge, and they (Giuliani & Pataki) put aside political issues in the name of getting the job done. In Louisiana, you had bickering and incompetent fools at the helm. It’s a whole lot easier to take charge when the parties on the ground are ready to act. Blanco and Nagin were too busy looking to blame others for things that were in part their own fault and in part the fault of others. Crying and pleading don’t get the job done. Thoughtful, confident assessment followed by clear and precise orders does.
And if you have a problem with the fact that the President didn’t do what he ought to have done, constitutional hindrances be damned, please go ask a lawyer or paralegal friend about The Law. There are more cases of The Law preventing right-action than many of us realize. Tort law is full of them, and these contradictions screw things up more often than they help make things right. It’s nuts, but until legal remedies are enacted and those remedies pass constitutional scrutiny, there isn’t a damn thing we can do about it. That is true no matter who the President is: Had Kerry been the president, he would likely have found himself in the “Can’t Win for Trying” dilemna in which Bush is caught. That’s inarguable, IMHO.
Hmmmm.
@ jim
“I’m thinking a commission very similar to the 9/11 commission, with the additional helpfulness of an independent lead investigator. I’m very willing to just settle for a 9/11-style commission. It could even have all the exact same people on it. I thought they did quite a good job.”
Frankly I don’t think the 9/11 Commission did all that good a job at all. First off they played the bi-partisan game by eliminating anything that might embarass either side. Gorelick’s self-imposed excessive “wall” has been fingered as the primary problem, yet you really don’t get that sense from the 9/11 Commission report.
Then there’s that whole “Able Danger” stuff that’s coming out.
I’m in favor of a Commission, with subpoena powers, but absolutely NO politicians from any party should be on it. The best idea I’ve heard so far is a Commission composed of retired military officers charged with determing all the facts, apportioning blame and publishing everything.
Regardless of who gets hammered, I want a Commission that doesn’t hold back and won’t whitewash anyone.
It’s just getting to that end point that frankly seems impossible.
To the liberals: Say the day after Katrina hit, GW Bush sent in Federal Troops all over NO. The left would say Bush is a jackbooted thug, trampling on our soverign states rights. Now, you know you would. This is all the typical liberal left playing both sides. It is the left that is transparent.
What does one do when one discovers another is posting with the same name?
Now don’t get me wrong, jim of neophiliac-dot-com is certainly entitled to post as he has and I am in no way criticizing him for it, name and all (“jim” is certainly a fine name, we both apparently agree on this! 😉 ).
This jim here – moi – is not the other one and I do not share his views. Still, if one could really get a true and honest investigation, I would not oppose it. Would both sides accept Colin Powell?
Only Wacoheads and Ruby Ridgers cry about jackbooted thugs; this liberal applauded both of those actions. Yesterday, for the first time EVER, Bush accepted responsibility for something that went wrong on his watch. Do you think he would have done that if he really thought he didn’t commit the FUBAR that exposes him and his policies for what they really are and was in desparate CYA mode? Those of you who are still blaming state and local officials are questioning Bush’s judgment to take responsibility, and I must ask: why do you hate America?
Colin Powell, hmmmm I might could go along with that. He might not accept the position as he is skilled bureacratic fighter and would see that this is a no-win position.
As Ed points out, a large component of military men would seem to be important since a) much of the response is from active/reserve military and B) nobody but the military has any conception of what it takes to move vast quantities of men and supplys over disturbed terriotry.
Tob
Blanco defenders,
1) By all accounts, including hers, Blanco caused two 24-hour critical delays, waiting to make a decision.
2) Blanco stopped the Red Cross from going in to the Superdome and the Convention Center. This is undisputed.
3) Blanco held back her own National Guard from NO, by her own account, fearing that thousands of LANG “would not be enough.”
Given the above, and the video, it is going to be very hard to establish Blanco as a fast thinking, action Governor who was held back by FEMA and the Feds. This is a leap only for the brain-dead.
Bush, at least, has accepted responsibility for problems on his side and worked to fix them. I may be the only one, but I think replacing Brown was more than just a political act.
“I must ask: why do you hate America?”
LOL
hey, Paul’s posted a follow up post to this one that raises an interesting point on this subject:
http://wizbangblog.com/archives/007084.php
I’m so there!
Tob
Are you sure they weren’t going to put the “Finders” in jail, not “Looters”.
If it’s all Blanco’s (a carnard from the Right), why did bush boy claim responsibility? And where are the troops anyway? Oh, that’s right…. Iraq.
Bok Bok Chicken Hawk
“Bok Bok Chicken Hawk”
I bow before your wit and wisdom.
Tob
“Bawk Bawk Chicken Hawk” sound better Lars.
also: your confusion between FEMA & military… is that intentional, or are you just playing dumb?
Who cares what SHE did, is she the leader of our country in time of national emergency? Is some mayor supposed to be in charge of our NATIONAL well-being?
When a huge emergency happens like Hurricane Katrina, the feds are in charge, because the NATION is at risk, not just some state, city, or county. Those evacuees have spread through-out the entire US, we are ALL paying for it. The effect of an entire major city, and the coastal areas of 3 states that have been shut down hits the entire country.
I don’t want my security in Texas to be determined by what some mayor or governor does in Louisiana in times of national emergencies. I want the feds to handle their part of it and mitigate what effect it is going to have.
So, if this is some Louisiana post, about Louisiana politics, then you got a point. But if you are trying to tell me that this national emergency is the fault of some local yokel in Louisiana, get real.
Frankly I don’t think the 9/11 Commission did all that good a job at all. First off they played the bi-partisan game by eliminating anything that might embarass either side.
Well, that’s a reality we can’t really avoid right now. To be more precise, I feel the 9/11 commission did a fine job, within the limitations of a highly divided partisan atmosphere. Important flaws were revealed, that if and when properly addressed, will help make our country safer.
Gorelick’s self-imposed excessive “wall” has been fingered as the primary problem, yet you really don’t get that sense from the 9/11 Commission report. Then there’s that whole “Able Danger” stuff that’s coming out.
And it has also come out that the US Gov’t was in fact warned that Al Qaeda wanted to crash planes into US landmarks, contrary to Rice’s statement that “no one could have predicted it”. I expect all conservatives to immediately demand her resignation for lying…not. 🙂
Nevertheless, the 9/11 commission shed a lot more light on a lot of things, than would have happened otherwise.
I’m in favor of a Commission, with subpoena powers, but absolutely NO politicians from any party should be on it. The best idea I’ve heard so far is a Commission composed of retired military officers charged with determing all the facts, apportioning blame and publishing everything.
It also would be useful if staffed by personnel who are experienced specifically in disaster management. So military officers with experience in this area would be useful, as would civilians with similar experience…
Regardless of who gets hammered, I want a Commission that doesn’t hold back and won’t whitewash anyone.
Definitely agreed there.
It’s just getting to that end point that frankly seems impossible.
That may be so. Still, the further it gets from the date of the incident, the more all concerned can cover their tracks – and there definitely should be some sort of investigation into a tragedy of this scale, regardless of how difficult the political process can make it.
Bush, at least, has accepted responsibility for problems on his side and worked to fix them.
For what it’s worth. We’ll see if this statement of responsibility, has any actual accountability or actions that follow…