(I’m breaking my blogging break because this is just too important to miss.)
For all of you who keep blaming Bush and trying to protect Blanco, I’m afraid I have some bad news for you. Blanco got caught on tape by CNN admitting she did not ask for Federal Troops. When she didn’t think the cameras were live, she made the startling admission to her press secretary.
AND that’s not even the worst of it….
Why didn’t she ask for federal troops? As Blanco explained to her press secretary as she wiped away tears, if troops came in, they would “put good people in jail.”
She was more worried about the “poor looters” than she was the victims. This is outrageous.
SHE WEEPS AT THE THOUGHT TO THROWING LOOTERS IN JAIL!
Then she tells her press secretary, “I really need to call for the military, I mean, I really should have started that in the first call.” BUSTED!
When Miles O’Brien asks her what day it was she asked for Federal troops, she tried desperately to stammer her way thru the answer like a 9th grade foreign language student trying to mumble their way the the oral part of a final exam. When pressed for an answer, Governor Blanco breaks down and has an Admiral Stockdale moment, replying:

“I don’t even know what day it is.”
Thank goodness The Political Teen got the damning video.
While she was sheading tears over the poor looters going to jail, they were destroying not only the city itself but its reputation worldwide. Incompetent does not even begin to describe this woman. I truly hope this woman runs for reelection… I’ll personally buy the air time to play this video. If you ever doubt the importance of your vote, watch this video.
Related Update: If you missed Mary Landrieu getting absolutely taken apart by questions she can’t answer on FOXNews Sunday, The Political Teen has that one too. It’s a don’t miss.

Fun with putting the shoe on the other foot. 🙂
****
Bush defenders,
1) Bush appointed an inexperienced, unqualified political hack to head FEMA, and didn’t pull him when his staggering incompetence was revealed – it was only once people screamed, the US was humiliated in front of the world, and his polls took a hit that anything happened to Brown.
2) Bush ate cake and played guitar, rather than straighten out the situation, and do many, many other things he could have done, until days and deaths later. This is undisputed.
3) New Mexico’s National Guard were held back, because no one could be bothered to hurry the paperwork.
Given the above, and the video, it is going to be very hard to establish Bush as a fast thinking, action President who was held back by Blanco and the locals. This is a leap only for the brain-dead.
Seems to me like nitpicking in an effort to find fault with the governor. Was her judgment bad in either not asking for the troops (or being more specific in her request, if you’re feeling generous)? Yeah, probably, but so what?
Was that really the biggest problem? Look at this: New Orleans has been a sitting duck for a Cat 3+ storm for decades. Everybody has known for years that the city was a disaster waiting to happen. Louisiana may not be the richest state, but New Orleans is a major tourist attraction that brings in a lot of money. Why wasn’t more of that going to build up the levees? Whether or not the federal government was remiss in not providing greater federal support for building up the levees, Louisiana should have been doing everything they could at their end. So this governor is at fault, and the one before her, and the one before that….
Does this excuse federal failings?–obviously not. The governor had no experience with this sort of thing, so is it really surprising if she made some poor decisions in the face of a massive disaster? That’s one reason why we need an effective FEMA–because local governments cannot be relied upon to have the experience, knowledge, resources, and resolve to deal effectively with this sort of once-in-a-lifetime disaster.
The governor’s handling of the crisis is likely to be a major issue for Louisiana residents. The rest of us, who don’t depend upon the judgment of the Louisiana governor, but who do have to rely upon the same FEMA and Homeland Safety, are understandably more concerned with why things weren’t handled better at the federal level.
Don’t forget that BushCo ran a national campaign that basically said “don’t vote for the dems – they won’t keep you safe. with us you are safe and secure.”
After all of those campaign scare tactics about keeping everyone safe from harm, it is unbelievable that in the post-9/11 world Bush names a buddy of his with no previous experience managing emergencies to be head of FEMA. What if this had been a terrorirst attack? What if a truck bomber – a la Tim McVeigh – had blown up the levees in New Orleans? The flooding in NO would have been the same, except no one would have had several days warning beforehand. Clearly, the handling of this disaster by the feds shows that BushCo was not up to the task, and that they put political patronage above national security (once again). That the Right is now campaigning to blame local officials is beyond pathetic.
This is not to say that Gov Blanco, Mayor Nagin, or other local officials didn’t drop the ball too. But they didn’t run a BS campaign based on national security. The local voters will decide their fate, and it is only up to the locals to do that. I don’t live in Lousiana, so I could give a rat’s petootey what the Gov did or didn’t do right. All I know is that the Bushies obviously failed in what was supposed to be their strong suit: handling national crises. The next disaster – be it at the hands of terrorists of mother nature – most likely will be somewhere other than Louisiana. It could be in my backyard or yours, and it is obvious that the Bush admin is not prepared, and does not have the right people or resources in place to respond adequately.
Now we see that the image of Bush cultivated after 9/11 as a strong national leader in times of crisis is what most of us knew it was: a big lie. Coupled with Iraq, that makes two colossal national failures that have done enormous damage to the US.
The Katrina disaster exposes more than just an inept federal response to crisis. It shows what happens when funding for our national infrastructure is gutted, or when an underclass is perpetuated by Republican economic programs. It shows what happens when neocon wars of aggression and tax cuts for the rich are favored over investing in our future.
This just in on Fox News!:
Gov Blanco was seen on tape to be hindering the dispatch of Lousiana National Guard to Iraq during the battle of Fallujah. Were it not for Gov Blanco, Bush would be winning the war on terror.
It’s these unpatriotic local officals that keep getting in the way of our glorious victory in Iraq.
Gee, what is *Bush* supposed to do about these wars? It’s not like it’s *his* fault. Shit happens! You lefties always want to play the blame game, and always want the feds to come in and bail us out of ill-planned wars against nations that had nothing to do with 9/11. Quit looking at the goverment as the solution to everything!
“Bush ate cake and played guitar, rather than straighten out the situation, and do many, many other things he could have done, until days and deaths later. This is undisputed.”
Actually, I disputed it.
Tob
Aaron,
Whatever.
Tob
Busy day.
I just learned that it’s a big deal that Chertoff didn’t understand his job, and delayed matters unnecessarily. Read it here:
http://tinyurl.com/93qze
For the impaired, this is a much bigger deal than any of your assertions about Blanco. Deal with it.
I also learned that Dick Cheney had electricity repairs redirected from a rural hospital to an oil pipeline. You can’t make this stuff up. Read it here:
http://tinyurl.com/9exey
No word yet if the delay in electricity caused any deaths.
The things you don’t learn in the MSM, eh?
tubino, yet again you’re late to the party. The Cheney pipeline story is also common knowledge.
Why do you think your gasoline isn’t $6 a gallon now?
Tob
But I will say this, aaron could learn a lot from you. At least you post links with your diatribes, even if they’re old news.
Tob
robert claims, “2) Blanco stopped the Red Cross from going in to the Superdome and the Convention Center. This is undisputed.”
No. It is debunked. The Red Cross now says it agreed to stay out.
http://tinyurl.com/aatmv
Anyway, new news is that Bush called Barbour three times, ignored Blanco.
If Blanco was really screwing up, FEMA and Bush should have been on the phone screaming. That didn’t happen.
Chertoff didn’t understand his own plan.
http://tinyurl.com/b4zx5
Ah the things you don’t learn in the MSM…
An uplifting story of individual responsibility over government regulation:
http://tinyurl.com/dl9m5
And there’s a moral there too.
toby –
“whatever”
very impressive.
You want links with that post? How about these?:
http://www.ItIsPainfullyFreakingObvious.com
http://www.HowTobyGotDupedByAChimp.com
http://www.MyDogAtTheEmergencyPlans.com
Tob takes out his pain thusly: “Why do you think your gasoline isn’t $6 a gallon now?”
‘Cept it seems the pipeline is primarily for JET FUEL. STill, nice try, in a kind of factless logic-free assertive way…
The issue isn’t whether pipelines need to work. It’s just interesting that at this level of detail, the VP is making personal calls. It raises questions. What other calls did he make? Is this any way to run a disaster plan? And why didn’t Bush or Chertoff or Brown seem to be finding anything worth pursuing with a call or two in Louisiana for DAY AFTER DAY???
Can any of you smartalecks explain why Bush’s declaration of emergency on Aug. 27 named all the wrong parishes, or rather left out the most important ones?
http://tinyurl.com/8lpgw
I honestly don’t understand this, though I’ve been looking for a while. The Hurricane Cindy explanation (the other parishes were already named from previous alert) doesn’t explain it, so don’t bother with that.
No! This can’t be! Rep. John Conyer’s and his all Democrat investigative team have already studied this fully and have determined that Blanco is off the hook. I wrote about it here: House Democrats Release “Non-Partisan” Investigation Results
Tubino says “robert claims, “2) Blanco stopped the Red Cross from going in to the Superdome and the Convention Center. This is undisputed.”
No. It is debunked. The Red Cross now says it agreed to stay out.”
FROM YOUR OWN DAMN LINK
Red Cross spokesperson Renita Hosler confirmed that authorities turned down repeated offers by the Red Cross to enter New Orleans with supplies.
Reading comprehension, its whats good for you!
wilky, how do figure “authorities” = Blanco???
reading comprehension — give it a chance!
I never understood the deal with this story, anyway. The Red Cross sez it won’t go into unsecured areas, and so the real argument starts with the chaos.
The only twist that seems interesting is that the “authorities” (apparently DHS) turned down RC help because they were afraid it would encourage people to stay. Yet people were kept in by gunpoint. Go figure.
Plenty more story left to be told. Did you hear the one about the FEMA officials making rescue nearly impossible?
“wilky, how do figure “authorities” “
Google, it to is whats good for you!
The Fox News Channel’s Major Garrett made another appearance on the program this evening, following up on his blockbuster story yesterday. Among other things, Garrett got confirmation –on camera– of the Louisian State department of Homeland Security’s blocking of the delivery of relief supplies to the Superdome and the Convention Center.
So many Constitutional lawyers here! And so little knowledge.
People, the President (Federal government) always … always… has the right to intervene to ensure Federal services — courts, customs collection, postal service — operate. He doesn’t need the permission of governors or mayors.
Lincoln nailed this one in 1861.
I have little use for Nagin and Blanco. But you can’t ignore the fact that Bush ignored his own power to intervene.
Well Allen If I was A DU kind of guy, my thinking would go something like this.
This all started when Blanco needed 24 hours to think about what she should do. So she gathered all the head honchos and came up with a plan. If we act dazed and confused we can get two senerios, she says. The first, we tell those in the city to go to the superdome and withhold food and water, we’ll tell them its because we don’t want people coming back into the city. The press will be out raged and do what they do best, blame Bush. But the real winner is if bush oversteps his bounds and rush in (he’s a fascist, don’t you know) then we can impeach that sorry MF. That should wipe that smirk off the chimps face. He doesn’t care about people (not like we do), beacuase if he did he would have rushed right done there and huffed and puffed and blew that storm away, beacuase, as everyone knows, we live in a theocracy.
——–
We should not ignore the fact that this was a storm of nature. One of the strongest ones our nation has encountered. We should feel blessed that the death count is so low, and pray it stays low. I really don’t care who gets the blame as long as we are dealing with facts. And I’m pretty sure that trying to compare Lincoln in 1861 to the response of this storm is a stretch.
senerios = scenarios
I agree that Blanco is toast, but I have to take offense of using Admiral Stockdale to Katherine Blanco. Admiral Stockdale was a great man and much more than the guy who said “Why am I here?” on TV. The guy is a Medal of Honor winner, Katherine Blanco is a friggin joke.
http://insidethemindsoh.blogspot.com/
Wilky, actually it’s not a stretch at all, since judicial precedent governs how we deal with stuff. You might think Civil War = boring history class and Katrina = now, but precedent is precedent.
As I said before: If the Federal courts (or what have you) cannot operate, the Federal government can use force to ensure that they can.
Had I been president, I would have nationalized the Guard and sent in troops at the outset. I doubt Blanco or Nagin would have objected, but if they had: “See you in court….”
Hmmmm.
@ tubino
“wilky, how do figure “authorities” = Blanco???”
Because Blanco, being Govenor of Louisiana, has direct control over the State Police of Lousisana along with the Louisiana National Guard. the State Police had setup roadblocks around New Orleans.
“The only twist that seems interesting is that the “authorities” (apparently DHS)”
You conveniently, or perhaps ignorantly, forgot to add that it was the *state* Department of Homeland Security that was responsible, not the DHS which is the federal Department of Homeland Security.
“Yet people were kept in by gunpoint. Go figure.”
Yeah. That’s called either a “cluster-f**k” or “sheer stupidity”.
“Did you hear the one about the FEMA officials making rescue nearly impossible?”
If that story has the same command over facts that you’ve shown already, it’ll be a complete waste of time.
Logic, what a frigging crime.
Frankly spending my evening educating liberals isn’t on my todo list so I’ll stop here. One day it’ll happen that a educated and informed liberal will stop by to debate and I’ll have a heart attack from shock.
And I’m pretty damn sure it won’t be tubino.
Hmmmm.
@ Allen Jenkins
“People, the President (Federal government) always … always… has the right to intervene to ensure Federal services — courts, customs collection, postal service — operate. He doesn’t need the permission of governors or mayors.
Lincoln nailed this one in 1861.”
I’ll be damned. After three weeks of this nonense being discussed on just about every political blog here’s someone who doesn’t know that the Posse Comitatus Act was passed in 1878 to prevent just that sort of thing.
I am simply astonished.
Well. No not really.
Here’s a link. Read. Learn. Comprehend. And don’t make a complete fool out of yourself again ok?
“Bush ate cake and played guitar, rather than straighten out the situation, and do many, many other things he could have done, until days and deaths later. This is undisputed.”
Actually, I disputed it.
OK. I mean, I can dispute that you disputed it. But I don’t have any reasonable grounds to dispute it.
So:
a) we know Bush called Mississippi Governor Barbour 3 times, and we know he didn’t call Blanco once in that same time period. So, he didn’t do as much as he could.
b) we know Bush ate birthday cake with John McCain, and played guitar, while, if nothing else, he could have been calling Blanco.
So, what grounds do you have for disputing this?
@#$%
It is up to each state to determine what help is needed in their state. It is up to the Federal Government to deal with interstate emergencies. This clearly was an interstate emergency, but, for example, the flooding in New Orleans only had to do with one state, one city. The Federal Government can deal with how help gets TO the affected states, because that money and/or supplies crosses state boundaries.
However, the state residents and city residents would better be served by their own representatives and city councils. They ARE after all, there for a reason. To represent, protect, and serve their own LOCAL constituents.
Exactly, Ed. Read the second, third, and fifth bullet points.
I hate to rub your “states rights” hide the wrong way, but the president should have simply sent in the troops and invited Louisiana to sue him later.
http://tinyurl.com/8gx2c
from “Commission Criticizes Storm Response”
John F. Lehman, a Republican on the [9-11] panel who was a Navy secretary in the Reagan administration, said he feared that the “unconscionable” failures of the rescue effort along the Gulf Coast would embolden terrorist groups to attack again on American soil, making quick adoption of the commission’s year-old recommendations all the more important.
Wow, just read Michael Brown’s account in today’s NYT. First, you have to recognize that his account is NOT verified by either the White House or LA officials. But if there’s any truth in his claim that it was clear early on that the Louisiana officials weren’t up to the job and he (Brownie) was asking for lots of help …
then it’s also clear that Chertoff and the White House had a LOT of warning, and a lot of requests from the director went ignored.
All along I’ve been saying that if Blanco and the others were nearly as inadequate as the republican noise machine says, then it was up to DHS/FEMA to take steps early, because it was FEMA’s job to coordinate the response!!!
Hmmmm.
@ Allen Jenkins
“I hate to rub your “states rights” hide the wrong way, but the president should have simply sent in the troops and invited Louisiana to sue him later.”
Louisiana wouldn’t be suing the President. Congress would be conducting **impeachment** hearings. This is what people have been trying to get you to understand.
A sitting President cannot grossly violate the law, as set forth in the US Constitution and by Congress, without getting impeached. Particularly this President with so many gunning for his hide.
Then there’s the whole issue of the UCMJ. I certainly hope you’ll understand the following point, but if not I’d suggest talking to someone who has military experience. The UCMJ forbids any soldier from following an illegal order. Period. if a soldier follows an illegal order then that soldier, whatever the rank, is subject to indictment, trial and imprisonment for obeying that illegal order depending on the circumstances.
If the Major General in command of the 82nd Airborne Division obeyed a direct, and *illegal*, order by the President to deploy into New Orleans, then that Major General, his staff and every single officer, NCO and soldier under his command would be liable. I can assure you that Major General would NOT obey that illegal order.
Our political, military and social structure is set up in such a way that the President literally could not give that order and have it obeyed.
When I was in the USMC we had to have a class around every 6 months on what is, and what isn’t a legal order and what the repercussions were for following an illegal order.
Nobody who got to the rank of Major General in the US Army is going to be ignorant of what is and what isn’t a legal order.
Got it?
I am a veteran, but thanks for the little lecture on the UCMJ. Glad to see you take it more seriously than Lynndie England.
Have a look at the link you gave us all. I think you’ll agree that the “exceptions” applied. If you don’t agree, well then… I don’t think I or anyone here can convince you otherwise.
Ed, I notice you don’t have a website or a blog. Why is that? You just like to troll comment logs?
Hmmmm.
@ Allen Jenkins
1. “I am a veteran, but thanks for the little lecture on the UCMJ. Glad to see you take it more seriously than Lynndie England.”
*shrug* you never can tell on blogs.
2. “Have a look at the link you gave us all. I think you’ll agree that the “exceptions” applied.”
In what way? Is looting suitable for a declaration of Insurrection against the wishes of the state’s duly elected Govenor? If Blanco were incapacitated or if Blanco had requested federal military intervention, then it wouldn’t have been a problem. But Blanco was obviously not incapacitated, incompetent yes but not incapacitated.
Plus I notice you didn’t refute my UCMJ point.
3. “Ed, I notice you don’t have a website or a blog. Why is that? You just like to troll comment logs?”
A. I don’t enjoy dealing with trackback spam.
B. I don’t enjoy dealing with comment spam.
C. I don’t have the inclination to blog all the time.
D. I have no interest in it.
E. I’m just too busy to do this sort of thing all the time.
As for the “troll” bit, I’ll just ignore that.
The whole thinking of this issue and the UCMJ is has too much gray area. The General can make the oppsite argument and say people are dying and I need to save them.
The simple fact of this whole issue is that Katherine Blanco is a politician and not a leader. I truly believe she does not understand what is in her power and what isn’t. She did not communicate clearly up the Chain of Command (CoC) to the President and just watching the whole affair, nor did she do it down the CoC to the Mayor. If she thought she asked for troops, which I believe she did not, why didn’t she follow up the request? She simply stated “give me everything” and than washed her hands of the whole affair and placed the blame on the President. Orders and requests need to be placed in a concise and timely manner to effective. She did neither.
To those who keep claiming Bush didn’t act because the Constitution prevents the Feds from interfering in local affairs (unless requested): Give me a freaking break.
There is no way in hell that Bush is even remotely aware of the laws involved. This whole rationale was something cooked up after the fact – just like the ever evolving rationales for the war in Iraq. Face it – Bush didn’t respond quickly because he was in vacation mode, and it took him several days to finally realize “what all the hullabaloo was all about”. It’s just that simple.
To claim Constitutional law prevented him from acting is ludicrous. That would assume that 1) he even knew what the law was (big big stretch, given his studied lack of interest in everything, and given that all of his advisers were on vacation as well) 2) he actually gave a rat’s ass what the law says (this is an administration that has demonstrated over and over that they see themselves as studly dudes who have precious little use for the law) 3) He put the law above the fact that hundreds or perhaps thousands of people were dying in the worst disaster to hit the US in 100 years.
But the Bush apologists will grasp at any straws to protect the carefully crafted image of infallibility of the Dear Leader. Kim Jung Il would be jealous of such blind loyalty that requires constant suspension of reality.
If in a disaster in which the Stafford Act has been invoked, the state governor is:
/in a fetal position under the desk/
/dead or incapacitated
/gone on vacation
/grossly incompetent
then which of these two ways does DHS/FEMA respond?
1) Well, let’s let things deteriorate, and we’ll know who to blame later. But schedule some photo-ops, okay?
2) Since the NRP and the President’s declaration puts FEMA in charge of coordinating the response, we’ll have to do the best we can to work with whoever is competent/alive/responsive.
The problem is that FEMA is admitting it went with #1, when the only responsible reaction was #2.
IOW, Blanco may have failed (though I don’t see it), but the coordination was up to DHS/FEMA — and it failed miserably.
Yep, you can bleat all you want, Blanco’s toast Nagin’s toast, its all a big game, blah blah blab, but the reality is after 911 Dear Leader told us never again. He was going to make sure that we were safe. He put together the Dept. of Homeland Security. Streamlined comunications, no more red tape, tust us we know what were doing. Well folks this was the first big test for DHS and they fail misarably. Right there on National TV for all the world to see. You’all can scream and holler, play your blame game, but many many folks saw Bush for the first time as he really is. It wasn’t pretty.
GOP talking point 2 (aka idiotic rationale number 2)
________
To those who say Bush’s slow response was because he was not kept informed by local officials of exactly what was happening, and that what was going on in New Orleans was very murky: Give me a freaking break.
You mean to tell me the President of the US has no idea of what is going on in a major US city, and has no way to find out? This from the same President who pretends to know and understand what is going on in Iraqi cities? This from the same President who pretends to be able to win a war against a shadowy world-wide terror organization?
Now, everyone had ample warning that this was a very dangerous storm that was heading directly towards a very vulnerable city. The President has at his disposal almost instantaneous and very detailed sattelite imagery of every square inch New Orleans, in visible light or infrared. The US military has fleets of helicopters and other naval aircraft at nearby Pensacola Naval Airstation (which was not evacuated), that could easily evaluate the situation in the hours following the storm and levee break.
If Bush just didn’t know how devastated New Orleans was for some days after the levees broke, it is not because he didn’t have the ability to know, but rather that he didn’t care to know.
And if Bush didn’t know just how bad New Orleans had become, leaders all over the world apparently did. While other world leaders were offering aid, Bush was in San Diego and Arizona yucking it up with McCain. What a pathetic spectacle: leaders of third world nations offering aid before our own finally snaps out of his vacation haze.
Can you guys give some SPECIFIC examples of FEMA failures? With cause and effect?
I can give you specific examples of failures by the Mayor and the Governor demonstrating cause and effect.
For example,
Cause: The mayor waited until less than 24 hours before the hurricane to order the evacuation despite the fact that it would take 72 hours to evacuate the city. Effect: An incomplete evacuation.
Cause: the mayor did not order public transportation to evacuate the indigent from the city, instead they were relocated to another part of the city. Effect: people were intentionally stranded in the city for a hurricane.
Cause: The mayor did not supply food, water, shelter and security to the SuperDome as per his evacuation plan. Effect: people were left starving and chaos erupted at the SuperDome.
Cause: The Governor did not activate enough National Guard and not soon enough. Effect: There was insufficient law enforcement to prevent looting and violence.
So give some specific serious examples. Not some lame partisan example. By the way what constitutes a reasonable timely/effective response? What should the Fed have done differently?
@ Ed
1. Yes, I know. Where were you? I was a CT(0)2 in Navy Intelligence.
2. As President, I wouldn’t have worried much about Governer Blanco. Sure, I would have spoken with her, and would have strongly urged her to request troops or Guard nationalization. But if she had not done so, I would have just done it.
3. UCMJ. Your “illegal orders” example is 100% correct; still, it’s a red herring. As President, you or I don’t call the commander of the 82nd and say “Go down to New Orleans, restore order” anymore than we can call some petty officer in the White House Comms Center and tell him to go fetch some Chinese carry-out.
What would happen is that you or I, as President, would say “let’s send the 82nd, even though Governer Blanco hasn’t asked for it”. The PC law would certainly come up. Maybe we would ask the AG for a ruling — he’s the government’s lawyer, after all. If he said “Yeah, I can make a case for this…”, I’m sure we would consult our SecDef (who has some good lawyers of his own).
In short, no one is going around giving “illegal” orders. By the time it reached the commander of the 82nd, the order has been washed and rinsed. The commander has one choice: obey or resign.
I think, too, we need to step away from the purely legal and look at the political. I detest Bush, and am perfectly happy that he looks like an ass. But, objectively, I think he had a sterling opportunity to lead in this case — the people of New Orleans wouldn’t be any worse off, and his political standing (and that of Republicans in Louisiana) would be sharply higher.
@ Aaron
Amen. If you want to be president, then BE a president.
From Allen Jenkins: “What would happen is that you or I, as President, would say “let’s send the 82nd, even though Governer Blanco hasn’t asked for it”. The PC law would certainly come up. Maybe we would ask the AG for a ruling — he’s the government’s lawyer, after all. If he said “Yeah, I can make a case for this…”, I’m sure we would consult our SecDef (who has some good lawyers of his own). “
But, what if he asked the AG and the AG said, “I CAN’T make a case for this without invoking an impeachable offense.” What then?
Then the President is on his own. And has to hope the SecDef will agree with him, and pass on the orders.
I would presume the AG would resign, speaking publicly about why.
When you use the term “impeachable offense”, what precisely do you mean? “Impeach” is another word for “Indict”. People are indicted all the time, and get off. And, unlike most people, an impeached (indicted) president knows exactly who his jury is.
Believe me, Bush could have sent whatever troops he wanted and a) the House would not have indicted him and b) the Senate would not have convicted him.
I know that makes a lot of libertarians angry, but that’s life in 2005.
And it assumes the Democrats wouldn’t (justifiably) raise as much hell as they could that Bush defied the Constitution. You seem awefully cavalier about the President defying the Constitution. Bad habit from Clinton?
What about future generations? What about the precedent that would set?
Again, you are putting the onus of the problem on the President, when Gov. Blanco could have ALSO solved the problem by turning over control of the NG. Instead, she had to wait 24 hrs to think about it. How many people died in THAT 24 hrs?
On who’s shoulder does that fact sit on?
@ Eric
I’ve not put the onus on the president; I’ve pointed out that the president has more powers than a lot of libertarians wish.
How would the president be “defying” the Constitution by sending troops in early? Before you answer that, I’d suggest a close read of the administrations of Jackson, Lincoln, McKinley, both Roosevelts, and every post WW2 president.
I said at the outset that I have little use for Blanco. What’s your point?
It is interesting to me that the Right makes so much political hay out of “taking responsibility”, and out of “accountability”.
Under this faux accountability ethos, teachers are to be held responsible for the sorry state of education. Poor residents are responsible for not getting out. Lousianans are responsible for living in Lousiana in the first place. Those who lack health care are responsible for not working for a employer who buys insurance. Iraqis are responsible for not making democracy work. Etc, etc, etc
But when it comes to a national emergency… well now, that’s the not administration’s responsibility. Despite campaigning on their bold leadership during times of national emergency, when the national emergency actually came, all they could muster were lame excuses that national emergencies are the responsibility of locals (who just happen to be democrats… just a coincidence, mind you)
Nothing, no matter what, is ever the responsibility of the “No Responsiblity” Administration. The Buck stops over there. The Dear Leader is only responsible for all that is good and great, but not for anything bad. Ever.
The aftermath of the Iraq war, for example, was so clearly and grossly mismanaged, and yet not a *single* admin official has ever been fired over it. On the contrary, they all get promoted and/or received medals!
Now, I have no problem with the principle of holding folks responsible. But there are vastly different responsibility criteria being applied to poor and middle classes, on the one hand, and on corporate and political power elites on the other. Under the Bushies, corporations who dump pollutants into our air and water are *not* to be held responsible for the clean-up (taxpayers foot the bill), and federal emergency management are not responsible for… emergency management.
The night before the D-Day invasion, Eisenhower wrote two communiques. One was in the event the invasion was successful, and the other in case of failure. The one for failure merely said “I take full responsibility”. Were Eisenhower a Bush Republican, his failure communique probably would have read “We tried, but shit happens, and we’ll have time for the blame game later.” Or maybe, “well, it’s not my fault – no one could have predicted there were be so many Germans waiting there.” Or, “we thought we were winning – the commanders on the ground didn’t tell me we were being pushed into the sea. (and I didn’t ask them)” Or, “well, if the Canadian and British troops had done their jobs, we would have won.” Or, “international law prevented me from entering French territorial waters without France’s permission.” etc etc etc
Allen Jenkins: “I hate to rub your “states rights” hide the wrong way, but the president should have simply sent in the troops and invited Louisiana to sue him later.”
“How would the president be “defying” the Constitution by sending troops in early? Before you answer that, I’d suggest a close read of the administrations of Jackson, Lincoln, McKinley, both Roosevelts, and every post WW2 president.”
Really? Please tell me how all those Presidents overcame the Posse Commitatus Act.
What’s my point? My point is that if the President had run in, nationalized the LANG and sent in the 82nd Airborne over the objections of Governor Blanco it would have violated the Posse Commitatus Act. He then would be guilty of violating Federal Law and thus be guilty of an impeachable offense. The Democrats certainly would see it that way, and so too would a lot of Republicans. I think you assume wrongly that Republicans are like Democrats who are willing to overlook the law in favor of party unity.
“I don’t understand the gleeful obsession with anything that hurts Bush regardless of the consequences to the American public and I doubt that attitude is going to win you any converts.”
Funny how a diphsit right winger can’t tell the difference between gleefulness and rage. Go figure.
Eric says: “He then would be guilty of violating Federal Law and thus be guilty of an impeachable offense. The Democrats certainly would see it that way, and so too would a lot of Republicans.”
Oh give me a break. This president has committed so many impeachable offenses already – swiftly moving Federal troops in to help people in an emergency does not even register on the scale. This president fabricated evidence to illegally invade another country that hadn’t done anything to us, and he didn’t even come close to getting impeached. No where close. He didn’t even care that he was violating international law by invading Iraq. And you expect us to believe that he didn’t act in this situation to help our own people because he would have been violating laws, and that he was afraid of getting impeached for it?? Please.
No one on either side of the aisle would have begrudged Bush moving rapidly in response to a natural disaster.
Add, Robert,
Try “going down” in the polls, in the fact that a serious dislike of Bush is about to become fashionable, and in all this inevitably rubbing off on clueless (Tom Delay, “Isn’t this kind of fun, boys?) Republicans. Consider right wing “we’re all in this just looking out for number 1” ideology sinking slowly in the West. All I’m saying is you can bray all you want to, but Bush has made you all look like elephant excrement even in the eyes of many staunch Republicans.