In my posting on gay marriage yesterday, a few commenters questioned the sincerity of my belief in gay marriage, saying that subsuming it to public opinion gave me an “easy out.” That’s a valid question, and one I believe deserves a sincere answer.
My position is often stated in idealism — support for democracy — but is rooted in the deepest pragmatism.
The issue of gay marriage came up in Massachusetts several years ago, when the case that ultimately brought it about began wending its way through the court system. Many at the time saw just what a huge issue it would become, and tried to get the state Constitution amended to address it. Time and again the legislature used its power to block such moves. Even when the Supreme Judicial Court formally told them to “crap or get off the pot,” they evaded the issue. Many observers at that time strongly suspected which way the Court was going to come down saw that as a clear warning, but it was still ignored.
So the Court issued its landmark decision, and gay marriage became legal in Massachusetts.
And as predicted, the opponents of gay marriage were incredibly energized. They had just been handed a huge defeat. Four judges, with the complicit help of a few leaders in the legislature, had forever changed the nature of marriage in the Bay State. The pro-gay-marriage side had managed to change the law with the assistance of less than two dozen people (I’d estimate).
This was a tremendous victory for their side (the side I support), but it’s also incredibly shaky. The way the change came about was by four judges interpreting the state Constitution, and several lawmakers in key positions preventing the other side from fighting back. And opposing them are the three other judges on the Supreme Judicial Court, along with a tremendous number of ordinary citizens.
Citizens also known as “taxpayers” and “voters.”
They’ve been fighting back, and their weapon of choice is the ultimate “big gun” in state politics — a Constitutional amendment. If they can push through such an amendment, the court’s ruling will be struck down and the justices rendered powerless to rule otherwise. This would be a huge defeat for gay marriage, as it would set back decades of progress and be almost impossible to overrule.
The process to amending Massachusetts’ Constitution is spelled out here, but let me give you the relevant parts: any amendment proposed by petition has to receive the approval of at least 25% of the legislature in two consecutive sessions. The sole defense the pro-gay-marriage side has is to keep it from getting that vote, or preventing a vote entirely. And that depends on them keeping a leash on the legislative leaders — people that can be voted out of office quite easily. And if the leaders themselves can’t be kicked out of office, then they can at least be defeated in their leadership roles.
The people who oppose gay marriage know this, and they’re acting. They’re lining up opponents for the leaders in their races, and they’re working to get other legislators elected as leaders within the House and Senate. If they’re successful, then that Amendment will pass, and gay marriage will be dead in Massachusetts for the foreseeable future.
At the same time, they keep electing governors who oppose gay marriage. And it’s the governor who nominates judges to the Supreme Judicial Court.
So yeah, I support the democratic principle here, out of idealism. But also out of sheer practicality — the way the system works, if enough people are sufficiently pissed off about the way gay marriage was instituted in Massachusetts, they have the means to kill it now and for a long time to come. All they need is the proper motivation — and they’ve got that in spades.



Let’s borrow Jay’s closing line so that we can apply such pragmatism to other civil rights examples….
if enough people are sufficiently pissed off about the way bans against interracial marriage were instituted in Arkansas, they have the means to kill it now and for a long time to come.
if enough people are sufficiently pissed off about the way segregation was instituted in Alabama, they have the means to kill it now and for a long time to come.
Since when was pragmatism any reasonable basis for ducking the moral challenge to provide equal rights under the law? What a fantastically convenient excuse to leave others at the back of the bus.
McCain: You examples are disgusting. Homosexual DOES NOT equal black.
Jay Tea: I am pro-traditional marriage but I must say that I respect your position. If the voters of my state approved gay “marriage” I would not go running to SCOTUS. Even though I would disagree and attempt to persuade the voters of their error, I would live with the decision. Unelected Judges are not kings!
Totally agree with your take, Jay.
I do think many on the left think everyone right of center who mentions proper process or ideals is just using it as an excuse.
Its not an excuse. It dangerous to allow the changing of contitutional definitions by activist courts.
It unleashes the powerful.
It’s tough to remain principled when what springs for you from that principled core is trampled by the process you uphold.
But I disagree with your “shaky” assessment, and I offer the humble example of Roe v. Wade.
We ned to put a curb on the power of these judges they are abusing the power of office its time to can a few especialy those put in by bill clinton
Lemmie see if I can figure this out. Millions of blacks were brutally enslaved and oppressed for hundreds of years. They were beaten, lynched, jailed, told they could not use “white” facilites, denied equal protection under the law, placed in poorly funded schools, and generally downtrodden until only a few decades ago. These people did not choose to be born black; it happened without their consent.
Homosexuals aren’t allowed to marry each other in almost every state. There is no solid scientific evidence suggesting that homosexuality is genetic (show me the “gay gene” and maybe I’ll change my statement, but until then…). Active homosexuality is a choice.
Some are stating that the black civil rights movement is equivalent to the pro-homosexual marriage movement.
Moral equivalence, anyone?
– Since the phrase “Gay Marriage” would seem to be at best, a rather strange conjugation, owing to the norms of the long standing definition of marraige, what is so wrong with the words “civil union”. Since the real purpose of all this public caterwalling, and intense effort to press for legal standing, has a great deal more to do with government doles and money/property rights than any real issues of morality ect., why not just set up a category for all other unions aside from hetero, and be done with it. That way if an Uncle wants to marry His niece, all the hassle and child protection laws will be safely skirted, and we could all be proud of our Democratic values, albeit taken to an insane extreme, just to mollycuddle a tiny vociferous minority. Jefferson would be proud….
Equal protection under the law is not an absolute. The military draft is a good example. At times in our history some citizens were compelled into military service while others were left to enjoy the benefits of American life, all based on a person’s age and gender. Equal protection under the law is established in the state and federal constitutions, and as such, is subject to change through the lawful process of amending these constitutions. There’s nothing unconstitutional about a new amendment limiting the scope of an exiting amendment or even repealing an existing amendment. Case in point is Prohibition established by the 18th amendment and repealed by the 21st amendment. The right of the people to amend the constitution is the most fundamental right of our system of government. To do otherwise is to forever suffer the tyranny of past generations upon current and future generations. Let the people vote!
Well SilverBubble and a very disgusted Steven Kelso Jr:
They surely were born black but they CHOSE to marry white girls. That was illegal, don’t you know. And yes, that is equivalent to this issue, and obviously so. That is, assuming you stop avoiding the evidence that homosexuality is at least partly nature rather than nurture.
Marriage is conferred by society onto a couple. You can’t force the public to give its blessing on that union if it doesn’t want to. Otherwise you make it an empty blessing.
The underlying principle and basis for deep seated differences on this issue is rooted in the issue that the Holy Bible declares that homosexuality is an abomination to God, that homosexuality is abominable. No where else to my knowledge does God use that harshest of condemnation about anything, not even limiting His condemnation to sin, but deeming it abominable.
There IS no proven, biological basis that proves homosexuality as being an inate characteristic of or by any humam being, no more than there can be proven that bestiality or sexual abuse is “inate” as an individual characteristic. There IS information established to support that certain brain differences can and do produce an increased willingness to commit impulsive acts by way of decreased control over impulsivity, but that’s about it. Including homosexuality and other forms of sexual deviances as to behaviors in these considerations is understandable to most, while it’s refuted based upon opinion and opinion only by those who cannot — in their very own experience — control their need, compulsion, to engage in homosexual behavior (and to blur the lines even further as to what that itself is and how it’s manifested).
Thus, the earlier medical and socio-religious understanding that homosexuality represents disordered thinking — to quote Pope Benedict here — is substantiated within the scope of what’s proven biologically while the very recent trend to present homosexuality (and various permutations of that, including sexual contact with children, sexual relationships with a range of partners, and more) as “normal” is entirely based upon OPINION and driven by the opinion at that of those who are engaged in the behaviors.
People attempt to accommodate most others and in a free society, generally to be tolerant to a point of indifference as long as their own lives aren’t negatively taxed, impacted by the ‘freedoms’ of others, and when the accommodations reach a point of taxing those who accommodate, the flexibility approaches (if not reaches) a conclusion.
The entire concept of marriage has been and throughout human history has been a sanctified, if not “holy”, organization between two persons of the opposite sex inorder to enable an organized sexual relationship that protects the two involved, enables offspring and a family, and protects and defines various relationships for all involved. It’s a basis upon which civilization has been established and maintained.
Yes, problems with marriage as we’ve known it but it isn’t enough to abandon the concept, BUT, to move the concept from what’s sensible and familiar socially, sociologically, religiously and legally into some area of unfamiliarity — even into areas that includes problematic behaviors that most of society has protected against for a long, long time now and for good reasons — is violating to many the general organization of what and who our society is.
The entire accommodation — what’s “democratic,” what’s “a right” and who has what among those because of why — is just the lid. The container is all the rest.
A footnote here: more than eighty percent of sexual abuse inflicted upon children by Catholic so-called ‘priests’ (I don’t regard them as such, is my point here) has been committed by male homosexuals. In violation of their religious vows, in violation of the “rights” of other and vulnerable human beings, and in violatio of all that society, our civilization, holds dear. This speaks volumes as to the far higher than usual degree of impulsivity and compulsivity that those who call themselves homosexuals experience and who they target through their disordered process. To enable “marriage” for “gay people” is mere sanction to disordered processes, but it does not thereby make it “democratic” to accommodate. It just makes it rationalized.
My take on marriage is that it’s purpose is to create an optimal environment for children. That’s the State’s stake in it. Otherwise why not call any bonding of 2 or more people or people/animals marriage? Where does the line get drawn? Why should those groupings be illegal?
I personally believe in civil unions to protect the Business/Legal rights of 2 people to formalize a relationship, but calling it marriage is a little too much for me.
Just my $.02
Today marks our 28th anniversary. I was 100 pounds lighter and the hair was a few shades darker. But my love for my wife is 100 times more today than it was on Oct. 7, 1977.
You wanna explain to me how two dudes marrying — or two women — or a dude and his horse — or some Cletus and his sister marrying — how any of that crap has anything to do with our Marriage.
Bill Clinton signed the Defense of Marriage Act into law. The day I need Bill Clinton to defend my marriage is the day I lose my will to live.
But hey, knock yourselves out nosing into someone else’s personal life.
Let’s see how Silverbubble’s (and others’) argument would have gone before bans on interracial marriage were declared unconstitutional.
Blacks and whites aren’t allowed to marry each other in many states. There is no solid scientific evidence suggesting that relationships between blacks and whites are genetic (show me the “interracial gene” and maybe I’ll change my statement, but until then…). Interracial relationships are a choice.
People all have equal rights to marry, meaning they all have the right to marry a member of the opposite sex who is of the same race. If we allow different races to marry, what will stop men from marrying their daughters, or women from marrying dogs? Where will these rights stop?
—–
Allow me to quote the Supreme Court’s decision in Loving v. Virginia for all those who quibble about marriage being a “right”:
Marriage is one of the “basic civil rights of man,” fundamental to our very existence and survival…. To deny this fundamental freedom on so unsupportable a basis as the racial classifications embodied in these statutes, classifications so directly subversive of the principle of equality at the heart of the Fourteenth Amendment, is surely to deprive all the State’s citizens of liberty without due process of law. The Fourteenth Amendment requires that the freedom of choice to marry not be restricted by invidious racial discriminations. Under our Constitution, the freedom to marry, or not marry, a person of another race resides with the individual and cannot be infringed by the State.
Some of you may wish to argue with Justice Warren that marriage is not a right, but something tells me you would be a little out of your league.
Suzy, you make a fine argument for keeping gay marriage out of your church. What exactly does that have to do with the state?
Wait, when did I say a damned thing about interracial marriages?
Don’t put words in my mouth.
In 1996, President Clinton signed the Defense of Marriage Act, which defines marriage to be a “legal union between one man and one woman.” Many other political leaders, Republicans and Democrats alike, have aligned themselves with both Presidents Bush and Clinton.
Defense of Marriage Act. Why hasn’t the SCOTUS struck this law down?
– mantis. This whole gay issue is just a pile of polemic bullshit. Just another thread in the relentless ongoing effort to normalize abberent behavior among a small minority so they can feel “good” about themselves, and the typical kind of “cause” the left is constantly trying to align itself with in order to add to its voter base. Why not just openly advertise that “Any one person, or group of people out there, with any sort of “cause”, no matter how off the wall or full of agenda, just align with us and we’ll back you in exchange for your vote….”… at least that would be honest and fit the reality of things….
– The problem is sport, when braindead moonbats like code pinko stands out in public and openly defiles our military men and women for defending their country in a cause they believe in…. When mother Sheehan calls our comander in chief a muderer…. When Scream Dean and Killer Kennedy go on national television and pander to the anti-American rabble…. When leftist MSM cartoonists publish openly racist/bigoted rot, unlike anything seen since the hard days of slavery…. When these things happen then its clear you don’t really care about a damn thing besides finding some way, any way, back to power…..and the reason you can’t get away with it anymore is precisely the medium you’re righting this garbage of yours in right at this moment…. just no place to hide anymore….
– “writing” not “righting” – PIMF
BBH,
Care to give a substantive rebuttal to what I actually wrote, or would you rather continue blaming me for Code Pink, Howard Dean, Ted Kennedy, cartoonists, and Cindy Sheehan (none of whom have I voted for, spoken to, or been in any other way related with)? Tell me why you think what I’m writing is “garbage”, instead of pushing some guilt by association angle, especially since there is no association.
While you’re at it answer this question: how am I trying to get in power, let alone “back to power”? The only power I hold or desire to hold is my voice, in the form of a vote. If you think the internet is going to take that away from me, well, keep barkin’ moonie.
Some of you seem to think gay marriage is not a civil rights issue because you claim homosexuality is not immutable like color or race. For a few reasons, I don’t think that argument hold up.
I don’t know whether homosexuality is immutable or not. I don’t know the science, and I doubt the state of today’s science knows the answer. But, I would think if a gay person could choose to be straight, then a straight person could choose to be sexually attracted to the same sex. I, for one, could not make that choice no matter how hard I tried. I do, however, believe the testimony of gays who have converted.
Now race is clearly immutable (with the exception of Michael jackson). Perhaps the racial civil rights examples are not a perfect analogy, since some people claim to have converted.
So, what’s a better analogy? How about religion? We know it’s protected by the equal protection clause. We know that people convert to and from Catholicism, Islam and Judaism evey day. Then, there are the “born again Christians.” We can’t discriminate based on any of those personal choices. It seems to me, swaping religions is much easier than swaping sexual preferences. Why not afford sexual orientation the same protections?
Of course, if anyone followed my posts on a sister thread yesterday, I remain bewildered why and how anyone could rationally deprive homosexuals of the ability to enjoy the same legal status as heterosexuals.
It seems like lots of people are missing an important point. The political move in Massachusetts is to pass a definition of marriage amendment to the state constitution. My point is that a legally passed amendment cannot be ruled unconstitutional without infringing on the more fundamental right of the people to amend the constitution. Yes, I understand the and the U.S. Supreme court could rule a state amendment as unconstitutional under the federal constitution, but that’s not what Jay’s piece is about. besides, an amendment to the Federal constitution could not be ruled unconstitutional by the U.S. Supreme court for the same reason. In that light the passage attributed to Justice Warren is irrelevant. Also, the state already regulates marriage in ways that would seem to be at odds with Justice Warren’s writing. If you don’t think so, try marrying your sibling.
Mark, I know you left the sister thread from yesterday before I ask this question: Where does it say a person’s motivation must be rational? As a Christian some would say that my entire belief structure is irrational, but are religious people excluded from voting and petitioning the government based on their beliefs? Not if you want to vote and petition the government based on your beliefs!
-S- said:
” No where else to my knowledge does God use that harshest of condemnation about anything…”
Actually abominations are common in Leviticus. Eating anything of the sea without scales is an abomination, as is mixing fabric in your clothes. I sometimes point out to Southern Baptists that if they eat shrimp and catfish while wearing a cotton/poly blend they may as well be sucking a….well we will leave the rest unsaid.^^
-S-
“The underlying principle and basis for deep seated differences on this issue is rooted in the issue that the Holy Bible declares that homosexuality is an abomination to God, that homosexuality is abominable. No where else to my knowledge does God use that harshest of condemnation about anything, not even limiting His condemnation to sin, but deeming it abominable.”
So, please let me know if I understand your position correctly. Are you saying a valid purpose of our government, whether state or federal, is to impose your Holy Bible on everyone, regardless of their religious beliefs? Hindus, Jews, Muslims, Pagans, athiests, agnostics. The government is to coerse everyone to conduct their lives precisely in accordance with the Holy Bible? Really?
I sincerely hope that’s not what you believe. If so, you are very very far out of touch with our Constitution, and all reasonable principles of government.
Mac Lorry,
It doesn’t. What I really meant, but didn’t quite say, is what rational STATE interest is there? I don’t expect people to be rational. I do expect state actions to be rational.
The system of checks and balances are designed to ensure the governement behaves rationally and fairly. Hopefully one of the three branches of government will keep the populous in check when they collectively decide to act irrationally.
Mark,
The phrase you used “…keep the populous in check when they collectively decide to act irrationally” is counter to the ideals of democracy. If the vast majority of people want to alter the constitution it’s their right to do so under that vary constitution. I submit that either the 18th or the 21st amendments to the U.S. constitution are irrational, being that one establishes Prohibition and the other repeals it. If PETA folks were in the vast majority, wouldn’t it be their right to amend the constitution to prohibit eating meat? What about smoking and drug laws? It seems legislators can rationalize any position, so who decides what’s irrational? The solution is to let the people vote.
To me this whole mess seems more like the government breaking into your house and putting a clock on the wall that you don’t want. You might want a clock, you might even buy this same sort of clock if you saw it in the store and HAD YOUR OWN FREE CHOICE to buy it or not.
But you didn’t have the chance to buy it, or the choice – it got shoved down your throat. I can sure understand why there’d be a LOT of folks pissed about that – I would be myself, and after what they pulled I wouldn’t be too eager to vote ‘yes’ in a referendum.
As far as it goes, I’m for gay marriage, personally – as long as it’s treated EXACTLY the same as conventional marriage. You want to get married? Fine by me. You want to split up? Then it’s divorce time – most likely a ‘no contest’ divorce. Just observe the legalities – that’s all I want to see.
And that doesn’t include legal activist judges shoving what THEY think is a good idea into law.
J.
Whoa!
Alot more homophobes here today than yesterday.
Good job, Jay!
But really he’s not saying anything different than his other posts on the subject, is he? Nothing new here, move along. We’re shrouding our hate under the guise of rationalizing laws barring certain civil rights to a class of people.
I’ll give Jay a modicum of credit for continuing to insist he’s for gay marriage. Bully.
Anytime I hear the terms Leviticus and abomination thrown around to dignify bigotry, I’m reminded of an exchange on West Wing:
President Bartlet (Martin Sheen): I like how you call homosexuality an abombination.
Jenna Jacobs: I don’t say homosexuality is an abomination, Mr. President, the Bible does.
President Bartlet: Yes, it does. Leviticus.
Jenna Jacobs: 18:22.
President Bartlet: Chapter and verse. I wanted to ask you a couple of questions while I have you here. I’m interested in selling my youngest daughter into slavery as sanctioned in Exodus 21:7. She’s a Georgetown sophmore, speaks fluent Italian, always cleared the table when it was her turn. What would a good price for her be? While thinking about that, can I ask another? My Chief of Staff Leo McGarry insists on working on the Sabbath. Exodus 35:2 clearly says he should be put to death. Am I morally obligated to kill him myself or is it okay to call the police? Here’s one that’s really important because we’ve got a lot of sports fans in this town: touching the skin of a dead pig makes one unclean. Leviticus 11:7. If they promise to wear gloves, can the Washington Redskins still play football? Can Notre Dame? Can West Point? Does the whole town really have to be together to stone my brother John for planting different crops side by side? Can I burn my mother in a small family gathering for wearing garments made from two different threads? “Think about that, will you?
Mac L.
The ideals of democracy are just that; ideals. That’s why this is a republic and not a true democracy.
If the people want to amend the constitution, they may. However, their abiltiy is strictly curtailed and a simple majority won’t get the job done–nor should it. An additional check over state constitutions is the US Constitution. It’s hard to get the job done, but you’re right; it is possible.
Now tell me your honest opinion. Would you want PETA gaining sufficient control that they could deprive you of eating all forms of animal products? Including fish and milk and cheese? I was a strict vegitarian for about 15 years while I ran more miles and marathons than sane people should (perceived health reasons, not religious or philosophical). But even at my most fanatic, I would have strongly opposed efforts to prevent others from eating meat. Wouldn’t you?
The analogy that everyone loves to deny is racism or sexism. For a long period of US history, the majority approved of slavery. Does that make it ok? Same with women’s rights. Should the majority always get their way? Be honest. No.
You admitted that not all your feelings or actions are rational. All people have irrational moments. We know how groups can be worked up into irrational lathers to the point where there is no more accountability. Look at riots, looting, lynchings, etc. Look how the morons at Daily Kos, Atrios, and the DU work themselves into a froth over ridiculous shit. We can’t trust our government to mob rule. Absolutely not. Do you disagree with this?
Dude, disagreement doesn’t equal homophobia. I don’t particularly care if it’s passed or not, and if it’s forced upon me I’ll back folks who’ll fight that legislation. If it’s put to a vote, I’ll likely vote for it – because I don’t see any real reason NOT to have it. If it passes, fine. If it doesn’t – again, fine. The people will have spoken, better luck next time.
But I want to have a CHOICE, not have it imposed by legislative fiat.
If raging advocacy is the only thing that doesn’t equal homophobia in your eyes, then I feel pretty sorry for you. If you define a person only by what their sexual orientation is, then you’re a bigot, no matter how you try to sugar coat it in acceptable PC flavors. (And using character dialog from a TV show to justify yourself? Wow.)
On preview: Mark – you’ve captured it. The minority shouldn’t be allowed to control the majority. A consensus is one thing, a dictatorship of the minority is something else.
J.
JLawson:
“And that doesn’t include legal activist judges shoving what THEY think is a good idea into law.”
Soooo, by that would you be refering to the SCOTUS examining the constitutionality of a state’s marriage requirements? Because if that is what you consider activism, then you are condemning about 95 percent of what the Court does.
JLawson,
You missed something vital. Mac Lorry was suggesting that if PETA held a MAJORITY, that they should be able to ban meat for us all. I disagreed with that.
You also said this:
“Dude, disagreement doesn’t equal homophobia. I don’t particularly care if it’s passed or not, and if it’s forced upon me I’ll back folks who’ll fight that legislation.”
You’re right. But if you read many of the posts above, some smack of blatant homophobia. Not yours, but others.
Wait, when did I say a damned thing about interracial marriages?
You didn’t. It just so happens that this SSM-equals-interracial-marriage trope is the one they think can win this argument for them.
Don’t put words in my mouth.
But they have to — otherwise they can’t push the SSM-equals-interracial-marriage trope in hopes of redefining the issue and trying to shame the other side into silence.
Indeed, let’s just ignore the real arguments because you have no rebuttal. Our grandchildren will read about the George Wallace’s of 2005. I do grant that it is human nature to elevate oneself above some boogeyman class of people. Always has been the case. We’ll keep the blacks down, the chicks down, the jews down, the gays down, whatever. However, the individual is soverign in the final analysis. The inevitable progress of more and more freedom for individuals will eventually settle this issue correctly.
What really boggles my mind is this:
What does even the most dogmatic “Christian” anti-gay homophobe lose if homosexuals are allowed an equal set of legal presumptions, rights, and benefits that straight people receive?
What is that threat? How in the world would they even discern between a contemporary gay relationship, and one that has been anointed by “marriage?” How would the change affect the daily lives of straight people? What is the loss? Please tell me! Really, the burden is on YOU to retain the status quo of disparate treatment.
Ok, you’ll argue everyone is treated equally to the right to marry the oposite sex. The more valid description is the “ability to marry the person you love.”
Mark,
I understand your argument and no, I wouldn’t like it if PETA was able to pass a constitutional ban on eating meat. Then again, lots of folks didn’t like the ban on alcohol the 18th amendment established, but it was a fact of life in this country until passage of the 21st amendment. My point is that a super majority has the right to amend the constitution in any way it sees fit and marriage amendments have already passed in 11 plus states. Jay’s piece is about just that, the people of Massachusetts working to define marriage through an amendment to their state’s constitution. As such, arguments about what is or isn’t rational are irrelevant. People are entitled to vote their own beliefs even if they come right out of the Bible, and if enough people vote for such an amendment, there’s no authority within the state of Massachusetts that can override that decision.
I think Jay was alluding to the fact that it might have been better for Gays to make their case to the voters, where a simple majority could change the marriage statutes, rather than go through the courts and incur the wrath of voters in the form of a constitutional amendment that will take a similar super majority to overturn. I have always claimed that the voters will decide the issue of gay marriage, not the courts. Interference in the political process by the courts only hastens the decision by voters, but in a way the courts don’t like; by taking it out of their hands.
Mac Lorry,
I hear ya, and generally I agree. But I also agree with some valid exceptions to your sentiments.
I’m curious about this one thing. Please don’t flame me for comparing sexual orientation with color, but I think it makes for a valid, if limited, analogy.
Do you disagree with the Court’s decision in Plessy v. Ferguson which made blacks seperate but equal? I’m not talking about the flaws with the decison compared to later decisions, but I’m talking about the Court’s improvement of black’s rights. Also, do you disagree with Brown v. Board of Education, which finally put blacks on an equal footing? Was it wrong of the Court to do that? Have you read the decisions?
If you support either of those decisions, then you must support the role of the court to uphold the constitution. You must support it’s role in protecting the minority from the tyranny of the majority, at least in some limited scenarios.
Are we together so far? If so, then I need to be clued in to the difference between Brown, and a future case involving gays. I understand the argument that gayness might be voluntary rather than an immutable characteristic–and I can deal with that. But what I’d like to know is, is there more?
Mark never did address this in a previous post, so imma be lazy and cut and paste it here. Not trying to flame you either, just want to hear your 2 cents.
Mark said:
“I was hoping to hear some solid state interests in prohibiting gay marriage…”
Couple of issues, gay marriage is not necessarily prohibited by the state. There are people who will marry gay people in this country, and no one gets arrested, it is just not recognised by the state. Not recognising something is different than prohibiting it. Secondly, the state is the people, theoritically at least, so how the community views it is the issue here.
It seems increasingly to me what we have is a clash between the traditional view of marriage and the modern world. The concept of marriage into pre-history has been a man and a woman, founding a new entity greater than themselves: the family. That is what the word marriage has come to symbolise: two different things forming a union greater than the sum of the parts. A marriage of chocolate and peanut butter, for instance. No ad man worth his salt would propose a marriage of chocolate and chocolate.
But now marriage has increasingly become a legal entity, more concerned with benefits and tax advantages than children and families, and traditional society is upset. Traditional society is the “state” in this country, and I would repeat my asserstion that the problem I have with the idea is you are forcing society, or the state, to recognise a concept they are not ready for yet. I think a civil union compromise is the civil solution.
B Moe:
“Not recognising something is different than prohibiting it.”
Maybe “prohibition” is the wrong word, and I suppose you’re right if you attach meaning to marriage beyond the legal benefits awarded by the state. I tend to look to religion or other spiritual sources, or just the relationship itself, to give marriage it’s true meaning, and I look to the state only for legal benefits.
I think the kernal of injustice is that same sex unions or marriages are deprived of the same set of legal benefits afforded to opposite sex unions. That failure to recognize is the key issue, and to me it is tantamount to prohibition. Semantics aside, do you disagree with me so far?
You’re right in that the state is the people. But the states confer legal benefits to people all the time without scrutiny or active participation of the people. The populous does not micro manage all the little things the government does. Why should they micro manage the little benefits attendent to marriage?
I was like you in thinking “civil union” would be adequate. After all, it serves all the purposes I look to states to fulfill in the context of marriage. But then I started thinking about the problems with “seperate but equal” from Plessy v. Ferguson. While I don’t foresee gay civil unions being forced to the back of the bus, I suppose the semantics of “civil union” and “marriage” could matter to some people (not me). Why not give them equal titles? What do straight people have to lose?
Put aside the arguments against judical activism and in favor of popular vote. Put aside the arguments about whether homosexuality is a choice or something innate. Put aside the view that everyone is treated equal because both gays and straights are equally excluded from state recognition of same sex marriages. put aside the arguments that homosexuality is a sin. Gimme this one answer:
How does the legal relationship of strangers affect you? How does it affect your marriage? How does it affect your livlihood? How does it affect any part of your well being? How would you even know?
A little background. There are two brands of homosexuals. There are some who have “sampled” both sexes, and for whatever reason simply prefer their own. There are others who have a psychological block towards intimacy with the opposite sex. The former is content to live and let live, having made a reasoned decision. The latter is an activist.
That said . . .
First, the government has no business recognizing a minority of choice.
Second, without the onslaught of moral relativism, homosexuals would still be able to receive counseling for their disorder, and overcome the problems associated with the self-loathing present within the “gay” community. As it is currently, none dare call it a “problem.”
Third, to those who wish to equate gay activism to the Civil Rights movement, how much support have you gotten from blacks in that equivocation? Just curious.
Fourth, and the point most central to my philosophy regarding this issue, the government has no business prying into people’s personal lives, legislating what a person can or cannot do in the bedroom. Conversely, however, a person has no business spreading the activities of their bedroom into the public eye. In a society with even a shred of modesty, that’s the way that people of all sexual persuasions would behave.
“Conversely, however, a person has no business spreading the activities of their bedroom into the public eye. In a society with even a shred of modesty, that’s the way that people of all sexual persuasions would behave.”
So are you arguing for a ban of state-recognized hetereosexual marriage. If not, how is your statement relevant to homosexual marriage?
Mark asked:
“How does the legal relationship of strangers affect you? How does it affect your marriage? How does it affect your livlihood? How does it affect any part of your well being? How would you even know?”
It doesn’t, and that is why I don’t care. I don’t understand why polygamy is illegal for that matter, as long as all the parties involved are consenting.
But I do understand the problem some people have with redefining a word and a concept that possibly predates government. Why do so many gays balk at the compromise of civil unions and insist it be called a wedding and a marriage? I think it is because of the implicit acceptance of the “tribe” if you will that the words bring. And while my heart may ache for them, you cannot legislate acceptance by people that aren’t ready for it yet. I fear instead it will cause a backlash of resentment that could set the movement back decades.
BoDiddly:
“First, the government has no business recognizing a minority of choice.”
Of course they do, and they do it all the time. Are there disparate laws for people whose favorite color is blue instead of purple? For people whose favorite music is rock instead of polkas? No. People are afforded equal protection under the laws unless there is a rational relationship between the disparate treatment and a legitimate government interest. That is the law. That is the Fourteenth Amendment. That, with few exceptions, is the world we’ve been living in for centuries.
So now sift through all the nice stuff you said, and direct me to the part where you expain what interest the state has in recognizing one form of relationship, and not the other. Because that is the key to this entire dilemma.
People have been spewing walls of text for two days here, and only 2 or 3 have honestly attempted to answer that one crucial question–and even they disagreed with the rationale they proffered. So what is it?
It’s been two days now, and I can only conclude that the anti-gay marriage group is unable to articulate a legitimate state interest in declining to recognize the relationships. Prove me wrong.
Hmmm.
Regardless of this rather bizzare online version of Sunday school, I’m opposed to gay marriage because I’m tired of people abusing the judicial system to force their views on me.
They want to change America? Fine. Then do it the right way. The long term way. Through voters.
What judges can give, they can take away.
B Moe:
With regard to your last paragraph, I don’t know. I have not heard any criticisms of “civil union” or arguments for “marriage.” As I said yesterday, I haven’t really followed the movement.
However, I can only speculate that they want to avoid the stigma of being “separate but equal,” and they feel entitled to the full enchilada. I could be entirely missing the boat here. However, it seems reasonable to label identical sets of legal benefits, with the same name. Where’s the harm in that?
Hey, ed:
“Regardless of this rather bizzare online version of Sunday school, I’m opposed to gay marriage because I’m tired of people abusing the judicial system to force their views on me.”
The thread through my questions is this: What is being forced on you?
Like it or not, gay relationships exist. You might think they’re perverted, or deranged, or sick or sinful or whatever, but they exist. Maybe you resent queens flaunting it in your face, maybe they should keep it in their bedroom, whatever. But that situation exists and it’s not going away as a result of any government or judicial activities. Accept that as a given, for a second.
Do you think an additional burden is forced on you, or that something is taken away, if those pre-existing homosexuals are afforded the same ability to confer the same benefits to their loved ones as straight people?
I’m asking because I am genuinely curious. Deep down, honestly, do you think you lose something if the state recognized gay marriages? I’m not saying you’re wrong, I merely want to know what you think.
With regard to judges taking away what they giveth–that can be said about any body, right? Laws are passed and repealed. Constitutional amendments (prohibition) with through the same. Is there a difference?
Wow, I really need to proof read before I post. Typing hastily in little blue boxes, without proof reading, leads to pretty bizarre dropped words and grammer. Sorry.
Mark: The thread through my questions is this: What is being forced on you?
Seriously?
What I think people miss is that, to a large extent, this is about the percieved purpose of the law as the definition of morality, right and wrong. Now, not everyone calls it morality, but it’s common. Certainly common on the left, as anything “good” ought to be compelled and anything “bad” ought to be prohibited. School is good, so we make laws compelling attendance. Drugs are bad, so we make them illegal. Charity is good, so we make it a function of the State.
What many conservatives don’t realize is that they are, just as much as liberals, prone to a Statist, paternalist, attitude. It may not be conscious on their part, but gay marriage is seen as something being forced on them because they have accepted, as definitions of right and wrong, legal and illegal.
When I was in the military overseas I realized to what extent law is a prop for virtue. There is no need for virtue when the law defines your behavior. What is different about overseas is that many of the laws don’t exist. Some people are virtuous without law. Other people, many people, are not.
For a whole lot of people “conform not to the world” is answered by doing their darndest to make sure that the world is following the right rules so that they do not have to find virtue or strength to stand in non-conformity. This is true of the right *and* the left, only for different things.
Mark:
Gay marriage isn’t about pre-existing homosexuals being “afforded the same ability to confer the same benefits to their loved ones as straight people.” If it was, then civil unions would solve the problem. This is about a vocal, radicalized, minority-within-a-minority demanding approval and acceptance, rather than tolerance, of a lifestyle that most people find “perverted, or deranged, or sick or sinful or whatever.” And using judicial fiat and the already battered civil and religious institution of marriage to do it. That’s what has so many people up in arms.
Btw, the state does indeed have a compelling interest in defining marriage as a union between heterosexual men and women. It’s called propagation of the species. And while no-fault divorce and the “who needs a piece of paper if you love each other” crowd may have weakened that argument, it is still there. Otherwise, why not allow poligamy, incestuous marriages, and and bestiality?