In my posting on gay marriage yesterday, a few commenters questioned the sincerity of my belief in gay marriage, saying that subsuming it to public opinion gave me an “easy out.” That’s a valid question, and one I believe deserves a sincere answer.
My position is often stated in idealism — support for democracy — but is rooted in the deepest pragmatism.
The issue of gay marriage came up in Massachusetts several years ago, when the case that ultimately brought it about began wending its way through the court system. Many at the time saw just what a huge issue it would become, and tried to get the state Constitution amended to address it. Time and again the legislature used its power to block such moves. Even when the Supreme Judicial Court formally told them to “crap or get off the pot,” they evaded the issue. Many observers at that time strongly suspected which way the Court was going to come down saw that as a clear warning, but it was still ignored.
So the Court issued its landmark decision, and gay marriage became legal in Massachusetts.
And as predicted, the opponents of gay marriage were incredibly energized. They had just been handed a huge defeat. Four judges, with the complicit help of a few leaders in the legislature, had forever changed the nature of marriage in the Bay State. The pro-gay-marriage side had managed to change the law with the assistance of less than two dozen people (I’d estimate).
This was a tremendous victory for their side (the side I support), but it’s also incredibly shaky. The way the change came about was by four judges interpreting the state Constitution, and several lawmakers in key positions preventing the other side from fighting back. And opposing them are the three other judges on the Supreme Judicial Court, along with a tremendous number of ordinary citizens.
Citizens also known as “taxpayers” and “voters.”
They’ve been fighting back, and their weapon of choice is the ultimate “big gun” in state politics — a Constitutional amendment. If they can push through such an amendment, the court’s ruling will be struck down and the justices rendered powerless to rule otherwise. This would be a huge defeat for gay marriage, as it would set back decades of progress and be almost impossible to overrule.
The process to amending Massachusetts’ Constitution is spelled out here, but let me give you the relevant parts: any amendment proposed by petition has to receive the approval of at least 25% of the legislature in two consecutive sessions. The sole defense the pro-gay-marriage side has is to keep it from getting that vote, or preventing a vote entirely. And that depends on them keeping a leash on the legislative leaders — people that can be voted out of office quite easily. And if the leaders themselves can’t be kicked out of office, then they can at least be defeated in their leadership roles.
The people who oppose gay marriage know this, and they’re acting. They’re lining up opponents for the leaders in their races, and they’re working to get other legislators elected as leaders within the House and Senate. If they’re successful, then that Amendment will pass, and gay marriage will be dead in Massachusetts for the foreseeable future.
At the same time, they keep electing governors who oppose gay marriage. And it’s the governor who nominates judges to the Supreme Judicial Court.
So yeah, I support the democratic principle here, out of idealism. But also out of sheer practicality — the way the system works, if enough people are sufficiently pissed off about the way gay marriage was instituted in Massachusetts, they have the means to kill it now and for a long time to come. All they need is the proper motivation — and they’ve got that in spades.


The states interest in marrage is to insure that the terms of the contract is carried out. Propagation of the species not constitionally the perogative of the state. This leaves the state the same right to regulate who may or may not freely enter into a contract…why do two adults need the states permission to do this? Call it civil union contract if done for all parties(gay and sraight) and reserve marriage for whatever church you have it blessed by.
fatman,
Gay marriage isn’t about pre-existing homosexuals being “afforded the same ability to confer the same benefits to their loved ones as straight people.” If it was, then civil unions would solve the problem.
Please list the states that have introduced legislation instituting civil unions for homosexual couples. How many are there? How many votes have such bills received? Have they solved the problem? Activists in this regard pursue their cause through the courts because we already have marriage, it doesn’t need to be constructed as civil unions would, and haven’t. They don’t exist. Btw propogation of the species is not the reason that we have civil marriages, otherwise how do couples unwilling or unable to bear children get married?
Mark,
I do agree with the court decisions that gave equal protection to all races. In fact it matches my Christian beliefs. I understand the claim that if sexual orientation is an immutable in-born trait, then it should be treated the same as race. I know you reject the counter claim that it already is treated the same in that homosexuals can marry someone of the opposite sex just like heterosexual can. In fact, many gays have done so and raised families, and in doing so, received a form of fulfillment they would never have experienced had the state embraced their desires.
Currently marriage is based on two fundamental principles, procreation biology and equality of the partners. The state grants special rights to procretion couples in return for future good citizens, without which society as we know it would collapse. Love between partners is irrelevant to that purpose. Not all heterosexual couples can procreate, but the state deals with people by type rather then as individuals. For example, someone of the type “65 or older” receives an extra exemption on their tax return regardless of their income or financial status. Further proof that marriage laws are instated for the purpose of procreating future generations of good citizens is demonstrated by the prohibition of marriage between close relatives of the opposite sex. Not all heterosexual couples can marry the person they love.
When you consider tax, pension and property laws, marriage is an expensive grant to individuals by the state. By type, homosexual unions serve no purpose in providing the state with future generations of good citizens. Given limited resources, the state has a compelling interest in restricting marriage to procreation couples.
None of these arguments are really relevant to what’s happening in Massachusetts as it’s now a political contest for votes. Some will vote for a marriage amendment based on their religious beliefs, while others will do so because they don’t like the way a vary small minority has circumvented the normal political process, or how gays have mistreated the Boy Scouts, or how they organize resistance to military recruiters on college campuses, or how they parade through the streets of cities like San Francisco. It’s these negative images that have formed super majorities in many other states and may do so again in Massachusetts.
Hmmmm.
@ Mark
“The thread through my questions is this: What is being forced on you?”
When people go to the state and federal Supreme Courts and other judicial jurisdictions to enact laws based on court rulings *instead* of going through the legislature, then that is by definition imposing their views on me.
It doesn’t matter one whit what those views are.
If people want laws enacted, then they should go through the various legislatures.
If people want attitudes changes, then they should go through the effort to changes people’s minds.
And I’ll note that this viewpoint is completely consistent with my other views on the US Constitution, the Supreme Court and judicial activism.
…
Frankly for a long time I was either ambivalent about gay marriage or in favor of it. Since I’m a hetero it really doesn’t mean much to me personally as I’m not offended at public displays of affection by people. Hell if people can kiss their dogs in public, why should’nt two loving people kiss in public? Why shouldn’t they get married and then have the wonderful opportunity to go through divorce court.
But then gays started manipulating the courts and thats when my mind changed. And, as of this moment, I am implacably against gay marriage and would sign onto any effort to amend the Constitution to ban it. Judicial activism cannot, must not, be rewarded in any way, shape or form.
This is a danger gay activists should be aware of in their quest to manipulate the American public. The enemies they make are not inconsequential and have a far reaching effect.
Hmmm.
“With regard to judges taking away what they giveth–that can be said about any body, right? Laws are passed and repealed. Constitutional amendments (prohibition) with through the same. Is there a difference?”
Laws are rarely repealed and are generally superceded by new laws. But in doing so there is an opportunity for public debate and consideration within the both the public and the legislature. With the passing of laws the public has someone to hold to account, those legislators that voted for the new laws.
In the case of judicial activism the ruling comes with little public input and very little warning. And the effect of these rulings take place immediately. Look at Kelo. It hasn’t been a single month since the ruling and look at how many stories there are about public takings.
And I remind you that federal judges must be impeached to be removed from the bench. Little things like making bizzare, crazy and irresponsible rulings aren’t generally enough. It requires actual breaking of the law to justify removing them.
New York City spends over $1 billion dollars per year to house homeless people. This wasn’t due to a state law. This wasn’t due to a city law. This wasn’t due to any law at all. It was due to the ruling of a judge.
And so every single year, year in and year out, the citizens of New York have to pony up massive amounts of money to house homeless people because a federal judge thinks it should be so, and because it probably makes her feel better about herself.
Abuse of the judiciary, by ANYONE and for ANY reason cannot be rewarded. Additionally judges that are complict in such activities must be removed from the bench.
And, in an alternate vein, this is also one of the reasons why I am so absolutely pissed off at Bush and the GOP.
What an exhuasting exercise.
A big argument has been about gays manipulating other peoples lives through the court system.
I wonder how many of the people who value a non-activist court, tried to stop those activizt judges and cops when gays were getting beat up all the time?
Maybe gays are getting in the face of society…the same society that marginalized them and didn’t apply the rules equally. Not about marriage…about jobs and school and housing.
Things change and they take time but that doesn’t mean that the conscience of our nation is clean.
Yes, the majority of the people who founded this nation were christians. But after witnessing the destructive force of sectarian violence for centuries they tried to create a nation that went beyond the views of the bible.
They weren’t entirely successful though, as I do remember something about some people being counted as 3/5ths of a person.
Mark, I know it was purely intentional, as I feel a person of your intelligence must make a conscious decision to avoid the intent of my statement.
“Recognition of a minority” by the state is wholly different than providing “equal protection under the law.” You know that, but you avoid the point. It was, I concede, an artful dodge to the issue. A minority, entitled to specific protections because of minority status, cannot be defined by behaviour alone. Some factor, beyond the control of the individual, must exist. Consider whether I could apply for handicapped benefits because I choose to sit in a wheelchair.
Mark, I’ll appeal to your knowedge of the law in posing a slightly different question than the one you propose. What was the original intent of those men who established marriage as an institution recognized by the state, and of those who, through the years, have penned and legislated laws that give preference to married couples in areas of privacy, inheritance, adoption, and taxation? Was the purpose of those laws directed towards state recognition of a romantic bond, or towards fostering a more favorable environment for the traditional family to exist and thrive? What interest of the state was served by its recognition of heterosexual marriage?
In that light, what interest of the state would be served by extending this privilege to homosexual unions?
Good points Bo, one could go further with what are the benefits to the state of recognising any marriage based on “romantic love” rather than procreation and stability. Historically the notion of romantic love having anything to do with marriage is a very recent development.
Hah!
Finally people are beginning to talk about legitimate state interests, and BoDiddly hit the nail pretty squarely on the head (as did a few others). After two or three days of this, It seemed all I would get would be more “gays are icky” or “gays are sinful” or “I’m for gay marriage as long as everyone else backs me up.”
Say what you want about judicial activism (I detest it, personally). But if you people didn’t start articulating some state interests, then the SCOTUS would likely have been REQUIRED to strike down state marriage laws, if such a case came before them. (Ok, I’m glossing over the definable class aspect here, and I will continue to for a moment). If the Court were faced with state laws that treat two different groups differently, and if no state justification were offered, then the Constitution requires this result. That is far from activism; that is exactly what the Court was created to do.
The opportunities for activism arise in 1) defining and recognizing a class, and 2) weighing the legitimacy of the state interests. Until this morning, this thread of comments offered nothing to weigh so the Court’s hands would have been tied.
Yes, there is still the huge question of whether a legitimate class exists. As many of you have already said, that will, in part, be determined based on whether homosexuality is simply a matter of choice or something less voluntary. I dont know the science, but I am aware several of you do think you have this answer. I’m skeptical. Personally, I think I could craft a better argument in favor of the class than against it, but I’m not inclined to spend the time to do the research and noodle this any longer. After all, this issue doesn’t affect me personally, so I’ll let those who truly care do the work.
BoDiddly, your last two paragraphs raise all the good questions, and they culminate with this:
“In that light, what interest of the state would be served by extending this privilege to homosexual unions”
The Court would not address that question as it stands. It needs to be converted into “what interests of the state would be served by NOT extending the privilege…” You raised several good reasons for states to recognize marriage, but you didn’t specifically address reasons why they should NOT recognize gay marriage, except to say one element of marriage, procreation, is absent with gays. I’d like to hear how you’d restate that paragraph with that emphasis.
Finally, is procreation really the best state interest here? In the days of in vitro fertilization and adoption and overpopulation? And, isn’t a family unit headed by two people of the same sex equally entitled to the same protections of the state? After all, many homosexuals have their own kids from natural birth, adoption, or whatever. Isn’t it about protecting the kids?
Gotta add one more thing before real life intervenes:
I’m a divorced father of two. For four years I’ve been “living in sin” with my fiance, who is a divorced mother of two.
My fiance changed jobs about 18 months ago, and we were looking at her insurance options with an eye toward insuring each other and our kids. You probably already know what we discovered, but we were taken by surprise this at the time:
In California, unmarried domestic partners of the same sex qualify for insurance. However, unmarried domestic partners of the oposite sex do not. Are the straight being discriminated against? I guess my situation can be cured by tying the knot, but the same cannot be said about homosexual relationships–yet.
Grrr,
Sorry for the typos–I really need to proof read before posting.
So to sum up:
Jay and his defenders are for gay marriage. Except when a court agrees with them, then they are implacably against gay marriage and would sign onto any effort to amend the Constitution to ban it.
toggle Marty Feldman eyes.
Mark, my point is that the court may actually have to rule upon my question, rather than upon yours. It’s not simply a clear-cut challenge to the status-quo.
I think the argument (and potentially the ruling) would be significantly different depending upon which scenario is in question. If a party petitions the court from the perspective of a state not granting marriage licenses to same-sex couples, there is a reciprocal question as to whether the Federal government has within its constitutional rights to determine whether a state must issue such licenses (this argument may well come through as very similar to the interracial marriage question, though as I’ve stated, I believe that to be a fallacious equivocation) If, however, the question is regarding reciprocity, the argument must turn its attention to whether a state is constitutionally required to recognize a license granted by another state, and the ruling is likely to be in support of non-reciprocity (a parallel is seen within gun laws and concealed-carry licenses).
As to the overall picture, the question of purpose in the issuance of marriage licenses to any couple must be addressed. As I remarked above, it significantly changes the debate if it’s accepted that the preservation and advancement of the traditional family is foremost in the purposes of the legal preferences extended to that entity.
Consider, too, the complexities that you raise within the question of same-sex couples raising children. Will the couple “train” homosexuality, thereby tearing down the “inborn” claim, will they allow their children to be heterosexual and in so doing giving a nod to the “natural” argument against homosexuality, or will they discourage hetersexuality, and in so doing put their child under the same pressures to be gay as they claim to have endured as society tried to make them “straight?”
And just to state the obvious, the notion of a pair of card-carrying NAMBLA members adopting a little boy is simply sickening.
“Defense of Marriage Act. Why hasn’t the SCOTUS struck this law down?”
Because the issue hasn’t come before the court, as far as I know. Do you know how a case rises to the SCOTUS? There has to be an actual, real, live lawsuit between real parties. Then one of those parties has to lose. Then the case has to rise up through the appellate court system until it is ripe for the SCOTUS to review. Then one of the parties has to petition the Court to have it reviewed–the Court has discretion on whether to take it. This takes years, and hundreds of thousands, if not millions, in legal fees to get a case to this level. DOMA is less than 10 years old, and it often takes longer than that for a case to reach the SCOTUS.
BoDiddly,
Forgive me, but I’m lost. I’m not quite sure what you’re saying in those first three paragraphs. I concede I killed a few brain cells last night, and I haven’t had my coffee yet.
I don’t know if this addresses what you said, but here it is. The recognition of marriage by states is well settled, and we agree that there are legitimate state interests in protecting the institution. If a civil rights case were brought before the SCOTUS, the question would need to be framed in terms of what legitimate interest is there in EXCLUDING same sex relationships.
In response to that question, you seem to suggest that some of the pillars of justification for marriage are absent in the gay context. In other words, I think you’re saying there is a weaker case for gay marriage than there is for straight marriage. But that doesn’t directly address the question.
The question is, what positive reasons are there to make a disctinction and exlude on that basis? What HARM is being prevented by the state’s position of disparate treatment? That would be a large portion of the Court’s inquiry, and that would not be satisfied by simply claiming there is a lesser justification for gay rather than straight marriage. Do you see the distinction? It is a very important disctinction for constitutional analysis.
Mark, why are you engaging this poster-boy for homophobia aka BoDiddly? By legitimizing his baseless rants as coherent arguments you convolute his clear bigotry. That is his goal.
He thinks gays have either chosen their lifestyle, or are sick. Strike one.
He has no problem putting a picture of his wife on his desk at work, yet if a gay man puts a picture of his significant other in the workplace, it’s shoving gay sex down his throat. Strike two.
He says all gays are card-carrying pedophiles who have no business rearing children. Strike three.
You can bet that the one thing he fears the most is that his kids (assuming he as the masculinity required to have kids) turn out gay.
Years from now his granchildren will read stories about the homophobes who worried that homosexuality was contagious, while probably not knowing their grandfather was one of those who perpetuated the bigoted myth.
My daughters, on the other hand, will always know that their father & mother taught them that is perfectly OK to be gay, and they should have every right the rest of us have. We have taught them that you cannot use the term “fag” in a derogatory manner, and if someone at school is being ridiculed for perceived gay behavior, stand up for them. We have taught them that gays are not sick, evil or otherwise any different from their mother and father.
John,
You may be right. But whether they’re shallow homophobes or not, I’m curious to see whether they can articulate the type of valid, coherent argument that a court could use to rule in their favor. A few, including BoDiddly, are starting to actually argue along those lines. Not saying they’re done fleshing it out, or that their reasons are compelling, but the arguments are beginning to take the proper shape. That’s a good start.
One thing is clear, all these purported “supporters” of gay marriage are working hard to sling every piece of junk obstacle they can into the path of equality. Kinda makes ya wonder, eh?
It also seems clear that nearly every SCOTUS decision based on the Bill of Rights would be considered “judicial activism” by these people–whether rights were denied or advanced.
As I stated before, marriage benefits are expensive, not only for the state, but for third parties like private pension funds. The state’s very existence requires future generations of good citizens and currently all people are a product of heterosexual reproduction (notice I didn’t say sex). Anyone can raise a child once it’s born and we have stories in our literature of wolfs and apes doing so, but historically what’s best for children is being raised by their natural parents. Given the expense of the marriage grant and the limited resources of the state, the state has a compelling interest in limiting marriage benefits to the procreation couple.
Traditional marriage is based on the principle of procreation biology and equality of the partners. Should these traditional principles be breached, then by what principle will the state be able to limit the marriage grant? Shouldn’t two siblings who share their property have the same rights as two homosexuals, or is the state going to require them to commit incest before they can obtain the same benefits as homosexuals? What about three adults? What harm is there in allowing any number of adults to marry? Sometimes the slop really is slippery.
Allow me to introduce the next poster-boy for homophobia: Mac Lorry
He says only good citizens are heterosexual citizens. Strike one.
He equates homosexual parents to wolves and apes. Strike two.
He says marriage is based on procreation. Therefore, sterile heterosexuals cannot obtain a marriage license. Oh, wait that’s false. Strike three.
Yep, the slop is getting slippery, alright.
Should 3 adults be allowed to get married together?
If not, why not?
Ya got me, Les, why not?
I can only imagine the slippery slop in my bedroom if I had two wives.
Hey everybody!
Welcome a new member to the poster-boys for homophobia club: Les Nessman!
Generally it would take three strikes for entry into this esteemed, yet widely populated club, but I’m nominating Les for membership due to the huge, gaping hole in his arguement. And it only took him 2 sentences to make the grade!
While I’m sure many of you will answer Les’s question, let me twist it a little as we slide down that slippery slop.
Leaving marriage out of the equation, should it be illegal for people to have threesomes? A little girl on girl action, with you, the dude, in the middle? Does that offend anyone here?
John, stop acting like an asshole.
It’s a serious question, and you’re evading it.
Why don’t you just answer the question?
Mark,
Is that a yes?
I don’t answer straw-man questions, poster-boy.
Allowing same-sex couples to marry does not change the restriction on the number of people who may contract a marriage. Furthermore, because of the reciprocal nature of many spousal rights and responsibilities, it would not be possible to give three-person groups equal rights and responsibilities as two-person groups.
In the jurisdictions throughout the world that have afforded legal recognition of same-sex unions, the dire consequences like bigamy, bestiality and incest have not come to pass.
And hey, I’m not acting like an asshole, I AM an asshole. And you’re a homophobe. Revel in it, brother!
John:
“I don’t answer straw-man questions, poster-boy.”
That’s good to know. Of course, what I am asking is a real question.
“Allowing same-sex couples to marry does not change the restriction on the number of people who may contract a marriage.”
Why not, exactly?
” Furthermore, because of the reciprocal nature of many spousal rights and responsibilities, it would not be possible to give three-person groups equal rights and responsibilities as two-person groups.”
Not possible? I’m sure some arrangements could be made. But, assuming you are correct, what rights and responsibilities could a two-person group do that a three-person group cannot do?
Les, I’ll type slowly so you can understand me.
A straw-man argument is one which is presented for the sole purpose of being easily refuted.
Obviously you are aptly prepared to refute anyone who thinks bigamy could be a viable institution, therefore I will not entertain the argument.
You, however, have the burden of explaining to us why you are against gay marriage. If your only argument is that you are afraid of bigamy, let me be the first to set your mind at ease.
So tell us, Les, what’s your real problem with gay marriage?
I see no danger inherent in gay marriage, but, John, you’re full of it.
Why not a three person marriage? Apparently there’s been one just recently in Europe. So how is this not a relevant question? What about polygamy is so hard to comprehend? Having more than one wife is the norm in *many* cultures and having more than one husband has been the norm in only a few, but these arrangements have a long standing in History.
The restriction of marriage to two people only is a modern invention. Furthermore, polygamy involves a man and multiple women with whom he hopes to procreate… the whole idea is more children. This is biologically based. His genes are reproduced more often if he’s got more wives. The opposite is also biologically based. Found in extremely harsh environments, more than one man may share a wife, supporting her and her children on the hopes that one or more of her children will be his.
While I believe that polyamorous arrangements have some inherent difficulties, I also believe that simply “living in sin” has inherent difficulties, yet people do it all the time. Sex before marriage causes all sorts of practical problems. Children outside of wedlock cause a whole passel more problems. Divorce is an unmitigated disaster, either because it really *was* necessary or else its provides it’s own disaster.
And you figure that difficulties working out a three way contract make the issue *impossible?*
Now, if you don’t call me a homophobe I’m going to be mighty disappointed.
John,
Don’t type slowly. You should read slowly. Because you obviously don’t understand plain English.
My question is a real one. Why are you too frightened to answer it honestly?
“Obviously you are aptly prepared to refute anyone who thinks bigamy could be a viable institution, therefore I will not entertain the argument.”
Actually, YOU are the one refuting bigamy, when you said : “Furthermore, because of the reciprocal nature of many spousal rights and responsibilities, it would not be possible to give three-person groups equal rights and responsibilities as two-person groups.” Or have you changed your mind in the last 5 minutes?
But, assuming you are correct, what rights and responsibilities could a two-person group do that a three-person group cannot do?
John,
Better than being moralphobic like yourself.
I didn’t say good citizens are only heterosexual, that’s a product of your own bigoted mind. Strike one.
I didn’t equate homosexual parents to wolves and apes. Learn to read. Strike two.
Traditional marriage is based on procreation biology and the equality of the partners. What did you think it was based on? Had you read my earlier post that I alluded to you would understand that the state deals with people by type such as 65 and older individuals who get an extra exemption on their tax returns regardless of their actual income or financial status. Similarly, traditional marriage is based on procreation type couples regardless of their fertility. If you weren’t a moralphobe you would understand why. Strike three and you are out!
Given the subject, “slop” is correct.
Les,
Thats an “undecided.” I haven’t spent any time noodling that one, except for a few private fantasies. But if pushed for an answer at this minute, let me say this: I can’t think of any insurmountable problems at the moment. Althought I’m sure there would be plenty of complications, I can’t think of any that can’t be worked out.
One question I have for you is whether you’re asking from pure intellectual curiosity, or whether you intend to bootstrap the responses into a rationale against gay marriage. I suspect you picked polygamy as being a notch downhill from gay marriage on a perceived slippery slope. There, you’ll rally a base of supporting arguments and hoist them up that slope a notch, where you’ll use the same arguments to support current state marriage requirements (i.e., opposite sex).
My hunch is it’s the later, not that there’s anything wrong with that. I suspect that’s why John eagerly inducted you as a poster-boy.
Personally, I don’t have a problem with straw man arguments. They’re used by the SCOTUS all the time to good effect. As long as the analogies are logically sound, they are excellent analytical tools.
So Synova and Les both advocate bigamy. Cool.
I’m sure at some point they are going to tell us how this supports their view on gay marriage.
Sorry Synova, I cannnot nominate you to the homophobia poster-boy club just yet. Let me know how you think bigamy relates to the issue of gay marriage and I’ll reconsider. Les was nominated because he brought it up first which made it clear to me he is a homophobe. I’m giving you the benefit of the doubt here and presume you are specifically answering Les and responding to my bullshit.
Just to be clear: Being against gay marriage, for whatever reason, is being against gays.
Oh, hey! There’s Mac Lorry! Beat up any gays today, Mac?
John said:
“Just to be clear: Being against gay marriage, for whatever reason, is being against gays.”
I’m not convinced of this. That is why I’ve been trying to probe “legitimate state interests” in the constitutional context rather than directly eliciting biases and prejudice. It is conceiveable that there are legitimate, non-prejudicial, reasons to limit marriage to opposite sex couples, I just don’t know what they are.
Wow, Mark.
Nice try to get into the club, but no dice. See, there IS no legitimate state interest. That’s my entire point.
Anybody who argues otherwise is a homophobe. They can perform all the mental gymnastics they want, but trying to carve out a legitimate state interest in not allowing gays to marry in an exercise in bigotry.
Now if you even remotely agree with any of these knuckle-draggers that try to shoe-horn a state interest in gay marriage, I’m putting you up for nomination to the club.
John,
“See, there IS no legitimate state interest.”
You god damned flamer! I bet your ass resembles those swollen, beet-red orifices usually seen in the baboon cage at the zoo!
Just kidding.
I can honestly see states making arguments around procreation, and I can see portions of the Court taking those seriously. Not that the weight would tip the scales in favor of bigotry, but at least there would be an honest debate.
Mark:
“One question I have for you is whether you’re asking from pure intellectual curiosity, or whether you intend to bootstrap the responses into a rationale against gay marriage.”
Both.
I haven’t heard one argument for gay marriage that can’t be used to argue for 3 people getting married together.
Are there any arguments that can be used exclusively for gay marriage?
Let’s walk down this procreation path and see where it leads us:
Same-sex marriage retains enough moral underpinning to support the familial role marriage plays in society despite the absence of a direct procreative element. Also, the institution of marriage would be strengthened by making it available to more people.
Same-sex marriage would encourage gays and lesbians to settle down with one partner and raise families.
Heterosexual marriage no longer retains a procreative function of the government. For example, the government offers child tax-credits and assistance regardless of marital status.
Are there any arguments that can be used exclusively for gay marriage?
Um, because gays are asking for this right and bigamists are not?
Poster-boy. I knew it.
Les:
“I haven’t heard one argument for gay marriage that can’t be used to argue for 3 people getting married together.”
But I think there are arguments against poligamy that do not apply to gay marriage. Isn’t that a more important question?
“Are there any arguments that can be used exclusively for gay marriage?”
I can’t think of any at the moment, but isn’t the more relevant question this?:
What arguments for straight marriage can’t be applied in the gay context? I can’t think of any except for procreation, and I think that’s a weak one.
But remember, at least in the context of constitutional analysis, the question put to the state is not, “why?” — it’s “why not?”
Who says that polygamists aren’t asking for the right? Heck, there’s groups that publically advocate “loving” children. It would be a bit much to think there weren’t groups that advocate polygamy as a legal option.
A threesome was married in Europe (Netherlands?) just recently. Obviously *they* wanted the right. I’ve got friends who are polyamorists… something quite different from people who just sleep around indescriminately. Might they want to get married for “real”… yes, they might.
What does this have to do with gay marriage? It’s simply a data point of a variety of “marriage” that happens to have a stronger Historical and cultural basis than gay marriage does. Certainly quite a few people will bring it up as a “slipery slope” argument. Claiming that it’s a non-issue, in your words “not be possible” isn’t an answer to that argument. If gay marriage is not a slippery-slope, go ahead and explain why it’s not.
Do I *advocate* polygamy? Not at all. As a common model I don’t think it works in a situation of social equity. Cultures where a man has/had many wives are/were heavily paternalistic. The family model is/was stable because the husband is/was so much more the boss than even the senior wife.
This doesn’t stop people from wanting to make a family of more than a couple. That I think it’s a bad idea is immaterial. That I think it is immoral is my own business.
But quite frankly, I don’t see the problem with allowing a category of domestic contract that incorporates “marriage” obligations and legal protections for other than heterosexual couples. Heck, I don’t see why sex even has to come into it. Our lives used to be much more generationally intertwined. Why not “marry” grandma? Why not pool domestic resources together instead of splintering them apart?
Your view of the world is too narrow, John.
I want to amend my last comments to Les.
Yes, there is an argument for gay marriage that does not apply to polygamy. In fact, it is probably the ONLY argument the gay marriage movement needs in its favor. Here it is:
“Because two straight people can, and already do, enjoy the legal benefits of marriage.”
Obviously that does not apply to polygamy.
Now, the rest of the analysis should be this:
“What is the distinction between gay marriage and straight marriage that justifies the refusal to recognize the former?”
Concerns of polygamy don’t really apply, do they?
93 comments and counting. Think Jay will award a prize to the 100th caller?
John: The only one making straw-man arguments is you. You are also making ad hominem attacks. Either join the discusion seriously or leave, we already know your opinion of anyone who does not agree with you.
Ding ding ding ding!
We have a new member of the homopobia poster-boys club: Synova!
-Gtatuitous mention of pedophila. Check.
-Gratuitous mention and advocation of marrying a family member. Check.
-Cloaking of the bigotry by attempting a reference that you are actually for gay marriage.
Check!
Actually I don’t disagree with some of what you said, but we clearly disagree about whether gays should be married.
You people in the club need to stand firm and announce that you are either for or against gay marriage. Your equivocation is growing tiresome.
Mark:
“But I think there are arguments against poligamy that do not apply to gay marriage. “
I don’t think so. But maybe you are correct. So tell me, what are those arguments?
Taking another tack, you said this:
“Yes, there is an argument for gay marriage that does not apply to polygamy. In fact, it is probably the ONLY argument the gay marriage movement needs in its favor. Here it is:
“Because two straight people can, and already do, enjoy the legal benefits of marriage.””
Not true, Mark.
Gay people can already, and do already, enjoy the legal benefits of marriage. Just not to the same sex.
Les:
“I don’t think so. But maybe you are correct. So tell me, what are those arguments?”
Well, some might be centered around the destabilizing effects of jealousy that could arise in the context of polygamy. I’m just guessing here, but I would imagine there are some pragmatic challenges that don’t apply to a two-person relationship.
“Gay people can already, and do already, enjoy the legal benefits of marriage. Just not to the same sex.”
You’re right and I need to be more precise. I’ve been using “gay” and “Straight” as shorthand for “same sex” and “opposite sex.” Yeah, it’s sloppy, but it requires fewer key strokes.
More importantly, the issue should be defined as “the legal benefits of marriage TO THE PERSON OF THEIR CHOICE.” Clearly, you can’t claim that equally exists in the gay/straight context.
Mark,
What interest does the sate have in awarding marriage to anyone if it’s not to gain future generations of good citizens? The first step in that process is always procreation, and baring future medical marvels, that step always starts with heterosexual reproduction. The natural family starts with one man and one woman.
One of the arguments for homosexual marriage used in the Massachusetts case was the many financial benefits the state bestows on married couples. Given limited resources, it follows that the state has a compelling interest in awarding those resources to the type of couples capable of procreation.
Financial limitations of the state has been used to exclude giving benefits to one group of people while freely giving them to another group of people. For example, someone who’s 70 gets Medicare benefits regardless of their financial status, but someone who’s 50 and can’t afford medical care is denied these same benefits. That’s age discrimination, but it’s allowed because, given the limited resources, the state has a compelling reason to selectively award such benefits. It’s the same with marriage.
Should the principle of procreation biology be discarded as a basis for marriage, then by what principle can the state deny marriage status to siblings who want the same financial benefits of marriage. Look around and you will find lots of adult siblings who have lived together for years; maybe more than the number of homosexuals couples. Once procreation biology is discarded there’s no logic to limiting marriage to just 2. Because of the expense, the only recourse left to the state will be to abolish marriage as a state recognized status.
Mac Lorry:
“Should the principle of procreation biology be discarded as a basis for marriage, then by what principle can the state deny marriage status to siblings who want the same financial benefits of marriage.”
I think procreation-related concerns are the most expressed justifications for barring blood marriages. The claimed dangers of birth defects from inbreeding come to mind first. I say “claimed” because I don’t know the biology or genetics aspects well.
But my problem with your procreation argument is that gays do procreate. Also, I think the benefits apply to the raising of the kid, not as an incentive to have more kids. Hell, we already have the welfare system to incentify crack whores to collect kids in efforts to increase benefits.
I’ll give you an example from my life. My ex-wife’s college room mate, and one of her best friends, had a baby around the same time my wife and I had our first. About five years later, she and her husband divorced because he was abusive. She eventually fell in love with another woman and they’ve been living together for the past 10 years or so. In fact, they moved to Jay’s state of New Hampshire where they operate a bed and breakfast together. My friend’s daughter now has two mommies, and they are excellent parents. The daughter is a very successful, well-adjusted, student and athlete, and she dates boys. Tell me, why shouldn’t the two mommies of this great kid receive the same benefits her birth mommy would have if she remained in the abusive relationship?
Mark:
“More importantly, the issue should be defined as “the legal benefits of marriage TO THE PERSON OF THEIR CHOICE.””
Person of their choice? Why not persons of their choice? Are you a polyphobe? heh.
So far I’ve only heard some vague noise about jealosy as a reason to oppose multi-marriage. If that is the argument, that is some very weak soup.
For all the reasons that the pro-gay ‘marriage’ side puts forth, if you are for gay ‘marriage’ and you are not for polygamy then you are a hypocrite.