OK, I’m finally getting off my can and tackling the “Katrina Auction” pieces. The first up is Zach Stover’s, who wanted my opinion of the Fair Tax proposal.
I’ve looked into the Fair Tax proposal, and I like it. It’s simple, it’s sensible, it seems “fair” (which is an incredibly loaded word), it’s elegant, and it’s practical. Which makes it even more of a damned shame that it’s simply not gonna happen.
There are two great forces in American society, and in the case of the Fair Tax, they are united in opposing it. Those are enlightened self-interest and inertia. Or, to put it another way, selfishness and greed.
For all the people being nibbled by the current tax structure, there are others who benefit greatly from it. The system, as convoluted and confusing and chaotic as it is, did not randomly evolve. Every single twist was created by someone with a very specific purpose in mind — to reward or punish an individual, a group, or a corporation. Every single outrageous aspect of the tax code has its defender.
Moreover, an entire industry has grown up dependent on the tax structure staying exactly as it is. Lawmakers, who view passing laws as their way of showing their constituents that they are doing their job. Bureaucrats, whose job is to oversee, administer, and interpret the tax code. Lobbyists, who justify their salaries by getting the lawmakers and bureaucrats to shape the laws and interpretations for the benefit of their clients. Tax attorneys (much like my own Senator, Judd Gregg), whose whole livelihood revolves around rescuing people from the tentacles of the tax code. Tax preparers, who charge hundreds or thousands of dollars to wring the most money they can back from the government and into the hands of those who paid it. Tax software publishers, who figured out how to replace the above folks with a CD-ROM. And even con artists, who sell people on plans to “opt out” of the supposedly “voluntary” income tax, or convince them that they are exempt from taxes as part of “slavery reparations” or a zillion other scams.
They might not have the numbers, but they have the motivation. Toss in the factor of “withholding,” where people never see the money they pay in taxes, but rejoice every year when the government might deign to give them back a portion of THEIR OWN MONEY (a category I ashamedly fall into), and you have a classic case of the old “boiling frog” urban legend — where, it is said, that if you put a frog in a pot of room-temperature water and then slowly heat it to boiling, the frog will happily sit there and boil to death.
In favor of the flat tax, a few highly-motivated activists. Against it, dozens of large corporations, hordes of bureaucrats, lawyers, and politicians. I might not like the answer, but I know which side I think will win.
Screw that. I definitely don’t like the answer. The Fair Tax plan deserves a Fair Shake. Unfortunately, I don’t see it happening. Tthe race may not go to the swift, nor the battle to the strong — but that’s the way to bet.


I have one question about all this. How in the world do withholding taxes contribute to the cost of a product other the the cost of a person to do the paperwork? The only payroll taxes that the company is responsible for is one half of socail security and medicare (7.35% up to the limit.) I don’t see where the Fair Tax is changing any of that.
More importantly, can anyone here honestly (and I do mean honestly) envision a system where there would be NO corporate taxes? Of course you can’t. The issue of taxes as a part of the cost of goods sold will not go away.
It seems rather a large leap of faith to presume that corporations would reduce prices by the exact amount of the taxes they are saving. Do you really think that every company would automatically reduce prices 23 percent? Or that the market would work so efficiently that competition would force everyone to reduce prices? And no, I’m not going to READ THE BOOK. Neal Boortz is an idiot. Anyone who says Katrina survivors should turn to prostitution rather than getting Federal assistance, or who can’t decide who’s more dangerous to our country, Osama bin Laden or Kerry voters, isn’t getting a dime of my money. That’s like me telling most of you that you’re not qualified to comment on race unless you’ve sent Al Sharpton $30 for his book.
That’s not the point! The point is that under the Fairtax, it’s likely that used items will sell for more than the retail price of new items. That’s because the tax is collected on the new item, but not on the used item regardless of what the current true tax rate is. The result is that used items will increase in price with the effect that buyers of used items will be paying a portion of the Fairtax, regardless of the specifics of the law. It’s a predictable unintended consequence. What I’m concerned about are the unpredictable unintended consequences.
Actually, that is the point. You’re comparing apples and oranges. On the one hand, you’re citing the price of an item with tax excluded from the picture (“the item now cost $2000”) and on the other hand you’re citing the price with tax including (“the item will cost $2800 under the FT”).
In the “$2000” price scenario, you’re paying for that item with POST-TAX money. In order to have $2000 in POST-TAX money you must earn approximately $2800 in PRE-TAX MONEY.
In the “$2800” price scenario, you’re paying for that item with PRE-TAX money. Under the FT, you’re not paying income tax. So, when you earn $2800, you have $2800 with which to pay for something. Under the current system when you earn $2800, you have about $2000 for which to pay with something.
You’re comparing apples to oranges. Re-read it.
– MikeB
Re MacLorry:
Can’t you see that it doesn’t matter if the retail price drops. All that matters is the relative difference in the price of new verses used. With the Fairtax someone wanting to sell a $2,000 item that they just paid maybe $2,800 for is not going to want to sell for less than the retail price of $2,000 as they would do under the current system. Part of the $800 tax (assuming a combined fed and state rate of 40%) will be passed on to the next purchaser. This is not intended in the Fairtax law, but it’s a predictable consequence. It’s the unpredictable consequences I’m concerned with.
Actually, it is an intended consequence. I’m replying to this as well in hopes to drive the point home. Under the current system, you’re paying with POST-TAX money. Under the FT, you’re paying with PRE-TAX money.
I’ll write it as an equation for simplicity.
Under the current system:
MoneyEarned – Taxes = ValueOfItem
$2800 – $800 = $2000
Under the FT:
MoneyEarned = ValueOfItem + Taxes
$2800 = $2000 + $800
These two equation essentially sum up what the FairTax is proposing to change.
For your example, ValueOfItem is $2000, taxes are rougly $800, and MoneyEarn is $2800. You’re neglecting the fact that under the current system you’re exchanging (MoneyEarned – Taxes) for ValueOfItem but acknowledging the fact that under the FT you’d exchange (MoneyEarned) for (ValueOfItem + Taxes).
That’s the point I was attempting to make by asking if you knew what your current tax burden was. People typically miss that their purchasing power has already been diluted under the current system and then complain when they see their purchasing power being diluted under the FT. Oddly, most seem more content to not have to see it. I’d rather have it fully visible.
– MikeB
schwerv,
I never said you said any of the above. What are you going to do, list all the things you never said? What you did say is the following:
In supporting the Fairtax you made a specific claim about China and the trade deficit we have with them. My point is that China is a special case and that due to a number of reasons I have already enumerated, it’s far beyond the ability of the Fairfax to resolve. No first world nation has been able to compete regardless of their tax structure. I understand it’s important to fix the trade deficit, but replacing our tax code with one that raises an equal amount of tax is not going to do it.
Given an unmanipulated market, the value of the dollar would drop relative to other currencies due to our trade deficits. This decline makes U.S. goods cheaper on the international market. However, when nations like China cheat, it keeps the price of U.S. goods high in their country. In addition, investment in the U.S. by other nations cause the dollar to rise which makes U.S. goods more expensive abroad. Check out this government document if you want to understand more about the reasons for the U.S. trade deficit. Taxes are only a small part of it.
MikeB,
But Mike, it was my example in the first place, and I didn’t misunderstand my own example. In my example I’m comparing the price of new verses used goods under the fair tax system, not between tax systems. In my example the tax rate of the current system is irrelevant. In my example all that counts is the relative price of new verses used goods.
If you want to make a point about how the rates compare between the current system and the Fairtax system make up your own example, don’t hijack mine and then tell me I’m wrong.
As far as the current tax rate, I pay 52.3% on the money I make in my business. That includes federal and state income tax, both halves of FICA, state unemployment tax, and the FUTA tax. For an employee I get to deduct half of FICA, but I then pay for worker compensation insurance. Once I have paid all the above, as a person I still have to pay state sales tax, property tax, vehicles license tax, and federal and state tax on gasoline. And that’s not the end of it, if you consider tax on your phone and cable TV bill. I have a good idea that I pay way too much tax, but I also understand enough about business to know that the Fairtax will still require an agency like the IRS to keep people from cheating, and I’m not taking about insignificant amounts.
MacLorry:
From your post above,
You’re comparing across tax systems. You can restate your argument if you like, but what you’ve argued is documented above. Your argument is flawed, wrong, or nonesense. You can pick your term, but either you’re trying to pretended you said something you didn’t or you don’t understand your argument.
The problem with your argument is that you’re comparing PRE-TAX money with POST-TAX purchasing power.
Your argument, as cited, is basically that _price_, in post-tax dollars, would be lower under the current system than it would be in pre-tax dollars under the FT.
If you buy a used widget now for $1700, you must still earn more than $2k to get that $1700. You’ve stated that since “Families … shopping at garage sales will find higher prices than under the current sytsem” as if this indicates some new burden that wasn’t there before and that’s BS.
– MikeB
Mac,
My point on the TV example is that a $2000 TV won’t cost $2800 when the FairTax is enacted. I personally think costs will rise (although Boortz glosses over it in the book), but not by the full 23% of the FairTax.
Let’s assume (keeping numbers rough) that the embedded taxes component of the TV is 20%. That means that due to competition, what you call the real non-tax price of that TV is really $1600, and $400 is eaten across the supply chain in taxes withheld from the employees. Now, you add the 23% FairTax (multiplying by 1.3), and you have a TV that costs $2080. As I said, most employees will fight to have their withheld taxes given to them (at least partly), so the true pre-FT cost won’t drop to $1600, it will drop to maybe $1750. Which means a slightly higher cost, maybe $2200. *NOT* $2800 as you suggest.
And that’s just the immediate answer. Over 5-10 years, the economy will reach an equilibrium where those embedded taxes will drop out of the cost of goods, as peoples’ wages reflect the true elimination of embedded taxes.
Remember that the FairTax is not added to other taxes, it replaces other taxes. In a perfect world, the price of products won’t change *AT ALL*, because the embedded taxes will all disappear immediately, being replaced by the FairTax. The transition not being entirely smooth, the price of goods will rise some, but not 30-40% by any means.
Mac,
Regarding China, there’s never going to be a point where some American industries will be competitive. America will never again control the textile industry, for example, because our people *WILL NOT* work for the wages necessary. What will happen, though, is that we will become much more competitive than we are today. And with many businesses in high-tax areas like Europe fleeing there for here, as Boortz says, the US will become the world’s largest tax haven, all the while continuing to have the stability and rule of law that other tax haven nations won’t have.
Let’s look outside the prices debate for a second. What will the FairTax do to our economy? All of sudden, products we export will have no embedded tax component. Essentially the export price will drop 20-25% (depending on the industry), making our products competitive in foreign markets they’re not competitive now. And since the US will impose the FairTax on imported products, other countries with high income taxes will find their products less marketable in the US. Right now, they are using things such as a VAT to allow their exports to compete more efficiently, we’ll take that idea and crank it up a notch.
Does that mean we’ll be able to manufacture things as cheaply as China? No. Wages are too high here. When you discuss goods that require much unskilled manual labor, you go to places where unskilled manual labor is cheap. But there are a lot of manufacturing jobs that require skilled equipment operators, or competent product QA/inspection people, and thus the advantage of China or India is much smaller. And at the margins, those companies will stay here. It won’t solve outsourcing, but it will make it much less attractive.
The FairTax is the best thing that could happen to the American economy. It would make us the most attractive country in the first world to operate a business. And with those business come jobs.
MikeB,
Well Mike you don’t know what you are talking about. A families who makes ends meet now by shopping at garage sales doesn’t pay any income tax under the current system. In fact they may be getting the Earned Income credit, which puts them in the negative tax bracket. Your example assumes the price of goods will go down because producers will pass their tax savings along to customers. Even if that’s true for U.S. produced goods, it’s not true for imported goods. A family who makes ends meet now by shopping at garage sales is likely to be buying clothing, 90% of which are imported, and won’t be effected much, if any, by the fairtax. Under the fairtax, the price of used goods will reflect the price of the new item plus the consumption tax. The effect is that such families will be paying some portion of the fairtax in the cost of used goods. The fairtax hurts the people who are least able to pay. It might be fair, but it’s not just.
Mac,
Regarding your last comment, those very poor people will be getting a raise in the form of the Prebate. If you assume they currently pay no income tax (although if they work, they are paying payroll taxes), they’ll still be coming out ahead.
Mac,
I’ll try to take on some of your questions about the FAQ (comment yesterday 10:34 AM):
#16 – Retirement Savings: If these are a 401K, they were already done with pre-tax money. If they were saved from post-tax money, the holder will not have to pay any income tax or capital gains tax from the gains they’ve made on those savings. It may not be what you’d consider to be the fairest system, but assuming the embedded taxes, it’s hard to say most of them would be worse off.
#21 – Home Mortgage: You will be charged the FairTax on new homes. Subsequent buyers will be charged *NO* tax on homes, as it is now a used item. They’re not charged tax on the increased value or the full value. The home mortgage deduction goes away, but remember, the taxes you’re deducting those costs against doesn’t even exist. Again, as I’ve said before, the transition may be rough. But since you’re not paying the FairTax on an existing mortgage, it seems like it doesn’t change the calculus too much.
#22 – Churches: See this link. It should answer the questions. As to whether a church could purchase something tax-free and then resell a week later as used, a business could do the same thing. It will come down to the enforcement agency to look out for patterns of this nature.
#25 – State Taxes: Yes, it is thought that most states would consider switching their tax systems, as they would either have to create their own reporting requirements (instead of piggybacking on the feds), or would have to do away with it altogether. However, your 40% number only applies to the currently tax-addled states such as CA, IL, MA, etc. If a state currently has a high income tax and high sales tax (like CA), it could mean they need to create a 10%+ state FairTax rate. But let’s face it. People in those states are already paying for their bloated, inefficient state governments. CA already has a 7%+ state sales tax. People and jobs will still be fleeing CA and MA for more tax-friendly shores, no matter how they try to fund their enormous tax burdens. Low-tax states (such as the states who currently *ONLY* have a sales tax) won’t be affected that much, and the FairTax rate they would have to institute wouldn’t be excessively high, as their current rates aren’t excessively high.
To your last point, about getting rid of the IRS, you’re right. But we won’t have any government agency with the ability to step in and investigate our incomes at will. The regulatory agency that will take its place will be more focused on retailers and businesses, who in most states already have to comply with sales tax collection anyway. It can easily be argued that whatever replaces the IRS won’t be the monster that the IRS has become, and that the simpler tax code will be much easier to enforce than the behemoth we currently have.
Brad Warbiany,
I appreciate your thoughtful responses. As for the TV example, you would do better picking a different item as all TVs sold in the U.S. are imported. I have the last Zenith model made in the U.S. and it’s getting old. The point is that the fairtax won’t reduce the price of items like TVs because there’s no signigicant U.S. tax burden in such products. With no U.S. TVs available, there’s no market pressure from cheaper U.S. goods to drive the price down. It seems like most of the manufactured goods you find in department stores are imported, so I’m skeptical that such prices will drop much under the fairtax system.
I agree with much of what you said about China. China is a special case, but it’s an important case as the U.S. ran up over an additional 200 billion dollar trade deficit with China just in the last year. The Chinese use that money to purchase U.S. treasury bonds, so in effect they are buying America itself.
The only problem is that the VAT is the only tax allowed under international trade treaties. We could implement a VAT ourselves, but applying the full Fairtax (which is not a VAT) to imported goods will likely be opposed by European trading partners under existing treaties. You are likely aware that treaties have the same legal weight as the Constitution itself, so no enacted federal law can supercede them. It would be a good idea to renegotiate the treaties anyway, but we can’t just impose whatever changes we like.
My main concerns about the Fairtax are that it won’t eliminate or even reduce the investigative and enforcement functions of the IRS, nor the record keeping required by those functions. The fairtax won’t substantially reduce the price of imported goods, which make up a substantial part of what most people buy. The fairtax removes the government’s ability to promote good ideas, such as home ownership, energy savings, and investment in R&D. The fairtax unjustly double taxes money people have in current savings, money they have already paid the full tax on. The fairtax also places the burden of special taxes on the general public, such as the extra tax people who smoke pay, and the gas tax for those who drive. All these user fees would be rolled up into one consumption tax under the fairtax. The elderly would be taxed at the same rate as working people. As it is now, when you stop working you stop paying most income tax and all payroll tax, but under the fairtax, there’s no reduction in tax burden when you retire. Proponents claim that the reduction in the cost of goods and services will offset this, but as I have pointed out, imported goods won’t experiences much reduction. I’m skeptical of many of the claims being floated by proponents.
Brad Warbiany,
The prebate will be consumed paying the consumption tax on items that can’t be purchased used such as food, utilities, gas, and insurance. While people who work pay 7.65% FICA tax, they also receive the Earned income credit, which can be a lot if they have kids. The earned income credit for a family of 4 making $28,000 is about $4,000. With the standard deduction and four exemptions they pay nothing in and get $4,000 back. That’s a tax rate of -14.2%, and most states also give such families a negative tax rate. This is the redistribution of wealth people talk about, but it goes to working people, so I feel it’s much better than standard welfare. The Fairtax removes the ability of government to target social problems and favor positive factors in our society such as work, home ownership and energy savings.
The underlying premise in a lot of examples given above is that goods will become significantly cheaper under the Fairtax then they are now, but I’m skeptical for several reasons. Much of that skepticism comes from my own experience running a subchapter S corporation. In FAQ 33 on the site Jay Tea linked to it states that “Businesses need answer only one question to determine the tax due: ‘How much was sold to consumers?'” Apparently that means that a wholesale business pays no taxes, but what about business purchases? FAQ 33 also says “The roughly 90-percent reduction in filers enables tax administrators more narrowly and effectively to address noncompliance and increases the likelihood of tax evasion discovery” The first bullet on the home page exclaims that the Fairtax “Abolishes the IRS”, so unless that’s just smoke and mirrors the statements from FAQ 33 must be referring to the type of administration typical of sales and use taxes. Currently, businesses are exempt from such taxes only for purchases of goods and services directly related to the “cost of goods sold.” That term has a specific meaning and it excludes most other business expenses I’ll use in the following example.
Subchapter S corporations are restricted to non-public tightly held (few shareholders) corporations. There’s no size (income) restriction, but often these are small to medium size business, you know that ones that employee most Americans, so anyone saying this is not an important part of our economy is full of it.
Subchapter S corporations pay NO income tax at all under the current tax system. I pay a bit less than 9% of my gross payroll in federal taxes (FICA and FUTA), and payroll is less than a third of my expenses. I’m not talking about the cost of goods sold, but expenses. I have to light and heat my building and pay for water, sewer and garbage collection. I get to use pre-tax dollars to pay for all of these, but under the Fairtax it seems I would be paying the 22% consumption tax on such expenses. I also pay a lot for advertisement, insurance, office supplies, equipment and employee training materials. All these would require I pay the 22% consumption tax under the Fairtax. I also get to expense anything relate to the business under section 179 including speculative R&D costs (I get to decide where to spend these dollars). The only limit is that the deductions are restricted to profits and a cap ($105,000 in 2005). I would have to pay the 22% consumption tax under the Fairtax for these purchases. I also get to depreciate other property, like the cost of the building itself over 39 years. On a million dollar property, that’s over $25,000 per year. Under the Fairtax, it looks like I would have to pay the %22 tax on the price of the building, but even if that’s not the case, I certainly wouldn’t get to deduct $25,000 per year. All of these deductions, including wages, cost of goods sold and payroll taxes, get subtracted from the gross income. What’s left is the net income, which is divided between the shareholders who than pay the income tax as individuals.
A few quick calculations and I discovered that the profits paid to shareholders would be almost 25% less under the Fairtax than under the current system. Yes, the shareholders wouldn’t have to pay income tax on that profit under the Fairtax, but they will have to pay the %22 tax one everything they consume. Given typical shareholder gross income is over $75,000 the Fairtax rebate reduces the effective rate to a bit over 19% for a single person. The result is that these individuals pay an effective rate of 39% under the Fairtax rather than the 28 to 33% they pay under the current system. To keep the shareholder’s real income the same, I’ll have to raise the price of our products. Having grown up as a farm kid, I can tell you the family farm gets lots of tax breaks that will likely go away under the Fairtax, so agricultural products are also likely to increase under the Fairtax.
In summary, the price of imported goods won’t go down substantially under the Fairtax, and the price of small business and agricultural products are likely to increase. The Fairtax is pie in the sky being promoted by a few wealthy people who will benefit greatly by transferring their tax burden to those less able to pay it. There’s nothing fair about the Fairtax.
MacLorry:
Says the man who arguments conflict his own prior statements….
Actually, the argument I presented didn’t rely upon any such presumption. The argument I presented to counter your generalization was that the price of goods does not go up, because you were confusing pre- and post-tax dollars.
Really ? By what standard of justice are you making this pronuciation ?
– MikeB
Just a note.
Since the post by Jay Tea Apr 17, 06, the FarTax Act H.R. 25 has gained momentum. There are now 67 co-sponsors and 6 presidential candidates for it. Top economists agree it is the best way to un-tax the poor and grow the economy.
I love Jay’s comment: “There are two great forces in American society, and in the case of the Fair Tax, they are united in opposing it. Those are enlightened self-interest and inertia. Or, to put it another way, selfishness and greed.”
It has been my experience that those against the FairTax have their pockets lined by the income tax; career politicians, lobbyists, tax lawyers, tax accountants, the non working rich, IRS agents, and illegal aliens.
Just ask:
• WHY DO WE PENALIZE LABOR AND PRODUCTION WITH THE INCOME TAX?
• WHY DO WE PENALIZE WORKING AMERICANS FOR WORKING?
• WHY DO WE PENALIZE WORKING AMERICANS BY TAXING OVERTIME?
• WHY DO WE PENALIZE WORKING AMERICANS BY TAXING SAVINGS?
• WHY DO WE PENALIZE WORKING AMERICANS BY TAXING INVESTMENTS?
• WHY DO WE PENALIZE WORKING AMERICANS FOR BUILDING WEALTH?
• WHY DO WE PENALIZE WORKING AMERICANS BY PASSING ON BIZ TAXES AND COMPLIANCE COSTS EMBEDED IN THE PRICE OF A PRODUCT?
• WHY CAN’T WE SET WORKING AMERICANS FREE BY PASSING THE FAIR TAX ACT?
http://www.fairtax.org support H.R. 25
Ashford Schwall aschwall@comcast.net