Polling numbers just don't add up

(Note: I really don’t have any conclusions here, just a collection of thoughts. Feel free to discuss things among yourselves.)

On the radio the other day, I heard a commentator discussing how President Bush’s approval ratings have fallen even lower. The number I heard was 31%, but that is being challenged — it seems the pollsters once again over-sampled Democrats.

But the particulars aren’t overly important. The commentator said that Bush’s numbers are lower than Clinton’s ever were — and that Clinton would never let his numbers get that bad. Clinton lived and died by polls, by people’s approval, and would have found some way to reverse things. Bush, on the other hand, doesn’t seem to care much for polls; he has his own beliefs and principles, and he stands by them solidly.

A long time ago, I was heavily involved in campus politics. A friend of mine and I were discussing the merits. I backed one candidate as a true believer, a sincere and decent guy. Walter, though, backed a guy who I described as a pure political animal, one who was interested in power and self-aggrandizement. He was lining himself up for a post-college political career, and saw student government as a mere stepping-stone on the way.

Walter’s argument was simple: his guy was someone you could depend on, you could work with. You could get him on your side just by making sure he understood how it would be to his benefit. It was a cold, pragmatic approach, and it repulsed me.

In the end, my guy won and Walter’s lost. And my guy was a disaster.

That’s the problem with the true believers — they rarely end up mediocre. They are either great successes, or great failures. My guy flopped. (It’s so bad that I don’t even remember who the hell he was, but I still remember Walter and his guy, James.)

So, Bush is a true believer, as opposed to Clinton the pragmatist. Reagan and FDR were true believers, but so was Carter. Nixon was, at his core, a pragmatist.

The other element of the polling that struck me is that politics is not a zero-sum game, especially when it comes to polls. Bush’s falling approval do not necessarily mean that his opponents are rising — because they aren’t. There is no ascending star on the Democratic side, just a bunch of retreads, has-beens, and never-weres who think they can capitalize on the numbers to boost themselves — and they can’t.

There’s an old saying in politics that you can’t beat someone with no one. It’s the principle that’s kept Ted and Patrick Kennedy (alias Old Pint and Half Pint) in office. And even though Bush can’t run again, he’s still somebody, and his designated successor will have that going for him (or her). The Democrats need to find someone that people can vote for, for a change — running as “I’m not George W. Bush” hasn’t worked for them yet.

(Update: Iowa Liberal whines that his trackback excoriating me (well, kicking sand on my shoes and stamping his feet) was blocked. Here you go, jb. Sorry to ruin your paranoid persecution complex.)

US Border Control Gives Minutemen Locations to Mexican Government
Why Price Controls Don't Work

173 Comments

  1. wavemaker May 9, 2006
  2. just me May 9, 2006
  3. astigafa May 9, 2006
  4. astigafa May 9, 2006
  5. viet vet May 9, 2006
  6. Jay Tea May 9, 2006
  7. virgo May 9, 2006
  8. epador May 9, 2006
  9. Jim in Cleveland May 9, 2006
  10. wavemaker May 9, 2006
  11. cubanbob May 9, 2006
  12. Jamie May 9, 2006
  13. astigafa May 9, 2006
  14. wavemaker May 9, 2006
  15. virgo May 9, 2006
  16. virgo May 9, 2006
  17. cubanbob May 9, 2006
  18. Jay Tea May 9, 2006
  19. mantis May 9, 2006
  20. tinkerbell May 9, 2006
  21. danjr0802 May 9, 2006
  22. Mike May 9, 2006
  23. salad buffet May 9, 2006
  24. Marc May 9, 2006
  25. Maimonides May 9, 2006
  26. malangali May 9, 2006
  27. scsiwuzzy May 9, 2006
  28. Jamie May 9, 2006
  29. scsiwuzzy May 9, 2006
  30. Erv May 9, 2006
  31. astigafa May 9, 2006
  32. gil May 9, 2006
  33. gil May 9, 2006
  34. jp2 May 9, 2006
  35. chimangaconquistador May 9, 2006
  36. John Gillnitz May 9, 2006
  37. Jimbo May 9, 2006
  38. Jimbo May 9, 2006
  39. Moochzilla May 9, 2006
  40. jay May 9, 2006
  41. Moochzilla May 9, 2006
  42. Aran May 9, 2006
  43. Dick Morrass May 9, 2006
  44. gil May 9, 2006
  45. wavemaker May 9, 2006
  46. chimangaconquistador May 9, 2006
  47. Moochzilla May 9, 2006
  48. Moochzilla May 9, 2006
  49. Scoop Jackson May 9, 2006
  50. Moochzilla May 9, 2006