(Note: I really don’t have any conclusions here, just a collection of thoughts. Feel free to discuss things among yourselves.)
On the radio the other day, I heard a commentator discussing how President Bush’s approval ratings have fallen even lower. The number I heard was 31%, but that is being challenged — it seems the pollsters once again over-sampled Democrats.
But the particulars aren’t overly important. The commentator said that Bush’s numbers are lower than Clinton’s ever were — and that Clinton would never let his numbers get that bad. Clinton lived and died by polls, by people’s approval, and would have found some way to reverse things. Bush, on the other hand, doesn’t seem to care much for polls; he has his own beliefs and principles, and he stands by them solidly.
A long time ago, I was heavily involved in campus politics. A friend of mine and I were discussing the merits. I backed one candidate as a true believer, a sincere and decent guy. Walter, though, backed a guy who I described as a pure political animal, one who was interested in power and self-aggrandizement. He was lining himself up for a post-college political career, and saw student government as a mere stepping-stone on the way.
Walter’s argument was simple: his guy was someone you could depend on, you could work with. You could get him on your side just by making sure he understood how it would be to his benefit. It was a cold, pragmatic approach, and it repulsed me.
In the end, my guy won and Walter’s lost. And my guy was a disaster.
That’s the problem with the true believers — they rarely end up mediocre. They are either great successes, or great failures. My guy flopped. (It’s so bad that I don’t even remember who the hell he was, but I still remember Walter and his guy, James.)
So, Bush is a true believer, as opposed to Clinton the pragmatist. Reagan and FDR were true believers, but so was Carter. Nixon was, at his core, a pragmatist.
The other element of the polling that struck me is that politics is not a zero-sum game, especially when it comes to polls. Bush’s falling approval do not necessarily mean that his opponents are rising — because they aren’t. There is no ascending star on the Democratic side, just a bunch of retreads, has-beens, and never-weres who think they can capitalize on the numbers to boost themselves — and they can’t.
There’s an old saying in politics that you can’t beat someone with no one. It’s the principle that’s kept Ted and Patrick Kennedy (alias Old Pint and Half Pint) in office. And even though Bush can’t run again, he’s still somebody, and his designated successor will have that going for him (or her). The Democrats need to find someone that people can vote for, for a change — running as “I’m not George W. Bush” hasn’t worked for them yet.
(Update: Iowa Liberal whines that his trackback excoriating me (well, kicking sand on my shoes and stamping his feet) was blocked. Here you go, jb. Sorry to ruin your paranoid persecution complex.)

“Principled” versus “pragmatic.” Fun example, but not necessarily instructive, if the suggestion is that “principled” = “disaster.” How do you trust the ego-centric pragmatist, who will shift his allegiance upon the first belief that it will further his own ends? And the principled politician has to be willing to compromise (at times), lest gridlock result time and again.
And unfortunately, we’ve run some pretty good candidates against Ted Kennedy (Joe Malone 1988, Mitt Romney 1994) — so it pains me to say, but here, you can’t beat Ted Kennedy with anyone.
I am not keen on the pragmatist.
What I think a true believer needs to do though, is have some on board (as in they are on board with the true believers political/positional ideas) that are pragmatists, or at least have realistic expectations on what can or can’t be done.
If the true believer doesn’t have some people around him/her to keep the ideas and vision focused, then I do think you end up with a disaster.
Although, I don’t know that the poll numbers indicate a disaster. Time will give us a better indicator of whether it is a disaster than opinion polls of the time.
…it seems the pollsters once again over-sampled Democrats.
…assumes that only Democrats are unhappy with W, which ain’t the case.
The Democrats need to find someone that people can vote for, for a change…
…and that ain’t gonna happen.
Poor Jay Tea. He just can’t admit that George Bush sucks as preznit, and 65% of the population agrees. It’s a pleasure seeing that the arrogant smirk has been wiped off the faces of you GOP nitwits.
By the way, if you think the approval ratings are bad now, wait until Karl Rove is indicted in the next few weeks.
Why do George Bush and republicans in general hate the USA so much?
viet vet, the other day you were bitching I wasn’t talking about politics. (Although Boston’s idiocy can be directly attributed to the micromanagement and nany-statism to which MA Democrats are infamous for.) Now, you say I’m a Republican, which I’m not.
So, why don’t you show me someone whose poll numbers are UP?
And just how are you so certain Rove will be indicted? Got some inside information? Your crystal ball tell you so? On precisely what charges? Or are you just fantasizing?
Poor liberals. The voters have shut them out of the legislative and executive branch, so they have to keep resorting to the one brach of the government where they don’t have to convince the people they’re right — the courts.
J.
Ha Ha Ha..
I can’t say much about the present Republican party that couldn’t be cut and pasted from your description of the Democrats. And the moonbats here keep accusing me of being a Republican too, JT.
However I did like this cartoon.
(note, cartoon from 9 May if you link after today)
Historical point–You are largely wrong to say FDR was a true believer. He was essentially a pragmatist, not an ideologue, particularly with how he dealt with the Depression in his first 100 days. To wit, here is a quote from FDR–
“Take a method and try it. If it fails, admit it frankly and try another”
Great cartoon.
I this this one is pretty right on also.
viet vet, you really are a tool.
Perhaps there ought to be a poll on who still believes in polls.
The only poll that counts is election day.
When the dimms fail to capture congress again in November whom are they going to believe, their own phoney polls or the election results? Wonder what the spin will be.
Some good thoughts there, Jay Tea. I would add one vital point that you omitted. For the “true believer” who actually wins an election to fail to act upon those principles upon which he was elected (as has an enormous herd of current Republicans) will always be disastrous to their poll numbers.
A “quick and dirty” analysis of how it works: Candidate X presents himself as radically different from Candidate Y, the incumbent. People like the way that X talks, really get behind him on his principles, feeling that he really thinks the same way about things and believes the same things are right as do they. Candidate X, meanwhile, is vilified as an idealogue and a “divisive” candidate by the supporters of Y. After the election, won by Candidate X, Y’s supporters aren’t swayed…they still don’t like X. When X takes office, the pressure exerted by the vocal minority who supported Y convinces him he needs to “soften” his stance on some of his principles. This message comes across to X’s supporters as a failure to act upon the principles that got X elected in the first place, so poll numbers plummet even among those who voted for X.
Next election, exasperated as his original voters are with X, they will likely still vote for him, preferring him to the alternative, but they still don’t like the fact that he didn’t adhere to the principles that made him the “different” candidate.
Such is the status of the RNC at this moment. Back in the mid-90s, people were tired of the DNC running the country with a staff of career politicians whose main objective was to further entrench themselves in the “DC Way” and to line their own pockets with tax dollars. Through the latter half of the 90s, the RNC reaped the benefits of that exasperation…and performed only marginally better, as they caved to pressure from that vocal minority (and the amplification by the MSM of that minority’s voice) to back down from the distinguishing (and yes, sometimes divisive) points upon which they were elected.
Maybe one day, the RNC will get the message that “not doing worse” than the other guys isn’t going to cut it. We want someone who will take the platform upon which they were elected and stand on the damned thing, rather than backing off when the pressure’s on.
cubanbob:
When the dimms fail to capture congress again in November…
Are you a betting man, CB? We are talking congress here and not the presidency, right?
I like Jamie’s scenario, but he left one thing out. Despite X’s display of “flexibility” and “willingness to listen” to Y’s people, he won’t get ONE VOTE from them. They’ll be out in force working for Candidate Z against X in the next cycle.
You are so right cubanbob, these pulls are b.s.moral boosters for the lib base! just like when Kerry was ahead according to exit polls in Ohio! wishful thinking..
Morale not moral, I meant.
Yep. I’m a betting man. Congress. Both houses.
The Senate and the the House of Representatives.
I’m saying the MSM polls are mostly bullshit. The dimms are not going to capture either house let alone both.
Being angry and frustrated with Bush and the Republicans doesn’t translate in to a vote for idiots, thieves and communists.
So astigafa what is your bet?
I wonder what the spin will be they loose again?
Like I said before, there ought to be a poll conducted on who actually believes the MSM polls.
Hmm… I’m not as gung-ho as cubanbob, but I think that’s a fairly safe bet. The Democrats will make some gains in the House, but not enough to garner a majority. However, it will still be spun as a major blow to Bush.
So, astigafa, care to make it a bet? And what sort of stakes are you willing to put up? You say the Dems will win back the House, cubanbob and I say no.
J.
Poor liberals. The voters have shut them out of the legislative and executive branch, so they have to keep resorting to the one brach of the government where they don’t have to convince the people they’re right — the courts.
Pretty sure it was the White House that called that particular investigation. The DOJ anyway.
clap harder, JT!
Well, if the Dems do make gains in the House or Senate, it will be a blow to the GOP. They don’t have that much of a lead in the Senate as it is.
I think they have a decent shot at the House, though they’ll have to get the “liberal press” to stop with the right wing spin that they don’t have an agenda.
Unlikely to happen though, given the oral that the MSM has been performing on Bush and the GOP since 2000.
Seriously hilarious depths of denial over here. Congratulations. My approval rating for you is 100%!
Being angry and frustrated with Bush and the Republicans doesn’t translate in to a vote for idiots, thieves and communists.
But the voters already DID vote for a bunch of idiots, thieves and communists (specifically, trotskyites).
Wait, which party are we talking about here?
I’m surprised to read this collection. With 48% of Conservatives and 65% of the nation disapproving of Bush, so much energy is spent maligning polling. This is not an argument of 5% or 2% as it was during the past two presidential elections. This is a landslide opinion of disgust. Let’s face facts, conservatives need to stop forgiving Bush and promoting him no matter what incompetent screw up he makes and work to preserving the Republic. Bush is not the answer, he is the problem.
AN anecdote about campus politics is always such a great metaphor for a national poll, don’t you think? Apparently you do.
As for “Beating Someone With No One,” well, this is rope-a-dope. Give Bush enough rope and he’ll hang all the GOP dopes.
bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls. bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls. bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls. bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls.
Excuse ME! This is one of the tiredest, lamest pieces of male bovine excrement that has ever come out of white house spin machine. Bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls??? Then why does he keep soon-to-be-indicted criminal mastermind Karl Rove on the public payroll? Yes, you can repeat this canard all you like, but it just isn’t true.
bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls. bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls. bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls. bush doesn’t pay attention to the polls.
Yeah, right.
Marc, the point you are missing, the point that much of the left missed in the last election cycle:
Lack of approval for one candidate does not equate to approval of the opposistion.
I have a 33% approval rating for Miller.
But I have a 5% approval for Coors.
When I attend a BBQ and those are my only choices (going sober, when family is concentrated may not be an option), I am grabbing a can of Miller.
Also, a large chunk of Bush’s low numbers are from his own base right now. About things like borders and immigration. We may not like how he’s handling it, and how the Reps are sticking their heads in the sand (or bending over for companies like Tyson or pandering to a potential group of future voters), but we aren’t going to vote in the party that tries to RECRUIT at the ILLEGAL immigrant rallies either!
No, the dissillusioned base will speak out in the primaries, and then either vote in the cadidates they hate the least, OR they will stay home out of disgust.
This is assuming the Dems don’t put up lightning rod candidates red staters will oppose even if it means voting for a complete loser (kinda sounds like the Kerry-Edwards strategy… they’ll vote for us because we aren’t Bush). Hillary Clinton, Howard Dean, Dennis Kuchinch(sp?) etc, are the type that could bring out the red vote despite a weak red ticket, IMO.
Yes, you can repeat this canard all you like, but it just isn’t true.
Heh….ironic, isn’t it….an allusion to repetition begetting reality coming from a liberal commenter.
In all honesty, though, I wish Bush (and by extension, the GOP) didn’t pay attention to the polls. I say let the libs & dems scream all they want, dance with the one what brung ya.
malangali,
Rove spins and Bush still does what he wants to do (if he listened to polls, he’d know that his base thinks his border policy is destructive and bone headed) 90% of the time. And most of what Rove does is act as the Left’s boogey man.
When people say Bush ignores the polls, they are making the disctinction between his and the previous administration which polled and focused grouped nearly everything they did.
Wow, a president who stands for what he believes instead of what the people want…why do I pay his salary again? I thought this was a democracy…?
Granted, that’s over-simplified, but so is the praise of an elected official for ignoring the changing desires of the people who elected him to represent them.
You say the Dems will win back the House, cubanbob and I say no.
We were talking House and Senate. Split bet? I do money, liquor or embarrasing public acts — rather fond of them all, really: they just go together.
cubanbob.
You are simply one of those people that dismiss as wrong, anything that does not agree with you views regardless of the evidence (Kind of like your compadre Bush); Or to put it in blunt terms, You (and Bush)are full of B.S.
Your fellow Republicans are not idiots. They PAY ATTENTION to the polls. They are trying desperately to do something to change them.If they don’t they know they will loose in November.
If Republican politicians would take your “Polls are always wrong” approach THEY WOULD BE EXTINCT.
Get a brain my friend.
Jay tea.
As far as the future goes you can create your own ready made delusion. That is the only thing left for people like you, when you see the present falling apart.
It is called mental masturbation. it’s realy sad.
“Seriously hilarious depths of denial over here. Congratulations. My approval rating for you is 100%!”
Serious denial indeed. (It ain’t just a river in Egypt)
Jay “The Jizzer” Tea has been wrong on so many counts, I won’t even run through them. Now he resorts to just calling people retarded. It’s all pretty funny watching it crumble at this point.
You libs are the ones fascinated by your ability to concoct a poll study showing your side always ahead or just about to take back something or proclaiming to speak for the majority when in actually the samplings are of less than 300th of 1% of the countrys population, not to mention weighted to favor the objectives of the poll taking group. so it is impossible to draw any definitive proof that polls suggest anything other then tiny snapshots of political leanings. in other words B.S.
High gas prices, never ending and pointless war, institutionalized corruption, increasing health care costs, and decreasing wages are finally convincing people to peek out of their corporate media echo chambers. Weather or not Dems can capitalize on that still remains to be seen.
See you at the ballot box.
Actually, it is quite amusing to see all the Right Wing blowhards scream and cry and claim “oversample” whenever the polls come out in a way they don’t like.
There are more Democrats than Republicans and that has always been true. What the pollsters are accurately capturing is that people are defecting from the Republican Party in droves.
My brother, a Conservative lawyer who is on the Chamber of Commerce and also a born again Christian campaigned hard for Bush in 2004.
Last time I talked to him he told me he is really not a die-hard GOP guy, he is really an “independent.” That same decision is being made all over the country and that is what we are seeing.
But keep drinking the Kool Aide, Bush apologists. I actually prefer that you continue to delude yourselves into thinking that Bush is loved by all and continue on your disastrous course. Well, disastrous for you. Great news for America.
Most Americans describe themselves as Democrats (although not by the margins they used to), so any sample of the ‘general public’ skews that way if done correctly. Statistically, this is appropriate – the poll should skew however the general population does.
Also, Bush just threw a lotof people overboard and gave up and quit on big initiatives (Social Security reform) based on polls. He has cranked up the anti-gas price rhetoric (despite being an oil man) because of polls. Polls are all any politician cares about. The difference is that Bush only wants 51% approval, wheras Clinton and Reagan looked to get mid-60’s.
Politics is a 365-day eternal re-election bid, make no mistake about it. If not for self (2 termer) than for the party.
Sad thing is that Bush has only been loved when he’s gotten the country attacked through inaction. His numbers rose on 9/11 and have steadily decreased thereafter. What a sad statement for Bush and foor the American people.
how can you say “…he has his own beliefs and principles, and he stands by them solidly…” with a straight face. this guy flips and flops more than a sun-fish pulled from his stocked pond in crawford. stop buying into the mythology and face reality.
Oh, and he was for the Dubai Ports Deal before he was against it.
You’re just going to have to deal with the facts: Bush is an historically unpopular president that has failed his people and his constitution.
Moochazillahudeen
How exactly did Bushs inaction get us attacked? what in hells name are you sniveling about?
I believe He was for the terminals deal right till the end!
Aran, He is not a historical anything yet He,s still in office pion.
these are facts, not apologys you Air America Rejects..
cjimangaconquistador.
The same comment as cubanbob, that deserves the same answer.
You own Republican politician friends are not Idiots. They are desperately trying to do something to change the same polls you dismiss as wrong.
You on the other hand would rather make pretend and make your own reality.
Funny I never heard of a liberal dismissing Bush ‘s polls after 9/11 (in the 90%’s)as wrong.
The polls came from the same people as today’s polls. Where they wrong after 9/11 also?. Or is it just the present number you don’t like.
Grow up. A sign of maturity is to accept bad news, and try to do something about it.
But if you want to make a Democrat a favor keep on and convince more Reps that everithing is peach and cool aid.
I see that, once again, a relatively benign tidbit of political commentating has turned into a full-fledged food fight.
astig, I’ll bet a 12 pack of [insert preferred brand of beer] on the GOP for each house (a case in all at risk); and if either side wins both houses, the loser has to don a Cindy Sheehan mask and sing “Stars and Stripes Forever” on the steps of the ACLU national headquarters in Manhattan.
As Howie Mandel would say, “deal, or no deal??”
gil
If they came from the same people then theres definetly something rotten in Denmark.
I am not a republican, nor do I own one?
I could,nt care less what the polls say good or bad its irrelevant! kind of like the Emmys or Grammy awards. means zero nada.
Im not a bush supporter
It would be a sign of maturity if You could frame a coherent argument to support Your flailing positions let alone annunciate clearly. sincerely Chimangaconquistador..
Hey Dick,
Oh, so I am with the terrorists because I question the President. With the mujahadeen reference.
Didn’t you used to blow the mujahadeen when they were fighting the USSR? Now it is a dirty word. Whatever, you commie. You follower.
Your president ignored instructions from the outgoing administraton to place Al Qaeda as enemy #1 (instead of Iraq) in the transfer meetings. Your president went fishing when presneted with warnings that they wanted to attack America using aviation. Your president staffed the CIA with ‘yes men’ who failed.
But most notably, your president sat there and read “My Pet Goat” with the nation under attack. Patton slapped guys for stuff like that.
Turn off Fox News and read a book. I just started reading Cobra II – a book written by a bunch of guys who I’m sure you would describe as sniveling, weak liberals. But who are anything but.
Funny, since you are a follower you’ll be following the polls soon as well, trashing your president just like everyone else.
And he ran and hid when the Ports Deal (which I happened to think was a non-issue given awful port security in general) became unpopular. He’s great at hiding! Hid after 9/11. Hid after Katrina. Hid after Cheney shooting. There is only one person better at hiding than him I guess – Osama Bin Laden. Are we catching OBL anytime soon? What was that again – “dead or alive”? I’ll take the former if anyone cares.
‘bush sux. rethugs sux.’
The fact that he was elected *twice* means nothing.
The fact that the Reps won the House and Senate means nothing.
The fact that the last time a Democrat presidential candidate got over 50% of the vote was in 1976 means nothing.
If you guys think the Dems have been doing well lately…..yikes. With friends like you, the Dems don’t need enemies.
But back to the point – polls are BS to some extent (wasn’t Kerry going to win the election based on exit polling?), but your attack on the methodology is off-base. For whatever reason most Americans describe themselves as Democrats, no matter how they eventually end up voting. That is why you should be THRILLED when they are on the plus side – it is much harder for the GOP to get those high marks.
In my line of work we use stats all the time, but you can tell if they are true based on the buzz – the word on the street. There is a lot of anger out there right now – you know anecdotally that the POTUS is not popular, that he is being held accountable personally. He fired or pushed out a few people, but to no avail – Americans blame him. Based on that these numbers make sense. Could Colbert have done what he did a year ago? Would you see such public anti-Bush comments even last Fall? Maybe it is just the gas prices that enables people, but that does not make it less real.
And this comes from a guy who believes Bush will be back to 42% by October – I believe that America is so afraid of change that both houses will stay with the GOP.