One day the story of WMD in Iraq will be known, at least partially. For now, the information is coming out in bits and pieces. Bottom line — those who said there was no WMD in Iraq were wrong. (Using the definition and standard they set for President Bush, I guess that means they were lying, right?)
Jay at Stop the ACLU has a great roundup of blogosphere reaction to the latest from Pete Hoekstra and Rick Santorum:
U.S. Senator Rick Santorum (R-PA), Chairman of the Senate Republican Conference, joined Congressman Peter Hoekstra, (R-MI-2), Chairman of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, today to make a major announcement regarding the release of newly declassified information that proves the existence of chemical munitions in Iraq since 2003. The information was released by the Director of National Intelligence, John Negroponte, and contained an unclassified summary of analysis conducted by the National Ground Intelligence Center. In March, Senator Santorum began advocating for the release of these documents to the American public.
“The information released today proves that weapons of mass destruction are, in fact, in Iraq,” said Senator Santorum. “It is essential for the American people to understand that these weapons are in Iraq. I will continue to advocate for the complete declassification of this report so we can more fully understand the complete WMD picture inside Iraq.”
The following are the six key points contained in the unclassified overview:
• Since 2003 Coalition forces have recovered approximately 500 weapons munitions which contain degraded mustard or sarin nerve agent.
• Despite many efforts to locate and destroy Iraq’s pre-Gulf War chemical munitions, filled and unfilled pre-Gulf War chemical munitions are assessed to still exist.
• Pre-Gulf War Iraqi chemical weapons could be sold on the black market. Use of these weapons by terrorists or insurgent groups would have implications for Coalition forces in Iraq. The possibility of use outside Iraq cannot be ruled out.
• The most likely munitions remaining are sarin and mustard-filled projectiles.
• The purity of the agent inside the munitions depends on many factors, including the manufacturing process, potential additives, and environmental storage conditions. While agents degrade over time, chemical warfare agents remain hazardous and potentially lethal.
• It has been reported in open press that insurgents and Iraqi groups desire to acquire and use chemical weapons. I have not checked in at the major liberal blogs to get reaction. My guess is that the conventional wisdom is still that Bush lied about WMD and that there was none in Iraq. (I will update later if I find this not to be the case.) What I find absolutely amazing is that many of those who believe Bush had something to do with the Twin Towers collapsing and who believe that John Kerry really won in Ohio find it impossible to believe that Saddam had WMD — even though Bill Clinton, the UN, France and dozens of Democrat politicians said he did over and over again.
Over two years ago, I found Ken Timmerman’s report of WMD found in Iraq quite compelling, but no one ever seemed to pay much attention to it. (Be sure to read it if you aren’t already familiar with it .) Maybe eventually all the information found will be compiled and we will have a comprehensive picture of everything that has been found. Maybe the media will even decide to report it.
UPDATE: From A Real Ugly American (via Flopping Aces’ excellent, must read post):
General Tom Mcinerney is reporting on Fox Hannity and Colmes right now that that the administration has been keeping this low profile to avoid exposing 3 of the 5 members of the UN Security council; Russia, China, and France. McInerney says these weapons will be traced to these countries, and asserts it is well known that Russia helped Saddam move most of his WMD stockpiles out of Iraq before the war.
I have on several occasions speculated about why the President would not be touting the information we have about WMD found in Iraq and had come to a similar conclusion. My theory was that if the public knew that certain other countries had been involved with moving WMD, they would demand action that we did not want to, or were not able to, take.
Check out Pajamas Media’s WMD Files for previous blogging on the subject. Just for the record, I never doubted.

KC, is your last question meant to be serious? What is the basis for deciding a moral war? There is one correct answer. Because the answer is obvious, I am going to cheat by requiring you to answer first. You tell me, what is the moral basis for determining a just war? Because of moral relativism, liberals usually struggle with this question a whole whopping lot.
Your attempt to reverse the question is amusing. You’re the “decider”, remember? The Iraq war was ONE moral necessity. It is your responsibility to name the “next moral necessity” if you wish to continue the conversation.
As a start – and with a basis in economic and geopolitical realism – I’d say that it’s when a country is attacked in an unprovoked fashion.
Off to bed now. Maybe you’ll be around tomorrow.
‘ Morality is not enforceable in that no sufficient model has ever been devised to adequately predict the outcome of human relationships” Not to Your sadistic twisted logic anyways.
mccain – I’ll leave you with one last question (or rather rephrase a previous one):
If you’re such a bleeding heart morally concerned individual and you’re so concerned with the welfare of the Iraqi people under Saddam – do you purport to say that ther aren’t people living in conditions much worse? What’s your answer to these people? Are they next on the “we’ll come to your rescue” list? Or are we primarily concerned with those who can be freed militarily?
You’re a massive hypocrite, and I regret wasting the time that I have here “debating” a liar.
You deserve to burn in hell.
KC, I forgot to add that your insistence on getting the last word is another sign of your maturity. I think it would be simpler to say “I must go last” than to type a lot of words which don’t have any relevance. With liberals, the substance of the thought is inversely related to the oxygen consumed.
I am forced to speculate that you think you have made some great points. This thread is about the discovery of WMD. You seem to be making two points. First, that maybe evil America gave him the WMD. That of course is a logical fallacy, an utter non-sequitur. Your second point is that these WMD weapons do not matter. It is unclear if it is the specific quantify of the WMD discovered that does not matter to you or if WMD itself does not matter. On this we agree. WMD does not matter to the moral correcness of our action. Do you have any other point to make in your wordy way?
914 –
Tell ya what. Shut your trap and quit preaching to people. Someone besides me might listen to you when you stop pretending to be the voice of Jesus Christ himself.
You know very little.
And you obviously sleep very little.
Yes Im tired, wheres My baby Hitler doll.
“If you’re such a bleeding heart morally concerned individual and you’re so concerned with the welfare of the Iraqi people under Saddam – do you purport to say that ther aren’t people living in conditions much worse?”
Again, you don’t even understand that you are making moral relativity arguments. I reject them, as do any logically thinking person, as determinant of anything at all. Moral relativist arguments are by definition indeterminant.
If you were to rephrase your question in a logical way, the answer is what you have already heard but not understood. With all actions, there is a moral calculation that must occur that weighs risks and rewards. It is hard to find other examples where we can reasonably expect 2,000,000 more people to die if we do nothing. You perhaps CAN find examples elsewhere in the word, but the risk/reward assessment must be made. When the risks and potential rewards are similar, of course we should act.
KC anytime you have anything Worthwhile to say…well you can pretend anyways.
You know far less! God bless always..
mccain,
last word quip aside, you should stop digging now.
If you expect anyone to believe you have any education or applicable experience in probabalistic methods, you’d know that it’s “inversely proportionate”, but I stray from the point.
You seem to be making two points. First, that maybe evil America gave him the WMD.
Correct!
Point 1: Well, America DID give him WMDs, as proven by Congressional Reports, intelligence sources, etc. Do you deny this? Do you support the moral basis for such actions on the part of the U.S.? Apparently you do, even as it contradicts your underlying philosophy.
Your second point is that these WMD weapons do not matter. It is unclear if it is the specific quantify of the WMD discovered that does not matter to you or if WMD itself does not matter. On this we agree. WMD does not matter to the moral correcness of our action. Do you have any other point to make in your wordy way?
Point 2: It’s not that they “do not matter”, rather do the matter in the context of the point that this thread is trying to make? The answer, of course, is no. They are WMDs that we already knew about, supported, and were defunct. The point of this article, in case it is lost on you, is that this somehow vindicates the position of the Administration that Saddam did, indeed have an ONGOING WMD PROGRAM, which it decidedly does not. Your inability to debate a point on its merits was made clear early on. Quantity has no bearing on this dicussion. These were unusable, discarded, and forgotten WMDs that were only of questionable use to the current insurgents. So in the sense that they are being trumpeted by desperate members of your Intelligent Design party, they are meaningless. People who embrace reality can see this readily.
So, for my reading pleasure tomorrow, tell me how either of these points are logical fallacies, and how they are NOT inter-related.
Better yet, save your breath and stop embarrassing yourself.
mccain,
last word quip aside, you should stop digging now.
If you expect anyone to believe you have any education or applicable experience in probabalistic methods, you’d know that it’s “inversely proportionate”, but I stray from the point.
You seem to be making two points. First, that maybe evil America gave him the WMD.
Correct!
Point 1: Well, America DID give him WMDs, as proven by Congressional Reports, intelligence sources, etc. Do you deny this? Do you support the moral basis for such actions on the part of the U.S.? Apparently you do, even as it contradicts your underlying philosophy.
Your second point is that these WMD weapons do not matter. It is unclear if it is the specific quantify of the WMD discovered that does not matter to you or if WMD itself does not matter. On this we agree. WMD does not matter to the moral correcness of our action. Do you have any other point to make in your wordy way?
Point 2: It’s not that they “do not matter”, rather do the matter in the context of the point that this thread is trying to make? The answer, of course, is no. They are WMDs that we already knew about, supported, and were defunct. The point of this article, in case it is lost on you, is that this somehow vindicates the position of the Administration that Saddam did, indeed have an ONGOING WMD PROGRAM, which it decidedly does not. Your inability to debate a point on its merits was made clear early on. Quantity has no bearing on this dicussion. These were unusable, discarded, and forgotten WMDs that were only of questionable use to the current insurgents. So in the sense that they are being trumpeted by desperate members of your Intelligent Design party, they are meaningless. People who embrace reality can see this readily.
So, for my reading pleasure tomorrow, tell me how either of these points are logical fallacies, and how they are NOT inter-related.
Better yet, save your breath and stop embarrassing yourself.
Strange error. Sorry for the repeat post.
Good night wing nuts.
Time for bed, gentlemen. KC, it has been “educational” listening to a typical young liberal profering typical anti-American rhetoric about your country’s moral actions in the world. At Churchill said, young conservatives have no heart, while older liberals have no brain. I will look forward to your transformation as you develop your intellectual capacity and fully see the world for what it is. Good luck in this pursuit.
By God, as if one wordy post isn’t enough he does it twice. There is an interesting phenomenon in the liberal mind that they become more relevant when they are louder. I’m afraid it isn’t so.
If you were to rephrase your question in a logical way, the answer is what you have already heard but not understood. With all actions, there is a moral calculation that must occur that weighs risks and rewards. It is hard to find other examples where we can reasonably expect 2,000,000 more people to die if we do nothing.
So if the hands-off policy towards the Sudan is kept in place, and given that militarily it’s practically a no risk situation, and we don’t act – you’re going to be up in arms, right?
Please, asshole – let’s hear your answer.
Not yet, germs.
KC, it has been “educational” listening to a typical young liberal profering typical anti-American rhetoric about your country’s moral actions in the world.
You have a gift for typing fighting words behind the vast internets and your screen.
If you can point out any anti-American rhetoric in my posts, I’ll forego the urge to punch you in the mouth, or rather, challenge you to a duel.
Get it, tough guy? You’re a lightweight.
KC
Now that you have found this assylum thru whatever Sanitorium link that brought you here, I hope you stay around and post some more from time to time. You are tenacious and your posts are well thought out.
You have McCain & 914 twisted around themselves w/ their crypto-fascist neocon thinking .
Wow, I missed alot since I posted last.
The only person I would like to address is Tom who spent alot of time writing to me his opinion and trying to pass it off as universal fact.
You start, Tom, by mentioning that you welcome the debate, but then proceed to trying to tell me who I am, what I beleive, what my education is, so on. Let me tell you something. No one would know better than I if my civil liberties are eroded, so don’t go playing omnipotent and lecturing me on the state of my life. Your infantile finger-pointing does not prove a point.
I don’t have a weak grasp on global issues Tom, I don’t have your grasp on global issues and that irks you doesn’t it?
Cheney is undermining our civil liberties every day?
Yet, you’re just saying that, there is no evidence of it. As I said and stand by, I have the same liberties I had before 911, so take off your tin foil hat and educate yourself instead of just jumping on the progressive bandwagon.
mak44,
I agree, the new blood is nice here. Even if I dont agree with alot of people that stopped by…it’s nice to not argue with all the same people everytime.
Uh, Heralder:
“I have the same liberties I had before 911”
Uh – no you don’t. E.G. 1:
Before 9/11 the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act was enforced, and failure by the government to obtain a warrant before wiretapping you was considered to be a felony punishable by 5 yrs in prison and a $10,000 fine.
Now – courtesy Ashcroft, Gonzales & Bush – it is no longer enforced.
E.G. 2: Before 9/11, as an American citizen you had a right to counsel and to confront your accusers. Now – if the Chimp deems you to be a “terrorist” all such protections may or MAY NOT be afforded you.
R. Lewis,
I think you miss the point. If Heralder, or those who believe as he does were to be investigated via illegal wiretapping/data snooping, and arrested on suspicion of plotting terroristic endeavors, sent off to a black site prison, and waterboarded without any due process, any contact with the outside world, and any hope of ever being released, they might begin to understand.
However, they are of the opinion that they simply need show their Republican voter registration card, and they’b be granted a pass.
mak44,
you hit the nail on the head. these guys (well, mccain really – since 914 is really not debating anything) will contort and twist their version of reality to suit their pre-conceived ideologies, even at the expense of contradicting these ideologies when it’s convenient to the “point” they are trying to make.
That’s why mccain eschewed discussion on the WMD find and relevance early on. In his mind, we’re fighting a morally just and necessary war. That it is actually a different war than that which was (wrongly) approved by the U.S. Congress is either invisible to him or too inconvenient to his underlying philosophy to admit. As I said before, he seems to be of the opinion that we can now sell wars on the bases of their relative moral value to the Congress and the American people in order to prosecute them overseas. Yet, when asked what the next “moral” action we should take is, even in his own opinion, he tucks his tail between his legs and retreats to vague generalities on morality and
the probability that these wars will eventually spawn “democracy” in the Middle East and the world.
1. What is our next military “moral action”, and what are the risks/rewards of this action? Your own opinion is fine.
2. Do you recognize the Hamas government of the Palestinian territories as a democracy? Would you be satisfied that if such democracies are elected that we’d see an end to armed conflict in the area?
KC
Sorry to keave You in such a quandry. But in all honesty Your the lightweight KID.
That’s okay guys. You can tell me till your blue in the face that in a theoretical situation I have lost my civil liberties. When innocent people begin to get marched off to prison for no reason I’ll come back to Wizbang and ammend my statement.
Yet again, my quality of life and my liberties have not been impacted since 911. You can tell me how my life has changed all you want, but I tend to form opinions based on experience. Thanks for your concern for me though.
Heralder,
I appreciate the willingness to debate. And I agree that most of our lives have not noticeably changed from a civil liberties perspective.
That’s okay guys. You can tell me till your blue in the face that in a theoretical situation I have lost my civil liberties. When innocent people begin to get marched off to prison for no reason I’ll come back to Wizbang and ammend my statement.
The only problem with this, Heralder is that without oversight and due process, we:
a) may not even KNOW that innocent people are being “marched off”
b) said people may never have a chance to even prove their innocence.
Is that so hard to postulate given the Executive power grab since 9/11?
914 – Are you a bot? Do you know what a “bot” is?
Does that compute?
KC
a)May not even KNOW that innocent people are being “marched off”
A hypothetical filled with paranoia and distrust.
b)Said people may never have a chance to prove their innocence
Said people exist only in Your convuluted logic.
KC, are You a phonie chronie? do You even know what one is?
Sigh – 914,
Do you mean “crony”?
A hypothetical filled with paranoia and distrust.
Do some research on what happened in Nazi Germany. Some villagers simply didn’t know what was happening when their neighbors disappeared, nor did they ask questions about the strange dust that the compound behind their village produced.
Slinging the word “paranoid” around does nothing for your credibility, and if you can’t imagine something similar ever happening again – please tell me why.
Said people exist only in Your convuluted logic.
Said people already exist in Guantanamo, and at countless, nameless black gulags scattered throughout the world. Just hope you don’t end up in one – they probably won’t give you chewing tabacky in there.
KC,
Of course there could be people being marched off and imprisoned wrongly without due process, without us knowing about it.
But yes it is, a theoretical situation. I understand you have little faith in our government and current president, but to think that he is deranged to the degree that this would happen is beyond my powers of reasoning.
Naturally it is within our right, and in fact we are obliged to, as Americans, to question our represenatives and to make sure this sort of thing does not happen. Bush may not be what you want him to be, but a fascist dictator he is not.
Perhaps some of my doubt comes from what kinds of dots you would have to mis-connect to think an average citizen was planning a terrorist attack when he was not. It seems quite difficult to screw up that badly, in plain terms.
KC,
In light of your response to 914, let me give my take on what you said:
Do some research on what happened in Nazi Germany. Some villagers simply didn’t know what was happening when their neighbors disappeared, nor did they ask questions about the strange dust that the compound behind their village produced.
A wise example to look at, to be sure. It does, however, fail right at the point to try to parallel it to a current Western democracy. How is it that some will think it not far-fetched to comapre Nazi Germany to Bush America? I see no like circumstances.
Said people already exist in Guantanamo, and at countless, nameless black gulags scattered throughout the world.
Guantanamo exists as housing for enemy combatants captured abroad. We are failing with Guantanamo because there have been no rules set forth before now to deal with exactly this type of situation.
Again I feel that Guatanamo and these “black gulags” (which there is no substantiated legal evidence of) are an erroneous comparison to our domestic civil liberties.
KC,
Just another question, and answer honestly, it is in no way a loaded question:
If your chosen candidate were president, and had instituted the same anti-terro laws, would you be comparing situations that happend in Nazi Germany to America today?
Good morning, KC. This thread is about to scroll off the homepage. You will be able to find it burried through a search so that you can continue your heroic vigil in the defence of something or other that nobody will read. I have concluded that you are a narcissist, which is typical for your tender years and is typical for liberals. Depression often results in self-loathing, the curious ability to hate oneself. You are a wonderful example of a typical liberal and so I enjoyed our exchange greatly from an educational perspective.
Your hatred of America is right out of Chomsky. Since you pretend to want an example (again) of your anti-Americanisms, I refer you again to the language you used yesterday, of which you later pretended to be kidding. More generally, your strange obsession with refuting this WMD report, as if it matters at all to the morality of the war, gives away the fact that you will do anything to lower public support for the war, no matter how disengenuous. Lower public support means lower troop morale. Lower troop morale means more dead soldiers. Your liberal rhetoric gets our soldiers killed.
You triumphantly ask a question about the next conflict, as if the question itself is an answer, but you did not answer my question about conflicts more generally. My question is when is a war just? Answer that easy question first, and then I will answer your question.
[ pin drop ]
Heralder
You posted: “Yet again, my quality of life and my liberties have not been impacted since 911. You can tell me how my life has changed all you want, but I tend to form opinions based on experience.”
A poem attributed to Martin Niemöller, an early supporter of Hitler, who later changed his convictions, after having steered clear of the Bazis until 1937, goes as follows:
When the Nazis came for the communists,
I remained silent;
I was not a communist.
When they locked up the social democrats,
I remained silent;
I was not a social democrat.
When they came for the trade unionists,
I did not speak out;
I was not a trade unionist.
When they came for the Jews,
I did not speak out;
I was not a Jew.
When they came for me,
there was no one left to speak out.
Well Mak, If You suddenly “disappear” we’ll know where You went..
If your chosen candidate were president, and had instituted the same anti-terro laws, would you be comparing situations that happend in Nazi Germany to America today?
An honest answer: Hell yes I would. I won’t even go into the fact thatI don’t think that “my chosen candidate” would have felt it necessary to circumvent the existing framework with which to accomplish legal domestic surveillance, then lie about it to cover it up. But if he/she had, I’d be just as pissed as I am today.
But yes it is, a theoretical situation. I understand you have little faith in our government and current president, but to think that he is deranged to the degree that this would happen is beyond my powers of reasoning.
Ah, but it’s a slippery slope, Heralder. Perhaps I’m not worried about “him” in particular. Perhaps I’m worried that the erosions of our civil liberties – or the framework that supports them – will eventually fall into the hands of another president without the scruples you right wingers so lavishly praise and readily assume that Bush possesses.
He’s shown before his inability to manage the consequenses of his actions, and even the inability to consider that there will be consequences to his actions, and I fear that the laws in place to protect us from terrorists are no more effective than the laws which already existed when used properly. The new framework, i.e. usurpation of power by the Executive branch simply lays the groundwork for further forays into a fascist executive fuhrer.
914
“when they were a 100% fresh and lethal, what was the objective of these weapons? to plop harmlessly in the sand or to murder by the 1,000s??”
When they were 100%fresh they were close to 100% functional. Over time the components become unreliable. They were design for a battlefield environment and being unreliable would make them ineffective and they can blow up in your face. Just like we don’t use munitions past their expiration date. It really sucks when a T.O.W. missile misfires. We don’t even use bullets that get to old. Not because that won’t fire or can’t kill but because of hazards to the user. The WMD shells may not be effective on a typical conventional battlefield like they were design for but good be of great use to a terrorist.
David Kay had issues with Bush when he was appointed. Politics make strange bedfellows. Besides nobody likes to be proven wrong.
mak44, that is a good poem which you apparently are unaware is directed toward immoral people who will risk nothing in the defence of liberty for other peoples. The last verse is what the Iraqi will say if liberals ever get their way.
McCain,
Your idiotic (and incorrect) guesswork as to my age and psychological temperment aside, I feel that I have intimidated you into again retreating back to rhetoric. Furthermore, as you have demonstrated a few times in this thread, your reading comprehension skills are almost as lacking and stunted as your reasoning ability.
My question is when is a war just? Answer that easy question first, and then I will answer your question.
As I stated BEFORE – A war is just when waged against a state that not only offers a realistic and demonstrable threat to the very existence of the nation making war, but has demonstrated the desire to do so by direct action. Whether this is an economic attack, or direct military attack. Either way, a nation must be attacked or be threatened with a legitimate imminent attack by another nation to wage a just war. There are other situations whereby a war may be considered just such as an ally being attacked in an unprovoked fashion.
Once you start defining war as just based on your particular moral beliefs, and not applying the same beliefs and rationale for war to all such transgressions, you become at best a noble hypocrite, and at worst expose your TRUE motivations for waging said wars. Oil? Again, what’s your answer on The Sudan?
That’s my OFF THE CUFF answer to you, even though you predictably deem any sentence over 10 words, and with any words you have to look up in the dictionary to be the rantings of a “narcissist”. It’s your defense mechanism, and I can try to understand.
More generally, your strange obsession with refuting this WMD report, as if it matters at all to the morality of the war, gives away the fact that you will do anything to lower public support for the war, no matter how disengenuous. Lower public support means lower troop morale. Lower troop morale means more dead soldiers. Your liberal rhetoric gets our soldiers killed.
1. The report has been successfully refuted. See posts above. End of story. It is what it is.
2. Now that you’ve said that opposing the war gets soldiers killed, prove it. Add that to the long list of questions you’re unable or simply too disingenuous to answer.
And BTW, as you seem obsessed with my age – I’m in my 30’s. But I think what you’re really saying, and possibly correctly, is that anyone with the patience to sit here and argue with you despite your obfuscation, ignorance on the topics (despite your protestation to the contrary), and willingness to say anything to score brownie points with your peanut gallery here, is in some way immature, then I think the proper term for that is projection.
Look it up.
KC & McCain, as well
KC, in answer to the 1st question you posed to McCain, the next moral war will be Iran. McCain & the rest of the inmates here at the Wizbang Assylum have already been beating the drums for just such action in threads posted since I first came across this Ship of Fools.
McCain’s response to my earlier question much further above as to where in the Constitution is the power of a President to conduct moral wars of liberation authorized, produced an insane response from McCain, that even Hitler could have used, had he been fettered by a constitution.
McCain & his ilk, Heralder, 914, Love America Immigrant et al are ready to sound the trumpets of war anytime some crypto-fascist like a Santorum jerks their string w/ jingoism.
You have seen this repeatedly in this thread now over 2 days. Because that sickening puke Santorum came running breathlessly w/ his newly declassified war propaganda re WMD’s, these fools will argue ad nauseum that Sen. Puking Santorum’s jingoistic rattle is all the justification required.
McCain, who doesn’t even realize what a crypto-fascist that he is, is ready to march others off to a bloody death for what he deems as morally justified wars formwhat he deems a greater good. He is Voltaire’s Dr. Pangloss incarnate. He should try reading Candide. And you can see from his response to my query above about the Constitution, the Constitution is no limitation whatsoever.
What this militaristic fool and the rest here like him don’t get is that if you are going to approbate the right to make moral determinations about so-called “just” wars, then there are 6.5 billion people on this planet entitled to their opinions as to what constitutes a “just war.” These Republicans, in spite of their denials, are in reality, Darwinists because they labor under the illusion that they are the fittest & therefore assume that their survival is certain, and of course, ordained by God, since they are of the “Judeo-Christian” ethic. And, sigh, if it doesn’t all work out, then that will be ok because they will have been God’s agents in His design to precipitate the End of Days.
McCain’s thinking in regard to “moral wars” makes him no different from the Islamofascists that he abhors.
And of course, McCain’s delusion that “Democracies” don’t fight one another is naive beyond belief. It is predicated on the insane delusion that we in the US have the moral right to gift the world w/ carbon copies of our political & economic system (Predatory Capitalism) for the benefit of the entire world.
If McCain and the rest of the assylum inmates get their wish for military incursion into Iraq they will be appalled at the world-wide political & economic results that will occur from that day forward.
What I find most appalling is that the dawn of the new Millenium just 6 years ago was an occasion where the world anticipated the most magnificent century ever w/ the potential for changes & innovation exceeding anyone’s imagination, and in 6 short years, Bush/Cheney Co. have managed to turn the 21st Century’s promise into a bleak & foreboding future, quite possibly portending the doom of humanity on this planet.
Quite frankly, this Republican mentality is proof that a significant part of the human species is genetically malprogrammed for the species’ survival.
KC, et me guess, your field of study was psychology? Or was it English? The reason that liberals such as you are generally illogical (and you don’t even realize it!) is that they are not trained in mathematics and the sciences. I’m guessing that your dissertation was something like Rousseau’s Neurosis: Adverb Usage and Wiener Size in the Age of Reason”
You failed the just war test. A war is just when the misery it causes is lesser than the misery that will result from not warring. Consider this axiom when listening to liberals call for an immoral pullout from Iraq.
Regarding the effect of public support on troop morality, and troop morality on battlefield perforance, you will need to get versed in military tactics before I can expect you to have a serious conversation about the topic. Start by reading Sun-Tzu. The body of impirical evidence is clear and has been known to military planners for at least 2,500 years, for everyone but illogical liberals.
McCain has obviously chosen to distance himself from the crumbling rationale offered up by the Administration, and decided to find and trumpet new reasons to support the current war that are more compatible with his moral inclinations, and for that very reason more difficult to refute with actual, reality-based facts.
His ability to rationalize and aggrandize the current war is indicative of intellectual immaturity, and the willingness to subscribe to a mob mentality should the situation present itself.
Once the underlying tenet of a given thread is proven false – especially one which purports to offer foundations for his irrational belief in this war, he shows a marked desire to emerge as “victorious” by diverting the subject of discussion to abstract philosphical questions to which there are no definitive answers.
I’d say he probably dropped out of college after about 2.5 years.
KC, et me guess, your field of study was psychology? Or was it English?
No, I’m flattered, but it was Electrical Engineering with a focus on Semiconductor Device Physics. I read on many subjects, however – and spare me your paint-by-numbers amateur assessment on the psyches of engineers and physicists.
I work for a mid-sized company that happens to also do defense contract work, and have more inside knowledge of what is happening, and the real motivations of the military industrial complex controlled DoD. Let’s just say that LOTS of people would lose their jobs if we didn’t have wars in which to play with all our technologically advanced toys, and the ability to continue to manufacture conflicts worthy of their use.
“a significant part of the Human species is genetically malprogrammed for the species survival”
Mak this fits You and the rest of the Insurgent leftists on this blog to a T.
You failed the just war test. A war is just when the misery it causes is lesser than the misery that will result from not warring. Consider this axiom when listening to liberals call for an immoral pullout from Iraq.
Does that mean I get an F, mccain? My first F ever? Please, oh please consider an extra credit assignment!
OK, whacko – and we’re back to your original and already debunked point whereby you presuppose that the misery being inflicted in this war is going to eventually be less than the misery inflicted by Saddam.
Note the use of the past tense. Inflicted. Those who wage war don’t have the luxury of presupposing that the amount of misery ethey often incorrectly assume would have been experienced would surpass the amount of misery as a result of making war. That point has already been passed, if you go by body counts.
Feel free to continue spouting off about how this will give life to democracy in the Middle East and how democracies don’t wage war. As much as I’d like to buy into your whimsical dream, history does not support you. We’ve created instability, and maybe if one day, long in the future, democracy does take root in the ME, you and your ilk will not be the ones to take credit for it.
You never answered my question. Would you settle for radical Islamic democracy a la Hamas? Oh, wait – you want a full fledged, checks and balances, LIBERAL form of democracy to just appear there. Good luck, dude.
there are 6.5 billion people on this planet entitled to their opinions as to what constitutes a “just war.”
That is an exceptional statement. The problem with your philosophy of moral relativism is that it cannot allow you to make moral judgements. To you, the opinions of all people must be equivalent and therefore no single person’s opinion can be correct. There is no right and wrong in the liberal mind, which is why you run in illogical circles about foreign policy considerations like this Iraq war.
“we in the US have the moral right to gift the world w/ carbon copies of our political & economic system”
No, not a right. We have a moral obligation to further freedom in the world to the extent it is within our power. And not necessarily US versions of democracy, but clearly western ideals of freedom. And that is because western culture is morally superior to other cultures. Your moral relativism will not allow you to agree.
You are congratulated for throwing the term “jingoism” twice into one comment post, and I am particularly amused by the term “predatory capitalism.” Why do you loathe our culture and country so very much?
Santorum reminds me of the kid who’s parents replace his dead goldfish in the middle of the night and everyone in the family smiles at him the next day, thinking how sad it is that he’s the only one who believes it’s the same fish.
Regarding the effect of public support on troop morality, and troop morality on battlefield perforance, you will need to get versed in military tactics before I can expect you to have a serious conversation about the topic.
Nice non-answer. I expected nothing less.
Did you mean “morality” or “mortality”?
How about a nice, clearly defined plan of action for what to do AFTER the toppling of the enemy’s government, along with a contingency plan as a start for bettering troop morale?
Are you saying our troops aren’t performing? Because it looks more like the planning wasn’t done (or if it was, it was conveniently ignored) at the top levels.
Enlighten me, genius – I read Sun Tzu back in 8th grade – how does questioning the war cause troops to be killed with greater frequency?
If the whole nation were steadfastly behind the war, would the enemy, while watching American TV simply say: “Shit, they’re all on the same side. Let’s surrender.”? What your stunted intellectual growth leaves you incapable of grasping is that the enemy can cherry pick information from “one side” here in the U.S. as easily as they can the other.
When are you going to give up?
WMD for the average Republican seeking re-election when they are down nearly 20 points now means…
We’re
Really
Desperate
Like Pavlov’s doggie, you guys fell for it. The DOD refuting their claims the same dang day, but you people here clap even louder!
What a lesson in partisanship. You have the left beat hands down on that.
Mak this fits You and the rest of the Insurgent leftists on this blog to a T.
That’s right, “914”. Mak, myself, and the rest of the fifth column represented here are simply awaiting our orders from OBL. We look forward to living in a fundamentalist Islamic state based on communist principles.
You’re no longer worthy of even the most base satire.
KC, you have entered the thread and remain a fantastic caricature of liberalism. Whether or not I am a fan of this administration (I am not), or a memeber of the Republican party (I am not), is completely irrelevant to support for the war. It is also irrelevant to your owm poor presentation and my correct conclusion that you are a narcissist. You continue to think that WMD is somehow determinant to a moral justification for the war (when it is not). Listen closely: WMD does not matter.
and no, you actually haven’t debunked anything I have said. I have made a statement about the morality of war, and the best you can come up with is “how do you know” and “who are you to decide.” That isn’t debunking, but rather, it is punting.
McCain
You offered your usual militaristic diarrhea: “You failed the just war test. A war is just when the misery it causes is lesser than the misery that will result from not warring. Consider this axiom…”
First, until the war is at least well under progress, that definition could not come close to defining a “morally just war” in advance w/o employing an arrogance of infallibility. And Who gives you the right to make that dtermination? You are deranged.
Second, the so-called wisdom of your definition is in the eye of the beholder.
If you want to try to make a distinction about probable misery, take a look at: http://www.peacetakescourage.com/wwjd.html
I am sure that the victims of your “just wars” are on their knees, if they have any knees left, thanking God for your arrogance & moral wisdom.
The absurdity of your position is in the very concepts that you vainly attempt to justify. Any reader of your pompous malarkey would see that you are certifiably insane.