One day the story of WMD in Iraq will be known, at least partially. For now, the information is coming out in bits and pieces. Bottom line — those who said there was no WMD in Iraq were wrong. (Using the definition and standard they set for President Bush, I guess that means they were lying, right?)
Jay at Stop the ACLU has a great roundup of blogosphere reaction to the latest from Pete Hoekstra and Rick Santorum:
U.S. Senator Rick Santorum (R-PA), Chairman of the Senate Republican Conference, joined Congressman Peter Hoekstra, (R-MI-2), Chairman of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, today to make a major announcement regarding the release of newly declassified information that proves the existence of chemical munitions in Iraq since 2003. The information was released by the Director of National Intelligence, John Negroponte, and contained an unclassified summary of analysis conducted by the National Ground Intelligence Center. In March, Senator Santorum began advocating for the release of these documents to the American public.
“The information released today proves that weapons of mass destruction are, in fact, in Iraq,” said Senator Santorum. “It is essential for the American people to understand that these weapons are in Iraq. I will continue to advocate for the complete declassification of this report so we can more fully understand the complete WMD picture inside Iraq.”
The following are the six key points contained in the unclassified overview:
• Since 2003 Coalition forces have recovered approximately 500 weapons munitions which contain degraded mustard or sarin nerve agent.
• Despite many efforts to locate and destroy Iraq’s pre-Gulf War chemical munitions, filled and unfilled pre-Gulf War chemical munitions are assessed to still exist.
• Pre-Gulf War Iraqi chemical weapons could be sold on the black market. Use of these weapons by terrorists or insurgent groups would have implications for Coalition forces in Iraq. The possibility of use outside Iraq cannot be ruled out.
• The most likely munitions remaining are sarin and mustard-filled projectiles.
• The purity of the agent inside the munitions depends on many factors, including the manufacturing process, potential additives, and environmental storage conditions. While agents degrade over time, chemical warfare agents remain hazardous and potentially lethal.
• It has been reported in open press that insurgents and Iraqi groups desire to acquire and use chemical weapons. I have not checked in at the major liberal blogs to get reaction. My guess is that the conventional wisdom is still that Bush lied about WMD and that there was none in Iraq. (I will update later if I find this not to be the case.) What I find absolutely amazing is that many of those who believe Bush had something to do with the Twin Towers collapsing and who believe that John Kerry really won in Ohio find it impossible to believe that Saddam had WMD — even though Bill Clinton, the UN, France and dozens of Democrat politicians said he did over and over again.
Over two years ago, I found Ken Timmerman’s report of WMD found in Iraq quite compelling, but no one ever seemed to pay much attention to it. (Be sure to read it if you aren’t already familiar with it .) Maybe eventually all the information found will be compiled and we will have a comprehensive picture of everything that has been found. Maybe the media will even decide to report it.
UPDATE: From A Real Ugly American (via Flopping Aces’ excellent, must read post):
General Tom Mcinerney is reporting on Fox Hannity and Colmes right now that that the administration has been keeping this low profile to avoid exposing 3 of the 5 members of the UN Security council; Russia, China, and France. McInerney says these weapons will be traced to these countries, and asserts it is well known that Russia helped Saddam move most of his WMD stockpiles out of Iraq before the war.
I have on several occasions speculated about why the President would not be touting the information we have about WMD found in Iraq and had come to a similar conclusion. My theory was that if the public knew that certain other countries had been involved with moving WMD, they would demand action that we did not want to, or were not able to, take.
Check out Pajamas Media’s WMD Files for previous blogging on the subject. Just for the record, I never doubted.

Heralder,
Good point that Nazi Germany is more like communist Russia or now communist Cuba, Venezuela, North Korea. Why people on the left tolerate folks like Carter who embrace these fascist/communist dictators.
The real gulags are in Iran, Cuba, NOrth Korea. It is naive or willfully ignorant to compare Guantanamo to real gulags. No different from Cindy Sheehan ‘s motto: “Bush is the worst terrorist in the world”. This is what I used to hear from the crypto-fascist left, ie the communists.
KC
Bwahh You big bad liberal, you hurt my feelings! BWAHHH liberals are supposed to be all caring… You certainly are a disappointment..
A brief chronology of events for the temporally challenged:
1. Rick Santorum et al, in desperation pending the coming elections release a recently declassified document stating that over 500 WMDs have been recovered in Iraq since 2003.
2. Wizbang proclaims far and wide that WMDs have, indeed been found. This fact purportedly grants legitimacy to our claims prior to invasion that Saddam was indeed actively developing WMDs, and that we knew where they were.
3. Just hours later, the DoD throws water on the declassified report by saying that these were, in fact, NOT new WMDs that we accused Saddam of actively developing, but old stock consisting of defunct equipment which are easily traceable to the pre Gulf War period when WE among other nations were assisting Saddam in his WMD, specifically chemical and biological WMD, development and deployment. It is laid out clearly in the links above.
4. Wizbang readers ignore these facts and cheer loudly until finally proven wrong. This leaves scragglers like McCain – described below – here to debate issues NOT CENTRAL to the topic of this thread.
4. Meanwhile, McCain is spouting off about how the WMDs don’t matter anyway, and that the war in Iraq was justified from a strictly moralistic standpoint. Incorrectly conflates my debunking of the WMD story with a projected desire on my part to justify the war on moral grounds.
5. McCain proves once and for all that he’s been drinking the Kool Aid, and that no amount of reason will ever break through his thick skull. He fails to:
1) Answer a question about our next military “moral endeavor”
2) Answer a question on whether he’s satisfied with Hamas as a democratically elected goverment
3) Demonstrate some kind of understanding of probalistic methods and how they apply numerically in this case to his core belief that the misery resulting from this war will be less than that assuming we had pursued other options.
4) Justify his assertion that questioning the war somehow gives strength to the enemy and demoralizes or own forces. Resorts to the usual conservative meme of calling opponents “traitors” and “liberals”…
Pathetic, Mac. I knew you didn’t have nothin’.
“First, until the war is at least well under progress, that definition could not come close to defining a “morally just war” in advance w/o employing an arrogance of infallibility. And Who gives you the right to make that dtermination? You are deranged.”
Your construct is based on a false premise. Moral relativist philosophy will not allow you to make judgements, but a better philosophy offers no such limitations. The short answer to your question is that I am able to make those judgements while you are not. In this particular war, the past record of Saddam’s activity in the middle east over the prior 15 years is the best predictor for what would happen in the future. Your second clue is that he announced his intentions, in what you would so readily dismiss an unimportant bluster. The Saddam misery index is quite high, I am sure you will agree.
First, until the war is at least well under progress, that definition could not come close to defining a “morally just war” in advance w/o employing an arrogance of infallibility. And Who gives you the right to make that dtermination? You are deranged.
The hypocritical narcissism of the “right” knows no bounds.
In this particular war, the past record of Saddam’s activity in the middle east over the prior 15 years is the best predictor for what would happen in the future.
And being the arrogant hypocrite that you are, you have failed to offer an opinion on the morality of our part in this record of activity. Was the misery lessened by supplying Saddam with WMDs and biological weapons? Yet another inconvenient question which will require that you directly contradict your philosophy.
Is the use of biological weapons, if it means that the misery is lessened justified? If so, why do no nations make use of them in war including the U.S.A.?
Your second clue is that he announced his intentions, in what you would so readily dismiss an unimportant bluster
And what, pray tell, intentions do you refer to? Is it sort of like when the knight in Monty Python’s Holy Grail, who after having all of his limbs cut off continues to make threats? Or do you have something else in mind?
Mac – give it up.
If so, why do no nations make use of them in war including the U.S.A.?
correction: If so, why do no nations NOT make use of them in war including the U.S.A.?
crypto-fascist left
Hahahaha. That’s the best one I’ve heard all day.
While both sides of the American political spectrum can exhibit fascist tendencies, it might do you some good to review the definition of facism, and where the definition has and has not been consistent with practice in “recent” world history.
I think you’ll find that the “right” is clearly headed in that direction:
http://www.cursor.org/stories/fascismi.php
1) Answer a question about our next military “moral endeavor”
War is moral when the benefits have an expectation of exceeding the costs, period, and yes, I certainly do have the capacity to judge that probability for myself. I believe that the next moral war will be Iran, either directly or indirectly, although I hope that it isn’t necessary. It is more likely that democracy will root there internally, but our pressure would clearly be a contributing factor in the event it happens. You will note that democracies tend not to just rush off to war. This Iraqi war was a long time in the making, and came about when their was apparently no other option for change there. What specifically do you actually disagree with in this paragraph.
2) Answer a question on whether he’s satisfied with Hamas as a democratically elected goverment.
Certainly no, just like I am not satisfied with the democratically elected government in Spain. That isn’t really the point. I am satisfied with the route that the eventual-Palestine is taking. The Hamas government will be short-lived IF they continue with their democratic experiment. What specifically do you disagree with?
3) Demonstrate some kind of understanding of probalistic methods and how they apply numerically in this case to his core belief that the misery resulting from this war will be less than that assuming we had pursued other options.
2,000,000 dead, due largely to Saddam Hussein. Past behavior is a good predictor for future behavior. Do you agree with that statement?
4) Justify his assertion that questioning the war somehow gives strength to the enemy and demoralizes or own forces. Resorts to the usual conservative meme of calling opponents “traitors” and “liberals”…
That is pretty obvious. Do you question Sun-Tse or our West Point training? Human behavior is often seen but not observed by those who are blinded. I will cite you studies, which I am convinced you will not read, but you must narrow your ignorance for me. Do you agree that public support for a war influences troop morale? yes or no. And do you believe that troop morale influences battlefield performance? yes or no. Agree with none, one, or both, so we can see the extent of your knowledge and save us both a little time.
I’ll answer your “questions” when you answer mine:
Was the misery lessened by supplying Saddam with WMDs and biological weapons? Yet another inconvenient question which will require that you directly contradict your philosophy.
Is the use of biological weapons, if it means that the misery is lessened justified? If so, why do no nations make use of them in war including the U.S.A.?
Now, I have answered your questions again, questions you pretend have not already been answered for your own narcissistic reasons. In the short time I have been gone, you have posed new questions. Thanks for your great interest in my opinions, but your great interest in your own education will need to slow down a bit. See the last comment and take your time to answer truthfully.
McCain: armchair generalissimo & Sphincter of Morality
You incontinently posted: “To you, the opinions of all people must be equivalent and therefore no single person’s opinion can be correct. There is no right and wrong in the liberal mind,”
Your mental excretions are getting further & further into the realm of insanity. Just where do you find the sanction of the infallibility of your moral judgement viz-a-viz someone else’s? Who appointed you the Determineror, or, in Chimpanzee-eze, the Decider?
And you further excreted: “We have a moral obligation to further freedom in the world to the extent it is within our power. And not necessarily US versions of democracy, but clearly western ideals of freedom.”
Just who gets the right to define “moral obligations?” You & your messianic morally superior Judeo-Christians? You are the epitome of a blind cultural ethnocentrist.
I’d wager whatever you wish, that an overwhelming majority of the rest of the West would suggest you take your so-called moral assessments and shove them where they will never see the light of day. A significant part of the West experienced Fascism in one way or another in the 20th Century. and they are not likely to swoon w/ your lunatic visions of your morally defined world.
I call the inability of conservatives to admit that Bush was wrong, so very wrong, about WMDs in Iraq, and the ongoing search for “those papers that’ll prove us right” the Bush Denial Syndrome.
You can keep conflating pre-1991 chemical weapons stocks with a program, but your attempt at persuasive redefinition is highly impersuasive. Wiz-bang? How about Crap-splash?
“A significant part of the West experienced Fascism in one way or another in the 20th Century. and they are not likely to swoon w/ your lunatic visions of your morally defined world.”
Have you observed that the countries who most recently experienced the smothering Soviet boot were more likely to help Iraqis win their own freedom? Somce uou don’t value the western ideal of freedom as others do, you are probably not the best person to guess how those who appreciate liberty feel.
The rest of your comment is liberal poopy nonsense, so I’ll let it sit there for amusement.
What specifically do you actually disagree with in this paragraph.
Aside from the fact that your notion of a “moral war” has nothing to do with morality, I’ll humor you anyway. How do you measure the benefits? How do you measure the cost? What units are you using?
Back to my previous example: if by providing Saddam the WMDs in the first place, are we not the real root cause of the deaths – since that seems to be how you measure costs? By extension, was today’s war one of the possible costs factored into whatever psuedo probabistic method your kind utilized back when we were providing these weapons to Saddam? If not, I’d say your model is broken.
Finally, since you purport to be such an expert on the subject – what exactly are the costs of the chain of events put into motion by western imperialism in the Middle East going back nearly 70 years?
Certainly no, just like I am not satisfied with the democratically elected government in Spain. That isn’t really the point. I am satisfied with the route that the eventual-Palestine is taking. The Hamas government will be short-lived IF they continue with their democratic experiment. What specifically do you disagree with?
The point is that we have a government which was democratically elected that advocates a non-peaceful platform for dealing with its nearest neighbor. Give me your other two examples.
2,000,000 dead, due largely to Saddam Hussein. Past behavior is a good predictor for future behavior. Do you agree with that statement?
If your understanding of the situation is that simplistic, then there’s no point answering you. Saddam was simply not capable anymore of carrying out such atrocities on the scale he is reported to have done in the past. And again, what role did we play therein?
While I can agree that past behavior is a good indicator, it’s a non-sequitor in this case. See the Monty Python knight example above. Situations change. See: Quadaffi (sp?)
That is pretty obvious. Do you question Sun-Tse or our West Point training?
Why you make it sound as if it would be the equivalent of questioning the Bible (which I do question).
Sun-Tzu and West Point don’t make allowances for the case where a war is fought under false pretenses. That alone is sufficient to lower morale in an improperly trained fighting force. Do a better job of brainwashing our professional soldiers (as effective soldiers should be to a degree) and stop your moaning. Since when is the rest of society responsible for West Point’s or boot camp’s failures to do their jobs?
I will cite you studies
Where are they?
Do you agree that public support for a war influences troop morale? yes or no. And do you believe that troop morale influences battlefield performance? yes or no
It shouldn’t. Not in a professionaly trained Army with clearly defined objectives and contingency plans. Again, are you questioning our troops’s battlefield performance? Because that was never even in question, unless you’re privvy to information I don’t have.
Bottom line: the Army had the money, troops, expertise, and equipment to do the job right and have made mistake after mistake all along the way. Are you blaming the American public for the poor foresight and failures of top Army brass?
Do you agree that public support for a war influences troop morale? yes or no. And do you believe that troop morale influences battlefield performance? yes or no.
I’ll answer your questions.
Yes on both counts.
However, both public support and troop morale are also contingent upon the unambiguous “rightness” of said war. Which is why you had overwhelming support for WWII. When you start dealing with the rest (WWI, Korea, Vietnam, and this one) you’re standing on more shaky ground – and public opinion thus reflects this.
And by this one I am referring to Iraq specifically, not the GWOT.
…
Have you observed that the countries who most recently experienced the smothering Soviet boot were more likely to help Iraqis win their own freedom?
1. Of course. They’re still grateful to the US, so it makes sense.
2. However, don’t forget the power of the purse – these countries are also more easily bribed.
I left for an hour and come back to a mosh pit.
Two people answered my post, I’ll do my best to respond.
mak44, you quoted a poem. Not very persuasive, however, as again, I fail to see the parallels of America today vs Nazi Germany pre-WWII.
In regards to a later post in which you lumped me with some other posters, well that’s just sloppy.
I have been actually more on your side of this topic since about 30 posts in. I don’t have a problem conceding my point or admitting mistakes, even if the left will gloat and dance and taunt me for it.
KC:
I won’t even go into the fact thatI don’t think that “my chosen candidate” would have felt it necessary to circumvent the existing framework with which to accomplish legal domestic surveillance, then lie about it to cover it up.
A good answer. My thought on this is not that the existing framework has been circumvented, but changed. Any domestic surveillance we’ve had in place is simply not equipped to root out who we’re trying to root out. And if the president and administration tells everyone just what changes have been made, then there’s no point in even doing it as it’s already compromised. The idea is supposed to be that the enemy doesn’t know he’s being watched.
Ah, but it’s a slippery slope, Heralder. Perhaps I’m not worried about “him” in particular. Perhaps I’m worried that the erosions of our civil liberties – or the framework that supports them – will eventually fall into the hands of another president without the scruples you right wingers so lavishly praise and readily assume that Bush possesses.
Makes sense. But do you think we’re voting a fascist into office that with the way our government is set up he will be irremovable?
There’s a fine line between vigilance and paranoia, I fear many of us have crossed it.
and I fear that the laws in place to protect us from terrorists are no more effective than the laws which already existed when used properly.
I think we can agree that after 911 and other attacks around the world since, that what we had in place was woefully insufficient.
You raise some good points, but we are of a different mind.
This thread is getting severely difficult to follow and probably has already slid off the front page.
I’ll see you all in another topic (which we’ll likely end up arguing the same ideas) 😛
KC, you have the insecure person’s annoying habit of asking a ton of questions in the hope it will deflect attention away from yourself. It is a sign that you are uncomfortable with your own ideas. From now, on I will answer two questions at a time, and ask you to express your ideas by answering two questions. Part of your last comment was actually a serous answer so there is some hope you can pull this off.
Q1. Back to my previous example: if by providing Saddam the WMDs in the first place, are we not the real root cause of the deaths – since that seems to be how you measure costs?
No. Gun manufacturers are not the “cause” of criminals killing victims. Your question is a common cliche that defies logic. There is a moral justification for using arms, and a moral justification for supplying arms. It is complex to assess whether or not it was moral to supply arms to Saddam at the time. One has to consider the effect of Iran overwhelmingly winning the Iraq war upon Iraqi citizens, and what Iran might do from that position of strength. But again, it is irrelevant to assessing the current war’s morality for reasons I have already explained to you. So although your question is interesting, the answer is not actually important to the current war.
Q2. “How do you measure the benefits? How do you measure the cost? What units are you using?”
I think you are not being serious now. Judgement, which is a concept that is disallowed by your bankrupt moral relativity philosophy, is actually important. It is my judgement that Saddam would continue his past behavior in the future. That is a reasonable conclusion to most people who aren’t playing little word games. Since Saddam Hussein started 3 major wars in the middle east within 11 years, it is probable he would do so sometime in the future. It is my judgement that the costs of stopping him when we did exceed the costs of stopping him in the future, or doing nothing.
Next will come my two questions for you.
Generalissimo & Infallible Moralist McCain
You excreted: “No. Gun manufacturers are not the “cause” of criminals killing victims. Your question is a common cliche that defies logic. There is a moral justification for using arms, and a moral justification for supplying arms. It is complex to assess whether or not it was moral to supply arms to Saddam at the time. One has to consider the effect of Iran overwhelmingly winning the Iraq war upon Iraqi citizens, and what Iran might do from that position of strength.”
As well, you refer to the “predictability of what Saddam was likely to do in the future. Yhe problem w/ your excrement is that it was CIA backed coup in 1968 that led to the installation of Saddam in the first place, and there was no reason to assume that Saddam was anything other than what we came to know him as in the last decade at the time when Reagan/Bush 41 saw fit to approve arms sales & WMD precursors to the Iraqi regime.
You right-wing extremists are forever failing to look far enough out to project the folly of your advocated policies. In the 1980’s, the simplistic Reagan/Bush 41 policy was to stick it in the eye of Iran, the hell w/ the aftermath.
Of course, the presumed moral assessment to stick it in the eye of Iran was generated 15 years before the Saddam coup when the CIA , again under Republican direction, saw fit to engineer a coup against a democratically elected Massadeqh in Iran, resulting in the seating of the of our brutal puppet, the Shah, which in turn precipitated the Khomeni Iranian coup in 1979.
What a web you moralm judges weave w/ your lunacy of justified war & intervention.
KC, you have the insecure person’s annoying habit of asking a ton of questions in the hope it will deflect attention away from yourself.
And the pot is calling the kettle black.
No. Gun manufacturers are not the “cause” of criminals killing victims. Your question is a common cliche that defies logic.
And again you either fail to grasp the topic of discussion, or just choose to obfuscate as usual. What if gun manufacturers were making bullets laden with the AIDS virus?
We’re not talking about “arms”. We’re talking about chemical and biological weapons that we supplied. That we say we won’t use in war. That we knew he was using, and assisted in the case of Iran, and turned a deaf ear in the case of the Kurds. That were and are illegal based on international precedent going back nearly a century.
So again, was it moral of us to supply weapons grade chemical and biological agents, and if so can we not assume that there was a calculus of sorts employed. Was the net misery higher or lower as a result of that strategic decision on the part of the Bush and Reagan administrations? Please try to answer, even though it hurts. Is it not hypocritical of us, and amoral to enable a proxy such as Saddam to wage illegal war because it suits our dubious foreign policy goals?
I think you are not being serious now. Judgement, which is a concept that is disallowed by your bankrupt moral relativity philosophy, is actually important. It is my judgement that Saddam would continue his past behavior in the future. That is a reasonable conclusion to most people who aren’t playing little word games. Since Saddam Hussein started 3 major wars in the middle east within 11 years, it is probable he would do so sometime in the future.
And given the terms of the UN sanctions and international force policing him for this very reason, it stands to reason that had he made overtures or taken any such action, he’d be taken out without the slightest shred of doubt cast on those who deposed him.
But you’re stuck here defending the indefensible because your Administration chose to operate outside the framework of international law and in contradiction to what any reasonable foreign policy planner would have advised barring ulterior motives for the action – which serve only to spawn conspiracy theories such as OIL.
Spare me your pathetic moral relativism arguments, and stick to the point.
Further, loon, we have humored you long enough here. Simply because YOU choose to try to change the topic of the thread after the original topic was rendered moot, does not mean that you should succeed. Start your own thread or blog, and we can debate the subject sans all the noise from those like 914.
Finally, if you based your support of the war on a moral calculus, and more specifically in terms of your misery quotient, then one is left to draw the following conclusion:
You do support the administration and their prosecution of the war, because you continue to defend it even though it was carried out haphazardly, without real planning for the aftermath (yes, people still died after “mission accomplished), and with senior level advice on troop levels, recovery planning, etc simply thrown out the window because they were inconvenient.
If you really supported the war for moral reasons, then you’d acknowledge these facts, and admit that the war to now has been managed incompetently.
As well, you refer to the “predictability of what Saddam was likely to do in the future. Yhe problem w/ your excrement is that it was CIA backed coup in 1968 that led to the installation of Saddam in the first place, and there was no reason to assume that Saddam was anything other than what we came to know him as in the last decade at the time when Reagan/Bush 41 saw fit to approve arms sales & WMD precursors to the Iraqi regime.
Again, you’ve hit the nail on the head. In not so many words, the neocon platform is, and always has been perpetual warfare as a way of life.
They had no realistic expectation of Saddam OTHER than what happened, and they were involved every step of the way.
Mister moral absolutist can move the goalposts all he wants, and he’s left in the same quandry.
Defending a preconcieved, non-reality based, indefensible position.
Grasping at straws……..
The munitions are 20 years old, remnants of the Iran-Iraq War.
“The intelligence officials also said that the munitions referred to in the report were produced before the Persian Gulf War in 1991 and that they had degraded and could not be used as designed. “There is no evidence today of any post-1991 WMD munitions,” said the official, who agreed to speak with reporters only if his identity and his agency were not disclosed.”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06/22/AR2006062201839.html
The U.S. military announced in 2004 in Iraq that several crates of the old shells had been uncovered and that they contained a blister agent that was no longer active. Neither the military nor the White House nor the CIA considered the shells to be evidence of what was alleged by the Bush administration to be a current Iraqi program to make chemical, biological and nuclear weapons.
Last night, intelligence officials reaffirmed that the shells were old and were not the suspected weapons of mass destruction sought in Iraq after the 2003 invasion.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06/21/AR2006062101837.html
So yeah, there’s that. Thanks for playing.
Heralder: A good answer. My thought on this is not that the existing framework has been circumvented, but changed.
All they had to do was have Congress make changes and be done with it. They couldn’t be bothered to do that, and figured they could just lie about it later.
FISA makes provisions for exactly the type of surveillance they are undertaking, and even gives a 72 hour window for obtaining ex post facto warrants.
And if the president and administration tells everyone just what changes have been made, then there’s no point in even doing it as it’s already compromised.
Another one of their arguments which defies reason and logic, and is intended only to stifle debate. Any would be terrorist too stupid to consider, that in the post 9/11 atmosphere here, we just might be listening in wasn’t going to get very far with their plot anyway.
So at best – we’re concentrating on the small timers who are dumb enough to communicate in a non-encrypted traditional manner, while breaking up some plots. At worst, we’re investing all this time on this type of surveillance only to completely miss something else.
McCain:KC, you have the insecure person’s annoying habit of asking a ton of questions in the hope it will deflect attention away from yourself.
Two things are fairly obvious to anyone reading this thread.
1. You are way off topic, and we have humored you long enough. The fact that you are not embarrassed by being so easily refuted is indicative of a mental disorder.
2. Here’s how it normally goes: Question – Answer, Question – Answer. Care to guess as to why it looks like I’ve asked so many questions?
Hint: It’s because I have to ask so many questions more than twice because you refuse to answer any of them honestly. Again, anyone reading this thread can scan up and see that I’ve answered any question you posed.
>>Your ignorance is really stunning. Nixon simply turned the war over to the South Vietnamse with the assumption of financial and military equipment support. The Dems cut off that funding (why? you know?). Reagan simply decided he needed to focus on fighting the bigger threat ala the Soviet Union (just like FDR sided with Stalin against Hitler).
Now can you join me in condemning the despicable Dems as represented by Murth in advocating the cut-and-run policy?
First let’s get things straight – It is the republicans who have the history of “Cutting and Running”, Like Nixon in vietnam and Reagan in Beirut, and Democrats like FDR, Wilson and Clinton in Bosnia who have the reputation for following through and finishing things.
Murtha’s policy is not cut and run, it is a sensible policy to focus our attention on the real enemy (muslim extremism) before our economy is bankrupted and our military is spent on this senseless and proven unnecessary war in Iraq.
McCain,
You’re obviously either not originally from the U.S.A., currently live abroad, were raised abroad, or all three.
I suspect you’re Israeli or British/Australian.
Am I far off?
…before our economy is bankrupted and our military is spent on this senseless and proven unnecessary war in Iraq.
Don’t get them started on that one. It’s social services bankrupting our economy – remember that. They do.
The military industrial complex is the ONLY reason our economy is not bankrupt, and they know that too.
Meant to say clinton in Kosovo, despite the cry-baby republicans who said we shouldn’t be there.
I quick perusal of spending in the US will shows that our prosperity is driven by social spending, that programs like Social security and the war on poverty (that cut poverty in half) have dramatically improved the prosperity and wealth of this nation.
>Don’t get them started on that one. It’s social services bankrupting our economy – remember that. They do.
>The military industrial complex is the ONLY reason our economy is not bankrupt, and they know that too.
Let me see your logic: Spending on military stuff which is either blown up or wastes away until it is obsolete has a positive effect on the economy, but social spending that is returned to the economy in money spent on food, clothing, housing and etc. is bankrupting our economy??? This make absolutly no sense! Money spent on the military is money that is wasted, lost to the economy. No one can eat a missile or a bomb or a fighter. Some of this is a necessary evil, but it is nothing more than a pure drain on the economy.
I quick perusal of spending in the US will shows that our prosperity is driven by social spending, that programs like Social security and the war on poverty (that cut poverty in half) have dramatically improved the prosperity and wealth of this nation.
Yeah, I was being facetious hoping to bait one of them into a “discussion”.
Nevermind.
>>Nixon simply turned the war over to the South Vietnamse with the assumption of financial and military equipment support. The Dems cut off that funding (why? you know?). Reagan simply decided he needed to focus on fighting the bigger threat ala the Soviet Union (just like FDR sided with Stalin against Hitler).
OK, MURTHA is simply suggesting that we turn the war over to the Iraqis, so we can focus on fighting the bigger threat of muslim extremism.
I am OK with that, given your support of the nearly identical nixon and reagan policies you must be in agreement also.
I’m sorry. I missed something. Wasn’t this entire story line of Sanorum’s refuted almost immediately (and embarassingly) the same day, as quoted above by red line? My understanding is the military has disavowed this story. The somewhat loony explanations for why this current Administration would shy away from proof that there were WMDs or that they were hidden by external forces in neighboring countries seem labored. This Administration perhaps has shied away from presenting “proof” after being embarassed so many times about the quality of proof (mobile bio labs, aluminum tubes, yellowcake, old artillery shells, etc. having been hauled out as trophies) and all refuted.
So I’m missing something here. Except in private conversations at fund raisers, this Administration does not claim WMDs were found. Their own investigator has filed a report stating none were found. The President has admitted as such. Let’s not talk about what Clinton or the rest of the world believed – I know that, and I agree – there was a general belief at the time of invasion that there was a likelihood of it, though the evidence never rose to the level of causus belli. I’m talking about right now. Nobody creditworthy believes this, right?
This make absolutly no sense! Money spent on the military is money that is wasted, lost to the economy. No one can eat a missile or a bomb or a fighter. Some of this is a necessary evil, but it is nothing more than a pure drain on the economy.
Well, a whole bunch of auxilliary discoveries are made via the vast amounts of government funded military research and development.
The way they see it, jobs are jobs, and a job at Lockheed Martin is a job that wouldn’t have been there without our huge government contractor industry base.
I happen to disagree, and for the advocates of the market economy, and “the ownership society” they sure seem to show a lack of faith in our ability to innovate sans the permanent war machine we have in place.
KC- I have a notorious Irony deficiency.
KC. Oops, I thought Kevin had ended this thread — a filter did capture my questions for you. Before we get justifiably banned for excessive wordiness and endless circles, I’m going to exit. Please visit other threads related to the Iraq war in the future, where your anti-American liberalism can be exposed and assaulted another day. In other words, you will get the last word which will allow you to pretend victory for some views which have been shown to be inarticulate and illogical. A narcissist can hope for nothing less than the final word. Do you realize how many posts you have made in the last few hours, without really saying much?
I’m talking about right now. Nobody creditworthy believes this, right?
Yeah, this particualr entry’s entire reason for being was debunked about 3 threads into it, and continually debunked over and over again all day and night for those too stupid to read.
Do you realize how many posts you have made in the last few hours, without really saying much?
One doesn’t need say much to limn the obvious logical fallacies in your arguments.
Later days, straight talker.
>>Well, a whole bunch of auxilliary discoveries >>are made via the vast amounts of government >>funded military research and development.
I absolutly agree, and this shows the important role that government spending can have in stimulating the economy. (Most recent example is the Internet, which is purely the result of government funding and investment in a research program. In this way, military spending is not a total waste. (The part that ends up as bombs is.) Just think how much more we could do if the 400 billion annually was spend directly on innovating new technologies instead of just getting the lucky byproducts of spending on something else. I bet with that money we could have a carbon free energy economy by now.
Overall, the war has proceeded very well compared to any previous ground wars. In WWII, 3000 soldiers were killed in one exercise. All this talk about incompetence is simply an excuse to find faults. This is another variation of the “perfection arg”. YOu can always find faults in anything to criticize. The do-nothing people are good at that.
And if we are intellectually honest, we must conclude that the liberal left is totally bankrupt both intellectually and morally. They have nothing constructive to offer. All they can do is to criticize and find faults. Of course, there are always things we can do better in hindsight. In my honest opinion, one big mistake in the war is that Bush has bent backward to treat the Dems as serious about national security. As implied by the args of many liberal posters, Bush should have treated the Dems as dishonest when they talked about regime change in Iraq and WMD threat from Saddam etc…
THe fact is the left has stood on the wrong side of history in the cold war: they decided to abandon the poor/oppressed to the communist gulag because of their ideology. Now they are willing to abandon the poor/oppressed to the jihadist terrorists and these tin-pot dictators simply because they hated Bush. The left is intellectually and morally bankrupt.
Just think how much more we could do if the 400 billion annually was spend directly on innovating new technologies instead of just getting the lucky byproducts of spending on something else. I bet with that money we could have a carbon free energy economy by now
—————————————————
I wonder why the government spending, ie the socialist model has stifled the economy of Europe and Canada.
Communism is pure gov spending. They are the ultimate leftist utopia.
trrll, Bush never said Iraq was an imminent threat. He said the world should not wait until the threat is imminent.
One could perhaps excuse rushing into a war with inadequate post-war preparation and limited international support, leaving American soldiers to bear the brunt of casualties and American taxpayers to foot most of the bill, if Bush genuinely believed that the threat was serious and imminent. I’ve generally been willing to cut Bush some slack in this respect, and presume that Administration rhetoric about the “smoking gun [being a] mushroom cloud” reflected a genuine belief in an imminent threat. I take it that you are not so generous.
Gun manufacturers are not the “cause” of criminals killing victims.
I agree, so long as the gun manufacturers take reasonable care to avoid providing guns to known murderers. I’m not sure that we can make such a claim when it comes to providing WMD to Saddam.
LoveAmerica Immigrant
You down here trifling with the trolls? they have been fantasizing for over a day on this subject? Desperately trying to convince anyone who lets them That WMDs are not WMDs because they were found in Iraq..
It may sound overtly illogical, but its all they have to run with..
Dont even humor them with logical arguments, all they want is to lash out at the object of their hatred..The frat boy in chief.
Leave them to wallow in their losses and lick their wounds amongst the den of iniquity they have so arrogantly stumbled into..
It must have been the curse of the Leprechaun that made Me do it..Any way good luck talking to these pieces of rock that have neither eyes to see or ears to hear.
KC
If you’re still around, you should check out the “Youse got a nice legislature here. Be a shame if anything should happen to it.” or the “Just the facts, ma’am threads.
There’s a lot more assholery going on on both.
“if Bush genuinely believed that the threat was serious and imminent. “
The fact that the administration made no plans or efforts to secure the suspect WMD sites in iraq after the invasion indicates, no PROVES, that Bush did not believe that there was any imminent threat.
Ummm… I seem to recall talk of “mushroom clouds” before the war- and now that we may have found some old and inneffective mustardgas weapons is supposed to make me change my mind?
So Bush didn’t lie? Will you admit that he exaggerated a bit? Mustardgas as WMD?
THe fact is the left has stood on the wrong side of history in the cold war: they decided to abandon the poor/oppressed to the communist gulag because of their ideology. Now they are willing to abandon the poor/oppressed to the jihadist terrorists and these tin-pot dictators simply because they hated Bush. The left is intellectually and morally bankrupt.
-LoveAmericaImmigrant
LAI – There is a long list of countries run by oppressive dictators. We’re gonna need blood and tresure to liberate them. Why not start with you? You can do your part by sending Uncle Sam some $ and enlisting today.
t-66
We already send uncle Sam enough blood and treasure.. I suggest if We intend to off any Dictators in the future we do it by nuclear means so as to avoid all this 2500 dead crap.
You guys trip me out. How much more discrediting do you people need before you come out of your little paranoid shell? You guys put Rick Man on Dog Santorums word over the DOD?
Talk about getting desperate! I love watching true believers get forcibly deprogrammed, although from the postings, some of you have a long way to go.