Updated
The dynamic duo of Eric Lichtblau and James Risen are at it again with their exposure of a classified program used to track the banking practices of people associated with al Qaeda.
Under a secret Bush administration program initiated weeks after the Sept. 11 attacks, counterterrorism officials have gained access to financial records from a vast international database and examined banking transactions involving thousands of Americans and others in the United States, according to government and industry officials.
Well, it’s not secret anymore.
The program is limited, government officials say, to tracing transactions of people suspected of ties to Al Qaeda by reviewing records from the nerve center of the global banking industry, a Belgian cooperative that routes about $6 trillion daily between banks, brokerages, stock exchanges and other institutions. The records mostly involve wire transfers and other methods of moving money overseas or into and out of the United States. Most routine financial transactions confined to this country are not in the database.
So, what’s the problem? Why is the New York Times publishing this information if virtually all the banking transactions that are being traced are overseas with no real effect to Americans? This question becomes even more important when we learn that the White House asked the New York Times to refrain from publishing this article because it could make the program less effective. Here’s the Times’ editor’s response:
Bill Keller, the newspaper’s executive editor, said: “We have listened closely to the administration’s arguments for withholding this information, and given them the most serious and respectful consideration. We remain convinced that the administration’s extraordinary access to this vast repository of international financial data, however carefully targeted use of it may be, is a matter of public interest.”
Which public interest is Mr. Keller looking out for? The American public at large isn’t affected. Besides, the American public has expressed support over and over again for programs like this one that track the activities of would-be terrorists intent on harming us. The only public affected is the terrorist kind. Would be terrorits are the direct beneficiaries of this kind of article.
Take a look at the terror suspects this formerly secret program has netted:
Among the successes was the capture of a Qaeda operative, Riduan Isamuddin, better known as Hambali, believed to be the mastermind of the 2002 bombing of a Bali resort, several officials said. The Swift data identified a previously unknown figure in Southeast Asia who had financial dealings with a person suspected of being a member of Al Qaeda; that link helped locate Hambali in Thailand in 2003, they said.
[snip]
The data also helped identify a Brooklyn man who was convicted on terrorism-related charges last year, the officials said. The man, Uzair Paracha, who worked at a New York import business, aided a Qaeda operative in Pakistan by agreeing to launder $200,000 through a Karachi bank, prosecutors said.
Because the New York Times published the details of the US government’s effective terrorist tracking program, al Qaeda operatives now have more opportunity to avoid being caught.
Michelle Malkin is similarly disgusted with the games the NY Times is playing with our national security.
How odd that most Americans think sleeper cells and buried WMDs in Iraq present more of a threat than the Administration’s surveillance of the banking activities of terrorists.
Alexandra Von Maltzan at Newsbusters:
What exactly constitutes “Government secrets” nowadays. Absolutely everything is out in the open, I have no idea how any covert operations or classified programs can be carried out anymore. With the likes of the NYT and the L.A. Times revealing to all and sundry classified information, the terrorists don’t need any help from their own, when they are getting plenty directly from us.
Tracking the finances of terrorist organizations is one of THE best tools we have to cut at the roots of terror. The NY Times doesn’t care. After specifically being asked not to release this information by our government because it might jeapordize its effectiveness. The NY Times doesn’t care how it effects National Security, they are leaking it to the public. Classified information? What’s that? We are in a transparent nation.
Keller has it out for the Bush administration and wants to salvage his sinking revenues. There is no reason to expose this because very few Americans have international bank dealings. And if they did, I am sure they would not mind someone scrutinizing the overseas entity.
The LA Times is also jumping on the destroy-America’s-national-security-capability bandwagon:
The U.S. government, without the knowledge of many banks and their customers, has engaged for years in a secret effort to track terrorist financing by accessing a vast database of confidential information on transfers of money between banks worldwide.
The program, run by the Treasury Department, is considered a potent weapon in the war on terrorism because of its ability to clandestinely monitor financial transactions and map terrorist webs.
Update: Let’s flashback to Gabriel Schoenfeld’s important piece from the March edition of Commentary Magazine in which he argued that the New York Times was violating the Espionage Act with its article that exposed the NSA’s terrorist surveillance program. This is what Mr. Schoenfeld said about the New York Times’ publication of the NSA program:
The Justice Department has already initiated a criminal investigation into the leak of the NSA program, focusing on which government employees may have broken the law. But the government is contending with hundreds of national-security leaks, and progress is uncertain at best. The real question that an intrepid prosecutor in the Justice Department should be asking is whether, in the aftermath of September 11, we as a nation can afford to permit the reporters and editors of a great newspaper to become the unelected authority that determines for all of us what is a legitimate secret and what is not. Like the Constitution itself, the First Amendment’s protections of freedom of the press are not a suicide pact. The laws governing what the Times has done are perfectly clear; will they be enforced?
Good question. Will they be enforced with the Times’ and the other media outlets’ exposure of this classified national security program?
Update II: The American Thinker notes that The New York Sun has quoted Mr. Schoenfeld on the possibility that the Times could be looking for trouble from the Attorney General:
A conservative magazine editor who is one of the leading advocates of prosecuting the Times for its December story, Gabriel Schoenfeld, told The New York Sun last night that the newspaper’s latest move could increase their legal jeopardy.
“They’re courting prosecution. … They’re increasingly behaving like if we were in the middle of World War II and they learned of plans to invade Normandy. Because they decided it’s a matter of public interest, they’d publish it,” Mr. Schoenfeld said. “I think this is reckless and likely to encourage Attorney General Gonzales to prosecute them, if not for this story, for some of the other things they’ve done.”
Read the rest of the Sun’s article.
Update III: Ed Morrissey is spot on with this:
Did no one read that and understand that the US has an extensive surveillance system on financial transactions around the world? Perhaps Keller, Lichtblau, and Risen need facts spelled out for them using crayon and words of two syllables and less, but the thinking world already understood that American intelligence had thoroughly penetrated global finance — exactly like we said we would do in the wake of 9/11.
This story is only good for one thing, and that is an attempt to blow the program and stop our ability to follow the money. The New York Times apparently wants to stage itself as a publication written by traitors for an audience of idiots.
Others blogging:
Iowa Voice
Sister Toldjah
Hot Air
Stop the
Jeff Goldstein
All Things Beautiful
Larry Kudlow


Who most benefits in both the immediate and long term, from the NYT/LAT/WSJ exposure of an effective, legal program to catch terrorists and their supporters? Follow the money and the hubris.
The above newspapers think they make money by attracting readers and attention. The reporters and editors gain an ego boost by ‘sticking it to Bush’ yet again (regardless of whom else gets ‘stuck’ in the process).
Those who transfer money for purposes of supporting terrorism benefit by learning about specific intelligence gathering efforts in SWIFT which was presumed to be safe for such activities due to its secrecy rules. As with any side in a war, they will take any and all information about the secret operations of their enemy (us) and use it to their best advantage.
People should understand intuitively that intelligence gathering is a delicate process that is easily undermined. This exposure by a small handful of known partisan editors and reporters with agendas that put making money and attacking the president over national security damages the SWIFT intelligence gathering effort – most likely rendering it useless immediately.
Worse, as a direct and easily predictable result of this articles, SWIFT will most likely choose or be forced to stop cooperating with the US to seek out terrorists and their supporters. This means that soon SWIFT will be completely safe for terrorists to use for funds transfer.
Lee: “All of this whining about this publication effecting security – but no one has shown how that’s true.”
The burden of proof lies with the editors and reporters of these newspapers (and those who support them) to ensure their efforts do not harm national security. With freedom comes responsiblity. As there is no value to the public in exposing this legal and heavily safe-guarded program, It would seem clear then that they allowed their desire to make money and attack Bush led them to publish material that can and probably will harm national security efforts.
Certainly no one is arguing that these disclousures help find terrorists and their supporters. Not even the editors of the newspapers in question.
Regarding burden of proof, tell us what it is that convinces you that the NYT’s telling terrorists and their supporters that SWIFT is being monitored does not provide those terrorists with information that is useful to their efforts?
Again, a direct and easily predictable result of this article will be that SWIFT stops its cooperation with the US and becomes effectively safe for terrorists to use for funds transfers. Tell us how that is ‘in the public interest’?
Also, I’ll take barking dogs over the sophomoric whining rats any day.
because it will show just how inneffective and insignificant you barking dogs really are, much like the right-wing campaign to reduce sales of the Dixie Chicks new album has instead helped it stay #1 from the very first week of its release
Shame they can’t put asses in the seats for concerts in the US. And that is with insanely fawning media attention.
— or the way that the barking wingnut loonies’ attack on Connie Chung’s tongue in cheek rendition of “Thanks for the Memories” has resulted in enough pubicity to possibly keep the show from being cancelled.
Care to reveal these “attacks”?
Despite the noise generated by barking dogs, you guys really don’t have much bite. Your boycotts and attacks show the effect to be quite the opposite from the desired goal.
Well, considering that NY Times stock has been amongst the worst performing stocks for a few years now — we couldn’t really hurt them MORE.
Besides, most of you don’t read newspapers, and probably can’t afford to buy a subscription to the NY Times on your service-industry jobs, so what’s your point? Call for the boycott of a newspaper none of you read? That’ll be effective…
Hmm, elitism too? I guess being wrong on science isn’t enough for you.
Judging by their STOCK performance — the NY Times doesn’t HAVE much of a “base” anymore.
-=Mike
…so, how is that TimesSelect thing working out? The fact that you don’t know clearly shows that it’s tanking.
The NY Times has gone far beyond irresponsibility and illegality this time. Some call it TREASON, myself included.
They deserve the contempt of all Americans, all possible economic sanctions, and the swift prosecution that ordinary citizens would receive.
If everyoen knew it was going on, pray tell, why did the NYT believe it to be a feature story? Next thing you know they’ll probably assign their top reporters to produce a story telling the world that Hollywood produces movies, or some such closely guarded secret.
The interesting thing is that the SWIFT organisation is not a “secret” organisation but has been opening collecting information for many years and is widely used by intelligence and law enforcement agencies to track transactions. If you ever do a wire transfer you’ll have to provide the SWIFT number to do it. As a Brit I am mildly bemused that it has just dawned on the American public that the government collects information on financial transactions. The UK government monitors ALL transactions of five thousand pounds or more, common knowledge everywhere else in the world but not here apparently, lol. It’s a non story really. So what is it about? Reps bashing Dems and vica versa as usual I would say. Cheers. Kev. PS keep it up, most amusing
Why is everyone so surprised at the idiocy of the media? Of course the Times were out of line and treasonous. They should be made to pay restitution for the damage they caused, if any damage can be determined from a fiscal standpoint. But what bothers me is not the media’s total disregard for reporting the truth – – it is the fact that the American People falls for their lies daily, hook – line and sinker.
Doug. You are missing the point. No secrets, no lies, no story, its a non issue. Just another way of rallying republicans. Do try and get an international perspective. Cheers. Kev.
Well, here is one American who is against such activity. I would never support such programs. Besides what’s going to happen, ‘terrorists’ all of a sudden stop using banks. What they are going to fedex cash in a box to their counterparts? Get real.
Since Americans don’t have enough balls to step up I hope the EU does. Maybe, they will put pressure on theis ‘bank co-op’ to make it stop.
Thanks Bush for everything I’m selling my SS# and birth certificate and getting the hell out of here. Soon enough the rest of you will have an RFID chip in your skull.
So just to confirm, it’s OK with everyone if the American pResident spies on non-US citizens, regardless of whether it violates our rights? Ok then, so it’s therefore alright if I hack in to his bank accounts. I don’t see why the government should be allowed to read my bank statement just because they say they want to. I can’t read their bank statement just because I want to (really I can’t, they don’t have accurate accounts). As for the claim that a panel of accountants checked to see it was only used to track terrorists, that’s moronic. As if a bunch of Ba. Acc. and MBAs are going to know the difference between terrorists and drug smuglers, even assuming there is one.
My mom used to read the NY Times funny papers to me when I was three. I have enjoyed the NY Times ever since then. Now I will not be buying and/or reading it anymore.
Did the New York Times ever see the World War II poster that said ,”Loose lips sink ships”? Either they haven’t or they don’t care, even if it means the killing of thousands of Americans right here in or own country.
In my opinion they are as bad as saboteurs! They have lost my money, and I hope many other people will responds in the same manner.
I new we were tracking the finances since Bush said so on 9/24. This would have realy freaked me out if it said we were not!
Great news!!!
Is it true that The New York Times is making cutbacks because of record low sales? Americans have spoken. It has become an embarrasment to be seen with that particular paper in your hands.