Let me make clear I’ve never been a big fan of Disney and ABC. When Disney bought ABC, I feared the worst — and those fears were confirmed when Disney turned ABC into a marketing arm for the company.
But now, with ABC’s planned “docudrama” on the leadup to 9/11, I find myself in the very uncomfortable position of defending them.
Just for the sake of argument, let’s presume that all the program’s critics are correct (a severely dubious possibility, but let’s run with it). Let’s say that the piece is a total smear of the Clinton administration and a near-perfect whitewashing of the Bush administration in recognizing and addressing the rising threat Al Qaeda posed. That through half-truths, selected omissions, and outright fabrications (kind of a mirror-image Fahrenheit 9/11), the tale told is all about how Bill Clinton was too busy selling military secrets to China, boinking everything in a skirt, and arranging the murders of dozens of people who might have some dirt on him, and the Bush administration was too busy trying to put “W’s” back on their computer keyboards (you can’t talk about Wahabism, War on Terror, or World Trade Center without that key letter) to catch up on what was brewing.
So, what should be done about it?
According to some key Democrats on Capitol Hill, it’s a Capital Offense. They want to “look into” revoking ABC’s broadcasting license and putting the network off the air.
It’s a familiar tactic. During the 2004 campaign, some folks put together a piece on the Swift Boat Veterans For Truth. When Sinclair, a chain of television stations, planned to air it, a bunch of the Left wanted to pull their licenses, too.
Now, I’ve been offended by my share of things on television. Janet Jackson and that boob (no, not Justin Timberlake) bugged me — mainly because I hated that grotesque jewelry she wore, mutilating the natural beauty and grace of the human female breast. I also thought it was almost as tacky to pull that off (no pun intended) during the Super Bowl, an event billed as a “family-friendly” event — and very few families would consider a pierced nipple “something the whole family can enjoy.” (For one, infants could injure themselves.)
And when CBS (in an eerily-prescient form of “fake but accurate”) planned a “biography” of Ronald Reagan that was little more than a thinly-veiled smear piece, there were lots of howls of protest and outrage. But the strongest action I can recall was a threat to boycott sponsors of the shows. And it worked — CBS moved it to Showtime, a network completely free of advertising sponsors to threaten.
Instead, the Democratic party is showing one area where it actually has some testicular fortitude — if you say something (or even might be planning to say something) that threatens their heroes, that makes them look bad, they’ll go straight for your jugular with all the power of the federal government they can muster. Constitutional principles (freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and so on) be damned.
So if you like the idea of Congress deciding just what opinions and viewpoints can and can not be aired over the public airwaves, feel free to support the NutRoots’ takeover of the Democratic party and their move to take the reins of government. For one, it’ll take that awful burden of thinking for yourself off your hands.



Jay:
It would be extremely interesting to have someone compile a list of all the threats made by senators and congresspersons and who said them. It would be fun to dredge it up at election time, when they start hollering about constitutional rights.
BTW, I seriously doubt that ABC is going to air anything close to the show that was originaly planned.
I would also note that non of these voices were to be heard when Far. 9/11 was released.
Jay et al:
What i see is righties weeping and stomping their feet because you thought you were going to get another opprtunity to beat up on Clinton. You don’t need any motivation….he’s your bogieman for all the world’s evils anyway. You all sound uttlery foolish…..as if there is some real threat to free speech here.
I’ve been saying this all along. There are very few, if any, lefty trolls on this site who have not at one time or another (or constantly in some cases) accused the right wing as being fascists. I realize that every thinking person knows that this is simply projection, which is very commonly employed by the left.
If Lee, Hugh, Muirego, Brian, BarneyG200, feild-negro, and the rest of the secular socialist troll crew on this site want to see a real fascist, they need look no further than the closest mirror
Jay,
You make a good point, but frankly I am too busy laughing at the comment about the “w’s” on the typewriter and the pierced nipple to even address it! Great point about the Swift Boat special. I had forgotten all about that one.
Hugh,
So you don’t think threatening a television station that you’re going to pull their license if they air something that doesn’t conform with your worldview (religion) is not a threat to free speach?
9/11 wasn’t released on TV. The national media has gone to crap ever since Reagan began its deregulation and consolidation.
And don’t talk about speech being controlled talk about libelous content being held and next talk about the Republicans bill just passed to “control speech” by raising huge fine for bad language. They want to control speech on cable and they also are not supporting net neutrality.
That you guys want lies and mis-information to be broadcast before the elections says a lot about how desperate you are, how bankrupt you are and how little the truth supports your position.
Bottom line Clinton was far more responsive to the terrorist threat pre- 9/11 then Bush. And the public should not be mis-informed on these issues using the publicly owned airways.
http://www.pbs.org/now/politics/mediatimeline.html
Hugh,
I think what the issue here is that plenty of “damning”, extremely critical movies and “documentaries” have been made about the Bush administration and no one has tried to stop it. But when something is about to air that would paint the Clinton administration in a poor light we have the censors rushing in with huge black markers and lawyers looking at ways to revoke ABC’s broadcast rights.
Didn’t we just see a “docudrama” in the UK that features president Bush’s assassination?
For 6 years we’ve been told that all of the world’s ills are the direct making of the current administration and I think it’s normal to want a little vindication for that.
Bunyan:
Point out the threat to “pull” their license. You folks are really acting silly on this one.
Hearlder:
That’s logical. We got bad so now it’s your turn to get bad. You in schoolyard or something?
I’ve been saying this all along. There are very few, if any, lefty trolls on this site who have not at one time or another (or constantly in some cases) accused the right wing as being fascists. I realize that every thinking person knows that this is simply projection, which is very commonly employed by the left.
If Lee, Hugh, Muirego, Brian, BarneyG200, feild-negro, and the rest of the secular socialist troll crew on this site want to see a real fascist, they need look no further than the closest mirror
Posted by: P. Bunyan
Hey DING DONG,
Do you understand that one of the main tenant/ methods of Fascism is consolidation of the media (started by Reagan) and involves use of propaganda? This is propaganda that would never have been allowed pre-Reagan.
http://www.pbs.org/now/politics/mediatimeline.html
Oh yeah and one other tenant of Fascism is to have an ignorant, uniformed , easily manipulated, appeasing public…THAT’S YOU!!!!!!
Hugh,
There’s a key part you’re missing here. Republicans got the Reagan mini-series knocked off by protesting, writing letters and threatening boycotts – which we all have the right to do.
No Republican lawmakers ever threatened Congressional action against CBS. No Republican threatened their broadcasting license. If you cannot see the difference between governmental action and private legal action by individuals i.e. boycotts, then it is obvious that you are significantly more ignorant and stupid, or dishonest, than you’ve let on.
The First Amendment of the United States Constitution:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
Harry Reid and his cohorts just threatened to do exactly what the Constitution forbids them to do, promising punishment by the government for the expression of views with which they disagree.
The Democrats have not been able to articulate a unified view of any issue for nearly a decade. But with this episode, at least, we now know exactly what the Democrats have come to stand for.
And you’ve revealed a great deal more about your character that you realize.
Look in the mirror muirego. Over 80% of the broadcast media in this country is socialist (left wing) biased.
I’m sure that was Reagan’s plan…
My God, how the tables have turned. Why is the Clinton response to the film any more outrageous than the Bush response to Farenheit 9/11? Aren’t the circumtances similar?
it seems that the people in this and other right wing forums are less indignant about idealogially motivated media when it is someone they dislike at the wrong end than one would have thought when everyone was taking the moral high road against Michael Moore.
Also, how does this film reconcile with the Right Wing talking points that the MSM being controlled by liberal socialist fanatics? I;m sure we’ll never hear that one again, right?
My God, how the tables have turned. Why is the Clinton response to the film any more outrageous than the Bush response to Farenheit 9/11? Aren’t the circumtances similar?
it seems that the people in this and other right wing forums are less indignant about idealogially motivated media when it is someone they dislike at the wrong end than one would have thought when everyone was taking the moral high road against Michael Moore.
Also, how does this film reconcile with the Right Wing talking points that the MSM being controlled by liberal socialist fanatics? I;m sure we’ll never hear that one again, right?
pharcyde/CenterLeft:
Exactly what was the Bush response to Farenheit 9/11? Because as far as I remember, there was NONE! Thank you for bringing that up by the way, I was just about to.
Muriego said, “That you guys want lies and mis-information to be broadcast before the elections says a lot about how desperate you are, how bankrupt you are and how little the truth supports your position.”
Oh really? Wow, ok, where were you when Michael Moore was sitting in a place of “honor” with Jimmy Carter? I don’t remember anyone in the Republican party bitching and moaning about that steaming pile Moore made and liberals swooned over. All I can say is HYPOCRITES!!!!!!!!!
I heard that they cut the scene that depicts bubba rollin barbra striesand in flour…
What you didn’t address, is the plan to introduce this into schools as part of a curriculum package by Scholastic, Inc.
I agree that ABC/Disney should be able to broadcast it regardless of its veracity. Introducing it into history classes is another thing.
Martin:
For the umpteenth time point out THE THREAT. Point out THE PUNISHMENT BY THE GOVERNMENT.
I really have come to expect more from you. This whole arguement is ridiculous and absurd. Is it politica? Of course it’s political? But to read that letter as “threatening to do exactly what the Constitution forbids…” is a silly stretch.
“Ignorant, stupid, dishonest…” What is that about? It tells me you know your argument has no merit. My “character”? What’s that about? If you need to insult and challenge “character”l you have nothing to say worth hearing.
Farleft: ” Why is the Clinton response to the film any more outrageous than the Bush response to Farenheit 9/11?”
How many Republican politician treatened to close the theaters that show Micheal Moore’s disingenuous secular-socialist propaganda film?
Hugh, please read closely, form the letter to Disney:
“The Communications Act of 1934 provides your network with a free broadcast license predicated on the fundamental understanding of your principle obligation to act as a trustee of the public airwaves in serving the public interest.”
“We urge you, after full consideration of the facts, to uphold your responsibilities as a respected member of American society and as a beneficiary of the free use of the public airwaves to cancel this factually inaccurate and deeply misguided program. We look forward to hearing back from you soon.”
A veiled threat is still a threat.
muirgeo — not to be too picky, but landlords have “tenants.” Political parties have TENETS.
Hugh:
By vindication, I did not mean revenge, I meant exoneration. This isn’t a tit-for-tat argument in my mind.
Posted over at Wizbang Politics: Same subject of course.
I have been following this story and the fury that is being generated by the Left is amazing. This morning it occurred to me that I had seen this all before. It was the Muslim response to a group of cartoons that they believe insulted their central religious figure. I am sure we are only a short way from Kos calling for the beheading of the executives at Disney…
Posted by: Lee Rodgers at September 8, 2006 08:45 AM
Martin,
I think you’re being a little nieve about “No Republican lawmakers ever threatened Congressional action against CBS.” for the airing of a Reagan mini-series. What do you call holding up federal action on rules to restrict ownership of local TV stations? Sound like a threat to Viacom’s first amendment rights to me. You can’t broadcast with out a FCC license.
http://www.cnn.com/2003/SHOWBIZ/TV/11/04/cbs.reagans.ap/
“Showtime and CBS are both owned by Viacom, which is anxiously awaiting federal action on rules to restrict ownership of local TV stations. Failure to enact such changes could cost Viacom millions of dollars, said Jeff Chester, head of the Center for Digital Democracy, a communications lobbying group.”
If that’s not a government threat to their broadcast license and bottom line, I don’t know what is.
So don’t freak out about a perceived threat by the Dems when your side used actually government intimidation to silence a First Amendment protected broadcast.
PS
I thought the whole Reagan mini series was pack of left wing lies. I just wanted you to take off your right wing rose colored glasses and see how the real world works.
Well, when your whole world revolves around conservofacist lies…
… you’ve got to expect to lose a battle once in a while.
The lies you guys tell are wearing thin on the American Public.
Heralder:
Thanks for the clarification. Don’t agree with your point but appreciate your view.
Hugh
I thought “fake but accurate” was OK. So isn’t “embellished but accurate” also OK?
Live@9,
I read the article … but could you please direct me to a quote by any elected Republican Congressman threatening to punish CBS for “The Reagans?”
I have a letter signed by the top leadership of the Congressional Democrat Party with a clear threat to revoke ABC’s broadcasting license unless they accede to the Democrat Party’s demands.
You have nothing more than speculation by some lobbyist named Jeff Chester.
Are you kidding me?
It’s so incredibly outrageous for any bureaucrat or politician to threaten someone’s broadcasting license for putting something on the air that reflects badly on them. It’s a communist tactic, pure and simple. The fact that they can even threaten to do it without facing universal scorn is very threatening to our democracy. And Kerry started this. The fact that they might actually cause this program to be canned is beyond outrageous. Can you imagine a Republican doing this? They wouldn’t even think it.
If the Islamists are unhinged, their leftist cousins are clearly moving in that direction. And who is more dangerous? The idiots who can destroy a building, a city or a way of life for future generations?
Who has damaged this country more? UBL, Bill Clinton or Jimmy Carter?
Hugh,
You’re more than capable of seeing a challenge to Democrats’ patriotism in an innocuous statement like “… we should not forget the lessons we have learned from not taking threats seriously …” by Bush Administration officials
… but you simply find it impossible to see the threat implied by Reid’s citing of the Communications Act of 1934 and the continued existence of ABC’s broadcasting license?
Sure …
I’m sorry but it’s time to reveal the dark secret, the unassailable truth, the secret that haunts America, the fact that every health care insurer refuses to admit. The right wing of this country suffers from paranoia as evidenced by your delusions of persecution regarding this ABC thing. In psychiatry a delusion is a fixed false belief that is resistant to reason or confrontation with actual fact.
Now we have people saying things like: :a clear threat to revoke”,”threatened to close theaters” “the punishment by the government”, “going to pull their license” etc. ad nauseum.
Perhaps if you all sought care together you get a group discount?? Health care costs might even decline, we might have a national boom. But then, there’s always the issue of Bill Clinton hiding under each and every one of your beds…oh if the commies have gotten out to make room.
Hey old “pucker puss” (lee lee) is back! Wait–hmmm are we sure it is the real one. Could he be going by the moniker of “hughie”, “preying mantis”,”mun-go”.”1/2 dead@8:30″,etc. They have to be one of the same as there could not be that many dumbasses in the world.
Martin:
Taken out of context and standing alone I would not say that phrase is a challenge to one’s patriotism. Taken in the context of the speech as well as other speeches by Rumsfeld, Cheyney and Bush over the past few weeks the intent is clear. Don’t be so naive.
How can one be a threat when one is powerless? Also, do you really really believe there would be an effort to revoke ABC’s license? If you do I feel sorry for you.
Again, it’s politics. Not nice politics but then I’m sure you folks appreciate not nice politics.
jhow:
Perhaps another delusinal paranoid? I yam who I yam to paraphrase Popeye the sailr man.
Don’t know Lee….don’t agree with a lot of what Lee has to say but by God I’ll defend his right to say it….also anyone’s right to say it ain’t so.
Hey Tea,
Don’t be apologic about defending ABC. Truth should be defended by all regardless of the source.
Personally, I think ABC should be allowed to broadcast this pile of crap. It’s the first ammendment. And, of course, opponents should be able to protest, boycott or whatever else they choose to do in exercising their constitutional rights.
Of course, the key area of dispute is, does the scene with Sandy Berger letting Osama get away reflect reality, or is it dishonest propaganda. I believe the latter, but I’m ready to hear evidence that this scene was accurate. Fire away!
muirego:
Pining for tighter government control of the media like the ‘good ole days’, are ya ? You’re doing an excellent job of making P Bunyan’s argument for him.
From a commentor at ThinkProgress:
I agree with most all of you! Never. ever, ever watch ABC again. This will drive them into the sewer and they will have to accept money from the same advertising entities that do so well on Fox cable. By god, them damn ABC conservatives will… actually prosper. Must be some damn Carl Rove conspir…wait, got tin foil in my mouth, hurts fillings….there. better… and did I mention that Dick Cheney is reported to own a TV that will actually be able to pick up this ABC illegal transmission? We all know that this conspir……wait, more tinfoil…. that’s better….we all know that Dick Cheney will use this undocumentery as an excuse to launch cruise missiles on the Clinton Library.
Comment by Uncomfortable truth — September 5, 2006 @ 2:48 am
Can the film now be counted as a campaign contribution to the dimwit party? I think it can and it is most likely a crime since it (cost of the film) exceeds the limits on contributions. The pundits and politicians can do and say what they want but the voters in mid America think the democrats just comitted a major felony. The average working american would be charged with a felony for making a threat like that to any company in the world.
USMC Pilot,
There are enough copies of the unedited version out there to compare the edited version to. I know Rush Limbaugh has a copy, Hugh Hewitt has one too. Trust me, we will know what got chopped by Tuesday.
Personally I hope the Democrats and their nutroot tools and trolls keep up the lunatic rantings. Right now they are doing the equivalent of turning the Democratic Titanic around to hit the iceberg a couple more times. I am going to enjoy watching the floorshow.
Scrapiron –
The voters in mid-America don’t know what the word felony means, and they think that Saddam Hussein was behind 9/11.
BTW, a good example of a felony are the dozens of times when the “President” violated FISA…and he continues to do so. (See the law—it’s a felony with punishment by fines and prison terms.)
Mob Boss: Well, Hugh, it’d be a real shame if somebody busted up your store.
Hugh: The mob CARES about my store!
Finding “you’re unpatriotic” in sentences that don’t come close to hinting at it isn’t paranoid, apparently, but seeing a threat to a license when a Senator mentions — for no reason, mind you — the power of Congress to control licensing is just absurd, eh?
-=Mike
lol @ Rovin’s post.
lol at the idea of Cheney bombing that appropriatly testicle & penis shaped building in Little Rock
Hey “hughie” will you defend old Billy Bob’s right to lie also (“I did not hump that there gal under my desk”) he he (“yam”- a member of the sweet potato family)
For those that claim that there wasn’t a veiled threat in Reid’s letter, then why was there a reference to the 1934 Communications Act?? Is that a normal response by a senator when one of the broadcast networks shows something with which he/she disagrees??
Remember this letter was sent in a climate where CW believes the Dems will regain control of at least the House, implying the threat has some teeth to it. IOW, it’s only a veiled threat because there’s a possibility the Dems could do something about it.
Hugh,
Taken out of context and standing alone I would not say that phrase is a challenge to one’s patriotism. Taken in the context … the intent is clear.
Ahh … so you do understand the importance of context. Good. Now, if only you were honest enough to take into context that there is no reason to mention the Communications Act and ABC’s broadcasting license, unless to highlight the fact that they, the Democrats, can do something about its continued existence?
How can one be a threat when one is powerless? Also, do you really really believe there would be an effort to revoke ABC’s license?
Now I see that you’re acknowledging that it is indeed a threat. But that we shouldn’t take it seriously because the Democrats are a minority in Congress.
Interesting.
Again, it’s politics. Not nice politics but then I’m sure you folks appreciate not nice politics.
I’m sorry, but considering that each and every single time a Bush Administration official gives a speech, the Left shrieks at the top of its lungs that the right to free speech is threatened, I seriously doubt you’d be quite so sanguine if the GOP were to send such a letter to CBS, even after it runs “Death Of A President“.
😀 … But I give you this; you are a very slippery character. I’m very impressed.
I thought the Bush administration was responisble for the poor box office performance of Basic Instinct 2? Man, ‘dem Bushies are powerful.
Martin:
Good try bud. Tis I who believe it is you who are slippery. You left out a key point I raised about context. I included the speeches recently given by Bush, Rumsfeld and Cheyney. From them there is a clear political meaning.
Because I raised a debating point about powerlessness to act certainly doesn’t mean I agree it was a threat. Good try at a trap…but no catch.
It is politics, politics and more politics. Admittedly, by the dem senators. You’d think you folks would admire it.
muirego:
This is propaganda that would never have been allowed pre-Reagan.”
Pining for tighter government control of the media like the ‘good ole days’, are ya ? You’re doing an excellent job of making P Bunyan’s argument for him.
Posted by: Mike
Absolutely. We ARE the government and the airwaves are owned by the people.
I suggest we regulate them for fairness and honesty. And also they should be broken up so no monopolies exist. But apparently you think it would serve the public interest to deregulate them, let them be owned by a small number of multi-national corporations and allow them to lie as much as they want…..you silly little know-nothing insignificant background Orwellian character you.
During times of universal deceit, telling the truth becomes a revolutionary act.
George Orwell
“Oh please I want to be a stupid propagandized media controlled mind-bot….just plug me into the Matrix. I don’t care if it’s reality as long as I THINK ITS REALITY I”LL BE FINE.”
A group quote by all living conservatives/ excluding the ones in charge