Let me make clear I’ve never been a big fan of Disney and ABC. When Disney bought ABC, I feared the worst — and those fears were confirmed when Disney turned ABC into a marketing arm for the company.
But now, with ABC’s planned “docudrama” on the leadup to 9/11, I find myself in the very uncomfortable position of defending them.
Just for the sake of argument, let’s presume that all the program’s critics are correct (a severely dubious possibility, but let’s run with it). Let’s say that the piece is a total smear of the Clinton administration and a near-perfect whitewashing of the Bush administration in recognizing and addressing the rising threat Al Qaeda posed. That through half-truths, selected omissions, and outright fabrications (kind of a mirror-image Fahrenheit 9/11), the tale told is all about how Bill Clinton was too busy selling military secrets to China, boinking everything in a skirt, and arranging the murders of dozens of people who might have some dirt on him, and the Bush administration was too busy trying to put “W’s” back on their computer keyboards (you can’t talk about Wahabism, War on Terror, or World Trade Center without that key letter) to catch up on what was brewing.
So, what should be done about it?
According to some key Democrats on Capitol Hill, it’s a Capital Offense. They want to “look into” revoking ABC’s broadcasting license and putting the network off the air.
It’s a familiar tactic. During the 2004 campaign, some folks put together a piece on the Swift Boat Veterans For Truth. When Sinclair, a chain of television stations, planned to air it, a bunch of the Left wanted to pull their licenses, too.
Now, I’ve been offended by my share of things on television. Janet Jackson and that boob (no, not Justin Timberlake) bugged me — mainly because I hated that grotesque jewelry she wore, mutilating the natural beauty and grace of the human female breast. I also thought it was almost as tacky to pull that off (no pun intended) during the Super Bowl, an event billed as a “family-friendly” event — and very few families would consider a pierced nipple “something the whole family can enjoy.” (For one, infants could injure themselves.)
And when CBS (in an eerily-prescient form of “fake but accurate”) planned a “biography” of Ronald Reagan that was little more than a thinly-veiled smear piece, there were lots of howls of protest and outrage. But the strongest action I can recall was a threat to boycott sponsors of the shows. And it worked — CBS moved it to Showtime, a network completely free of advertising sponsors to threaten.
Instead, the Democratic party is showing one area where it actually has some testicular fortitude — if you say something (or even might be planning to say something) that threatens their heroes, that makes them look bad, they’ll go straight for your jugular with all the power of the federal government they can muster. Constitutional principles (freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and so on) be damned.
So if you like the idea of Congress deciding just what opinions and viewpoints can and can not be aired over the public airwaves, feel free to support the NutRoots’ takeover of the Democratic party and their move to take the reins of government. For one, it’ll take that awful burden of thinking for yourself off your hands.


JHOW66
Wrong, yams and sweet potatos are not in the same family.
They want to “look into” revoking ABC’s broadcasting license and putting the network off the air.
Cute, you put “look into” in quotes as if you’re quoting someone. But you’re really just making it up. Sure, it was stupid for the Democrats to even write such a letter, and even dumber to bring up licenses, but the fact remains that the networks do use our airwaves for free and have responsibilities to live up to. If they don’t and are called on it, that’s not a threat.
You people are ridiculous.
Here’s Sen. Brownback “threatening” the networks licences,
and here’s Rep. Pickering doing the same, and Rep. Upton.
Well, they mention broadcast licenses and the networks’ responsibilities to the public, so they must be threats, right? A imagined…er, veiled threat is still a threat, right?
Hope your vapors clear up soon, folks.
Hugh,
So if the Reid letter was only about politics (your contention), what’s wrong with the Reps politicizing the contents of that letter?? Isn’t that basically what’s going on, the Reps demonstrating what giving Congressional control to the Dems would mean??
millco:
Absolutley…..nothing wrong at all.
Absolutely. We ARE the government and the airwaves are owned by the people.
Wow. You really aren’t a fan of the 1st Amendment are you? And since when do we OWN airwaves? Can I sue you for violating my airwave property boundaries? Does my airwave property boundary follow me as I travel, or do I trespass on everybody else’s airwaves?
Truly deep stuff.
I suggest we regulate them for fairness and honesty.
Bye-bye all licenses, since the news has never been fair nor particularly honest.
But apparently you think it would serve the public interest to deregulate them, let them be owned by a small number of multi-national corporations and allow them to lie as much as they want.
Hmm, how about we try this?
There are more television channels than, say, newspapers. Why don’t we heavily regulate NEWSPAPERS, since they are, by far, the more rare outlet for info?
Or would you see that for the patently ridiculous idea that it is?
During times of universal deceit, telling the truth becomes a revolutionary act.
George Orwell
And pointing out that Clinton’s people were hardly bastions of excellence about terrorism — just as Condi gets trashed — is somehow incorrect?
Got it.
Cute, you put “look into” in quotes as if you’re quoting someone. But you’re really just making it up. Sure, it was stupid for the Democrats to even write such a letter, and even dumber to bring up licenses, but the fact remains that the networks do use our airwaves for free and have responsibilities to live up to. If they don’t and are called on it, that’s not a threat.
Small problem.
The examples you cited aren’t comparable.
Brownback dealt solely with fines. While absurd nanny-statist of him, it’s a far cry from SHUTTING THEM DOWN. Ditto Pickering.
All we’ve learned is that the lefties will heartily support government shutting down the press they don’t agree with.
They have a lot more in common with our opponents than even I could have fathomed.
-=Mike
While absurd nanny-statist of him, it’s a far cry from SHUTTING THEM DOWN.
They said they were going to shut ABC down? When?
There is a ESPN commercial where Dwayne Wade is sprucing up his video’s. It’s just like this.
Hugh,
That’s fair. I would agree that the letter isn’t a substantive issue (no licenses will be revoked), only a political miscalculation by Dems, especially this close to an election they’re supposed to win.
It’s just another example that this election is like a football game between two 8-8 teams. Neither is good enough to win on their own, so they try to capitalize on the other’s mistakes.
millco:
Couldn’t agree more. Nice to see someone as astute as me!!!!
ABC’s decision to promote this “docu-drama” by releasing review copies exclusively to extremely partisan, conservative outlets gave the game away. That action revealed that in their own estimation this is a purely partisan endeavor aimed at a specific, limited political audience — and aimed at serving specific political interests during the election season — rather than a disinterested work that’s intention is only to present an historically accurate representation of events to the public at large and raise issues of significant concern to all Americans.
Political players come and go. But powerful media interests are with us always. When such interests let themselves be so nakedly pressed into the service of specific political players, they encourage extreme cynicism among the public at large and do great damage to the public trust.
We need some ethical and disinterested players among the most powerful interests in our society to speak, at least on occasion, to our common interests and deeply shared values as Americans, and to encourage the unity that our forefathers recognized as essential to our strength as a nation.
That there are no longer such players — among our religious leaders, our political leaders or our corporate and media leaders — is a loss to the entire nation.
I think tennis is a better analogy and this letter was definitely an unforced error.
This reminds of the last major election when the Dems were convinced that they would win and win easily. They will not win this time either and that will be crushing. In fact, I bet they are so sure they have not even thought of contingency plans.
The simple truth of the matter is that almost everyone in our government, from Jimmy Carter through G. W. Bush on the morning of 9/11/01, as well as the various Congresses from the 1970s to the 2000s, and most in the CIA and FBI, failed to take the threat of international Islamic terrorism as seriously as it needed to be. All of the warning signs were read wrong, downplayed, ignored, or thoroughly misunderstood, or mis-communicated, or lost in the bureaucracy, or forbidden to be shared with competing intelligence agencies, etc. etc.
Clinton and his team were in office for 8 years and had numerous attacks to deal with, but chose to use diplomacy and criminal justice. Bush chose to start formulating a more comprehesive approach, nothing of which even came close to fruition before 9/11. Neither administration was steller, neither administration recognized just how dangerous the climate was becoming.
The 9/11 commission got it right: there was a “lack of immagination.”
But since 9/11, Bush has been utterly determined that it not happen again–and to also stamp out the incredible evil of Islamic fascism/terrorism. Bush got the message loud and clear. It’s such a bloody shame that the Clintonites care more about their legacy than the future.
But bitching about the lead up to 9/11 and who was to blame is like the old slur that FDR know of and let Pearl Harbor happen.
Free speech is a very selective concept with the Dems. One more reason they don’t get my vote.
Are you truly such an illiterate, ignorant moron as to not see the irony of calling others facists while at the very same time advocating that only government filtered programming be allowed ? Surely, not even you are that stupid.
What are the democrats afraid of? What is in this movie? Does it have anything to do with documents Sandy Burglar stole? I think everyone is curious now. I would like to buy 100 dvd copies of the original version. Where can I buy them?
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
Such hypocrites. You would all be up in arms if your Chimp in office was the subject of the same sort of twisted facts on film.
Stop trying to act outraged. It’s just plain hollow.
The democrats have put ABC in a position they can’t wiggle out of, if they show the movie the democrats will revoke their license (first they have to regain power) and if they don’t show the movie due to blackmail by the democrats the Republicans and true Americans will send the democrats home in droves come Nov. I don’t know one person that is in favor of giving in to blackmail.
I sent my comment to ABC this morning:
“Either show the ‘Path to 9-11’ in its entirety or make a public admission on every newscast that you were blackmailed by the democratic party into changing it”.
A simple and short notice that they are being watched and the next move is theirs to make or break the network and put all broadcasters in a position that they will have to bow and scrape to the democrats before each broadcast or lose their broadcast license.
Objections to subject matter that appear on the public air waves — and efforts to limit what appears — come from every place on the political spectrum. These efforts have never been limited to one political party or one side in the ideological debate.
Republican office holders certainly have made threats against the licenses of particular media players in the past, and most likely will do so again in the future.
And if the issue is gross distortions of the truth and efforts to influence public opinion with lies and other forms of dishonesty, they will have a point.
Freedom of the press does not excuse either dangerous irresponsibility or slander. The media does have ethical responsibilities to the public, and they should be pressured to live up to those responsibilities.
As for purely political speech, the media, and most of the rest of us, were probably better off during the days of the Fairness Doctrine. That doctrine required presentation of “both sides” of political issues and required that the broadcat media offer opportunities for rebuttal of partisan presentations and arguments.
The lifting of that doctrine has encouraged more angry, colorful and extreme partisan speech in the media, that many may find more entertaining — but it has also encouraged the increasing number of, and increasingly angry, colorful and extremely partisan attacks against the media that we see today.
Thor4, you are an idiot, plain and simple.
Bush has already been the subject of “the same sort of twisted facts on film”, several times in fact. There have been countless books, articles, news reports and films about Bush that are factually incorrect. Have you heard Bush complain or speak up about ONE single one of them? No, you haven’t, I challenge you to find me one example. The only hypocrites here are you and the other moonbats and the democratic party. If the white house had tried to squash any of the “patriotic dissent” against Bush, liberals would go stark raving mad shouting about the first amendment and republicans being fascists, yet when the democrats want to trample the first amendment it is all well and good. The issue here is that Clinton and the democrats don’t give a crap about the truth, or te future, they care only about their “legacy”. The reason you don’t here Bush crying about all the garbage written and produced about him is that he would actually like to get some work done for this country.
By the way, this is extremely vague —
“According to some key Democrats on Capitol Hill, it’s a Capital Offense. They want to “look into” revoking ABC’s broadcasting license and putting the network off the air.”
Can anyone tell me specifically who “some” are? And provide precise quotes of their alleged threats?
esmense, you bring up a good point about the fairness doctrine. In regards to ABC’s “docu-drama”, everyone who has viewed it has said that it is unflattering to both the Clinton and Bush administrations. Sounds fair. Of course you only hear one side crying about it.
Thor4 – Heard of Mikey Moore and F9/11 which I am sure you believed to be fact.
esmense – Care to apply fairness doctrine to NPR, ABC news (GMA). NBC new (Today’s Show), and CBS News?
D_Hogg —
When it was Reagan’s ox being gored (and “legacy” being threatened) — at least as perceived by Republicans — the crying was all on the other side. And the network (NBC, in that case) responded by pulling the program from its broadcast outlet.
My personal opinion about this situation is that the producers of the program — who have been upfront about their political leanings — certainly were politically motivated in terms of how they decided to both present and promote the material. They had a partisan objective — in terms of both influencing public and historical perception and influencing the upcoming election. But I think ABC and Disney, much to their regret now, were clueless about that agenda. No large corporate entity that relies on the broadest possible public support can afford to pander so dramatically to a limited partisan audience. Such pandering inevitably engenders a huge negative backlash from those outside the golden partisan circle.
If this program is pulled or edited, it won’t be because of letters from out-of-power politicians. It will be because of outrage expressed by hundreds of thousand of ordingary viewers.
The conservatives who post here may believe that Americans overwhelmingly see things exactly as they do — but the fact is that millions of Americans don’t. And corporate entities like Disney and ABC really can’t afford to get on the wrong side of that large a segment of the public.
Thor4 – Heard of Mikey Moore and F9/11 which I am sure you believed to be fact.
Posted by: James Brewer
The big picture of Michael Moores’ film IS true. Rich guys with power start wars and poor kids fight them….they die and the rich get a little richer. Completely supported by the evidence.
You guys need to listen to Ike. I’m not the one making this stuff up.
“In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military industrial complex. The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist.
We must never let the weight of this combination endanger our liberties or democratic processes. We should take nothing for granted. Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry can compel the proper meshing of the huge industrial and military machinery of defense with our peaceful methods and goals, so that security and liberty may prosper together.
Dwight D. Eisenhower, 1961
plenty of “damning”, extremely critical movies and “documentaries” have been made about the Bush administration and no one has tried to stop it.
You’re obviously forgetting Disney’s decision to kill the completed F/911 and not release it, causing the producers to find another release outlet. This move was predicated on the threat of political fallout, namely the loss of tax breaks in the state where the president’s brother was governor.
Hey “waldo” yams and sweet potatos are in the same “family” at my house. We eat them both. Ahem.
“
let’s presume that all the program’s critics are correct (a severely dubious possibility
…
CBS planned a “biography” of Ronald Reagan that was little more than a thinly-veiled smear piece
That tells you all you need to know right there about where Jay is coming from. It is “dubious” that a movie about Clinton could contain mere inaccuracies, but an unqualified fact that the movie about Reagan was a flat-out smear piece.
And let’s not forget the strawman where “Let’s say that the piece is” is followed by a list of things no one ever said.
Esmense, the problem is what the crying was trying to do about it. The whole Reagan “docu-drama” thing caused conservatives to boycott sponsors. What we’re worried is that liberals are talking about government regulation. Can you not see the difference? I believe in the right to free speech. I also believe in the right of a free press. How can you not see that this ABC documentary is both? What conservatives did was a “free speech” way of showing displeasure by boycotting sponsors in this capitalist way. If Democrats wrote letters amongst themselves to boycott sponsors of ABC, that would have been the correct action. Instead a few of them write a letter threatening ABC itself of Government action (please don’t whitewash what the letter says, mentioning that ABC still has to have the Fed. Government’s license-permission-to stay on the air is more or less a veiled threat).
Oh and technically another “legal” way to go about this would be for them to sue ABC over libel. The fact that they AREN’T shows that they think it is factually accurate.
Jame Brewer —
Of course the “Fairness Doctrine” no longer applies to any media outlet — including the ones you mention.
You may be younger than me and so don’t remember how things worked when it did apply — when it was routine for news outlets to provide time, at the end of a broadcast, to individuals and representatives of groups who wished to rebut or provide another side to some presentation of a particular issue that had appeared in the news. Personally, I think such opportunities for rebuttal were a good thing.
Instead a few of them write a letter threatening ABC itself of Government action (please don’t whitewash what the letter says, mentioning that ABC still has to have the Fed. Government’s license-permission-to stay on the air is more or less a veiled threat).
Try less. What action has been threatened? Reminding a network of its responsibility to the public because they are, in fact, using our airwaves, is not a threat.
If you want an example of a real threat, look at when the House passed their version of the Broadcast Decency Enforcement Act of 2005, which provided for license revocation for three indecency violations. That is a threat, legislation introduced to force the networks to cease airing certain (ill-defined) content.
You’ll see that Rep. Pickering is still pushing it even though the Senate axed that part of the bill:
Pickering suggested that future legislation could consider license revocation for multiple indecency offenses
A letter written to the network reminding them of their responsibilities to the public is not a threat, no matter how you try to spin it. If you think that ABC is worried about legislation designed to take away their license (which would no doubt be unconstitutional), or that somehow the Democrats are going to persuade the FCC to hold hearings on license revocation (which would also be unconstitutional since presumably ABC would not be in violation of FCC guidelines no matter what they air, unless it’s bare breasts), rather than ratings you are delusional. And if you think that’s what this letter means you are equally delusional.
FWIW I think the letter was a dumb move. Not threatening, just stupid. I understood when Clinton and crew complained, since they are the ones being portrayed, apparently inaccurately, but the Congressional Dems should have stayed out of it.
esmense, the problem with your analogie is that noone in the republican party tried to stop the Reagan “film”. That was done through boycotts of sponsors. That is VASTLY different from the higher ups in the democratic party threatening ABC and Disney. Furthermore, as has been mentioned before, the docudrama is apparently not kind to either the Clinton or Bush administrations, and I am sure that is rightly so, yet we only hear whining from one group here, arguably the one that doesn’t want “truth-out”. And if you really think that objections from the american public, which I guarantee you the majority of which would NOT support such censorship, are going to be a greater influence in the pulling of this docudrama then the letters and cries from the Clintonistas, then you are dimmer then any of us knew.
muirgeo, you are a total idiot, FAKE BUT ACCURATE huh. The bigger picture of F 9/11 is true?! Holy crap, I am laughing my ass off, your hypocrisy gets more and more transparent by the second. If that is truly the case, then why in the HELL are you arguing against the airing of this docudrama?! Cause surely “the bigger picture IS true”, it has been corroborated by the CIA agent named in the Berger incident, as well as other Clinton Admins. Surely I jest though, you’d rather believe someone who has pled guilty to crimes that relate exactly to what the democrats are kicking and screaming about.
Henry —
The broadcast media are and alway have been government regulated. What do you think the FCC is?
I asked for some genuine and specific quotes from Democrats threatening ABC in a previous post, and no one has provided any.
As mantis points out in his post, reminding a powerful media network like ABC, and a content producer like Disney, of their public responsibilities is not a threat. Holding them accountable for the truth and accuracy of the material they broadcast is a public responsibility — a responsibility that you and I bear as much as do members of congress.
Everyone, including you, me and Democratic members of congress, has a right to protest the actions of the media — and try to influence their behavior when we believe it is detrimental to public interest or even just our own interest.
D_Hoggs —
Use your common sense. The producers of this material did not promote their project heavily among conservative media outlets (while denying access to review copies to liberal outlets) because they thought the program would be perceived as critical of Bush. Quite the opposite. They knew that they had slanted the material to satisfy conservatives, and they knew that they could depend on conservatives to promote the project exactly for that reason.
As for threat of boycott, that is exactly what the hundreds of thousand of ordinary people who have been registering their displeasure with ABC and Disney have been doing — threatening to boycott their products. In this case, advertisers haven’t been threatened with boycott only because the program is to be presented without commercials.
If this program WAS highly critical of Bush would prominent conservative political figures make public protests (as they did with the Reagan movie)? Of course they would.
The tendency of partisans to ascribe saintliness to members of their team and the worst of human frailties to their opposite is amusing.
The fact is, in matters like this, there is absolutely no difference between how Democrats or Republicans behave.
we only hear whining from one group here, arguably the one that doesn’t want “truth-out”.
I really can’t tell if someone making such a statement is really that ignorant of reality, or if they’re intentionally misrepresenting the reality.
The ONLY so-called “whines” that have been made are those that are INSISTING the truth be told. And not some partisan version of the truth that Clinton will offer, but rather the hard, documented, right-there-for-anyone-to-see-if-they-bothered-to-look, can’t-be-denied, actual, honest truth. Why are you afraid of the truth?
Brian:”The ONLY so-called “whines” that have been made are those that are INSISTING the truth be told. And not some partisan version of the truth that Clinton will offer..”
Really? Then why are the Clintonites and Dems the only ones crying about it?
Face it: The Reps would prefer a docudrama that makes them look good and the Dems look bad.
The Dems would prefer a docudrama that makes them look good and the Reps look bad.
But the only ones trying to change the show are the Clintonites.
By all accounts from people who have already seen it, BOTH sides made mistakes. Doesn’t it make you wonder why only the Dems are protesting so much?
Why aren’t the Republicans protesting? Because the movie was made by ideological conservatives and Republican partisans — and based, in part, on a book written by a Bush administration PR official.
The mini-series undoubtedly offers criticism of Bush administration actions — or more likely inactions — and it also reportedly criticizes the law enforcement and military agencies involved. But, what it doesn’t do to the Bush administration that it does do with the Clinton administration, is make scenes and speeches up out of wholecloth in order to create false history. Furthermore, the false history thus created obviously is intended to serve the Bush administrations political interests.
So tell me, with all that going for them in this project — the blame cast dramatically on the Democrats and a helpful-to-them false version of history broadcast to millions during the election season — why would they protest some minor criticism of their own actions?
They would be fools if they did so. Because that kind of complaint would get the series cancelled — and that wouldn’t serve the Bush administration’s purposes at all.
So if the letter wasn’t a veiled threat, then where’s their correction saying they weren’t implying any actual action or anything like that? I’m sure they’ve heard by now what they’re being accused of.
furthermore:
“But, what it doesn’t do to the Bush administration that it does do with the Clinton administration, is make scenes and speeches up out of wholecloth in order to create false history.”
Oh really? Have you seen it? I mean, in it’s entirety. Because to my knowledge, those who have actually seen anything at all have only seen Part I, unedited. And considering that it follows a timeline, the role Bush’s admin plays should be covered later. Likely in Part II.
One should not speak of that which one does not know. It could make one look foolish later.
So if the letter wasn’t a veiled threat, then where’s their correction saying they weren’t implying any actual action or anything like that? I’m sure they’ve heard by now what they’re being accused of.
My guess is that if they have heard the silly accusations from Powerline and Wizbang, they realize that no normal people agree or even care, and it’s not worth responding to. Something about wrestling with pigs comes to mind.
Oh and technically another “legal” way to go about this would be for them to sue ABC over libel. The fact that they AREN’T shows that they think it is factually accurate.
Actually, no political figure really wants to sue for that because it’s usually a bigger headache than it’s worth. It keeps the smear in the air longer.
Use your common sense. The producers of this material did not promote their project heavily among conservative media outlets (while denying access to review copies to liberal outlets) because they thought the program would be perceived as critical of Bush.
To use one example, how did Hugh Hewitt get a copy?
He asked for it. WEEKS and weeks ago.
Did the leftie blogs ask for it?
Good money says no, they did not.
If this program WAS highly critical of Bush would prominent conservative political figures make public protests (as they did with the Reagan movie)? Of course they would.
It is and we’re not.
Why aren’t the Republicans protesting? Because the movie was made by ideological conservatives and Republican partisans — and based, in part, on a book written by a Bush administration PR official.
Which would be news to the producer and executive producer of the piece.
Unless you think the writer has the ability to override the people bankrolling it and controlling all aspects of the production.
-=Mike
mantis; those “silly accusations” are not coming just from Powerline and Wizbang. Although why you’ve singled those two out is clear to me as I’ve seen much of your commentary here. Considering that, I think my question was fair. As I stated myself, more than once, the letter can be construed as a veiled threat. It doesn’t specifically say so, and I’m not convinced that it WAS a threat, real or imagined, but I understand why some people think so. Considering the visciouness of the dialogue that has ensued from all quarters since even before the letter, I can understand why tensions are high and one would come to that conclusion.
I am, however, curious about your assumption of what constitutes “normal people”. Isn’t that a bit subjective?
Really? Then why are the Clintonites and Dems the only ones crying about it?
The answer is so obvious it makes the question ridiculous. Because they are the ones most harmed by the lies being shown. Because they are the only ones with enough integrity to point out the inaccuracies being told in a historical drama.
Face it: The Reps would prefer a docudrama that makes them look good and the Dems look bad.
The Dems would prefer a docudrama that makes them look good and the Reps look bad.
Perhaps, but all I want is the truth. Don’t you?
Because to my knowledge, those who have actually seen anything at all have only seen Part I, unedited. And considering that it follows a timeline, the role Bush’s admin plays should be covered later. Likely in Part II.
One should not speak of that which one does not know. It could make one look foolish later.
Sounds reasonable. I assume that also applies to the many conservatives saying “the movie is just as critical of Bush as it is of Clinton”? By your assessment, they have no way of knowing that, and are just making even more shit up as part of their partisan ranting. At least the left has a tangible something on which to base their criticism. The right has nothing with which to counter them, except for blind hatred.
Because they are the only ones with enough integrity to point out the inaccuracies being told in a historical drama.
Explains the condemnation the Dems had for Fahrenheit 9/11.
-=Mike
Explains the condemnation the Dems had for Fahrenheit 9/11.
Most liberals, myself included, have significant disdain for F9/11 and Michael Moore. For all the times the conservatives on this blog have rolled him out, I don’t recall seeing a single post from the left defending him.
The difference is that conservatives’ disdain of Moore arose immediately, based on nothing more than gut hatred. Whereas liberals, although admittedly inclined to favor Moore’s positions to begin with, were open enough to listen to the rational (and I emphasize, rational) response and rebuttal, and then use logic and reason to ultimately agree that yes, in fact, Moore distorted facts and the film was in many ways inaccurate. Those “56 lies in F/911”, although many of them are lies or stretches themselves, contained enough truth to reveal Moore’s distortions to anyone open enough to accept the truth. Are you not open enough to accept the truth about “Path to 9/11”?
That you continue to hold Moore up as some kind of hero of the left shows just how out of touch you are with mainstream America.
Most liberals, myself included, have significant disdain for F9/11 and Michael Moore.
Your ability to silence it truly is impressive.
For all the times the conservatives on this blog have rolled him out, I don’t recall seeing a single post from the left defending him.
There were a few in one of these posts, arguing that the overall story was true.
The difference is that conservatives’ disdain of Moore arose immediately, based on nothing more than gut hatred.
And not a long track record of outright lies, eh?
Whereas liberals, although admittedly inclined to favor Moore’s positions to begin with, were open enough to listen to the rational (and I emphasize, rational) response and rebuttal, and then use logic and reason to ultimately agree that yes, in fact, Moore distorted facts and the film was in many ways inaccurate.
Yet…your side is threatening to yank a broadcasting license for a movie you haven’t even seen yet. And you defend it.
Bizarre.
Those “56 lies in F/911”, although many of them are lies or stretches themselves, contained enough truth to reveal Moore’s distortions to anyone open enough to accept the truth. Are you not open enough to accept the truth about “Path to 9/11”?
What, that both sides were hardly perfect about terrorism before 9/11? Yup, quite open to it.
Your side seems incapable of handling ANY questioning of the Clinton record.
That you continue to hold Moore up as some kind of hero of the left shows just how out of touch you are with mainstream America.
That your side’s political party hugged him and had him sit in the VIP box at their Convention shows that one side of the aisle is out of touch.
-=Mike
Brian, that you forget that Michael Moore was given a position of honor at the last Democratic National Convention and several congressional Democratic leaders attended the premiere and praised the movie shows how out of touch you are with the current mainstream Democratic Party.
For all the Left’s demonizing of Pat Robertson, Jerry Falwell, Pat Buchanan, Ann Coulter, et al, I don’t recall any of those people getting anywhere near the attention and laudations Michael Moore, Howard Dean, Cindy Sheehan, Code Pink, etc. have garnered.
J.
Your ability to silence it truly is impressive.
What, we now have to actively protest Michael Moore? How about if we just let him fade away, or boo him when he tries to make political speeches at non-political events? When was the last time you heard anyone care about anything he’s had to say? Certainly he is far less visible in Democratic politics than Ann Coulter is in Republican politics.
And not a long track record of outright lies, eh?
That’s just admitting you support condemning a piece of work based on preconceived notions, and not on the merits.
Yet…your side is threatening to yank a broadcasting license for a movie you haven’t even seen yet. And you defend it.
I’m not sure what this response has to do with the passage from my post that you’re responding to. No, I haven’t seen the movie yet, but I am relying on the statements from those who have, including the producers themselves and conservative pundits. If you wish to dispute that the scene descriptions being debated are not actual scenes from the movie, feel free to do so. But no one else has disputed that they actually appear in the advance copies of the film.
I haven’t defended anything, nor do I agree that reminding a public broadcasting entity of their responsibility and requirement to use the public airwaves in a non-partisan way constitutes a “threat”. At least, no moreso than any reminder to someone that they’re not doing what they agreed to. When a cop tells you “when you got your license, you agreed not to speed”, I suppose there’s an implicit threat there that you risk your license by continuing to speed, but there’s really no other way to tell someone that they’re violating their agreement. Unless you think the networks should not be held to what they agreed to.
What, that both sides were hardly perfect about terrorism before 9/11? Yup, quite open to it.
Nice strawman, but no, that’s not what I suggested you cannot accept. Though I also agree that both sides were hardly perfect about terrorism. Wouldn’t you rather see the hardly perfect truth, as opposed to the hardly perfect falsehood?
Your side seems incapable of handling ANY questioning of the Clinton record.
I can fully handle the accurate record, as clearly and indisputably described in the 9/11 Commission Report. What I cannot handle is the false presentation of any record, Clinton or Bush. Apparently false records are OK with you.
Brian: ” “Really? Then why are the Clintonites and Dems the only ones crying about it?”
The answer is so obvious it makes the question ridiculous. Because they are the ones most harmed by the lies being shown.”
Uh, Brian, if you haven’t seen the movie, then how do you know it’s the Dems that are ‘most harmed’? You don’t.
.
.
“At least the left has a tangible something on which to base their criticism. “
Again, how do you know that if you haven’t seen it? You can’t.
.
.
” ‘Face it: The Reps would prefer a docudrama that makes them look good and the Dems look bad.
The Dems would prefer a docudrama that makes them look good and the Reps look bad.’
Perhaps, but all I want is the truth. Don’t you?”
And you expect to get The Truth out of some Hollywood production? I don’t. It’s a docudrama, for chrissake. Show me one, just one, that was 100% truth with no embellishments. You can’t; but you sure are holding this one particular movie to the highest standards ever.
.
.
Face it Brian. The Dems are making themselves look whiny to the general public by protesting too much. They are also bringing extra attention to the movie and giving the appearance that they have something to hide, even if they do not.
They just don’t look very grownup in this whole affair.