The more I think about Pope Benedict’s remarks last week, and the fallout thereof, the more I think I like this guy.
He initially quoted they Byzantine emperor Manuel II, who said in 1391:
“Show me just what Muhammad brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached.”
It provoked a HUGE furor, with all sorts of people — not just Muslims, but some others as well — calling him all sorts of names and demanding all kinds of apologies and acts of contrition and even some for some serious retribution against the Pontiff.
Then he issued his apology, stating that he”sincerely regrets that certain passages of his address could have sounded offensive to the sensitivities of the Muslim faithful…”
A few accused Bennie (I like him so much, I feel comfortable calling him by a nickname) of weaseling, of backing down from his initial statement. Hell, at first, so did I. But then I thought about it some more, and two things struck me:
1) While whole hosts of people got bent out of shape over his quoting Manuel II, I didn’t see too many refutations of it, with people citing just where Manuel got it wrong and showing some positive innovations from Islam.
2) Bennie’s “apology” followed the liberal model of such things, saying in essence “I’m sorry you were offended.” He didn’t say he was wrong, that he regretted saying it, or any of the other hallmarks of a sincere apology; he just said he felt badly that some folks didn’t like hearing it.
I have a lot of issues with the Catholic Church in general, and I’m not really thrilled with a lot of Benedict XVI’s notions and policies, but in this matter he’s got this agnostic firmly in his corner.
Can I have an “AMEN!” from the people?

AMEN!
Amen, brother !
Ditto!
ya know..if you folks want to live in a world over 500 years ago..before Martin Luther literally nailed the Cath Church..before so many of the white folks came to America because of Cath crap like this…then I say Amen….
Jesus expressed love to a whore..a tax collecter was one of his disciples..his message was one of tolerance(I can quote scripture)
C’mon..how about some amens for the Spanish Cath. Inquisition..
Dear Jay! I completely agree with you – having the same distance from the Catholic Church (compare with my blog), except that I am impressed by one thing: are you an atheist who became a Cardinal and actually voted for Bennie? 🙂 Or what do you mean by saying that you voted for him?
Amen, Bennie!!!
Catholics have looked upon their shameful past history with forced conversions and the Pope has invited Muslims to do the same. The answer was quite predictable when you consider most of these people are still living in the 7th Century.
Somehow I get the feeling that this was not the kind of dialogue Khatami had in mind when he was on his “Smiling face of Islam” tour here in America. It is too frank and honest for his tastes.
http://www.ushmm.org/wlc/article.php?lang=en&ModuleId=10005206
AMEN! May god continue to give this man the wisdom and strength to speak out against the oh so peaceful religion 😉
Yeah the old , “My God is better then your God” argument. That always has worked so well in the past to settle disputes.
I would like to comment on the Pope’s recent message denigrating the prophet Muhammad and misinterpreting Islam and misunderstanding jihad (self control).
1) John Paul II was the embodiment of the love of Jesus and he endeared people to him and Catholicism. Praying to the common God and joint prayers were a fantastic manifestation of our common humanity. Any other direction will alienate Muslims, Christians and Jews away from each other.
2) Arab armies never conquered or stayed in India, Indonesia, Malaysia, or Bangladesh, where 80% of all Muslims reside. Arab armies did reach the Indus, but Mohammad bin Qasim quickly withdrew. The conversions for a vast majority of Muslims (who now live in Asia)was by Sufis and traders and by example and because Islam was LOGICAL and simple…pray to one God.
3) In the 7th century, Arab armies comprised of less than 25,000 able bodied men as soldiers, out of a population of 50,000. It is a physical impossibility to spread Islam to millions with such a small army or by force of arms. Muslims could not have spread Islam through the sword from Arabia to Morocco and destroyed the Byzantine and Roman empires, if Islam did not have grass level appeal based on “Arianism” (unity of God), which was never actually eliminated even though Emperor Constantine had imposed trinity at the Council of Nicea in 325AD.
4) The idea of holy war or jihad (which is about defending the community or at most about establishing rule by Muslims, not about imposing the faith on individuals by force) is also not a Quranic doctrine. The doctrine was elaborated much later, on the Umayyad-Byzantine frontier, long after the Prophet’s death. In fact, in early Islam it was hard to join, and Christians who asked to become Muslim were routinely turned away. The tyrannical governor of Iraq, al-Hajjaj, was notorious for this rejection of applicants, because he got higher taxes on non-Muslims. Arab Muslims had conquered Iraq, which was then largely pagan, Zoroastrian, Christian and Jewish. But they weren’t seeking converts and certainly weren’t imposing their religion. http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2006/09/15/18311787.php
5) But there have been many schools of Islamic theology and philosophy. The Mu’tazilite school maintained exactly what the Pope is saying, that God must act in accordance with reason and the good as humans know them. The Mu’tazilite approach is still popular in Zaidism and in Twelver Shiism of the Iraqi and Iranian sort. The Ash’ari school, in contrast, insisted that God was beyond human reason and therefore could not be judged rationally. (I think the Pope would find that Tertullian and perhaps also John Calvin would be more sympathetic to this view within Christianity than he is).
As for the Quran, it constantly appeals to reason in knowing God, and in refuting idolatry and paganism, and asks, “do you not reason?” “do you not understand?” (a fala ta`qilun?)
http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2006/09/15/18311787.php
6) The idea of holy war or jihad (which is about defending the community or at most about establishing rule by Muslims, not about imposing the faith on individuals by force) is also not a Quranic doctrine. The doctrine was elaborated much later, on the Umayyad-Byzantine frontier, long after the Prophet’s death. In fact, in early Islam it was hard to join, and Christians who asked to become Muslim were routinely turned away. The tyrannical governor of Iraq, al-Hajjaj, was notorious for this rejection of applicants, because he got higher taxes on non-Muslims. Arab Muslims had conquered Iraq, which was then largely pagan, Zoroastrian, Christian and Jewish. But they weren’t seeking converts and certainly weren’t imposing their religion.
http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2006/09/15/18311787.php
7) Did the Pope have selective amnesia about tolerating the holocaust, sprinkling holy water on the marching Nazi soldiers, directing the crusades, supporting the ethnic cleansing of native Americans, supporting conquistador invasions, administering the Spanish inquisition, encouraging colonialism to civilize the natives, and finding quotes in the Bible to support slavery.
7) Finally, that Byzantine emperor that the Pope quoted, Manuel II? The Byzantines had been weakened by Latin predations during the fourth Crusade, so it was in a way Rome that had sought coercion first. And, he ended his days as a vassal of the Ottoman Empire.
http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2006/09/15/18311787.php
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Crusade
8) Emperor Manuel II Paleologos of the Byzantine Empire did not agree with the Vatican. He wrote the quote during the siege of Constantinople.
9) The propaganda against our prophet has been waged for centuries, and Muslims keep growing. The more they send crusades, the more Islam grows.
10) [2:62] Those who believe (in the Qur’an), and those who follow the Jewish (scriptures), and the Christians and the Sabians– any who believe in God and the Last Day, and work righteousness, shall have their reward with their Lord; on them shall be no fear, nor shall they grieve. ‘
May God forgive the sins of the Pope and may he find enlightenment. God Bless him.
……………… when you consider most of these people are still living in the 7th Century.
Posted by: Elroy Jetson
Yeah when they catch up with our 9th century Catholic/ Christian Religions then we should stop bombing them.
I am just so disgusted that the Pope decided to recant all that stuff he said and now says he is “deeply sorry”. So much for infallibility. Turns out he is just a Muslim-lover like all the rest of the liberals when the pressure is on, he doesn’t have the stomach for a really holy war.
Those Muslim barbarians;
http://www.europas-historie.net/hispaniola-50a.JPG
I mean I see the attraction of painting everything with the simplicity of either black or white like the modern neocon likes to do. I mean life is just SO much simpler that way.
But unfortunately some of us are stuck wanting to know the truth and are unable to accept these simplifications because we are uncompromising with the truth and all its shades of grade.
AMEN! Well put, and I hope the Pope won’t be strong armed bt those dopes…
muirgeo:
Others might accuse you of having a “September 10th” mentality. That’s not fair.
You’re fixated on stuff that happened decades, if not centuries ago.
We’re dealing with the here and now. Perhaps you’ve heard of it.
And before you bring out the “those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it,” let me give you a new catchphrase: “those who spend all their time looking backwards tend to walk off cliffs.”
J.
I too am confused how you can claim to have voted for the Holy Father. Perhaps you are a Cardinal running a blog for fun in his spare time.
I think the Muslims are just proving the point of their violent ways by rioting and attacking churches. The ironic thing is, they’re not smart enough to attack the right churches. They’re attacking Orthodox and Protestant churches.
I am somewhat disappointed in the Vatican issuing the quasi-apology. It seems that for some reason in the world, people are afraid to offend Muslims, but to hell with everyone else. Look at the Democrats who are going against Bush’s interrogation legislation. They want to give these Muslim terrorists more rights than our soldiers get when they’re captured. Newsflash…the Geneva convention only applies to uniformed soldiers fighting for a state…not terrorists.
I digress.
It’s amazing to me how it is so socially permissible to mock the Catholic Church with jokes about priests, yet the minute someone says something against another religion (which isn’t even what his holiness did), all hell breaks loose. What a double standard.
All Pope Benedict did was quote someone to illustrate how some Muslims have used Islam to buttress their violence.
Arab armies never conquered or stayed in India, Indonesia, Malaysia, or Bangladesh, where 80% of all Muslims reside. Arab armies did reach the Indus, but Mohammad bin Qasim quickly withdrew. The conversions for a vast majority of Muslims (who now live in Asia)was by Sufis and traders and by example and because Islam was LOGICAL and simple…pray to one God.
India was taken over by Islamic force more than once. Your qualifier of ‘Arab’ is deceptive.
I wish he hadn’t even given that much of an apology.
And it’s rther typical that the usual suspects have stepped up to compare the Catholic past to the Muslim present. I guess we’re all screwed, since the prerequisite for speaking Truth is eternal perfection.
And Moin ansari must have missed the “conversions” of the FOX reporters at the point of a gun. Not to mention all the warnings about violence in response to Benedict’s suggestion that Islam is violent. Surely those giving the warnings believe that it is *true*.
I wish he hadn’t issued even that non-apology.
How can we expect any Muslim to denounce violence if Benedict backs down? How can we expect any “moderate” Muslim to speak up if our media, the high-priests of free speech back down from threats of violence?
My God forgive Muslims, Moin ansari, for failing to denounce those who truely denegrate Muhammad. Every pulic demonstration of violence, of hatred such as burning Benedict in effigy, every threat made, and every person killed over a picture of Muhammad with a bomb in his turban only proves that Muhammad does not serve God nor do his followers.
The people making Islam look bad are Islamists, not Popes and not cartoonists.
You make your prophet a mockery. No one else has to do it for you.
I wanna’ add my AMEN! to Jay’s comments. Barbara
Someone should come up with something every day to set the Islamofascist off. They will kill their own and burn their own countries down. Works for me.
The only thing i’ve seem more stupid in the past 40 years was the blacks burning their own neighborhoods in several protest that changed nothing. The only ones that made out were the theives that started to riots, and what they stole was gone when they needed the next fix. Hey, something similiar to New Orleans last year. Protest as a cover for robbery and murder.
More proof that religion is the opposite of truth, wisdom, and justice
Now we have the Grand Inquisitor (the pot) lecturing Islam (the kettle) about spreading religion through violence (dark deeds) and quoting a Dark Ages text while the USA and Europe are in the midst of the Neo-Crusades. Does anyone else see the irony and absurdity in this situation?
The West has killed far more Muslims than they have killed westerners, yet our press and leaders can only see Muslim desperation in the face of western military and economic dominance, (all in the name of God and country), as the sources of evil in this world.
Guess what guys and girls, war is evil, no matter what the excuse or cause or who is doing the killing. Any idiot who thinks the Creator would judge religion or war as wise or acceptable activities has a very big surprise in store.
Here is Wisdom…
I’ll give you an ‘Amen’ to that JT.
The Pope called them on their actions, they didn’t like it and the predictable Friday evening riots after prayers erupted. RoPMA
muirgeo, we don’t really care about the color of the sky in your world, its fxved up and you’re ignoring reality.
“West has killed far more Muslims than they have killed westerners” – Uhm *Muslims* have killed more Muslims than any of those.
What worries me most is the Mufti of Saudi Arabia’s reaction. Instead of questioning whether the Pope was correctly quoted, asking for an apology or actually answering the Pope’s concerns, he’s all like “This shows that this inter-faith dialogue stuff is nonsense. As we allways KNEW.” …. What? Was he correctly quoted on that?
C.S. Lewis, a noted Christian apologist and Oxford don, wrote this in his essay, Why I Am Not A Pacifist:
“The doctrine that war is always a greater evil seems to imply a materialist ethic, a belief that death and pain are the greatest evils. But I do not think they are. I think the suppression of a higher religion by a lower, or even a higher secular culture by a lower, a much greater evil. Nor am I greatly moved by the fact that many of the individuals we strike down in war are innocent. […] The question is whether war is the greatest evil in the world, so that any state of affairs which might result from submission is certainly preferable. And I do not see any really cogent arguments for that view.”
misunderstanding jihad (self control).
Moin ansari,
Maybe we misunderstand because too many Muslims use that as the battle cry to kill people. I guess that means they misunderstand it too. Obviously in their understanding exercising good ‘self control’ means good aim, well disciplined bomb-making, honing one’s decaptiation skills, firing misiles at cities ffull of people with some degree of accuracy and learning to fly planes into buildings full of civilians. Then again, maybe we have a better grasp of what it means than you do.
Hey,
I am glad that Jay can see the truth in what the Pope said and also carefully discerned his apology to see that it was done with Christian charity, while not sacrificing the truth in his message.
By the way, you should look into the Catholic faith. I am an x-atheist, x-agnostic, and fortunately am finally a Catholic revert. There is nothing more precious than finding and following the truth.
Some websites have excellent information about the Catholic faith:
http://www.catholic.com A radio program, Catholic Answers Live, answers call in questions from anyone curious about the faith. Their programs are archived can be downloaded at http://www.catholic.com. Many of the apologists are converts to the Catholic faith.
Find out what you’ve been missing! Learn answers to questions about the faith from those who know it and love it, not the media and others who have decided to hate it and don’t understand it.
Other websites:
http://www.catholicity.com/maryfoundation/ (free tapes and CD’s about topics in the Catholic faith)
catholicconvert.com (info posted by a convert from Baptist to Catholic)
http://www.patrickmadrid.com
God bless,
Cathy
To all well-meaning peace-loving Muslims everywhere who are willing to stand up and publicly denounce those attempting to force Islam down our throats via terrorism and despotism…WELCOME!!
To all Muslims who do NOT fit into the category above or are themselves attempting to force Islam down our throats via terrorism and despotism…DIE!!
Period.
Nuff said?
You get an “Amen!” from this Catholic, Jay.
Where are the Muslim clerics denouncing beheadings, suicide bombings, insurgency in Iraq, etc? Nowhere to be seen. Yet they come out of the woodwork against the Holy Father.
And none of them are denouncing the attack on the churches.
I love how our military can’t even go after Al-Qaeda when they’re hiding in a Mosque…and if we do, we’re disrespecting their faith. But they can burn Christian churches down. Which, again, are the wrong churches if they want to prove a point. Just shows their stupidity.
I saw some Arab punk interviewed on the local news today and he said that Pope Benedict should educate himself about other religions. Um, excuse me, son, I think the Pope knows more about religion than you will know about anything in your entire life.
I don’t even think 95% of these idiots know exactly what the Pope said…they just hear that he is supposed to have torn into Islam and they run with it.
I hope to God that he does not apologize tomorrow. I would have preferred if the Vatican hadn’t even said what they have so far. But a “sorry if you’re mad, but too bad” kind of statement isn’t too bad I guess.
This is getting a little off-topic, but frankly, I wish Vatican II had never happened. It loosened the Church up too much and allowed too much lovey dovey-ness with other religions. I’m not saying we should hate all other religions. I’m saying that we’ve gone to the other extreme and begun to be hyper-sensitive to everything.
The full text of his talk makes clear the central problem of this primitive, anti-humanistic “religion” called Islam. Their “allah” requires blind submission and the suppression of reason in exploring the fundamental questions of life!
I have the full text, and some rather incendiary, if also historically accurate, comments over at http://thomistic.blogspot.com/.
The last thing they need is the equivalent of the Reformation!
1) The Byzantine emperor was much closer to the roots of Islam than we are today. He knew what he was talking about and was disgusted by it.
2) Please don’t believe the “Benedict sprinkled Nazi’s with holy water” crap. He was involunatarily inducted into the Hitler Youth Army as a boy but he, at great risk to himself, refused to participate. He rebuked the Nazi movement upon pains of his life.
3) Pope Benedict did NOT apologize. He said he regreted that if offended Muslims, rather like Dick Durbin said he regreted that any military personel took it badly that he compared them to Nazis or Pol Pot.
4) Pope Benedict, when he was Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, since 1981. His job before the Papacy was literally to fight heresy and protect the teachings of the Church. He understands world religions and relativism, humanism and secularism in the Church. He is AMPLY quaified to speak on Islam, and he has been speaking out against Islamic terrorism for a year and a 1/2.
5) What the Emperor was referring to is Muhammed’s synthesis of the monotheistic faiths (Judaism and Christianity) and the reducing of them to simplistic categories that codified 7th century Arab culture. There is not much anyone can point to of any value in Islam that was not already revealed through Moses and Jesus. What IS unique to Islam is the introduction of violence into its canon, the reduction of the rights of women, the bizarre sensuality of its afterlife rewards, and many other things that are wildly out of step with the ancient texts it claims to endorse and supersede (the Christian Bible). The Pope MUST repudiate the Qoran which flatly denies the Divinity of Jesus, his vicarious atoning death, his resurrection and the Church. How can the Pope represent Christ by going too far to demonstrate concord with THAT?
GO POPE BENEDICT. I’m proud to be a Catholic.
Of course you like Benedict, because you’re ignorant. I said more than 5 years ago that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger would be the next Pope after John Paul died.
How did I know, other than the fact that I always know? Because Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict) who was in charge of doctrine, said that “Jesus is not the Jewish Messiah.”
I was sold. I knew then, FIVE YEARS AGO, that Ratzinger would be the next Pope so I was waiting in anticipation for the announcement after John Paul died. When the guy said, “Ratzinger,” I was like, darn, the world is screwed.
I knew then. I’m telling you now. Ratzinger has already said that he doesn’t have that much time. Who else mentioned in end times prophecy in the Bible also knew that he didn’t have a short time?
The guy who I thought, FIVE YEARS AGO, that Ratzinger (now Benedict) would end up being.
The FALSE PROPHET mentioned in the Book of Revelation.
Go Blue!
ST, please give a link for that.
I can well imagine context makes a huges difference. For example. I believe it is more likely that Cardinal Ratzinger said, “Jesus was not the Jewish Messiah–he was mankind’s Messiah.” I don’t know that’s what he said, but I don’t accept your quote without documentation–the burden of proof is on you.
Amen!
ya know..if you folks want to live in a world over 500 years ago..before Martin Luther literally nailed the Cath Church..before so many of the white folks came to America because of Cath crap like this…then I say Amen….
Jesus expressed love to a whore..a tax collecter was one of his disciples..his message was one of tolerance(I can quote scripture)
C’mon..how about some amens for the Spanish Cath. Inquisition..
Posted by: Drew at September 16, 2006 05:33 PM
To set the record straight … Mary Magdalene was not a whore. That was one of the many deceptions perpetrated by the Catholic Church to disempower women, originated by Pope Gregory, whether maliciously or not is still debated, when he described “Mary” as a sinful woman.
Anyway … this whole deal with Muslims seething at every offense, whether merely perceive or real, yet at the same time, they offend against the rest of the world in word and in action, often bloody … it’s getting old. Really old. Churches and synagogues are burned, Jews and Christians reviled and mocked … I think it’s time for some Judeo-Christian seething. Car swarm anyone?
One of the hallmarks of a psychopathic personality disorder is the delusional thinking that one can do as one pleases with impunity, that one’s opinions are the only ones that count and are right, that others must submit, obey and agree … pretty much describes Islamic thinking.
Psychopaths are also experts in using language and semantics … for instance, the Koran forbids the killing of innocents. Great. Wonderful. Religion of Peace. Tolerant and all that. You betcha.
Now define “innocent”
As when Bush uttered the “I” word (Islamofascist) the mere fact that common, everyday Muslims … the so-called peaceful, non-violent, moderate Muslims … got all offended speaks volumes about how they really feel about terrorism and how they identify with the Splodeydopes.
Ya almost had me for a second there 7thStar, til the part about the West killing more Muslims than visa versa. And what followed.
I’m not Amening anyone anymore. Especially the Pope. When the Catholic Church backs up its words of reconciliation/apology regarding past transgressions with meaningful action, well, that’ll probably be when Hell Freezes Over. Until then I see the Pope as another Pat Robertson with fancier clothes and abode.
Aside: Human beings tend to kill each other over control of land, resources and other people. Words and ideas don’t stop this. It’s a world of survival of those who recognize, structure their society, prepare and act based on that sad fact of genetics. Its sometimes possible to convince would-be killers to take non-violent actions, but sometimes its not. It is never possible from a position of weakness relative to the killers. Non-violence has not prevailed unless the violent side lost its will to kill. I am not aware of this having happened due to simple fatigue from slaughtering victims.
A significant portion of Islam wants control of the world, and it is prepared to lie, cheat, maim, enslave, threaten and slaughter to this end. Kinda like certain other organized religions have in the past. The religions that now restrain their battle for power to avoid overt slaughter, gained so much ground and wealth from the same approach in the past.
The Pophet of Islam is no way a terrerist. He came here with peace and love , he suffered alot for his purpose. the only war in the world history is ‘victory of makkah’ won without any bloodshed .later his grandson in karbalah proved that his grandfather was a pacifist. there is alot of differene between apope and an emperor .pope should not have done so.
if Islam is said to havespread through sword it werw some other people not prophet of islam him self and history knows very well they are disputed ones .
read the history of saints and s,ufis of islam, the true followers of the prophet it will became totally clear there is nothing like this
everybody has the right to defend them as crusaders have been doing despite the lovely teachings of the Holy Christ
what they are doing now is not in conformity wih his teachings . am I right?
If what they are doing now is not in conformity with his teachings, I’m glad to hear it. I hope it is true. I want it to be true.
But if someone *says* Islam is violent and that violence begins with the prophet, hassan, the way to prove them wrong is not to become violent and threaten violence.
The people giving Islam a bad name are not the Pope or some cartoonists in Denmark. The people defaming the prophet are Muslim. It’s the glorification of martyrdom in Palistine. It’s protestors in Indonesia who wear “bomb vest” fashion. It’s the long history of terrorist violence from Al Qaida culminating in the 9-11 atrocity. It’s the people dead because of a lie about a flushed Koran and people dead because of “cartoons” that a Muslim religious leader added horrible pictures to in order to rile up violence and which resulted in more dead people.
Insisting that Islam is peaceful is probably worth while but maybe you should tell the people killing others in the name of God and the prophet or converting journalists with a gun to their heads.
They seem to have missed the memo.
Hassan … the Koran is the word of Allah as told to Mohammed, therefore it is his interpretation and teaching, correct?
OK, then … so, what does the Koran say?
Allah has purchased of their faithful lives and worldly goods, and in return has promised them the Garden. They will fight for His cause, kill and be killed. – 9:111
Allah is an enemy to unbelievers. – Sura 2:98
On unbelievers is the curse of Allah. – Sura 2:161
Slay them wherever ye find them and drive them out of the places whence they drove you out, for persecution is worse than slaughter. – 2:191
O believers, take not Jews and Christians as friends; they are friends of each other. Those of you who make them his friends is one of them. God does not guide an unjust people. – 5:54
It is not for any Prophet to have captives until he has made slaughter in the land. – 8:67
When the sacred months are over, slay the idolaters wherever you find them. Arrest them, besiege them, and lie in ambush everywhere for them. – 9:5
O Prophet! Make war on the unbelievers and the hypocrites. Be harsh with them. Their ultimate abode is hell, a hapless journey’s end. – 9:73
When you meet the unbelievers, smite their necks, then when you have made wide slaughter among them, tie fast the bonds, then set them free, either by grace or ransom, until the war lays down its burdens. – 47:4
=========
RoPMA™
let’s see, islam brought rules of war, rules of marriage, rules of punishment, rules of inheritence, when the catholic church blinded scientists for say the world was round and orbited around the sun, islam’s book said that the earth orbits around the sun and around itsself as with all other planets each in their unique universe in the many universes, it says not fear the dark oceans as the deeper you go, the darker they are and this is due to refraction, mary was a woman chosen by God, not to what the jews have said and made stories up, i will leave that to your imagination, etc. etc. although i was born catholic, yet i cannot deny islam’s virtues, the sad ting is that our socalled western civilization was the result of the demise and revolt and the falling of our church, show me what the spanish inquisition and what the catholic missionaries gave to the maya and the aztec indians? the sad thing is that we take cheap shots at muslims becuase we know they cannot insult mary and jesus because both are up there and equal to mohammad, and the punishment of one of their own insulting the lord or the virgin mary is the same as insulting mohammad, etc, etc., lets see, philosophy, medicine, mathematics, astronomy. one has to ponder, why would a man of such intellect and prestige say his. also, it s a bad example, the person mentioned in the dialogue was an orthodox christian emperor whose city was later looted and ransacked by the fourth crusade, the typical crusader carnage and massacres, not a smart example to begin with. the church wants dialogue to create controversy, controversy means unity and jobs for them use of their services, controversy would mean facing the Turkey question and embarassing them and kicking them out of the eu talks, controversy means we are back an we have a cause know, forget the child-molesting, forget everything, lets justify muslim blood, all in all, it was prety stupid, unless, could it be that the pope mentioned as an example of intolerence? think about it, an emperor of another christian faith who suffered from the crusaders going to kill the muslims and whose fate was the same as the muslims, hhhmm, that would really be interesting!
Sounds to me like old “mun-go” is a goat herder.
Benedict is nothing but a pathetic face of the crusaders.
There is a pattern of hatred that betrays this man’s mind and true feelings. It is clear that his agenda runs parallel with the Islamophobia that has gripped Western countries.
There is no ‘philosophical’ difference of opinion here, there is no ‘taking’ his speech out of context. His speech and the juxtaposition of the opinion of a looser (14th century Emperor Manuel II Paleologos of the Byzantine Empire) without any embarrasment for the sheer ignorance it displays.
Is he a coward that uses the speech of a man dead some 700 years to voice his own thinking? Then retreats to the excuse of ‘difference of philosophy’? Wussy
Is he not implying, in the faux apology and multifaceted-speak of the Catholic Church, that he STILL believes Muslims force people to convert on pain of violence thus ‘philosophically’ disagress with them?
Would he just as happily quote the Catholic Church’s anti-semitic, specifically anti-Jewish views?
Does he not see, or is he too thick or dumb to comprehend that Islam today is the fasterst growing religion all over the world especially in America and Europe. Who is forcing these poeple to convert? His stupidity astounds me!
Let this be a lesson to those who believe the Catholics are sincere in their quest for dialogue between faiths. Let them see that despite their seemingly polite words, hatred, ignorance and consequent bigotry runs deep in their hearts, sometimes beyond the reach of evidence or thought.
Bunch of evil crusaders with leaders like Bush and Benedict as dumb as each other.
Dear LissaKay and othersI
I did not mean this at all .You have misinterpreted that. Those who imposed Islam through sword are themselves controversial figures in Islam. As far as koranic verses are concerned they are about particular time, event and must not be generalized
.O.k. thank you .
You guys at whizbang and mensnewsdaily are doing a terrific job speaking out against the Jihadists.
Keep up the good work. Here’s a link to an excellent essay defending the Pope by a mensnewsdaily columnist:
http://mensnewsdaily.com/2006/09/16/the-pope-should-not-apologize-to-muslim-leaders/
You have misinterpreted that. Those who imposed Islam through sword are themselves controversial figures in Islam.
We’re not understanding Muslims again! Muslims who killed people who refused to accept Islam are controversial! Some day we’ll all look back and those who are killing people now might be called controversial too, at least those of us who survive the controversy.
I have been listening and kind of keeping my ear to the ground—so to speak. It seems to me that there are Muslims that are bound and determined to make things rough for everyone. No I am not talking about the average Joe blow Muslim that has to live under the conditions of poverty, I am talking about the ones that have everything and they still want more.
They inflame the young people to do their dirty work (suicide bombings, car bombings and the use of IEDs) by promising them with the myth of 72 virgins when they get to the promised land. Of course, these cowardly clerics and others sit back and gloat, while these young promising youths get is more death and destruction.
These are the ones that are easily offended and the first to lash out at whoever makes any derogatory (supposedly) comments about Islam. It also seems to me that the ones that are doing the most squawking are the ones that are doing these things.
I still think that if Jimmy Caaaaaaater had bombed the American Embassy, in Tehran, when the Iranian radicals invaded it; the radical Muslims would have quit then and there. I am also sure that the families would have understood the rational behind the move.
Then there is the so-called mainstream media. They are the ones that are fanning the flames of the jihad. They report the jihadist bullshit as gospel and most of the sheeple believe what they printed or put out on the tube. These radicals have found a willing participant in their crusade and are exploiting it to the max
White liberals love to recite the litany of rotely learned Catholic atrocities, most of which are the inventions of their own crazed, puritan ancestors, at the slightest pretext, but I have yet to read a post here that in anyway even attempts to refute the Byzantine emperor who the pope quoted. One historically confused person sniffs that it’s a dark age quotation, as though that somehow by itself discredits it or as though the 15th century
were in the dark ages! Besides that we are off to the races with sanctimonious condemnations of the crusades and Spain.
2 questions:
A)How again is it that the muslims originally came into the land that the crusaders invaded? Were they going door to door on bicycles, handing out pamphlets?
B)How again is it that the Muslims originally came
into Iberia? Vacationers? Algebra Teachers? Just asking.
The Pope should not apologize for telling it like it is. The violent reaction of the Muslim world has spoken volumes about the ‘religion’, and has proven the Pope’s quote to be true. Killing a nun…? Come on, is that what Allah would really want?
You know how to do a google search? It was about 5 years ago. If that page is still up, I’ll be surprised. And it wasn’t in that context. It was in the context that Jews are still waiting for their messiah to show up because Jesus wasn’t their’s, even though Jesus himself said that he came to save both the Jew and the Gentile.
What Ratzinger was doing was laying the foundation for the antiChrist to claim to be that messiah, and Ratzinger, as I said back then, would be the next Pope and False Prophet leading people to that antiChrist.
Oh, and your boy Bush is in on it as well.
It’s just like the Catholic Church to change what Jesus said, though. That’s why Leo IV and Urban II adopted the muslim doctrine of Jihad and commissioned the killing rampages that characterized the Crusades when Jews and Christians were also slaughtered, right along with Muslims; mostly women and children.
There is more than a history of religious bloodshed to go around, and the fact of the matter is it never solves anything.
Hopefully, those who advocate these wars and retaliations are the ones actually fighting them, otherwise they are nothing but loudmouthed cowards.
Found it
http://www.thejewishweek.com/news/newscontent.php3?artid=5649#top
http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/printer-friendly.asp?ARTICLE_ID=42039