The ugliness that is the former Representative Mark Foley (R-FL) scandal keeps getting odder and odder — and while remaining just as disgusting, has taken a few odd twists.
On Tuesday, Wild Bill of Passionate America sent out a press release saying he had uncovered the identity of the object of Mr. Foley’s affections, and intended to reveal it. I was on his list, and excoriated him in a private e-mail for doing so. There were some profanities involved, and a request that he not bother me any more.
What Bill had not included — and did not clarify enough for me to grasp, but that could very well be my fault — was the key element of the expose’ was that the person in question was NOT a minor at the time of the most explicit and incriminating conversations.
That changes everything.
Foley, thanks to the passage of a certain date in time, suddenly is transformed from a predatory pedophile into a more-creepy version of the kind of guy who goes for the “Barely Legal” not-quite-kiddie-porn. Morally and ethically, it matters little, but legally it’s a world of difference. As an old writing teacher used to quote, it’s the difference between the lightning and the lightning bug.
Foley still remains a creepy degenerate swine who saw the Congressional Page program as his private harem-in-grooming, and deserved to get kicked out on his ass and eyed suspiciously by the general public for the rest of his life. But it’s looking more and more like he stopped himself just short of doing anything overtly criminal. He’s no Gerry Studds, more like a Gary Condit.
So, how did the story get out, and how did it get out in such an incorrect fashion? Here’s one theory, one that seems to fit the available facts.
Someone finds out about Foley’s fondness for young men, and his tendency to express that towards Congressional pages. They start gathering up their evidence, but they want it to get out in a way that’s not traceable back to them directly. (My suspicion is either a Democratic operative or an independent whose sympathies lie in that direction.) They set up a bogus blog on Blogspot and start talking about sex predators. Then they pretend to get their Foley evidence from an “anonymous reader” and publish it. After that, it’s just a matter of waiting for it to be discovered.
But then it isn’t discovered. No one notices it. So they have to make sure it’s discovered. They shopped it around to a variety of sources, but no one seemed to want to “bite.”
Then they realize that this red meat is just the sort of thing that the slavering attack dogs at Daily Kos would be all over, so they (either directly or through a proxy) post the link to the Foley material that they “discovered” over at Kos. The Kossacks take a quick look (and since it feeds to their prejudices and baser instincts) and run like hell with it. With the compression of the news cycle and the instant access to information we have today, Foley is Dead Representative Walking and quits in record time.
It would be very fascinating to see the originating IP of that person who posted it on Kos. Could they be linked back to the bogus blog? Or was it someone at one of the organizations offered the information, and disagreed with the decision to ignore it? The Kos people, who are paranoid (and rightly so) about getting set up, first thought the “WHInternNow” person who linked to the bogus blog in the first place.
I’m not holding my breath, though. That action would require Kos and his Kossacks to act like responsible netizens, and that is a very foreign concept to them. I suspect they did a quick check to see if they could pin it on a conservative, then assured themselves they’d done an adequate job of fact-checking the matter.
The person who exposed Foley did the right thing, but it’s starting to look more and more like they did it in the wrong way. This has the signatures of a “political hit,” carefully timed and arranged to do the maximum political damage to the Republican party very close to the election. That means that instead of exposing Foley and his deviant ways as soon as they could, the let him continue posing a potential threat to young men until the timing suited the exposer’s agenda — and that is utterly despicable. Had Foley actually committed any overt acts against an underaged person during that time, the exposer would have shared in the moral responsibility for allowing it to happen.
So, to sum up: Foley is a loathsome scumbag, and deserves public scorn and suspicion for the rest of his days. The person who exposed him did the nation a favor by doing so. But if — IF — that person sat on the information until such time as suited their own political agenda, then they, too, ought to be held up for public contempt.
They remind me of the firefighter who, in order to be seen as a hero, starts fires that he can then extinguish — or, in this case, let the fire get more intense before rushing to the rescue. There’s a reason we lock those people up, instead of giving them medals.


RE: Mitchel.
” Who is this Gil character a fish?”
“I want to know what the fish knew and when did they know it’?
Hey Mitch, Are you OK?
What on earth are you talking about?
What fish? Who mentioned fish?
Are you another one of those that “drinks at home while sending IM’s over the net?
I could care less who did what, when Michel. Fishes aside, Foley did it, and the Republican Leadership covered up…… Or try to answer why the Republican leaders that I already named fingered the Speker of the House …..
You want to debate, or you want to go fishing?
RE: Darleen, and Martin.
So the e-mails are as Darleen puts it “There is no there there” or Mitchel “The FBI found nothing there”.
You two birds are missrepresenting the issue. Please explain to me why AGAIN PAY ATTENTION AND ANSWER DIRECTLY TO MY F—-QUESTION Because I keep on asking it, and Republicans on this blog just act like they can’t read.
1. Congressman Rodney Alexander Republican for Louisiana
2. Congressman John Bohener Republican for Ohio
3. Congressman Tom Reynor Republican for New York
All involved directly in the scandal because all had something to do with the Page program have, declared in all the Networks that they informed the Speaker of the House about the problem and what did he do? ….. Not a thing that is a fact. Some one (Reyno and possibly Hatcher) talked to Foley at different times and ask him to stop. After he turmed up drunk at the Pages dorm he was “asked to stop”, after he was asked to stop by Congressman Reynor a $100,000 campain “contribution” was transfered to Reynor’s bank account. All these “little” Red Flags of course point to “no there there” …. I mean how on earth can any one get to any other conclusion!!!
If there is no “there there” Darleen I am going to ask you to send me YOUR PICTURE preferibly in a Bikini….. After that maibe we can talk about your friends physical attributes “No there there Darleen”? or are we getting a bit personal here? Do I sound like a jerk Darleen? Yes I do Darleen, and you know it. Or, Maibe Darleen, you are really a closet Liberal and don’t mind it. But me and millions of Americans would find a “there there” if a 54 old man starts asking for the picture of my Daughter or Son in the context of talking about the physical attributes of their friends.
No there there Martin because the FBI sat on the evidence? What do you think the evidence was doing at the FBI in the first place?, why do you think parents from the kids in question contacted their Congressman Rodney Alexander?, why do you think Tom Reynor claims that he talked to Foley and ask him to stop?, and from where in hell do you get that the FBI was not going to investigate? Please point to me to where is it that you can find an FBI statement dismising the issue as “not there there”.
Yes. You acknowledged that you would not find the emails “harmless and innocuous”, although you used quite lengthy and roundabout scenarios to say so, instead of just admitting it.
No. I would still find them innocuous. But I would be a bit disturbed simply because I would not be comfortable with my 17 year old child having a 40+ year old friend that I do not personally know. I will not automatically assume that the 40+ year old is a paedophile and demand an investigation into every nook and cranny of his life.
That wouldn’t be your call. If there’s evidence, or even a threat, of a sexual predator in the midst of a group, the unwillingness of a single victim to pursue it is no reason to stop investigating. Would you want police to stop looking into the actions of a teacher at your kid’s school who was “creepy” toward another child, but their parents declined to pursue the matter?
Try to keep up. The FBI were given these e-mails in July and they found nothing in them to make them want to investigate further.
Sorry if your amazing powers of hindsight makes you disagree, but, like Hastert, I would not demand for the police to rifle through someone’s personal effects on account of e-mails like these, especially if all I had were those innocuous (according to the FBI as well) e-mails and after I asked him to cease all contact and he promptly did.
Read the news more. The IMs were provided by the interns, but only after the emails were reported in the media.
Don’t lie. Foley resigned last Friday after being confronted with the IMs from 2003 by ABC reporters. Two Florida newspapers had those e-mails since last year, and like Hastert and the FBI thought they were nothing and not worthy of a write-up. There was no story prior to that in the Press featuring the e-mails alone.
You don’t need probable cause to quietly ask a few other interns if they noticed anything strange about Foley.
Another amazing demonstration of your powers of hindsight.
The following is the text of the former page’s family’s statement:
Well, gil, it’s obvious you’re correct, Rodney Alexander personally helped Foley brutally rape that young man! And the sick parents are covering up for him!
Please point to me to where is it that you can find an FBI statement dismising the issue as “not there there”.
I quote:
No there there Martin because the FBI sat on the evidence?
And now the FBI covers up for pederasts? Maybe in your world, everybody, including of course every single Republican, even the guy sitting in Barrow, Alaska knew what Foley was up to and was covering up for him. Heck, you probably think I bought Foley his computer!
I would still find them innocuous. But I would be a bit disturbed simply because I would not be comfortable
You’re contradicting yourself. “Innocuous” things don’t make people “disturbed and uncomfortable”. Just admit you over-stated your position, and move on.
I will not automatically assume that the 40+ year old is a paedophile and demand an investigation into every nook and cranny of his life.
I would not demand for the police to rifle through someone’s personal effects
That’s a common theme with conservatives. “All or none”. You either do nothing, or “demand an investigation into every nook and cranny of his life”. You either do nothing, or you “rifle through personal effects”. You either sit there quietly for 7 minutes, or you run screaming from the room and scare all the children. I’ve seen this reasoning over and over. You have no middle ground.
I’ve said this before, many times… you have someone quietly ask other pages and/or staffers if there’s anything going on with Foley that you need to be concerned about. Not only is that the right thing to do to make sure the children are protected, but it’s also the very best “cover your ass” move that Hastert could have made.
The FBI were given these e-mails in July and they found nothing in them to make them want to investigate further.
And whoever made that decision has pretty lousy judgment, wouldn’t you say?
>>The IMs were provided by the interns, but only after the emails were reported in the media.
Don’t lie. Foley resigned last Friday after being confronted with the IMs from 2003 by ABC reporters.
I wasn’t lying, and neither did you. The first ABC News story didn’t even mention the IMs. It was all about the emails. It was Thursday. And then on Friday the IMs came to light: “Hours earlier, ABC News had read excerpts of instant messages provided by former male pages….” And Foley resigned. Please do some basic research before accusing me of lying.
Another amazing demonstration of your powers of hindsight.
Not hindsight. Good judgment. Someone comes to me and says one of my guys has been “over friendly” with a teenager, and it’s risen to the level that one of my lieutenants felt he needed to bring it to my attention and discuss the issue with the boy’s family, I’m going to ask what else has he done that we don’t know about.
But I guess I’m not going to convince you. If you saw a train barreling down on someone, and you didn’t yell out to warn them, and later someone asked you why not, you’d just dismiss their “amazing powers of hindsight”.
Yep, as JT said eariler this week, the Foley scandel is a sure sign things are getting BETTER in Washington. Anybody can attempt to SPIN CRAP into GOLD. I just call it Lieing.
In reading these posts, I realize that I am not the only one to realize that Jay Tea is a complete joke. The truth to him is whatever he wants it to be, then he tries to forcefeed it to everybody else. Surprise surprise, he always spins the story in favor of the Republicans and always spins against the Democrats. What a joke. The truth is whereever it lies. The truth is simply not a member of the Republican Party OR the Democratic Party. Jay is a JOKE!
Surprise surprise, he always spins the story in favor of the Republicans and always spins against the Democrats.
Oh, no, you’ve got him so wrong! He’s a libertarian and independent. So you can see, there are many anti-Republican posts from him, too. Somewhere. If you keep looking. Maybe. (Not.)
By the way, here’s a conservative publication that also finds the “gee, what else could I have done?” defense to be ludicrous:
It is enough for me that GOP leaders knew that a parent and child had lodged a complaint. They should at a minimum have questioned other pages to find out if other boys may have been involved.
Exactly what I have been saying.
RE: Martim A. Knight.
We agree Martin. The FBI IS CONDUCTING AN INVESTIGATION CORRECT?
A)To trow back your own words at you. The Investigation is ONGOING.
B)QUote from you: “The investigation concluded that the e-mails do not rise to the level of crimial activity”.
Point B. First. Neither I nor any Democrat claims that the E-Mails are criminal. I and millions argue that they raised a RED FLAG With GAY PREDATOR all over it but not much was done about it. That is what the FBI investigation is supposed to uncover. Please stop trying to confuse the issue.
I asked you if you could point to me where did you find the case dismissed by the FBI because as you put it there was” no there there”? I did not ask you to give me the “opinion” of an “unnamed” field official stating that the case was not criminal in his opinion. I will answer my own question since you are avoiding it…
Question. Since you are stating that the FBI found that there was “no there there” please tell us where can you find the case’s Dismissal?……..
Answer. NOWHERE.The case was never closed. The case is active. And now is urgent because is out in the light. Just because the case was not taken immediately by the FBI and acted upon (You should not be surprised when it comes to a Congressman) that in no way shape or form translates that the case was dismissed because they found not there there as you imply by your remark.
Simple is in it?
POINT A. Indeed the parents of the first page contacted Congressman Rodney Alexander. The context of the letter is simple if you open your mind. They are politely asking the Congressman to do something about a gay man sending e-mails to their son. Why ? Because they consider them inapropiate. But in your opinion since “there is no there there” I guess the parents were just pissing in the wind, and beeing paranoiac. Again you are making my point. The parents, the page, the Congressman from Louisiana were ovbiously finding a “there there” don’t you think? Or you still don’t see it? Furthermore,
What the letter does not say is that the Congressman had a HISTORY of this “little” indiscretions, and that the history was known by the Republican Leaders for years. Still no red flags right?
Fine, I am not going to argue any more about this. Have it your way. The Republican Right gets all worked up because there is a tit flash at an NFL game, but all the above is not a problem. Republicans bring back Congress, take Bush out of a vacation, and make a circus over a pasient right to die (With Court authorization)in peace, and with some dignity but here you and your felow Republicans can’t see a problem with his e-mails…. Fine.
Just grant me this. You should not be surprised if people call you or your Republican friends hypocrits. No offense but you do the same with Democrats that defend BJ’s at the oval office don’t you? Remember whenyou laughed at the “A BJ is not sex” ? …. You sound the same now.
A Hypocrit does not have a party he just has a double standard.
I see Lee and company finally shut up about the Fox caption now that I brought out the MSNBC snafu. About f’in time.
Martin, you can keep pulling up quotes to answer the charges, but the nutroots gang are simply going to change the subjet, or move the goalposts. Only mantis usually argues constructively. And I see even he/she isn’t bothering to wallow in this thread.
Dick Burns: get a penicillin shot already.
By the way, when this was John Tower or Bob Packwood, etc, Sexual Harassment was the national scourge in the hallowed halls of government. Yet, Clinton got a pass from the same groups (NOW, I’m looking at you) who attacked the above gentlemen. Now all of a sudden, the Dems have their knickers in a twist again. What, did sexual harassment not exist between the years of 1994 and 2006? Curious minds want to know.
If Hastert is supposed to play mind-reader vis-a-vis the IMs and investigate the IMs before anyone knew of their existence, then why isn’t Pelosi calling for investigation of some of her Party’s little indescrecions…like say blocks of money in a freezer somewhere in New Orleans (William Jefferson, I’m looking at you.) In fact, you Leftists should be f—ing grateful to Dennis Hassert, because he help cover Jefferson’s arse when the FBI came a knocking.
Be careful what you wish for Leftists.
Frankly, I’m already tired of the Foley nonsense, and it’s not going to affect most voters…most Republicans/Conservatives never heard of the guy until this week, and he’s not in their state…that is, if they even have been following the story. Because most voters are not news-junkies.
So, we can all sit back and wait for the next scandal-du-semaine, which will probably be something a Democrat has done…and so on, and on.
RE: James.
Sounds good to me.
Democrats are hypocrits
Republicans are hypocrits
But keep it fair and balanced if you please.
Hastert is no mind reader, but then again you don’t need to read minds to figure this one out. My dog could do it.
If I ask you for your picture…. While talking about how athletic your friend looks, I am shure you will have a very, very hard time figuring out that I am hitting on you right? ….
So say again, how old are you? and can you send me your picture? Just “no there there” and B-J’s at the Oval Office is not really sex…… Republicans or Democrats they all sound the same to me. I guess is the sound of hypocricy.
You think there may be any decent politicians left?
Once we were lead by gigants. Washington, Jefferson, Theodore Roosevelt, Franklin Roosevelt, Lincoln, and many more. Republicans and Democrats all. Man that made mistakes, man that were all too human. But above all man that took responsibility for their actions.
Today it seems to me that no politician is accountable any more. We voters just give them a pass. and they take advantage of our ignorance, to continue with their ways. The base will always defend me is their idea… And they are right.
I hope that Republicans learn to be tough with their leaders because you elected them, and I hope Democrats do the same. Today voters do the opposite and that is wrong.
That is what infuriates me the most. The partisans that defend the indefensible because they feel that they will give a “win” to the other side. That is a sick, sick way of living indeed.
“I see Lee and company finally shut up about the Fox caption now that I brought out the MSNBC snafu. About f’in time.
According to the info you provided AP apologized for their mistake. Did Fox — no – because it wasn’t a mistake – it happened three times in a row on O’Reilly’s show. One time – maybe a mistake – not the second or third time. Those, at a minimum, were intentional.
It was Fox News being intentionally dishonest with the American people. Nothing new, I admit.
gil …
Let’s try this again.
The e-mails were provided to the FBI in July. The FBI concluded that “they did not rise to the level of criminal activity” and declined to further investigate. That means that there was no case to begin with. There was no case file open and therefore there was no on-going investigation.
This is something someone with a moderate level of intelligence and some education simply from watching TV should be able to pick up. But I guess I do need to spell it out for you.
When a police agency is alerted to a possible crime, they first of all look into it to determine if a crime has been committed. If they determine that a crime has been (or may have been) committed, they open a case file and continue to investigate. If not, they simply file the report and do nothing further; there’s no case to investigate.
The FBI is opening a new case now that the IMs have come to light. The e-mails are now part of this new case where they by themselves did not warrant one.
That’s how it works, gil. So, when the FBI guy says that “… it did not rise to the level of criminal activity” it means that there was no case. Believe it or not, a person can ask for another person’s picture in a way that is discomfitting without actually wanting to have sex with him/her. Even gay men. Did Foley ask the boy to send him a picture of himself naked, or in some other sexual pose? Did he ask him any sexual questions or proposition him?
Let’s go back to the parent’s letter and highlight a part that you seem to have skimmed.
In other words, neither the FBI nor the parents of the page thought those e-mails were enough to start an investigation or start asking questions that could very well destroy an innocent man who may have simply made an innocent, if somewhat inappropriate request.
I did not ask you to give me the “opinion” of an “unnamed” field official stating that the case was not criminal in his opinion. I will answer my own question since you are avoiding it…
I’ve already explained to you that there was no “case”. I wonder, do you so easily dismiss the New York Times when they cite anonymous sources who leak opportunistically selected bits of National Security documents?
Hypocrisy seems to be a vice that you’re well acquainted with yourself.
Next time, Martin, save the electrons and bandwidth, and just say this:
“The e-mails were provided to the FBI in July. The FBI concluded that “they did not rise to the level of criminal activity” and declined to further investigate. That means that there was no case to begin with.”
No, it means they declined to investigate.
I’d like to know why, and hear it from their mouths, not your imagination.