I watched the morning news today with a sick feeling in the pit of my stomach. The “anchor,” if you can call Diane Sawyer that, was a little too happy to report all the talk of the possibility of imminent troop withdrawals now that Democrats won control of Congress. They also reported on the upcoming report from Baker’s group and a bit on Rumsfeld’s replacement, Gates. The information Bob Owens has compiled at Confederate Yankee about Robert Gates gives me even more reason for concern. Read it all.
Owens also quotes James Lewis at The American Thinker.
The Baker commission seems to be doing a lot more than just re-thinking Iraq. It appears to be copiously leaking a Vietnam-type cut-and-run plan that will leave the Gulf far more dangerous than it is now. The Vietnam model looks like a “face-saving” retreat by the United States–just like that one that left Vietnam a Stalinist prison state with tens of thousands of boat people fleeing and dying, and next door in Cambodia, two or three million dead at the hands of Pol Pot.
Baker’s press leaks seem designed to test public reaction to the cut-and-run plan.
Conservatives have lost Congress for the next two years, but acquiescing in a disastrous retreat from Iraq would be the worst of all possible worlds. It would empower all the most destabilizing actors: Ahmadinejad, his dangerous guru Ayatollah Yazdi, and Moqtada el Sadr, who wants to turn Iraq into another Khomeinist state.
Withdrawal would embolden Hamas and Hezbollah and weaken Iran’s natural enemies–the Sunni Arab countries, including the Sunni Gulf states. In Afghanistan, the Taliban would be reinvigorated, and in Pakistan the Al-Qaida-supporting elements in the military and secret services might try–again–to launch a coup. A successful Al Qaeda coup in Pakistan would give Islamofascists not just one, but two nuclear-armed states.
The US held on in Vietnam for fourteen years. We gave Vietnamization a chance. The 12 million Iraqis who voted for parliamentary parties deserve a chance to see their elected government work. Not long ago I wrote about how a lot of attention was paid to the way the President had conducted the war, but practically none was paid to how those who opposed the war had conducted themselves and how that might have affected the situation in Iraq. I got a lot of email from liberals saying I was trying to blame Democrats for Bush’s failures and that nothing they had done had any impact on the mission in Iraq. They are dead wrong. Public opinion and support is incredibly important when waging war and I think it can be seen now quite dramatically in the talk of plans to cut and run. Democrats are not in power yet, but just from the support gleaned through their success at the polls, corresponding action is being discussed seriously. God help us if their plan for failure in Iraq, and it cannot be described in any other way, is enacted.
Update: I referred to the “Brady” plan when I meant the Baker plan but have now corrected it.
Update II: Read Bob Owens’ plea to the President to recommit to the effort in Iraq.

John: I sound angry? Are you serious? You read Hugh’s profane diatribe and you say I sound angry? Another comedian!
BTW, nice dig at the “Republican policy maker” 🙂
Gee, I’m sorry you don’t like Christians, but then again you would hardly be a liberal if you did, right?
Hugh, I continue to be endlessly humored by your repeated claim that I am holier-than-thou and sanctimonious (how many years of “catholic education” did you have again? hehehe). I guess when someone calls you on your implied piety (“I was in church last Sunday…”), it pretty much makes you go crazy, complete with F bombs. Interesting. Side note: If you went to a “real” Catholic (capital”C” BTW) church they could do an exorcism on you or something and make you stop that:).
Okay, you two have finally worn me down. Hugh, I for one am now fully convinced you are, in fact, a Holy Man of God, and totally take back anything that I wrote that may have implied you are a fake Christian practicing fake Christianity in a fake church. I’m really, really sorry.
BTW, I suggest you not get too close to John as he says he doesn’t like your faith…
Peace Moonbeam,
Damn, yeah you do really seem angry. You seem to be getting more and more wound up, and for my part, I’m sorry about that. I’m not your enemy.
In fact if you sit right now, and ask yourself “Am I angry?” I think you’d have to say yes. If not, I think you’re lying to yourself, and if you deny that, you’re lying to the rest of us. If so, nothing you say has any credibility.
I’m trying to ask you a serious question or two.
It’s not a “dig” at “the republican policy maker”. I heard him say it within the last two weeks, I just don’t recall the name.
OK, can I appologize, and we can talk? Tell me about your faith.
Peace, about Hugh’s 19 years of Catholic schooling, it’s highly possible that it took him 7 yrs to pass the 12th grade.
“As expected your reply was smug, holier-than-thou and sanctimonious.”
This is typical behavior of the Democrat Party of Perpetual Fraud. The best time to find a Democrat anywhere near a church would be just before an election. The one where their Media has set up camp at.
Hugh , your eyes should be ripped from their sockets since they serve you no purpose. Your blind as a bat and to reality.
Lee, lucky for you , your comment you made toward Scrapiron wasn’t made with the three of us in the same room. But then again, the punkass Un-American coward that you are hasn’t the BALLS to do so.
Now before you start labeling me RightWing whatever or Religious whatever. I’m Registered Democratic , went to Catholic school for 12 years with of course means I served as an alter boy for many years. I haven’t been to church in years other than Weddings or Funerals. Having won back your pretious power back , why do you guys still sound like assholes and sore losers?
Gee John, are you trying to hypnotize me into thinking I’m angry? “You are so angry, just relax and know you are so angry…” Please stop, I just don’t feel like being angry right now, and I certainly don’t feel the need to explain traditional Christianity to you, so you can lamely attempt to discredit it.
You can borrow someone’s Bible (I’d suggest a Republican:)and read all about it yourself. After you familiarize yourself with it, you can explain it to Hugh (if he’s not in his “catholic education” class, of course.)
Me, I’ve got to play some Battlefield 2 with other warmongering conservatives. It’s what we do.
Peace,
You started this part of the thread with;
“Hugh, STEP AWAY FROM THE BONG.
your “blame America” leftist diatribes probably play well at the Daily Kos where you can circle-jerk with fellow “free thinkers,” but many here have a clear understanding of history and reality.
You and others like you are absolutely the biggest threat to this country, and it appears your Godless party comrades are about to prove it.”
Then you expect me to feel bad because Hugh may have insulted you after you sent this to him?
So now, you want to go play your shoot-em-up games because that’s what good christian republicans do?
I was trying to have a legitimate discussion with you. I’ve not called you any names, or made fun of your point of view.
Wow,
When did you Wingnuts become such doom and gloom chicken little drama queens? Just go back and read your post election posts and you’ll see what I mean. I use to respect the political right of this country (Reagan, Bush 41) but you guys have turned into the biggest bunch of finger pointing cry babies ever.
What if we pull out of Iraq in a phased and orderly manner and things don’t fall apart here in America? I know some (not all) of you who support the occupation of Iraq have a vested interest in keeping this gravy train rolling. We are talking 2 to 3 billion dollars a week are being spent on this war in Iraq. The American people have said in no uncertain terms, no more.
Solve the Iraq issue for middle Americans and you may just have a chance in 08. Stay the course, and see your political capitol continue to slide downward. Looks to me like you guys kind of enjoy being on the loosing side of things.
I’ll make a few comments, because this is just absurd.
The fact it doesn’t claim to have “the” answer, doesn’t think it should tell people how to practice faith or morals, etc. obviously makes it the perfect fit for a liberal who doesn’t want to wrestle with such weighty issues.
PeaceMoonbeam, my church (and I grew up Methodist) had a minister who actually told us to question what was considered the “exact” translations of events in the bible – not because he was a hethen but because it would strengthen our faith when we try to understand the reality of those times. For example, he considered Adam and Eve more of a parable than a real event.
Believe it or not, your arrogant certainty about what’s right and wrong is, well, wrong. And just because you can’t think for yourself doesn’t mean others are assholes or politically corrupt. You seem fearful. That’s what I get out of this. You probably don’t even know you are. Get some help.
Lee, lucky for you , your comment you made toward Scrapiron wasn’t made with the three of us in the same room. But then again, the punkass Un-American coward that you are hasn’t the BALLS to do so.
Rob, you’re a posturing little ass with nothing to contribute other than your typical nastiness. You throw out alot of slogans and particularly like “Democrat Party of Perpetual Fraud” but it just shows your inability to add useful criticism to a discussion. Go back to school.
Now, I’m not suggesting I’m any voice of reason here (and my comments tend to be ridiculous anyway) but I just can’t stomach some of this bile – especially from some hypocrite like PeaceMoonbeam who cloaks his anger behind the bible. It’s ugly, simple minded and it exposes you for who you are – a scared little child who needs to be told what to do and how to think (obviously by a church that caters to that) and is deathly afraid of change or opinions that challenge his tenuous grasp on reality.
And Scrapiron, if you still need that hug, it’s here for you, big boy.
John,
I doesn’t matter that the Democrats ran Joe Lieberman out of the Democrat party and that he won anyway without the far left vote. Joe holds the balance of power in the most powerful legislative body in Washington. If he decides not to vote for Harry Reid as Senate Majority Leader but for Mitch McConnell instead, the Senate will belong to the Republicans, PERIOD. I only wish I could see Howard Dean groveling and sucking to keep Joe happy.
Oyster:
Sometimes when you’re in a pig pen you just have to wrestle with the pigs. They can get unruly you know.
I guess it’s too late to ask if anyone could answer my questions about the polls? Every time I post something about how I don’t understand how these polls come to the conclusions they do, no one answers. Could it be I’m not the only one?
hansel2:
Wow, another religious freedom fighter! My guess is you also have been extensively trained for decades in “catholic education.”
BTW, it’s Bible (capital “B”).
hansel2 I thank you for your learned theological input, it changed my whole belief system.
PS: My Methodist minister told me Adam and Eve were aliens from Venus.
John S.,
My thoughts were in regard to RicardoVerde who had written;
“Am I the only one who finds it humorous that the far left side of the Democrats has succeeded in making Joe Lieberman the most powerful man in congress?”
Of course it wasn’t the far left… But it’s easy to blame everything on the mysterious, evil, lurking “Far Left”.
So you mentioned that;
“I doesn’t matter that the Democrats ran Joe Lieberman out of the Democrat party and that he won anyway without the far left vote.”
Well, yes… For the purpose of my response to RicardoVerde it does. That’s exactly the point. Secondly, the “Democrats” did not run Joe out of the part. It’s a primary vote for Pete’s sake. In any primary, republican or democratic unless it’s unopposed, somebody wins and somebody loses. That’s just the way it is. You don’t get tossed out, you just have to try again. There are no “The Democrats” that toss you out. You just didn’t get enough votes.
He does hold a certain ballance of power as you mention, but it’s a bit like the power the Vice President holds in the senate. Man, when it’s a tie, he’s got absolute power, but other than that not so much. Joe as an independent won’t be able to do much on his own, so he’s got to throw in with somebody (which was your point, and well said), and he’s stated he’ll caucus with the Democrats.
Ah, we’ll see what happens. I’m sure it’s going to be an interesting session.
Thank you,
John
“Oyster:
Sometimes when you’re in a pig pen you just have to wrestle with the pigs. They can get unruly you know.
Posted by: Hugh at November 14, 2006 08:25 AM”
Hugh,
Most normal people don’t feel a need to start wrestling pigs when in their vicinity. I have little doubt PETA would not be happy with this violent behavior directed at peaceful beings.
In any case it seems obvious that if you are planning to wrestle you better at least make sure you’re stronger than the pigs.
Add john to the list of those with shit for brains.
Jhow66,
I am overwhelmed with your superior logic.
If you parents will let you on the internet later I demand a rematch.
John
OK. Iran’s Leader primes and crows even louder, he seems emboldened; are you still confused how the election results and Rumsfeld’s resulting dismissal aka resignation were deciphered by “them”?