In the run up to the 2004 presidential election, leftists started an internet rumor that President Bush and Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld would reinstate the draft in order to fight their “illegal” war. Now that the Democrats have majorities in both houses of Congress, guess what Democrat Charlie Rangel wants to do? Yep, you got it. Reinstate the draft:
Americans would have to sign up for a new military draft after turning 18 if the incoming chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee has his way.
Rep. Charles Rangel, D-N.Y., said Sunday he sees his idea as a way to deter politicians from launching wars and to bolster U.S. troop levels insufficient to cover potential future action in Iran, North Korea and Iraq.
“There’s no question in my mind that this president and this administration would never have invaded Iraq, especially on the flimsy evidence that was presented to the Congress, if indeed we had a draft and members of Congress and the administration thought that their kids from their communities would be placed in harm’s way,” Rangel said.
Rangel, a veteran of the Korean War who has unsuccessfully sponsored legislation on conscription in the past, said he will propose a measure early next year.
In 2003, he proposed a measure covering people age 18 to 26. This year, he offered a plan to mandate military service for men and women between age 18 and 42; it went nowhere in the Republican-led Congress.
Democrats will control the House and Senate come January because of their victories in the Nov. 7 election.
At a time when some lawmakers are urging the military to send more troops to Iraq, “I don’t see how anyone can support the war and not support the draft,” said Rangel, who also proposed a draft in January 2003, before the U.S. invasion of Iraq.
Sen. Lindsey Graham, a South Carolina Republican who is a colonel in the U.S. Air Force Standby Reserve, said he agreed that the U.S. does not have enough people in the military.
“I think we can do this with an all-voluntary service, all-voluntary Army, Air Force, Marine Corps and Navy. And if we can’t, then we’ll look for some other option,” said Graham, who is assigned as a reserve judge to the Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals.
Rangel, the next chairman of the House tax-writing committee, said he worried the military was being strained by its overseas commitments.
“If we’re going to challenge Iran and challenge North Korea and then, as some people have asked, to send more troops to Iraq, we can’t do that without a draft,” Rangel said.
He said having a draft would not necessarily mean everyone called to duty would have to serve. Instead, “young people (would) commit themselves to a couple of years in service to this great republic, whether it’s our seaports, our airports, in schools, in hospitals,” with a promise of educational benefits at the end of service.
Graham said he believes the all-voluntary military “represents the country pretty well in terms of ethnic makeup, economic background.”
A military draft won’t have a snowball’s chance in hell because supporting the idea would be political suicide. But leave it to a Democrat to announce something like this.
Again, I ask: buyer’s remorse, anyone?
Update: Allahpundit has video of Charlie Rangel discussing his brilliant idea on Face the Nation and also writes this:
With talk now of Bush sending 20,000 more troops to Iraq and Zinni and Batiste telling the Times that withdrawal would be disastrous, doves need to recapture the momentum. Enter the draft bill, which is doomed to fail but at least gives the media a few weeks of material with which to dissuade anyone leaning towards redoubling our efforts to win this thing.

In other words, Lee… we’ve LOST because people want to lose.
WE KNEW THAT.
It’s morally inexcusable, it’s reprehensible, but if it’s true it’s true and if we lose it’s because people chose to lose and the deaths and hardship resulting will be on the heads of those “without the patience.”
I too would like to know where CB has travelled too, where she stayed (how modern the accomodations) and how long she stayed, how many locals she got to know by name, what their economic station was, etc.
Yeah, the same old bleat about how Americans don’t travel enough to understand the depths of human nature.
Karma, man. What goes around comes around… in the form of the US Army. Hoo Aah.
I’m still laughing at the many great smackdowns in here of Lee and civil behavior’s moronic posts.
That’s why I enjoy this blog so much! 🙂
Buhs led us into war, and lost it. Now America must decide what to do next.
Since conservatives are choosing to whine and lay blame they are and should be left out of the discussion. You worthless sots got us into an un-winnable war, and have cost hundreds of thousands of lives needlessly, destroyed families, ruined cultures, and facilitated our enemies. Iran and North Korea should not be threats they are now – but you morons and your failed war on terror have done much more harm than good.
That must really sting. No wonder you idiots are crying louder than ever. History will mark this disaster as a monumental failure of the conservatives and Republican’ts.
You flat out LIE lee and then ignore it when people call you out. You specifically said that the war was lost, and that Kissinger said so publicly. That is not at ALL what he said, he said that it can’t be won “in a time period that the political processes of the democracies will support”, aka, the timeline that the democrats want to put on it. Nowhere in there does he say that the war is lost like you continue to say he is saying.
As for Kissinger being a regular, Snow said, “I don’t want to say “fairly regularly,” in no way does that sound like he’s saying hes a regular. The other quote in there, “Dr. Kissinger comes in quite often — it’s when he disagrees with the administration on policy.” I take it you didn’t actually see this press conference where Snow laughs as he says that, an obvious joke referring to Kissinger disagreeing often with the administration. You are so fucking dishonest lee.
History will indeed tell lee, and you will be wrong on all counts. Unfortunately you are so intellectually dishonest that you’ll be teaching your putrid liberal grandkids that Bush blew up the towers and personally raped and tortured 2 million Iraqis.
“he said that it can’t be won “in a time period that the political processes of the democracies will support”
Glad you can read piggy. It thrills me that someone with your obvious disabilities can read.
Now this proves what moron? Does it change the outcome predicted by Kissinger? Not at all. All it does is provide an opportunity for Republican apologists like you to blame someone else. This time, you can blame on it the fact that America and Iraq are both democracies — feel better? No — I’m sure you’d prefer that the US wasn’t a democracy, and that our citizens didn’t have the right to vote and speak up, right piggy?
The blame lies with the failure of the Republican’ts to execute on the war on terror. It was wrong from the start. Bush lied going in – and lied about where we are today – Stay the course – my ass!
The rest of your loser slobberings aren’t worth addressing.
First of all dumbass, since when does an outcome that Kssinger predicts equal reality? The only thing he said in that statement is that he doesn’t forsee this war to be winable if placed on a timeline. As far as I have seen there is no timeline yet, and Kissinger’s “theory” doesn’t make it so anyway!
Secondly, I suppose you saying that you’re glad I can read means that you can not read. Because you are the one who read those statments as him saying the war is lost, which he most definitely did not say. So, keep on making shit up lee, I would say you look dumber and dumber with every post, but I am not sure that anyone here thinks there is any lower for you to go. Where the fuck were you educated anyway, and for how long?!!
Please don’t be stupid! The only reason Rangel even brought this up was to generate a dialog where by EVERYBODY in our great country sacrifice something for the vanity war dubya started. He doesn’t want a draft. He simply wants everybody to understand that the War on Terra (accodring to Dubya) will last forever and there needs to be an awareness that someones kids must serve so we can kill the furriners. The thinking is that if donors to the republican party thought maybe their own children will be sent to die in this illegal way, maybe – just maybe, they would re-think their stance on the war. After all, I am for war as long as someone elses kids fight it for me. So please don’t be naive. I give you folks much more credit than that. Is that credit misplaced? I hope not.
Yes Tom, we all get that, thats why the title of the post says it is the dems favorite “scare tactic”.
Buhs led us into war, and lost it. Now America must decide what to do next.
Since conservatives are choosing to whine and lay blame they are and should be left out of the discussion. You worthless sots got us into an un-winnable war, and have cost hundreds of thousands of lives needlessly, destroyed families, ruined cultures, and facilitated our enemies. Iran and North Korea should not be threats they are now – but you morons and your failed war on terror have done much more harm than good.
That must really sting. No wonder you idiots are crying louder than ever. History will mark this disaster as a monumental failure of the conservatives and Republican’ts.
Posted by: Lee at November 20, 2006 03:57 PM
First, Bush didn’t lose the war. How can a president lose any war? if we retreat the people of the united States of America will lose the war, not any one Tom, Dick or George, no matter waht their current title is.
Second, the war is not unwinnable. No war is ever “unwinnable”. I’ll allow that some battles such as faced by the Jews at Masada can be, but wars are never unwinnable. If they were the VietCong would have given up in the first 6 months of the “Vietnam War” as they were never going to win on the battlefield.
Third, could you produce the hundreds of thousands of bodies you say that the Americans have caused the death of and then produce actual medical evidence that proves US involvement in the deaths? Or is this the standard anti-patriotic, anti-military paranoia being spouted?
As for Iran and North Korea being threats? How are they threats? The fact that they might have nuclear capability? How would you have prevented that? Talk? We did, they ignored it. Or are you saying we should have bombed them? I thought you were against violence. Or are you only against it until you are for it?
As for whining and “laying blame”. Where have I done that. I am personally disappointed that the US military was not permitted to execuse a much more aggresive battle plan, but that is neither here nor there. And I don’t think the war is actually lost. I think its become more of a slow drip of pain and blood and that it didn’t need to, but I also believe that if we allowed the US military to be a bit more aggresive and made it clear that we were there until Iraq had a stable government that wasn’t threatened by the jihadi militants the war would be won in under 2 years. However, I also know that liberals like youreself will never accept the possibliity and that your rhetoric will keep the morale of the enemy up as they believe that you will be able to generate enough political pressure to force an early retreat.
“I also know that liberals like youreself will never accept the possibliity and that your rhetoric will keep the morale of the enemy up as they believe that you will be able to generate enough political pressure to force an early retreat.”
Lee and CB, YOU ARE THE ENEMY! As far as I’m concerned , You might as well be along side the Terrorists next time they are in the crosshairs of a gunship. I’m registered democratic and not only our Country would greatly benefit but the entire planet would be a more peaceful place without your self worshipping lying punk asses. STFU!
It won’t work this time, Lee. If the war is lost it’s because of all the back stabbing lefties like yourself who have been whining from 9/12 to this day. Unlike the leftist caused disaster of Vietnam, your whining words and back stabbing antics are forever recorded and searchable on the web. Whatever happens as the result of the left’s cut and run policy in Iraq will be properly credited to the left. The insurgents could never win in Iraq without the help of the loony left in this country.
Charles Rangel isn’t too far from the mark when he calls for re-instatement of the draft. But with one caveat .. only so in time of war as declared by the Congress. Other than physical disabilities, no deferrments .. especially to university and college matriculators
Committing our armed forces into war is a grave decision. It’s a time of criticality, separations, shattered lives, suffering and sadness It must be entered into as such.
Given this, why the War Powers Resolution of 1973? This act by Congress was and remains a tarnished abdication of one of the Congresses’ most critical responsibilites. It’s all there in Article 1, Section 8 of our Constitution .. short and specific. It’ a political cop-out and institutional disgrace. It should be exorcised from the books. This Act made the disastrous tragedies of Korea, Vietnam and Iraq not only possible, but near impossible to avoid.
Will our next Congress be prepared to declare war on terrorism?
Rangel’s intention with his draft proposal is to make war so unpalatable with the public that no President can sustain any future military action. In effect, Rangel want’s to disarm this nation. A lot of lefties see that as a good thing, apparently believing there’s no real need to use military force. Given the U.S. is at war with radical Islam, which apparently is news to those on the left, disarming this nation is suicide. Of course lefties see such talk as just scare tactics, but by the time events prove the left wrong, it will be too late to do anything about it.
We already see Iran moving to take over Iraq on the diplomatic front. As soon as the Iraqi government agrees to expel all U.S. forces, much of the violence will stop, simply because Iran has been the instigator of that violence from the beginning. When the U.S. leaves the area, the takeover of Iraq will proceed until completed. Similarly, Iran will force the U.S. to leave Afghanistan while continuing to threaten Israel. Iran can do this because it’s not about military force alone, it’s about the will to use that force and the U.S. has proven it doesn’t have the will to win the war with radical Islam. Being the real target of radical Islam is the destruction if Israel, the leaders of radical Islam would be smart to leave the U.S. to slumber in leftist decay.
At some point the forces of radical Islam will march against Israel in overwhelming numbers, something like 100 million armed men. Then the big surprise comes.