Goin’ to the chapel…

When Mitt Romney was governor of Massachusetts, he did all he could to stave off gay marriage. This wasn’t much, considering he was saddled with a legislature that was 85% Democratic and a state supreme court that sanctioned gay marriage by a 4-3 vote, but one thing he could do was dust off an old law and insist it be enforced. This measure, dating back to 1913, was a legacy of segregation and racism — it forbid couples from marrying if their marriage was illegal in their state of residence. At the time, it was to keep interracial couples forbidden from wedding in their home state from coming to Massachusetts, gettting married, and going back home and forcing their home state to sanction their union.

Well, Romney’s successor, Deval Patrick, wants to repeal that law. So do the heads of the heads of both houses of the legislature. With that much heavy firepower behind it, I think it’s safe to assume that the bill’s days are numbered.

This brings up a whole peck of fascinating (well, fascinating to me) issues and questions. Setting aside the impetus for the matter, gay marriage (which I support and a whole bunch of you don’t), let’s look at just what this entails:

1) The Tenth Amendment says that the powers not explicitly given to the federal government are the responsibility of the states, or the people. Marriage is not one of those listed.

2) The Defense Of Marriage Act (signed by President Bill Clinton in 1996) says that other states do not have to recognize gay marriages sanctioned by other states.

3) Article VI, Paragraph 2 of the United States Constitution says that in cases of conflict, federal law supercedes state law, and the Constitution and treaties supercede federal law.

4) Article IV, Section I, says that each state must give “full faith and credit” to the “public Acts, Records, and judicial Proceedings of every other State.” This has traditionally included marriage and divorce — witness Las Vegas and Atlantic City marriages and divorces.

I think a compelling argument can be made on both sides of the issue here. But to attempt to reconcile the above citations, though, require some interesting twists of logic:

Marriage, as an institution, is regulated by the states. Each state can set its own rules, but it has to accept those marriages sanctioned by another state. Unless it’s a same-sex marriage, because then the federal government says they don’t have to, and federal law trumps state law. Except when it conflicts with the Constitution, and that says that states have to accept marriages and other things certified by another state, and the Constitution trumps federal law. Or maybe not.

Regardless, I still can’t claim my computer as a dependent on my taxes, and that’s gotta violate my Constitutional rights somehow.

I’d be interested in hearing you folks’ arguments on this one. I’ll just ask the lawyers present to set aside specific cases and examples, though, and discuss this one purely on its own merits and principles. I’m not looking for legal opinions, but simple analysis of the facts and the existing situation. In other words, I’m not asking “what would the courts say,” but “what SHOULD be done.”

And please, keep the particulars of the case out of the argument. Today it’s gay marriage, but the Massachusetts law in question was created to address interracial marriage — and I think we all agree that the government has no business preventing that.

Nancy Pelosi Conducts her Own Foreign Policy
A Moving Tribute