As you were forewarned, more on the immigration issue. In comments to the original post, one reader suggested the possibility of solving the problem by deporting the estimated 8 – 12 million illegal workers already here. This is an often-encountered argument among the “enforcement first” or “enforcement only” advocates. It relies on multiple false presumptions, though.
Now, even most of those with this view realize it is impossible to “round ’em up” with law enforcement. For example, we currently have about three million people incarcerated in this country. They are serving an average sentence of three years, but their actual average time served is eighteen months. This means that we catch and convict about 2 million serious criminals per year – that includes ALL levels of law enforcement, though: federal, state, and local. So in order to capture and deport 12 million illegals beyond the current law enforcement efforts in, say, three years, would require increasing the total number of law enforcement officers in this country by 200%. Where would these people come from, who would train them, how would they operate? Will we have checkpoints? “Papers, please.”
Of course, this is only a nightmare, so the proponents of such fantasies suggest businesses who employ illegals might be forced to stop, and turn them in, with the threat of draconian penalties if they fail to comply.
Leaving aside for the moment the concept of government requiring private citizens, untrained and unarmed, to enforce the laws the government itself, with its virtually unlimited resources, cannot, may we recall this has already been attempted?
One feature of the Simpson-Mazzoli bill was to require employers to submit a form, the “I-9,” verifying each new hire, which would include photocopies of three forms of ID, at least one of which must have a picture. Employers who failed to comply would be subject to drastic penalties, so we all did – religiously. Now, if an ID is faked well enough to pass a layman’s inspection, it might be good enough for a photocopy to even pass an expert’s examination. Not that it had to – so many of these forms were being received, they overwhelmed the ability to examine them, so they simply didn’t examine them. And this did . . . exactly what good?
Even if it were possible to somehow detect and deport 12 million illegal workers immediately, who would replace them? I warned before that math would be involved:
]]>< 
