Supreme Court Monday

Click the below link for the latest happenings in the U.S. Supreme Court.

]]>< ![CDATA[

Court Refuses to Disturb 30-Year State Sentence for Teenage Murderer

The Supreme Court on Monday refused to review a 30-year state prison sentence for a South Carolina teen who was 12 years old when he engaged in premeditated murder of his grandparents.

That decision unquestionably will get under the skin of liberal law students, liberal law professors and other poseurs. It should warm the hearts, however, of conservatives and other Federalism/states’ rights advocates.

Here’s a link to the AP’s version of events.

* * *
Speaking of Federalism and states’ rights:

Court to Hear Oral Arguments on Death Penalty for Child Rape

The Supreme Court on Wednesday will hear oral arguments on whether a state can impose the death penalty for the rape of a child, or whether that would be proscribed as cruel and unusual punishment under the 8th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

To me the answer to that question is obvious:

Barring a clear and direct violation of a primary and unambiguous right under the federal Constitution, sovereign states should have carte blanche to administer their own criminal justice systems with whatever punishments their people and their elected representative see fit. Capital punishment under state law for child rape is well within the purview of what should be deemed constitutional under federal law.

Besides, that case brings up what for 15 years I’ve referred to as the “U.C. Berkeley” standard. If you’re not sure what to think about a particular Supreme Court dispute ask yourself what a law professor at U.C. Berkeley would do about it. The opposite of that is correct.

Here’s a link to the AP’s agenda-driven report.

* * *
Court Will Hear Prosecutorial Immunity Case

The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to decide whether a man who served 24 years in prison before his murder conviction was overturned can sue a former Los Angeles County district attorney and a top deputy prosecutor for wrongful conviction.

The result in that case is easy to predict. The leftist 9th Circuit voted to allow that lawsuit to proceed. Which means, ipso facto, the SCOTUS is quite likely to reverse and to throw the former prisoner’s case out of court.

Here’s a link to the AP’s version of events.

Hey, That Smarts!
Looking Ahead to Indiana